CROMWELL'S PURITANISM
This was a task highly difficult. Many of the letters had seen the light in various forms, but were so presented to the public as to repel: "too often," says Mr. Carlyle, "it is apparent that the very editor of these poor utterances had, if reading mean understanding, never read them. They stand in their old spelling; mispunctuated, misprinted, unelucidated, unintelligible—defaced with the dark incrustations too well known to students of that period." This industrious, painstaking editor, however, saw much light out "of darkness on the back of darkness, thick and threefold;" and how bright that light has been for us who reap the harvest of an author's toilsome and persevering efforts, writers of all kinds and professions, and readers of all sorts, have plainly seen. Perhaps the grimness of Cromwell's religious character—or we should rather say, its grim aspect, for it was not destitute of light and sweetness—had peculiar attractions for so rugged a mind as the editor's; and the unprosaic and vigorous piety of the Protector admirably met the tastes of a writer who has shown by his works how much he can appreciate brave conviction in past days. We are not insensible of Carlyle's theological inadequacies, but there is something in his teaching more noble even than his most ruthless unveiling of immeasurable cant, or his strongest, and as we think unwarrantable condemnations of the present day. And we give a warm welcome to the very cheap edition recently issued of "Oliver Cromwell's Letters and Speeches," and wish for it a success proportioned to its universally admitted deserts. The work must ever be regarded as an English classic, which no educated man or lad will fail to read.
The letters of Cromwell, Mr. Carlyle has pointed out, are not distinguished by literary art—"No eloquence, elegance, not always even clearness of expression, is to be looked for in them." Cromwell had no time for such arts. Perhaps, he had but little disposition for them. "Superfluity, as if by a natural law of the case, the writer has had to discard; whatsoever quality can be dispensed with is indifferent to him. With unwieldy movement, yet with a great solid step he presses through, towards his object; has marked out very decisively what the real steps towards it are; discriminating well the essential from the extraneous." And again, "Cromwell, emblem of the dumb English, is interesting to me by the very inadequacy of his speech. Heroic insight valour and belief, without words—how noble is it in comparison to the adroitest flow of words without heroic insight."
Glimpses here and there in this wonderful collection of letters are afforded us of the nature of the Protector's piety. Worthy of study are they all. In an age when Puritanic sincerity was as greatly scoffed at and lampooned by witless worldlings, as loyalty to the same fundamental truths is denounced to-day by the pretentious superfine criticism of the "advanced" theologians, Cromwell, with true manly vigour, gave his adhesion to the cause of evangelical religion. He became, as his biographer truly says, "the soul of the Puritan revolt;" hence the popular fancy is correct, and the general vilification of his character easily accounted for. "His words, and still more his silences," says Mr. Carlyle, "and unconscious instincts, when you have spelt and lovingly deciphered these also out of his words, will in several ways reward the study of an earnest man. An earnest man, I apprehend, may gather
from these words of Oliver's, were there even no other evidence, that the character of Oliver, and of the Affairs he worked in, is much the reverse of that mad jumble of 'hypocrisies,' etc., etc., which at present passes current as such."
The earliest letter extant reveals Cromwell's religious earnestness. At a time when the saintly Laud was hunting down all gospel lecturers and putting an end to all gracious discourses, Oliver wrote from St. Ives beseeching his "very loving friend, Mr. Storie, at the sign of the Dog in the Royal Exchange, London," to see that Dr. Wells, "a man of goodness and industry," probably labouring at St. Ives, should not fail in his lectureship through lack of funds—"for who goeth to warfare at his own cost? I beseech you, therefore, in the bowels of Jesus Christ, put it forward and let the good man have his pay." In this letter the noble writer very faithfully declares:—"Amongst the catalogue of those good works which your fellow-citizens and our countrymen have done, this will not be reckoned for the least, that they have provided for the feeding of souls. Building of hospitals provides for men's bodies; to build material temples is judged a work of piety; but they that procure spiritual food, they that build up spiritual temples, they are the men truly charitable, truly pious." An argument this every way for the proper sustentation of godly ministers and the augmentation of their incomes—a clear proof that whatever his faults, Oliver had no sympathy with the heresy of those who depreciate the Christian ministry, and count the honest labourer unworthy of his honest hire.
Throughout his life, Cromwell remained true to his early religious convictions. We see in all his letters evidences of his unfaltering faith in the truths of the gospel; and his earnest personal piety is to be observed in his correspondence with the members of his family and with his political associates. He gives us in one letter a very pleasing testimony of his conversion. We may be sure that it was in no spirit of affectation or hypocrisy that he confessed the unsatisfactoriness of his past life. "You know what my manner of life hath been. Oh, I lived in and loved darkness, and hated light; I was a chief, the chief of sinners. This is true: I hated godliness, yet God had mercy on me. O the riches of his mercy! Praise him for me;—pray for me, that he who hath begun a good work would perfect it in the day of Christ." It is not needful for us to interpret this confession as some have done. There is no evidence that the writer had been grossly immoral, or dissolute in any way. A man may feel himself to be the chief of sinners who has lived a fairly moral life; sins against light and knowledge, warning and reproof, conscience and God, are grave enough to justify the lowliest confession. Clerical writers have been only too anxious to damn this man's character before conversion, and to flagellate him for an hypocrisy which they love to ascribe to him.
* "Reverend Mark Noble says, the above letter is very curious and a convincing proof how far gone Oliver was, at that time, in religious enthusiasm. Yes, my reverend imbecile friend, he is clearly one of those singular Christian enthusiasts who believe that they have a soul to be saved, even as you do, my reverend imbecile friend, that you have a stomach to be satisfied—and who likewise, astonishing to say, actually take some trouble about that. Far gone, indeed, my reverend imbecile friend!"—Carlyle, vol. i., p. 70.
177
There is so little that is compatible with the Christian life in the savage work of bloodshed, (Dr. Norman Macleod notwithstanding,) that the frequent references to God in Cromwell's letters during the Civil War rather grate upon the sensitive ear. And yet such allusions made by men deeply imbued with the spirit of the Old Testament, believing in the "God of hosts," the "Lord strong and mighty in battle," the Lord as "a man of war," deeply persuaded that their cause was God's, and that they were but instruments in his hands (as, indeed, half an eye can see) were perfectly natural. Not difficult to understand are these brave Puritan warriors. We all know the oft-repeated story of the men of Naseby—the Ironsides, the Invincibles—who "when the roaring shot poured thick and hot" were "stalwart men and true;" who in the death-grapple of physical force made their proud enemies give way inch by inch, and triumphed over the very men who had heretofore flouted and ridiculed in their cups the psalm-singing men of Liberty. It was not a gloomy fanaticism, an unscrupulous purpose, a whining cant, that made these men mighty in the presence of foemen worthy of their steel. These were men of character, of probity and virtue, and stern piety, strong in principle, stout of heart, and unbending in the presence of temptation and wrong. Significant enough was Cromwell's description of these determined foes of oppressions, kingly and cleric: they were men "who made some conscience of what they did." They were proudly conscious of the justness of their cause, and to the God of battles they committed its issue. And Cromwell not only shared this conviction, but represented it with an intensified earnestness. After the battle of Marston Moor, he wrote: "Truly England and the church of God hath had a great favour from the Lord, in this great victory given unto us, such as the like never was since this war began. It had all the evidences of an absolute victory obtained by the Lord's blessing upon the godly party principally." The enemy was not charged, he goes on to say, but routed: "God made them as stubble to our swords." This he writes to Colonel Valentine Walton, who had lost his son in this battle, as will appear from the following excerpt which is worth reading:—
"Sir,—God hath taken away your eldest son by a cannon-shot. It broke his leg. We were necessitated to have it cut off, whereof he died. Sir, you know our own trials this way,* but the Lord supported me with this, that the Lord took him into the happiness we all pant for and look for. There is your precious child full of glory, never to know sin or sorrow any more. He was a gallant young man, exceedingly gracious. God give you his comfort. Before his death he was so full of comfort, that to Frank Russel and myself he could not express it, 'It was so great above his pain.' This he said to us. Indeed it was admirable. A little after, he said, 'one thing lay upon his spirit.' I asked him what that was? He told me it was, that God had not suffered him to be any more the executioner of His enemies. • • • • But few knew him; for he was a precious young man, fit for God. You have cause to bless the Lord. He is a glorious saint in heaven; wherein you ought exceedingly to rejoice. Let this drink up your sorrow; seeing these are not feigned words to comfort you, but the thing is so real and undoubted a truth. You may do all things by the strength of Christ. Seek that, and you shall easily bear your trial. Let this public mercy to the church of God make you to forget your private sorrow."
* Cromwell had only recently lost his son, Oliver, in conflict with the Royalists.
Slanderous tongues were busy in those days as afterwards, and Cromwell heard and treated them with the contempt that slander richly deserves. "We desire," he says, with true lofty dignity, "to refer the many slanders heaped upon us by false tongues to God,—who will, in due time, make it appear to the world that we study the glory of God, and the honour and liberty of the Parliament, for which we unanimously fight, without seeking our own interests." This has in it the ring of Puritanism, which never shrank from any self-denying ordinance, or from any painful self-sacrifice. Cromwell gives ample proofs, by letters and speeches, of his extreme dislike of the civil war. He professed to detest and abhor the accusation that had been made against the Parliamentarians, that they sought to maintain their religious opinions by force. "I profess," he says, "I could never satisfy myself of the justness of this war, but from the authority of the Parliament to maintain itself in its rights; and in this cause I hope to approve myself an honest man and single hearted." A few months after this was written, Cromwell rose from his seat in the House of Commons, and in the midst of breathless silence uttered these historic words: "It is now a time to speak, or for ever hold the tongue. The important occasion now is no less than to save a nation out of a bleeding, nay, almost dying, condition, which the long continuance of this war hath already brought it to; so that without a more speedy, vigorous and effectual prosecution of the war—casting off all lingering proceedings like those of soldiers-of-fortune beyond sea, to spin out a war—we shall make the kingdom weary of us and hate the name of a Parliament." This speech was delivered in view of the celebrated Self-denying Ordinance, and very briskly indeed did the "great business," as Cromwell invariably called it, proceed after this new epoch in military affairs.
Cromwell sits down quietly after the storming of poor Bristol, and gives to Mr. Speaker a full and detailed account of the work and of its successful issue. He thinks he must be a very atheist who cannot see that "all this is none other than the work of God." Praises were due to the gallant men: "It's their joy that they are instruments of God's glory and their country's good. It's their honour that God vouchsafes to use them. Sir, they that have been employed in this service know that faith and prayer obtained this city for you: I do not say ours only, but of the people of God with you and all England over, who have wrestled with God for a blessing in this very thing. Our desires are, that God may be glorified by the same spirit of faith by which we ask all our sufficiency, and have received it." There is an unusually grand religious force about these convictions; this rugged Puritanism is heroically expressed.
In the midst of those difficult, intricate Scotch negotiations, Cromwell can find but little time to write to the members of his family; but, when he does this, he manifests deep religious concern for his kith and kin. Writing from the fashionable quarter of Drury-lane—how hard to realise that this low haunt was ever fashionable!—he urges his newly-wedded daughter not to forget the culture of her soul. "Dear heart, press on! let not husband, let not anything cool thy affections after Christ." On the contrary, he hopes the new relationship will subserve her spiritual interests. "That which is best worthy of love in thy
179
husband is that of the image of Christ he bears. Look on that, and love it best, and all the rest for that." His anxiety a little further on, that his son should have as a wife one who had "that assurance of godliness" is not insignificant. The father who made "the offer of a very great proposition" to Oliver, in the shape of his daughter to Oliver's son, whoever he was, seems to be a moral and fair sort of man, but of anything beyond there was no certainty in Cromwell's mind. He had, on these grounds, other preferences.
Quite at home, and exceedingly friendly with those right honourable Puritan noblemen and gentlemen, whose delight was great in sustaining a godly and efficient ministry, Cromwell, behind none in this service to the state, encouraged them not a little, and poured forth his earnest and devout desires to them. To Lord Wharton he thus writes—a thanksgiving letter it is: "When we think of our God, what are we? Oh, his mercy to the whole society of saints,—despised, jeered saints! Let them mock on. Would we were all saints! The best of us are, God knows, poor weak saints, yet saints; if not sheep, yet lambs, and must be fed. We have daily bread, and shall have it, in spite of all enemies. There's enough in our Father's house, and he dispenseth it. I think through these outward mercies, as we call them, faith, patience, love, hope, are exercised and perfected,—yea, Christ formed, and grows to a perfect man within us."
Here we have good Puritanic advice,—lessons learnt from such uncommonly good chaplains as Dr. Owen, and Dr. Goodwin—given to the wife of Lieut.-General Fleetwood:—
"Salute your dear wife from me. Bid her beware of a bondage spirit. Fear is the natural issue of such a spirit; the antidote is love. The voice of fear is: 'if I had done this, if I had avoided that, how well it had been with me!' I know this hath been her vain reasoning, poor Biddy!
"Love argueth in this wise: 'what a Christ have I; what a Father in and through him. What a name hath my Father, merciful, gracious, long-suffering, abundant in goodness and truth, forgiving iniquity, transgression, and sin. What a nature hath my Father: he is love: free in it, unchangeable, infinite. What a covenant between him and Christ, for all his seed, for every one, wherein he undertakes all, and the poor soul nothing! The new covenant is grace—to or upon the soul; to which it (the soul) is passive and receptive; I'll do away their sins, I'll write my law, &c.; I'll put it in their hearts,—they shall never depart from me, &c.'
"This commends the love of God: its Christ's dying for men without strength, for men whilst sinners, whilst enemies. And shall we seek for the root of our comforts within us,—what God hath done, what he is to us in Christ, is the root of our comfort, in this is stability; in us is weakness. Acts of obedience are not perfect, and therefore yield not perfect grace. Faith as an act yields it not; but only as it carries us into him, who is our perfect rest and peace; in whom we are accounted of, and received by, the Father—even as Christ himself. This is our high calling. Rest we here, and only here."
Surely, there is here much soundness in theology, and much spiritual perception likewise. Cromwell clearly had not seen the abyss of "advanced thought," now so perceptible alas! But it was something to be contented with such really substantial thought as was given the world by the Puritan chaplains afore-mentioned. And now, Oliver Cromwell is, significantly enough, "His Highness."
We might almost say "his Royal Highness," but that he refuses all kingship, and manifests but little faith in titles. He is a true king, nevertheless, the only fit one that all England could then find. His words are royal, although his speech limps; his thoughts and designs are best of all. A fervently devout king too!—in the great congregation of Parliament, reminding "my lords and gentlemen" of the goodness of God to this nation; appropriating for this purpose the Psalmist's jubilant strains, "Surely salvation is nigh unto them that fear him; that glory may dwell in our land." "Thou hast been favourable to thy land:" "Truly I hope," says Cromwell, "this is His land. In some sense it may be given out that it is God's land; and he that hath the weakest knowledge, and the worst memory, can easily tell that we are 'a redeemed people' 'from the time' when God was first pleased to to look favourably upon us, 'to redeem us' out of the hands of Popery, in that never-to-be-forgotten Reformation, that most significant and greatest 'mercy' the nation hath felt or tasted." The preaching of the gospel without let or hindrance, he goes on to say, is a distinguishing mercy: "Who would have forethought when we were plunged into the midst of our troubles, that ever the people of God should have had liberty to worship God without fear or enemies." Indeed, it was a triumph, all the greater when contrasted with subsequent events, and repealings, and oppressive acts against conscience, and a general state of what astronomers call "backwardation" which clearly Cromwell could not have foreseen. In this very speech, as in others, we have not only the fundamental creed of Puritanism, or Calvinism, (not hyper however) stated, but somewhat expounded; for the speaker was a skilled theologian, accustomed to all the ins-and-outs of the much-abused Five Points, and a very earnest lover and supporter of a godly and instructive ministry. No one had a keener perception of genius in the pulpit than he. Gathering round him men who could preach, and think, and write; scholars, of whose scholarship no preacher need now be ashamed; men mighty in the Scriptures far beyond any who have come after them, as some of us still think, despite the current of the times; Cromwell showed how intelligently and completely he had grasped the doctrines then so ably and profitably expounded.
As Carlyle tells us, in his dying hours Cromwell spoke much of "the Covenants." "Faith in the Covenant," made holy and true by the Mediator of the Covenant, "is my only support." This he left to his wife and children "to feed upon." "All the promises of God are in him; yea, and in him Amen; to the glory of God by us—by us in Jesus Christ." Beautiful hope to die with!
