Menu
‹ Chapter 52 of 203 ›

Remarks on Beecher's Life of Christ — By Vernon J. Charlesworth

13 min read · Chapter 52 of 203

THE author of "Ecce Homo" has endeavoured to write a Life of Christ from the standpoint of a contemporary. Mr. Beecher, on the other hand, has "endeavoured to present scenes that occurred two thousand years ago as they would appear to modern eyes if the events had taken place in our day." It is, perhaps, difficult to say whose task was the easier, or which of the two has achieved the greater success. Both works are characterised by fine touches of genius and poetry, and in a sense one is the complement of the other. We apply to neither the test of a rigid orthodoxy, but while questioning the soundness of many of the conclusions, we welcome the attempt of both writers to crystallise into a consistent whole the disjointed fragments of the evangelic records.

"Writing in full sympathy with the Gospels as authentic historical documents, and with the nature and teachings of the great personage whom they describe," Mr. Beecher has "attentively considered whatever has been said, on every side, in the works of critical objectors," and has sought to depict the Saviour, "in his life, his social relations, his disposition, his deeds, and his doctrines." These sentences indicate the scope of the work to which the author is committed, and of which we have the first instalment in the volume before us. It is not our intention to write a critical review, strictly speaking, but to glean from its ample pages a few choice extracts, which will be acceptable to those of our readers who cannot command the volume, and at the same time indicate, in all fidelity, the points upon which we join issue with the author. We are much mistaken if many of our readers are not induced to enrich their libraries by the addition of a book, which, beyond all his other productions, will secure for Mr. Beecher no obscure niche in the temple of fame.

The chapter on the overture of angels abounds with striking metaphors in Mr. Beecher's best style. "Angels seem as birds when new-come in spring, to have flown hither and thither in songful mood, dipping their white wings into our atmosphere, just touching the earth, or glancing along its surface as sea-birds skim the surface of the sea. And yet birds are far too rude and wings too burdensome to express adequately that feeling of unlaboured angelic motion, which the narrative produces upon the imagination. Their airy and gentle coming would perhaps be better compared to the glow of colours flung by the sun upon morning clouds, that seem to be born just where they appear. Like a beam of light striking through some orifice, they shine upon Zacharias in the Temple. As the morning light finds the flowers, so found they the mother of Jesus. To the shepherds' eyes they filled the midnight arch like auroral beams of light; but not as silently, for they sang, and more marvellously than "when the morning stars sang together, and all the sons of God shouted for joy."

Mr. Beecher seems to grow dizzy by his lofty poetising, or he would not commit himself, in sober mood, to the proposition that "traits of personal tenderness and generous love will draw the human heart to God." History warrants no such belief; indeed, it flatly contradicts it. The unsullied purity of the character of Jesus revealed human guilt as it never had been revealed before, and its light proving intolerable, men instead of being drawn to God, merged their prejudices in the common cry, "away with Him, away with Him, crucify Him, crucify Him!" Incarnate excellence does not destroy the enmity of the carnal mind.

"As asters, among plants, go all summer long unbeautiful, their flowers hidden within, and burst into bloom at the very end of summer and in late autumn, with the frosts upon their heads, so this aged saint (Simcon) had blossomed at the close of a long life, into this noble ecstasy of joy. In a stormy time, when outward life moves wholly against one's wishes, he is truly great whose soul becomes a sanctuary in which patience dwells with hope. In one hour Simcon received full satisfaction for the yearnings of many years."

"The guide of the Magi was a light kindled in the heavens to instruct and lead those whose eyes were prepared to receive it." In dealing with those who eliminate the miraculous from the historic narrative of the appearance of the star in the east, the author's sarcasm is most refreshing. "The disciples plucked the wheat-heads, and rubbing them in their hands, they ate the grain. But our sceptical believers take from the New Testament its supernatural element,—rub out the wheat and eat the chaff."

In the second chapter, Mr. Beecher deals with metaphysical questions respecting the original nature of Christ. He sets aside the humanitarian view which regards Jesus simply as an extraordinary man; the theory of compromise which represents him as more than human but as less than divine; and the doctrine of the church, since the fourth century, which attributes to Jesus a double nature—a human soul and a divine soul in one body,—and stands to "the simple and more philosophical views of the sacred Scriptures." "We are not to look," he says, "for a glorified, an enthroned Jesus, but for God, manifest in the flesh; and, in this view, the very limitations and seeming discrepancies

171

in a divine life become congruous parts of the whole sublime problem. We are to distinguish between difficulties which are inherent in the nature of the infinite, and those which are but the imperfections of our own philosophy. In the one case, the perplexity lies in the weakness of our reason; in the other, the weakness of our reasoning. The truth of the proper divinity of Christ is the marrow of the sacred Scriptures."

