Menu

The Testament of Solomon: McCown’s Introduction

The English introduction to the standard Greek edition of the Testament of Solomon. It tells what the book contains, describes the manuscripts, traces the history of the text, and discusses the ideas of the book about demons, magic and medicine and its sources in Jewish, Greek, Egyptian and Babylonian belief, and its date and place of writing. This page has 10 chapters and about 30,829 words.

The third century 1st–3rd century AD Testament of Solomon 10 chapters English translation: Public domain
Download the English translation EPUB 81 KBPlain text 175 KB
Show:
EnglishPublic-domain English text, 1922; OCR text
Contents (10)
  1. I. Character and Contents
  2. II. Description of the Manuscripts
  3. III. Modern Editions, Translations, and Treatises
  4. IV. The Textual History of the Testament
  5. V. Language and Style
  6. VI. The Chief Ideas of the Testament
  7. VII. The Sources and Relationships of the Subject Matter
  8. VIII. The Testament in Literature and History
  9. IX. The Date of the Testament and Its Recensions
  10. X. Authorship and Provenience
I. Character and Contents
1. The Testament of Solomon is a combination of folktales and a magician's vade-mecum. In its interpretations of Scripture and its legends of biblical personages it reminds one of the Haggadah. In its stories of demons and their activities it is similar to the Arabian Nights. Its magical formulae and recipes relate it to the execration tablets, the amulets, and the magical papyri of antiquity, and to the medical recipe books of the Middle Ages. The same combination of naïve popular science and laboriously learned philosophy runs indirectly into the Faust literature, and directly into the Clavicula Salomonis, the "Key of All Mysteries". It is a product of those three pseudo-sciences which have brought more disappointed hopes and abject terrors to mankind than any others: astrology, demonology, and magic.
2. It is as a leaf from the common man's thinking that the Testament has its chief value. Its superstitious puerilities arouse intense interest, when one thinks of them as recording the hopes and fears of the vast majority of mankind. The "Meditations" of Marcus Aurelius and the "Confessions" of St. Augustine open the door to the innermost thoughts of two great personalities who have done much to mould the life of their own and all succeeding generations. Books like the Testament help one to understand the psychological reactions of the great shadowy army of men who followed these leaders afar off. They explain why the philosophical emperor, who had learned "not to give credit to what was said by miracle-workers and jugglers about incantations and the driving away of demons and such things", should have allowed two lions to be cast into the Danube with elaborate ceremonies and costly sacrifices, in the vain hope of winning success for the Roman arms, and should have consulted the Chaldeans to cure Faustina's infatuation for a gladiator. In spite of their absurdities demonology and magic had a tremendous hold upon the great body of mankind. The Testament is doubly welcome, since unfortunately we have too few first hand sources in this field.
3. The document also makes a contribution to a most important chapter in the early history of Christianity, coming as it probably does from the fourth century, or earlier, and embodying much older materials. One of the prominent motifs in the work is the conception of Christ as conqueror of demons. The Christian compiler combines a simple, unhesitating faith in the efficacy of the pagan formulae he cites with an inconsistent trust in the superior power of Christus invictus. Dion Cassius ascribes the famous thunder storm that miraculously refreshed the Roman legions and discomfited their enemies during the Marcomannic war to the magic arts of an Egyptian sorcerer. The Christians claimed the marvel came in answer to the prayers of the 'Thundering Legion', and made the incident a powerful argument for the new faith. Our author, combining the two contradictory points of view, stands as a representative of the great majority of the Christians of his time, to whom their faith
was but another superstition superimposed upon the old. It was impossible all at once to replace the old sensuous paganism with a spiritual and ethical monotheism. During the long struggle Christianity was fearfully debased and weakened. How much of the old was carried over into the new religion the Testament of Solomon helps one partly to realize. 4. Another important service the Testament renders in that it represents, so far as it is Jewish, "pre-Talmudic demonology", and one might add, Palestinian demonology. It is, to be sure, much more than a Christian revision of a Jewish work. A profusion of both Christian and pagan ideas and materials are to be found in it, and until these are indicated, the document must be used with caution. However, when once these elements are eliminated, as they can be with some certainty, the Test comes to be of real assistance in reconstructing the thought world of the Palestinian Jew in the first century of our era, and it is, therefore, important not only for the student of church history, but for the New Testament and the Jewish scholar.
5. A complete table of contents is given at the end of this section. The aim of the present paragraph is to call attention to the main ideas that enter into the construction of the work. In the two chief recensions the story in brief is as follows: In response to his prayers Solomon receives his famous magic ring, in order that he may protect a favorite workman on the Temple, who is being tormented by a demon. By means of the ring the King calls the demon before him, learns the powers and activities of all the demons, the formula, or angelic name, which frustrates each, and in addition many secrets of nature and of the future. The demons are used to perform various tasks in connection with the building of the temple. The story ends with an account of Solomon's fall because of his love for a Shunamite girl, and of the consequent loss of his power over the demons. This simple framework, without plot or progress of thought, allows the introduction of a bizarre medley of stories
1\* about demons. The writer's chief interest is medico-magical. He writes to make known to the world what the diseases and ills are which demons bring to mankind, and how their malevolent designs are to be frustrated. His angelology is only a foil to his demonology, for God's messengers come to earth solely for the purpose of counteracting demonic agency. The motif of temple building, which introduces the story, is well-maintained throughout, entering into almost every section. Yet, while ostensibly primary, it is really subordinate; it is part of the background against which the author can display his demonological knowledge. Another motif is the wisdom and glory of Solomon. This also is kept continually in mind throughout the entire narrative. In one brief section the demons are for the moment entirely forgotten, while the magnificence of Solomon's buildings, the wealth of his treasury, and the homage rendered him by other nations are described. Though the "Queen of the South" is introduced as a sorceress (), it is without a trace of the Jinn of the Bilkis legend. However, Solomon's power is due to his ring, his wisdom and magnificence to what the demons have taught him and done for him, and thus the whole is brought within the writer's circle of ideas. Another very natural interest betrays itself. No doubt many an inquiring mind had asked how the magicians came to know the secret names and incantations by which the demons could be laid.
In a well known Egyptian legend, Isis, the divine sorceress, wishes to learn the secret, allpowerful name of Re. She causes him to be bitten by a serpent, and he must reveal the name before she can cure him. The question which inspired the Egyptian story is more satisfactorily answered by the Testament. Solomon's magic ring forces the revelations, and the wise king before his death writes all this hidden lore in a "Testament", which is handed down to future generations, that they may be able to escape the wiles of their demonic tormentors. It is in this connection that the
motivation for the story of Solomon's fall is not unskillfully supplied. According to one manuscript, a demon foretells the sad end of the King's glory, and, when the prophecy is fulfilled, the chastened monarch, satisfied of the truth of all that the demons have told him, writes it down. Thus, with all its variety of contents, the work is a real unity, owing to the writer's preponderating interest in magic and demonology. 6. The following inventory of the contents of the recensions of the Testament is intended to show in the most concise manner what the various forms of the work contain. By comparison of the numbers in this list with those of the "Comparative Table" opposite it will be plain at once what part of the total material each manuscript contains. References to chapter and section or to pages of the Greek text will, it is hoped, render the rapid survey of the latter easier.
The "Comparative Table" is intended to show the material contained in each manuscript, and thus to illustrate the relations of the manuscripts one to another. The divisions of the manuscripts into families, or recensions, here adopted is supported by other considerations, as will appear later. Yet the proof offered by this table is so simple and decisive that further evidence is hardly necessary. In the table the figures at the left refer to the sectional numbers in the conspectus of contents on the opposite page. The letters, a, b, and c, used in the columns pertaining to the manuscripts, stand for Recensions A, B, and C, and indicate that the recension contains the material of the section in question. Where one of the letters: d, h, i, l, p, etc., appears, it indicates that in that section the manuscript shows material peculiar to it. The cipher: o indicates that the section is wanting through the carelessness of the scribe or accident to the manuscript, not by intentional omission on the part of the editor of the recension.
a) Prefatory matter (not originally part of Test) 1. Title 2. Doxology 3. David's sin with Bathsheba, D I 1-3 4. Failure of God's attempt to stop David, D I 4-6 5. Nathan's reproof of David, D I 7-11 6. Solomon's birth, reign, power, and wisdom, D I 12f. 7. Solomon's prayer; command to build Temple, UVW, Prol. 1-5 8. Building of Temple, D II 1; cf. Test I 1 b) Testament proper, matter common to majority of MSS 9. The favorite slave, or chief architect, I 1; D II 2 10. His affliction by a vampire, I 2; D II 2 11. Solomon's prayer about the matter, I 3; D II 3 12. Solomon examines the slave, I 3f.; D II 3f. 13. Solomon's supplication for him, I 5; D II 5 14. The answer, a magic ring, I 6f.; D II 6f. 15. The inscription on the ring (not original)
16. Solomon gives the ring to the slave, I 8f.; D II 8f. 17. The capture of the demon, Ornias, I 10-14; D II 10-13. 18. Solomon examines Ornias, II 1-9, D III 1-4 19. Ornias fetches Beelzebul, who is examined, III 1-7 20. Onoskelis summoned and examined, IV 1-12 21. Asmodaeus summoned and examined, V 1-5 22. Asmodaeus further examined, V 6-13 23. Beelzebul re-examined, VI 1-11 24. Lix Tetrax, VII 1-8 25. The seven sister vices, VIII 1-12 26. Phonos, IX 1-7 c) Testament proper continued in Recensions A and B 27. Punishment of Phonos, IX 8 28. Kyon, or Rhabdos, and the green stone, X 1-11 29. Leontophoron, XI 1-7
II. Description of the Manuscripts
The manuscripts are here described in the briefest manner that seemed consistent with the desire to put the reader in possession of the main facts necessary to estimate their relative importance and their relationships. They are taken up in the order in which they appear in the foregoing table, that is, following the alphabetical order of the letters which have been chosen to symbolize them, which is also the order of priority in the development of the Test. 1. D Dionysius monastery, Mt. Athos, No. 132, ff. 367—374, XVI cent.; entitled ; published by Istrin, cf. Edition No. 4; collated by photograph, from which the title is missing; pages of Test deleted by transverse lines. Istrin gives no description of the manuscript. The photograph shows it to have been carefully and correctly written and well preserved; it seems to be in small format. The hand is heavy, round, and beautifully clear, with the customary ligatures and abbreviations. Orthography and punctuation (comma, question mark, and period) are exceptionally good. The iota subscript is lacking. The $\beta$ is often written like an $v$. In one instance an omitted word was added at the bottom of the page; in another the order of two clauses was reversed by putting the letter $\beta$ before the first, $\alpha$ before the second. Otherwise there are no important corrections or erasures. A later hand has added marginal notes giving some of the subjects mentioned in the text. The title given by Istrin appears to have been written above the ornamental head-piece, and only the lower part of the letter $\pi$ appears in the photograph. The Solomonic writing, which fills eight leaves, was wrongly bound. The leaves are in the order 367—371, 374, 373, 372. The page on which
3 occurs for , I 10; for II 2, 4; is always written with the grave accent. the next selection begins appears to be 375. The writing covers only about two-thirds of f. 374, something having been erased from the remainder of the page. F. 366 contains the conclusion of a religious or ecclesiastical writing which I do not recognize. On f. 375 begins a selection described in another hand as , () ', '. 2. H Private library of the Earl of Leicester, Holkham Hall, Norfolk, England, No. 99, described in the catalogue as "Opuscula theologica varia, on paper, Quarto XV and XVI cent." The Test is of the XV cent.; cm. 16<21.5; 35 ff., unnumbered; f. 1 recto and f. 35 verso blank, making 68 pages; entitled , etc.; well preserved, unpublished. The writing is large, round, and clear; and , and may easily be confused. Ligatures and abbreviations are frequent; iotacism often appears; the iota subscript is rare. The punctuation, which is intelligently used, consists mainly of the period, placed sometimes higher, sometimes lower. Corrections and erasures are rare. It is the only manuscript which boasts rubrics placed before the chief divisions of the story. The title and the
initial letters of the lesser sections are also in red. In XXII 10, 11 for has been mistaken for . Aside from the Test the contents of the codex are theological and ecclesiastical. There is nothing to indicate its provenience except a tract copied in the same hand as the Test and called in the catalogue "Johannes Canabutii magistri ad principem Aeni et Samothraciae". This seems to point to Greece. 3. I Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris, Supplément grec, No. 500, XVI cent., paper, cm. 16×22; ff. 78—82; entitled , etc., with added in a careless hand in the upper margin of the page; well preserved; published by Istrin, cf. Edition No. 4. The writing is fine, slender, and somewhat crowded; ligatures are extremely frequent and intricate, abbreviations and compendia numerous. Iotacism is comparatively rare; Attic orthography appears occasionally; e. g., (II 1); the iota subscript is wanting; the punctuation (comma and period), the division of words, and the use of breathings and accents correct. Corrections and erasures are very rare. Although a broad margin has been left, marginal variants and glosses are wanting. The title with a conventional ornamental head-piece above it, the magical inscription of the ring, and occasional initial letters of sections are rubricated.
The codex contains a miscellaneous collection of classical, philosophical, ethical, theological, and biblical writings, including Ecclesiastes and Canticles, some of them unfinished. The Test follows the two Solomonic works just mentioned. Unfortunately, as with some of the other works, the copyist soon became weary of the stories of the many demons and broke off in the middle of a sentence and a column, when he had written about one sixth of the Test. The well known Greek scholar, Minoides Minas, whose name appears on one of the fly leaves at the back, owned the codex, and through his heirs it came into the Bibliothèque Nationale in 1864. Minas had been under commission from the French government to seek manuscripts in European Turkey, Asia Minor, and especially at Mt. Athos. Where he acquired this one is unknown. Doubtless it was somewhere in the Levant. 4. L Harleian MSS, British Museum, No. 5596; 58 ff., paper, cm. 23×34, XV cent., described in the printed catalogue as "Geomantica, exorcismi, divinationes et huius modi," with the addition in the written "Class-catalogue" of the words "quaedam Salomonis," well preserved, unpublished. Four fragments are used as follows: 1) ff. 8—18, the title, originally missing, supplied by a later hand in Latin: "Quomodo Solomon aedificaturus templum cum spiritibus colloquitus fuit, et multa edoctus," 2) f. 7—7, 3) f. 33, and 4) ff. 39—41. (On the last three fragments, which are designated by T, see below.)
The writing is low, broad, round, and heavy; it is somewhat run together, yet it is regular, very clear, and not without beauty. Abbreviations and ligatures are frequent, compendia less so. Iotacism is not frequent. The iota subscript does not appear. The comma (rather infrequent), the period, and, at the end of the more important sections, a triple period make up the punctuation. Erasures, corrections, and Greek glosses are wanting. A later hand has added in Latin, besides the title, occasional marginal notices and translations, and has marked by a cross and circle those peculiar directions for the use of the Test as a magical remedy for disease which render this MS unique. The MS also has the distinction of being the only one written in columns, two to the page. They are seven to eight centimeters wide, and contain twenty lines. In fragment 1) no colors are used except on the seal of Solomon. It is painted
with silver over red, as are the titles of the sections in the Clavicula (see below), and the numbers as well as the article () before each name in the list of fifty-one demons (Fragment 4). The rather coarse, yellow paper of the codex is beginning to decay. At one spot in the lower half of the inner column many of the leaves have rubbed until a few letters have disappeared. Harleian MS 5596 is entirely filled with magical, astrological, and demonological matter, evidently written by a mediaeval magician for practical use in his profession. The largest part (ff. 18–44r) is taken up by the Greek form of the Clavicula Salomonis. In it Fragments 3) and 4), which appear respectively in Recensions A and C in other MSS of the Test, are found. The first seven leaves of the codex contain various brief magical, geomantical, and astrological excerpts and observations, ending with Fragment 2), which is the second form of the Onoskelis story, found in Recension C of the Test. Two other of these excerpts bring this MS into relation with MS V, which contains a copy of Recension C; viz., (sic), f. 5ᵛ, col. 2, and a "Pythagorean table," (sic) , f. 6ᵛ, col. 2, both also found in MS V. I have discovered only one other MS in which the Clavicula and the Test appear together, and that is MS W, in which there are three very badly written pages of the former and a complete copy of Recension C of the latter. Fragment 1), or L, contains about two-thirds of the Test, ending in the middle of a column.
While on a brief visit to England in January and February, 1908, I undertook to go through all the Greek MSS of magical contents in the British Museum, as well as all the Solomonic literature in Latin, French, and English. In the course of the search I came across the Onoskelu story, then the longer fragment of the Test (L), and later the other pieces in the Clavicula. Unfortunately I have been able to get no light on the provenience of the codex. But it certainly has Italian relationships, since the "Pythagorean" letter and table are found in several other Italian MSS besides V, and S of Vienna which is closely related to V. 5. P Bibliothèque Nationale, Anciens fonds grecs, No. 38 (Colbert 4895); XVI cent., paper, cm. 15.5×20.5; 24 ff. in three quaternions; well preserved; entitled , etc.; published by Fleck, reprinted in part by Fürst, and entire by Migne; cf. Editions Nos. 1, 2, and 3.
The manuscript has been carefully and intelligently written. The handwriting is somewhat unskilful and angular in appearance, but easily readable. The letters are ligatured as ordinarily in the sixteenth century, but compendia and abbreviations are rare, even such words as and being often written out in full. Iotacism is very rare. The iota subscript, the accents, and the breathings are almost always correctly given. Unfortunately the punctuation, consisting of the comma, and the period at various heights, is most profusely employed and, as Fürst says, "verstößt gegen jede auf bestimmte Grundsätze basierte Abzeichnung der Satzteile". Not only has the manuscript been carefully written, but part of it has also been through the hands of a corrector. A large number of letters which seemed uncertain to the copyist were marked with three dots; in other instances he left part of a line vacant for the insertion of the proper words. Two such cases occur on the first page, where blacker ink, smaller and more crowded letters, and more numerous abbreviations show that the words were put in later. In one case the corrector hit upon the right text; in the other he missed. On f. 2 a similar blank was left, but the corrector was too uncertain to put his conjecture in the text; it remains on the margin. Unfortunately he failed to go carefully through the entire manuscript, and not all of the uncertain places received his attention. Occasional corrections were made in the course of the writing. Initial letters of sections are enlarged, and in two or three instances the closing lines of paragraphs have been left partly blank. No attempt has been made to rubricate or decorate the manuscript. It contains only the Test.
As to the provenience of the codex little can be made out. It belonged to the library of M. le President de Mesmes according to the catalogue printed by Montfaucon in 1739. Henri de Mesmes died in 1596, his son, Jean-Jaques, who inherited his manuscripts, in 1642. In 1679 Colbert bought about 215 manuscripts from the Duchesse de Vivonne, great-granddaughter of the former, among them the Test, as the list shows. The manuscripts of Colbert came into the Bibliothèque du Roi in 1732. In the catalogue of the Bibliothèque Royale (later Nationale) of 1740 it is mentioned as "No. 38 olim Colbert." Back of the library of de Mesmes it cannot be traced. Above the beginning of the text on the first page is written "Codex Colb. 4895 Regius 2913 3', preceded by a short word ending in many flourishes. Of this, to me illegible, part of the superscription M. Omont says: "'Cent': ce numero est une code d'inventaire des manuscrits de la duchesse de Vivonne; il provient très vraisemblablement des de Mesmes".
This manuscript has been occasionally noticed by scholars. Du Cange used it in his Glossarium published in 1688, referring to "Salomonis Testamentum ex Codd. Reg. 1843 et Colbert," and adding "vide notas nostras as Zonarae Annal. p. 83". In these Notae, published in 1687, he gives the title almost as in P with the remark, "legimus apographum ex Bibliotheca Thuanea." Either this is a slip of the memory, or else the "apographum" was merely a copy of the title. The library of Jaques August de Thou (died 1617) was sold in 1680, most of the ancient manuscripts being acquired by Colbert. But none of the printed catalogues of the library of de Thou show any copy of the Test. Other references to the Testament are secondary and rest upon Du Cange or Gaulmin, until finally Fleck came across the manuscript and published it in 1837. His edition has been the basis of all subsequent labors upon this piece of Solomonic literature, until the publication of Istrin.
UNT. 9: McCown. 6. Q Andreas Convent, Mt. Athos, No. 73, ff. 11—15: XV cent.; published by Istrin, cf. Edition No. 4. Although Istrin has given no description of the manuscript or critical apparatus, it is evident from the number of omitted letters which he has supplied in brackets, as well as from the frequent longer lacunae that it was carelessly copied from a defective exemplar. The manuscript contains only about one third of P; viz., the first ninety and the last two hundred thirty-seven lines, cc. III 1—XX 9 being omitted. The omission occurs near the bottom of f. 12ʳ, many pages, evidently, having dropped out of its exemplar. 7. S Vienna, codex philos. graec. 108; paper, cm. 19×25; XVI cent.; well preserved; the greater part unpublished. Contains two unpublished fragments: 1) copies of the twelve seals said in MSS VW to have been found on the ring of Solomon, f. 361ᵛ; 2) one of the recipes found in the same recension (VII 7), f. 167ᵛ.
The codex contains much astrological matter, and many Solomonic amulets and selections. It has a large number of amulets like those in MS V, and long selections of magical content written in the peculiar cryptography to be found in that manuscript. They must, therefore, be of related origin, S having been copied from V or its exemplar. I have not learned anything concerning its provenience. 8. T British Museum, Harleian MS No. 5596; cf. supra, No. 4. This manuscript has already been fully described. A different letter, T, is used to designate the three fragments which are not incorporated in the incomplete copy of the Test found in this manuscript, and which belong to different recensions. T (or simple T) designates a fragment containing the variant story of Onoskelis (Rec. C, XI), and part of Solomon's conversation with Paltiel Tzamal (Rec. C, XII 1—4, and 6 — in part —). It begins without title in the middle of col. 1 on f. 7, being separated from a magic formula which precedes it by a slight space, and ends in the middle of col. 2 on the verso of the same leaf. The remainder of the column is blank. The Test begins at the top of the next column, f. 8.
T designates a fragment from the Clavicula containing a representation of a seal and inscription which, according to MSS HI, was that on Solomon's ring. The seal, an elongated six-sided figure containing ten circles and various magical characters with the word , takes up the greater part of the first column on the page (f. 33), and following it are given certain instructions and the inscription (cf. infra p. 2/3.), which runs over into the second column, under the rubric . The Test in this manuscript (L), contains a somewhat different but closely related version of the inscription on the seal. T designates a section in the Clavicula which contains the list of fifty (or fifty-one) demons which makes up a considerable portion of the unique matter in Rec. C. It runs from f. 39 (bottom) to f. 41 (top), and bears the rubric, (sic) . The previous section has for its rubric, (modern Greek, mirror). It is an exorcism of a certain female demon and her people ( . . . ) in order that they may perform certain services for the magician, particularly that they may answer truthfully any questions he may ask. It is written in very late Greek with an Italian flavor, much more modern than the already late Greek of the list of fifty demons. T is followed by a list of the demons and angels that rule each hour of the day, and another of the ruling planets and the work proper to each hour of the day. Both of these subjects had already been covered more briefly in an earlier part of the Clavicula; that is, the writer is
2\* here adding to the Clavicula matter of various kinds that belongs to the same sort of magic, but was not found in his copy. The last two sections he probably found in another recension of the Clavicula, for they appear without great difference of text in the Munich codex. The origin of the list of fifty demons will be discussed later. The text of Tᵈ covers about one fifth of Rec. C. 9. U Ambrosian library, Milan, No. 1030 (H 2 inf.); paper, cm. 16×22.6; ff. 1—378; XVI cent.; two fragments: 1) f. 233ᵛ, (= Uᵈ), 2) f. 252ᵛ (= Uᵖ). As this manuscript is known to me only through the catalogue and a photograph of the page on which Fragment 1) is found, a full description of it is impossible. As to the handwriting of the page photographed, however, and general contents, it closely resembles manuscripts V and W, discussions of which follow. It has two pages from the Clavicula, here called as in Munich MS No. 70, the "Pythagorean" letter and table found in Harl. MS No. 5596 and Bologna University MS 3632, and some astrological matter found in the Bologna manuscript.
The manuscript contains several unfinished fragments, some of them, like those from the Test, "transversis lineis deleta." I should judge that the scribe filled up odds and ends of time and space by copying little sections from other manuscripts. Thus he started in on the list of demons, and when he had reached the bottom of the page stopped. He probably had W or its exemplar before him, for he usually follows the W text. Uᵈ designates a fragment which, like Tᵈ, contains the list of demons given in Rec. C. In this case, however, it is a mere fugitive fragment, with no relation to what precedes or follows, except as it is all of astrological character, and it does not com- plete the list, ending with § 11. It bears the title, . . Up I have chosen to designate a little fragment which begins very abruptly in the middle of a sentence in § 5 of the "Prologue" to Recension C, with the words, · , , . The catalogue does not quote farther, nor give the explicit.
10. V Bologna, Library of the University, MS No. 3632; 475 ff., paper, cm. 21.9×29.6; XV cent.; written by a physician, John of Aro (or the son of Aro, or Aron); Test, entitled , ., ff. 436—441; dated (f. 441) December 14, 1440. Unpublished. The codex is poorly preserved. The leather of the half-leather binding is torn away, and the book is almost in pieces. The rough, gray paper is becoming discolored, yet the writing is distinct. One would not form a high estimate of the education of Dr. John from his handwriting, for it is loose, careless, and irregular, and his lines run up hill. His spelling is equally unsatisfactory. No distinction is made between, , , , , and ; between and ; or between and . Often and , occasionally and are interchanged. The accents are usually placed on the right syllable, but no attention is paid to the distinction between acute, grave, and circumflex, the last appearing even on . The breathings also are interchanged. The iota subscript is wanting. The punctuation, consisting of comma and period, is in general not bad, but not entirely consistent. Abbreviations, ligatures, and compendia are extremely frequent. Well known words or forms are abbreviated by leaving off the last few
letters. The title, the subscription, and the initial letters of the chief sections are rubricated. Corrections, erasures, and marginal notes are wanting. The contents of the codex are instructive both as to the medical practice and the religious beliefs of the Middle Ages, for they include all sorts of pseudo-scientific biological information, pages of medico-magical formulae, partly in cryptography, and long astrological treatises. The codex is rendered unique by its cryptography and by the large number of illustrations, poorly drawn and highly colored, including drawings of animals and plants, and magical and astrological figures. The Test stands in gathering of the codex, being preceded by 1) , f. 435, and 2) ' ' , f. 435. Following the Test comes ' . After the letter of this third the codex ends (f. 475). Two further writings mentioned in the (f. 16ᵛ) are wanting; 1) (sic) , and 2) . None of these items were originally in the , but the writings themselves are in the same hand as the greater part of the book. They evidently were not a part of the original plan of the copyist. The codex contains also the "Pythagorean" matter found in Harl. 5596, but in this case the copyist saved himself trouble by pasting in six leaves, the first five of which, containing the "Pythagorean" letter, were written in another hand, Dr. John continuing on the sixth. The titles of the
writings which were pasted in are an original part of the , and therefore, probably of the plan. From the similarity of subject matter it is plain, I think, that T, U, and V are very closely related. The Test covers the lower two thirds of f. 436v, on which it begins. After fifteen lines at the top of the succeeding page, all the remainder is occupied by the twelve seals which were engraved on Solomon's ring, with an additional circle in which the description of the seals given in the text is repeated. The next six pages are written solid, the writing space averaging cm. 17.5×25. On f. 441v the first eleven centimeters of the writing space are occupied by a circular figure intended to represent a magic writing of Solomon which is mentioned in the text (Rec. C XIII 14), and bearing the superscription, () () () . Beside it stands another, empty circle. There follow the concluding five lines of the Test, and then the subscription, consisting of seven lines, the first five of which are in the cryptographic character peculiar to this MS and Vienna 108.
The subscription, reduced to ordinary characters, is given in the Text, p. 212. Lines five and six read, ' () , ' () ' () '. The name, is abbreviated to , the remainder of the line up to and including being in cryptographic characters. On f. 362r the name is given again in cryptographic characters, this time spelled out in full, as follows: . On f. 327r it is found again thus: . There can be no doubt as to the reading of the characters, since by a combination of two lists of words and their equivalents in different parts of the codex a key is formed to the cryptography. Aro I take as a place name, but am unable to locate it. As to date there is no difficulty, since that part of the subscription exhibits only the common abbreviations. The world year 6949 corresponds to 1440—1. The indiction, four, fits that year according to the table given by Gardthausen. The date is, therefore, December 14, 1440. On f. 269v (bottom) one reads the date ,5m', and on f. 327r after the name, ,5m'; that is, 6939, or 1430—1, and 6952, or 1443—4. Although the meaning of the accompanying notice is not clear to me, I take it for an astronomical remark1. That on f. 327r has the appearance of having been added to the page at the lower margin after the original writing had been completed. As we have already seen, the codex falls into two parts, the second beginning with gathering , f. 435, and there is no reason why the first part may not have been written last, yet I incline to think the date was added after the writing.
There are several other writings in the codex which in the are called , all of them having to do with magic. The references to Solomon, however, were added after the first writing of the index, and it would seem that after writing the latter part of the codex, the scribe came to the conclusion that Solomon was the great source of all magical science and proceeded to give him due credit. The Test may well have been the cause of this opinion. Most of the writings marked have no relation to the ancient king, except that they are magical. However, on ff. 360—361 is a considerable collection of amulets, two of which bear his name. In the one it is simply a part of the incantation2. The other, a circle four centimeters in dia- meter, bears the title, (), and it contains within it the inscription which, according to H and I, belongs on Solomon's magic seal, and which is given in the Clavicula in Harl. 5596 (= Tʳ), and in a slightly different form in the Test in that manuscript (L). The Bologna version has been designated as Vʳ.
As to the provenience of the codex I have been able to learn nothing more than has been already intimated. The cryptography of the manuscript is sufficiently like the stenography of Cod. Vat. Graec. 1809 to make one think of the monastery of Grottaferrata as some way the source of Dr. John's knowledge of stenography. Yet the inference that he was connected with the monastery would be extremely uncertain. He may have gotten the stenography indirectly or even have developed it independently upon the basis of more ancient systems. That the manuscript is Italian in origin there can be no doubt. 11. W Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris, Anc. fonds grecs, No. 2419, XV cent. paper, cm. 27×37, 342 ff., written by George Mediatès. Test entitled , ., ff. 266ᵛ—270ᵛ. Well preserved. Unpublished. The codex resembles very closely the foregoing. The writing is somewhat more regular and less hasty in most of the codex. Iotacisms are almost as numerous; doubled letters are almost always written singly, even where they belong to different words. As to all other points W is just a trifle better than V. W omits occasional phrases that are found in V, sometimes apparently through carelessness, sometimes because they were unintelligible.
As to contents again there is great similarity, but in W the () () . Beneath is written the following prescription for the use of the amulet: () () ( add. Bol; more correct spelling adopted where MSS differed). alchemistic and astronomical interests outweigh the biological and the magico-medical. Berthelot says of it, "Ce manuscrit infolio . . . est des plus précieux pour l'histoire de l'Astronomie, de l'Astrologie, de l'Alchimie, et de la Magie au moyen âge; c'est une réunion indigeste de documents de dates diverses et parfois fort anciens, depuis l'Almageste de Ptolémée et les auteurs arabes jusqu'aux écrivains de la fin du moyen âge". The codex contains three pages from the Clavicula, and some "Hermetic" and "Pythagorean" writings. The fact which connects it most clearly and indubitably with Bologna 3632 is that the Test is immediately preceded by the Hermetic work on the planets and the twelve signs of the zodiac, and followed, though not immediately, by two of the "dream books" which also appear in the Italian manuscript. The very position of the beginning of the Test on the page is the same in the two manuscripts. As in V, so in W, the Test begins about one third down the page, and at the bottom of the next page are found the large seals that in this recension belong on Solomon's ring. Either the one was copied from the other, or both followed very closely the same exemplar. The decision of this question can best be left to a later section (III 4) where the text will be discussed.
As to the provenience of the codex, M. Omont has given me the following information: "Grec 2419: Provient du cardinal Nicolas Ridolfi ( 1550), puis du maréchal Pierre Strozzi ( 1558) et de Catherine de Medicis, après la mort de laquelle (1589), il resta sous scellés jusqu'à son entrée dans la bibliothèque du Roi en 1599. Au fol. 340°, le bibliothécaire de Ridolfi, Matthieu Devaris, a écrit cette note sur l'origine du ms.: , , . N° 35. [Deleted by a transverse line.] N° 44 vigesim. quart. (Ce sont deux numéros successifs de la bibliothèque du Cardinal Ridolfi; s. e. capsae. désigne ici le maître de De- varis, le cardinal Nicolas Ridolfi.)" W, then, like V, came from Italy. The name of the writer was George Mediates (or, Meidiates), as appears from a subscription found on f. 288. From a Paschalion on f. 275 running from 1462 to 1492 the conclusion is drawn that the codex was written about 1462.
The codex has been frequently used by scholars. Gaulmin in all probability took from its the excerpts he quoted in his notes on Psellus de oper. daem. From it Du Cange prepared a very considerable list of chemical and astrological abbreviations and tachygraphic signs. In more recent times Berthelot has taken from it some important chapters in his Collection des Anciens Alchimistes Grecs, while Reitzenstein refers to it several times in his Poimandres. Aside from Gaulmin I know of no publication which refers to the Test. 12. , . 16. XVI (. 431), . . . 4. . . This reference is taken from Lambros' Catalogue of the MSS on Mt. Athos, No. 3221, p. 287. I attempted to secure a photograph, but was unsuccessful, and know only this reference to the manuscript. 13. While studying in Berlin, Paris, London, Heidelberg, Munich, and smaller places on the Continent, I made search for other manuscripts and for translations of the Test, but without success. None of the catalogues which I was able to consult gave indications of its presence in any form. Through the kindness of Dr. A. F. R. Petsch, then professor in Heidelberg, and later in the University of Liverpool, inquiries were made by friends of his in the libraries at St. Petersburg and Moscow, but without success. Dr. F. C. Conybeare was so kind as to search in the Vatican Library. Though he was under the impression that a Latin manuscript was in existence, he was
III. Modern Editions, Translations, and Treatises
unable to verify that supposition or to find any other manuscripts. No doubt such exist and will be found, but no others are available at present.
Iii. Modern Editions, Translations, and Treatises.1. Fabricius deserves mention before all others, because he first attempted a systematic collection of materials bearing on the Test. As already indicated, he gathered his excerpts from Gaulmin and Du Cange, whose quotations he prints in full with some attempt at emendation. 2. Fleck rather inaccurately copied the editio princeps from MS P, mistaking many letters, and so causing himself and those who have had to depend upon his edition much difficulty. He evidently was not familiar with sixteenth century ligatures. While it has not seemed necessary to note his misreadings in the critical apparatus of the present edition, some of the more important have been included as samples of his errors. 3. Apparently the first scholar to concern himself with the text which Fleck had printed was Bornemann. In 1843 and in 1846 he published conjectural emendations of the text, showing no little ingenuity, and in some obvious cases finding the original, though missing it in every real difficulty, as is usual with such conjectures. In 1844 he published a complete translation in German, marked by the same learning and good sense shown in his "Conjectanea".
4. Fürst was the next to deal with the Test, printing the Greek text after Fleck, with a German translation, also in 1844. was so kind also as to send me a reference to Chachanov's History of Georgian Literature (I 170ff.), where mention is made of Georgian manuscripts of the Test. Unfortunately the work was to be found neither in Berlin, London, nor Chicago, and I have not seen the pages in question. The work, however, was not completed. Little attention was given to emending the text, but no small learning was expended on its proper translation and interpretation, though, rather strangely, the title is rendered "Bund", not "Testament", or "Vermächtniss." 5. In Migne's Patrologia Graeca a reprint of the text from Fleck with a Latin translation was appended to Psellus, because of the fact that Gaulmin had quoted the Test in his Notae to Psellus' de oper. daem. The reprint shows the usual additional typographical errors, but in a few cases Fleck's more obvious mistakes were corrected. The article in Migne's Dictionnaire des Apocryphs (Bibliogr. III 3) adds nothing new.
6. Chronologically next in order is Dr. F. C. Conybeare's translation with introduction in the old Jewish Quarterly Review, which is marked by the famous rationalist's usual careful scholarship and independence of judgment. He did all one could do with Fleck's edition. However, I am inclined to differ from him on questions of date and origin. 7. As a result of the publication of Conybeare's translation there appeared two brief articles in the Manchester Guardian, one by Dr. Montague Rhodes James, and the other by Dr. Conybeare, and a brief review in the Theologische Literaturzeitung by Schürer, who differed with Conybeare as to the Jewish origin of the Test. 8. In the same year that Dr. Conybeare's translation appeared, the Russian scholar, Istrin, presented the text of the fragmentary manuscripts which I have called I and Q, and of the interesting story called MS D. His introduction indicates the true relationship, as I believe, between D and the Test.
9. A brief notice of Istrin's publication and a review by Dr. E. Kurz appeared in the Byzantinische Zeitschrift. 10. Harnack has a brief notice in his Altchristliche Literatur, and Schürer a considerable one in his Geschichte des jüdischen Volkes, which includes a valuable collection of materials. To
IV. The Textual History of the Testament
Dr. Kohler's article in the Jewish Encyclopedia I owe the interesting suggestion that the Test represents pre-Talmudic demonology. Other encyclopedia articles make no special contribution. 11. In Salzberger's dissertation on the Salomosage much space is dedicated to the Test. He accepts Conybeare's conclusions as to authorship and date, and accordingly takes the Test as representative of early Jewish-Christian demonology and folklore, making no attempt to distinguish Hellenistic elements. He has evidently used Conybeare's translation without reference to the Greek text. 12. Ginzberg's Legends of the Jews contains a section devoted to the Test. It is a paraphrase and epitome rather than a translation, but follows the text of Fleck rather closely. One error is sufficiently serious to deserve mention: the aerial column of c. XXIV is confused with the cornerstone of c. XXIII. As unfortunately the notes and references, which, according to the preface, were to have appeared in the last volume, are lacking, there is nothing to indicate the source from which the story was taken. As a piece of entertaining writing the work may have a place, but it is a hindrance rather than a help to the study of ancient Jewish thinking because of its uncritical confusion of older and later materials. Ginzberg was not justified in using the Test without first sifting out the considerable non-Jewish elements more carefully than he does.
Iv. the Textual History of the Testament.1. The manuscript families. — On the textual evidence alone, without reference to wider considerations of language and subject matter, which will be taken up later, the various MSS divide themselves into four clearly marked classes or recensions. a) MS D differs from the rest in that it is not a "Testament." Of magico-medical formulae there are none. It is simply a biography of Solomon in which the demonological interest outweighs all others, quite closely resembling in many features the Arabian Nights. It clearly belongs to the "literature of entertainment," where Schürer wished to class the whole Test. b) MSS H, I, and L (Rec. A) stand very close together, H and I agreeing in a beginning which is entirely different from that in the other MSS, H and L (after I drops out) in the long omission, cc. XIV 3—XVI 1. L might deserve to be put by itself as a separate recension, for it has at a late period undergone a special revision. A magician has endeavored to make the work more useful for members of his profession by introducing directions for the use of the more important magical formulae in the cure of some disease, probably demon possession. He has also made some further changes in the opening sections. However, all these alterations, marked by modern Greek forms, are so easily detached from the remainder and affect it so little that there is no need to separate it from H and I as a textual witness.
c) MSS P and Q (Rec. B), again, clearly stand together almost from beginning to end. The title and the opening sentences are good illustrations of their close similarity throughout. This recension, in P at least, is marked by two explanations of the writing of the Test, by a shorter beginning and ending, and by more extended accounts of many of the demons. d) MSS V and W with the fragments S, T, and U group themselves as an entirely different recension (C), which has undergone a thorough revision. The Prologue, as I have called it, in order to bring the chapter and verse divisions into line with the other recensions, and the altered title, but especially the entirely different ending from IX 8 on are sufficient evidence. This recension is more interested in demonology as a means for revealing nature's treasures and mysteries than in its medical aspect as emphasized in the original Test. It is marked by scribal omissions.
2. The relationships and relative dates of the recensions. — a) MS D represents the story which formed the basis of the Test. The recensions have just been considered in what the writer regards as their chronological order. It is inconceivable that any one should take the Test as found in Recs. A, B, or C, and, by eliminating all the magico-medical element and the "testament" motif, reduce it to the simple tale of Solomon's birth and greatness, his temple building and dealing with demons, which appears in MS D. On the other hand, the very close resemblances between MS D and Recs. A and B as to general outline and even as to text in places, e. g., in the story of the old man and his son, c. XXI, proves the closest possible relationship, and, therefore, the dependence of the Test upon the story as found in MS D.
Yet D in its present form cannot have been the basis of the Test. It occasionally shows a fuller, secondary text, e. g., in the threat of the old man to cease working if Solomon did not condemn his son (D IV 2). Especially is this true of D VII. The question of c. VII 1, ; and its answer, , , after the statements of c. III 4—8 that all the demons had been brought in and set to work in the temple are manifestly a later addition. There is no reason why c. VII should not have been put into the Test if it had lain before its writer. It is evident, then, that MS D represents a revision of the work that formed the original of the Test.
The question as to whether cc. I, II, and VIII were part of this original is harder to answer. The editor of the Test could not well include cc. I and II in a "testament," which must have been written in the first person to have entirely consistent. The abrupt beginning of Rec. B is probably due to truncating the original story in order to eliminate these elements, which do not fit the new plan. C. VIII could easily have been put into the first person and left in the Test. Yet it seems entirely possible that it was in the original and was omitted by the editor of the Test merely because it did not interest him, or perhaps because it did not suit the pathos of the fall. It is not inconsistent with the remainder of D, but rather comes as a fitting conclusion to a narrative of which the account of the sin of David and the birth of Solomon was the beginning. I am inclined, therefore, to regard D I—VI, VIII as the original basis for the Test; with certain changes which we cannot follow and the addition of c. VII, D received its present form. The making of the Test was a much more complicated process.
b) Recensions A and B are both revisions of the original Test. The question of priority in this case is much more difficult. It is plain that A is secondary at its beginning, because it is much fuller than B (c. I 1f). Again at its conclusion, A, here represented by H only, is much fuller, and probably represents an expansion (C. XXVI 8—10). In the main, however, A has the shorter text in so many places where B presents fuller information regarding the demons, that one cannot but conclude that Rec. A has the claim to priority in most cases, and is nearest the original Test c) Recension C is a revision of Recension B. The nature of the material in the added chapters of C, as well as the fact that in the fragments, especially in T, much of it occurs in, or in UNT. 9: McCown. connection with, the Clavicula, which is a mediaeval product, establishes the character of this recension as secondary and late. The interesting account in C XIII of the origin of a - which is to be given to the world as a deception and a snare, while the true, original Testament is to be preserved in one copy only until "the expected parousia of God," when it is again to be spread abroad, is plainly intended to establish faith in this recension as the real original article over against Rec. B, which it was to supplant. The numerous agreements of B and C prove that the latter was based upon the type of text found in the former, yet in some cases C has a more primitive text than the present MS representatives of B (MSS PQ) offer.
d) Illustration will serve to make the relationships of the recensions clearer. A good example is to be found in c. III 7. Here Rec. A (HIL) gives a text which is entirely fitting and intelligible: -'. This became nonsense by misreading into , as V shows (W omits this much). P, wishing to leave nothing unintelligible, altered to , which in itself is good, but does not fit the context which follows in § 8. Another example of B's improvement upon a text which seemed unintelligible is found in II 8, where both V and W, as W in the previous case, omitted the difficult words. In c. XVIII 42 the editor of B expands a short section which in A merely closes the account of the thirty-six decani into an entirely new narrative of Solomon's treatment of demons in general. On the other hand, in the latter part of the Test, where H alone represents Rec. A, there are a number of sections in which the text of H is so brief as to be almost unintelligible, and, as it seems to me, shows evidence of hasty abbreviation. In these sections I have given B the preference, as also in the conclusion (c. XXVI 7—8), where H has an expanded text.
3. The evolution of the Testament: summary of conclusions. — A number of stories about Solomon in which demons played a large part were gathered into a tale, d, a revision of which lies before us in MS D. Some one who was interested in the magical cure of diseases then conceived the idea of the Test, and decapitated the story of d, leaving it to begin abruptly as in Rec. B with the tale of a demon who plagued the King's favorite workman during the temple building. The editor added a more fitting conclusion in the story of Solomon's fall as found in Rec. B. The original Test, then, consisted of the beginning and ending as in Rec. B (MSS PQ), but with the body of the work mainly as in Rec. A (MSS HIL). The present beginning of Rec. A resulted from an attempt to remove the abruptness of the first sentence, being constructed by piecing together from later sections items regarding the favorite workman. This redacteur also thought himself able to construct a conclusion with greater parenetic value. Rec. B is another independent working over of the original Test, with certain interesting additions. Whereas redacteur A was mainly concerned with making the story read better, redacteur B was in possession of fuller knowledge regarding many of the demons mentioned, and accordingly added to or replaced several sections. Finally a student of demonological literature with a theological and scientific bent discovered some fragments which he thought Solomonic and which appeared to him to have greater value than a good part of the Test. So taking Rec. B he constructed another Test, putting in a preface, or prologue, containing certain prayers of Solomon, removing the abruptness of the beginning much as redacteur A did, and replacing the latter two-thirds of the Test by his new material. In the story of Onoskelu (Rec. C XI) he
3\* presents a variant form of a tale which he allows to remain in the earlier, unaltered part under the name of Onoskelis (c. IV). He seeks to give authority to his version by representing that it was feared and secretly preserved at the request of a great demon, Paltiel Tzamal, who wished to prevent the publication of its great mysteries, and that the well known, current form of the Test had been specially written for Hezekiah, thus utilizing an early tradition. MS L represents an interesting step in another direction, the attempt to make the work of greater practical value as a physician's vade mecum, or book of prescriptions. Its reading with the proper rites would cure the possessed. 4. The textual value of the MSS and their use in reconstructing the text. — Although MS D represents the original story from which the Test was evolved, it possesses no primary textual value, since it is not the Test, and, though its contents are similar, its text is rarely that of the Test. The attempt here is to reconstruct the original Test out of which Recs. A and B have grown. MS D is printed separately at the end of the volume.
Our MSS of Rec. C come from a class of men of rather low mentality and poor Greek education. The numerous omissions are textually of little moment, because the redacteur was interested in different matters from the originator of the Test, and the scribes were careless. Since, as we have already shown above (IV 2 c, d), C is derived from B, their agreement can have little weight per se against acceptable readings found in A alone. Where, however, Recs. A and C agree, they represent the original text. Without C it would have been much more difficult to show that B was secondary. While neither V nor W could have been copied the one from the other, they may have come from the same exemplar. Where it was unintelligible or corrupt, Rec. B represents a learned, and in MS P a very careful, revision. Occasionally P alone preserves the true text owing to the greater intelligence with which it has been handled. Yet it must be used with great caution, since both redacteur B and scribe P have taken great liberties with the text in making additions, alterations, and omissions. Q shows more errors than P, but fewer intentional changes.
The MSS of Rec. A have been rather mechanically copied. In some instances the scribes have not taken the liberty to drop or emend what they could not understand, but have reproduced it letter for letter. There are omissions due to carelessness, one so long as probably to have been caused by a missed or missing leaf in the exemplar. In general H appears to have suffered least from intentional revision, but to have been in less skilful hands than I. Both were conscientiously copied by scribes who knew little of magic. Therefore the better instructed L occasionally presents a preferable reading, although he was somewhat careless and illiterate and his practical directions often vitiate his text. In c. I I have followed MS I, since it alone preserves the first person, which the original Test ought to have shown throughout, and also since it appears to me, following occurs, where other MSS make it possible to determine the true text; e. g., IV 5 (), II 9, IV 12. W omits by homoeoteleuton, IV 12, of intention, II 9, VIII 9, where the passage seemed unintelligible. Therefore V could not have copied from W. But I do not believe W could have made out the true text from V's unwarranted expansion in II 6 ( . . . ), nor is he likely to have omitted the right words in IX 9.
V. Language and Style
a suggestion of Dr. Goodspeed, that H exhibits an attempt to make clearer the somewhat unusual language of I regarding the favorite slave. Here, however, as in the concluding sections, Rec. A shows signs of undue expansion, and in constructing the text of the Test, which always appears at the top of the page, I have followed Rec. B. Again, in certain sections toward the end, I have thought that Rec. A gave evidence of abridgment, and in these places, especially since the carelessly written H is here the only MS of Rec. A, I have given Rec. B the preference. In general, then, unless weighty reasons appeared to the contrary, H has been made the basis of this edition. The rule adopted has been, 'When in doubt, follow H.' In concluding this section it should be noted that we cannot claim to have the original Test in our reconstructed text. Such an admission would be called for on a priori grounds alone. But we have evidence on the subject, for, in the quotation from the Test which occurs in the Dialogue of Timothy and Aquila, the Jew insists that Solomon , while in the Test as we now have it, although the Shunamite says (MS H) or (MSS PQ), Solomon merely says (MS H) or . If we could find the original MS, many such differences would appear, but not enough to vitiate our general conclusions regarding the work.
V. Language and Style.This section will be made quite brief, as the grammatical index will supplement it by presenting the evidence for the positions taken. 1. MS D. — As to language and style there are decided differences between the recensions. In this regard, as well as from the diplomatic standpoint, MS D is far superior to the rest. An educated Greek has edited and written it. The outstanding inaccuracy in his grammar is the use of the nominative absolute, or rather nominativus pendens, not a serious blunder, which occurs a few times. Once is used with and the infinitive. Otherwise tenses and cases are on the whole correctly used. The optative, subjunctive, imperative in both second and third person, and a future participle of purpose are found. Late forms and usages are rare. For the dative with the accusative is frequent. In IV 9 is a (Homeric and) late usage, subjunctive for future, which has contributed to such a future as in VI 2. replaces in IV 11.
As to style, the constant use of the historical present and the occasional omission of or after the name of the speaker in dialogue lends vivacity, while the conversations are short and to the point. The writer has a fairly large vocabulary, including a considerable number of particles. There is a heaping up of epithets and synonymous words when opportunity offers. Specially noteworthy is the constant use of the circumstantial participle in various relations. The author is fond of dropping in a verb to separate the article and attributives from their noun. The use of = "Majesty," and = "Excellency" in direct address is Byzantine. 2. Rec. C. — This, the latest recension, is at the antipodes from MS D. How far its present condition is due to scribal carelessness and ignorance we cannot say, but probably they are partly accountable for its very poor Greek. Errors, such as the accusative for the dative, and late forms, such as - as ending of the accusative singular in the third declension with an analogous nominative, e. g., , abound, and there are several Latinisms. The first sentence is an unattachable genitive absolute. The editor was fond of compound tenses. As to style
the additions show somewhat ambitious attempts at fine writing, e. g., in the prayers of the Prologue and in the closing chapter. The same trick appears as in D, of dropping the verb in between attributives and their nouns. 3. Rec. B. — Rec. B is more correct as to grammar and simpler as to style than Rec. C. Between A and B there is little difference, but in its additions B, especially MS P, shows a tendency to more "correct" usage, but also to compound words, and in one instance it has a decided Latinism, . 4. Rec. A and the original Testament. — The editorial additions to Rec. A have some glaring errors, particularly in MS L, but, if we may judge from this recension, the Test was originally a very simple piece of writing in fairly correct Koinè Greek. It paid no attention to refinements of rhetoric or lexicography, but told its story in a straightforward, paratactic style, such as one might expect from a man of small education and mental ability in recounting an interesting series of stories. On the whole the grammar is that of the New Testament, with developments along the lines taken by the Koinè such as would seem to point to a period subsequent to the New Testament. The disappearance of the optative, the aorist subjunctive for the future, the increase in the use of prepositions and compound words, and the numerous locutions which are characterized by the Atticists as vulgar constitute the evidence on this point. Real Semitisms do not appear in the Test. That the construction may be called such I cannot believe. Another so-called Semitism, the demonstrative repeating the relative, occurs, but it is a mere blunder due to an attempt to repair a garbled passage.
5. Letter of Adarkes to Solomon. — The letter of the Arabian King in c. XXII contains two peculiarities, the absence of the name of the sender from the introductory formula and in MS D the use of direct address, , . Unfortunately the two treatises which have appeared on the subject of Greek letter formulae do not carry the subject far enough into the Byzantine period to aid us here, and the extant letters have too often been handed down without the introductory formula. So far as the evidence goes, the use of variations of the customary formula, , does not mark any particular era. The use of with the vocative seems a sign either of servility or of poor breeding, for three of the instances known to me from the papyri are from people of little culture, while the ancients particularly reprobated the use of the first person and direct address. Perhaps the editor of D thought such familiarity entirely legitimate between kings, or wished to represent the Arabian king as inferior to Solomon.
To account for the absence of the senders's name three theories are possible: either has fallen out by haplography, or the MS D form was original and the present text of A and B is a correction to the third person, or the writer has used the form which was customary in copies of letters. Other evidence for the secondary character of the present text of D seems too strong to allow the second alternative. For the first speaks the fact that the MSS differ decidedly as to the lines immediately preceding the letter. More decisive, however, seems the consideration that such a writer could hardly be expected to be precise as to letter formulae, particularly as the identity of the sender is plainly indicated in the text. Unfortunately in any case we reach the negative conclusion that the peculiarities of the letter formulae give no aid in determining the date of the recensions.
VI. The Chief Ideas of the Testament
6. Is the Testament a translation? — Dr. M. Gaster argues that the Test is translated from Hebrew. Such a view is naturally suggested by the large number of Hebrew names of angels and demons, to say nothing of the fact that Solomon, the great Jewish wise man, is the hero of the story. Dr. Gaster finds evidence of translation in the expression , , . . . . He believes that we have here a misunderstanding of the word Shem-ha-meforash, perush having been taken to mean "interpretation." Aside from the precariousness of argument from a single case such as this, the decisive fact is that this expression is an editorial addition found only in MS P. HL present a shorter and simpler text, (). There is no reason why HL should have omitted the phrases of P if they had stood in the original Test, for they are perfectly intelligible, with only an element of mystery in the word such as this sort of literature loves. The editor of Rec. B contributed this out of his fund of magical knowledge.
As it seems to me, the strongest evidence for translation from a Semitic original is to be found in Rec. A in the list of decani, the thirty-six , where all from the twentieth on call themselves (H, XVIII 24—40), or (L, XVIII 24—28). This word surely is a transliteration of רִיחַ. But even such a transliteration does not prove that the whole Test was originally written in Hebrew or Aramaic. This particular section, which is plainly of Egyptian origin, has been partially revised by a Jew before it was taken over into the Test. Another possible piece of evidence is to be found in the clause . Ouriel is not the "power of God," as in Recs. B and C, but the "light of God." It might be thought that originally בְּרִיאֵל stood in the text and was translated by some one who failed to recognize it as a proper noun. The copyists, feeling the need of some name, have made various "corrections." Such a supposi-
tion would be entirely probable if the language of the Test elsewhere gave evidence of translation. It is more likely the passage was written by one who knew no Hebrew. 7. Tentative conclusion. — It seems much more natural to explain all apparent indications of Semitic origin as due to the fact that the writer of the Test has used materials already translated from languages unfamiliar to him. Did the heathen compiler of the great Paris magic papyrus translate the biblical material he used? Did the writers of the Synoptic Gospels translate their sources from Aramaic? No one so alleges. Our tentative conclusion, then, at this stage of the investigation, must be that the native language of the writer of the Test was Greek. So far a study of the language of the work has taken us. For a more precise answer as to its origin we must analyze its chief ideas and their sources.
Vi. the Chief Ideas of the Testament.The Test is a collection of astrological, demonological, and magical lore, brought together without any attempt at consistency. The writer attempts no science or philosophy of demonology; indeed he is a compiler rather than an author. 1. Demonology. No general statement is made as to the origin of demons, and the data given in particular cases disagree. Some are fallen angels, others are the offspring of angels and the daughters of men. One is the spirit of a murdered giant, one is perhaps born of a bath qol. They dwell in deserts, tombs, precipices, caves, chasms, and at cross roads. As to their nature certain intimations are given. Most of them are embodied spirits. Of one this is distinctly stated, while a number are minutely described, generally as griffins combined of animals and birds, or of animals and man. One is a wind merely, but when put into a sack he acts like a man. They can, within limits, assume different forms. They are an-
thropomorphically conceived. Onoskelis quails before a threatened beating, Asmodaeus is bound and beaten, Kunopegos almost faints from thirst, Akephalos Daemon sees through his breasts and is blinded when the seal is pressed upon him. Some are female, and the writer probably thought it possible for both males and females to have offspring. They have all the physical as well as psychical passions of mankind. Though they thus resemble human beings so closely, they have a certain likeness also to the angels. They escape many of the physical limitations of men, in that they may assume various forms and are supernaturally crafty and powerful. They know the future, and several of them tell Solomon of coming events. How this is possible is explained by Ornias, who relates that the demons fly up to the gates of heaven and overhear the decisions announced to the great concourse of angels there; then, coming down, they make use of their knowledge to injure mankind. However, this foreknowledge is gained at great risk, for, having no place to light at the gate of heaven, they become weary and fall, and these falling demons are what men call shooting stars.
No systematized demonic hierarchy is known. Beelzebul, as chief of the whole tribe of demons, is summoned to assist Solomon in dealing with them. He has a vicegerent, named Abezethibou, like himself a fallen angel, who is the great spirit of rebellion against God and the good. Beelzebul apparently now rules upon earth and Abezethibou in Tartarus, though the latter is "nourished in the Red Sea," where he was confined on the overthrow of Pharaoh and his host. He is haled before Solomon by Ephippas, not by Beelzebul, and may, therefore, be thought of as independent of the latter. Beelzebul is plainly identified with the of the Gospels, for he trembles before "Emmanuel of the Hellenists". But he is not "Lucifer, star of the morning"; his star is . Except in C. III, where he is first summoned, and in C. VI, where he is examined, Beelzebul is a figurehead. Only Kunopegos, a sort of Poseidon, mentions the fact that he, with all the demons, is subject to Beelzebul's direction, and at intervals comes to land to consult him; it was on one of these trips that Beelzebul arrested him and brought him before Solomon.
Many interesting demonic figures appear, such as Ornias, Asmodaeus, Lix Tetrax, Pterodrakon, the dog Rhabdos, the three headed dragon called , Leontophoron the demon of Gadara, three liliths, or Empusas, called Onoskelis, Enepsigos, and Obyzuth, seven stars that are , and other thirty-six with the same high sounding title who are the decani. Limitation of space forbids their further discussion here. They cause all kinds of diseases and bodily defects, from seasickness to epilepsy, being particularly dangerous to women in childbirth and to infants. They destroy fields, flocks, houses, ships, and human lives, and will finally bring the end of the world. The thirty-six decani are entirely of this sort. Demons are sources also of moral evil, inspiring heresies, idolatry, lust, theft, envy, hatred, murder, war, and kinred evils. The seven spirits who call themselves are of this kind. So far as the writer of the Test has thought the matter out, evil does not reside in the flesh, nor in matter, nor can it be ascribed to God; sins are the result of demonic incitement. How or when the angels came to sin we are not told. In any case there is no real dualism in the Test. Though Beelzebul rules "the spiritual hosts of wickedness," they and he are completely subject to God and to the divinely ordained means for their subjugation. Mention is made of demons in Tartarus, but no punishment for them seems to be known ex-
cept that which Solomon and the magic revealed in the Test can inflict. 2. Astrology. — A large proportion of the demons in the Test have some definite astrological relationship. Demons and men are said to reside in a star, or a sign of the zodiac, or a phase of the moon, and mortals seem to be particularly liable to injury from demons who are with them, that is belong to the same star. The author seems to think of the influence of the stars as wholly baleful. Asmodaeus says, "through the stars I [scatter] madness after women", and that suggests the prevailing notion. There is, I believe, no reference to prediction by means of astrology. One chapter (XVIII), a list of the thirty-six decani, is a piece of astrological material taken over bodily. In this case each is thought of as a demon causing certain diseases, which are recorded, and the means for counteracting them are detailed. Here the astrological entity does not belong to the demon, or the demon to it, but is the demon. On the other hand one may doubt whether the stars are thought of as living beings, for in XX 17 it is said, "the stars are founded in the firmament" so that they cannot fall. It would seem that astrological influences are operative, not of themselves, but through the demons that "dwell" in each star or sign. In other words, the astral deities of paganism have become demons. It is interesting to note also that the pillar of cloud of the ancient Israelites is transferred to the heavens, for, as Dr. James has pointed out, the pillar suspended in air is the Milky Way.
3. Angelology. — The angelology of the Test is entirely undeveloped. Aside from Michael and Raphael no angels appear as actual actors. Numerous angel names, including many that are familiar and many not elsewhere discovered, are scattered through the book, but they are charms rather than designations of real beings. They are given solely for their apotropaic value. Considering the fact, however, that the two great archangels do actually appear, it is likely that the author believed in the actual existence of great numbers of angels, just as he did of demons, and thought that each appeared, when his name was called, to subdue the demon subject to him. Aside from the use of the word there is no allusion to an angelic hierarchy. 4. Magic and Medicine. — The prime interest of the writer of the Test was medical. For him demons were what bacilli are to the modern physician, and his magical recipes and angel names are his pharmacopoeia. The one case where he embarks upon a piece of magical mysticism only serves to emphasize this fact. For when, at Solomon's request that he speak , Beelzebul tells him the recipe whereby he may see the heavenly dragons circling 'round and hauling the chariot of the sun, he is at once rebuked and silenced. Evidently this was forbidden magic, although it might well be true. There is likewise a story of obtaining wealth through a demon, but such suggestions bear fruit only for the beautifying of the temple. Such use of demons is evidently dangerous.
As in his demonology, so also in his magic the author combined various and inconsistent views. He has full confidence in the power of the magic name, which, in most cases, is an angel name. To subjugate Onoskelis Solomon "spoke the name of the Holy One of Israel". Men are led astray, says Asmodaeus, "because they do not know the names of the angels which are ordained over us". In the original Test Ephesia grammata are infrequent, except in the list of the thirty-six decani. Here there appear some well known angel names, a few that are possibly real names, but not a few in the best manner of the magic papyri and "Gnostic" amulets. Since these voces mysticae are less numerous in the former part of the section, it would appear that a Jewish editor had undertaken the task of removing the heathen elements, but had become weary before he was done.
Likewise there appear the well-known apotropaic materials, such as iron, lead, wood from a wrecked ship, spittle, certain organs of animals, and kinds of plants, and the common magical devices, such as the use of the cause to cure the ill, i. e., the name of the demon to drive the demon away or a fishbone to cure a person who has swallowed one, the drinking of potions or sprinkling them about, and the writing of amulets or hanging them in the house. Surely these methods of aversion are fundamentally inconsistent with monotheism and with the view that the angels are appointed to frustrate the demons. The ring of Solomon differs only in that it was probably thought to contain the ineffable name. 5. Solomon. — Few figures have bulked larger in the folklore of Jews, Mohammedans, and Christians than Solomon. In the Test he is already the wise man and magician par excellence, the favorite of God, endowed by him with divine , which includes insight into the crafty wiles of his demonic captives. He uses the demons for one purpose only, to assist in building and beautifying the great Temple at Jerusalem, this labor being the usual form of punishment adopted for them. Solomon's glory, the visit and gifts of the Queen of Sheba, and the gifts of other kings are described in some detail; but all this is only temporary, for the wise king, deceived by Eros, held by the bonds of Artemis as the demons prophesied, is eventually led
by the Shunamite to sacrifice locusts to the gods of the Jebusites, and thus loses all his power. How soon he dies is not indicated, but at his death, convinced by the fulfilment of their prophecies that all the demons had said was true, he writes the Test and leaves it to the Children of Israel. The chief part of Solomon's magical equipment is his ring, which is given to him by Michael at God's command in answer to the king's prayer. Either in his own hand, or that of his best beloved servant, or even the demon Ornias it at once subdues every demon. The editors have removed the original statement as to the inscription, if there was one. What became of the ring after Solomon's fall is not stated. Several features of the Solomonic legend receive their first known literary expression in the Test. To quote Salzberger, "Immerhin wird es hier zum ersten Male ausgesprochen, daß Sal. Geister beim Tempelbau verwendet habe und daß er, durch die Liebe zu einer Jebusiterin in heidnischen Kult verstrickt, der Macht über die Geister verlustig gegangen und ihnen zum Gespött geworden sei. Zu beachten ist auch, daß die Königin des Südens" bereits als eine Zauberin () auftritt".
6. Apocalyptic element. — The apocalyptic element in the Test is very slight. Certain prophecies by the demons and their speedy and exact fulfilment are related in order to prove the trustworthiness of the demons' revelations in general, and, in particular, of their statements regarding their own activities and the means for their frustration. In some cases these prophecies extend far beyond Solomon's time, particularly in certain references to Christ as one who will subdue individual demons. The only section which may be called measurably apocalyptic UNT. 9: McCown. in tone is found in that part of the Test which is preserved only in MS P, and, therefore, while there is no doubt that the original Test had a prophecy in this place, it seems very likely that it resembled the one in V 5, and contained at least no such detailed reference to Christ as is now there found.
Did the writer of the Test, then, know nothing of the apocalyptic hopes of Judaism and Christianity? At best these hopes had little meaning for him. He makes no reference to that element in Apocalyptic for which we would most naturally look, the expectation of the final overthrow and eternal binding of Beelzebul and his hosts. Aside from a single mention of the , the writer has his eyes on his muckrake and sees no happier future for the world than in the continued use of his wretched recipes. 7. Jesus Christ. — One of the outstanding inconsistencies of the Test is its introduction of Christ as the "angel" who subdues certain demons. Whether these passages are Christian interpolations in a Jewish document will be discussed later. We are now concerned with the religious standpoint of the writer who gave the Test its present form. It is probable that VI 8 contains a reference to Christ. Certainly Rec B so understood it, and the phrase is natural from the pen of a Christian who was without knowledge of Hebrew, but familiar with the use of the term Immanuel in Christian circles, as in XI 6. Yet the text is so corrupt and the MSS agree so little that the meaning cannot be certainly made out. The garbled allusion to the "place of a skull" and "the wood" in XII 3 is so unintelligible as to afford no light on the author's views, but is plainly of Christian origin.
Unmistakable is the reference in c. XI to the incident of the Gadarene demoniac who had a legion of devils. But what is the meaning of ,
VII. The Sources and Relationships of the Subject Matter
in section 6? P probably understood it to refer to ' (= 644), the numerical value of , already introduced in VI 8 and XI 6. Can the three characters mean the trinity? In XVII 4 is mentioned . may be a reminiscence of Apoc XXII 4, . The sign is the cross, as the next line shows, not a number as Conybeare concluded from P's frequent introduction of '. Another distinctively Christian passage is much milder in the A form than in Rec B, which, as Conybeare points out, is distinctively patri-passian in character. Rec A mentions the virgin birth, an adoration by angels, and the crucifixion. The allusions to the permanent immaculacy of the Virgin and to the victory of Christ over Satan in the Temptation in XV 10f. cannot be used to define the position of the originator of the Test. Dr. Conybeare's characterization of the Christianity of the Test as "equivocal" is far more true of the original than it was of Rec B, which he had before him. The nature of the writer's faith can be better understood after an investigation of the sources and relationships of his subject matter, to which we now turn.
Vii. the Sources and Relationships of the Subject Matter.1. Syncretism of the Testament. — To set forth what the present writer has collected for the purpose of interpreting the Test and determining its sources and relationships would require a large volume. Yet what has been gathered has only touched the fringe of that great body of material bearing on magic, demonology, astrology, and kindred superstitions which has recently appeared, much of it since this work was first under- 4\* 52 The universal human element. Assyrian and Babylonian influence. taken. The purpose is to introduce here only what is absolutely germane to the subject of the section. One point is clear beyond cavil: Like other magic the Test is thoroughly eclectic. It borrows and combines elements, often contradictory, from all the nations that contributed to the civilization about the eastern Mediterranean, without any apparent consciousness of their sources. The whole course of the succeeding discussion will offer illustrations of this patent fact.
2. The universal human element. — In one direction caution is necessary, perhaps especially in the realm of comparative magical and mythological study. Similarities are not always an evidence of borrowing. Take an example from the story of Lix Tetrax. As the demon in the form of a sand storm whirl-wind approaches Solomon, he lays it by spitting on the ground. In a modern Bengali charm for a whirl-wind exactly the same means is used to stay the demon. Did the Test borrow from India or the Bengali from the Test? Manifestly neither. Spitting is almost universally apotropaic. And what is more natural than that spittle should magically lay a dust storm. So in many instances from widely separated localities the human mind under similar circumstances has reached similar conclusions. With this caution in mind we can proceed to notice the instances of real borrowing. 3. Assyrian and Babylonian influence. — The great civilization on the Euphrates deeply affected Hellenistic, Jewish, and Christian demonological and magical beliefs. Babylonia is one of the few countries in which theology and demonology, religion and "her bastard daughter, magic," seem from the first to have gone hand in hand. There are no indications that the official cultus ever regarded magic as alien. Rather, the exorcism of
countless demons seems to have been one of the regular duties of the priesthood, and, to judge from the relative proportion of magical texts among those that have been preserved, one of the most important duties. Nowhere do we find a ranker growth of demonological beliefs than in Babylonia. Every possible ill or accident that could happen, "a toothache, a headache, a broken bone, a raging fever, an outburst of anger, of jealousy, of incomprehensible disease", all were ascribed to demonic agency, and were to be averted or cured by means of incantations. This is precisely the atmosphere of the Test. But it is also that of Hellenistic superstition, and such a general similarity of tone proves no direct relationship between the Test and the Euphrates valley. Can we find more definite evidence of dependence? A peculiar resemblance appears between one class of Babylonian demons and a figure in the Test: the ašakku marsu and Ephippas, the wind demon of Arabia. Since the similarity is somewhat vague, I call attention to it with some hesitation. Ephippas is an early morning blast of wind that kills man and beast, or, according to MS D, "uproots houses and trees and hills, and destroys men". The ašakku marsu is "der Dämon der auszehrenden Krankheit" according to Jastrow, but Sayce and Thompson render the word "fever." The following from Thompson's translation of the Ašakku series shows interesting similarities with Ephippas' activities:
... the evil Fiend, The evil Spirit which in the street creates a storm wind . . . Girt with dread brilliance it filleth the broad earth, Enveloped in terror it casteth fear abroad; It roameth through the street, it is let loose in the road . . . An evil ghost(?) hath assailed the land, And perturbed the people of the land above and below: A pestilence, a plague that giveth the land no rest, The great Demon, Spirit, and Fiend, which roameth the broad places for men, The angry, quaking storm [which if one] seeth Fever (ašakku) hath blown upon a man as the wind-blast. That this is the closest parallel between the Test and Assyro-Babylonian demonology is significant. Granting that Babylonian, or, at least, Semitic superstition may have contributed to the figure of Ephippas, we still can assert only that the Test rests ultimately upon that great mass of Sumerian-Semitic beliefs of which we have the earliest and fullest illustrations from the Babylonian tablets, but not that it has borrowed directly.
4. Iranian influence. — To Mazdaism is to be ascribed the questionable honor, not of introducing demonology and angelology into Judaism, but of decidedly directing its development. The Test has not been so deeply affected as has the New Testament Apocalypse, for example, in its war between Michael and the Dragon, nor even as Paul; for there is no dualism in our text. Its writer knows Beelzebul only as "ruler of the demons". He has no doubt that God can empower Solomon or any one who knows the angelic names to frustrate and bind any and all demons. The archangels, though their names appear, never are grouped together as seven, and the one group of seven demons has no Parsi coloring. Yet one cannot read the Persian sacred writings without being struck by the Test. And, furthermore, the Test has adopted one Mazdian demon, Aëšma daëva, or Asmodaeus, very much in his Magian character. Plainly the demon of the Test is the same as that of Tobit, but the writer did not have Tobit before him or he would not have used the heart and gall, instead of the heart and liver, of the fish as his . His additional details, such as the name of the fish, , show that, while he may have had the story of Tobit in his mind, he was drawing upon the developing Jewish folklore which had its fount in the original source and eventuated in the Talmudic Asmodaeus.
In another direction we naturally look for Persian influence to manifest itself, namely on the Solomonic legend. The Mohammedans identified Solomon with Yima, the Jamshid of Firdausi, because he had taken over so many traits of the Persian hero, particularly his renown as a builder. The Talmudic story of Solomon combines elements from the legends of Takhma Urupa, who made Ahriman his horse until his wife betrayed him, of Yima, the prosperous king and great builder, who, like Takhma Urupa, "ruled over the Daëvas and men, the Yātus and Pairikas," but sinned and fell before the usurping Azhi Dahāka, and of Thraëtaona, the first healer, the inventor of magic, the fiend-smiter. In the Test, however, we catch the story midway in its development. There has arisen, as yet, no demonic being to depose the king, and the Test lacks, therefore, the most characteristic detail which the Talmud borrowed from Persia.
The evidence, then, justifies the conclusion that Persian influences are at work upon the folklore from which the Test drew its inspiration, and have affected our text in part directly, in part through Tobit and, no doubt, other Apocrypha. Yet the Test cannot come from circles where, as in Babylon, for example, Magian influence was dominant. 5. Egyptian elements. — Egypt is pre-eminently the land of magic, but not of demonology. Her "Book of the Dead" almost from its inception had the purpose of magically insuring the happiness of the dead in the hereafter; and the ancient inhabitants of the Nile valley were so much concerned with the future life that their magical texts gave little attention to avert- ing ill from the living. Yet enough has been preserved to show that the fear of evil spirits, especially the ghosts of the dead, was abroad here as in Babylonia and Persia, even thought the official texts reflect but little of it. Egyptian demonology is so lacking in definite color and in general so much like that of Babylonia and Greece that one can hardly hope to show from this side any distinctive Egyptian traits in the Test. In the times when the Test was written it was of the variegated mixture that we call Hellenistic.
When we turn to astrology, however, the case is different, for one of the longest sections in the Test, that having to do with the thirty-six decani, is distinctly Egyptian. It has been generally accepted since Letronne that astrology is not, as the ancients supposed, of Egyptian origin, but rather that Babylonia was its native land. As Boll, however, has shown, having been adopted by the Egyptian priesthood and actively practised by them, it came to be so thoroughly at home and so mixed with Egyptian elements as to be really native, "in ihrer Eigenart autochthon, wenn auch in allem rein ägyptischen Inhalt von sehr spätem Ursprung". Particularly is this true of the decani. They were originally, not Babylonian, but Egyptian divisions of the equator, which were given an astrological significance. "Nur diese (the Egyptian astrology) hat die 36 Dekane personifiziert: alle andere Dekandarstellungen in Indien oder bei den Arabern gehen darauf in letzter Linie zurück," says Boll. This sentence is especially noteworthy for our purpose, for the Test has fully personified the decani.
Various lists of decani have come down to us. With these the names in the Test do not at all agree, but seem rather for the most part to be Hebrew, or, perhaps, mock Hebrew. Yet the Test's account of the activities of these siderial spirits is not original invention, for, at the beginning, the two chief lists, one given by Pitra from a Moscow and a Vienna MS, and one given by Kroll from another Vienna MS, agree with the Test in certain essential particulars. The names in Vind. 108 and its fellow, Par. 2419, do not correspond with any other list, just as those of the Test do not. The peculiarity of the names in the last, therefore, need not trouble us. That the activities ascribed to the several decans should not agree in all the lists is not strange, in view of the confusion in the Egyptian lists. While there is much closer resemblance between Pitra's and Kroll's documents than between either of them and the Test, still they differ in many important particulars. They all agree on the fundamental proposition, which Celsus described as an Egyptian belief, that the decans rule diseases, each of a certain part of the body. In the case of the first decan all three agree that it is the head, although the Test adds , which M-V puts under the second. Vind. 108 has under the second decan, while the Test has it under the third. Under the third both M-V and Vind. 108 have among other things toothache. All three agree that the fourth decan rules diseases of the throat. From this point on there are still fewer similarities between the three accounts, yet these we have indi-
cated are more than fortuitous. They evidently rest upon a common tradition. But M-V has for the first few names the Hellenistic transliteration of the old Egyptian names, and therefore serves to connect this common tradition with Egypt. We are safe, then, in concluding that this chapter of the Test comes from Egyptian sources, presenting probably a Jewish revision of a list of decani. The editor has made it more nearly monotheistic than the other accounts mentioned above, in regarding the decans as demons who cause disease, rather than deities who "rule" () or cure (lāra) the parts affected. Yet he has failed to purge out all the heathen elements, such as the amulets and voces mysticae. Other evidence of Egyptian influence I am unable to find. 6. Jewish elements and relationships. — a) That Judaism is one main source of the Test is apparent on every page. The background, the plot, and the principal characters are Jewish. Solomon, wise man, builder, and glorious king, the Queen of Sheba, and the Shunamite girl are all familiar Old Testament figures, though sometimes presented here in strange connections. In pre-Christian times Solomon was already on the way to become a magician, both in the canonical books and in the Apocrypha. Josephus shows this conception of the king gradually developing, his exorcisms and the remedial or magical plants he had recommended being already in practical use by Jewish magicians. His ring, his power over demons, and his use of them on the Temple become commonplaces of Jewish legendary lore. His glory and his fall are put in telling contrast by the editors of the Old Testament as they are by the Test.
b) The angelology and demonology of the Test are practically those of the Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha. Our text contains the view, based upon Gen VI 1—4 and found in Ethiopic Enoch VI—VII, XV—XVI and Jubilees VII 21ff., X 5, that the angels who fell and their offspring became demons; but much of it seems rather to follow the belief found in the Similitudes (I En XXXVII—L XXI; cf. Charles, Enoch p. 107) that demons have existed since the creation. The Pseudo-Philonic Jewish work de antiquitatibus biblicis, dating from the latter part of the first century A. D., in its citharismus regis David contra daemonium Saulis, unites this view with another found in the Test as to the origin of certain demons. According to a badly tangled passage Onoskelis is born of an echo. In the Citharismus David addresses the demon thus: Et factum est tunc nomen in compaginatione extensionis quod appellatum est superius caelum . . . (There follows a reference to the creation of the earth but not of animals and man.) Et post haec facta est tribus spirituum vestrorum. Et nunc molesta esse noli, tanquam secunda creatura; si quominus, memorare Tartari in quo ambulas. Aut non audire . . . . Aut immemores quoniam de resultatione in chaomate nata est vestra creatura.
Less apposite is a parallel Dr. James notes from Dieterich, Abraxas, p. 17, . In spite of great differences in detail the general manner in which each demon's work is described in I En LXIX 1—12 may well have contributed to the demon portraits in the Test. The section on the seven (c. VII) is based upon exactly the same conceptions of evil and of demons as the list of seven vices in Test. Reuben III 3—6; yet the lists do not agree except that the third in each has to do with , apparently a mere coincidence. Jub X 7—9, which tells how God commanded the angels to imprison nine tenths of the evil spirits in "the place of condemnation", and left one tenth free under command of Mastema, explains the statement of Beelzebul in Test VI 3 that his second in command rules his race in Tartarus. Not only its demonology in general but certain particular figures of our text are well known in Jewish mind. Tobit has made Asmodaeus at home in the Jewish folklore. The lilith also came to belong to Judaism as it did to other nations.
Judaism, however, gave more attention to angels than to demons. While here the Test differs in emphasis, the view point is the same. Among the Jews as in our text exorcism was one of the chief means of healing, so much so that in antiquity the Jew became almost as famous for magical arts as the Chaldean. "The Graeco-Roman world regarded the Jews as a race of magicians". Angel names, of which so many occur in the Pseudepigrapha, were often used in incantations. The Jews were fully persuaded of the power of the "name", and they also thought of the angels as specially commissioned to protect the righteous from the machinations of demons. There are thus many similarities between the Test and Jewish folklore and superstition of the beginning of the Christian era. But that our document is dependent in a literary way upon the Apocrypha or Pseudepigrapha does not at all appear. I have discovered but two quotations from Jewish literature, one the passage touching the corner stone, the other the phrase , taken from the Wisdom of Solomon, and a possible allusion to the same book. In the passages describing Solomon's glory and the Temple, where one would expect quotation, there is only a free development of the biblical accounts. One might mention elements of Jewish thinking which are absent from the Test, such as the coming of the Messiah to destroy all the demons. We must, then,
conclude that, while the writer of our document operated with much the same beliefs as the Apocryphal and Pseudepigraphic writers, he is not in a literary way dependent upon any Jewish literature. On the other hand so many traits connect him with the rabbinical writings that we must suppose him to live during or after the first century of the Christian era.
c) Turning to the Talmud we find parallels to many of our stories. The account of Benaiah's capture of Asmodaeus by the use of a magic ring and chain, a bundle of wool, and a skin of wine reminds one of the slave's capture of Ornias (I 10—14) and again of Ephippas (XXII 9—16), for the ring is used in both cases. It is pressed upon Ornias and seals Ephippas in his sack, while in the rabbinic legend Benaiah cries to Asmodaeus, "The name of the Lord is upon thee." Ephippas is caught in the sack instead of by drinking wine from it. Asmodaeus shows a knowledge of the future and laughs at men's foolish plans, just as Ornias does. The idea that the demons know the future is found elsewhere in the Talmud. In Hagiga 16a the collocation of ideas is much the same as in the Test. "The rabbans taught: The demons possess six characteristics, three like the ministering angels, and three like the sons of men. Three like the ministering angels: they have wings like the ministering angels and they fly from one end of the world to the other like the ministering angels and they know what is determined for the future (מה שעתיד להיות) like the ministering angels. They know! Do you come to that opinion? Rather they hear it from behind the curtain like the ministering angels. Three like the sons of men: they eat and drink like the sons of men, they propagate themselves like the sons of men, and they die like the sons of men". The Aboth of R. Nathan
adds: "Many say: They change their appearance according to every form as they wish, and they see and are not seen'. This passage is instructive in that it describes the demonology of the Test and reduces it to a system which apparently our writer was not able to construct. d) While, however, there are many resemblances between Jewish angelology, demonology, magic, and mythology and the Test, it must not forthwith be taken as proved that it is a Jewish work. It certainly was not a product of rabbinic Judaism such as is seen in the Babylonian Talmud, and later Jewish speculation. Samael appears only in MS D, the angel of death, Malak ha-Moweth, of the Zohar and Qelippoth not at all. Asmodaeus is an entirely different character, his place being taken by Ornias and the New Testament Beelzebul. The mists of Jewish tradition come to surround Solomon with a halo which only begins to appear in the Test. Among the many later traits not found in our document, one which might easily have been used is the statement in Targum Sheni Esther that "Solomon ruled over the wild beasts, over the birds of heaven, and over the creeping beasts of the earth, as well as over the devils, the spirits of the night; and he understood the language of all these according as it is written, 'and he talked with the trees,'" instead of 'of the trees,' I Kg IV 33.
One of the most decisive illustrations of the difference between the Test and later Judaism is the account of the fall of Solomon. The subject was one which the Jewish theologians in the early Christian centuries discussed with some heat. The Test in its attitude stands midway between the Tannaim and the Amoraim, in that, while Solomon falls, it is under the pressure of a passion which seems not to be regarded as ille- gitimate, and his worship of idols was not conscious and brazen, but consisted merely in crushing certain locusts before idols, for he "did not consider the blood of the locusts". This charitable estimate quite befits a writer who wished his work accepted as a valuable medical treatise from Solomon's own hand. That in the Test Asmodaeus has nothing to do with the king's fall at once differentiates the work from the Talmud and proves that it had no close connection with those popular cycles of Solomonic myth from which the rabbis probably drew their stories. Moreover, in the Test there is, on the one hand, no hint that the king lost his throne along with his power over the demons; and, on the other, no restoration of his power, while the ring, which is the chief means by which he gains his power over the demons, is not indispensable, as it is in the Talmudic legends. The connection of a Shunamite girl with Solomon's fall is unique. It must have been suggested by the name in Cant VI 12; VII 1, and it would seem to hint at an interpretation of Canticles otherwise unknown to me, and entirely
contradictory to that which became customary in Jewish and Christian circles. A comparison of the Test, then, with Jewish thought in the same field confirms the statement which Dr. Kohler makes, that our document is pre-Talmudic. It is, moreover, closer to the Palestinian than to the Babylonian Talmud. If Loewe is right in his contention that it was Galilean, not Judean, rabbis who believed in demonology and magic, we have just the line of tradition we should expect in a Christian work, which would be connected with Palestine rather than Babylon, and with Galilee rather than Judea. e) One offshoot of Jewish magic remains to be considered. Perhaps the most interesting and valuable of recent publications in this field is Montgomery's Aramaic Incantation Texts from Nippur, inscriptions from a series of magic bowls in rabbinic Aramaic, Syriac, and Mandaic, intended to protect the houses and families of the clients, and dating from the sixth century A. D. Some are distinctly heathen, all are decidedly eclectic, mingling Babylonian, Jewish, and Hellenistic elements, but the majority show Jewish influence and were prepared for Jews. Strangely enough, in view of the place of origin, Persian demonology has left no trace, but "Egypto-Hellenistic magic is one of the prime sources of our texts". How is the Test related to this remarkable series of incantations?
In many respects the similarity is great. We find the same kind of angel names ending in -el, the same trust in their efficacy, and the same conception of demons as the causes of ills and diseases of all sorts. The sealing of demons is mentioned in most of the texts, and Solomon's seal is referred to in some. In a related text Grünbaum found the phrase "jinn of Solomon". UNT. 9: McCown. On the other hand there are decided differences. The magician is not concerned with individual demons or angels. Personal names of demons are few; rather they are addressed as classes, "Demons and Devils and Satans and Liliths', while the angels, even more than in the Test, come to be mere charms, not personalities. The black art is personified, and the Curse and the Vow, and Arts and Practices" are adjured. Certain familiar names appear which the Test lacks; for example, Metatron, Abraxas, and Hermes. Rather more of plainly Hellenistic magic enters into the Aramaic texts; for example, Zeus and Okeanos. Heathen deities appear more distinctly: Sames, Sin, Bel, and Nirig. The charms are much more elaborate than any in the Test.
From this hasty comparison it is evident that Montgomery's texts and ours belong to the same world, that of syncretistic Hellenism, but not to the same part of that world, nor to the same era. The Test comes from an earlier, or at least a less highly developed stage in the history of magic, and, strange as it may appear, shows really less of Hellenistic influence on its magic, if not on its demonology, than do the Semitic texts. 7. Hellenistic elements and relationships. — No one familiar with the magic papyri can fail to identify the Test as a Hellenistic work. Upon the basis of primitive Greek and Roman animism the popular mind had constructed by the time of the early Empire a magic that borrowed from all the races, Babylonian, Persian, Indian, Jewish, and Egyptian, that had contributed to its civilization, and yet was thoroughly naturalized. It is in this world that the Test belongs.
Onoskelis is no doubt, the well known Greek female demon, although the manner of her birth can be paralleled from both Greek and Jewish sources. Enepsigos is probably Hekate. One demon I have identified with Lix Tetrax, two of the original Ephesia grammata, in part because, while the name is corrupted, it is in the Test connected with a wind as it is in a Cretan tablet of the fourth century B. C.. In any case the section is Hellenistic, as the charm · · · shows; the demon also cures fever, a heathen, not a Jewish or Christian idea. Kynopegos may be identified with Poseidon. Akephalos Daemon appears in the magic papyri. The idea of demons as the cause of disease was familiar to the Greek mind, for the were the ancient Greek form of microbe. The similarity of views on this subject among men widely separated in time and place is illustrated by the fact that Plato, Apuleius, and the Talmud all agree in regarding demons as partly human, partly supernatural in their nature.
The magic of the Test is not outwardly so different from that of the magic papyri, and the writer was familiar with the praxis of the latter, as VI 10 and XVIII show. But rarely appear, and when they do they are an evidence that the section in which they occur has come from Hellenism; nor do the incantations and amulets have the elaborateness that characterizes them in the papyri. The angel, a messenger of God, is the agent of healing and protection. No black magic, nor defixiones appear. The Test, then, differs from the magic papyri chiefly in that it is the work of a Christian using heathen materials rather than that of a heathen working on Jewish or Christian matter. The passages in the papyri which mention Solomon merely show that his fame as a magician was spreading beyond the limits of Judaism and Christianity. One is inclined to think that some legend of Solomon's dealing with demons is back of the line that speaks of Solomon's laying his seal on the tongue of Jeremiah.
8. Christian elements and relationships. a) Relation to the New Testament. — The thought of our text regarding Christ has already been sufficiently discussed. As to demonology the New Testament is not sufficiently detailed to permit a comparison of individual figures except in the case of Beelzebul, who is a purely New Testament character, so far as our knowledge goes, and who has been fully adopted into our text. In general it is quite evident that Paul and the writers of the Synoptic Gospels believed in demonic activities such as are described in the Test. They differ in the essential point that Christ's is the only name to use in exorcism, and, according to Luke, it could safely be invoked only by real Christians; all magic books were to be burned. New Testament language has been adopted by our writer in the phrases , applied to the seven spirits of evil, or ( ) applied to the thirty-six decani, and as designations of angelic beings. Dr. Conybeare has collected and discussed a considerable number of words and phrases common to our text and
the New Testament. He comes to the conclusion, with which we must on the whole agree, that the similarity of phrase is due to common environment. "Paul merely glances at a system of belief which the Testament sets before us in lengthy detail'. But the environment of our writer includes the New Testament. Not as if he had first hand acquaintance with it. That is excluded by those passages which deal with its incidents or ideas. When he describes the Gadarene" demon, Leontophoron, he refers only to the outstanding features of the story which any one would remember who had heard it read or told. Likewise in mentioning Jesus he alludes only to characteristic features of Christian doctrine which would impress themselves on a hearer who was . The story of the rejected cornerstone, combining as it does Ps CXVIII 22 and Is XXVIII 16 after the manner of I Pt II 6f., but referring them to an actual stone, reads like anti-Christian polemic from the Jewish side. Certainly our writer was not familiar with the Christian application of these verses, if he was a Christian.
After weighing the evidence one is driven to the conclusion that the author of the Test had the same relation to the New Testament that we have found him sustaining to the Old Testament and the apocryphal literature. All this constitutes part of the background of his thinking, and he had a superficial knowledge of it derived from hearing it read in the Sabbath worship, or mentioned in sermons and discussions; an occasional phrase or quotation sticks in his mind, or he may borrow from other better instructed magicians; but he is not working with copies of any of this literature before him. He composes freely without literary trammels. It is auricular knowledge with an absence of literary dependence rather than a very early date which makes the Test at once like and unlike the New Testament. b) Relation to the early Church. — To what class of Christians would such a work as the Test appeal? One would expect to find much Gnostic material in such a work, especially in view of the fact that so many so-called "Gnostic amulets" have been preserved, many of them coupling the name of Solomon with Abraxas and similar words of power. In fact, Dr. Conybeare concludes, "It is probable . . . that the Testament was the favourite book of the Ophiani, or of some analogous sect which combined a belief in Emmanuel with a mass of pre-existent Jewish superstitions". With this we cannot agree.
The passage on which Dr. Conybeare seems to base this judgment appears to me directly to contradict it. The seven ruling demons, faith in whom Origen ascribed to the Ophiani, are, to be sure, just the sort of beings in which the author of the Test believes. But these seven, which with the "mother" play so important a part in Gnosticism, are certainly the seven planets. In the Test the only group of seven which appears is to be identified with the Pleiades; they have none of the characteristics of the Gnostic seven, nor is there any "mother" mentioned with them. Sophia is personified in Proverbs and Wisdom as in the Test long before her appropriation by Gnosticism. The prohibition of the invocation of angels' names "um irgend eine Sache" in the Second Book of Jeñ is a direct attack upon such practices as the Test sought to further. A similar condemnation of heathen magic and astrology appears in Pistis Sophia,
but, as Dieterich pointed out, the Gnostic insisted he had the key to the true science, and it was this that gave Gnostic amulets such tremendous vogue. Now one of the striking facts about the original Test is that, outside the chapter on the thirty-six decani (XVIII), which, as we have seen, is of Egyptian origin, it contains practically none of the names which are commonly found on Gnostic amulets, or are regarded as characteristic of Gnosticism; such names as Abraxas and Ialdaboth. The distinctly Gnostic elements belong to sections which have been assigned on other grounds to the later recensions. The one piece of cosmic mysticism occurring in the Test, the directions for seeing "the heavenly dragons dragging the chariot of the sun", presents a contrast to Pistis Sophia c. 136, which describes the sun as a great dragon with his tail in his mouth. The words and phrases in the list of the decani which have a Gnostic sound may be in part really of Gnostic origin; for example, · · , · · · · , · . Some, perhaps all, are borrowed by Gnosticism and the Test from the same sources, Judaism, heathenism, and Christianity. None of the characteristic features of the Gnostic systems, such as dualism, emanations, syzygies, and mystic names being found in the Test, and there being so few allusions of any kind to Gnostic language, the conclusion must be that our text has not come under Gnostic influence.
One story in the Test brings it into touch with Ethiopia. From Ethiopia comes a story of Solomon's fall which closely parallels that in the Test. In the Talmud it is Asmodaeus who temporarily deposes the King by seizing his ring. In this Ethiopian legend Pharaoh's daughter seduces him. She urges him to worship her idols; he refuses. She entices him until finally he promises on oath that he will do whatever she wishes. Then she ties a thread across the middle of the door of the temple of her gods (that is, across the door half way up), brings three locusts, sets them in the temple of her gods, and says to him, "Come to me stooping so as not to break the woolen thread, kill these locusts before me, and twist their necks." When he complies, she says to him, "From now on I will do thy will, since thou hast made offering to my gods and hast prayed to them." The writer, moved by the same apologetic tendency as in the Test, explains that he acted thus on account of his oath in order that he might not perjure himself, although he knew that it was a sin to enter the idol temple.
The parallels between this legend and that in the Test are too striking to be overlooked. Furthermore, Ethiopic magic and demonology as a whole are much like those of the Test. "Very great importance is attached in (Ethiopic) magic spells to the knowledge of names and the power resident in them; and in this potent element of the magician's art Jewish, Christian, and pagan ideas curiously meet... In Abyssinia, Biblical sacred names, together with a large number of fanciful appellations much resembling those in the Jewish Kabbala, were magically pronounced for the purpose of warding off the power of demons and all kinds of diseases". The use of slips of paper as amulets to be tied to the person or wall, the prominence of Michael, the use of angelic names against demons and diseases, the lilith-like Werzelya, and the power of Solomon over demons almost make the impression that it is the Test which Margoliouth is describing. Remembering also the similarity of the Test and Ethiopic Enoch one might be led to the conclusion that the
Test must have come from the land from which the Ethiopic church received its legends, that is, from Egypt. Lest one should infer too much, it is to be noted that legends similar to those in our text are to be found in other parts of the Christian world. Dr. Conybeare has discovered a parallel to the story of the corner stone which human agency could not lift in life of St. Nino, the mother of the Georgian church. In the Georgian life of the saint and the Armenian history of the Georgians is a story of a cedar column, the seventh and last necessary to the erection of the first church in the newly converted kingdom, which the king and all his people were unable to move, but which, in the early morning, after the defeat of the hosts of evil by St. Nino's prayers, is moved by invisible hands to the base prepared for it. In Rufinus' Ecclesiastical History the same story is told of the "Iberians" and their king, but the miracle is heightened by leaving the pillar suspended above its base. One might think of a combination of the stories of the corner stone and the aerial column in this last legend, but the connection is very tenuous.
Dr. James writes to me: "I would add two more references to your bit of testimonia. In the Syriac Obsequies of the Virgin, Wright, Contributions to the Apocryphal Literature of the NT, 1865, p. 42, is the story of the old man and his son [Test XX] — the end of it only, and in different guise, but unmistakably the same tale. It is from a fifth century MS (see p. 12). Also in a tract called Inventiones Nominum which I printed in Journal of Theological Studies, 1903, p. 224, § 27, is, 'Tres sunt Orniae... Tercius est Ornias princeps demoniorum.' In one MS this is emended to 'Ornias princeps Lacedaemoniorum' in allusion to I Macc. XII 7; but I feel sure it is an emendation. It is interesting to find an allusion in Latin." Returning from these excursions to outlying fields of Christian thought and life we find every reason for believing
that the Test belongs in the ordinary current of Christian faith and practice. From Paul on down the church fathers believed in the real existence and the dangerous powers of demons. "Aus dem tiefsten Gefühl heraus, von der Hilflosigkeit und niedergedrückten Stimmung, wie dieser Glaube sie erzeugt hatte, eine Rettung gefunden zu haben, schreibt ein Christ des II. Jahrh. (Clemens Alex., Theodoti Exc. 71, 72) die Worte: 'Verschiedenartig sind die Gestirne und ihre Kräfte, heilsame, schädliche, rechte, linke... Von diesem Widerstreit und Kampf der Kräfte rettet uns der Herr und gibt uns Frieden vor dem Kampfe der Kräfte und der Engel, den die einen für, die anderen wider uns führen'. Origen also seems to believe fully in the powerful names" known by "the Egyptians, or by the Magi among the Persians, or by the Indian philosophers called Brahmans," as he does in the power of the name of God and of Jesus and of angel names. That Christians practise sorcery or exorcism by demonic names he indignantly denies; it is the name of Jesus which drives out demons. Jesus has freed the Christian from all superstitious fears.
If such was the case with the leaders in the Christian church, how can we expect that the rank and file of their followers should fully grasp and consistently apply the one great idea in which Christian magic differed from heathen, that Christ's was the sole name of power to use for all purposes of healing and protection? The newly converted idolater cannot at once rise to the full heights of Christian spirituality. The ancient church replaced the heathen deities with the crucifix and the images of the saints and madonna, and the old abra-dacadabra with angel names. At a very early time on Christian amulets the Lord's Prayer, verses from the Psalms, and other familiar passages replaced the heathen myths and incantations. Similarly the writer of the Test is making a brave, though but partially successful, attempt to put Christian (i. e., Jewish and Christian) ideas in the place of heathen. This whole movement is most illuminatingly set forth in an excerpt quoted by F. C. Burkitt from the Syriac homily De magis, incantoribus, et divinis, in which "the writer complains that his fellow-Christians, even the clergy, resorted to Magicians and Jews. He says (col. 395): 'Instead of the blessings of the Saints, lo, they carry about the incantations of the magicians, and instead of the holy cross, lo, they carry the books of devils... One carries it on his head, and another round his neck, and a child, who knows nothing at all, carries about devils' names and comes (to church)... Polluted and abominable priests take refuge in the names of demons...' Magic grew in power in the church, especially from the fourth century on, and was officially recognized in the sixth and seventh. Our text is a document of this progressive paganizing of official Christianity rather than the product of some obscure heretical sect.
c) Relation to mediaeval Christianity. — That the Test belongs to orthodox Christianity is further demonstrated when one turns to study the preservation of the ideas for which it stands in the European world. Illustrations are too numerous to present in detail. The Queen of Sheba will serve as one. Kraus has collected many references of Byzantine writers to the fabled queen, which show that in using her the Test was following, or inaugurating, Christian tradition. As to Solomon there was in the beginning some difference of opinion among Christian writers. Early anti-Jewish polemics, like the Dialogue of Timothy and Aquila, for example, find Solomon used to offset the claims of Jesus. Not only did their Jewish opponents apply many a Messianic passage to the wise son of David, but they made the claim that he had anticipated and excelled Jesus in his power over demons, thus undermining the Christian argument that Jesus was the Messiah because he had broken the power of Satan, and weakening the Christian appeal to a world that was languishing under the oppressive fear of demonic activities. To offset this Jewish claim these Christian writers bitterly attacked the memory of the wise king, maintaining that his was only a temporary victory over the demons, who overcame him at the end of his life. Leontius of Constantinople argues at some length that Christ's greatness is manifest in his power over demons while he was here on earth. In the midst of his description of the cure of the Gadarene demoniac he abruptly turns the request of the "Legion" to enter the swine to account in this fashion: · ' , ; , , , ; ' · ; ; ' ; ; ' , · , . , , ' . , , ... . ... , ;
The original Test shows no suspicion of a conflict of claims between Solomon and Christ, but in c. XV 10—12 Rec. B (MS P) attempts to combine the Jewish and Christian viewpoints. As to the glorious king's sad end, these early fathers think of him as falling a prey to the demons through the seduction of women, or vice versa. But the majority of Christian writers, like Josephus, ascribe his fall into idolatry to his love for women without the interposition of demonic agency. The Test in one place takes the former view, but in the closing chapter apparently the latter. Here again our text shows its early date. The conception of Solomon as a great magician who was powerful over demons and disease is witnessed to by scores of amulets and incantations, and especially by such books as the Clavicula. Many of the demons of the Test lived on. Asmo-
about 485—542. Cf. Gelzer, Leont. v. Byz., etc., and Hist. Ztschr. LXI (1899) 1—32, Fabricius, Bib. Graec. VIII 319ff. daeus goes through many transformations. Obyzut appears in the Abyzu of Pradel's Griechische und süditalienische Gebete, while Ornias appears in the same documents. Gaulmin and Migne were right in bringing the Test and Psellus together. The great Byzantine's is but the effort of a master mind to systematize the ideas which the Test merely registers. Withal, this whole complex of Byzantine demonology and magic makes the impression of being a more highly developed form of the conceptions with which our text is operating. The roots of the tree run back to the Sumerians, the Babylonians, the Iranians, and the Pelasgians, the Test stands for the blossom, Psellus gives us the ripened fruit dissected and analyzed. 9. Relation to Arabian folklore. — Arabic literature, since it is especially rich in demon lore and Solomonic myth, invites particular comparison with the Test. In general Arabian beliefs and practices in the field of demonology and magic are not essentially different from those of our text except in one feature which Islam inherited from heathenism, the idea of the Jinn,
Schwab, Dict. 421, " ; sur une hématite figurant un Salomon à cheval, perçant de sa lance un ennemi terrassé, avec la légende , au Cabinet des Medailles et Antiques de la Bibliothèque Nat. II 3039". The late Prof. Nestle wrote me of a Sol. on horseback as an amulet against malocchio, published by Bienkowski in Eranos Vindobonensis, 1893, 288. Amulets in MSS are well illustrated by those in cod. Bonon. univ. 3632, cf. supra p. 24. Cf. Heim "Incantamenta magica," in Jbb. für class. Philol. Sup. XIX (1893) pp. 463—576, Nos. 56 = 169, 61, 62, 236, 237, and Sorlin Dorigny, "Sal. als Reiter," in Rev. des Études Grecs IV (1891) 217—296. The pilgrim of Bordeaux in the IV cent. was shown the "crypta ubi S. daemones torquebat," Schürer GJV III 418, from Tobler, Palaest. descript. (1869) 3, Pal. Pil. Text Soc., Bordeaux Pilg. 20. Dr. Conybeare drew my attention to Gannurini's ed. of St. Silvia's Perigrinatio (IV cent.), according to which the ring was kept in the Church of St. James (p. 96 and 95 n. 2). The tradition was that Vespasian took it to Rome, whence Constantine returned it (ibid. 96 n. 3), cf. Petri diaconi liber de locis sanctis, ibid. 117; see Pal. Pil. Text Soc., The Pilgrimage of S. Silvia to the Holy Places, 64 and 125.
which are often kindly and beneficent creatures. In our writer's mind there is properly no place for any good among demons, although he is once or twice betrayed by his pagan materials into referring to their healing powers. The wild exuberance of Arab fancy as we see it in the Thousand and One Nights is another mark of differentiation. The Quran and even more the Arabian Nights have made all the world familiar with Solomon's authority over the Jinn and with the latter's terrible forms and powers. In the Quran are allusions to the fallen angels, Hārūt and Mārūt, and to the devils who were subject to Solomon, some as builders, and others bound in fetters. In the Nights we find full accounts of how Solomon placed rebellious Jinn in bottles, or in cucurbites of copper, poured lead over them, and sealed them with his ring, with tales of their later escape from these prisons.
According to the Quran the Jinn are not allowed to listen at the gates of heaven, but God has placed the stars there as weapons for the angels to throw at them if they make the attempt. In the Nights the Jinniyah Maymunah "made for the firmament, thinking to listen by stealth to the converse of the angels," and when she ascended "skywards till she drew near the heaven of the world, the lowest of the heavens," she found an Ifrit there before her. In another story "Allah suffered his angelic host to shoot down the Ifrit with a shooting star. The likeness and unlikeness of the conceptions in the Test are apparent. Salzberger's dissertation on the Salomosage, although it does not reach the fall of the king, presents a rich collection of legends, particularly with regard to his relations to the demons. He gathers them under four rubrics, the punishment of the demons, their appearance before Solomon, the description of certain individuals, especially Sahr, and Solomon's ring. Two descriptions of the appearance of the devils as they are marshalled before the king are given from three Berlin MSS of Kisa'i. The portrayal of demonic forms as given "nach dem korrecteren und vollständigeren Text der dritten Berliner Handschrift des Kisa'i" would seem most strikingly like that in the Test, were it not that the other two MSS give in a longer and shorter form descriptions which are still more similar. Solomon inquires from the demons, just as in the Test, what their activities are, and, having learned, chains them so they may injure mankind no more. The ring, as in the Test, is brought down from heaven, and by its aid Solomon becomes master of the demons.
Yet, with all these close resemblances, there are also great differences between the Test and the Arabic legends. All the Jewish stories of Solomon's glory and wisdom, his wonderful ring, the building of the Temple by the aid of the demons, and his dealings with the queen of Sheba have grown marvellously under the fructifying fancy of the Arabs. Beside the marvels of the Quran and its commentaries, and especially the Arabian Nights the Test is dull and tame. Most of the features in which we found Jewish legend to have evolved beyond the Test are to be found in still more highly developed form among the Arabs; for example, Solomon's power over the animals is greatly extended; Sahr is the Talmudic Asmodaeus, but worse; Iblis, the devil, whose refusal to worship Adam leads to his fall, is not, like Beelzebul in the Test, subject to Solomon, but carries a step farther that independence and insolence which Asmodaeus shows in the Jewish legends; the king's fall has quite a different aspect in the Quran.
The ring also, as Salzberger shows, develops a new character in Arabic legend different from that which it has in the Test, evolving along the lines suggested by the Talmudic story of Asmodaeus' theft of it. Kisa'i is the first to describe it fully. It is so glorious that no one can look at it without repeating the Moslem creed, and has four considerable legends engraved upon it. It is either brought by Gabriel, or of itself comes from the throne of God and appears upon Solomon's hand. Solomon's fall according to Kisa'i was due to conscious or unconscious idolworship, which, if I understand Salzberger, was connected with the sacrifice of locusts. This tradition, then, connects the Test on the one hand with Ethiopia, and on the other with Arabia. Since Ethiopia was closely connected with Arabia in Christian history, we have probably to think of a Palestinian Jewish tradition which never found its way to Babylon, nor, so far as I know, into official Palestinian Jewish literature, but passed by way of the Jewish colonies in southern Arabia into Ethiopian and Mohammedan legend, and directly from Palestinian Judaism into our Christian work, for we cannot suppose that the Test arose in Arabia. This being so, one of the links that would connect our text with Egypt is broken.
These examples are sufficient to illustrate both the likeness and the unlikeness of the Test to Arabic literature. They show how Arabic legend, where it resembles our work, has developed its UNT. 9: McCown. ideas farther and in a different manner, and how in many particulars it rests upon the sort of Jewish tradition seen in the Talmud. 10. Unique matter in Recension A. — Having studied the material relationships of the Test as a whole we now undertake the same task for the individual recensions. As Rec. A is nearest the original, it has little matter that calls for comment. Its expansions are of a purely narrative sort. MS L alone has undergone a considerable revision by a mediaeval magician, who added nothing new, but merely mutilated the document. The single addition of importance in this recension is the inscription on the ring. 11. Unique matter in Recension B. — The peculiarities of Rec. B, and particularly of MS P, the only complete MS of this recension, consist in the main of unimportant interpolations and alterations. There are, however, a few additions of moment. These may be classed under four heads: (1) those which show familiarity with demonological tradition; e. g., the reference to the ghosts of the giants, to the female demon Obyzuth as , and to Enepsigos, another female demon, as , the allusion to a cycle of legend regarding and , the added charms in XVIII 23, 27 f., further information regarding Abezethibu; (2) those which are Gnostic in character; e. g., the allusions to the eleven fathers and the eleventh aeon; (3) those which have a cabalistic tendency; e. g., the introduction of Apharoph for Raphael, of ' for Emmanuel, and of ' for Raphael, and
(4) those which show familiarity with Christianity. Additions are found in every section that refers to Christ; viz., VI 8, XI, XII 3, XVII 4, and XXII 20. The additions in the first three passages are not important. The remaining two, however, seem to be due to an attempt to make the Christianity of the Test less "equivocal," since in XVII 4 the "becoming man" of the Savior is mentioned, and in XXII 20 the one to be born of a virgin and crucified is called . These additions lead to the belief that in XV 10f, where Rec. A is wanting by accident, the positive Christian ideas advanced, viz., that it is the son of God who is to be stretched on the tree, that his mother is never to know man, and that he is especially fit to receive dominion over all the demons because he overcame the devil ( rarely occurs in the Test) are probably the work of the B redacteur. This conclusion is supported by the fact that the Test elsewhere makes no attempt at systematic thought or generalization. At any rate we cannot definitely claim these ideas for the original writer, and must conclude that B is not only much better instructed in the faith, but also later.
12. Unique matter in Recension C. — Rec. C deserves a special investigation of much greater proportions than can be given here, in order to determine its sources and relationships. As we have already seen, its language is late, and the codices in which it is found as well as its unique material relate it to the Clavicula. Many problems I must leave to others. Why is Beelzebul called Eltzianphiel? What is the meaning of Onoskelu's birth ? Whence comes the idea of the bird that flies over God's head? One of the most interesting and baffling sections is that which we have called the "Prologue". In spite of defective grammar the editor has 6\* been able to select from some source certain high sounding prayers, which; I think, have no parallels in the LXX, the New Testament, or the early fathers. Possibly he borrowed from some, to him well known, liturgy.
The magical cup and table in c. XI 7ff. are related to the "marvelous cup of crystal middlemost of which was the figure of a lion faced by a kneeling man grasping a bow with arrow drawn to the very head, together with the food-tray of Sulayman, the son of David" in the story of "Sinbad the Seaman and Sinbad the Landsman" from the Arabian Nights. The added magical formulae connect this recension more closely than the others to the magical literature of the Middle Ages on the one hand, and to the magical papyri on the other. The word Agla (XIII 6), which by notarikon stands for "thou art mighty forever, O Lord," indicates dependence upon Jewish cabalism, and probably a relatively late date, for the word is not in the magic papyri, so far as I can discover, but is a favorite in the Middle Ages. The magical recipe of c. IX 9f. and the list of fifty demons in c. X have many marks which show that they are later than the original Test and have arisen in a different circle. The list is not concerned solely or primarily with the cure of diseases; it relates the powers, some good, some evil, of each demon, and implies that these powers are under the control of him who knows the demon's seal. Furthermore, each demon rules a certain number of inferiors. These ideas are to be found, on the one hand, in Gnosticism, which details the number of spirits ruled by each , and, on the other, in mediaeval
magic. The resemblance between c. X and the language of Pistis Sophia regarding the five and the and of the thirteenth , and the various , , and lists of names in chapters 5—40 and 45—52 in the First Book of Jeu is most striking. Furthermore, there are close resemblances between the magical figures of the Coptic papyri, the Clavicula, both Latin and Greek, and the unique sections of this recension. We cannot attempt to trace the connecting links between these widely separated branches of magic, which, no doubt, go back to a common source in Hellenistic syncretism. The facts presented are an interesting illustration of the wide wanderings of superstitions, and the tenacity with which they maintain their forms in their migrations. 13. Unique matter in MS D. — On internal grounds and by comparison with Recs. A and B we have decided that MS D c. I—VI and VIII present in general the form of the original story of Solomon out of which the Test was developed. From what sources did this legend come? As it now stands, it is quite plainly a Christian redaction of Jewish midrashim regarding Solomon, Palestinian, perhaps Galilean, in origin, rather than Babylonian. That the legend of c. I is ultimately Jewish is suggested by Nathan's stopping to bury a dead countryman, a trait borrowed from Magianism. Traces of later influences are to be found in c. VII. The story of Solomon's flying through the air appears in Jewish mythology, where he is said to have ridden on an eagle, but in Mohammedan legend, according to the Quran on a wind, and in the
Arabian Nights on a magic carpet. If the story originally referred to Asmodaeus' usurpation of the throne, then we have also Jewish sources. This chapter, then, would seem to be an addition from a Jewish-Mohammedan type of tradition. All the remainder of this version we have already traced to Jewish sources. From considerations of textual and literary criticism we concluded that D in its present form was late, but that its archetype (d) was the starting point for the Test. From its language and style we concluded that it was Byzantine. Our conclusions based upon a study of its subject matter accord with this and take us one step further: an originally Jewish document or cycle of legends has been thoroughly worked over by an educated Christian in early Byzantine times. Since there are no Christian elements in those parts of d which were taken over into the Test, and the quality of the Christianity in Rec. A is much poorer than in D, it is natural to conclude that d had nothing Christian in it when it was transformed into the Test.
14. Solomon's seal. — The origin of the seals supposedly engraved on the ring of Solomon is of subordinate importance, since they are in any case secondary additions in our MSS. The simplest form is that found in Rec. B, which attempts no reproduction, but merely says the inscription was a pentagram. Since this is the western type of the tradition, it cannot have been original. Rec. A presents an interesting formula consisting for the most part of unintelligible words and containing those combinations of vowels so common in Hellenistic magic. MS L alone reproduces the seal with the legend in the form of a circle, the formula appearing around the circumference, while the interior contains magic signs. In the manuscript in which L is found, Harl. 5596, the Clavicula contains a seal of different shape on which the same legend was to be written. In Bologna University MS No. 3632 (V of the Test) there is found among many such "pentacles" a circle inscribed , within which is written the same legend. No doubt the editor of Rec. A got his seal from some such collection. The wording of the inscription would seem to link it to the older amulets and magic papyri, but in any case it is younger than the Test, which shows little trace of such influence.
In Rec. C twelve large seals are found, the first a rectangle with various transverse lines and magic sings, the remaining eleven round and also containing various mystical symbols. In the fifth and the ninth are figures that look like the signs for Virgo and Scorpio, in the seventh for Aquarius, in the eighth for Pisces; the third, fourth, and fifth contain among others modifications of the Christian monogram ℟. The fact that these same seals are found in a Vienna MS which does not contain the Test is, I think, indicative of their origin. We must conclude that the original Test contained no description or reproduction of the seal. 15. Summary and conclusions. — If our previous conclusions are correct, the original Jewish stem of the present Test consisted of the narrative parts of chapters I, II, XX, XXII, XXIII, and XXIV, i. e., of those parts which are common to the Test and MS D. Upon this parent stem have been grafted (1) certain sections which describe the demons more fully, (2) two brief references to the work as a Test, which give it the name (XV 13f, XXVI 8), other considerable sections containing demonic prophecies whose later fulfilment is represented as constituting the basis for Solomon's faith in their testimony, and which, therefore, are intended to validate the work to the public (XII 4, XV 12ff., XX 21), and (4) additions made merely for the story's sake or intended to link the parts of the story together (VI 3, 5f., XIX, XXI, XXII 7f., 17).
In this division of the Introduction we have given attention mainly to the origin of the first of these four classes of additions, which includes the demonological, astrological, and magical elements in the work, additions marked by the questions ; ; ; ; It is for the sake of answering these questions that the Test was written. As we have seen, the material for the answers has been drawn through Judaism from Babylonia in Ephippas (XXII) and possibly in the lilith-like Obyzuth (XIII) and from Persia in Asmodaeus (V); from Hellenistic Egypt come the decani although the section has been much altered by Jewish or Christian revisers (XVIII); from Hellenistic Greek mythology come Onoskelis (IV), Lix Tetrax (VII), Akephalos Daemon (IX), Enepsigos (= Hekate, XV), Kunopegos (= Poseidon, XVI), and possibly the dog, Rhabdos (X, = ? Cerberus) and Pterodrakon (XIV = ? Typhon), from Hellenistic mysticism the recipe for a cosmic revelation (VI 10f.); from (perhaps Galilean) Jewish sources come the seven , the giant, Machthon, the demon of the Red Sea, Abezethibou (XXV), and probably the Shunamite (XXVI); from Christian, or Jewish-Christian sources in part, come Beelzebul (III, VI 1—9), Leontophoron, the demon of Gadara (XI), and perhaps the demon of epilepsy called , beside the charms which include some allusion to Christ (XV 10f., XVII 4).
What sort of a man could have held such inconsistent and ill-digested views drawn from all these diverse sources. He cannot have been a heathen for he knows Judaism and Christianity, the Old Testament and the New too well. He cannot have been a Jew because of the Christian elements. Dr. Conybeare suggests that we have here as in the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs, "a Christian recension of a Jewish book". Although I cannot agree with Schürer that there are no Jewish passages in the book, Dr. Conybeare's hypothesis does not seem to
meet the facts in the case. There is too much Christian material in the Test. Particularly is it to be noted that, in both places where the word testament occurs (XV 14, XXVI 8), it is closely connected with passages which are Christian in tone; c. XV 10f. in the form in which we have it is the most characteristically Christian section in the entire work; c. XXVI 8 in Rec. B, which we believe to represent the original here, is less markedly so than is MS H with its reference to the "Jews," and yet we have discovered that the whole of the last chapter is based on a legend which otherwise comes to us from a Christian source. Moreover, the demonology of the work, which so much resembles that of the New Testament and the pseudepigrapha which were accepted in the Christian church, and the language with its resemblances to that of the New Testament even in passages where there is no quotation or direct allusion point to a Christian origin. The absence too of smaller inconsistencies from the narrative, especially of Rec. A, the impossibility of finding the joints in the mending, point to unity of authorship for the Test as such. We conclude, then, that while the original story d was probably Jewish, the demonological document which first called itself a Testament, best represented in Rec. A, was a Christian work.
The man who composed our Test bears no distinctive marks of any heterodox circle, yet he was no thorough-going Christian. He was above all a magician, and it is as such that he collected this bizarre potpourri of fragments from almost every nation that had contributed to Mediterranean civilization. He must have been a Greek Christian, familiar, perhaps from childhood, with the language of the Septuagint and New Testament, familiar also with many legends of Jewish origin, but entirely familiar too with the demonology and magic of the heathen world, to which he belonged almost as truly as he did to Christianity. For him Christ is not yet master of the whole world; nevertheless, Christ's is a name to conjure with, and, when he is at a loss for a powerful angel name, the new savior comes into the exorcism. He is a half-hearted Christian in a world where Christianity is not yet the conquering religion. This is the more
VIII. The Testament in Literature and History
evident when one compares Recs. B and C, which introduce elements which reveal the period when Christianity had conquered, and was absorbing its former foes and their superstitions.
Viii. the Testament in Literature and History.1. Solomonic books of healing and magic among the Jews.— a) The literary starting point for all the later legends regarding Solomon's wisdom is to be found in III Reg III. Here, as Benzinger points out, it is the judicial wisdom of the ruler that is in the writer's mind. In c. V 9—14, on the other hand, it is "religiöse Lebensweisheit'. Furthermore, Benzinger believes that in comparing Solomon's wisdom with that of the children of the East and the wisdom of the Egyptians the writer intended to imply that Solomon knew magic and astrology, for these ancients were famous for such knowledge, as the records of the Exodus, for example, testify. How far back may we place this earliest reference to Solomon's magical knowledge? The verses in question can hardly belong to the earlier sources of the Books of Kings as Kautzsch seems to imply, but rather to the final redaction of the book. The least that one can say is that it must date before the Septuagint translation. More than two centuries, therefore, before Christ, in the leading circles of Palestinian Judaism, Solomon is already a magician. The interpolator of the passage may not have thought of him as the author of magical books, but surely many readers would understand from the allusion to the wisdom of the ancients and Egypt that meant, not psalms, but carmina, incantations, and that the discourses must include their medical, or what amounted to the same thing, their magical uses.
b) The next reference to Solomon's magical powers, in Wisdom VII 17—22, makes no allusion to writings; indeed the context does not call for it. But it does plainly involve the ascription to the supposed writer of knowledge of astrology, of the nature of beasts and spirits, as well as of men, of the , the , and the , of "all things that are either secret or manifest". The Wisdom of Solomon, then, is a witness to the acceptance of the legend of Solomon's astrological, demonological, and magical accomplishments in Alexandrian Judaism in the first century B. C., and, let it be noted, by a thoroughly educated and highly cultured Jew of the Dispersion. c) A still further allusion to Solomon's authority over demons is found in Pseudo-Philo, de antiquitatibus biblicis, in Citharismus regis David contra daemonium Saulis, which we have already quoted. The lines which concern us here should run, according to Dr. James, as follows: Argüet autem te metra nova unde natus sum de quo nascetur post tempus de lateribus meis qui vos domabit. Dr. James says, "In this last sentence it seems at first sight as though we had a prophecy of Messiah, and a possible Christian touch. But a little consideration will show, I think, that the 'vanquisher of demons' who is to spring from David is not Messiah, but Solomon the king of Genies, the wizard whose spells produced such marked effects in the time of Josephus, the hero, too, of the Testament of Solomon, where he figures almost solely as the restrainer and chastiser of mischievous spirits".
d) The next mention of Solomon's power as a magician is the decisive one, without which one might doubt the interpretations adopted above. There can be no doubt as to Josephus' meaning on the whole when he relates the following: (44) [] , · ' , ' . ' · , ' . (45) ' . , , ' . (46) ' · , , . . (47) , , ' , ' , , , ... (49) ... We have quoted the passage at length, because we believe that, having it before the eye and remembering the previous Jewish allusions to Solomonic incantations, one cannot but accept Albrecht Dieterich's conclusion that Josephus means to imply that books were in circulation under Solomon's name which gave the magical, or medicinal, virtues of plants after the plan of the works later written by Pamphilus and called . And surely the had long ago been written down.
e) The Mishna says that Hezekiah hid the "book of recipes", which, according to Maimonides and Rashi meant a book which Solomon had written; Maimonides holding that it was a book of magic, Rashi that the evil consisted in its leading men not to pray to God for their healing. Otherwise rabbinic literature does not refer to such Solomonic works; evidently this sort of tradition was avoided in official Judaism. f) After Talmudic times I know of no reference to such books until we reach the Jews of the Middle Ages. In fact Moses takes the place of Solomon in Jewish literature and becomes the representative wise man, as Solomon does for the Christians. Steinschneider gives citations from writers of the twelfth and following centuries who look upon Solomon as the source of all wisdom, including medicine, magic, and astrology. In particular, Sheintob ben Isaac of Tortosa (1260) in his paraphrase of Zahravi's Tasrif, called ספר השמות (XI cent.), gives "eine Schilderung der Weisheit Salomo's (namentlich in der Naturkunde), unter dessen Namen in Zahravi ein Verband (רטיה) erwähnt werde, der auf weißer Marmortafel an der Wand seines Palastes eingegraben war, wie verschiedene Rezepte (נוסחאות ופוקחות), die von den Späteren (האחרונים) erläutert worden; Scheintob hat 'hier in Marseille' den Christen mehr davon erläutert, als er in Zahravi fand". We have here possible the contract with the demons, and certainly the magical recipes said to have been written on the temple gates. Steinschneider
is only partly right in trying to relieve his compatriots of the responsibility for the ascription of such works to Solomon. The Christians, however, developed the tradition far more than did the Jews from whom they received it. 2. Solomonic books among the Arabs. — A single reference in the Quran and the comments thereon show that among the Jews of Mohammed's time magical books of Solomon were known. Sura II 95ff. reads: "And when there came unto them a prophet from God confirming that scripture which was with them, some of those to whom the scriptures were given cast the book of God behind their backs as if they knew it not: and they follow the device which the devils devised against the kingdom of Solomon; and Solomon was not an unbeliever, but the devils believed not, they taught men sorcery." The context supports Sale's interpretation drawn from Yahya and Jallalo'ddin, that this device against the kingdom of Solomon consisted in the devils' attempt to blacken the character of Solomon by writing books of sorcery, hiding them under his throne, and after his death pretending he had had in them the recipes by which he obtained his power.
3. Among Christians. — a) The power of Salomonic exorcisms. — One line of Christian tradition goes back to Josephus and follows him more or less closely, recounting merely the power of the exorcisms he had composed. Origen, who writes "a Salomone scriptis adjurationibus solent daemones adjurari. Sed ipsi qui utuntur adjurationibus illis, aliquoties nec idoneis constitutis libris utuntur: quibusdam autem et de Hebraeo acceptis adjurant daemonia," may be merely paraphrasing Josephus, or he may have had personal knowledge of Solomonic works. The first I have discovered to quote Josephus expressly is Georgius Monachus (c. 850), who is followed by Cedrenus (c. 1100), Zonaras (c. 1150), and Glycas (after 1150). b) Solomon the ultimate source of medical wisdom. — Other Christian writers start from the Old Testament notices of Solomon's wisdom, developing the tradition in various directions. In the first place, according to Theodoret (386/393—458), he was wiser than the most famous wise men to whom the Hellenistic world looked back. In his Quaestiones in III Reg., Qu. X he asks, " (cod. , ) , ;" He answers, . ... , , , . Procopius of Gaza, without acknowledging his debt, quotes Theodoret almost word for word. Georgius Monachus and after him Georgius Cedrenus give a slightly different version of Theodoret, adding also a part of Theodoret's Quaest. XVIII.
In the second place Theodoret represents the wise king as the source from which the ancients derived their knowledge of medicine. He asks, " ...", and answers, , , , , · ... · , , - , . , . Procopius of Gaza quotes Theodoret as far as . Anastasius Sinaites repeats both question and answer almost word for word. So far as I have discovered, no others use the first part of the reply ending with , but Georgius Monachus, Cedrenus, and Glycas weave into their account of Hezekiah's suppression of Solomon's books the sentence, ' , or its equivalent. c) Hezekiah's suppression of Solomon's books. 1) Origin of the legend. — The question naturally arose as to what had become of all the proverbs, odes, and scientific writings of Solomon. So far as the sources show, this question was first raised and answered by Hippolytus in his commentary on Canticles, portions of which are preserved in Armenian, Syriac, Slavic, and Georgian. The last mentioned version contains a discussion, the essence of which has been handed down also in a quotation or summary found in the Quaestiones of Anastasius Sinaites.
In Quaest. XLI Anastasius collects several ancient references to Solomon's books and wisdom. Beginning with an unacknowledged quotation from Theodoret, he reproduces Sap VII 16—21 and III Reg IV 26—29, and then adds the following: . ; ; ; . ; ; . , · . , ... Perhaps Jerome has this in mind when he says, Aiunt Hebraei cum inter cetera scripta Salomonis quae antiquata sunt, nec in memoria duraverunt, et hic liber [Eccl.] obliterandus videretur... ex hoc uno capitulo [XII] meruisse auctoritatem. That general encyclopedia, the Hypomnesticon, written by the otherwise unknown Josephus Christianus, mentions written by Solomon among the books referred to in the Scriptures but not now found. Michael Glycas gives a badly garbled account of it all, making Hezekiah's revision fall after the Exile and Ezra's labors, and naming as his authority, evidently by mistake. 2) The writings on the temple gate. — In view of Hezekiah's iconoclastic zeal as to the brazen serpent, it was inevitable that some one should suggest that he had also suppressed the magical writings of Solomon. Two Christian writers present an independent tradition, somewhat like that of Sheintob already mentioned. Georgius Syncellus (c. 800) in his -
UNT. 9: McCown. , when speaking of Solomon's reign, merely describes most concisely his wisdom and fall; when he comes to Hezekiah, after expanding IV Reg XVIII 4, he adds, . , ' . , · . Suidas abbreviates the account and puts for . 3) Solomon's magical books suppressed. — Turning to Anastasius Sinaites again we make the interesting discovery that he ascribes the account of the reforming activity of Hezekiah to Eusebius. The final section in Quaest. XII runs as follows: . , , , , , , , , , , . The Hypomnesticon of Josephus, which in chapter 120, as we have seen, tells of Hezekiah's revision of Solomon's proverbs, says in c. 74, , , . The account given by Georgius Monachus of Solomon's wisdom combines part of the Eusebian quotation with express indication of its origin, with extracts from Theodoret and Flavius Josephus, as we have seen. Georgius Cedrenus practically repeats Monachus, but with the addition of a clause , apparently borrowed from Syncellus or Suidas; he mentions no authority. Glycas presents on the whole an independent account of Solomon's wisdom and literary activities, but like Anastasius, he appeals to the authority of Eusebius; he says, , ' . . . .
Is this appeal to the authority of Eusebius deceptive? We may not be sure of the date of the Quaestiones of Anastasius in their present form, but, whoever the writer of Quaest. XII is, he quotes accurately from Theodoret, and from a lost work of Hippolytus. Is not the presumption in favor of accepting his testimony regarding Eusebius, and supposing that he is quoting from some lost work of the great historian? That Eusebius should make such a statement cannot seem at all strange in view of the reference by Origen to "a Salomone scriptis adjurantionibus" 4) One further reference to the tradition that Hezekiah took summary measures with Solomon's medico-magical writings is of particular interest to us, since it is found in Rec. C of the Test (c. XIII 1—12) and, indeed, forms its raison d'être. If this 1 discover no marks to indicate its date; the quotation above is more closely related to Glycas than Georgius Monachus, yet the similarity may be due merely to likeness of literary method.
7\* legend was already found in Eusebius, as it was in the Mishna, there were plenty of channels through which redacteur C might have obtained it. Yet the mention of "burning" and "hiding" (c. XIII 4, 8f.) suggests that Rec. C comes from the time of Cedrenus and Glycas, for the earlier writers do not use the word . d) Solomonic books of incantations in the Middle Ages. — 1) Solomonic books of magic and astrology found in mediaeval manuscripts. — In spite of these records of the sad fate of Solomon's medico-magical literary efforts, such books continued to flourish. The long lists given by M. Seligsohn in his article, "Solomon-Apocryphal Works", in the Jewish Encyclopedia is by no means exhaustive. Indeed Solomon's reputation became such that any thing connected with magic or astrology or science might be ascribed to him. The most popular of the works which are consistently handed down under his name is the Clavicula, or , as some of the Greek copies have it. The two are not exactly the same, but along with the Sepher Raziel, the Semiphoras, and others of the sort, are of a well marked type. They consist mainly of prayers and incantations intended to accomplish various purposes, usually by commanding demonic aid. The prayers are usually interlarded with barbaric names, and there are many pentacles, or magical drawings, each of which gives power over the demon to which it belongs, or serves as an amulet for some specific purpose. Lists of the angels and demons who rule the days and hours are given.
None of these works is like the Test. It is much older in language than any of the Greek works of this sort, and differs from them all as to purpose; for, aside from Rec. C, which has drawn upon them in part, the Test is interested in the demons primarily as the causes of disease. The writer wishes to disclose their nature, relationships, and activities for the same reason that a doctor studies diseases, that he may counteract them. These other books are technical works for the professional astrologer and magician, not concerned with the cure of diseases, in fact rarely showing any medical interest, but anxious rather to show how the demons may be used to gain wealth, power, and happiness. The list of fifty demons in Rec. C (c. X) is characteristic of this type of literature. With it compare the list of thirty-six decani in Recs. A and B (XVIII) to gain a sharp definition of the contrast. When, therefore, the Christian writers refer to a Solomonic "book of healing" they are not thinking of the Clavicula, nor of any of the similar works. The Test is the one Solomonic work which fits the term. Having thus cleared the way, we are ready to consider the evidence that goes to show that such a book was actually in use during the Middle Ages.
2) Literary references to contemporaneous Solomonic medical works. (a) The citations above which mention medico-magical books of Solomon might be supposed not to imply first hand knowledge of any such works. There are others, however, which show that they were well known. Following the brief quotation given above the Hypomnesticon continues, , , [] ' , . The man who wrote this is not depending upon what he has read, but describes what he knows of personal observation. There is no reason why such a sentence could not have been written in the fifth century. (b) The next allusion is equally direct and unambiguous. Nicetas Acominatus, or Choniates, who was a high official at the Byzantine court about 1200 and wrote his History from personal recollections, knew an interpreter and sycophant at the court, Aaron by name, who was also a magician. He relates of him, , ' · , . This describes accurately parts of the and the Latin Clavicula, as well as the new material in Rec. C. The list of fifty demons (c. X) is intended to accomplish just the end of calling in certain demons and the hosts they command, while Paltiel Tzamal uses almost the language of Nicetas in describing the obedience Solomon may expect. It is no doubt a book of this sort, not the Test, which Aaron used, for no mention is made of healing.
(c) Michael Glycas, in the passage already referred to, has a description of Solomon's magical books which we have reserved for separate discussion, because in it he takes a path of his own. His statement is as follows: ... , , , , . , , , , , . ' . This is the Test in everything but name. The latter is throughout concerned with bringing down demons; their forms, natures, and peculiarities are most carefully described. One of the chief purposes of the work is to tell how they are discovered in their lurking places and bound or destroyed. A special feature is the labor to which each demon is con- demned, one of the most striking instances being that of Leontophoron, who is sentenced to the task of cutting wood for the Temple. Cures by the means Glycas mentions are to be found One cannot avoid the conclusion that it is the Test which is here described, either from Glycas' own knowledge, or after some popular account. That he does not name the title need not trouble us.
(d) The next allusion is dubious. In the Decretum Gelasia-num mention is made of a Salomonis interdictio, or as the later texts have it contradictio. In the Decretum in the next line as a separate item and in the Collectio Herovalliana in the same and the following lines mention is made of phylacteria, which contain the names, not of angels, but of demons. In pseudo-Isidor, de Muneris, a line intervenes between the contradictio and phylacteria. Probably, therefore, the two are distinct works, and the second is no doubt the Clavicula, which is characterized by seals and amulets. We must at least postulate the possibility that the interdictio is the Test, since in this sort of literature there is a tendency to assimilate titles. It is entirely possible, however, that the Test never became sufficiently known in the West to call for a pronouncement against it. (e) The most important notice we have reserved to the last. In the Dialogue of Timothy and Aquila the Christian says, , [] , . The Jew replies, . , ' . The Christian accepts the correction: , , '
. This allusion is of value, not only for the sake of the help is gives us in dating the Test, as we shall see in the next section of our discussion, but also because the title appears here, and from the reference to the locusts we can be sure beyond a doubt that it is our Test to which reference is made; we also see that the Test was held in high honor in Christian circles. (f) Summary: the Christian use of the Testament. — One might expect to find more allusions to the Test in early Christian literature and more evidence of its use. But it was one of those books which circulated among the people without attracting literary attention. Moreover, it represents a passing, though very important, phase of theological development. As the world became more and more Christianized, it could not but prove unsatisfactory to Christian thinking, even in the revised form of Rec. B, and it had no vital attraction which could overcome the fatal weakness of its inconsistent combination of paganism and Christianity. The allusions to it in Timothy and Aquila, in the Hypomnesticon, and in Glycas are all we could rightly expect in view of its character.
IX. The Date of the Testament and Its Recensions
1. Previous opinions as to date. — Having studied our document on the linguistic and material sides and investigated its sources and relationships, we are prepared to attempt to date it. It will be an advantage first to summarize previous opinion on this point. a) Fleck regarded the Test as a Byzantine work belonging to the Middle Ages, but advanced no arguments to substantiate his conclusion. Likewise Istrin, who discovered MS D and recognized it as the basis of the Test, regarded the latter as belonging to the Middle Ages (c. 1200), though containing pre-Christian elements. b) Bornemann concluded that it belonged to the early fourth century, since its demonology resembled that of Lactantius in his Institutions. Toy accepts this verdict without investigation. Harnack merely refers to the Test in this fashion: "Verschiedene 'Testamente', so das des Salomo, deren Alter nicht zu bestimmen ist, und die vielleicht gar nicht in die ersten Jahrh. gehören". Schürer makes no attempt to fix the date, but thinks the passage from Leontius is especially to be considered in this connection.
c) After careful investigation Dr. Conybeare concludes, "It is impossible to say when and where the Christian elements present in the Testament were worked into it, but the stress only a loose epitome of III Reg IX 6—9a, with the addition of the phrase "et persecuti sunt regem suum dilectissimum et cruciauerunt illum in humilitate magna" (ibid. p. 360, II. 32ff.). It may well come from some Christian apocryphon (as Roensch supposed) which summarized O. T. history, or even from a Book of Solomon, but it can hardly have any connection with the Test. In humilitate magna does not necessarily imply the virgin birth, while in ultionem sanctae crucis (ibid. p. 359, l. 10) presents an anti-Semitism to which our document has no parallel. laid on the name Emmanuel and on its numerical value, on the writing of the name on the forehead, the use of the word -, the patripassian conceptions, all have a very archaic air, and seem to belong to about 100 A. D." "In its original [Jewish] form" it may be "the very collection of incantations which, according to Josephus, was composed and bequeathed by Solomon". Kohler accepts Conybeare's results and, as we have already seen, regards our document as representing pre-Talmudic demonology. Salzberger adopts the views of Kohler and Conybeare.
2. Conclusions. — Which of these dates can we adopt? Unfortunately there are in the work no historical allusions which can aid us. Yet one piece of external evidence immediately proves the late date adopted by Fleck and Istrin untenable, I mean, of course, the mention of the Test in the Dialogue of Timothy and Aquila. Conybeare's manuscript of the Dialogue belongs to the twelfth century, and he says of the work, "The title affixed to TA describes the debate as having taken place in the days of Archbishop Cyril, and to this date belong the allusions to the Trinity in foll. 75 v, 101 v, 103 r. But this title really no more than marks the time at which the work assumed its present form." The materials are in part much older. Since, however, we have no way of proving that the allusion to the Test belongs to the older stratum, our terminus ad quem must be set about the time of Cyril (died 444), that is at 400.
As to the terminus a quo we must conclude that it is 100 A. D., at which date Dr. Conybeare would place the Test, regarding the Jewish original as still earlier. But what Conybeare regards as the "Jewish original" was a book of incantations, while we have found the original to be only a story containing no exorcisms, as MS D shows, and the Test as such to have been a Christian work. The book which Eleazar in Josephus' story used may be represented by the Hygromanteia, or Clavicula; it cannot have been the Test, for a Jew would not have used such a Christian work, nor is it likely to have been written so early. Can we now date our document more precisely within the limits 100—400 A. D.? We are left to depend upon general considerations of language and subject matter. In view of the lateness of our manuscripts we cannot be absolutely sure of the linguistic evidence, but, as we have seen, it seems to point to a time when the Koiné was in full sway, after the New Testament was written, which merely confirms the general conclusion we have already reached.
As to the type of thought and the materials entering into the work, we come to conclusions differing from Conybeare's. The items upon which he most relies are found to belong to a secondary recension. The relation to the New Testament we have explained, by supposing the Test to depend, not upon pre-Gospel Synoptic tradition, but upon imperfect, perhaps auricular, knowledge of the written Gospels. The allusion to the corner stone, which might seem to imply a date before the idea of Christ as the corner-stone became common Christian property, proves nothing, for in the fourth and the sixth century we have the application of the same Old Testament passages to an actual corner stone. Rec. B belongs to the time when Christianity was conquering the world, but the original Test to the age of Alexander Severus and his lararium with Apollonius, Christ, Abraham, and Orpheus on an equal footing. As Conybeare well shows, its demonology is much like that which Celsus and Origen described. As it appears to the writer, without attempting to be too precise, the conditions of language and
X. Authorship and Provenience
and subject matter are best met by supposing the Test to have been written early in the third century. 3. Date of the original Jewish ground work. — Josephus shows that ideas of Solomon's character and his dealings with demons such as are found in d (the prototype of MS D and the Test) were common among the Jews already in the first century A. D., although they do not appear in the Talmud until the third century. Therefore d may be as early as the first century of the Christian era. At present our data allow no more precise date. 4. Date of the Recensions. — Rec. A, which differs but little from the original, probably underwent trifling changes with every transcription. The concluding sections (XXVI 8—10) belong to Byzantine times. For MS L the same man was probably editor and copyist, in mediaeval times. Rec. B may well belong to the fourth or fifth century, when Christianity was conscious of her conquest of the world, and her theology was being carefully formulated. Rec. C, although probably containing very old material, presents also much that smacks of the Middle Ages, and is apparently not much older than the manuscripts that preserve it. It may well belong to the twelfth or thirteenth century.
X. Authorship and Provenience.1. Authorship: Opinions. — As to the kind of individual who wrote the Test there are at least four possibilities: he may have been either a Jew or a Christian; if a Jew, either Aramaic or Greek speaking; if a Christian, either Jewish or Greek in origin. Gaster believes that originally the Test was written in Aramaic. Harnack, Conybeare, and Kohler think it to be a Christian revision of a Jewish work. Toy concludes, "the author of the Testament is a Greek speaking Jewish Christian". Schürer held it to be the work of a Christian with "no Jewish places" in it. 2. Authorship: Conclusions. — We have found Gaster's assumption of an Aramaic original untenable. Our new materials render the opinion that the Test was originally Jewish likewise impossible. Only the ground work, d, which was not a "testament", and certain of the materials were Jewish. Was the author, then, a Christian of Jewish or Gentile origin? A final answer can hardly be given. On the one hand, the abundance of Jewish material and the Jewish trust in angel names, on the other the plainly Christian and heathen elements worked into the warp and woof of the document point in opposite directions. However, if the date for which we have just argued is correct, there is no reason why a Greek Christian should not have written the whole work, for he would be heir of both Jewish and Gentile materials and much more likely than a Jewish Christian to combine them in his faith. In the third century also Christian Jews would be few. The probabilities, therefore, are in favor of Greek Christian authorship.
3. Provenience. — So far as I am aware, no one has attempted to decide from what part of the ancient world the Test came — perhaps wisely, for no certain conclusion can be reached. Three regions suggest themselves: Palestine, Egypt, and the province of Asia. Much is in favor of the first, particularly if one think of Galilee, where Judaism and Hellenism were in the closest contact, and where Christianity took its rise and won its first conquests. Again, as we have seen, some of the materials come from Egypt, and some appear in Ethiopia, which was Christianized from Egypt, while the only early literary allusion to the work by name is Egyptian. One would think that the sand storm demon, Lix Tetrax, had originated in a land like Palestine or Egypt, where such storms were familiar phenomena. Yet from Ac XIX 19 we see that "Asia" was probably as much a center of magic as Egypt, and if its climate had permitted, we should no doubt have an abundance of magical papyri from that region also.
Against Palestine is the fact that its popular Christianity was no doubt Aramaic rather than Greek speaking, while the Test, which is not the work of a leader in the church but of some uninstructed individual, is nevertheless thoroughly Greek in its language and much of its material. Against Egypt the strongest argument is the absence of Gnostic influence and of specific resemblances to the magic papyri. Against Ephesus or some part of "Asia" no decisive objections appear. In its favor are the only two geographical terms in the document, Lydia and Olympus. The very fact that the sand storm receives as its name two of the Ephesia grammata points — very weakly, to be sure — in the same direction. Like Egypt, Asia was a meeting place for all the currents of ancient thought. We are dealing only with probabilities; in a work that borrows so impartially from all lands, no marks are decisive. As it seems to the writer, the probabilities are to be ranged in ascending order, Galilee, Egypt, Asia. Farther one cannot go until more light is thrown upon the whole subject of demonology, magic, and astrology, as well as on Christian origins.
4. Provenience of the recensions. — As to the place of origin of Recs. A and B I see no possibility of arriving at a conclusion, unless Rec. B may be thought of as western on account of its western form of Solomon's seal, the pentagram. The manuscripts of Rec. C are so thoroughly Italian that one is tempted to suppose the recension originated in Greek-speaking southern Italy. MS D is, as we have seen, Byzantine in origin, but whether from Asia Minor or Europe one cannot say.

Source. English text by Chester Charlton McCown, from The Testament of Solomon, edited from manuscripts at Mount Athos, Bologna, Holkham Hall, Jerusalem, London, Milan, Paris, and Vienna, with introduction, by Chester Charlton McCown (Leipzig: J. C. Hinrichs, 1922; Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 9); public domain. The text was read by machine (Mistral OCR) from a scan from Cornell University Library at the Internet Archive and has not been proofread against the printed book. SermonIndex has removed running heads and page numbers, joined words split across lines, and divided the text into chapters and short sections; the wording is the author’s own. Footnotes and the editor’s introduction are left out. Only McCown’s English introduction is given here. His Greek text of the Testament with its critical notes, the appendices, the bibliography and the indexes are left out; Greek words quoted in the introduction are also left out. No original-language text is shown beside it, and no modern English version has been made.

Licence. The book was published in 1922 and is in the public domain.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate