Menu
‹ Chapter 174 of 203 ›

THE LETTER

15 min read · Chapter 174 of 203

As it is not likely the Rector of Ashton will play with fire again just

yet, except it be to put Mr. Waterton's letter into it, we present the

reader with a copy of that production:—

"Chapel House, October 30th, 1870.

"To the Rector of Ashton.

"SIR,—Permit me to congratulate you upon your researches in con-

nection with the writings of John Calvin. I trust that you will find

many other passages which will be as helpful to your cause as those

which you quoted to Mr. John Blake. The more thoroughly you

pursue your investigations of the great reformer's works, the more shall

I rejoice, but allow me to advise you the next time you quote Calvin to

a cottager, to refrain from giving book, chapter, and section, for perhaps

he may find some one to turn up the place for him. But I forbear; the

most accurate sometimes err in making quotations, and the most candid

may by accident err on their own side.

"By your leave, or possibly without it, I shall offer a few observations

upon your treatise on Confirmation, but before I do so, permit me to

remind you that the mode of reasoning which you adopt with

cottagers may have been successful in some cases, but is hardly such

as a gentleman from the university should employ in print. You know

very well that you bamboozled the poor man, and you must yourself

have felt that your arguments were better adapted for the region of

bacon in the flitch, than for the judgment of that other Bacon, whose

laws of reasoning you doubtless admire. The days are changed, my dear

sir, since your predecessors had to deal solely with an uneducated and

servile peasantry; men's minds are on the wing, and you must use better

means if you would secure them to your church. Garbled quotations

are pieces of artillery very apt to recoil and injure those employing them;

and arguments in which there is much sound, but no sense, are in much

the same category.

"You, a man whose name is, I doubt not, honourably recorded upon

the rolls of an ancient university, have tried to prove confirmation by

a bishop from the fact that Jacob laid his hands on the two sons of

Joseph, and gave them his benediction; why did you not sustain the

argument by the soldiers laying hands on Athaliah, or Haman's scorning

to lay hands on Mordecai only? The sound might have convinced the

cottager quite as well, and the sense would not have been very much

TROWEL. Nov. 1, 1870.]

CONFIRMATION.

501

further off. Why not have proved the Christian duty of sticking holly in the church at Christmas, from Jacob's setting the rods before the flocks when they came to drink? Pray, sir, were you serious? You might with equal force have proved that Confirmation ought to be performed in a bedchamber, and that the bishop should lean on a stick during the ceremony, because Jacob leaned upon his staff. You do not surely expect any sensible person to answer such an argument, except by ridiculing it. You were in a sore strait when you fell back upon the venerable patriarch and his two grandsons. I doubt not you deeply regret that he did not lay hands on all his family, for then there would have been a little better pretext for your laying such violent hands on him, as to make him out to be of your persuasion.

"You next had the courage to mention the divine name of the Redeemer, and to insinuate that his putting his hands upon young children was a species of Confirmation. Surely then he confirmed the unbaptised, for you will hardly have the hardihood to affirm that these children had been presented at a font? Again, dear sir, I can hardly think you serious, for if the act of our Lord in laying his sacred hands on children is a precedent for you, so also was his anointing the blind man's eyes with the clay made by his spittle, and his driving out buyers and sellers from the temple with a scourge of small cords. I must confess, if you would elevate the last into a frequent ceremony, I should defer to your opinion if you pleaded its great necessity and usefulness as a reason for its perpetuity. Our Lord's eating a piece of broiled fish and of an honeycomb has probably never suggested itself to you as the basis of a new ecclesiastical ordinance, and I humbly make you a present of the proposal, doubting not that your fertile powers of sophistry could support the new invention by the example of Samson with the dead lion, Jonathan in the wood, the practice of Peter, and the claims of his successors to the sweets of dignity and the ring of the fisherman; the practice of broiling, also, was nearly universal in that branch of the Catholic church, with which many of your brethren are anxious to be re-united. Pardon me if I seem to banter, my sense of the ridiculous has to be held in restraint or I could not even read some of your arguments, much less attempt to weigh them—weigh them, indeed, I cannot pretend to do, for I possess no instrument of sufficient sensitiveness to be affected by substances of such exceptional tenuity.

"Instances of laying on of hands for the purpose of ordination, since you confess that they are not to the point, you need not have quoted, but a little dust in the eyes of John Blake was no doubt desirable. You might have been content to have gone on to your great passage in Acts viii. 17, for now that John Blake has read your tract, he asks himself why you took up so much time with irrelevant matters, and, poor ignorant man that he is, I fear he half thinks that you wanted to confuse his mind, or that you were so short of suitable material that you filled up with what lay next to hand. However, this is not the business which concerns me. Peter and John it seems, went down to Samaria, and laid their hands on the converts, "and they received the Holy Ghost." This you allege as a reason why bishops, who cannot give the Holy Ghost, should go through the form of laying their precious fingers on all the lads and lasses whom the parish priest can sweep together. I say that the bishop

[THE SWORD AND THE

TROWEL. NOV. 1, 1876.

cannot give the Holy Ghost, and you know he cannot. Give to those words

the sense intended in the Acts of the Apostles, and you know that no man

living can confer the Holy Ghost. It was the gift of miracles and tongues

which was hereby given. The graces and spiritual blessings of the Holy

Ghost are not here intended, for, believe me, Simon Magus would not have

given a penny for them. You know that story concerning Simon Magus,

you need not that any man teach it to you; at least, if you know it not,

many of your fellow clergy do, and you at least know that Simonites never

invest their ready cash in bidding for spiritual gifts; they procure unto

themselves a goodly heritage of quite another kind. Now, as it is clear

that miraculous gifts were conferred by the laying on of hands, and you

dare not pretend that your so-called 'Confirmation' confers such gifts,

your bishops, in going through the useless form, are mere mimics, or as

Calvin rightly says, stage-players and apes. Because a cup filled with

cold water may refresh a dying soldier, would you think it praiseworthy

to uplift a cup without a drop of water in it, and put it to parched lips?

Because to break your bread with the hungry is true charity, would you

think it right to set the needy at a bare table, where you busied yourself

with carving the air? Yet your bishops do much the same, and you

think a great deal of the performance. Your clouds are without

rain, and your wells are without water, and yet you glory in

them! The empty hands of your bishops have nothing to communicate,

yet must they needs mimic the apostles, whose hands bestowed

priceless gifts. Why do they not continue to bid lame men rise up and

walk, though the healing power is not with them? They have aprons

still, and aprons of finer material than ever were taken from the body of

Paul: why do they not distribute them amongst the sick? Why, sir,

because the imposture would be soon discovered when the matter con-

cerned the body; yet it would not be one whit more barefaced than the

farce which now is indulged in with reference to the soul. So much

for your blessed Samaritan argument!

"You next conduct us to Ephesus, and with a great flourish of trumpets

about Paul's call to the apostleship, which, by the way, is nothing to

the point, and merely inserted to put Mr. Blake off his guard, you have

the courage to bring in the apostle's laying on of hands upon the

baptised Ephesians, as a proof of your favourite ceremony. Now, sir,

you could not have been oblivious to the fact, that after Paul had laid

his hands on the twelve men, 'the Holy Spirit came on them, and'—

and what?—'they spake with tongues and prophesied.' It is plain,

then, that the laying on of hands was meant to convey supernatural

gifts, which your prelatical mimicry does not and cannot do. You

use the form, but have not the power which went with it, for none of your

confirmed boys and girls either edify us with prophesying, or astonish us

by speaking in unknown tongues. Seeing that you imitate the mere

form, but have none of the real power, I commend to your study the

succeeding verses of the chapter (Acts xix. 13), in which the seven sons

of one, Sceva, a Jew tried their hands at imitating apostles, and failed

very much in the same way as your bishops do. The devil said outright

to them, what in his sleeve he says at every Confirmation, 'Jesus I know,

and Paul I know, but who are ye?'

"You vary your attempts at scriptural argument with references

TROWEL. Nov. 1, 1870.

CONFIRMATION.

503

to the Fathers, and give an extract of a very apocryphal character from Clemens Alexandrinus, in which a young man is said to have been 'scaled with the Lord's signature.' The Pope of Rome and Zadkiel, I suppose know between them what that means, but I question if any one else does. Moreover, if Clemens when in a cloudy condition did write something like that, I should like to see a full copy of the epistle, book, or whatever else you call it, in which the expression occurs. Remembering your very remarkable extract from Calvin, I am not inclined to place too implicit a reliance upon your accuracy in quotation, and as your only reference for verification is to a tract by a brother Anglican, I shall take leave to doubt its truthfulness till I have chapter and book for it. However, if I were to concede the authenticity of your citation, and were willing to admit the authority of Clemens, I should still remain more convinced of the power of your imagination than of the force of your reason. For the connection between sealing with a signature and laying on of hands, is not self-evident, nor indeed, evident at all. 'Scaling,' you say, was the term which was used to express Confirmation in the primitive church; you mean in the degenerate church, after she had heaped to herself ceremonies and carnal ordinances. There is not a single syllable of Scripture to connect sealing and the apostolic laying on of hands, and if there were, it would not avail you, since your episcopal pantomime is quite another thing. Sir, you are as great at bamboozling as at quotation, and you give us a notable specimen when you say, 'You remember St. Paul, in the Ephesians called it the same name; he does so in two places. Ephes. i. 13; iv. 30.' Now, sir, Paul never alluded to it, if by it, you mean your episcopal imposition of hands; he never even dreamed of such folly; it is an invention of a far later date than Paul lived to see. He spoke of that secret spiritual seal of the Holy Ghost, which spiritual men understand by joyful experience, but which it would be a waste of time to try to explain to such as you are. I make this last remark in no spirit of severity, but because the barefaced untruthfulness of your assertions, the remarkable character of your quotations, and the clinging of your mind to outward forms, unitedly compel me to fear that any deep and purely spiritual truth would lie quite out of your region of experience.

Now, sir, it should be clear to you, and I half suspect it is so, that neither the laying on of hands in apostolic ordination, nor the laying on of hands in conferring the gifts of the Spirit, are proofs of the propriety of a ceremony by which no one is ordained and no gifts are transmitted. If you assert that grace is communicated to youths of both sexes by the contact of their heads and the bishop's fingers, I fear that some persons more truthful than polite will tell you that you lie, and I shall personally soften down much the same conviction into an enquiry, whether a person capable of declaring his belief in such an absurdity may not also be so nearly idiotic as to be a believer in his own assertion? If the characters of confirmed persons were evidently sanctified, and their hearts manifestly renewed, from the moment of the episcopal manipulation, we could not deny the efficacy of a ceremony so clearly attended with real power; but we do object to believe that any grace is imparted where no mental, moral, or spiritual

[THE SWORD AND THE

TROWEL. Nov. 1, 1870.

advantage is produced. Sir, grace is not animal magnetism, or a subtle fluid, or an electric influence; the operations of the Holy Spirit are not mechanical or chemical, but affect the mind, the heart, the spiritual nature of men. To talk of these influences being conveyed by a ceremony in cases where no holy emotion is excited, no spiritual life displayed, and no moral improvement perceived, betrays the grossest ignorance of the nature, character, and influences of the Holy Spirit.

Sir, I have much more to say upon the subject in hand, but I have already written enough to convince any rational man that episcopal laying on of hands is but a mockery, since it no longer in any degree bestows the power which the apostles communicated thereby. Cease, sir, to play at miracles now that the miraculous power is gone. Do not travestie in solemn farce that which you should treat with reverence. Certain spiritualists have been mimicking the sacred dove, the rushing wind, the flames of fire, and the gift of tongues. Sir, we both abhor their profanity; let us studiously avoid falling into the same condemnation. Satan is pre-eminently a counterfeiter of the wonders and teachings of our Lord, and the art of counterfeiting consists very much in producing the same outward form without the like intrinsic value; let us, sir, keep as far from this crime as we possibly can.

In conclusion, it is sometimes affirmed that Confirmation is at least a harmless ceremony, and it is alleged that as it may be a means of grace to some, it ought to be treated with respect, or at least with lenient consideration. Upon this subject a far abler pen than mine has written the following paragraph, and with that, which I assure you is a correct quotation, I shall close:—

"To speak freely, sir, this ceremony of Confirmation, as it is at present appointed and practised in your church, is so far from being greatly conducive to holiness of life, that there is great reason to apprehend it may be productive of quite different, and even dangerous consequences, by cherishing in men's minds false and presumptuous hopes, or by deluding them into wrong notions, as to the safety of their state, and the terms of acceptance and favour with God.

By the order of your Common Prayer, all persons baptised, when they come to competent years and are able to say the Lord's Prayer, creed, and ten commandments, and the answers of the short catechism, are to be brought to Confirmation. The bishop having asked, 'Whether they renew the solemn promise and vow which was made in their names in baptism,' etc. Upon their answering we do, he proceeds thereupon to declare in the most solemn manner, even in an address to God himself, that he has vouchsafed to regenerate these his servants by water and the Holy Ghost; (note, not by water only, but also by the Holy Ghost) and to give them the forgiveness of all their sins; and, laying his hand upon the head of each particular person, he certifies him by that sign of God's favour and gracious goodness towards him.

"I pray you, sir, in the name of God, inform me, what warrant has the bishop to pronounce a man's sins all forgiven, and himself regenerated by the Holy Ghost, upon no other grounds than his being able to say the short catechism, and declaring that he stands by his baptismal engagements? Will you say that this is the Christian doctrine concerning the terms of acceptance and forgiveness with God? Are good vows and resolutions, declared in the church, infallible or proper proofs of a regeneration by the Holy Ghost? Is a man's professing that he repents, and promising that he will live godly, that actual repentance and amendment of life which alone can insure the divine pardon and favour? Are there not multitudes who call Christ their Lord, and publicly profess to stand by their baptismal covenant, whom, however, he will reject with abhorrence at

TROWELL. Nov. 1, 1870.

CONFIRMATION.

565

last? You will inform me then, sir, how the bishops upon this mere profession and promise, presume to declare to Almighty God, and to assure the person that he is regenerated, forgiven, and unquestionably in a state of favour with heaven?

"The expressions, you must acknowledge, are couched in strong and absolute terms: nor do I find that there is any intimation that their forgiveness depends upon their care to keep and to live up to their baptismal engagements. No: but though their whole life hath hitherto been scandalously corrupt, yet, upon their being able to say the Lord's Prayer, etc., the bishop solemnly pronounces a most absolute pardon over them, appeals to Almighty God that he hath forgiven them all their sins, and, lest this should be too little to satisfy the doubting sinner, and appease his upbraiding conscience, he lays his hand upon his head, and certifies him by that sign of God's favour and goodness towards him.

"The bishop, sir, the multitudes who come to be confirmed, are taught to consider as an ambassador of Christ, a successor of the apostles, and a special minister of God. When they hear then, this sacred person so solemnly declaring that they are fully justified, pardoned, and regenerated, by the Holy Ghost, can you blame them if they believe it, and rest satisfied that their souls are in a safe and happy state? And, as full remission of sins, and the favour of God are to be had on such easy terms, can you wonder should you see thousands eagerly flocking from all quarters to accept it; or that persons of very vile and profligate characters should often thrust themselves in to partake of this benefit, and be seen receiving upon their knees, episcopal absolution, and solemn assurances of God's favour and grace?

"You know the aptness of mankind to deceive themselves with false hopes, and to substitute good purposes, professions and vows, in the place of real repentance and amendment of life. You also know, sir (and, have no doubt, often declared it from your pulpit), that this is one of the chief hindrances of men's becoming truly good. Now, should your office for Confirmation be found thus plainly and directly tending to cherish these false hopes, you must excuse me if I believe, that so far from its conducing to holiness of life, it greatly tends to promote that self-deception which is so fatal to the souls of men.

"Let me further ask you, sir, on this head, is it any breach of charity to suppose, that, amongst the vast crowds which present themselves on such occasions, there are often many whom God, who knows their hearts, knows to be persons of a corrupt and wicked mind, and to be still under the power and tyranny of sin? Can the good bishop himself, in any judgment of charity, suppose there are not some such amongst the thousands he confirms? Candidly tell me then, sir, upon what grounds he absolutely and without reserve declares to the eternal God concerning them all, that he hath fully forgiven these his servants, when God at the same time knows many of them not to be his servants, and that he hath not at all forgiven them? Upon what grounds does he lay his hand on each individual person, to assure him of God's favour, and of his regeneration by the Holy Ghost, when, in truth, some of those whom he thus assures are absolute and entire strangers to the renewing influences of God's Spirit, and fast bound in their sins? To me it appears, I do not say a very shocking, but, I must say, a very unaccountable solemnity, and I should be glad to know how to reconcile it to the reverence you owe to God, or to the faithfulness and charity due to the souls of men."

And now, sir, as I have been able to correct your reading of John Calvin for you, I shall be delighted if the Spirit of God will enlighten you in the reading of Holy Scripture, so that you may no longer be a blind leader of the blind; and I am, with all fitting courtesy,

Yours faithfully,

JOHN WATERTON.

73

THOWEL, Nov. 1, 1870.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate