Menu
‹ Chapter 204 of 255 ›

WINDING UP, FOR THE PRESENT, THE SCIENCE DISCUSSION

4 min read · Chapter 204 of 255

The neighbours were out in force the following night. Before the evening was over some of them turned upon Jericho Jones. They were determined to finish the battle that had been begun when the book agent was there a fortnight ago.

"Come, now, Jerry," said one of them; "we will, for the present, raise no question as to whether your iron-clad was made or was developed. But just tell us where that original dug-out came from which you said formed your protoplasm."

"I told you," said Jerry, "that it originated from matter, force, and motion."

"Yes, but is that all?" said the other.

"Science knows of nothing back of that," retorted Jerry.

"Jerry," his inquisitor resumed, "there's that bundle of shingles you are sitting on; it is composed of matter. The shingles were cut by means of force, and the force was attended by motion; but was there no fourth element connected with its manufacture--no mechanic who had a hand in it?"

"Of course, there was," said Jerry.

"Well, then," returned the other, "do you pretend to say that the universe came into existence from matter, force, and motion only without any Creator to wield them all?"

"Nothing but what we scientists call the Unknown and the Unknowable."

"Do you pretend to say, Jerry, that nobody can know anything whatever about that unseen power—whether it is intelligent, or is wise, or has any design or plan or purpose?"

"I do," said Jerry. "I would have you know, neighbours, that I am an Agnostic;" and he folded his arms in proud complacency.

About half the company were familiar with the word; the others were not. The former burst into a roar of merriment; the latter were dazed for a moment.

Jimmy Riggs spoke up—

"An Agnostic! Now, what is that again?"

An appeal was made to the schoolmaster to explain the word.

"An Agnostic," he replied, "Jimmy, is an ignoramus. 'Agnostic' is a Greek word, and means 'one who does not know anything.' 'Ignoramus' is a Latin word, and means about the same thing."

"Do you mean to say," asked Jimmy again, "that an Agnostic is a natural-born fool or a self-made fool?"

"Far from it, Jimmy; he is not so much a natural-born fool as a self-made fool—which is something a great deal worse. However, there is a difference in the use of the words. An ignoramus usually means a poor dolt or dunce who has never had a chance to learn anything; an Agnostic is a lofty term which scientists assume to cover wilful ignorance."

Jimmy lapsed into a profound and silent endeavour to grapple with the new ideas thus sprung upon him.

The schoolmaster continued his remarks for the benefit of the others—

"You see, neighbours, it is just here: there are only three ways possible of finding out the origin and the drift of all things:

"First, to be on the spot and see with one's own eyes. Of course, that is out of the question.

"Second, to learn by inference, which is an application of the doctrine that a design proves a designer. Many scientists fight against this mode of dealing with the subject. The only real reason for so doing is that they do not like to accept the conclusions to which the evidences of design would lead them—the recognition of an almighty and personal God.

"Third, testimony of a witness—that is, of the Creator. The scientists do not like to admit any Creator. They trace the origin of the locomotive up to the machine-shop. There they abruptly stop, saying, 'here is matter, force, and motion.' They refuse to step within the workshop and face the engineer

who built the locomotive. Up to the point of reaching the Creator, sceptical scientists profess to know almost everything; beyond that point they deny that it is possible to know anything. They say, 'It is impossible we should find out anything about the engineer who is alleged to have made this locomotive. We don't know anything, and we don't want to know anything. Let us enjoy the locomotive itself. Eat and drink, for to-morrow we die.'

When the company dispersed, Jimmy betook himself home. His wife asked him—

"Jimmy, what was all that racket over at the saw-mill about?"

"Well, I don't know that I can exactly tell, Hannah; I am a good deal mixed in my own mind about it. But they say that all the different things in the world made themselves—sort of grew, like."

Dame Riggs opened her eyes and stared at Jimmy, waiting for further information. Jimmy floundered along as best he could.

"And where did all that nonsense start from?"

"It was commenced," Jimmy replied, "by that book agent who was here two weeks ago. He was backed up by Jerry Jones; but I don't think Jerry believed a word of what he was saying. He is always talking some sort of nonsense. The book agent explained it to us by speaking of your dough that you make into biscuits and crullers. He said that dough divided itself up into one thing and another of its own accord."

Dame Riggs's eyes snapped—

"Did he mean to say that I had nothing to do with making those biscuits?"

Jimmy was meek, and took an alarm:

"Well, really, Hannah, I don't exactly know what he did mean."

Just at this moment who should come in but Jerry Jones himself, who wanted to borrow some little thing from Jimmy.

Dame Riggs turned to him—

"Well, Jerry, what is all this nonsense that has been going on over at the saw-mill?"

Jerry went on to explain that all things were evolved, or developed, or made up, out of one simple material.

"Just for instance, Mrs. Riggs, as all your nice bread and biscuits and jumbles came from one original piece of dough."

"Yes, but who made them different, and where did the dough come from?" quickly asked Hannah, who had common sense, if not science.

Jerry made an evasive reply.

The dame put another question—

"And did the heavens and the earth have no Creator, either?"

"Well, we scientists don't know of any Creator."

"And, Jerry, do you make your ignorance the measure of other people's knowledge?" The dame looked at him for a moment or two in silence. Then she said slowly, with a mixture of pity and contempt, "Jerry, if I didn't know that you did have common sense when you choose to use it, I would set you down as an idiot. If that's all you have to talk about over there, you and Jimmy both ought to be at home."

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate