Menu

63 Sermon Illustrations on Baseball

63 illustrations Page 2 of 2

Baseball in Christian preaching often symbolizes the Christian life as a spiritual game requiring faith, perseverance, and discipline (1 Corinthians 9:24). Illustrations use imagery of players, games, and the stadium to depict themes like running the race, touching base with God, and the struggle against fear and failure (Hebrews 12:1). These pictures connect familiar sports experiences to spiritual truths and Christian ministry.

A Perfect Game, In God's Providence

Watching Randy Johnson pitch is always a treat. The 6-foot-10 lefty is an imposing figure on the mound, and staring at him from the batter's box has to be an intimidating experience.

But watching the Big Unit pitch his perfect game May 18, 2004, was truly something special. Johnson's performance will go down as one of the greatest pitching feats ever, especially considering his age of 40.

In fact, Johnson became the oldest player in major league history to throw a perfect game when he retired all 27 Atlanta Braves batters he faced. He also became only the sixth player in baseball history to throw a no-hitter in both the American and National Leagues.

It was only the 17th time a pitcher has tossed a perfect game in major league history. That should give you a pretty good idea of just how rare the achievement is.

“A game like this was pretty special,” Johnson said in an AP story. “It doesn't come along very often.”

A lock for baseball's Hall of Fame, Johnson's perfect game is a nice exclamation point to a superb career. He has won 234 games and has a career ERA of 3.09. His 3,952 strikeouts place him fourth on the all-time list, behind only Nolan Ryan, Steve Carlton and Roger Clemens. He has also won five Cy Young Awards and is a World Series MVP.

But despite all the honors, all the accomplishments and all the accolades, Johnson remains humble about his place in baseball history.

Johnson wrote the forward to Dave Dravecky's little book, “Play Ball.” In it, Johnson talks about his love for the game's history. His basement isn't adorned with any of his Cy Young awards, but with his collection of autographs from players like Cy Young himself, Lefty Grove, Kid Nichols and Babe Ruth.

“I love the history of the game, and I enjoy learning what those old-timers have done,” Johnson wrote. “These days, I'm greatly humbled by what I've been able to accomplish between the lines.”

Johnson goes on to give God the credit for his ability and for his success on the baseball field.

“With each passing season, I'm realizing that any history I'm making has not been done by my own strength,” Johnson wrote. “The Lord has taught me to accept the peaks and valleys and try to do my best -- to get the most out of my ability. I understand that the Lord is in charge of our destiny and that the blessings I've been given could come and go at any moment. That knowledge has helped me mentally prepare to be the best pitcher I can be.”

The peaks far outnumber the valleys in Johnson's career, and Tuesday's game [May 18, 2004] was certainly the pinnacle for him. We saw one of baseball's best achieve perfection.

*

[Original illustration at this number was a duplicate in HolwickID 25837-26027]

He Was Comfortable With Who He Was

Sports writer Ted Simonson had been assigned to collect material for a book on Bobby Richardson, the New York Yankees’ great second baseman in the 1960s. Ted was chatting with Bobby in a Baltimore hotel lobby after a game with the Orioles. A few feet away from them was the Yankees’ superstar, Mickey Mantle, signing autographs in the midst of a boisterous crowd of youthful fans.

Ted writes, “I noticed one boy having trouble getting through the crowd with his autograph book. Suddenly he saw the two of us and ran up to Bobby.

“‘Do you work for the Yankees, mister?’

“‘Sure do,’ was the reply.

“‘Would you please get Mickey’s autograph for me?’

“Bobby got up immediately, walked to the crowd, and waited until he could get through to the famous home-run hitter. A few moments later, he returned.

“‘There you are,’ he said, returning the autograph book.

“‘Thanks, mister!’ And the boy was gone. It was clear that he had no notion of who had done him the favor.

“Bobby grinned at me. ‘I get to do that a lot,’ he said as we continued our interview.”

We, like Bobby Richardson, need to be comfortable with who we are.

________

Harry Genet, MEN OF INTEGRITY managing editor

Perfect Sportsmanship: the Beauty of Forgiveness

Luke 11:4

Despite all the positive things we associate with the word “sportsmanship,” sports often brings out the worst in people: Little League parents behaving badly, drunken crowds, just for example.

But it doesn’t have to be this way.

As most of the world knows by now, Armando Galarraga of the Detroit Tigers was one out away from throwing the 21st perfect game in Major League Baseball history. With two outs in the ninth, the Cleveland Indians batter hit a grounder to the Tiger first baseman. Galarraga, the pitcher, raced to cover first.

It’s a routine play, and the Tigers seemed to have pulled it off: Galarraga and the ball reached first base at least a step ahead of the runner. With that, Galarraga, who earlier in week had faced a possible demotion to the minor leagues, would become a baseball immortal.

Except he didn’t. As you probably know, umpire Jim Joyce called the batter “safe.” Galarraga’s response was “a simple smile.” A smile that, as Joe Posnanski of Sports Illustrated said, seemed to ask “Are you sure? I really hope you are sure.”

Galarraga was the only one smiling. The blown call outraged fans across the country. The most measured response called for Joyce to be fired. The more unhinged ones threatened Joyce and his family.

For his part, as soon as he saw the replay, Joyce knew that he had gotten it wrong. He told reporters “I just cost that kid a perfect game.”

By baseball standards, such an admission was extraordinary: Umpires are paid to make judgment calls and stand by them. Players and managers can argue with them but only within limits, and with no expectation of having the call reversed.

So, when Joyce apologized to Galarraga, we were already in unfamiliar territory. When Galarraga, in turn forgave Joyce, adding that Joyce probably felt worst than he did and “nobody’s perfect,” we were witnessing something extraordinary.

The victim of what Posnanski calls one of “most absurd injustices in the history of baseball” went out his way to comfort the umpire who made the mistake. And the umpire was humble enough to ask for forgiveness. It was, as Posnanski called it, a “beautiful” lesson.

It was also a lesson made possible only by Christianity. I really don’t know anything about Galarraga’s or Joyce’s beliefs, but I do know that it was Christianity that taught the world the virtues of humility and forgiveness.

Neither of these were considered virtues in the ancient world (or in any pagan or postmodern culture for that matter). On the contrary, they were signs of weakness.

The Christian message summed up in the words “forgive us our sins as we forgive those who sin against us,” provided a revolutionary new basis for human relationships. And it has the power to transform lives — both of victims and offenders — as I’ve witnessed over and over in 30 years of prison ministry. It has the power to heal nations, as the world witnessed in the aftermath of the genocide in Rwanda.

What happened after that baseball game was more beautiful than Galarraga’s pitching. Especially for a postmodern culture that rejects the faith that gave meaning to the words “I’m sorry” and “I forgive you.”

And that’s one call I’m sure of.

________

Copyright (c) 2010 Prison Fellowship Ministries. Reprinted with permission. "BreakPoint with Chuck Colson" is a radio ministry of Prison Fellowship Ministries.

from BreakPoint Commentary · Charles Colson via Kerux Sermon and Illustration Database baseballhumility

Who Controls the Umpires?

A former manager of the New York Yankees once told about a dream he had in which he died and went to heaven. There he was ordered to organize and manage a ball team. He said he was overwhelmed by all the available talent - Christy Mathewson, Walter Johnson, Rube Waddell, Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, and many other superstars. Just then the phone rang. It was Satan calling to challenge the heavenly team to a game. “But you haven't got a chance of winning,” said the manager. “You see I got all the great ball players up here.” Satan explained, “Oh, I know that. But I've got all the umpires!”

- Hastings

from Fredericksburg Bible Illustrator Supplements via Kerux Sermon and Illustration Database baseballjudging

Avid Baseball Fans

Seems the preacher and his song leader were both avid baseball fans. These guys didn't just [like] baseball, they lived, breathed and [ate] baseball. What time they weren't about church duties, they were attending a game, watching a game on the tube, or coaching a Little League game in the park.

One day, one of them mused about whether there would be baseball in heaven and quite a conversation ensued. Every thing is perfect in heaven, isn't it? We will want for nothing in heaven, will we? [Surely] there will be baseball in heaven!

They finally made a pact that whichever one got to heaven first would somehow try to contact the other and let him know for a fact whether they had baseball.

Well, as it turned out, the preacher died first. A week later he appeared to the song leader in a dream and said, “Well, I have some good news and some bad news. The good news is, there is indeed baseball in heaven. The bad news is, you're scheduled to pitch this Saturday.”

*

from Fredericksburg Bible Illustrator Supplements via Kerux Sermon and Illustration Database baseball

Cheating In Big-league Sports

Examples of cheating in big-league sports. Ultimate is White [Black] Sox scandal in 1919 World Series, where 8 players threw the series to the Cincinnati Reds. Claude "Lefty" Williams pitched the crucial eighth game (out of nine). He was promised $10,000, paid only $5,000. In the first inning he gave the Reds 5 runs. They won 10-5. The players were unrepentant when caught. They had excuses, just like Adam and Eve in the garden. Blamed their boss, Charles Comiskey, for being stingy.

TEN REASONS WHY PITTSBURGH PIRATES OUTFIELDER BILLY SUNDAY SAYS HE LEFT BASEBALL IN 1893

TEN REASONS WHY PITTSBURGH PIRATES OUTFIELDER BILLY SUNDAY SAYS HE LEFT BASEBALL IN 1893 (USA Today Baseball Weekly, June 8-14, 1994)

1. Because it is a life which has an undesirable future.

2. Because it develops a spirit of jealousy and selfishness; one's whole desires are for personal success regardless of what befalls others.

3. Because it tends to indolence as shown by the fact that few use the five months of unemployed time for study and self-improvement and preparation for future pursuit.

4. Because it is better to benefit mankind than to simply amuse them.

5. Because after one attains to a certain standard of efficiency, there is no more room for development.

6. Because it does not develop one for future usefulness; as illustrated by the fact that many ex-ballplayers are engaged in the saloon business.

7. Because it is a life in which morality is not an essential to success; one may be a consummate rogue and a first-class ballplayer.

8. Because reflections on past "grand stand catches," "great slides to the plate," "stolen bases," and the echo of applauding multitudes are very poor food for consolation.

9. Because I felt called of God to do His service.

10. Because of the anticipated contentment (now realized) which comes to any man who finds himself in the right place.

*

Little League Strips Bronx Team of Title

Friday August 31 7:30 PM ET

Little League Strips Bronx Team of Title

WILLIAMSPORT, Pa. (Reuters) - Bronx pitcher Danny Almonte seemed like a man among boys with his 75-mph fastballs at this year's Little League World Series, and with good reason: the Dominican-born youngster was too old to be playing.

The Dominican Republic on Friday declared the boy to be 14, two years beyond the Little League's top age limit, and warned that his father Felipe de Jesus Almonte could face criminal prosecution for filing a false birth certificate suggesting that his son was an eligible 12-year-old.

It was the first time in the 55-year history of the Little League World Series that a player has been confirmed to be ineligible because of age.

Within hours, Little League Baseball, which bills itself as the world's largest youth sports organization, said the Bronx's Rolando Paulino All-Stars would forfeit all their playoff victories, including their third-place World Series standing, which would go to a team from Curacao, Netherlands Antilles.

League officials also removed Bronx Little League founder Rolando Paulino indefinitely from the organization and banned Almonte's father from involvement in the Little League program worldwide.

NO ACTION AGAINST BOY

Officials did not take action against the boy himself but instead welcomed him to participate in a Little League program for teen-agers. League officials also let stand the charter of the local Rolando Paulino Little League as an asset to the children of the inner-city community it serves.

``Clearly, adults have used Danny Almonte and his teammates in a most contemptible and despicable way. Their actions are reprehensible,'' said Little League President Stephen Keener, who blamed Paulino and the senior Almonte for supplying the league with false documents that had claimed the boy was eligible to play.

``We are certainly sad and angry that we were deceived. In fact, millions of Little Leaguers around the world were deceived,'' added Keener, who apologized to teams that were denied a chance to play in the Little League World Series because of the deception.

The Williamsport, Pennsylvania-based Little League spent the week engulfed in speculation about Almonte's age after Sports Illustrated magazine presented it with a Dominican document suggesting the boy had been born on April 7, 1987. Rolando Paulino officials had given the Little League records showing a 1989 birth.

Earlier on Friday, Paulino himself told a news conference that he still believed in the birth certificate that showed Almonte to be 12 years old. ``If there are any parents who lied to the league, that's just not my problem,'' he said.

News of Almonte's age and the Little League's response came just days after members of the Bronx all-star team had been feted as heroes in New York. They took part in a victory parade and were compared to their Major League neighbors, the New York Yankees.

BUSH SAID DISAPPOINTED

Friday's revelation also led President Bush, who had attended the final game of the World Series to underscore the Little League's value as a medium for teaching children about sportsmanship and fair play, to express his regrets about the outcome through an aide.

``The president was disappointed to hear that,'' said White House spokesman Ari Fleischer. ``Little League is Little League, and the age is up to 12.''

Almonte, who led his team as far as the U.S. championship in the world tournament that ended last Sunday, threw the first perfect game seen at a Little League World Series in 44 years before the Bronx All-Stars lost to a team from Florida.

The Little League World Series championship ultimately went to a team from Tokyo.

Not only did the Little League welcome Almonte to continue his baseball career in its more age-appropriate Senior League, officials also offered educational assistance for him amid reports that he has not been enrolled in school since he arrived in the United States more than a year ago.

Leadership Without Words

From 1949 to 1958, Pee Wee Reese was captain of baseball's Dodgers. Named not for his size but for playing marbles as a kid with a pee-wee shooter, he was a great shortstop, a daring baserunner, and a superb clutch hitter. He was an eight-time All Star and sparked the Dodgers to seven National League pennants. He fielded the final ground ball in Brooklyn's only World Series championship in 1955. He never earned more than $35,000 playing the game he loved.

During his total of sixteen years on the field for the Dodgers, Reese was respected as a person as well as a ballplayer. His fellow Dodgers called him simply "The Captain" and deferred to his judgment on many a matter. He wasn't good at speeches. His leadership came from inner confidence, integrity, and consistency. His manner had the unpretentious effect of causing people to trust and follow him.

Just back from a three-year stint in the Navy during World War II, Reese had helped win a war against racial intolerance in Europe and was destined to be caught up in fighting the same evil in his own country. His team decided to break the barrier against black players by bringing up a young player named Jackie Robinson.

Some of the Dodger players began circulating a petition in the clubhouse to protest the plan. It said in effect that the players signing it wouldn't play on a team with a black man. Confident that Reese would sign it because he was a Southerner, it was shoved under his nose. "I'm not signing!" he said, and the petition died.

Robinson was with the team for spring training in 1947. Before a game in Cincinnati, just across the river from Reese's native Kentucky, the ugliness was intense. Fans in the stands joined players in the opposing dugout to shout racial slurs at the solitary black man taking infield practice at second base.

Pee Wee Reese raised his arm to halt the team's warmup. He walked from his shortstop position to second base and put his arm around Jackie Robinson's shoulders. That event is viewed as a turning point in the history of baseball. By extension, it was also a major blow against racism in American society.

"Pee Wee kind of sensed the sort of hopeless, dead feeling in me and came over and stood beside me for a while," Robinson recalled. "He didn't say a word, but he looked over at the chaps who were yelling at me . . . and just stared. He was standing by me. I could tell you that."

Sometimes you don't need to say anything to lead. Just be there. Stand for what you know is right. There is an eloquence in actions that words can't equal.

His Father's Arm

Someone said that encouragement is simply reminding a person of the "shoulders" he's standing on, the heritage he's been given. That's what happened when a young man, the son of a star baseball player, was drafted by one of the minor league teams. As hard as he tried, his first season was disappointing, and by midseason he expected to be released any day.

The coaches were bewildered by his failure because he possessed all the characteristics of a superb athlete, but he couldn't seem to incorporate those advantages into a coordinated effort. He seemed to have become disconnected from his potential.

His future seemed darkest one day when he had already struck out his first time at bat. Then he stepped up to the batter's box again and quickly ran up two strikes. The catcher called a time-out and trotted to the pitcher's mound for a conference. While they were busy the umpire, standing behind the plate, spoke casually to the boy.

Then play resumed, the next pitch was thrown - and the young man knocked it out of the park. That was the turning point. From then on, he played the game with a new confidence and power that quickly drew the attention of the parent team, and he was called up to the majors.

On the day he was leaving for the city, one of his coaches asked him what had caused such a turnaround. The young man replied it was the encouraging remark the umpire had made that day when his baseball career had seemed doomed.

"He told me I reminded him of all the times he had stood behind my dad in the batter's box," the boy explained. "He said I was holding the bat just the way Dad had held it. And he told me, 'I can see his genes in you; you have your father's arms.' After that, whenever I swung the bat, I just imagined I was using Dad's arms instead of my own."

_________________

by Barbara Johnson (c) 1998, from Chicken Soup for the Sports Fan's Soul by Jack Canfield, Mark Victor Hansen, Jim Tunney and Mark and Chrissy Donnelly.

*

from Internet: Chicken Soup Of The Day · Barbara Johnson via Kerux Sermon and Illustration Database baseballfailurefather

Nolan Ryan's Failure

Luke 22:32

By 1989, baseball player Nolan Ryan reached an incredible 5,000 strike outs, and all those no hitters. Ryan is a phenomenal baseball player.

In his rookie year, 18 years earlier, Gil Hodges was the manager of the Mets, and was impatient with Ryan. Although Ryan could consistently throw the ball over ninety miles an hour, most of the time it didn't go over the plate. He was walking everybody, hitting a lot of people, too. Hodges told Ryan at the beginning of a particular game that he was to pitch better in that game or he would pull him out and trade him. He would be finished.

Ryan went into that game trying to do his best, determined that he was going to succeed. He was miserable. He walked something like seven or eight batters in four innings. Hodges took him out. Later that season he was traded to the Angels.

After the game Richard Reeves went down into the locker room to interview the players. He noticed Nolan Ryan was apart from the others, looking into a mirror, obviously having difficulty tying his tie. Reeves got closer to him and noticed that there were tears in his eyes. He was crying. He couldn't see to tie his tie.

Reeves remembered that incident on the occasion of celebrating Nolan Ryan as one of the immortals of baseball. He remembered that this legendary man, Nolan Ryan, began thinking he had failed. But he kept on working. He kept on practicing.

__________

Source: The Timothy Report, Copyright (c) 2004 Swan Lake Communications, http://www.timothyreport.com

*

[Original illustration at this number was a duplicate in KeruxID 25837-26027]

How Baseball Is Like the Christian Walk

Romans 7:15

Baseball means dealing with failure. “There is more Met than Yankee in all of us,” as Roger Angell has poignantly written.

Every person who has ever played the game of baseball has been a consistent failure. It has been more than 70 years since the Splendid Splinter, Ted Williams, finished the 1941 baseball season with a .406 batting average. Williams’ failure rate of 60 percent means that he failed less often than any batter in the seven subsequent decades. In fact, only five other players in the live ball era (since 1920) have matched the success of his 60 percent failure rate. Babe Ruth, known for hitting 714 home runs, struck out 1,330 times in his Major League Baseball career. The Cy Young Award is baseball’s most coveted honor for the game’s best pitcher each season. And yet the award’s namesake lost 316 games as a major league pitcher.

The reality that baseball is a game of managed failure for every player, even the great ones, is one of the reasons the game imbedded so deeply in the fabric of American culture. Baseball became the national pastime because it reflected the national character -- a collective team endeavor that called consistently for individual responsibility and personal sacrifice for the greater good. John Updike noted, baseball is “an essentially lonely game.” Once the batting order is set there is nowhere to hide; your turn at the plate is coming. The fact that the whole team is counting on you in that moment produces the possibility of personal exultation or humiliation. Unlike other youth sports, baseball doesn’t permit a game to be dominated by a star player whose teammates are simply along for the ride.

I fear that one of the reasons for the waning popularity of baseball in American culture is not because the game has changed but because we have changed. It takes time and patience to understand the game of baseball, and becoming a proficient player is hard -- very hard. Natural physical gifting and innate athleticism are no predictors of baseball success. In fact, the baseball Hall of Fame extols the virtues of the game’s greatest players, and the shocking reality is not the amazing size, strength and speed of the game’s heroes but the almost comical diversity of body type and physical ability. The game’s greatest players have been tall and short, skinny and fat, slow and fast, muscular and flabby, intelligent, and well, not so intelligent. But they all have one thing in common. Every one of them developed the emotional capacity to persevere in the face of frequent, chronic failure, and occasional humiliation.

If my suppositions are correct, what was once seen as a part of the glory of baseball -- learning to persevere in the face of consistent failure -- is now perceived to be a reason to avoid the game. Parents simply looking for ways to keep their children busy and happy will choose sports that do not include the pressure and individualized responsibility that baseball has always demanded. Baseball requires a kind of moral courage that keeps persisting in the face of inevitable repeated personal failures. That is the sober unalterable reality for Albert Pujols and every little leaguer as well. Thus, baseball demands a huge time commitment for dads, not simply in teaching and repetitively practicing the fundamentals of the game, but also calling sons to the kind of moral courage the game demands. Rarely ever will a boy persist in baseball if his dad has little interest in the game. As Diana Schaub avers in her essay “America at Bat,” “Without fathers, there is no baseball, only football and basketball.”

Baseball does not fit well with the current trend of sports leagues that don’t keep score and where the goal is for everyone to be successful and know that they are always a winner. Such a notion does violence to a game that is structurally committed to constant reminders of the participant’s finitude and allows no room for such utopian fantasies. One of the reasons baseball has been so slow to embrace instant replay in the sport (and rightly so) is that a game marked by chronic managed failure propagates no delusions of human perfectionism in its players or its umpires. When a baseball purist asserts, “Bad calls are a part of the game,” he is saying something about the warp and woof of the game.

Only genuine baseball fans understood the reaction of Detroit Tigers pitcher Armando Galarraga during the 2010 baseball season when he was one out from throwing a perfect game (there have only been 23) and veteran umpire Jim Joyce made one of the worst big moment calls in baseball history. Joyce, inexplicably, called the batter safe at first base. When the next batter was retired, Galarraga was saddled with the most disappointing one hitter in the history of the game. How did Galarraga respond to the injustice? When it happened he offered a stunned grin and after the game he said, “He is human. Nobody’s perfect.... I want to tell him not to worry about it.” That moment was a beautiful window into what makes baseball unique.

No baseball player can survive and thrive without hope. When Henry Aaron was asked if he arrived at the ballpark every day knowing he would get two hits his reply was, “No. What I do know is that if I don’t get ‘em today, I’m sure going to get ‘em tomorrow.” Babe Ruth was fond of saying, “Every strike gets me closer to the next home run.” Persistent, daily plodding in the face of chronic managed failure, driven by future hope sounds a lot like my daily Christian walk.

The Apostle Paul wrote, “For I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate” (Romans 7:15). But he went on to write, “Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord! ... There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus” (Romans 7:25a, 8:1). The reality of his persistent failure and limitations did not paralyze him because he knew his story fit into a larger picture of the story of Christ. In the Kingdom of Christ, “all things work together for good, for those who are called according to his purpose” and those who love God are being conformed to the image of Christ (Romans 8:28-29).

As players prepare for Opening Day, every one of them knows perfection is impossible. No team will win 162 games; no one will bat 1.000, and no regular starting pitcher will go undefeated. Nevertheless, they practice with a sense of hope that this just might be their year. Despite their constant failure, if they keep stepping up to the plate and heading out to their position in the field, it all might work together for something special and if not there is always next year.

The very existence of another baseball season, another 162-game, seven-month exercise in hopeful, managed failure is a faint echo of the glorious promise James offers to all who have put their faith in the Lord Jesus Christ: “Count it all joy, my brothers, when you meet trials of various kinds, for you know that the testing of your faith produces steadfastness” (James 1:2-3). Every one of us has the tendency to compare the highlight reel of others’ successes to our daily failures and lose heart. But baseball, for those of us who love it, provides a constant reminder that everyone (even the superstars) strikes out, but the game still goes on.

Like most years, I think this just might be the year for my beloved Atlanta Braves to win it all. But whether they do or not, I am thankful that the chill of winter is giving way to spring and umpires will soon yell, “Play Ball!” Angell was right, “There is more Met than Yankee in all of us” but as much as a Braves fan hates to admit it, there is a glimmer of a greater glory that the Mets keep taking the field.

The Communion of Sins

Jude 1:23

Late February [2015] brought the sad news that Josh Hamilton of the Angels may have had a relapse in his fight against alcohol and drug abuse.

Hamilton’s story arc — from first overall pick in the 1999 MLB draft, to being out of the game because of drug and alcohol addiction, to recovery and a spectacular comeback — has inspired many people, including many Christians. Hamilton credited his faith in Christ with helping him overcome his demons and finally fulfill his enormous potential.

I don’t know Hamilton, or even anyone who knows Hamilton, but I know a thing or 75 about personal demons and patterns of sin. I suspect that among the many things going through Hamilton’s mind is the idea that he has let a lot of people down, many of whom he has never even met.

That last part is the biggest, if not only, difference between Hamilton’s story and mine. (Or yours.) His struggles and failure are public and, thus, the stuff of potential humiliation; mine are private and “only” the stuff of guilt and shame.

Many years ago, I heard someone change the words of the Apostle’s Creed from I believe in “the communion of saints [and] the forgiveness of sin” to “the communion of sins [and] the forgiveness of saints.” The phrase has stuck with me all these years because I’m frankly counting on God enjoying the play on words as much as I do. I derive comfort from the possibility that when St. Paul told the Philippians that he was confident “that he who began a good work in you will carry it on to completion until the day of Christ Jesus,” he was suggesting that along the way forgiveness will abound.

I need it. We all do.

My favorite illustration of what the “communion of sins” might look like comes from Brennan Manning’s “The Ragamuffin Gospel.” In it, he tells the story of an Alcoholic Anonymous meeting in which a guy he calls “Phil” admits that he fell off the wagon after being sober for seven years.

Phil knows he screwed up. He even has an idea of why: He didn’t pay enough attention to what A.A. calls “H.A.L.T.,” which stands for “hungry,” “angry,” “lonely,” and “tired,” the emotional states that make you more vulnerable to taking that first drink.

The response to Phil’s confession wasn’t condemnation, disappointment, or even surprise. Instead, his fellow recovering alcoholics said things like “Thank God you’re back,” “Boy, that took a lot of guts,” and “Let’s get together tomorrow and figure out what you needed relief from.” At the end of the meeting a woman Manning calls “Denise” kissed Phil and told him, “You old ragamuffin! Let’s go. I’m treating you to a banana split at the Tastee Freeze.”

Phil’s confession did take guts. It also took belonging to a communion of sinners where the forgiveness of saints, or people who would be saints, is lived out. Stated plainly, Phil felt safe to be what he was, a man struggling with his demons, instead of striving to be what Manning calls “the imposter,” the false self that everyone admires and no one knows.

I don’t know if your church feels safe. I suspect not. Unlike A.A. meetings, where, in Manning’s words, “Everyone is there because he or she made a big slobbering mess of his or her life,” churches are invested in seeming to be filled with shiny, happy people even when they’re not. I know. I’m one of those people who doesn’t always find it easy to be shiny and happy.

So I pray that Josh Hamilton finds such a safe place. And that I do, too.

==================

Comments:

I agree completely. “I don’t know if your church feels safe. I suspect not. Unlike A.A. meetings, where, in Manning’s words, ‘Everyone is there because he or she made a big slobbering mess of his or her life,’ churches are invested in seeming to be filled with shiny, happy people even when they’re not. I know. I’m one of those people who doesn’t always find it easy to be shiny and happy.”

I attended 12-Step meetings for two years, and, sad to say, in one month I found more honesty about problems there than I saw in the church in ten years. People in 12-Step groups attend because they feel a need, ‘cos they know they are messed up, and desperately need help. (Dare I say, ‘a Savior’?) Otherwise, what’s the point?

What is an increasing wonder to me is that we are the people and this is the entity by which our Lord Jesus has chosen to change the world, and to change Eternity. As C.S. Lewis wrote, “Who can duly adore such a Love...?”

Posted By: Kevin Peet on March 04, 2015

========

Thank you, Roberto. This is the best thing I’ve seen here in a long time. I pray our churches learn not to project “Shiny and Happy,” but project forgiveness.

Posted By: Dan Gill on March 03, 2015

________

Also see HolwickID #35389 and #63433.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate