Hugh Miller—Apprentice and Stonemason — By W. R. Selway
THE brown moors, rugged hills, and craggy peaks of Scotland have produced many a worthy representative son of toil, but few of greater breadth, deeper intelligence, keener apprehension, or sterner character than he whose history has been so well placed before us by the author of the "Life and Letters of Hugh Miller."* The name of the Cromarty mason is known wherever the Anglo-Saxon tongue is spoken, and from his own inimitable writings we have learned much of his struggles, his aspirations, his labours, and his successes; but not until these volumes shall have been perused will the full and rich story of his life be wholly apprehended, and those lessons gathered up which it is so well designed to furnish.
When the present century was in its babyhood, and no seers could have ventured to predict the wondrous development of intellectual and spiritual life which it has already witnessed; in a small seaport town on the north-eastern coast of Scotland, looking out upon the Morav Frith, in the lowly dwelling of a sailor's wife, was born one who was destined to exercise no small influence upon his countrymen, and through them upon the spread of freedom and free opinions throughout the world.
The infant boy, who upon 10th October, 1802, after some demur, made his first bleatings heard, was the first born of a girl of eighteen years only. His father had attained the mature age of forty-four; and appears to have been a man of energy and strength, very gentle, yet very brave; his son doubtless bore the manly lineaments of his father's mind as well as those of his strong and well-knit frame. We are told that throughout life Hugh's mother displayed no special force of mind or character, and indeed, she would appear to have been an impressionable being of somewhat superstitious tendencies, with whom it would have been dangerous for a young lad with so strong an intellect and ardent imagination to have wholly passed his time; but fortunately
* "The Life and Letters of Hugh Miller." By Peter Bayne, M.A. 2 vols. Strahan & Co. 1871.
for him, after the death of his father, the two brothers of his mother came to her aid in guiding the wayward life of his youth. These were both admirable men—honest, industrious, God fearing. In a dame school, at his sixth year, he mastered the mystery of the alphabet. Soon after he was able to read he was sent to the parish school, where he was under a teacher who lacked the power of individualizing his pupils, and thus leading each one in the fittest path; and so it happened that Miller found in the school on congenial pathway, and spent the greater part of his time in idling about the harbour, talking with the sailors aboard the ships, peering at the strange creatures of the sea lurking in the tidal pools, or in hunting the caves along the shore, which with all their hidden beauties and dark mysteries, were a source of infinite pleasure to him. After ten years of school work, such as it was, he was master of a large amount of desultory reading, penmanship clear and strong, a smattering of arithmetic, with spelling of which a boy of ten might be ashamed. Having had three schoolmasters in succession, all of whom had failed with him, he finally left school, closing his academical career with a pitched battle with the dominic! Was ever such an unpromising boyhood? His childhood had been spent, the days in apparently idle trauntism, his evenings sitting by his mother's knee, while she plied her needle at shroud making, telling him the while weird stories of the unseen world. Afterwards he had with his uncles, or with some chosen companions, passed many an hour amid the grand solitudes of nature communing with the winds, the waves, and the rocks. The time had not been lost, however to human eye it might appear to have been misspent; God had been thus training a mighty intellect, and imprinting upon it a love to the wonders of his creative power, which was in later days to bring forth much ripe and valued fruit. Writing twenty years after to his friend, Miss Dunbar, he says, "ever since I recollect myself, I had a turn for the study of natural history. I was studying it all unwittingly, when my friends thought I was doing nothing or worse." Nor was his moral being uninfluenced for good all these years; the quiet undemonstrative piety and upright conduct of his uncles appear greatly to have moulded his mind, and it is most pleasing to hear him saying many years after, and when the world was smiling upon him, "I never knew a man more rigidly just in his dealings than uncle James, or who regarded every species of meanness with a more thorough contempt."
What is to be done with this stubborn, intractable youth who scorns pedagogues, and has a strong indisposition to work? It is true that he can talk in blank verse, invoke mimic heroes, describe with fascinating power suppositious scenes, write poetry, and never have enough of books; but none of these, or all of them, will provide food for the cupboard, or aid his struggling mother, who in the bitterness of her sorrow, after the death of his two sisters, remarked how different her condition would have been had it pleased heaven to take her son, and leave her one of her daughters. The time has come, however, when he must yield to stern necessity; his uncles, firm in their belief that his vagaries were not the mere impulses of an idle lad, but that he possessed the divine rays of true genius, and hoping that needful grace would be given, wished, as is so common with the pious Scotch, to see him enter the
263
sacred profession, and urged him to prepare for college; but it was a sufficient answer to men of their stamp that he did not feel called thereunto, and so we find him bound apprentice to another uncle, his mother's brother-in-law, David Wright, a stonemason, and taking his way to the quarry, in the cold of a February morning. He was a slender lad, by no means of a strong and robust physical structure, and was consequently oppressed by the unwonted toil, his spirits failed, and his health gave way. Yet he persevered, for ere he started in this career, good uncle James had hinted with some severity, that if he had found books too hard for him, he might find labour harder still; and had with that dogged determination, which in after life so strongly characterized him, resolved to show his uncle that he could work as well as play. He was very nearly at the commencement of his life of labour making a complete shipwreck of all his hopes, if indeed he then had any: his weakness and depression were temptations to become a dram drinker, and when at laying the foundation stone of a house, he with the other workmen was treated in a way which, alas! is still far too common, not with wholesome food, but with intoxicating liquor: he drank two glasses of whisky, and found on reaching his home that he could not understand what he attempted to read. A sense of the degradation took forcible hold of him, and he determined "never again to sacrifice his capacity of intellectual enjoyment to a drinking usage;" "and with God's help," he adds, "I was enabled to hold by the determination." In the months of winter, when his work was in abeyance, he continued to read much, and to exercise his pen in short poems and other literary work. He had the inestimable advantage of the friendship not only of his two uncles, but of young men in like humble circumstances with himself, but of warm sensibilities, high minded, intelligent, and gentle, with whom he conversed freely, compared mental notes, and indulged in criticism of each other's productions. Such mutual criticism pruned the luxuriance without suppressing the vigour of Miller's spirit. These companionships softened his rugged asperities, and opened channels for the outpouring of his mind in letters singularly chaste and elegant. He fulfilled his apprenticeship with hearty dutifulness, and was at the end of the term an accomplished workman, his master declaring that Hugh had been "beyond comparison, more tractable and obedient than any indentured pupil he ever had." As Mr. Bayne has it, "The education of toil has done more for him than any previous education, and the unruly boy has become a thoughtful, docile young man." The young man is now his own master, and he will exercise his first free labour by erecting upon a piece of ground, he had inherited from his father, a cottage for his mother's sister, whose little cash alone sufficed to buy the timber and pay for carting the stone. This was the result of the same self-sacrificing spirit which induced him to take revenge upon a churlish landlord of a village inn, who had paid money to one of Miller's brother workmen for his hammer and trowel, but had not received them, by taking his own tools from his bag, and leaving them with the innkeeper's wife. He obtains work at Conon-side, and is sent to Gairloch, Ross-shire, whence in his twenty-first year he writes a letter affording evidence of that wonderful facility of description of which he afterwards became so
great a master. Our space forbids quotation in confirmation of this, but we may note in the following extract his force of character and conscious superiority, mingled with a quiet humour. What can be more naive than his feeling that he must thrash the bullying, swearing, drunken carter, much his senior, in order to make his commission good? He writes, "I came here about a month ago, after a delightful journey of two days from Conon-side, from whence I have been despatched by my employer with another mason lad, and a comical fellow, a carter, to procure materials for the building. Though the youngest of the party, I am intrusted with the charge of the others in consideration of my great gravity and wonderful command of the pen; but as far as the carter is concerned the charge is a truly woeful one. He bullies, and swears, and steals, and tells lies, and cares for nobody. I am stronger, however, and more active than he, and must give him a beating when I have recovered my lameness, to make my commission good. My comrade, the mason, and I have been living in a state of warfare with him ever since we came here. On the morning we set out from Conon-side he left us to drive his cart and went to Dingwall, where he loitered and got drunk: we in turn, after waiting for him two long hours at the village of Contin, drove away, leaving him to follow us on foot as he best might, for at least thirty miles, and he has not yet forgiven us the trick."
Miller is now fairly launched upon the world as a journeyman stone-mason; he travels from place to place within a limited range of Cromarty as his employer finds work and needs ready hands to perform it; his labour is not light, nor his fare the daintiest, while his lodgings are in barns or other outhouses. Writing to his friend, he informs him that he is one of a party doing some work at the house of a minister, and describing his own lodging says: "The sun is looking in at us through the holes in the roof, speckling the floor with bright patches till it resembles a piece of calico. There are two windows in the apartment; one of them filled up with turf and stone, the other occupied by an unglazed frame. The fire is placed against the rough, unplastered gable, into which we have stuck a pin for suspending our pot over it; the smoke finds it way out through the holes of the roof and window. Our meal-sack hangs by a rope from one of the rafters, at the height of a man's head from the floor—our only means of preserving it from our thievish cohabitants, the rats. As for our furniture, 'tis altogether admirable. The two large stones are the steadiest seats I ever sat upon, though perhaps a little ponderous when we have occasion to shift them; and the bed, which pray observe, is perfectly unique. It is formed of a pair of the minister's harrows with the spikes turned down, and covered with an old door and a bunch of straw; and as for culinary utensils, yonder is a wooden cog, and here a pot. We are a little extravagant to be sure in our household expenses, for times are somewhat hard; but for meal and salt, and every other item included, none of us have yet exceeded half-a-crown per week."
That could have been no ordinary working man who, in circumstances such as these, sustained his intellectual life by laying at full length on the ground and poring over the printed page so long as the peat fire smoking on the hearth could be coaxed into yielding a little light, and
265
only closing the book when the fire had become extinguished, or had been made incapable of blazing by the rain, which freely entered the holes in the roof. But these were not the worst of his surroundings; he not only in these wanderings lacked the sympathy of a congenial mind, but was often doomed to pass many hours of rest, as well as of toil, in the enforced company of dissolute, drunken, or otherwise vicious workmen, finding his solace in sleep when it was impossible to read or write. He, however, continued to ply his hammer and chisel, having his curiosity occasionally stimulated as his keen eye deserved in the material upon the bench relics of animal or vegetable existence so entirely different from all that lived around, that neither he nor his fellow workmen could give them names, or form a reasonable opinion as to how they came within the masses of stone. Although it does not appear that at this period he was at all acquainted with the works of geologists, we learn from a lecture, delivered many years after, before "The Philosophical Institution of Edinburgh," that his capacious memory received impressions which in afterlife became of service in his scientific investigations. In this lecture he observes: "I was engaged as a stone-cutter a few miles from Edinburgh, and the stone in which I wrought was, I soon found, exceedingly rich in organic casts and impressions. Often have I detected in the rude block placed before me to be fashioned into some moulded transam or carved mullion, fragments of a sculpture which I might in vain attempt to rival." On pointing out to another workman on one occasion a beautiful impression where an animal had once been entombed, and had left a hollow cavity as the token of its former presence, the rejoinder was, "Ah! You have got one of these terrible tangle-holes; they're the dash'dest things in all the quarry!"
In his twenty-fourth year he ventured to send through the hands of a friend to the Scotsman newspaper, "An Ode upon Greece," but was doomed to disappointment—it was not published. He continued, however, to write, and making the acquaintance of Mr. Carruthers, of Inverness, ultimately published "Poems, written in the Leisure Hours of a Journeyman Mason"—a book which, though now unknown, became the medium of introduction between Miller and several friends, one of whom was to a great extent instrumental in determining the future of his life. The publication was warmly received, and at first plaudits resounded sufficiently loud to turn the head of a weaker man; but the author on seeing his works in print, and bringing to bear upon them, in that condition, the usual critical bent of his mind, needed not, and indeed did not, wait until it was found they did not sell, to arrive at the conclusion that it was not in Poetry he was to win either fame or profit. But his mind was too active, and his pen too ready—the one to be stilled or the other to be laid aside—as the result of a first failure. Writing to Mr. Forsyth, he says: "At this moment when I can look back to the complete failure of my speculation, I am as determined upon improving to the utmost of my ability, as a writer, as I could have been had the public by buying my work rendered the speculation a good one. . . . Could I decide whether I possess or be devoid of true genius, it would be an easy matter for me to anticipate the result. If destitute of this spirit, I shall certainly not rise to eminence; for my situation in life is not one of those in which fortune, or the influence of friends, can supply
the want of ability, or in which mediocrity of talent can become admirable by clothing itself in the spoils of learning. My education is imperfect; I cannot even subsist except by devoting seven-eighths of my waking hours to the avocations of a laborious profession." He therefore determines to lay aside poetry and give all his leisure time to cultivating prose composition; not idly dreaming that he has genius which will one day make him successful, but earnestly labouring that he may attain that skill which shall compel attention. And how well did he succeed! His powers of description have rarely been equalled; and the judicious touches of his poetic imagination, like choice parterres of flowers in a richly cultivated landscape, by their perfume and beauty afford additional gratification to the beholder. The cultivated genius of Miller enriched and adorned every subject upon which he treated. His next essay at publication was in the columns of the Inverness Courier, which were freely opened to him by his friend, Mr. Carruthers. The letters thus published attracted considerable attention, and Miller became a man of renown in the little society of Cromarty as he wielded his mallet or plied his chisel, "building," as he says, "houses by day, and castles by night."
His letters to various correspondents are charming examples of epistolary skill, and must have produced in the minds of their recipients the most lively satisfaction, impressing them with a strong admiration of his character as well as of his skill. Upon no one, probably, did his letters have a stronger effect than upon Miss Dunbar, of Boath, a lady who was his senior by about twenty years, and who, while enjoying all the pleasures of his literary skill, evinced toward him an affection quite maternal, which induced her to address him letters of strong sagacity and earnest wisdom, and to her death to take the strongest interest in all that related to his welfare. Beneath the rugged exterior of this humble mason there must have dwelt a gentle spirit, or this high-born, educated, and intelligent woman would never have been drawn so closely toward him. She was wealthy: he was poor. Wishing to be of temporal service to him, Miss Dunbar offered him pecuniary aid, but he firmly, though respectfully, declined it; and, as if fearing he might be carrying his chivalrous independence to excess, he adds: "If the spirit which God has bestowed upon me to preserve me from all the little meannesses of solicitation and to secure to me in my humble sphere that feeling of self-respect, without which no one can fulfil the duties of a man or deserve the respect of others, should at times impel me towards the opposite extreme, and make me, in some little degree, jealous of even the kindness of a friend, will you not tolerate in me a weakness so necessarily, so inseparably connected with that species of strength which renders me, if anything does, in some measure worthy of your friendship?" There was yet another lady whose interest was excited by this poetic mechanic—Miss Fraser, who, writing from Cromarty to her daughter, then in England, sent a volume of poems and letters on "The Herring Fishery, by a Stonemason, whom I can see from my window engaged in building a wall." Miss Fraser, in her turn, became interested in Miller; and on meeting him in the limited society of the little town (into which, to their credit be it said, this plain and poor man was freely admitted, in recognition of the aristocracy of
267
intellect), the feeling ripened into friendship, and thence to a warmth which alarmed her mother, and possibly caused a pang of regret that she had unwittingly brought them together. The lady, who was young (many years the junior of Miller), inspired him with a new hope and new desires, and gave him an aim in life which he had hitherto lacked. He had been content to earn a scanty subsistence by his handicraft, finding solace and obtaining mental growth in books, meditation, and the use of his pen; but this woman, who had cast her subtle but powerful spell over him, was of gentle birth, had received the best education then obtainable by young ladies, and was accustomed to a distinguished circle of society. With a strong sense of justice, Miller felt that it would be highly improper to make such a one the wife of a working man. Is he then to embitter his future life by relinquishing this his first love, or shall he strive to accomplish his wishes by bringing the beloved one down to his condition? He does not adopt either of these unworthy courses, but manfully determines Miss Fraser shall be his wife, but not until he can bring her to the house of one who is no longer a mechanic. He will work, and work, and work; his pen shall be the talisman which shall open a way of escape from manual labour, and provide a home to which he can, without a blush of shame or feeling of compunction, bring home his wife.
Some five or six years previous to the advent of Miss Fraser at Cromarty, a most important change had been wrought in the spiritual condition of Miller; and the mode in which this was brought about affords great encouragement to the free use of epistolary appeals or counsel from one friend to another. We have already adverted to the pleasant and useful intercourse which subsisted between Miller and some of his youthful companions in the days of his apprenticeship. One of these young men had left his business under the solemn conviction that he was called to the ministry; and writing from his place of study to Miller, he urges him to yield implicit faith in Christ, crying, with impassioned earnestness, "My dear Hugh, dost thou believe? Do you believe that he lived?—that he died to save sinners?" To these questions Hugh's replies are not definite; the arrow may have entered, but rather than admit the wound he tries to turn the direction of the correspondence. But Swanson, the young student, returns to his point, and again and again calls upon him "to accept of Christ," and to "see freeness and fulness of the gospel offers made to you." Although the letters from Miller to his friend at this time do not afford that satisfactory evidence of his conversion which would have caused Swanson's heart to bound with joy, there is no rebuff, no coldness, but a warmth of gratitude and of manly thankfulness which must have given rise to hope that the effort had not been made in vain. In December, 1825, we find him writing to Swanson: "I am an unsteady and a wavering creature, nursing, in my foolishness, vain hopes, blinded by vain affections: in short, one who, though he may have his minutes of conviction and contrition, is altogether enamoured of the things of this world and a contemner of the cross." Fourteen months after this, the decisive change had been wrought, as he informs his friend and early companion, William Ross: "I now believe what I did not once believe, and I have determined, relying on the help of God, to make the doctrines
of Christianity the rule of my belief: its precepts that of my conduct. Oh, William, how easy it is to write of virtuous deeds! how difficult to perform them! How easy is it to make a good resolve! and how difficult to abide by one! But the power, truth, and goodness of God are infinite, and he has promised to give his Holy Spirit to them that ask him." Of this friend to whom he thus unbosoms himself, and who was soon removed by death, he afterwards wrote to Mr. Strahan: "No sense of sacredness, no feeling of devotion, connected with either his genius or his worth, shall ever press on the minds of those who behold the nameless sod which covers his remains; and yet though thus obscure, he has earned a loftier fame than that which the men of this earth can bestow. Through the grace of God he had subdued his own spirit; he had striven against the ills of human life and human nature, and so far as these concerned himself he had overcome them; and as he had the merit of living without reproach, so he had the happiness of dying without fear. These, my dear sir, were achievements greater than any merely literary ones, and you know the fame awarded to such God has described as bestowed by his own lips and those of the pure spirits of heaven." Gentle must have been the nature and warm the heart of the strong, shaggy, hard-handed mason, who could write thus of a delicate journeyman house-painter, who had sickened and fallen into an early grave, leaving little behind him but the deep wellings of affection his goodness had evoked within the bosom of his friend. Henceforth the life of Miller is to be guided by the principle of the gospel; he is to be in the world to effect a great work therein, yet not to be of it. He does not allow his light to become dim or his warmth to grow cold. The fervour of his piety and the depth of his feeling are evinced in a letter written, in 1835, to Mr. William Smith, wherein he says: "Permit me again, my dear William, to recommend to you Jesus Christ as the only Saviour. Open all your heart to him, for he is man, and can sympathise in all its affections; trust yourself implicitly in him, for he is God, omnipotent to aid and unable to deceive. Faith can realize his presence, and there is happiness to be found in his society, where the full heart pours itself out before him, of which the world can form no conception. In life or in death, in health or in sickness, it is well to be able to lean oneself on him, as John did at the last supper, and to feel, as it were, the heart of his humanity beating under the broad buckler of his power. Whatever it may be your fate to encounter—whether protracted, spirit-subduing indisposition, or that solemn and awful change so big with interest to the human heart and so fitted to awaken its hopes and its fears; or whether you are to be again restored to the lesser cares and narrower prospects of the present life—in whatever circumstances placed, or by whatever objects surrounded, you will find him to be an all-sufficient Saviour, and the friend that sticketh closer than a brother. Would that I were worthy to recommend him to you—more like himself! but I know you will forgive me the freedom with which I write, and that you will not associate with his infinite wisdom and purity any of the folly or the evil which attaches to, my dear William, your sincere and affectionate friend, Hugh Miller."
[In a second paper we shall see Hugh Miller as the Editor and Man of Science.]
