Menu
‹ Chapter 93 of 206 ›

The Personality, Deity, and Proper Honour of the Holy Ghost — A Paper Read At The College Conference, 1871 — By Pastor W. Anderson, Of Warkworth, Northumberland

18 min read · Chapter 93 of 206

IT is with diffidence I attempt the treatment of a subject so recondite and vast in an assembly like the present. Perhaps the proper place for ministerial youth with regard to this theme would be, the feet of "such an one as Paul the aged." The temerity and superficiality inseparable from

the thinkings of the immature, are far from being helps in dispelling the darkness which envelops the constitution of the Deity. Whilst candidly confessing this, allow us to remind you that, were we to delay the discussion of the Deity until we could adequately do so, our pen would remain for ever still and our lips for ever silent. Nor need the attempt of the inexperienced to gain and systematise a knowledge of God provoke censure; for as naturally as the flower bursts its bud to look upon the sun, the stream gushes to its ocean home, and the child turns his first filial feeling parentward, so natural is it for the renewed heart to seek after God; and provided it pursues its investigation reverently and inductively, the blessing of the pure in heart shall rest upon it. On the threshold of this theme we are met by the enquiry, What are the means and light placed within our reach for understanding the Godhead? To this we know of many, but can give only one satisfactory answer—the inspired Word of God. We are not, we hope, entirely unacquainted with the broken tones which rise from the deep of our sublime, though fallen nature, and which rightly

19

interpreted are cries after the Infinite. We have marked the efforts of Reason, in what is commonly called the field of natural theology, endeavouring, by a priori and a posteriori processes, to build an intellectual Babel, and thus form a view-point of God. We have pondered heart intuition, dwarfed and deadened by sin, or fostered and cultured by virtue, in its earnest but blind strivings after its Fount and Author; or, to pass from the abstract to the concrete, we have seen men receiving earth's dainties only to find them unsatisfying husks, pursuing pleasures only to meet bitter disappointment, as the hot hand grasps these sparkling dew-drops; and we have thought that from needs too vast for the universe to satisfy, we could form a faint guess of God. We have looked upon those whose ear has heard the calls of Conscience, and whose feet have tremblingly trodden the dimly-lighted path of virtue, and as we have listened to their plaintive prayer, "Give us light, and let us die," we have said, "Faint these sparks, but born to die; yet in their effort to fly upward, do they not tell of a central and undying sun?" Thus Reason, Intuition, the needs of the sinning, and the ideals of the virtuous for ages in classic heathendom, sought after God, finally resulting in the practical polytheism of the masses, the satiric scepticism of the many, and the vague theorists of the noble few. Turning from these nearly effaced heart-hieroglyphics, to a land some three hundred by two hundred miles, we find God for fifteen centuries giving a gradual apocalypse of himself. As in the Mosaic account of the creation, we are told, the work of the fourth day was, to centre in two ruling orbs the formerly existing light: so the sixty-six revelation fragments are now centred in the Old and New Testaments—the concentrated light of a thus completed Bible falling full upon the Deity. If, however, we conclude that therefore doubt and difficulty must end, we egregiously err. "Mystery," says Vinet, of Lausanne, "is the cup which holds the wine of truth; break the cup, and the wine is spilt." The Scripture revelation of the Godhead brings to us a mystery all its own—the doctrine of the Trinity—break, deny it, and you lose the soft aspect of Fatherhood, the tender relationship of Brotherhood, and the potently peaceful feeling of indwelling Deity. We have alluded to the doctrine of the Trinity here, lest in a close and separate study of its persons we should make over-prominent the Spirit, to the marring our views of the Father and the Son. Indeed, it appears to us impossible rightly to treat of one person unless we have clear and orthodox views of the Trinity. On this, time forbids that we should dwell, yet ere passing, let us hint at three heresies that beset the ponderer of any of the persons of the Godhead. We need hardly say we refer to the ὁμοιονιον, which degrades the second and third persons to the first rank of creatureship; to Sabellianism, which would give us unity in three phases, as the moon now seems a horn, then forms the arc of a circle, ultimately appearing globular; to Tritheism, which would give us the absurdity of three infinite and distinct Gods. In opposition to the first, we hold the ὁμοιονιον; in opposition to the second, we believe in the personality of the Father, Son, and Spirit; and in opposition to the last, we receive the unity of the essence.

Having looked at the faint Godward pointings of the human heart, taken the Scriptures as our infallible guide, and expressed our belief in

291

the Trinity, we now find our way disencumbered, and may at once advance to a separate study of God the Holy Ghost.

I. We shall first attempt to prove his personality. Let us preface our proof by showing the necessity for such a demonstration from bygone ecclesiastical history. According to Neander, the ancient church generally agreed in holding the personality of the Holy Ghost; it has also continued the common Christian belief of succeeding times. Yet there never have been wanting some to discard and deny it.

In the Patristic period, Lactantius and the Monarchians explained the Holy Ghost as the sanctifying energy of the Father and the Son. The uncle and nephew, Socinus, in the sixteenth century, of course endorsed the same tenet, differing only in holding that the energy came from the One God. Dr. John Owen, in his work on the Spirit, tells of some whom he calls Quakers (whether he always means by that appellation the definite sect, or whether he uses it often as a term of opprobrium, to designate those whom he deemed grievously heterodox, we are unable to determine), who, though receiving the divinity of the Son, believed not in the personality of the Spirit. And, strange as it may appear, that giant of evangelical Nonconformity, Robert Hall, was, we are told in his memoir by Dr. Gregory, a dualist up till about the year 1800, calling the third person of the Trinity in guarded words, "the influence of the Spirit of God." In view of such a past of doubt and opposition to what we believe Scriptural and important, it becomes us to have clear, and as far as may be, thorough convictions of the Spirit's personality. In explaining personality as subsistence, or mode of subsistence, we are apt to make it darker than before. In preference to any such definition, we shall consider it as possessing three constituents—consciousness, character, and will. If these can be affirmed of the Spirit, then most irrefragably can it be demonstrated that he is a person.

1. Let us attend, first, to the lowest part of personality, consciousness. Here at once the Scripture claims of the Holy Ghost join issue with the theory of his being an attribute or influence.

It may be well at the outset of our reasoning to make a frank confession, and guard against a false canon. We feel no hesitancy in allowing that many times in the Old Testament the words "Spirit of God" do not mean the third person of the Trinity. One would scarcely like to hazard his consciousness on Job xxvii. 3: "The Spirit of God is in my nostrils." But this concession is by no means to be cooled down into the dogmatic canon, that we are to see no more meaning in the Scriptures than they to whom they were at first given—that because they thought the breath which moved upon chaos was only an influence from God, that we are to arrive at the same conclusion; that because they looked upon prophetic inspiration as being a divine afflatus, we are wrong in looking upon it as the especial work of the Spirit. Those who would have us believe so, forget that God has sown his revelation field with acorn principles; that as seeds have been found in the cerements of Egyptian mummies, and have germinated and grown thousands of years after, so in the Old Testament Scriptures do we find germs of the doctrine and many works of the Spirit—largely unperceived, we doubt not, by the most pious and enlightened Jews, yet ready to rise into prominence under the revealings of Christianity. We own that sometimes

spirit may simply mean breath, and sometimes influence; yet we leave ourselves uncommitted and unbound, ready to claim all passages whose pointings, from contextual and New Testament allusion, are clear. From the feelings attributed to the Spirit, "being vexed and grieved," from the acts performed by him, convincing and sanctifying the soul, we are irresistibly compelled to acknowledge and receive the consciousness of the Spirit. We neither, we hope, overlook nor dispute the vast, almost boundless power of influence. We are ready to admit that even the indirect influence of a praying Redeemer prompted the request, "Teach us also to pray," that even the indirect influence of a peerless sufferer pierced the criminal darkness of the heart of the dying thief. We allow the potency of the brave Captain's influence on his fainting, despairing warriors; we glory in the influence of thoughts incarnate, sometimes confined in words and buried in boards, asserting ages after the prerogative of all original thinking to reproduce itself in other minds; we concede to influence an eternal power. That God might have accomplished by it all we believe is performed by the third person of the Trinity we do not deny, but content ourselves with reiterating our previously proven averment, that the Spirit is conscious, and consequently cannot be an influence.

"Yet," it might be asked, "Do not the phrases, 'baptised with the Holy Ghost,' 'filled with the Holy Ghost,' 'the Holy Ghost fell on them,' indicate and imply simply a divine influence?" To this a common reply would be, Christ is represented as a Sun, Star, and Branch. Does the appositeness of these figures endanger the consciousness of the Son? By such an answer the questioner may be silenced, but hardly enlightened. The true way, we think, in dealing with passages which seem to indicate that the Spirit is an influence, is, not evasively to lessen their force by an appeal to their figurative form, but fearlessly to seek in their application and operation a solution of the difficulty. Can spirits directly and consciously, without any medium, act upon each other? We think not. Were a rose and the sun unseen, how could we judge of their existence, but by the fragrance of the one and the beams of the other? Were an unseen musician to enchain our souls, while with ductile and skilful fingers he sweeps the cords or keys, how could we judge of his presence but by what we heard? To rise to ourselves. We really see not our friends: their spirits act upon us by the looks of their eyes, the words of their lips, or the grasp of their hands; so that we act and are acted upon mediately. If this be a general law of the intelligent universe—and we cannot conceive of its being otherwise—then the descent of the Holy Ghost was experienced as the rain falling on the parched ground, as the body being enclosed in the waters of the pool, or as a cistern and reservoir being filled.

2. The second constituent of personality is character. The word χαρακτηρ, from which character is derived, is translated in Heb. i. 3, "express image." You know it comes from καρατειν, to engrave, so that the image on a coin is a character. Those mental and moral powers which we possess are God's image or character upon us, although sadly defaced and marred by sin. We cannot say that we are great admirers of the common division made of the character of man, for like all arbitrary divisions, it is faulty and apt to mislead, yet it forms

293

two sufficient centres around which all else may rotate—we mean the head and the heart, the intellect and the affections. These two in a greater or less degree of perfection form a character. Uncommonly cold intellectual beings we have met, yet we never doubted they had a heart somewhere, although we have felt puzzled how to reach it. Warm natures we, too, have come across, and though the intellectual seed was rotting, and the powers rusting away in disuse, we have been led to believe that were only something to crack in their heads, as in Dr. Adam Clarke's, they, too, might yet enjoy the pleasure of intellectual freedom and exercise.

Two works are again and again spoken of as being performed by the Spirit; teaching and comforting, both of which evince his character; the one in the intellectual, and the other in the heart aspect.

(1) He is spoken of as his people's teacher. The qualifications of an apt and successful teacher are so well, and we hope experimentally, known by you, as to render dilating upon them unnecessary. Let us only hurriedly indicate a few. He who would teach must think fairly, deeply, and perseveringly. An unthinking teacher can be but one remove from parrotism. A teacher must have good judgment to know the times when, the truths which, and the persons to whom he may communicate his instructions in their fulness and variety. A teacher must at least, to be successful, have some measure of imagination; that power which opens the gates of hades, and renders near and palpable the misery of the lost; that annihilates for a little time and space, filling the soul with the restful joy of heaven. And so must he likewise possess memory and power of persuasion. Thus we see that the work of teaching rightly done involves the exercise of thought, judgment, imagination, and memory, and these combined form the intellectual part of character. We have seen that the Holy Ghost is the church's teacher, and must therefore have the intellectual part of character.

(2) He is called his people's paraclete or Comforter, and all heart affections cluster around this office. He who would be a Barnabas must preserve his heart unveteranized by contact with suffering, having a large love ever ready to melt into sympathy with the tried, the contrite, and the sad. He who would be a comforter must possess a deep, intuitive heart knowledge. This Job's friends lacked, and lacking, wounded more painfully rather than soothed him. He who is the saint's perfect Comforter, must have every heart-affection completely developed and exercised. And thus from these two offices, though we are by no means restricted to them, we have shown that the Holy Ghost, in the intellectual and heart aspect, has perfect character, and character is the second constituent of personality.

(3) The last composite of personality is will. This is the faculty which completes personality. Hodge,* quoting and clothing Sir William Hamilton's thought, says: "There is included in the will, that in the exercise of the faculty of volition, or self-decision, the soul truly originates action; i.e., acts as an original cause of its own acts, therein differing from all material causes, which act only as they are acted upon. This is the transcendental element of the human will, generally

* In "Outlines of Theology," p. 222.

marked by the term spontaneity, which has rendered the whole subject so obscure. The action of an absolute cause, that is, of one really originating action, is a mystery to our understandings, though it be daily part of our personal experience." If the theory of the absolutely self-determining power of the will were correct, then indeed its possession would be the crowning evidence of personality. But we must not strengthen our position with what appears to us to be error. Dr. Chalmers' "Institutes," vol. ii., in a chapter on the necessity of human actions and of the human will, demonstrates, that while every man may do as he wills, yet he wills to do some things to the neglect of others, by the laws of suggestion and pathology. To use his own illustration: "A sweet and a bitter apple are presented to us for choice: if we prefer the sweet, it is easy to discover what has caused the volition; or if obstinately bent on showing the freedom of our will, we choose the bitter, it then becomes still more easy to detect that the love of conquest in debate has overcome the predilection for the sweet apple, and so fixed our choice." What philosophers call "absolute causation," a kind of Deity in the mind, is acted upon and altered by a thousand slight material causes. Giving up this high, and, as we think, untenable ground, will still remains the chief evidence of personality. Give us a man of strong will, not one swelling with egotism, for a brave heart never thinks of assuring you it is not afraid—and we will point you to one who will make a mark on his age, and wield an influence over his brother men. Without entering amply into this question, let us observe, will acts affirmatively and negatively. It commands and forbids. The former the Holy Ghost did when he said, "Separate unto me Paul and Barnabas;" the latter, when "the Holy Ghost forbade Paul." Lengthily, and we fear tiresomely, have we dwelt upon this division, only because we knew of no other way of giving our meaning more briefly. To sum up, then, our argument, we have proved the consciousness of the Spirit, because he feels and acts. We have proved the character of the Spirit in its intellectuality, from his office of teacher, and in its heart work from his office of comforter. We have proved his possession of will, because he commands and forbids. He who feels and acts, he who teaches and comforts, he who commands and forbids, must be a person.

II. Let us now deal with the Deity of the Holy Ghost. Some few there have been who, acknowledging the personality, have denied the Deity of the Holy Ghost—Patripassianists in the primitive period, and Dr. Samuel Clarke in more modern times. The latter in his "Scriptural Doctrine of the Trinity," says: "The Holy Spirit of God does not in Scripture generally signify a mere power or operation of the Father, but more usually a real person; that that person is not self-existent, but derives his being from the Father by the Son; that as he is subordinate to the Father, so he is also in Scripture represented as subordinate to the Son, both by nature and the will of the Father." Who can, upon a careful study of the history of doctrines, doubt that God has sovereignly caused heresy to exercise a most blessed ministry? Israel's Samsons have never ceased to obtain sweetness out of the rent lions of heterodoxy. May the Deity of the Spirit be more studied and prized by us, because Satan has sought to wrest it from us.

295

Our first proof of the Deity of the Spirit is—

1. That divine attributes are ascribed to him.

(1) Omnipresence. Psalm cxxxix. 7. "Whither shall I go from thy Spirit? or whither shall I flee from thy presence?"

(2) Omniscience. 1 Cor. ii. 10, 11, "The Spirit scarebeth all things, yea, the deep things of God." "The things of God knoweth no man, but the Spirit of God."

(3) Omnipotence, or at least, power. Romans xv. 19, "Through mighty signs and wonders, by the power of the Spirit of God."

(4) Wisdom. Isaiah xi. 2. "The spirit of wisdom shall rest upon him."

(5) Goodness. Psalm cxliii. 10, "Thy Spirit is good."

(6) Holiness. Isaiah xlix. 7, "And his Holy One."

(7) Truth. John xvi. 13, "The Spirit of truth."

That some of these proof passages may be received with hesitancy and doubt will not excite our wonder, yet we feel sure the more they are examined the more capable will they appear of bearing the burden of proof that has been laid upon them. As omnipresence, omniscience, omnipotence, wisdom, goodness, holiness, truth, are predicated of the Holy Spirit, he must therefore be God.

2. The second, which is indeed a class of proofs of the Deity of the Holy Spirit, is the works performed by him.

(1) The first work known to us performed by him was creation. Gen. i. 2; Job xxvi. 13. "The Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters." "By his Spirit he hath garnished the heavens."

(2) The second work we notice is inspiration. The sixty-six books of which the Bible is composed contain all possible variety of matter. Their forty writers are drawn from all ranks, with differences of temperament and culture; yet were all prompted to write and speak by the inspiring Spirit.

(3) The third work we notice is, the Spirit operating in and through bad men. Balaam and the disobedient prophet, spoken of in Kings. In Exodus xxxi. 3, we read of Bezaleel, the artificer, having the supernatural help of the Spirit. May not many of the inventions, original books, and sciences, owe their existence and development to the influence of the Holy Spirit upon the mind?

(4) A fourth work of the Spirit is miracles.

(5) A fifth work of the Spirit is his resting upon Christ. Besides the perfect human soul and body of the Second Person of the Trinity of Immanuel, the Spirit came upon him in the form of a dove, and was given to him without measure. It has often been matter of speculative wonder to us, whether the Spirit was Christ's paraclete, solacing him in his hours of weakness and sorrow; whether he wrought his miracles by the Spirit's power: here we touch on the trinal constitution of the Godhead, and all grows dark with insufferable light.

(6) The sixth and last work of the Spirit we shall mention is the resurrection. Romans viii. 11. "If the Spirit of him that raised up Jesus from the dead dwell in you, he that raised up Christ from the dead shall also quicken your mortal bodies by his Spirit that dwelleth in you."

The works of creation, inspiration, miracle, and resurrection form a body of overwhelming proof for the Deity of the Spirit. Did time permit we might from the baptismal formula, and the benediction,

occurring in 2 Cor. xiii. 14, show that he was co-equal with the Father and the Son.

III. We shall now, in the third and last place, ponder the proper honour of the Holy Ghost. There appear to us to be three ways of understanding and rendering honour to the Holy Ghost, which time will allow us but briefly to hint at.

1. The first is by recognising with the heart that this is the dispensation of the Spirit. As the advent of the Redeemer was the subject of Old Testament prophecy, so the coming of the Spirit was the prophetic burden of the Messiah ministry. At the birth of the Redeemer the angels sang, the star shone, and the shepherds worshipped; at the descent of the Spirit mighty signs and wonders were wrought. During the earthly life of the Redeemer the docile few flourished as trees planted by the rivers of waters, while the enmity of the opposing was stirred into greater fierceness. In this ministry of the Spirit the church is being saved, sanctified, comforted; while the hearts of the unsaved are becoming harder by withstanding his gentle drawings.

Had the Jews known the day of their merciful visitation, they would have wistfully hung on the words of him who spake as never man spake. Let but the church and the world fervently believe that this is the dispensation of the Third Person of the Trinity; that he is now in our world, in our sanctuaries, in our homes, in our hearts; and whilst the consciousness will quicken languid Christian life and work, it will bring to the Spirit a revenue of glory.

2. Again, we honour the Spirit by practically attending to the doctrine of instrumentality. Angelic and human ministries are alike exhibitions of the doctrine of instrumentality. Honours he God more who with reefed sail allows the favouring gale to pass, than he who, with anxious effort, makes the winds his coursers, speeding him over the liquid pathway? That minister, that Christian, honours the Spirit most, who with single-heartedness attends to instrumentality, expecting the Spirit's blessing, not apart from, but through the diligent use of means.

3. Again, we honour the Holy Spirit, as must be obvious to all, by addressing him in prayer and exalting him in praise, as we do the Father and the Son. During these troubled ages the Spirit has been secretly working in every heart, savingly and sanctifyingly working in the church. Softly as the night dew in the conversion of the ones and twos, publicly and loudly as outpoured torrents in revivals and reformations. Nor can we bring ourselves to believe that the prophecy of Joel has yet received its complete fulfilment, "For the promise is unto you, and to your children, and to all that are afar off, even as many as the Lord our God shall call." In this outstretched valley of spiritual death must the Christian prophet stand, and though he sees under the word the bones becoming bodies, and though the hideous ghastliness of the charnel-house is now partly modified, and corpses seem quietly to rest as in a peaceful dormitory, he knows that death still exercises over them his, to human power, inexorable dominion, and he lifts his eyes Godward, pleading, "Come from the four winds, O breath, and breathe upon these slain, that they may live." Yes, O long-limited Spirit, come from any one, or all of the four winds, from any denomination, any preacher, any spiritual agency, and breathe upon these slain, that this Golgotha world may become a deathless, sinless Eden.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate