Exodus 5

Exodus 5:1 to Exodus 6:1. The application to the Pharaoh, and its failure. Exodus 5:1 to Exodus 6:1 is for its greater part a continuous narrative from J: but at the beginning v. 3 seems to be a doublet of v. 1, and (especially) v. 5 of v. 4; hence most critics refer vv. 1, 2, 4 to E.

Exodus 5:1-5

1–5. Moses and Aaron ask permission of the Pharaoh for the Israelites to keep a three days’ feast in the wilderness. The request is refused.

Exodus 5:2

2. The Pharaoh replies contemptuously that he knows nothing of Jehovah, and need not therefore listen to His behests.

Exodus 5:3

3. The request itself, as far as ‘our God,’ is repeated almost verbatim from Exodus 3:18 (J). ‘God of the Hebrews’ is J’s standing expression (see the note ibid.); contrast ‘God of Israel,’ v. 1. lest he fall upon us, &c.] for neglecting the duty laid upon us.

Exodus 5:4

4. The Pharaoh regards the pilgrimage as merely an excuse for a holiday; and bids Moses and Aaron no longer unsettle the people. burdens] Exodus 1:11, Exodus 2:11.

Exodus 5:5

5. the people of the land] the common work-people; cf. Jeremiah 52:25. They are already sufficiently numerous; and idleness will unsettle them, and make them dangerous to their masters.

Exodus 5:6-9

6–9. The Pharaoh commands the Egyptian ‘taskmasters’ (whom he must be supposed—see v. 10—to have summoned to his presence) to increase the tasks imposed upon the Israelites: they are to find their straw themselves, and yet to make the same number of bricks. Bricks in Egypt (which in the earlier periods were much larger than our bricks, generally about 15 × 7 × 4½ in.) were made (on Exodus 1:14) from the mud of the Nile, mixed usually with chopped straw or reed, to give it coherence and prevent cracks while drying, and then dried in the sun (EB. i. 609; cf. L. and B. i. 165). These bricks remained black. Burnt red brick was first introduced into Egypt by the Romans.

Exodus 5:8

8. tale] that which is told or counted: an archaism for ‘number’ (= Germ. Zahl). So v. 18, 1 Samuel 18:27, 1 Chronicles 9:28. Cf. Milton, L’Allegro, 67 f., ‘And every shepherd tells [i.e. counts: Psalms 48:12; Psalms 147:4] his tale [viz. of sheep] Under the hawthorn in the dale.’ The Heb. here means properly a rightly regulated amount. therefore they cry, &c.] Their request to be allowed to make a pilgrimage to their God is merely a pretext for idleness.

Exodus 5:9

9. Let them be fully occupied with their work, and have no time to regard ‘lying words,’ as if God had really demanded a pilgrimage of them.

Exodus 5:10-12

10–12. The ‘taskmasters’ communicate the Pharaoh’s commands to the people.

Exodus 5:12

12. to gather stubble] which might be difficult to find, except immediately after the harvest.

Exodus 5:13-14

13–14. Although however the number of workers was thus materially diminished, the ‘taskmasters,’ carrying out the Pharaoh’s injunctions, still demand the same tale of bricks; and as it is not forthcoming, the ‘officers’ (v. 6) of the Israelites are held responsible for the deficit, and beaten.

Exodus 5:14

14. task] prescribed portion (or amount): cf. Proverbs 30:8 (RVm.), Exodus 31:15. Not as in v. 13, or as in ‘taskmasters’ (v. 6). yesterday and to-day] i.e., by Heb. idiom, recently. So heretofore is lit. ‘yesterday and the third day’; cf., in the Hebrews , vv7, 8.

Exodus 5:15-19

15–19. The officers of the Israelites expostulate with the Pharaoh, but to no effect. Cf. Erman, 177 (a complaint of the absence of straw).

Exodus 5:16

16. they say] viz. the Egyptian ‘taskmasters.’ but the fault is in thine own people] The text cannot be right: not only is the Heb. ungrammatical, but the fault was not in the people, but in the king. It is better, adding one letter, to read with LXX. Pesh. Di. Bä. ‘and thou sinnest against thine own people,’ i.e. committest a wrong against thine own subjects, the Hebrews.

Exodus 5:17-18

17, 18. The king impatiently turns them away, repeating the charge of idleness which he had made before (v. 8), and insisting again that they must produce the same amount of bricks as before.

Exodus 5:19

19. in evil case] in having to tell their people that there was to be no abatement from their daily task. The description here given of Egyptian brick-making is well illustrated from the monuments. The accompanying illustration (given more completely in Wilk.-B. i. 344) from the tomb of Rekhmâra, vizier of Thothmes III (1503–1449 b.c.), at ‘Abd el-Ḳ ?urnah, opposite to Luxor, represents Asiatic captives making bricks for the temple of Amon at Thebes. On the left we see men drawing water from a tank to moisten the mud: elsewhere there are men carrying the mud in baskets, kneading it with their feet, placing it in moulds (which would usually be stamped with the name of the reigning king), exposing the bricks to dry, piling them up in rows, and building a wall with them; in the lower picture we notice an Egyptian ‘taskmaster’ with hid rod. The gangs of slaves, or captives, engaged upon such work, were organized almost like an army: they were under the superintendence of ‘standard-bearers,’ chosen out of the Egyptian army (corresponding to the ‘taskmasters’ here), and they had also officers of their own (corresponding to the shôṭ ?erim), who were responsible to the standard-bearers. See Erman, pp. 417 f., 128. At Tell el-Maskhuta, the site of Pithom (Exodus 1:11), M.

Naville found bricks, some made with chopped straw or reed, and some without it (Pithom, p. 11b). Most Egyptian bricks, however, do not contain straw; and Petrie (Egypt and Israel, 30) think that the straw here asked for was for dipping the hand in, or sprinkling over the still soft bricks, that they might not stick.

Exodus 5:20-21

20–21. On coming out from their audience with the Pharaoh, they meet Moses and Aaron; and blame them for being the cause of this aggravation of the people’s sufferings.

Exodus 5:21

21. Jehovah look upon you, and judge] not leave you unheeded and unpunished, for the evil you have brought upon the people. made our savour to be abhorred, &c.] lit. made our savour to stink; as we should say, brought us into ill odour with: cf. Genesis 34:30; also, in the Heb., 1 Samuel 13:4, 2 Samuel 10:6 al. to put, &c.] They have simply, by asking permission for the pilgrimage, given the Pharaoh an opportunity to ruin us.

Exodus 5:22-23

22–23. Moses expostulates with Jehovah; and asks why He has thus brought trouble upon His people, and sent Moses himself upon a fruitless mission. entreated] an archaism for treated (ill-treated); so Genesis 12:16, Numbers 11:11, Deuteronomy 26:6 al. Elsewhere the same Heb. is rendered dealt ill with (Genesis 43:6), or brought evil upon (1 Kings 17:20). For the colours of the original, the copper-coloured bodies and white loin-cloths of the men, and the blue water in the tank, &c., see Lepsius’ Denkmäler, v. 40. For the inscriptions accompanying the pictures, see the Introduction, p. xxxi.

Exodus 5:23

23. neither, &c.] according to the promise, Exo Exodus 3:8.