E.A. Johnston warns that many preachers today act as butchers of souls by offering a false gospel, and calls for true surgeons of souls who faithfully preach repentance, regeneration, and the necessity of salvation through Christ.
In 'A Butcher Or Surgeon of Souls,' E.A. Johnston challenges the contemporary church to examine the quality of gospel preaching. Using a vivid analogy from the Civil War, Johnston contrasts false teachers who harm souls with true ministers who faithfully call sinners to repentance and regeneration. This sermon is a passionate call for a return to biblical truth and a revival of faithful soul care in the church.
Full Transcript
I have often traveled to Shiloh National Cemetery and Battlefield, a scene of one of the bloodiest conflicts of the Civil War. I'd visit the bloody pond and the hornet's nest, and I'd hear stories about how young boys who were wounded in battle, they'd be carried to the surgeon's makeshift tent, where he would amputate their leg with a dirty saw, and kangarine would sit in and send them to an early grave. Many of these army surgeons were just butchers of boys.
And I'm going to apply that analogy, friends, to some of our pulpits today, where blind guides feed poor sinners a false gospel, and through their ignorance, butcher souls and send them on to hell, because we're living in a day of great apostasy in our churches, and poor sinners need to know how to get saved, and there are few surgeons of souls around today that know how to point someone savingly to Christ. I'm afraid we're in the same shape as the bloody war camps, where there were more butchers than surgeons, and many suffered under their bloody hands. The title of my message today, friends, is A Butcher or Surgeon of Souls, and my text can be found in Jeremiah chapter 6. You can turn in your Bibles there now, friends.
We will be in verses 13 through 16. I want to read us this striking passage of scripture, where God has a grievance against the preachers in that day, and may the Spirit of the Lord attend the reading of His Holy Word. For from the least of them, even unto the greatest of them, every one is given to covetousness.
And from the prophet, even unto the priest, every one dealeth falsely, but they have healed also the herd of the daughter of my people slightly, saying, Peace, peace, when there is no peace. I will stop there, friends. How many times have I sat in churches where the pastor was given an invitation, and I sat there scratching my head, wondering if that pastor himself was even saved.
I've watched people respond to an altar call, and walk an aisle, and a man up there speaks peace to them, when there is no peace. How harmful it is to an awakened soul to have a pastor heal their wounds slightly, and tell them they're now saved, when they've yet to find Christ, the only one who can save them. The blind lead the blind today, and all fall into a ditch.
Whereas a true surgeon of souls is deeply familiar with the risen Christ, and how he saves sinners. A surgeon of souls knows full well the wicked windings of the human heart, because he's gotten a pretty ugly view of his own heart, and he knows the heart of man is wicked and deceitful at best. A surgeon of souls will preach the law to shut up a sinner, up to God for salvation, and awaken him to his lost condition.
A surgeon of souls will not fear man, but only fear God, and warn men, and women, and boys and girls about a future judgment that awaits all mankind. A surgeon of souls will not be afraid to call sin black, and hail high, and inform you of your duty of repentance. And a surgeon of souls will not candy coat the gospel to make it more appealing, but he will preach up a bloody cross, and a blood stained savior from sin.
A surgeon of souls will preach messages on the utter necessity of being born again, if you want to see heaven, and show you your need of a supernatural act of grace upon the heart called regeneration. And a surgeon of souls, friends, will stand on his Bible, and lean upon the Holy Spirit to open hearts and bring conviction of sin, as he boldly stands on the word of God and declares, Thus saith the Lord. Let me read us, friends, verse 16, which talks about this.
Thus saith the Lord, Stand ye in the ways, and see, and ask for the old paths, where is the good way, and walk therein, and ye shall find rest for your souls. But they said, We will not walk therein. I'll be honest with you, friends.
There was a time, years ago, when I was a butcher of souls. I fed people a pat plant of salvation that was handed to me by my denomination. I didn't know any better, and I caused a lot of harm to folks in my ignorance.
I remember an ice cream man who I butchered with my easy-believe gospel, and I got him to repeat a prayer, and I patted him on the back and told him he was now saved. Shame on me. Shame on anyone who deals falsely with an immortal soul.
But God, in his mercy, taught me the real gospel of the Son of God, who came down here to save lost sinners. Listen to me, friends. We need a revolution in this country.
I don't mean riots in the streets. That's probably coming anyway. I mean a revolution in our pulpits, in return to tread in the old paths of the great doctrines of the gospel, which are ruin, redemption, repentance, and regeneration.
Pray, friends, for this revolution to take place. Pray that it will, for the sake of souls. We need more surgeons today than butchers.
Let us pray.
Sermon Outline
-
I
- Analogy of Civil War surgeons and butchers
- Comparison to modern pulpits and false gospel
- Introduction of Jeremiah 6:13-16 as text
-
II
- The danger of false peace and shallow healing
- The harm of leading souls astray
- The need for true knowledge of Christ
-
III
- Characteristics of a surgeon of souls
- Preaching law to awaken sinners
- Boldness in proclaiming sin and judgment
-
IV
- Call for a revolution in the pulpits
- Return to old paths of gospel doctrines
- Personal testimony of transformation from butcher to surgeon
Key Quotes
“Many of these army surgeons were just butchers of boys.” — E.A. Johnston
“The blind lead the blind today, and all fall into a ditch.” — E.A. Johnston
“We need a revolution in our pulpits, in return to tread in the old paths of the great doctrines of the gospel.” — E.A. Johnston
Application Points
- Examine your own heart and salvation to ensure it is grounded in true gospel repentance and regeneration.
- Pray for and support faithful preachers who boldly proclaim the whole counsel of God.
- Reject shallow or easy-believe gospel messages and seek deeper understanding of Christ's saving work.