Without qualification the following propositions do not express the truth respecting man as a fallen being:—"Man's nature and God's nature do not differ in kind, but in degree of the same attributes. The identification of the divine and the human nature was one of the grand results of the Incarnation. Manhood is nearer Godhood than we have been wont to believe." It is true that "God said, let us make man in our image." But how little trace of the divine origin is there in fallen humanity? The Fall has obliterated the fair marks of our heavenly original. The splendour of Eden's innocency is eclipsed by the black pall of sin. To accomplish human redemption God has sent forth his Son, "the express image of his person," and "He hath predestinated us to be conformed to the image of his son." But we think our author forgets that all this points to the upbringing of redeemed humanity only, in resurrection, to the standard of God's lofty ideal, and by no means justifies the assertion of the identity of the divine and human now. It is not logical to assume an ultimate limited possibility to be a present universal fact.

"For twelve years of childhood the only syllable of history uttered is, 'and the child grew, and waxed strong in spirit, filled with wisdom, and the grace of God was upon him.' This, then, was not a divinity coming through the clouds into human life, full-orbed, triumphing with the undiminished strength of a heavenly nature over those conditions which men must bear. It was a divine child, and childhood meant latent power, undeveloped faculty, unripe organs, a being without habits, without character, without experience; a cluster of germs, a branch full of unblossomed buds, a mere seed of manhood. Except his mother's arms, there was no circle of light about his head, fondly as artists have loved to paint it. Nothing could be more unnatural than to suppose that he was a child without childhood, a full and perfect being cleft from the Almighty, as Minerva was fabled to have come from the head of Jupiter. He was the Son of Man—a real boy, as afterwards he was a most manly man. How early he came to himself, and felt within him the motions of his Godhead, none can tell. At twelve he overrode the interpretations of the doctors, and, as one having authority, sat in judgment upon the imperfect religion of his ancestors. This first visit to Jerusalem stands up in his childhood as Mount Tabor rises from the plain—the one solitary point of definite record. It is plain, from his reply to his mother, that he was conscious of the nature that was in him, and that strong impulses urged him to disclose his power. It is, therefore, very significant, and not the least of the signs of divinity, that he ruled his spirit, and dwelt at home in unmurmuring expectation; this is in itself a wonder of divinity, if men were only wise enough to marvel."

In the chapter on "The Voice in the Wilderness," there is some clever writing on the prophetical office and the missions of the prophets. "A prophet was more than one who foretold events. He forefelt and

foretought high moral truths. He had escaped the thrall of passion in which other men lived; and, without help inherited from old civilizations, by the force of the divine Spirit, acting upon a nature of genius in moral directions, he went a-head of his nation and of his age, denouncing evil, revealing justice, enjoining social purity, and inspiring a noble piety. A prophet was born to his office. The call of God, in all ages, has come to natures already prepared for the office to which they were called. The morning star of a new era, John, is speedily lost in the blaze of him who was and is the 'light of the world.' His was one of those lives which are lost to themselves that they may spring up in others. He came both in grandeur and in beauty, like a summer storm, which, falling in rain, is lost in the soil, and re-appears neither as vapour nor cloud, but is transformed into flowers and fruits. John was Christ's forerunner, as the ploughman goes before the sower. Upon the rough furrows, and not on the shorn lawn, is there hope for the seed."

The meagre records which we possess do not warrant, we think, the assertion that in John's preaching "there was no future, no great spirit land, no heaven above his world." His call to repentance was surely based upon hope as well as fear. "Flee from the wrath to come" was not the whole of his message. The greatest amongst the prophets was certainly not the least evangelical.

Of John's baptism, Mr. Beecher asks, "was it into the Jewish church that he baptised? Was it an initiation into a new sect? Was it Christian baptism?" His answer is negative on each point, and he says, "It was a symbolic act, signifying that one had risen to a higher moral condition. It was declaratory of moral transition." We are not disposed to quarrel with the author's judgment of the baptism of repentance, but when he asserts that "neither John, nor afterwards Jesus, gave to the act any ecclesiastical meaning," we demand his reasons for the assertion. The very formula of Christ's baptism is against the assumption. If baptism is that symbolic act by which a man declares, "I forsake my sins, and rise to a better life," where is the author's consistency in practising infant baptism? The inspired apostles always regarded Christian baptism as symbolic of incorporation with the mystical body of Christ, the church. It does not indicate, merely, the rising to a higher life, but the possession of a divine life in fellowship with the risen Christ. "We are crucified together with Christ; we are risen together with Christ," is the avowal of every believer by the symbolic voice of Christian baptism. The Church is the unity of saved men, and immersion is the divinely appointed sign of incorporation. "A baptism to a higher life would probably be Christ's interpretation of John's baptism for himself. And he submitted to it, as one of the great multitude. The rising from lower to higher moral states, Jesus experienced in common with the multitude." To us it is scarcely conceivable that, by a symbolic act, the Saviour made any advance in his moral state. We are quite contented with the belief that by this overt act he placed himself at the head of his baptised followers. The whole subject is capable of a fuller discussion, but this is beside our purpose in the present paper.

In treating of the temptation of our Lord, Mr. Beecher is bold without

173

being irreverent. "It is not strange to us, now well instructed in the spirit of Christ's mission, that he did not enter at once upon his work of teaching. Midway between his private life, now ended, and his public ministry, about to begin, there was to be a long and silent discipline. The three narratives of the temptation by Matthew, Mark, and Luke, lift us at once into the region of mystery. That which is important to any proper consideration of the obscure sublimity of this mystery is, that it shall be a temptation of the devil as an actual personal spirit; that it shall be a real temptation, or one that put the faculties of Christ's soul to task, and required a resistance of his whole nature, as other temptations do of human nature. It is on this account that we have regarded the temptation as of two parts or series—the first, a personal and private conflict, running through forty solitary days of fasting in the wilderness; and the second, a ministerial trial, represented by the symbolism of the bread, the temple, and the mountain top. Through that long battle of life, in which every man is engaged, and in every mood of the struggle which men of aspiration and moral sense make toward perfect holiness, there is an inspiration of comfort to be derived from the example of Christ. In places the most strange, and in the desolate way where men dwell with the wild beasts of the passions, if there be but a twilight of faith, we shall find his footsteps, and know that he has been there—is there again, living over anew in us his own struggles, and saying, with the authority of a God and the tenderness of a Father: 'In the world ye shall have tribulation; but be of good cheer; I have overcome the world.' Our author thinks that by fasting and solitude our divine Lord rose at length to the vision state, and that the three temptations foreshadowed the trials to which he would be exposed through his whole career in the use of divine power. The Satanic challenge, "command that these stones be made bread," Mr. Beecher interprets as "the spirit of this world soliciting Jesus to employ that divine power which now began to effilge in him, for secular and physical, rather than for moral and spiritual, ends. It was, if one might so say, the whole selfish spirit of time and history pleading that Jesus should work upon matter and for the flesh, rather than upon the soul and for the spirit."

Again, "Jesus was next solicited to let the spirit of admiration and praise be the genius of the new movement. 'If thou be the Son of God, cast thyself down from hence.' This symbol, as a trial scene, contains not only an appeal to the love of praise in Jesus, but an appeal to the principle of admiration in the multitude."

In the final scene "there was a tremendous temptation to exhibit before men his real place and authority; to appear as great as he really was; to so use his energies that men should admit him to be greater than generals, higher than kings, more glorious than temple or palace. In that mountain vision he saw the line of temptations which would beat in upon the principle of self-esteem, that source and fountain of ambition among men. With men, the difficulty is to rise into eminence. With Jesus, the very reverse was true." It is quite true, as the author admits, that "This view is not exhaustively satisfactory. No view is. Whichever theory one takes in explaining the temptation, he must take it with its painful perplexities."

In discussing the personal appearance of Jesus, Mr. Beecher admits the difficulties of his stand-point. He says, "The utmost care will not wholly prevent our beholding Jesus through the medium of subsequent history. His very name is a love-name, and kindles in tender and grateful natures a kind of poetry of feeling. As at evening, we see the sun through an atmosphere which the sun itself has filled with vapour, and by which its colour and dimensions are changed to the eye, so we see in Jesus the qualities which he has inspired in us. We see him in imagination, not as they saw him who companied with him from the beginning, but under the dazzling reflection of two thousand years of adoration. There is absolutely nothing to determine the personal appearance of Jesus. There is a conventional head of Christ which has come down to us through the schools of art, but it is of no direct historic value. It is not a little remarkable that this typical head is not a Jewish head. The christian artists all attempted to express in our Lord's face a feeling of spiritual elevation and of sympathy, which was wholly unknown to classic Grecian art. Still less is the historic art head of Christ of the Roman type. As Christ spiritually united in himself all nationalities, so in art his head has a certain universality. But, how unsatisfying is all art, even in its noblest achievements, when by the presentation of a human face it undertakes to meet the conceptions which we have of the glory of divinity! The gospels give a portrait, not of attitudes or of features, but of the disposition and of the soul. We must not, then, take with us, in following out the life of Jesus, the conception of a formidable being, terrible in holiness. We must clothe him in our imagination with traits that made little children run to him; that made mothers long to have him touch their babes; that won to him the poor and suffering; that made the rich and influential throw wide open the doors of their houses to him; that brought around him a company of noble women, who travelled with him, attended to his wants, and supplied his necessities from their own wealth; that irresistibly attracted those other women, in whom vice had not yet destroyed all longing for a better life; that excited among the learned a vehement curiosity of disputation, while the unlettered declared that he spake as one having authority."

(To be continued.)

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate