STIMPSON AND JIM MANLY EXCHANGE VIEWS
The notable events of the next evening were three:
First, a preliminary set to between Jim Manly and Stimpson.
Second, a general charge on Jerry's position.
Third, a supplementary talk between Jimmy Riggs and his wife on the evolution of dough.
Jim Manly complained that Jericho Jones was not wishing to help, but to hinder, the cause of science. The dug-out as an illustration did not represent the case fairly. A dug-out is a senseless piece of wood. But the bioplasm of science has life; and it is the life which enables it to evolve and differentiate.
Stimpson replied—
"Well, Jim, that, instead of making it easier, only makes it harder for you to explain. For instance: on your work-bench you have a screw-driver made out of an old file. Now, it wouldn't do to say that that file had made itself into a screw-driver; it's your business to account for the change. You have also on your work-bench another screw-driver, though a very small one. The top of the handle screws off. Inside are a dozen little implements of one kind and another—a little corkscrew, a bradawl, a punch, a tiny saw—any one of which can be fitted on the end and used. The instrument can punch; it can bore; it can file; it can saw; and what not. Now, it is much harder to explain the origin of that set of tools than of the first one; but suppose, in addition to its being able to do a good many kinds of work, that the bradawl handle had the power of working itself, and, still more, had the power to discern where its work was needed; that it could see where a hole was needed, and could make it; could see where a line was needed, and could mark it; could chisel a little at one time and rasp a little at another; and, without anybody's help or anybody's handling it, could make some ingenious piece of cabinet work. You would certainly have a marvellous tool, and you would have a big job on hand to tell how it came to do all that.
"So about your bioplasm. You say that it has life, and therefore it knows how to do things. You have got a harder question to answer now than you had before. Tell me, what is life? Where does it come from? If I should ask you how the little handle came to do such a piece of cabinet-work, and you shall tell that it was because it had power to do so, you would not be answering my question. I ask you, how is it the bioplasm does this? Before, there were two questions to be put to you:
"First. Where did bioplasm come from?
"Second. How did it get its power to differentiate?
35
"And now to these you render necessary the addition of another question:
"Third Where did the bioplasm get its life from?
"It did not always have it; it originated at some time. It must either have originated from an outside source, or it must have originated from itself. You, who boast of your scientific knowledge, do not like to admit that this life came from some independent and outside source, because that would lead you too near to the recognition of a personal God. You prefer to believe that life originated itself. Indeed, you are forced to hold that view if you reject the other. And if you hold that perishable life originates itself, then I don't see that Jericho is so very unscientific when he teaches that his dug-out gradually evolved some sort of intelligence and some sort of differentiating power of its own. It might require myriads and myriads of ages, and a succession of myriads of dug-outs one after the other, each one showing an infinitesimal advance upon the preceding ones, before we reach the period of even the homely Indian canoe which Jerry takes as his bioplasm. His talk is nonsensical, I know; but then, to tell you the honest truth, Jim, so is yours. I can't see that there is any substantial difference between you. You insist upon unlimited time; that's all he wants. Besides, you know, you teach that this world, in its present state, is tens of thousands of years old. Who knows but the ancestors of Jericho's dug-out go 'way back beyond the Carboniferous period? If one atom of matter can originate life, I don't see why another cannot. Your leading scientists aver that the promise and potency of all life was in the fire-mist of the remote ages of the past. Mark you, they say all life. Now, do give Jerry's dug-out a little of the benefit of the supposition.
"The fact is, Jim, if anybody else would talk about ordinary matters as scientists talk about their matters, people would set him down as a natural-born fool. Both you and I were at the great Exposition in Philadelphia. You saw the huge Corliss engine. All around it, in every direction, ingenious machines were at work. Some were pumping water; some were weaving; some were printing; some were sewing. You did not see the power that moved all these things: all you saw was matter, force, and motion. Now, suppose I had chosen to deny that there was any intelligence behind all this, would you set me down for a knave or for a fool? Suppose I should say to you, there is nothing here but mechanical law, and 'science is its prophet;' I should be doing just what the worshippers of science are doing every day. I behold the movements of the ponderous engine, and I cry out—'No builder!' I see the looms working out their marvellous patterns of beauty, and I cry out—'No designer!' I see the printing-press throwing off printed sheets faster than I can pick them up, and I cry—'No artificer!' I behold a thousand objects of ingenious handicraft, and I cry—'No maker!'
"Your men of science look at this wondrous earth, with its innumerable adaptations to specific ends, and they cry out—'No Creator!' They behold the wondrous movement of the heavenly bodies, and they cry out—'No God!' 'No Preserver!' 'No Providence!' They say they do not see a Creator at work; they say they have never seen him at work. Why, therefore, should they admit there is one? But because they say they do not see the hand of a Creator, is that evidence that there is no Creator? I might go through a machine-shop where a hundred kinds of work are done; I might possibly, by great care and by dodging this way and that, manage to avoid seeing directly any one at work. Then I might go away and say I saw the engine in process of building, but declare upon my word of honour that I did not see anyone at work on it. To maintain and perpetuate ignorance in such a case must demand consummate tact and skill. Your men of science, while examining and probing the innumerable things that God has made, can never for a single moment escape the evidence of design; and yet they declare themselves ignorant of the existence of a Creator. The achievement of ignorance, under such circumstances, is a greater feat of genius than any of their discoveries has ever been."
539
