You Sour and Bread — By Edward Leach
IT was a bleak, wet morning, and the streets of London were coated with a liquid paste of intolerable consistency—such mud as few other cities can boast of, or would care to retain so long without energetic efforts for its removal. In a narrow court, situated in one of the least fragrant nooks of the thousands of insalubrious haunts of poverty in the great city, we came upon a mission chapel, which was being besieged by a crowd of youngsters, of both sexes and of every degree of wretchedness. Such a tribe of tatterdemalions is not to be seen in one group every day. Pushing, contriving, almost fighting their way through the narrow door that led to the area of the building, these children of want were seeking with no small anxiety to enjoy a feast to which they were unaccustomed in the miserable hovels they call their homes. At last they all succeeded in effecting, without accident or serious quarrel, an entrance, and when this was accomplished there was an amusing scramble for first places and chosen seats, which resulted, contrary to the Darwinian hypothesis, in the strongest going to the wall, for the weak children knew how to care for themselves, and the younger they were and the less protected, the more acute and determined they seemed to be. Those who secured the highest seats retained them with such resolution that he would have been a hero who could have forcibly dislodged them. What prehensile power these little fellows had! One thing they knew, if no other—that possession is nine points of the law, and for the remaining point they were utterly regardless. He might win who could, and he who could was permitted to win. So, questions of place settled, every one good-humouredly sets his or her little heart upon the expected treat. The girls maintain silence, and graciously smooth down the rumpled clothes of their sisters, while the boys chaff and whistle, and hurrah with evident satisfaction to themselves, making hideous discord with their mugs and jugs, and miscellaneous crockery: for “miscellaneous” is the only right word with which to describe the curious and varied assortment of utensils furnished them by their parents. Mugs without handles, jugs without spouts, basins that were out of proportion to the size of those who carried them, cracked china, dilapidated brown ware, shapely and shapeless—a more unique collection we never saw. Then for spoons—those who had any—pewter, tin, and iron, of varied age and disability—there was a singular variety. Wonderfully patient were they all until the arrival of the first can of steaming hot soup. Then began the “Hip, hip, hurrah!” of the boys, and the gleesome chatter of the girls; and the smallest child and the dirtiest (and small and dirty many of them were) looked bright with expectation. Some set to work to empty the well-filled basins, and mugs and jugs, with a sober earnestness, while others attacked the provender timidly, with an awkwardness partly due to novelty, but in some cases traceable to the peculiarly ungainly and inconvenient utensils containing the soup, and the equally inconvenient spoons or ladles with which they conveyed it to their mouths. There was no stint in
257
the supply; the most voracious was satisfied, and there was not the sign of a sigh for more, when they left the building with their empty, greasy, cracked crockeryware. Such a repast was sumptuous to them. On the next day they would have to be content with the less nourishing food furnished by their poor parents, but might remember, as no doubt they would, that pea soup and bread would be their fare again ere the week had closed; for during the severe winter two and sometimes three dinners were given to the poor children of the district at this commodious mission chapel, so that they were better fitted to brave the inclemency which carried to an untimely grave so many other little hungry ones.
Pea-soup dinners have of late been the fashion among the unfashionable. One would think that the virtues and properties of this decoction had never been fully understood before, or that its suitability and cheapness for the famishing poor had not been discovered. Certain it is, that we owe the establishment of the first metropolitan soup-kitchen to the distress caused in the autumn and winter of 1816 by the potato blight. From that day to the present the institution has been growingly popular. Charitable persons of all creeds, and of no distinctive creed at all, have found in this an opportunity for supplying a great want, and have vied with each other in dispensing freely the golden-coloured liquid to the needy and hungry. Scarcely a Christian church is without its soup-kitchen, and to many mission-halls it is a necessary adjunct; in some we believe it is the only really useful branch of the work. Those whose gifts or persuasiveness can only influence twenty persons to suffer the word of exhortation at a service of religion may attract a large number to a service of soup. Really we are not surprised that the poor should doggedly decline to be bored by some of the so-called evangelists, who have no qualification whatever for preaching, and are only, by their failure, illustrations of the necessity of treating even the poorest as somewhat higher in intelligence than infants. While chapels and mission-halls have done their share, schools have also dispensed cheap food. Indeed, so numerous are the public and private kitchens, and so many the appeals made for funds to carry them on, that an attempt to report upon them for the guidance of the benevolent deserves our heartiest thanks. Such an attempt has been made by a society, organized for charitable relief and the repression of mendicity. We do not now express our opinion on the work which this society seeks to do, although we object to district committees relieving people of whom they know nothing, and can know nothing, and fear that such an arrangement will encourage rather than repress mendicity. As a rule—the exceptions being where certain common-sense safeguards against imposition are violated—those who labour among the poor are best fitted to judge as to their worthiness to receive relief, while committees are easily befooled. A badly-dressed man recently succeeded in obtaining a loan of money from a committee, with which to purchase a suit of clothes, to enable him to obtain a situation; but if the said committee had only consulted an evangelist labouring in the immediate district, they might with far greater wisdom have retained their cash. We do not argue that every minister should combine the dispensation of temporal relief with his spiritual duties, but we are fully persuaded that
17
such a one who visits the poor, and who employs Bible-women and other agents to evangelise among them, is not ill-fitted to become the almoner and counsellor of charity. It is possible for soup to become the medium of proselytism, a practice which episcopal clergymen have so long indulged in that they are now crying out against the evil of it, as seen by the aid of a microscope in dissenting communities. In rural districts, coal tickets, blankets, and alms are the engines of demoralization, freely used by clergymen to counteract the growing influence of the dissenting minister; and we are not surprised, therefore, to learn that the slightest semblance to this practice among other religious communities, in towns not wholly enslaved by the clergy, and where the squire is unknown, should arouse the indignation of the gentlemen who are so sensitive of others labouring within their parochial preserves. Whether the establishment of soup-kitchens has robbed the clergy of any of their flock, we do not know; but if dispensing this form of charity has resulted in the ingathering of persons to hear the gospel from the lips of a Dissenter, who formerly attended no house of prayer, the objections of the clergyman are foolish and blasphemous.
The report to which we have alluded presents us with not a little interesting statistical information. From it we learn that the out-door relief list of metropolitan paupers amounts to 127,000 on a single day; but this must be doubled or trebled if we would ascertain the whole number relieved by the Poor Law system during the year. Such is the great army of London pauperism, and there can be no doubt that a very large proportion of this host are fed at the dinner tables provided by the charitable. Not a few depend wholly upon charity, and find that it pays. "In estimating," says the report, "the influence of this class of charities [soup-kitchens, etc.], it is impossible to leave out of sight the vast number of bread, grocery, coal, and blanket tickets which are distributed by district visitors and religious and charitable societies, the doles of bread made at the churches under ancient endowments, or the extensive system of out-door relief maintained in the metropolis under the Poor Law." There is nothing to prevent the same persons being the recipients of most of these charities. We have known cases in which a round of visits has been made by the same persons to all the charities of the district—church and chapel and we have been told of cases in which the High Church has been visited in the morning for the sacrament money, and the mission hall in the evening for conscience sake. Unfortunately, all good objects may be abused, and the soup-kitchen has something to answer for in encouraging pauperism. The hospitality so gladly afforded to the poorer classes when the bread-winner is out of work or sick has been encroached upon wantonly. "We were told at one soup-kitchen," says the report, "that the applications from the families of workpeople are more frequent towards the end of the week, when the wages have been spent; and at another, that it was regarded as a privilege to relieve the family of an honest workman. Can we wonder that London workmen have lost, to a great extent, not merely the habit, but the very idea of thrift; and that, instead of saving when they are in full health and work against a bad time, they spend all they get in present indulgence,
259
knowing that others will provide for them and their families when they are in want?" It is noticed that gin-palaces and beer-shops do not decrease in number or languish in neglect where poverty is deepest: they must be largely supported by the class who profess the greatest indigence, and who, were they honest, might in many cases acknowledge the greatest indolence. Only a short time ago we observed a deplorably-attired woman leave a parochial school-room with a can of steaming soup, turn the corner of the street, and leaving her can in charge of another woman outside, she entered the public-house where probably she spent that which would have sufficed to cover the cost of the soup that had been given her. Still, there are hundreds of honest poor who suffer from insufficient food. Five medical gentlemen who are the inspectors of the Lisson Grove Dinner-table, state that though much of the sufferings of the poor is directly or indirectly the result of drunkenness, idleness, and vice, yet "that is not so extensively the case as some would have us believe. Whatever may be the causes, the effects are disastrous; the women become unhealthy, and the men die, till it seems as if half the poor population consisted of sickly widows, and puny, ill-fed children." The medical officer of the Privy Council tells us of the prevalence of relapsing fever, through poverty and privation—"so much so," he says, "that the disease is often known by the name of famine fever." The winter brings the inevitable disease, and with it the greater need for abundant relief. Imposition there may be, and the sufferings of those relieved may often be traced to their own folly and thriftlessness; but these sufferings must be mitigated by those who can do so. It is nevertheless true that "we are moving in a vicious circle. Increased destitution requires more abundant relief, and more abundant relief encourages those habits which lead to a further aggravation of the destitution, and so on." Here is a dilemma, and, says the report upon the soup kitchens, if we would escape it, "we must endeavour, while giving present relief to the poor, to improve their permanent condition, and to restore them to habits of self-respect and self-support." "The problem to be solved," they again say, "is how to give charitable relief without inducing habits of intemperance, and to educate young and old to industry, temperance, thrift, and mutual help." They need, in short, religious and moral training. We could point to a well-filled mission-hall in St. Giles's where many have been rescued by the gospel from not only a condition of absolute want, but from the loss of self-respect, and who are well-dressed, respectable, hard-working and thrifty persons. That education is not sufficient to prevent a man losing his self-respect, we learn from the painful details given in the last year's report of this evangelical mission. "Not unfrequently do we meet with those who have at one time been respectably connected—sons of noblemen, clergymen, physicians, editors of newspapers, etc.—and in most cases they have been reduced to beggary either through excessive drinking of spirituous liquors, or dark deeds of crime." Such degraded persons are brought under the sound of the gospel, and made decent members of society—honest, industrious, temperate. And their first introduction to this higher life has often been accomplished through the soup-kitchen.
A "model soup-kitchen" is conducted on the principle of each
recipient paying something towards his dinner, but even this is liable to abuse, and to sell food at less than cost price has its disadvantages. It has been observed to encourage begging. Thus, a trustworthy gentleman, living near the Model Soup-kitchen in Easton Road, says that he saw the same cadgers come day after day, and that he once saw a man take ninepence in about an hour, under the pretence that he needed a copper to buy a penny basin of soup. Public kitchens, where wholesome food could be procured at the cost price, would be a boon and a charity. "We believe," says the report, "that, even now, the great majority of those who are indulged in formú pauperis with buying at half-price at the soup-kitchens, could equally well pay the full price; and we are convinced that, if public kitchens were established in each district on the footing recommended, constantly increasing numbers of the poor would become ashamed of dependence, and turning their backs on the old pauperising soup-kitchens, would swell the ranks of the industrious, honest, thrifty, temperate labourers. We say 'temperate,' because we believe that the craving arising from insufficient or unsuitable food, is one main cause for the constant use of stimulants; and that, when an abundant supply of good, cheap food shall be provided, we shall hear less of the excessive number of gin-palaces, low public-houses, and beer-houses, which cause so much trouble to our community by fostering intemperance and crime, and by aggravating the poor rates, police rates, and prison expenditure. The social habits of our people must also be taken into account. Working people love to have a chat as well as those of higher rank, and the only places generally open to them at present are the public-houses. For this reason we hope that tea-and-coffee-rooms, well provided with the current newspapers and magazines, will be annexed to the public kitchens, and that workmen will be encouraged to bring their families with them."
These weighty words have our heartiest sympathy. Poor people who are either unable to read, or have but little taste, or have but little to read, nevertheless enjoy a little chat and innocent amusement. Their homes are no source of comfort to them; and if the mission-hall or the tea-room, or soup-kitchen could be made attractive, and be always open for them in the evenings, not only might they be kept from the public-house, but brought under the genial influences of Christianity. The great secret of the success which has attended the evangelistic and social efforts of one who has proved a religious and social reformer in a low metropolitan district, has been the keeping open of his building every evening, constantly offering some attraction, either of decidedly devotional, or intellectual, or entertaining character, and always baptising the whole in the social element. He has acted upon the words of the report long before they were written: "Useful information, counsel, and sympathy, the discouragement of idleness, improvidence, and drunkenness; the encouragement of thrift, with a view to make provision for want of work, sickness, and old age; assistance in sending the children to school and getting out the young men and women in life; the promotion of cleanliness in person and dwelling, and arranging for the proper execution of the sanitary laws—these are the means by which the poor of London may be
261
rendered self-respecting and self-supporting; and an upward progress may be secured by which each succeeding generation may arrive nearer to that standard to which we aspire for our country." Our friend has helped in this direction, first and chiefest, by preaching the gospel; then by lecturing on sanitary and other useful subjects; by starting penny and other savings banks, clubs, promoting emigration, ragged schools, and feeding the children of poverty. And whatever may be the social drawbacks attendant upon the gratuitous distribution of soup to adults, there can be no doubt that no harm, but unmixed good, must flow from a frequent distribution to the poor, hungry, ill-clad children to whom reference was made at the beginning of this paper.
