Confirmation — A Review. By C. H. Spurgeon
THE Rev. Alfred Potter, Rector of Keyworth, Notts, has issued a treatise on "Confirmation," in which under the title of the Rector of Ashton he holds two imaginary conversations with a dissenting cottager named John Blake; we beg to present the reverend gentleman with some account of the sequel to his former pastoral visitations, giving him free permission to print and circulate the appendix under the same cover as the treatise itself, so as to make a complete thing of it.
THE INTERVIEW.
John Blake: Sir, you were so kind as to call at my house and talk with me about having my children confirmed, and therefore I thought you would not object to my calling upon you and continuing the conversation.
The Rector of Ashton: Indeed, John, I do not see how I can raise any objection, though I certainly hoped that the matter had been set at rest in your mind, and that your children would have been confirmed without any further ado. How is it that you are not fully persuaded? I left you, as I thought, quite decided, and I hope no one has interfered to unsettle your mind.
John: Well, sir, you know my missus is a capital wife, and a very sensible woman.
Rector: That she certainly is, and a most excellent churchwoman too. I remember how smilingly she dusted a chair for me* when I called at your cottage, and the way in which the children bowed and curtseyed showed that she knew how to bring them up to behave lowly and reverently to all their betters.
John: That is very true, sir, as far as it goes, but with all her good manners she has a mind of her own, and is a rare stickler for fair play. So when you were gone, she said, "Now, John, our rector spoke up well for his side of the question, and upset you very soon, though he was not over clear on some points. Now, as you know, I have always believed him to be right, but, still, you have been a deal better man since you went to the meeting, and when you went to church you always went to sleep and never got a bit of good. I should like you to hear what the meeting minister has to say for himself. They that go to hear him are not all fools, and the minister himself is a very good man; I think you are bound to hear what he has to say. These things are solemn matters, and there's nothing like seeing to the bottom of them." So you see, sir, I took her advice, and went to see Mr. Waterton.
Rector: What, that man! Why, John he is an Anabaptist and a Calvinist: you could not have gone to a more dangerous person.
John: Why, sir, I went to him just because he is a Calvinist. I felt
* See the reverend gentleman's tract, in which he makes a great point of this. Little things please parsonic minds.
[THE SWORD AND THE
TROWEL. Nov. 1, 1870.
sure I should get to know about some of the tough points you gravelled
me with, if I went to him.
Rector: How is that, John—why should he know about it any more
than Mr. Conference, the Wesleyan?
John: Don't you remember, sir, you told me that John Calvin was
very much of your way of thinking, and I thought a Calvinist was the
very man to tell me more on the matter. To tell you the truth, sir, I
thought I had fairly got him into a corner, and I did not know but
what he would come over to the church along with me, and the missus
and children.
Rector: You did very wrong in going to him. But pray what did he
say?
John: Sir, he made me open my eyes very wide when he told me that
you had printed our talk with one another; and when I read it I saw
that you had put words into my mouth which I am sure I never said.
Why, sir, you make me out to be as soft as wax, and you say nothing
about those little raps I gave you. I don't think it is a fair thing for a
gentleman to do, to make a poor man out to be a simple Simon, but you
clergy do take dreadful liberties with us poor people. However, it is
quite as well as it is, for now I shall not make many bones about it,
but shall expect you to hear me patiently, even if what I say does not
quite suit you. An Englishman who has been unfairly treated, has a
fair right to put matters on the square a little, whether he lives in a
cottage or a mansion. Cost me what it may, after what you have printed
I feel I must speak my mind.
Rector: Well, John, I did not quite mean my tract to be a verbally
correct account of our interview. You could not expect me to circulate
any errors you may have brought forward. However, as you feel some-
what hurt, I will hear what you have to say, if you say it respectfully;
though, mark you, it is a liberty I should not think of giving you again.
Remember, I am the ordained minister of this parish, and you cannot
expect to teach me.
John: Certainly not, sir; and I did not think of coming to you till
you first came to me. But I am obliged by the liberty you give me, and
I will now tell you what Mr. Waterton said to me. As for your printing
what I never said, we will say no more about that; I felt it a good deal
for the moment, but I have got over it.
Rector: Go on, John, and pray be as short as you can.
John: Well, sir, you led me to believe that Calvin agreed with this
confirmation business. You said that he had written these words, "Such
laying on of hands I approve, and I would that the custom were this day
restored to its purity."* Mr. Waterton said it was very good of you to
mention the book and chapter,† and he took down the volume and read
out the passage to me, as follows, here it is on a bit of paper—"The
* Please take a note of the gentleman's name. The Rev. Alfred Potter, Rector
of Keyworth, Notts, actually gives this as a quotation from Calvin. Let him enjoy
the high character for integrity which such a mode of quotation must win him with
all candid men. The Latin of the passage is, "Tulcm ergo manuum impositionem,
que simpliciter loco benedictionem fiat, laudo, et restitutam hodie in purum usum
velim."
† Institutes. Book IV., Chapter xix., sec. 4.
TROWEL. Nov. 1, 1870.
CONFIRMATION.
499
laying on of hands, which is done simply by way of benediction I commend,
and would like to see restored to its pure use in the present day." Now,
sir, would you be so good as to tell me why you left out those words
about benediction, when as a learned gentleman you were talking to a
poor uneducated man? Was it fair, sir?
Rector: I am not going into an argument with you; you confess you
are uneducated, so, pray, do not press me. I could give excellent reasons
but you would not be capable of appreciating them. You know nothing
of logic.
John: Just so, sir, and that makes all the difference, no doubt. But Mr.
Waterton took the trouble to write out an extract from the very next
page of Calvin's Institutes, which he said he should try to hope you had
never read, and I am sure I hope so too, for I should not like to think
bally of you, sir. Here is the piece he copied:—
"It pleased the Lord that those visible and admirable gifts of the Holy Spirit
which he then poured out upon his people, should be administered and distributed by his apostles by the laying on of hands. I think that there was no
deeper mystery under this laying on of hands, but I interpret that this kind of
ceremony was used by them to intimate, by the outward act, that they commended to God, and, as it were, offered him on whom they laid hands. Did
this ministry, which the apostles then performed, still remain in the church, it
would also still behoove us to observe the laying on of hands; but since that
gift has ceased to be conferred, to what end is the laying on of hands? Assuredly
the Holy Spirit is still present with the people of God; without his guidance
and direction the church of God cannot subsist. For we have a promise of
perpetual duration, by which Christ invites the thirsty to come to him, that they
may drink living water. (John vii. 37.) But those miraculous powers and
manifest operations, which were distributed by the laying on of hands, have
ceased. They were only for a time. For it was right that the new preaching
of the gospel, the new Kingdom of Christ, should be signalised and magnified
by unwonted and unheard of miracles. When the Lord ceased from these, he
did not forthwith abandon his church, but intimated that the magnificence of
his kingdom, and the dignity of his word, had been sufficiently manifested. In
what respect, then, can these stage-players say that they imitate the apostles?
The object of the laying on of hands was, that the evident power of the Holy
Spirit might be immediately exerted. This they effect not. Why, then, do
they claim to themselves the laying on of hands, which is indeed said to have
been used by the apostles, but altogether to a different end?
"The same account is to be given were anyone to insist that the breathing
of our Lord upon his disciples (John xx. 22) is a sacrament by which the Holy
Spirit is conferred. But the Lord did this once for all, and did not also wish
us to do it. In the same way, also, the apostles laid their hands, agreeably
to that time at which it pleased the Lord that the visible gifts of the Spirit
should be dispensed in answer to their prayers; not that posterity might, as
those apes do, mimic the empty and useless sign without the reality."
There, sir, I feel awfully sorry for you, you had better have done
without Calvin. However, Mr. Waterton said, it was a very small
question what Calvin did or did not teach; it was after all a thing to
be settled by the word of God. He said that as far as his memory
served him, Calvin would have used a kind of laying on of hands, but
that what he would have meant by it was as wide as the poles asunder
from what you mean by Confirmation, for you told me that in Confirmation "the Holy Spirit supplies grace for growth in holiness."
• Institutes; Book IV. c. 19, sec. 6, 7.
[THE SWORD AND THE
TROWEL. Nov. 1, 1870.
Rector: John, I am astonished at you. You have insulted me to my
face. How dare you say you were awfully sorry for me? You sorry
for me indeed. I have had quite enough of this; I was foolish to
allow you to talk to me at all. Leave my house immediately. I shall see
Farmer Bramble about you. Go at once. I want no more of your
rudeness.
John: Sir, I am not rude but plain, but I will certainly go as you
wish it. It is just as Mr. Waterton said. He told me you would not
like to be put in such a fix, and would be sure to stop me, and he gave
me this letter to leave with you, with his compliments. I meant no offence,
but if truth offends, so must it be. Good morning, sir.
