Eighty rhythms in which Ephrem answers those who pry into the nature of God, and insists that the Son’s generation from the Father is to be believed and not examined. They are among his central works against the Arians and Anomoeans, written in Edessa about the middle of the fourth century. This page has 79 chapters and about 73,262 words.
The age of Nicaeac. AD 306–373Ephrem the Syrian79 chaptersEnglish translation: Public domain
INSTEAD of that all-quickening standard which He Who The Son's Generation incomprehensible to weak man. 107 teacheth all had set for us, a new faith hath this presumptuous generation made for us. He Who knoweth all knoweth what is the cause of their stirrings. If pride was the cause of them, may our Lord restrain its haughtiness, and if strife was the cause of them, may our Lord increase our harmony, and if love was the cause of them, may He reveal to them that be His, what is His. O thou that shootest at a great Mountain, fancy not that thine arrows have hit! from thyself they have gone a little way, and that standard they have not hit. For high is that Generation of the Son above the questioning of man. Set thyself a standard of thine own stock like that which is near thee, that by the testimony of what is near, that which is far may be believed. Let the soul be to thee a standard, for those that philosophize about it miss of it. For one confesses
Church. He that ordereth the successions of natures and creatures, He it is that ordered the successions of Prophets and of Apostles from one age even to another. Blessed be He that begun and perfecteth." If instead of 'traditions' we render successions, as may be done, still he plainly contemplates doctrine as delivered through those successions. Again, vol. i. p. 454, f. he says, "When thou hearest of the well-ordered ministry of Solomon's princes, and the exact arrangement of those who brought the supply of bread to the great congregation of men and women, and purveyed hay and barley for the stallions and the horses, bethink thyself of the all-pervading beautiful order which Immanuel has stamped upon His Church. For these spiritual princes nourish all the children of the Church in their order: the chief shepherds, to wit, offer deep things to the perfect, and to penitents and those that stand without the gates they bring hay and barley—not that these mysteries are barley and hay, but that men such as those, have their conversation like the beasts, and consequently are not nourished as rational men. Nourished however they are, seeing we give nourishment even to beasts; as the Prophet says, Thou, Lord, shalt save both man and beast." These passages bring out the force of the first sentence; they shew St. E. to conceive of the faith as somewhat substantive, as held by the Church only, as old, and so opposed to the new doctrine, and lastly, as dispensed by the Church. It may be added that the
word [a] is used for a mark or butt to aim at, in which sense it corresponds to the [a]n[as]i[as]i[as] [a]n[as] of St. Athanasius, c. Arian. iii. §. 28. As the soul may be a standard for the natural reason to aim at, so God is for the reason enlightened by Baptism: see note b, on p. 87. The soul unable to comprehend that it exists, another [says] that it existeth not. One puts it in subjection to death e, another above the power of death. One maketh it out of something, and another, out of nothing f. He that sees its greatness makes it a small part of somewhat great g, and he that sees its evanescence, maketh it a breath of air. There is that maketh it a breathing, and there is also that calleth it blood h. One that seeth its fieriness, says that it is of fire i, another that seeth its viewlessness j, lays down that it is of the wind. One makes it a part of God k, and another an inspiration [from God]. One maketh it of one essence, and another of many essences l. There is that maketh it of one element, and there is that maketh it of seven m compounded elements n. There is that magnifieth and extols its nature, and there is that degradeth its race and maketh it little. If then in regard to the bewildered soul, that which even dreams bewilder, men of research be so bewildered as to have
aim, as follows, i That the soul is incomprehensible appears from this: of those who have disputed about the soul, (to pass over the rife and endless battling about it,) some have said that it did not exist, some that it did; some have doubted. If then the dogmatists allow that this is a controversy which cannot be settled, they do thereby allow the incomprehensibility of the soul. j Pyrrh. Hyp. ii. 5. p. 74. Fabr.
come short of it, who is able to trace out that untraceable Generation? Come let us wonder at him who says of the soul that it does not exist, for when the soul is even dwelling in him, it yet disputes against itself, it rejects itself, in that it says of its own essence that it exists not. The soul that gropeth not out its own self, [so as to know] whether it exists or exists not, sufficeth not to feel itself. How should it, which is at a loss what to say of itself, be able to search out Him by Whose S. hands it was created. Though in its proper nature not to be which grinds seen, its own mirror is, to let it see that it exists: in this, [the its gift of] speech, hath the soul been able to see itself, forasmuch mouth as it is by that gift that its glory is greater than that of the dumb animals. While then the soul exists, yet to itself it exists not, to its knowledge. For how can it not exist? for see! it is comprehended by its workings; and when from the Creator it existed, it perished by its own free-will. If then in regard to all this the soul rejecteth its true nature, and feeleth not its own majesty; this soul that denieth itself, what is there that it shall be able to confess to exist as it really does? And if the soul misseth of the very investigation of its own self, what shall it seek out by its searching? what shall it comprehend by its questioning? and if it be so far from itself, how shall it find the Secret One?
If then our knowledge knows not how to know itself, how shall it dare to raise difficulties about the Generation of Him that knoweth all things? The thing made that knoweth not itself, how should it seek into its Maker? The mighty Nature, that never was not, is spoken of by all mouths. The mouth that willeth to speak of That which is unspeakable, bringeth Him to littleness, in that it sufficeth not for His greatness. Every one then that wisheth to magnify God exceedingly, as He is great in His own Nature, himself in magnifying Him is magnified in Him. Restrain searching which sufficeth not [to reach] Him, and gain silence, which is becoming, of Him. Give me, Lord, to use them both discerningly, that I may neither search rashly, nor be silent carelessly. Teach me words of edification, and make me gain the silence of discernment.
1. Blessed be he that hath fixed him up the delicate mirror of truth, and hath seen therein Thy Generation, which is too great for any tongues! Blessed be he that hath been brought near to the knowledge of truth, and hath learnt by it that God cannot be searched out by any man! Blessed he who lxx.§.1. hath been, Lord, a sailor of Truth in this generation, whose faith also hath not lost its savour among the savourless that pry into Thee! Blessed he that hath surrounded his hearing with the wall of silence, and through it have never broken the questionings of the wise that have fought with Thee! xx.§.3. Blessed he that hath let the wings of the Spirit grow secretly on him, and because there was questioning upon earth, hath left it and gone up to Heaven! Blessed he again that hath been a sailor for his Faith, and from the storms of controversy hath fled into the port of Silence! Blessed also be he that lvii.§.4. hath felt that the language of his mouth was weak, and the womb of it cannot suffice for that unutterable Generation! Blessed he that hath withheld his tongue from relating the Procreation, which is not allowed him [to speak of]! Blessed he that hath punished himself for ought that he has pried into S. whose harp sings thereof! Blessed he that hath tuned his harp with Psalms which David sung, with plain things that are not to be questioned, and obscure that are not to be searched into!
Blessed he that hath made him a measure of truth every day, and hath weighed therein all his questionings that he may not raise superfluous questions! Blessed he that hath made Him a just measure, which is meted with that of the Prophets and Apostles, the measure that Righteousness hath made! Blessed he that weigheth his searching by the edification of his hearers, and it is not too light, lest it should be wanting, nor too heavy, lest it be sunk! Blessed he that hath not passed over the boundary in his haste, and also he whose delay laboureth for peace, and findeth it! Blessed be he that seeks laboriously for that which he is competent to find! Blessed he that does not distract himself with investigating the Incomprehensible! Blessed he whose tongue hath been to Thee, Lord, as of a harp, and who sings with it sounds able to heal those that hear them!
2. Blessed be he, Lord, that hath gained the Truth which sustaineth the weak, whose verity also is as a staff to the feeble-minded! Blessed he whose doctrine is good leaven, so that he thereby communicates a right taste to the foolish who is unleavened! Blessed he that cleanseth his disputation as a mirror for them that are lacking in faith, that they may by it clear off their spots! Blessed he whose speech is as a medicine of life, and he quickeneth the spiritually dead that lift themselves up against Him that quickeneth all! Blessed he that is dumb what time Thy Generation is pried into! Blessed he that becometh a trumpet what time Thy Generation is proclaimed! 3. Blessed he that knoweth, Lord, that the power of searching after Thee is hard to obtain! Blessed he that knoweth how sweet is the taste of speaking Thy praise! Blessed be he, Lord, that giveth not his mouth to be a Evils of disputatiousness.
conduit for the foolish questionings that well forth from glozing disputers! Blessed he, Lord, whose tongue is a pure vessel, and he speaketh therewith the Truth that floweth down from Prophets and Apostles! Blessed he that hath not tasted the gall of wisdom of the Greeks! Blessed he that hath not let slip the simplicity of the Apostles!
1. Blessed be he, Lord, who, in great love, hath been worthy to call Thee beloved Son, which [Name] God Thy Father Himself called Thee! Blessed he, Lord, that hath weaned his mouth from all questionings and hath called Thee the Son of God, which [Name] the Holy Ghost called Thee! Blessed he, Lord, Ps. 2, 7. &c. who hath been worthy to believe in simplicity and to call Thee 'Son,' as all the Prophets and Apostles called Thee! ab. p. 111,n.d. Blessed he that knoweth, Lord, that Thy Majesty is unsearchable, and hath rebuked his tongue speedily that by silence p. 110. he might honour Thy Generation! Blessed he, Lord, that hath obtained a hidden eye wherewith to see how the Angels turn abashed from Thee, and how shamelessly man dealeth! See iv. §. 1. Blessed he, Lord, that hath expanded his mind, and hath contemplated Thee, how that creatures cannot attain to Thee, and hath given Thee thanks, because he hath been worthy of having Thee to dwell in him! Blessed be he that knoweth, Lord, that Thou art God, the Son of God, and knoweth himself whose son he is—a mortal the son of a mortal! Blessed he that hath reflected that Adonai is Thy Father, and hath also remembered his own generation, that he is a Son of Adam of the dust! Blessed he that hath reflected that the Angels by silence confess Thee, and hath speedily chidden with himself because his tongue has been so daring! Blessed he that hath understood that the heavens above were still, and the earth below was moved, and hath quieted his soul whilst among the waves [thereof]! Blessed he, Lord, that Angels leave what man boldly prieth into.
hath learnt that the Seraph crieth, 'Holy,' and is still, that the Seraphim search not at all, and that hath left alone what the Seraphim leave, and hath chosen what the Seraphim chose! 2. Who then is not astonished that Thou art sitting at the Right Hand, and that dust which sitteth upon dust upon its dunghill searcheth into Thee! Blessed, Lord, be he that knoweth that Thou art in the Bosom of the [Divine] Essence, and hath remembered that himself is fast falling into the bosom of the earth his mother! Who, Lord, is not astonished that Thou art the Creator of all creatures, that man essayeth to search into Thee, and yet knoweth not what his own soul is! This is a wonder that it is Thou, Lord, alone that knowest Thy Father, and yet vile dust lifteth itself up even to search into Thy Father in Thee, O Lord! Blessed he, Lord, that by his conversation hath become godlike, who, as having sanctified himself, calleth Thee God, the Son of God!
1. A thousand thousands stand, ten thousand ten thousands run: thousands and ten thousands are not able to search into One: for all of them in silence stand to minister. He hath no assessor save the Son who is from Him: within the Silence [alone] is there investigation into Him. If the Angels had come to search, they had met the Silence, and been restrained. The First-Born entered the belly, and the pure Virgin suffered not. He went in, and came forth in pangs, and the Fair One perceived Him. Glorious and hidden was His entering in: vile and visible His coming forth, for He was God in His going in, and Man in His coming forth. A wonder and an astonishment to hear! Fire went into the Belly, and clothed himself with a Body and came forth! Gabriel gave the Name of 'Lord' to Him Who is the Lord of Angels. He called Him 'Lord' that he might teach that He was his Lord, and not his fellow-servant. Michael was Gabriel's fellow-servant. The Son is the Lord of servants: High is His Nature as is His Name. The servant cannot search Him
a 'Silence' '' '' is used of God by Dionys. Areop. de Div. Nom. p. 841. which Corderius (p. 848.) says, is used, "because neither can we by speech declare God, nor doth He thereby so declare Himself to us as that we can know Him perfectly as He is." b 'Suffered,' will apply to mind or body. St. Hil. de Trin. iii. §. 19. 'She begat a perfect Man without having ought that was her's minished.' See on xviii. fin. The received doctrine is, that as Christ entered the house in spite of the doors being shut, so He came forth from the Blessed Virgin without opening the gate of her womb. See Petav. de Incarn. x. 6. §. 3. and Assem. in Oper. Gr. iii. (p. 41.) Huet. Origenian ii. 4. §. 2. who quote Pseud.-Orig. Hom. in div. Theod. Dial. 2. p. 79. St. Aug. de Civ. D. xxii. 8. §. 21. Jerom. c. Pel. ii. §. 4. St. Ambr. Epist. 81. (42. §. 4. Bened. whom see on Comm. in Luc. ii. §. 57.) St. Hormisd. Epist. 79. Greg. Magn. Hom. 26. §. 1. in Evan. besides several passages from the Opera Graeca of St. E. e. g. vol. ii. p. 265. "Mary neither suffered as a woman, nor had she the pains in bringing forth as a Virgin." See above, p. 40. and 46.
where he speaks of the womb as sealed, an expression used by Origen and others, and taken from Cant. iv. 12. The 'pangs' he mentions presently (if not those of Compassion) may of course be quite consistent with this, as they may have preceded Child-birth. particularly of the Incarnation and Omnipresence. 117 had begun to enquire into Thy appearance among things created, they comprehended not how, by running up and down, to come to a stand in their search into Thee. For See p. 24. they saw Thee in the depth, they saw Thee above on high; they saw Thee in the sepulchre, they saw Thee in the chamber, they saw Thee dead, they found Thee a raiser of the dead: they were amazed, they were astonied, and had no strength left. 4. In every place is Thy mysterious Presence, Lord, and S. Thy mystery from every place Thou art withdrawn. Though Thy mysterious Presence be in the height, yet it feeleth not that Thou art what Thou art. Though Thy mysterious Presence be in the depth, is it not comprehended what it is. Though Thy mysterious Presence be in the sea, from the sea Thou art concealed: though Thy mysterious Presence be in the dry land, it knoweth not that Thou art He. Blessed be the glorious hidden One, since even Thy little mystery is a fountain of mysteries! who is able to clear up mysteries that fail not? If a man were to take a likeness of Thee it would be a fountain whence all likenesses would flow, and to what shall Ps. 139.
Silence and prayer more becoming than prying, we be able to look and shadow out Thy Image upon our heart. In Thy one adorable Image ten thousand beauteous things are crowded together. 5. Wondrous art Thou altogether on all sides that we seek Thee! Thou art near and far off. Who shall approach to Thee? No searching is able to extend and reach unto Thee. When it had reached itself forth to approach, it was intercepted and stopped short. It is too short to reach Thy mountain; faith does find it, and love with prayer. Imagining and recommended by Scripture and the example of Angels. 119 7. And if there be a mode of seeking Him out, come let us seek out the hidden One; come, let us in astonishment feel after Him if He can be comprehended! Thou art revealed, Lord, to babes and hidden from the cunning; to him that believeth Thou art found, to him that searcheth Thou art hidden. Blessed be he that is simple in searching out Thee and vigorous at Thy promise. Searching, Lord, is too little to glorify Thee within itself. The power that extendeth unto every place is able to search for Thee, in the height to shadow Thee forth, and in the depth to feel after Thee, but though reaching to every place is not able to find out Thee. Blessed be he that hath felt that [only] in the Bosom of Thy Father is the enquiry into Thee fully set at rest.
8. The Seraph that is winged and flieth is too weak to search Thee out; his wing is weak in comparison of Thee, so as not to measure with Thy Majesty. In Thy Bosom are the worlds laid; how much soever one would wander into it, one is hindered. The Seraph whose voice proclaims Thee Holy, in reverential silence keeps from search into Thee.. and Woe unto him that is bold, when the Seraph before Thee with his wings covereth his face! The Cherubs bear that Mighty One Who beareth all. Bowing downwards do the hosts of the Cherubim in fear beneath Thy chariot... and the hosts of the Cherubim in fear beneath Thy chariot... and the rest of the Cherses and fear to gaze therein, carrying yet not able to find Him, trembling when approaching. Blessed he that hath learnt the honour due to Thee from them, and hath praised and been silent in fear!
1. THE knowledge of Angels searcheth in measure, the knowledge of men without measure goeth roaming. Thy mercy put in Thy way inns and milestones that the unsettled disputers might come into order. Blessed he that hath measured his wonder with his knowledge so as to reach the inns. The knowledge of man to the knowledge of an Angel is like a feeble twilight, and even the knowledge of Angels to the knowledge of the Spirit is as a little twinkling. [Yet] the Spirit Is. 53, 8. saith of the Son, 'Who hath declared His generation?' Rashn. f. ness is for running on and passing over the boundary which the Spirit came up to and was still. Degrees of knowledge as of created beings different. 121 stretch himself unto aught that is greater than his own measure. Hereto nature witnesseth by the subordination that is therein*, for rank leadeth unto rank unto that which is the crown: and also the counsels of Jethro made subordinations from degree to degree even up to Moses himself. Men, who are of vile degree, trespass over the degrees of Angels to come up to the First-born and search into Him!
3. It was not, Lord, from envy in Thee, that Thy works were less than Thee; the work can never be made equal with its Maker. It were a fearful blasphemy if it could be made equal to Him, since the servant would be companion of his Lord, and the Lord fellow-servant of His servant. Blessed be he who hath felt that it was in His love that the Lord condescended and the Maker put on the work. There is no
* We have already seen above, n. b. p. 107. St. E.'s way of arguing from analogy upon such subjects: as it is a common habit with him so to argue, an instance or two shall be here added; on Numbers xi. 25. p. 257. he says, "God took of the Spirit that was on him and gave it to the seventy elders. As the fruits of trees receive the juice that distils from their branches, so the seventy elders felt the Spirit which distilled from Moses and entered into them. And again, the sense (of the text) is not that He minished him, but it explains how it was from Christ that all intellectual Spirits received." On Numbers i. he says, p. 250, e. "Here is a type of the twelve Apostles, by whose means the chosen below were enrolled in the Church on earth, but those above perhaps by the head of their order. That he did not number the tribe of Levi with Israel, although he was of Israel, is again a type of the Saints, who although they be of the world, yet are not reckoned of the world: The Archangels too are higher than their companies, as the head is above the members." Again, on Joshua, p. 305, c. "By those that dwell in cities are typified those that stand in the rank of virtues and powers and dominions; those again who have their portion in country places are a semblance of those who stand in a lower contemplation, as Principalities and Angels." And on 1 Kings iv. p. 454. a. Of the different provisions for the king's table he says, "first take thee in the fine flour, a type
of those Angels, that without a veil, see the things of God, and are counted worthy to see the mysteries from God without the mediation of others. And these be like the fine flour, because it is by a light clear and pure that they are enlightened, and are in their essence pure without spot and without mixture. These are they whom we account Seraphim and Cherubim. But those who eat flower mixed with bran, are those [men] who hitherto have not attained to a capability for the pure light, for hitherto they have not attained a mind pure and perfect every whit, but there is over them a covering like to the bran, &c." See also vol. i. p. 269. We see here that he holds men and Angels to see God in very different ways; and that in spite of his holding as St. Thomas did, that Angels see God without any medium, he also holds in the text, that Angels themselves see Him in different degrees.
† This seems to have been originally suggested by Plato, (Tim. §. 10. "He who established this universe was good, and in him who is good doth no envy ever at any time have place,") and is used in a similar way by St. E. R. xlvi. §. 2. St. Athan. c. Gent. §. 41. St. Greg. Naz. p. 16. d. p. 543. d. St. Gr. Nys. c. Eun. p. 372. a. xxi. §. 2. St. Epiphan. i. p. 959. a. If Arianism grew out of Platonism, we should not forget any service the heathen did to orthodoxy, especially when (as Heindorf notices) he is opposing the current heathen notion of the enviousness of the Divinity. ‡ i. e. put on our nature. Christ takes our names, gives us His. work of His that can be compared unto its Maker. For not even are the names of the two equal and more than the names are p. 133. they themselves unequal. The Lord willed in His love to make His servants share in His names. Priests and kings by grace clad on Thy surnames, and Moses and Joshua Thy names.
4. Merciful was the Lord in that He also clad on our names; Met. 13, even to a grain of mustard seed He condescended to compare Himself. He gave unto us His Names, He took from us our names. His Names made us great, our names made Him small. Blessed be he who covered his own name with Thy goodly Name, and hath ornamented with Thy Name his own names: Let nature be a furnace unto us p. 133. for the word of truth. Lo, the sun is all of him visible to the eye of all; it is not that he is in any thing concealed that the eye cannot search into him. The whole of him is visible before it, yet can it not see one hundredth part of him. In the sun is revealed Thy hidden Generation, and who can gaze upon the might thereof? Analogies in air and colour to God's pervading presence. 123
Breath all depend; It beareth all without weariness; in His fulness they all dwell, and as in an empty space they abide. He is too great to be hidden in any thing. Lo! He is covered though not hidden, for with Himself He veileth Himself. 6. Parallels to the air, hath He made thee also in the colours; by them hath He shadowed thee out a likeness of the Eternal, Who [Himself] cannot be shadowed out. For He is near us and far off; though He is in us, He is not; and though the creation is in Him, it is as though it were not in Him; though
to quote some passages here to shew how strongly he (in common with other writers before Pelagian times) expressed himself upon man's freedom, as the weight of the passage in the text cannot otherwise be duly appreciated. Vol. ii. p. 326. b. "If Enoch, that lived, found no way to live without the Tree of Life, who is there that can live without the living Son, Whose fruit giveth life to all? No man can gain a reward proportioned to his labour save by justice: no man can receive one greater than his labour save by grace. Whose labour then sufficeth for the price of the Kingdom and receiveth in justice so as not to inherit by grace? There is a drop by justice and the rest by grace. The labour of justice (i. e. which in justice requires reward) is the cause to the Giver, to give for the little great riches without measure. Neither is He blameable for adding, who addeth thus to all things. For a mortal man's scant labour in the stead of much persuadeth that he will hereafter work: for were he to prolong his life, then his labours had been great. Wherefore it is justice while it is also grace, for it would have been justice had his life been prolonged." Again ib. p. 461, e. he says, "Thou that art our Healer, heal our free-will: healed may it be by Thee, and by Thee forgiveness gain. Refuse not to assist it, for in Thee its health also standeth. O mighty gift, whereby Thou hast made us greater than the seas that are fettered by their boundaries, than the earth, the heaven, and the mountains that without are very small! May our Lord visit our mind, the will whereof is enfeebled by its wealth, and its thoughts by its possessions, and by its desires enfeebled is its power. For evil, if man willetth not, does not exist, like darkness which
existeth not if it be light, or a forest, if it be let run wild, for want of tilling. ...Blessed be the Creator of free-will, the handmaid to whom He hath given power over the soul. Who is to hide free-will that is as the sun shining in the firmament? who deny its dominion whereof the power is as God in might? comp. (vol. i. p. 120.) quoted in p. 117. n. k. ...Blessed be He that plaited the commandments that by them free-will might be crowned! Blessed be He that hath made just men numerous, to be witnesses that cry aloud concerning free-will." See xxv. §. 3. xxviii. §. 2. xxxi. §. 2. lxxix. §. 3. contr. Scrut. i. §. 35. Again, vol. i. p. 143, a. speaking of Cain he says; "if thou doest not well, sin lieth at the door of thy heart; these words go to shew, that God wisheth man's repentance and waiteth for him to return, and exciteth and giveth opportunities which are a call thereto. They shew also that man has power over himself and a liberty of willing. Lo, sin lieth at the door of thy mind like to a fanged beast at the door of a house, if thou turn thee to it, it will get it power over thee." St. E., as other Fathers, when arguing with fatalists, insists on the fact of man's freedom, and does not go into the question of the way in which he became free. See his de Lib. Arbitrio, iii. p. 359. Petavius de Deo ix. 4. and 5. notices how the earlier writers have been causelessly impeached, and may yet be defended upon this subject.
The Son is as unsearchable as the Father, Ps. 31, no one is able to veil himself in Him, yet He covereth him in Himself. We have shadowed forth for the sake of our quietness the Eternal that cannot be felt: let us not explore Him, but let us depart and go forth by the straight course to silence. If a blind man shall touch a living coal to explore it, its brightness profiteth him not, but its heat burneth him. So doth a hidden Essence harm them that search into it, but them that worship it, it advantageth. yet is Light, Life, and Health to the good and humble. 125 interest" with Him, that we may demand it of Him Mat. 25, again. 9. Praise thou the hidden Light by means of the gleaming from Him; hard is it for the eye of the soul to look at the secret Light. By means of the shining from Him it is able to go p. 87, to meet Him. He sent forth a brightness from Himself to n. h. them that sit in darkness. He turned away their eyes from the beauty of worthless things to the beauty of Him that sent Him. Wonder is there and astonishment at our age! for p. 107, there are bruises in our bodies, and scars in our souls, and n. d. seams in our spirits. Instead then of searching out where there was medicine suited for us, we have probed our Physician, and have searched into His nature and birth. Oh, how bitter is our wound! It is with the Physician that chaseth away our pangs that we have bruised our own selves.
10. May Thy faith be in my mind a curdle which, when poured into it, may thicken my thoughts from prying and p. 98, straying. I will knock at Thy gate, O Lord, that Thy gift §. 5. may dwell upon me in righteousness, that my poverty may come and be suddenly enriched, for it oweth ten thousand talents. O Lord, do Thou make me a debtor, that I may make Thee pay interest from what is Thine own.
1. How then can a man miss of the True One, when the True One is a great Mountain that may be seen even by the blind? For who does not perceive by the word 'Father' that He has a Son; it was not because He was in need that He begat Him, seeing that He Who begat Him lacketh nothing; neither did any causes beget Him, the Father Himself in His Love begat the Glorious Son. The eye is too weak to gaze upon the great might of the sun. He maketh his intenseness dim, he softeneth down his vehemence, his ray doth spread itself abroad, and cometh down unto the eye. Without the Son of the Hidden no one hath seen the Hidden one; for He is concealed from His works. By His Son is the Essence seen which cannot be seen. In the Ray from Various veils, thro' which man is visited by Christ, his Creator. 127
Himself He softened His wondrous might; for our Strength-ener would not weaken. He was pleasing unto us, when He softened it for us. By a ray we have represented Him, not that this is indeed like Him, for there is nothing which accurately shadoweth forth Him. He lets Himself be shadowed forth in similitudes, that according to our strength we may learn Him in His blessed dispensations. 2. For in bread the Strong One that cannot be eaten, is eaten. In strong wine also is drunk the Power which cannot be drunk. We also anoint ourselves in oil with the Power which cannot be used as ointment. And as He hath softened Himself for the mouth in pleasant meats, and it eateth Him, so He hath made the sight of Himself soft to the eye. He hath softened His might in words, so that the ear may also hear Him. Amongst those conceived Thou art marvellous: amongst those born Thou art glorious: amongst the baptized Thou art approved: amongst the redeemed Thou art desirable: amongst the sacrificed Thou art slain: amongst pleasant meats Thou art eaten: among the Prophets Thou art mingled: in the Apostles Thou art mixed: the whole of Thee, Lord, is in all: in the deep Thou art buried: in the height Thou art worshipped!
3. In the beginning then by the First-born were the works created. For God said, Let there be light, and it was created. To whom then did He give the command, for as yet nothing existed? Now if He had given the command to light, He would not have commanded it to be, for He said, Let there be light. For this word 'it was,' is different from Gen. 1, 'let it be.' He evidently intended the First-born when He created Adam, [saying,] Let Us make man in Our Image, according to Our Likeness. It were blindness to think that then too weak to create in silence? Or the sounds which He spake did He give them a body, so that they became the works h? Both these alternatives are untenable i; that 1 S. are which is third is tenable, viz. that it was to the Second 2 S. are Person 2 that He gave the command; for if a man should say 2 S. His that God gave the command to the work to be created 3, this 3 Second is confuted in Adam, since He said not to him, let Us make 3 Iossenman in Our image; it was not to His companion i that He 3 See spake, nor yet to His servant did He give the command. 11, 34. It was not meet that a servant should be made by his fellow-servant. All of them were created by the Son.
5. A thing made is too little to create, along with the Creator, the creation. There is no other Eternal 4 to be as a 4 or partaker with Him; servant and associate fail, and the Only. 4 Son begotten Son remains, who was not to be commanded as a servant, nor be put on an equality with a companion. His Son sufficed for His voice. Blessed be the Eternal that softened the might of His voice in His Son k. For behold the First-born how different He is from companions, and from servants how diverse! For He is high and yet humbled Himself. He is lifted up above servants and lowered more than companions. He is not numbered with servants, neither is He reckoned with companions. He is raised up above both; He is not servant, since He is Son; He is not companion, since He is First-born. The true One is plainly revealed to him that willeth to see Him. The six days that were created bear witness on six sides; they proclaim to the four quarters, and to the height, and to the depth, that it was not the things made which He commanded to make themselves; by One, from One, were they created. The Father gave the command with His voice; the Son finished the work.
The words of Creation discussed. 6. It is very plain, that if He commanded the earth to bring forth, it was fitting that He should speak in the way of command with the earth also, as He said unto Eve, in sorrow shalt thou bring forth; instead of saying, let it bring forth, He would have said, 'bring forth.' It was His Son Himself Who set and planted it: by the Tree of Life alone, the Planter shadowed out His own Likeness. He knew how to make it known, that He was speaking with water, as He knew how to make it known, that He was speaking with Cain. When He said, let them bring forth fruit abundantly, He would have said, 'Bring ye forth abundantly.' For His speaking to them was different from that to others. His beloved Son He charged to create the beloved fishes and the beautiful birds. He that knoweth all things provided, that in the forming of man He should reveal the greatness of the First-born. He saw that of all His works the son of Adam was perverted. He revealed His Son openly, that whoso denied the First-born, him might Adam his father, who by the First-born was created, refute; when he was not, by Him He created him, and when he sinned and went astray, in Him He called him.—Jesus, Thou glorious Name, thou hidden bridge that carrieth over from death to life, at Thee have I arrived and stand still! in J Thy initial I am detained; be a bridge to my speech that I may pass over to Thy truth. Thy love is a bridge to Thy servant; by Thee shall I pass over to Thy Father; I will pass over and say, blessed be He that softened down His might in His Son!
and the seven indicates the creature by reason of the life and body. For in the former there are three things, whence it comes that God is to be loved with all the heart, with all the soul, and with all the mind; in the body the four elements, of which it consists, are quite obvious." This meaning of four occurs in St. E. i. p. 233 d. f. of our Lord's Body. As persons of late years found mysteries in the name Latinus, or as alpha and omega are insisted on in Holy Writ, so was Christ's holy name of old. St. E. may refer to what was obvious enough to devotional people of the day. Didymus de Trin. p. 264. treats in a like way of the word -. The proposed emendation requires the change of a single letter: how far the present letter in the codices may be like the proposed one, in default of any accurate description of the character used in them, (known to me,) I cannot judge; but I think there is strong internal evidence in its favour which I proceed to state.
It is a thing very much to be observed, as bearing not only on this, but on other passages, that St. Ephrem's manner is not to quote Scripture, but to allude to it. Now whoever reads over this section, must see, at first sight, that something, supposed to be known, is wanting to make the connection between its parts clear. St. John 1, 18, which has in the Syriac the very word proposed, will supply this want. In the Syriac it runs thus: 'No man hath seen God at any time: God, the Only-Begotten, Who is in the Bosom of His Father, He hath declared Him.' Assume that St. E. is expecting his readers to be familiar with this text, and the passage becomes clear: insist on the present reading, and the allusion is lost. Next, the word , (which it may seem to a Syriac scholar super-erogatory to assert,) is in frequent use with St. Ephrem for the Womb, or Bosom of the Father. As the passages in which it occurs, will of course throw light upon the passage in question, it may be useful to put some of them together here.
(§. 1.) One of them has occurred already in R. iii. §. 2. "Blessed, Lord, be he that knoweth that Thou art in the Bosom of the [Divine] Essence, and hath remembered that himself is fast falling into the bosom of the earth, his mother." See also §. 7. and ix. 45. (§. 2.) In lx. §. 3. he says, "Leave ye unto God Himself the names that He called His Son: He affirmed that He begat Him from His own Bosom, (or Womb,) yet not after our custom, but in a way above it, and all-wonderful." (§. 3.) And §. 5. 'The Holy One in [His Name] Eternal,' is consistent with His Eternity, in [His Name] 'Just,' with His Justice, in [His Name] 'Good,' with His Goodness: in these He is consistent; and how comes His Fatherhood to be different, in that it is inconsistent with Itself, if [that is] He has no glorious Son from His Bosom?' Here besides the we have the same epithet of the Son .
(§. 4.) Contr. Scrut. i. §. 2. fin. "If thou canst find out the Father, then along with Him shalt thou find out the Son? He is with His Mouth when commanding, with His Arm when He ordereth things. By Him He worketh, by Him likewise He commands: the One for the Other alone sufficeth: in His Bosom is He when He embraceth, &c." (§. 5.) Ib. §. 14. 'The Father, in whose Bosom is the Son, alone knoweth, &c.' And iii. §. 10. 'If thou canst measure that Eternal One, then thou hast measured the Son, that is from His Bosom.' Vol. ii. p. 330. a. 'Our Lord Jesus Christ rose unto us from the Bosom of His Father.' Ibid. p. 472. 'Praise thou the Son that dwelleth in His Bosom, and possesseth all things.' (§. 6.) To these passages shall be added one, in which I suspect there is the same mistake as in the text, as it will serve as an introduction to two or three other The use of the word 'Bosom' illustrated
passages, that will be found to bear upon the doctrine in the text. It occurs contr. Serut. i. §. 30. "How should a fruit be named so, if in reality it were not so? Name thou the Father 'Root,' surname the Son as His 'Fruit.' He is blended with Him, and distinct from Him. He is in His Bosom, and on His Right Hand. For if He were not blended with Him, then His Beloved were not in His Bosom. If again He were not distinct from Him, He would not be sitting at His Right Hand. Blended with Him is He, seeing He is in His Bosom, distinct from Him, seeing He is on His Right Hand. They are One in one Will: They are Two in two Names: They have not two Wills. They have two appellations. The Name of Fatherhood belongeth to the Father: His Name guardeth His Honour. The Name of Generateness belongeth to the Son, His Name guardeth His Generation," &c. see the place. Presently he adds, "Fruit and tree also are not one, though they are one. The fruit is known as the fruit, and the tree as the root. In one equal love are they mingled." Perhaps 'bosom' should be substituted here.
As then St. E. co frequently uses the word 'Bosom' in the sense here contemplated, as he uses it in a similar connection in (3.) to that of the present context, as a reference to St. John i. 18. will clear up the abrupt transition to the Incarnation; as the phrase the Father Himself seems to have so little force with the present reading; it seems not unlikely that the first letter of the word bosom is wrong. The context with the proposed reading would be capable of some such paraphrase as this: Though human eyes cannot gaze at the Son, as He is in the Bosom of the Father, as neither can they at the sun's light in its bosom; still in His Dispensation for man's good, the Son may be beheld. As St. E. is writing against the Anomoeans, it may serve further to illustrate the text, if some passages are put together which tend to shew that his view of doctrine is such as would preclude his sympathizing much with the Semi-arian way of opposing them. To the Anomoean tenet that the Son was unlike the Father, the Semi-arians opposed their statement, that He was in all things like ( not ), and by this rejection of the precluded the possibility of asserting that They have one Will except
figuratively, as brethren, who dwell together at unity, have one will. Doubtless the tone of the Semi-arians in many cases was better than their statements implied: still likeness of substance is not sameness, and therefore implies unlikeness, as St. Austin has on another matter observed, (c. Faust. Man. xvi. §. 15.) and as the Semi-arians at Ancyra (ap. Epiphan. i. p. 855. a.) seem to have seen. Neither am I able to see how the Two Persons, if not consubstantial, can possibly be conceived (save figuratively) to have one Will. So Greg. Nys. ii. p. 376. d. "The identity of choices () necessarily indicates the community of nature in those that so choose." This (as has been shewn me) was proved by passages from the Fathers to be their usual doctrine, in the Latoran Council in A.D. 649. see Harduin's Conc. vol. iii. p. 858. Petav. de Trin. iv. 15.
The doctrine of the Perichoresis is taught in the passage just given from St. E., the perfect in-dwelling of One Person in the Other being expressed by the word I have rendered 'blended,' which, as is plain from this and other passages, (see above, p. 34, n. g. and xl. §. 1.) does not imply any confusion. Vol. ii. p. 471. d. puts his view on this point beyond a doubt. "One Name hath the Eternal, who hath none other that is equal to Him. But if He (be repeated in His Son, i. e.) is two owing to having a Son, how can He dwell in Him when He is not generate from Him? Great perplexity seeing that if the two eternals dwell in each other, lo! there is confusion with blasphemy. But if it be space in which they dwell, then the space is greater than the eternal, seeing it limiteth the same. It is clear that if Eternal dwell in Eternal, either He is His Son, or of His framing. But if the eternals dwell from everlasting each in his own place, &c." Here he is arguing against the Manichean notion of two eternal principles; he winds up with the passage just quoted §. 5. from p. 472, "Praise thou the Son, &c." and assumes the doctrine of the Perichoresis to be known, and that it will at once clash with the Manichean doctrine. To speak of a co-eternal Son in a co-eternal Father is consistent: to speak of a bad and good principle mutually indwelling in each other is inconsistent, and must lead to the assumption of a space in which they dwell, and which is greater than they. See on St. Austin's Confess. p. 314.
To return to the 'one Will.' In vol. ii. p. 396. O. G. he says on his death-bed, "Not by the Three Names of Fire, not by their One Movement and Will, have I ever doubted touching the Church or the power of God: If I have magnified the Father more than His Son in my mind, may He shew no mercy on me, or if I have made the Holy Spirit less than God, dark be mine eyes: If I have not confessed according to these words, to outer darkness may I go, or if I am speaking figuratively (ⲏⲥⲥⲥⲥ) with the wicked in the fire may I burn." This solemn asseveration is consistent with the above cited passage, as also (as we shall see) with lxxvii. §. 5. and contr. Scrut. i. §. 32. ii. §. 8. Again in xlvi. 4. he argues against the heretical dilemma, 'if the True One begat, He begat either by His Will or against His Will.' But the reading in the text is not what one should expect from a writer aware of that dilemma, and arguing against it in another part of the same work.
In lii. §. 1. the very term in the present text is used I think unquestionably of the sonship which is by grace. 'As by His Names He is comprehended to be God, and Just and Good, so the Name of Father evinceth Him to be a Generator. For the very Name of Fatherhood used of Him beareth witness of the Son, and as He was the Father of One, in His Love it is that He is so of many. Praises be to His Grace!' which doctrine of sonship by grace occurs again in xxix. §. 1. in other terms. See v. §. 3. The epithet 'glorious' seems to me to suggest to St. E.'s mind the idea of the sun shining in his might. Hence he passes off to the giving of 'that Light' to us, through the Incarnation, and the blessings, sacramental or other, attending it. Or he may mean more generally, that we do not grasp the Divine Essence shining in its strength, but only some small part of Its operations. 'For look' (he says, vol. ii. p. 518, c. on another point) 'at the source of this sun which we see, and observe that the fountain-head of its rays is unbearable, but when the shining of it spreads abroad, feeble and dulled does the might of its rays become: heat too and the gleam of it which is from fire is dulled and minished each moment. How much more dulled then will the Brilliance be which from a lengthened
distance extendeth unto us!' It is quite possible that a scribe who looked over the passage before transcribing might purposely substitute 'love' for 'bosom' to suit the immediate context, if unlearned; and if heterodox to meet the wishes of others. But in §. 3. St. E. seems plainly to return to the coeternity of the Son with the Father, and to be arguing §. 5. that though commanded, He was in no way inferior, as the Homœousian system at least tended to make Him.
1. Who, that forgets himself, and knows not his own understanding, would declare the nature of the First-born, the Lord of natures? The natures, that by Him exist, who is able to search out? Even that nature which is in himself he cannot search out. How then shall he who meets a reproof in his own self, in that he is not equal to [investigating] himself, be equal to [investigating] his Lord? Plain is the object before us, great, and open, and at hand: yet, whoso will hit at it, misses it and fails. If then the object close at hand none be capable of hitting, the Hidden Object that strikes awe what man shall find a way to hit? The Manhood none is equal to: who can attain unto the hidden Godhead?
2. Heb. 10, 20. 2. He came down, and veiled His face with a veil of Flesh. From the brilliance of His light the whole of Jordan light became. He gleamed a little in the mount; trembling, quivering, and aghast, were those three pillars that the Apostle so accounted: He granted them a sight of His hidden glory commensurate with their strength. The sea beheld Him and was shaken; though so sturdy with its waves, yet it bowed its back and bare Him, and took Him better than the colt. When He sat within the ship, the sailors counted Him a man: He went down and trod the sea, and awe the shipmen felt at Him. With no searching searched they Him, but with wonder wondered at Him. They praised and held their peace in fear. The Magi again sought Him, and when they found Him in the manger, it was not prying, but worship, that they offered to Him in silence: not empty strifes, but offerings, were what they gave to Him. Do thou too seek for the First-born, and if thou hast found Him in the height, instead of wrangling disputations open thy treasures before Him, and offer unto Him thy works.
3. Come, let us be astonied at the men that saw the King in His low estate, and neither searched nor sought; not one of them made inquiry: there, pure faith was victorious in silence. The Magi, when He was in His low estate, durst not search into Him, who shall dare to search into Him now that He hath gone up and sat down at the Right Hand on high? Yea, the thief made no enquiries, but believed without searching into Him. The one on the left hand enquired, and his enquiring cut off his hope. The Scribes that sought fell with Herod, who asked [after] Him. Satan tempted Him, wishing to know who He was. Unto all these that searched, the Messiah gave Himself not, as He did to the little children. A star rose above Him, to shew without all controversy that He was indeed the Bright Light of the Gentiles, in that they saw the Truth in Him. On Him when baptized the Spirit settled in the form of a dove, that He might shew without question that it was He who was to baptize with fire. The voice openly proclaimed, 'This is My Son and My Beloved,' that the voice might reprove prying.
4. These affections have they repressed who have refrained from searching, and have quieted the soul that it might believe without toil. The Pharisees enquired, Who is this, and Whose Son? As searching into the Truth they fell from the Truth. On faith all dependeth. When seeking after the Truth Himself, in the seeking of Him they lost Him. The centurion was commended when he marvelled at Him as God: in faith he honoured Him, and suffered Him not to come in. His coming in he counted a weighty matter: do thou then St. Thomas blamed for believing slowly. think so of searching into Him, because at this day thou hast no room for checking His visibly coming in, check and count a weighty thing the searching into Him, that He may praise thy faith before Angels on high. Weigh them together, the Centurion that believes, and that Thomas who would feel and search. His Lord praised the former, and the latter did His Master rebuke. If he were blamed that dared to search into Him and so believed, what disgrace does he store up for himself that wisheth to search first, and to believe afterwards?
4 The more usual view of St. Thomas' doubt is perhaps to regard it as a dispensation, whereby for 'the more confirmation of the faith' light was for a time withheld from him. It is, however, usual with St. E. to avail himself as well of the moral and literal, as of the deeper and spiritual, lessons of Scripture. Thus in p. 20. he may be said to moralize on Noah's drunkenness, while in vol. i. p. 152. there quoted, and p. 3. he considers of what it was the type: in vol. i. p. 112. d. we find him stating in terms that he gives both interpretations of the Benedictions of Jacob. Thus too in R. ix. §. 3. he speaks of Job as if he had done what (as he notices on Jerem. xx.) 'the Spirit says he did not,' sin or blaspheme with his lips. A large part of the prophecies he refers to Zorobabel, sometimes stating along with this, and sometimes not, the ultimate and spiritual sense of them.
5 See R. ix. §. 2. and xi. §. 4. St. Meletius in St. Epiph. i. p. 881. "There is reason to fear, lest, if forced to speak upon topics that we are not able to speak of, we should be no longer allowed to speak upon those whereof we are able. For it is from belief we ought to speak, and not from things spoken to believe; since it says, I believed and therefore did I speak." The Anomæans objected to the Catholics, that they worshipped they knew not what, (V. G. Nys. ii. p. 519. l.) In observing on this sort of reasoning, St. Bas. Ep. 234. §. 2. says, "A sufficient faith it is that knoweth that God is, without knowing what He is, in that He is a rewarder, &c. For the knowledge of the Divine Essence is the perception of His incomprehensible-ness; and what we worship is not that whereof it is comprehended what the essence is, but that it is."
In this Rhythm St. E. is enforcing the necessity of faith in order to the reception of doctrine of the Eternal Generation of the Son, a doctrine which 'more than any part of the Christian Religion requireth of us mere faith upon authority only.' See Pet. de Trin. v. 5. who gives several passages to this effect from the Greek and Latin Fathers.
1. O the brightness of Moses which none could behold! Ex. 34, 29. They that beheld him were not able to look at a mortal: who shall dare to look upon the Quickener of all living? If the brightness of the servant was so powerful, who shall look stedfastly upon his Lord? for the Mount Sinai when Ex. 19, it saw Him, smoked and was melted before Him. The 18. mighty men were not equal to seeing the glory of Moses. A veil ministered between the brightness and the people, instead of the veil which wore away, a Brightness of living Fire surrounded the chariot, that the Cherubim might not be affrighted a. Let stillness and silence be the curtain to thee, Levit. 16, 2. that thou gaze not upon His Brightness. 2. There was none that approached the folds 1 of the visible 1 S. veil to pry into the brightness of the servant that was dwelling Bosom within it. When Moses had been to gaze on Him, all the tribes were moved: how much more fearful the searching into that wherein Thy Generation is hidden! If Thou lookest upon the Angels, the Heaven and the Heaven of Heavens tremble before Thee. In the veil of Moses Thy Ex. 4, bright shining Truth was hidden, in his stammering was 10, 11; 6, 12. hidden Thy ready-speaking teaching 2. Beneath two veils 2 S. Thy Truth was hidden, and Thy speaking. As for the veil Targum Thou didst lift it up, and the stammering Thou didst make 2 Cor. 3, to speak plain. The whole of Thee came forth to sight. 16. Lo! Truth speaketh in the mouth, and verity is revealed to the eyes. The veil upon his face and the stammering of his mouth, as two veils veiled the blinded people: but to the just that longed for 3 Thy day Thou wert revealed. The 3pp.4.66.
Lessons against prying, from the types heretics also, who at this day are blinded with the veil, stutter, and are blindfold. They are blind to Thy beauty, and to Thy teaching dumb.
3. These types under Moses shadowed out to the foolish two veils spread over the crucifiers. The Truth hath risen up Deut. openly: let us not grope in darkness: let not searching into Him be unto us another veil. His beauty came forth openly. 28, 29. Job 12 25. Liken not thou Him to any thing, for He is like His Father in the whole of Him. Into the Holy of Holies the priest went in silence: once only in the year did he go in in fear. And if See Heb. he reverenced the whole of that dwelling-place of His, who shall dare to search into the Power which dwelt in it? Let us feel a share of his awe in searching out of the First-born, since He is Lord of the sanctuary. Numb. 4. Two hundred and fifty priests with their censers were burnt up, because they wished to seize on Aaron's priest-16, 2. hood; and they of Corah's company were swallowed up, ib. 31. because they wished to be priests. If the priesthood of Aaron was thus altogether fearful, how much more fearful 1 Acts the Lord of priests who made priests with His own Blood! 20, 28. Who would dare to search into Him? Great was the shock, contr. that the sons of Aaron were [so] suddenly burnt up! They Ser. i. dared to offer up strange fire, and were burnt up. Who §. 46. then will escape that bringeth up into the Church strange n. b. p. questioning?
There is indeed in the Church a seeking which 3 p. 112, questioning? There is indeed in the Church a seeking which n. g. examineh things revealed, but not one that prich into things p. 141. hidden. 2 Sam. 5. Uzzah, the chief priest, when he went to stay [the ark], 6, 6. was taken off. What he was commanded he did not, things 4 S. they not commanded he performed. He was commanded to carry commanded him the ark upon his shoulders: He put forth his hand to stay the Might of Him that stays up all things. He thought the ark was about to fall: when he approached it, it slew him. Do not shew honour to what is holy on a side that they have not commanded thee. Uzziah shewed an honour, which was a dishonour. Do not as avenging the Truth search into and dishonour the First-born. Think not that the faith is likely to fall. Itself supporteth them that are cast down: do not support it as Uzza, lest in anger it destroy thee.
6. The princes [of the Philistines] who were insolent honoured the ark; when they had made trial of its might, they worshipped it with offerings. Dagon, before it, was broken off, for it cut off his limbs. How much more should we honour the Gospel, before which the wicked one was destroyed. From his dominion did it cut him off; with offerings let us appease it, for it hath healed our torn wounds. The Jordan also saw the ark and was divided in two parts, for it ran away before it and fled behind it. It flowed down, not after its nature, because it saw the Lord of natures. If the ark was fearful because the tables were within it; how much more fearful is searching [into Him], and who shall approach unto it since the Lord of the tables is hidden in it? 7. Daniel saw wondrous living creatures. He saw also that the Ancient of Days was sitting in glory. He approached to the living creatures that he might ask and learn. He approached not to search into the glory of the High One. Fools have left the works and run on to the Maker that they might search out, Who He is. Daniel saw one of the Angels and was affrighted. He approached not to search into him; the voice that he heard he was not able to bear. Daniel was not able to hearken even to his voice. He looked not upon him that ministered; upon Him that was ministered unto, who shall look? The sea that saw the sign of Him feared and fled back and was moved, it was divided into two heaps. Daniel that asked concerning the words, heard that Daniel's unquestioning temper to be imitated.
Dan. 12, they were sealed, and that it was not seeming to search out the hidden things of the future! Who shall dare to search into the Treasury in Whom dwelleth all knowledge? The First-born is the Treasury of the Father, in Whom is all His counsel*; and who is equal to searching into Him? Counsel, lit. thought or imagination. St. E. means to imply that the whole of the Father's counsels whether in creating or ruling are in the Son. St. G. Nys. ii. p. 376. urges against the Anomoans that their theory would exclude the Son from the functions of Providence, a simple Nature having a simple Will (wominess), which Will displays itself in Providence, in which Providence the Son doeth whatsoever He seeth the Father do. St. E. is arguing here, as others have done, that if the judgments of God are past finding out, a fortiori God Himself is incomprehensible. See St. Greg. Naz. i. p. 551. c. Nyss. ii. p. 520. c. St. Epiph. i. p. 943. c. St. Chrysost. Hom. I. de Inc. p. 300. who all refer to Rom. xi. 33.
1. RIGHT was once the searching which hath been perverted in our age. Read and seek [to see] that He is the Son, so that thou seek not how He is so. Jordan fled and turned back to do honour to the ark. Thou searchest and goest in to do dishonour to His Majesty. The right-minded [sons] pp. 3, turned themselves so as not to look at Noah, that they might reprove the daring ones. They went backwards to hide what was uncovered. Do thou turn back the searching which uncovers what is hidden. There they hid what was uncovered: here men pry into what is concealed. The chaste men spread a garment and hid him that they might not see: the disputer, if possible, strippeth the First-born of His glory, that His whole Nature may be scrutinized. 2. Prove by thyself this, that all which is easy becomes difficult, if thou alterest the nature of it, or disturbest the order of it. Walking is very easy, and yet difficult if thou doest it backwards. Disputing is throughout difficult, because men dispute not orderly. Rashness hath perverted the Faith in our generation, because it is in a perverted way that it questioneth.
3. God pleaded with Job; He asked him about things before his eyes, and with questions put him to silence. If Job were not able to speak of things before his eyes, who shall dare to plead about the hidden things of the First-born? Weak was Job, who in his scourges overcame, in his questionings was overcome; on the side that belonged to him he overcame, on the side that did not belong to him even he Lessons against prying from the conduct was overcome; he overcame in the combat in which it belongs to us to overcome, in investigating he was overcome, for it is not ours to be disputing. The wicked one made confusion, that he might make us to cease from what is in our power, and in what was not belonging to us might make us over-anxious. 4. Ezechiel He asked if the bones would rise, and though the Prophet knew that the dead should be restored, he ventured not to speak of that which he knew. He gathered in all his knowledge, and to the Knower of all things he offered it up. Who shall dare to search into a question which is hidden away from all, and for One alone hath light upon it?
5. Zachariah also questioned about the mysteries revealed; the Angel therefore wished to prove him, if his earnestness Zech. 4, was exhausted, saying thus: Knowest thou not these things? He was not ashamed to confess, that he might put the proud to shame. The Prophet was not confident about his own 1 p. 128, knowledge, as the rash of our day. But Zachariah the priest questioned that he might dispute. The Angel took away his speech that he might make disputers fear; if the Chief Priest was smitten, because he scrutinized and wished to learn the generation and conception of the preacher and servant, terror, and shuddering, and fear to him who shall be bold enough to search into the generation of the Lord of all. 2 S. they Because Zachariah scrutinized, his mouth was bridled with silence. He afterwards in silence did honour unto that which he had scrutinized. The generation of the First-born how much more should we honour in silence! Since he was blamed that scrutinized the generation in the womb of his 3 S. of own wife, let him fear that hath approached to the [Divine] his Essence to search out His Well-beloved in His Womb.
Zachariah by his questionings let go of the Truth. Every man therefore that questioneth at all, his questioning shews that he has no faith hitherto. His prying looseneth the faith wherewith he had been believing. Zachariah sheweth this, since he lost the faith of his heart by the questions of his month. 5. The serpents bit the people in the wilderness. [Moses] Numb. fastened up another serpent that they might look thereon and be revived. The sight revived the people [of God] and faith the nations. A type of the First-born [this]! It was not searching into Him which healed them; seeing of Him alone revived them. In faith look upon the Lord of types, that He may quicken thee! Also the blood of the sprinkling that was poured out upon the doors, and the cloud too, and the rock, and the pillar, and the rod, these be types of the First-born. When this gainsaying people did not pry into the glorious types, do not ye Gentiles search into the First-born, that Treasure of mysteries, lest the blind rejoice [over you].
6. Though ye were all of one mind, ye have been divided, Clem. Alex. Strom. vi. f. 80. p. 780. Pott. "Half the world are as afraid, as children are of bugbear, of the Grecian philosophy, being apprehensive of its leading them astray. But if faith with them (for call it knowledge I cannot) be of such a sort that it may be by persuasive discourses loosened, let it be loosened at any rate by these discourses of theirs which belong to men that confess that the truth is not to be theirs; for truth, as one says, is invincible, but falsehood it is that gets loosened." So too St. Chrys. on Rom. iv. 21. p. 125. O. T. "He that is persuaded with words, may have his persuasion altered too by them. But he, &c." On Num. xxi. 8. p. 263. a. he says, "Moses fixed it in the door of the tabernacle, that they might turn their faces thither, from whence they had turned them away, and that the place whence healing came forth to them might be honourable in their eyes; the while in it were shadowed out types of Him who said, 'As Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness for the healing of the children of Israel, so is the Son of Man to be lifted up upon the Cross for the redemption of all nations.'" The same fact he urges vol. ii. p. 483. e. as others have done, against the Jews,
as a proof that their law was typical and to pass away. "How came God who in the wilderness wrote and warned the Jew, saying, 'Thou shalt not make any image or likeness, lest thou die,' to form a serpent, whereon, as upon God, man should look and be healed?" Of the blood, see p. 32, note n. and p. 138, note b. of the cloud I do not recollect any other notice in St. E.; of the rock, on Num. xxi. 17. he says, "They say that that rock, which went with them, (1 Cor. x. 4.) even in the time that they journeyed, sent down twelve streams, but in the time of their encamping did not indeed withdraw them altogether, yet did not altogether send them down;" where he evidently has the Apostles filled from Christ in his mind, as he says plainly on Deut. xxxii. 13. that "the rock is a type of Christ, that true Rock Who is the Head of the eternal Building and Fountain of Life." Of the rod of Aaron which budded, he says on Num. xvii. that "it was a type of the adorable Body of Immanuel, which, although of the same nature with corruptible ones, remained itself alone in the sepulchre incorruptible."
God is incomprehensible to man. for that ye have come near to search into the Nature that cannot be searched out. The blind people thought that our Truth itself is false. If it were false, it would necessarily have been minished, lo! it is altogether strengthened! Ye blind perceive not that it is in His Majesty that ye have been straying, for if He had been an Angel or weak man, searching into Him would have been an easy thing; since one would have known that He was a servant. Disputing, then, which is against Him, comes to be in the place of Him. Itself bears witness that He is great, seeing He cannot be searched out, and proclaimeth that He is God, for lo! [all] ages have been wandering in Him, and have not been able to comprehend Him. If all measures were to come and go down to the sea, they would be short, and be surpassed, and would not contain the whole of it. They are measured by it, yet are unable to measure it; and not because they were surpassed, is that not the sea; for it is even because it is so, that the foolish dared to come down to Him. Whoever is able to search, to him He is poor. The knowledge that is able to comprehend Him that knoweth all things must be greater than Him, since it sufficeth to measure Him entirely. He that can search out the Father and the Son, is greater than Both of Them. Forbear, and let it be an anathema, for the Father and the Son to be searched into, and for dust and ashes to be lifted up!
1. THOU, Lord, hast caused it to be written, Open thy mouth, Ps. 81, 10. and I shall fill it. Lo! the mouth of Thy servant is open to Thee, with his mind! Do Thou fill it, Lord, with Thy Gift, that according to Thy will I may sing Thy praise. For speaking of Thee every man hath his own proper measure; S. there are degrees of within the silence is Thy Generation sealed up, and what all measures to mouth is it that dareth to meddle therewith? Though Thy all men Nature is One, the explanations thereof are manifold. Lofty R. iv. §. 1. discourses are there, and intermediate, and lowly on the part of the lowly. Deem me worthy as it were of the crumbs, p. 152, n. b. S. wisdoms. note e, that I may gather up the droppings of Thy wisdom. 2. Thy visible Generation is laid up with Thy Father. note e, Angels are astonied at Thy smaller riches. A small drop, p. 115. O Lord, of Thy history becomes with those below a flood of interpretations; for if John, even, that great one, cried [saying], 'I am not worthy, O Lord, to [unloose] the 27. §. 8. latchets of Thy shoes,' I will flee as that sinful woman to Mat. 9, the shadow of Thy garments, that I may begin from thence; . and as she who was affrighted, yet took heart, because she was Mat. 9, 21. Luke 8, 47.
Lessons against prying from Christ's visible made whole; heal my fright at the danger, and let me take heart in Thee, may I be also moved from Thy garment to Thy Body, that according to my power I may speak of Thee. 3. Thy garment, Lord, is a fountain of medicines. In Thy visible vesture there dwelleth an hidden power. A little spittle from Thy mouth became also a great miracle of light in the midst of its clay. In Thy Bread is hidden the Spirit that cannot be eaten; in Thy Wine there dwelleth the Fire that cannot be drunk. The Spirit in Thy Bread and the Fire in Thy Cup are distinct miracles, which our lips receive. 4. When the Lord came down to the earth unto mortal men, He created them a new Creation, as in the Angels He mingled Fire and the Spirit, that they might be of Fire and Spirit in a hidden manner. The Seraph did not bring the living coal near with his fingers; it did but come close up to Isaiah's mouth; he did not himself lay hold of it or eat it; but unto us the Lord hath given both of them.
5. To the Angels which are spiritual Abraham brought bodily food, and they ate. A new miracle it is, that our mighty Lord giveth to bodily creatures Fire and the Spirit, as food Above, p. 81. he calls the Angels Empyreals, as in vol. ii. p. 330. f. 334. a. The word for 'Spirit,' as in Greek and Hebrew, is the same as that for 'wind.' The idea that Angels consist of Fire and Spirit is suggested by Ps. 104, 4. 'He maketh His Angels spirits, and His Ministers a flaming fire,' which of course does not (as Euseb. Præp. Ev. vii. 15. p. 326. d. notices) imply that they consist of material fire or wind, but only that the words are used of them, as fire and spirit are of God. St. Greg. Naz. Or. xxxiv. v. fin. p. 560. quoting the same text, says, "Angels are called fire and spirit, partly as being above our senses, and partly as ministering to our purification, ( ,) though I am aware that these are names of the First Essence."
See above, p. 30, n. k. contr. Scrut. i. §. 12. St. James of Sarug, A. D. 480, quoted in Assemanni's Antirrh. adv. Kohl, p. 5. "The Seraph took not hold of it with his hand, that he might not be burned: neither did the prophet take it in his mouth, that he might not be consumed: the one did not seize hold of, the other did not eat the glorified (ember). It was because it was incorporeal, that it was not to be taken hold of, nor eaten, but after this Coal hath presented itself to sight in a Body, lo! it is eaten from the table of the Godhend. So on Ezek. x. v. 2. St. E. says, "These coals, and the man that is clothed in fine linen, that bringeth them and casteth them upon the people, are a type of the priest by whose mediatorship the living coals of the Life-producing Body of our Lord are given away. But see there is another Cherub that reacheth them forth, and placeth them in his fists! this is a type, to shew that it is not the priest who is able to make the Body, of the bread, but Another, to wit, the Holy Ghost: the priest, therefore, doth but lend his hands as a mediator, and his lips offer prayers with supplications, as a servant suing for mercy."—which passage seems to Ass. to have been copied by St. Chrysost. Hom. lxxxiii. in Matt. p. 870. b. See p. 119, n. l.
Greg. Naz. Or. 34. p. 549. "Abraham, that great patriarch, was justified by faith, and offered a sacrifice strange and typical of the great One: yet he saw not God as God, but nourished Him as if man, and was commended for having reverenced as far as he did comprehend." Generation and the fruits of it in the Eucharist. 147 and drink. Fire came down upon sinners in wrath, and consumed them. The Fire of the Merciful in bread cometh down and abideth. Instead of that fire which devoured men, ye eat a Fire in bread and are quickened. As fire came down on the sacrifice of Elijah and consumed it, the Fire of Mercy hath become to us a Living Sacrifice. Fire ate up the oblations, and we, O Lord, have eaten Thy Fire in Thy Oblation. 6. Who hath ever taken hold of the Spirit in his fists? Come and see, O Solomon, what the Lord of thy father hath done. For Fire and Spirit against its nature He hath mingled, and hath poured them into the fists of His disciples. He asked, 'Who hath bound the waters in a garment?' Lo! the Fountain in a garment, the lap of Mary! From the Cup of Life the distilling of life in the midst of the garment do Thine hand-maids take!
7. Oh, Might hidden in the veil of the sanctuary, that Might which the mind never conceives, It hath His love brought down; and It hath descended and brooded over the veil of the altar of propitiation. Lo! Fire and Spirit in the bosom of her that bare Thee! Lo! Fire and Spirit in that river wherein Thou wert baptized, Fire and Spirit in our baptism! In the Bread and the Cup is Fire and the Holy Ghost. Thy Bread killeth the greedy one who had made us his bread; Thy cup destroyeth death which swallowed us uph. We have eaten Thee, O Lord, yea, we have drunken Thee, not that we shall make Thee fail, but that we might have life in Theei. Mark 1, 8. The latchet of Thy shoe was a thing fearful to the discerning; the hem of Thy garment was fearful to the understanding: our generation is foolish in scrutinizing Thee. Oh, Feast which is drunken with new Wine! Wonder
Ps. 77, is there in Thy footsteps that went upon the waters; the great sea didst Thou make obedient beneath Thy feet; to a little stream1 Thy head made itself obedient, in that it condescended to be baptized therein. The stream2 was like John who baptized therein. Both of them in littleness mutually shadow out each other. To the little stream and the weak servant the Lord of them both made Himself obedient. 9. See my folds be filled, Lord, with the dropping of Thy blessings; and as no room is now remaining, as in my borders I am full, O stay Thy Gift, and, as a store, O keep it in Thy treasury for Thee to give it us again!
1. I, O LORD, am not worthy, neither venture I upon this; for should I venture to fly, I should not reach it. He deceiveth Himself whosoever ventureth without Thee upon what is Thine, O Thou that art above all. Thy Nature with its breath reproacheth us when it affrighteth us. Thy height mocketh us, so high and lifted up is it. Thy mercy also, lo! it putteth us to shame, it hath so humbled itself to the abjects. Let him who hath ventured, yield proof openly; let his eye see the Great Mountain from afar, let his eye reprove that mind of his, because he hath scrutinized Him without measure; for his own troubled course reproacheth him, and his vision putteth him to shame. His troubled course reproacheth his tongue, that he hath thus strayed into that Majesty, in Whose Bosom the world is placed, as but a span.
2. Lo! his ear is not able to hear the mighty crash, neither can it hear the still silence; how then shall he hear the voice ab. p. 128, n.g. of the Son or the silence of the Father, when the silence too is vocal? The heavens declare the glory of God. Lo! a silence, the whole whereof muttereth among all languages to all languages! This firmament, lo! it declareth day by day the glory of its Maker. Man is too little to be able to hear all languages, and if he sufficed to hear the tongue of Angels that are spirits, so might he lift himself up to hear the silence which speaketh between the Father and the Son. Our The narrow path of Orthodoxy tongue is estranged to the voice of beasts; the tongue of Angels is estranged to every [other] tongue. That silence wherewith the Father speaketh with His Well-beloved, is strange unto the Angels.
3. Good is He that clad Him in all forms for our sight, clad Himself likewise in all voices in order to have intercourse with us . He alone is able to see His Own Nature, and His silence He alone can hear. His Son that is from Him is Himself also equal to Him. And he that is a stranger to His Nature is a stranger to the investigation of Him, and he wandereth exceedingly, since there is no path that leadeth to the Hidden One. When the Creator trod a path for the creature that the offerings of prayers might come to His door, it was not a path for prying which He made that by it man might come to the door of the [Divine] Essence. 4. To him that bringeth an offering and cometh unto prayer, the Way sheweth itself and cleaveth to him, and the Door itself when it seeth him, also openeth itself before his offering. Whoso cometh unto that Majesty to scrutinize, the paths are deceitful, the gates are closed to him, and there is a waste and a desert and a veritable solitude, and the rash one wanown nature doth reproach, in that he wandereth in Thee, while even it is not acquainted with itself. Foolish is he that thinketh he can overcome death, and he cannot know death nor its essence. Knowledge does not remain with him that forgetteth his own nature in Thy Nature. He is blameworthy who hath lost his own and found neither his own nor Thine. He deceiveth himself that thinketh that he hath mounted up and searched out Thee. He injureth not Thee by all his knowledge, since it is in Thee; and what is his, is without Thee.
5. My mouth sufficeth not for Thee, and I rejoice that I sufficed not, for if I sufficed it were a blasphemy on both accounts; either that the nature of man should be greater than that of God, or that it should be equal were harsh to think. Thy feast is athirst for them that were bidden. Without bound Thy banquet rejoiceth in ready guests and their dresses, Thy chamber longeth for the virgins whose lamps are furnished with oil. There are many called, that long for Thy door, but since Thy door is narrow, they are very few that have given up and cast away every thing, and have been able to enter in, because it hateth riches. 6. Thy furnace exulteth in us, that it may be perfect in the assaying, and true in the trial. And since Thou hast lifted up our mind unto the impress of Thy Image, on it, Lord, may there be cast the impress of Thy Truth. Thy path to us is long. It is shortened, for in His mercy He cut short the length of it, in His love for him that is weak. He extended His mountain unto him that is little, that the praise for Thy wisdom might be increased. The throne of Thy glory, and also the tribunal of Thy righteousness, rejoiceth in the victor that put the adversary to shame. Thy mercy also sustaineth the weak, and even Gehenna would be refreshed with Thy shadow.
See contr. Scrut. iii. §. 24. where a similar impossibility is noticed; unless it be thought that St. E. held with St. Austin (in a difficult passage in the Enchir. ad Laur. v. fin.) that the punishment of the damned, though unalterable as a condition, might, in degree, be al- leviated. It may be right to add, to prevent misconception, that St. E. held the fire of hell to be "inextinguishable, not consuming that which it devoureth, seeing it was not appointed to consume, but to cause suffering and torment." ii. p. 354, s.
Christ, the Remnant, draweth all men to Him. 153 for Thy Twelve who shall sit thereat. With Thy rain every thing increaseth, with Thy dew every thing is moistened. Thy doctrine is a hidden dew for the hidden earth. Gather, O Lord, Thy fruit as a vintager, and offer it to Thy Father as a Sheaf of reconciliation. 3. Thou art a Branch of that Vine which is from Egypt, which also the wild boar of the forest devoured, when it sprouted and put forth its twig from it; which bare the blessed Cluster and the Cup of the Medicine of Life. From the family of the circumcised and from the place of tares there came up unto us the Sheaf which was full of New Bread, from the bitter the sweet Fruit, and from the murderers the Physician that healed all. In a spicy root the Son of David was brought to us, and from a dry ground flowed unto us the Fountain of mercies. How shall we reject that Fountain, which mercies have poured forth in dry lands? Thy key manifesteth itself unto him that seeketh it. Thy treasure rejoiceth in the thief that taketh it by violence, because Thou didst rejoice in that woman who from the hem of Thy garment took and stole a medicine for her plague. Thy leaven, O Lord, longed for a mass of sinners, that it might change them, and draw them to repentance. Thy light maketh the path of Truth even; it cleanseth out and taketh away from it [all] stumbling stones. Thy silver, O Lord, sheweth mercy unto the empty, that he may be enriched thereby. Thy pound sheweth mercy, since it cometh to the humble with ten pounds; Thy talent desireth to come to the indolent with ten. Glory to Him that enricheth all!
4. Thy armour, O Lord, rejoiceth in a penitent that fighteth with wickedness: Thy vineyard rejoiceth in the idler, who contendeth victoriously with the thrifty, that with open mouth and unveiled face he may claim his reward. Glory to the Rewarder of all! Thy yoke, Lord, rejoiceth in subduing the rebellious; Thy rod rejoiceth in scattering the assembled So, in the far west, St. Austin on Ps. 1. §. 4. "As this visible earth nourisheth and containeth the visible man, so doth that invisible earth the interior man: from the face of which earth it is that the wind scattereth the ungodly, &c." See also Jerome on Esai. lviii. v. fin. Of the parable here referred to (Matt. xx. 1.) he gives elsewhere, vol. i. p. 153, a. and p. 269, e. the other and perhaps more exact interpretation, which refers the different hours to the different interpositions of Christ for His Church.
Christ desirous of all men's salvation. Ezek. wolves, and Thy fold in gathering the persecuted sheep into 22, 7. the pasture. Glory to the Shepherd of all! Thy haven Ps. 2, 9. looketh for our ship, which Thou wilt bring unto it. Direct Ez. 34, it with Thy Spirit; in Thy love with the oars of Thy mercies 22. let it be assisted: let it stop the mouth of the greedy sea. Ps. 107, Glory to Thy assistance! Thy Rock looketh for them that 30. build, that the foundations may be builded upon it, and all John 10, that see it may give [Thee] glory. Let not their tower, Lord, 11. be a laughing-stock: in Thee may it be finished! Glory be to wind Him that perfecteth all! Thy seed looketh for lands that are Mat. 7, to be tilled. In the least may it bring from Thee thirty-fold; 24. and in the middling may it bring sixty, and in the perfect may Luke 14, it bring an hundred-fold. 28.
5. Thy mirror is clear, and all of it turneth towards Thee. Thy brightness inciteth the filthy to cleanse themselves thereon, since no impurity can be joined unto Thee, unless S.sears. it hath wiped from it its stains. Thy hyssop looketh for us ab.p.3. that it may be gracious unto us in its mercy. With the dew of Thy mercy, Lord, let us be cleansed again. The Lord Ezek. hath no pleasure in our uncleanness, though the Just One is 18, 23. greatly glorified in our purity. John 15,
1. I WOULD keep my faith from the deceit which hath burst up here, and which, while it confesseth the Father, denieth the Only-Begotten: and since the investigators have flown up to all the high things, in the Fort of Truth I would keep my faith. I came near to the Father, and He denoteth Himself by His Paternity: I came near to the Son, and He hath blended Him in His Sonship: as hath the Holy Spirit also His holiness: in Him then do I also conclude the all-hallowing mystery! All faith which is not signed is error. Let us prepare ourselves for tribulation if it come, whether our spirit suffer, or our soul depart, or our body be burned. Who shall overcome us? This is that which is written, neither height, nor depth, nor sword, shall be able to cut off our faith. Who shall cut off the glory-rays that cannot be cut off from the Sun of Truth. Upon the Three Names our baptism hangeth. In the Three Mysteries our faith overcometh. The Three Names our Lord gave to His Twelve, that in them we might find a refuge. The soul that is not sealed is like a wandering sheep: and that which is sealed in one name is also to be rejected, and that whose seal, being inadmissible, is stolen, it also strayeth. Blessed be He that hath sealed us for Himself! The doctrine is a treasury of the faith: the voice is the key, and the tongue as it were the treasurer. Never hath the faith ceased to set forth and yield truth unto the hearers. To silence are the trumpet and the faith strangers. Never did the trumpet mutter low in the secret The Faith lifts up its voice to all.
chamber, and the faith also did never steal away and mutter the truth low in secret or in a hidden place. 2. Who ever saw [before] a tree which produced only a single fruit with this fruit singly upon it continually? Faith it is which hath Truth singly hung upon it: for Truth is one. Let not my tongue be silent or be bridled for the faith, let it ascend from my lips, Lord, as an offering unto Thee. Lo! from branches speaking or silent my tongue hath gathered it for Thee! This sentiment occurs again, R. is a beacon to all—as fides is used in xx. §. 2. The faith means probably Latin and wives in Greek for a form of the written form of it, the Creed which words.
1. I HAVE invited Thee, Lord, to a banquet of songs: the wine in the banquet hath failed, even the language of praise. Thou Guest, who filledst the waterpots with goodly wine, fill my mouth with the praise of Thee! The wine that was in the water-pots was near akin to, yea, was of the same stock with this reasonable wine which begetteth praise, since that wine also begat praise from them that drank it, who saw the miracle. Oh, Thou most just, if in the marriage-feast, which was not Thine own, Thou filledst six waterpots with that goodly wine, in this feast, instead of waterpots, fill ten thousand ears, Lord, with sweetness. Oh, Jesus, who wast invited to the feast of others, lo! now is Thine own feast, chaste and fair! gladden Thy youths! for lo! Thy guests also are lacking, Lord! with Thy songs let Thy harp speak. The soul is Thy bride and the body is Thy bridechamber: Thy guests are the senses with the mental faculties. And if it be one Body which Thou hast for a banquet, Thy guestchamber is the Church, inasmuch as she imitateth Thee!
2. An holy man took the synagogue up to mount Sinai. His body shone with white garments, and [yet] his heart was dark. She played the adulteress with the calf, and the High One was displeased at her and brake the tables, that writing of His Covenant. Who ever at any time saw a bawling out amidst a deed of lust, [or] a bride that would * It is common to explain the number five of the senses: see Method. C. Virg. vi. §. 3. Augustin in Ps. xlix. §. 9. Greg. M. in Evang. cap. i. Hom. xii. §. 1. who all consider the five virgins to have reference to the five senses. I believe St. E. has somewhat of the kind in his mind here, and wishes to imply that the five senses, with the mental faculties thereto corresponding, are to be like the five virgins admitted to the feast. See R. iv. §. 3. The next words, I believe, mean, 'If one man's body, so filled with praises, has thereby become a banquet to Thee, still it is in the Church that
such a banquet must be prepared: he must be a member of Thy visible representative.' Or, perhaps it is better to take the words 'one Body' of Christ's Body as a newly introduced subject, suggested by the mention of the human body, the banquet, again, of the Supper in which It is eaten, as suggested by the 'banquet of songs' and the guest-chamber of the visible Church which imitates Christ in giving His Body to her disciples. The passage, however, is one upon the meaning of which I feel more uncertain the more I look at it. 158 The Jews' ingratitude warns Christians to be thankful.
1. LET him that is a man care for the things of a man: let him who is mortal muse upon what is commanded; and again, let him that is a sinner seek medicine fit for his wound. Let the discerning with silence venerate Thy God-head: let the learned in stillness be amazed at Thy Majesty: let the wise with wholesome words proclaim to children the glory of Thy kingdom. Let not our soul go astray and raise doubts about our God. Let us mete our mind and measure also our imagination, and let us know our knowledge how much too small and foolish it is, to search into Him, who knoweth all things. 2. Tell me how thou didst shadow out in thy mind that Generation which is at a mighty distance from thy scrutinizing? Thou fanciedst It was a little mountain, into the midst of which thou didst descend to explore it. In silence seal up thy mouth: let not thy tongue be rash. Know thyself a creature made, a child of clay, for a great gulph and boundless is between thee and the Son in the parts where thou searchest into Him. He that is weak hath no concern with difficulties; nor he that is feeble with perplexities: and let not him who is of the earth lift himself so proudly up, that his mouth should haste to fly up at his Maker. He that scrutinizeth is a limb that is broken: let it get itself healed, lest it hurt the whole body, and lest, because it is diseased, the Healer of all pains should cut it off and drive it away from His pasture.
3. Every one that questioneth, is a companion of him that is lost, and he that searcheth, is a fellow unto him that is gone astray. For never did one that is lost seek and find himself, like to the scrutinizer. Let him who is a member fix himself firmly upon Christ. Let not his blade be separated The disputatious blind, and miss their aim. from his Root: for the Vintager cutteth off him whose fruit He hath perceived to be bitter. 2 Cor. 4, 3. 4.
1. How shall Thy servant, Lord, cease from giving Thee glory? how shall my tongue desist from Thy praise? How shall I stop up the sweet overflow which Thou hast opened in my mind that was parched? With what is Thine I will sing praise unto Thee, from Thine own gift. For in Thee, Lord, it is that I am rich, and unto Thee I bring forth increase. In Thee I am increased, and shall I refuse Thee, O Thou Giver of all increase? Blessed be He that sent Thee unto us! Thy treasure is sweet, and we are Thy treasurers. My deposit is increased in Thy storehouse as a choice seed. This is of Thy gentle mercy, that Thou causest my little to have great returns. For, lo! our debts are great, and who shall dare to ask? Lo! the danger is taken away, in Thy mercy, from the oppressors who have taken and oppressed. Yea, they dissemble, and have come to the door of Thy treasury. Give unto us, O give unto us more! To be bold I would not wish, from being daring I refrain myself. Which then of the two is preferable to Thee, Lord? The boldness of our love is pleasing unto Thee, as it is pleasing to Thee that we should steal from Thy treasury.
2. To Thee, Lord, my faith I bring as an offering in its nakedness: I have brought it without works; it as being Thine will be enriched by Thee, and I from it, and also from Thee, since I am [found] wanting. A merchant bringeth a pearl to the king; he receiveth it in its nakedness, and by himself he enhanceth it. If the king enhanceth it in his crown, how much more, Lord, shall my faith be enhanced in Thee? If even the husbandman offers plucked fruit, and the lord of the vineyard rejoiceth therein, and even giveth him clothing, and if the workman for fruit plucked receiveth clothing, clothe me with Thy mercy. He whose faith is great is not small: the faith that in him is small, in Faith should shew its inward growth outwardly. Thee, Lord, it is enhanced; and if even wheat corn is enriched in the dust, let my faith be enriched from Thy treasury. It sufficeth then for that [corn] and also for this faith that it is not we who, as though impostors, give to it from what is its own. Strip not off even from what is its own; because it groweth not in us, let it not therefore, Lord, diminish in us.
3. Woe [unto us] if we see the abode of idle disputants; we have been naughty labourers who have turned idle and fallen asleep! But and if we be watchful, we shall receive the reward which the prudent receiveth, who hath not been in any wise idle. Yet at this time many smother it entirely, for beneath the veil of the silence of fear have they put it, whose faith watcheth in their hearts, while their profession slumbereth in their mouths. For this is not prayer ministering in silence. Faith, typified by the face, is set in an open place. He that concealeth his faith, it were fitting for him to cover his face also.
1. HE that seeketh after the Truth in a grudging spirit, not even if he meeteth it will he be able to know it. Since envy troubleth his mind, he doth not know it, not even if he graspeth hold of it. His anger is mad, and dareth without considering. He disturbeth the earth, he graspeth also at the heaven. He knoweth not his fellow-servant, neither distinguisheth he the servant from his Lord. Who would not weep to see that his neighbours have forsaken and left the contest with them without, and themselves among themselves as strangers are daring at disputation? Who would not blame him who, though insufficient for the things which in his own self are concealed from himself, yet proudly lifteth himself up above his Creator, though not attaining even unto the creatures? 2. God seeing that He was never at any time searched out, clothed Himself with a body that may be searched out, that we might cease from searching into His Divine Nature, and rest ourselves in the Generation of His Human Nature. He persuadeth us to ask how the Divine Nature came down, and in the Belly was for nine months silent. Thirty years also He was in the earth, that by His long stay we might gain Him by use. He left those above, and became a companion unto those below: He left those that were found, and sought for those that were lost: He left those that were wise, He chose those that were simple, and by them He spread His simple preaching unto every man: He left the chariot of the four living creatures, and came down: and the Cross He made Him a chariot unto the Christ the Creator of all things.
four quarters [of the world]: He left the Seraphim and also the Cherubim, and came down and endured the contempt of His crucifiers. 3. Thou art the Son of the Living One, and Thou art the Son of a mortal. Thou art the Son of our Creator, O Lord, who in Thee stablished all things, and also the Son of Joseph, that workman who learnt by Thee. By Thee it was, that the Maker without teaching stablished [all things]! with Thy Finger the Creator fashioned all the creatures! by Thee it was that Joseph fashioned his carpenter's work, since he saw that Thou wert his Teacher! Hail! Son of the Creator. Hail! to the Son of Carpenter, who, when creating, created every thing in the mystery of the Cross. And haply even in the house of Joseph, that carpenter, with the Cross He was busied all the day. n. x.
As the first chapter of Ezekiel is evidently in St. E.'s mind in the text, it may be allowable to give here a portion of his commentary on the place: p. 166. "The faces of the lion, who is the king of beasts, represent to us the kings and princes of the world, who have come under and been subdued to the yoke of the Church, which is represented by the chariot; or to the Gospel, which self-same Gospel the chariot represents. The faces of the eagle again are, that we may know that it is from above that He, which shall come, is to be. But by the faces of the birds and the beasts, he represents the nations differing in their habits, who have received the Gospel and wrought at its spiritual toils... The hand that was beneath the wings of the Cherubs represents to us, that it was the might of Him Who is the Son of Man, which supporteth the chariot that carrieth Him. By this hand also he pointeth out that Christ our Redeemer put on a man's body. 'The hand of a man beneath the wings,' i.e. the foundations of the Church it is His Right Hand which
supporteth...The faces were in the four corners, though they were upon two sides. One face was that which looked to the West, from one corner, another again, opposite to it to the North, and another to the East, and that opposite to it to the South: and so it was opposite each one of the faces that the quarter to which it looked was, and each observed it whenever they moved. They formed therefore the shape of a plinth, whose breadth does not amount to its length. For the ox was yoked with anima's that destroy it, unclean with the clean. Here is a marvel to see three unclean species and one clean: and by this he taught us, that it was out of those that were circumcised that choice was made of those to be Apostles to the Gentiles: by the four corners he hinteth at the four quarters of the world."
i.e. as having four quarters. See §. 2. and xviii. §. 1. In a similar way Eph. 3, 18. is taken of the Cross by St. Greg. Nys. Or. Cat. 32. c. Eun. p. 582. Jerom. in Es. v. 10. Austin. de Doctr. Christ. ii. §. 62.
1. THE young of a bird, unless it be matured, is not able to break through its covering, through its imperfect state; and faith which is under silence is also imperfect. Oh perfect it, Thou that perfectest all things! The race of birds is brought up by a threefold advance from the belly, to the egg: from hence to the nest, and when it is perfected, it flieth in the air: it spreadeth its wings in the mystery of the Cross. And faith too is perfected by threefold advance. For since in the Father, and in the Son, and in the Holy Ghost the Apostles believed, thus the faith flew unto the four quarters [of the world] in the mystery of the Cross. The Threefold Names are sown in a threefold way, in the R. xl. §. 1. The manifold occurrence of Holy Cross spirit and in the soul and in the body, as in the mystery. When our trinity was perfected by the Threefold One, it reigned unto the ends [of the earth].
By 'the mystery' probably the Sacrament of Baptism is intended. The connection probably is to be found by recalling the use of the Cross at Baptism; upon which see Gretser de Cr. iv. 13. In vol. ii. p. 336, b. we find the following parallel passage: "Grant to us, Lord, that we may kindle three bright-shining lights to Thee, the spirit, the soul, and the body. The spirit let us give to the Father, the soul let us give to the Son, and let us give the body to the Holy Ghost. Oh, Father, hallow Thou our spirit for us! and oh, Son, hallow Thou our soul for us! and oh, Holy Ghost, hallow the feeble body from its spots! Grant to us, Lord, to rejoice in Thee, and that Thou mayst rejoice in us, and from spirit, soul, and body, to Thee be glory and on us Thy mercies! This passage, as well as the text, evidently alludes to 1 Thess. v. 23. the only difference is that supplies the place of in the text, as the word for spirit. Of which more in note c. St. E. is probably aiming at furnishing a sort of Creed against some heresy in vogue, although it may be difficult to determine precisely what he alludes to. Two errors, however, seem to deserve notice in this view. Apollinaris is said by St. G. Naz. ad Cledon. i. p. 744. to have made the Trinity consist of great, greater, and greatest;
Spirit, Son, and Father, as brightness, ray, and sun:—in the text the Three Persons are set before us as working Each alike man's renovation, though in distinct ways; which of course must not be so taken as to militate against the well-known rule, 'that whatever God does externally to himself, that the whole Trinity does.' St. E.'s object seems to be to mark out the distinctness of the Persons, as well as their equality. Basil. Ep. 265. §. 2. (compare Euseb. c. Marcell. ii. 4. Timoth. Pr. ap. Cotel. M. G. iii. p. 395. speaks of Apollinaris as restoring Sabellius' doctrine and one form of this, of which we learn from Epiphan. Hær. lxii. init. (who says they abounded in Mesopotamia; see also St. E. ii. p. 485, d. 488, c. and Assem. B. O. i. p. 111. and
Pseudo-Athan. c. Sabell. Gregales, §. 13. would be obviated by the text. "This man (says St. Epiph.) and the Sabellians after him teach that the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, is the same, so that there are three names in one subsistency, as in [the case of] man, body, soul, and spirit; that the body, so to say, is the Father, the soul the Son, and that as the spirit of a man so is the Holy Ghost in the Godhead." The form of Baptism was often urged as telling against Sabellians as well as Arians, (see Petav. de Trin. ii. 12. §. 8.) the singular 'Name' proving the Unity, and the repetition of 'the' proving the Trinity of Persons. This then would be a heresy at which the passage quoted and the text might be levelled, though it might meet some secret form of Apollinarianism, the maintainers of which had 'for disciples of the inner school' more open biasphemies. Vid. Gr. Naz. p. 746, c. Our trinity means man's nature consisting of three things, a mode of speaking to be found in St. Austin de Trin. ix. x. xi. A passage from the author c. Sabell. Greg. §. 8. may be added here. "Let no one who denieth the Three expect to find the Unity, but in the Trinity let him behold the Unity, having the sum of the faith in his Baptism, and in the three holy seals whereby he was regenerated into salvation, remembering what the Apostle says, 'There is one God, &c.' 1 Cor. 8, 6. See also Jerome on Eph. iv. 30. We are sealed with the Holy Spirit of God, that our spirit and soul may be impressed with the seal of God, and we may recover that image and likeness, after which we were in the beginning created."
It remains to shew why the particular Persons are assigned in the way adopted in both places by St. E. St. Greg. Nyss. ii. p. 602. says that St. Paul often "calleth the mind () spirit; for when this hath received the participation of the Spirit, then unto those who have received it, is present the honourable estate of adopted sonship." The word in the passage quoted answers to commonly, and also to this as illuminated. See on and if the soul suffer, it is wholly blended with the Son; and R. xi. if the body confess and be burned, it communicateth wholly §. 6. with the Holy Ghost. And if the little bird drew in its wings and refused to use the silly mystery of the Cross, the air would then refuse her, and not bear her up; but her wings praise the Rood. And if a ship spreadeth her sails for the sea, in the mystery of the Rood and from the yoke of wood, she maketh a bosom for the wind; when she hath spread forth the Rood, then is the course spread clearly out for her voyage. And if the ship was that of the Jew, the Cross rebuked him by his deed, since though not intending it, in the ship himself with his own hands hath spread and displayed the mystery of the Rood. The sea by the Rood was subjected to the unbelievers: but unless the crucifers had made wood into the form of a cross, and upon it had hung the Body as a sail, the voyage would have halted. Oh, pure bosom [of a sail], sign mysterious of the Body of our Redeemer, which was filled with the Spirit, although It in no wise confined It. By the [same] Breath which dwelleth in the sail do bodies live, in which the soul dwelleth.
Ezech. xxxvii. 1. Levit. 1. xxiii. and vol. i. p. 139, e. p. 132, b. p. 398, a. The spirit then being that part or faculty of the soul which receives the Gift of the Spirit, is said to be sealed with the Father, because as the Father is the Fount of the Godhead, so the spirit becomes by that Gift the fountain of a new life in man. Greg. Naz. p. 742, d. "If it was by sanctifying like by like that Christ would put an end to the condemnation of sin, then as He needed Flesh, by reason of the flesh which was under condemnation, and a Soul, by reason of the soul; so did He also need a (spirit or) mind, (), by reason of the (spirit or) mind which not only stumbled in Adam, but was the seat of the disease, (.) as the physicians say of bodily ailments. For it was that which received the commandment, which also did not keep it ... and chiefly needed salvation." comp. Cyril de Incarn. cap. 15. Mai C. N. viii. p. 77. It then may be viewed as the fountain of sin in the old Adam, of grace by the new. The expressions, God of the spirits, &c. &c. Father of spirits, Heb. xii. should be borne in mind. It may suffer from weariness, (see 2 Cor. ii. 13.) though preserved from
falling by the seal upon it. Manifold occurrence of Holy Cross 3. Neither, again, doth the land yield itself to the crucifiers, without the fair mystery of the shining Rood. It is the sign of a Rood which worketh it and softeneth it, and scattereth its seed therein. Neither doth his dress please him without a mystery: he spreads out his arms in putting it on as if a Rood. Lo! his covering is a mirror to him, the sign is sealed upon it which he denieth. If the crucifier buyeth a lamb and killeth it, upon wood he hangs it, Lord, that he may shadow forth the slaughter of Thee. And again, when he hideth wheat in the earth, the living seed preacheth Thy resurrection. In his flock he museth on Thee, because it is kept by Thy Rod. And in his vineyard is the cluster full of the type of Thy Blood: and when upon his tree the fruit hangeth, it is a type of Thy Cross and of the Fruit of Thy Body.
4. Lo! in the house of unbelievers the preacher of Thee crieth aloud, Ye that sleep arise, be watchful! Since it is plain what he signifies by clapping his wings there. Lo! he proclaimeth the resurrection of the dead to that buried living man, seeing that his sleep is deadly to himself. And if scribed by Himself, He was able to contain Himself as well entire without being aught impeded, as without being aught circumscribed, yet in no way straitened; this is in very deed a sign of a natural Power, that may not by any external force be shut out from its own uncircumscribed condition, or be circumscribed in doing what it pleaseth. This too is what is spoken of as the exceeding wonder by him who saith of Christ after the flesh, that in Him dwelleth all the fulness of the Godhead bodily." The word rendered sail might also be rendered 'linen cloth.' Comp. note p, p. 68.
St. Just. Mart. c. Tryph. p. 259. "The lamb that is roasted, is roasted in a form like to that of the Cross; for one upright spit is passed through it from the nethermost parts to the head, and one again into the back, to which also the shoulders of the lamb are affixed." This is not precisely like what St. E. says, as he alludes to the slaughter rather than the roasting of the lamb. The directions in the Mishna, Pesach. v. §. 9, compared with note 1, may serve to bring out St. E.'s meaning. "How did they hang [the lamb] and skin it? Hooks of iron were fixed in walls and posts, whereby they hung them and skinned them. And every one that had not where to hang and skin it, got thin smooth staves, and rested them upon his own shoulder and the shoulder of his fellow, and so hung it and skinned it."
in her nest by mere touch her womb conceiveth holily from the warmth of the [male's] cherishing wings, and hath her R. xii. issue without other intercourse, then, lo! in his own house S. marhe hath a mirror of Mary! futurum." To me the passage is very obscure, but sepulto isto vivo would seem to be the literal rendering of He would then be aluding to Matt. viii. 22. 1 Tim. v. 6. Rev. iii. 1. and the like, and the passage might be paraphrased: the cock says, Awake thou that sleepest, rise from thy death of sin, be buried no more therein, seeing there is a resurrection and a judgment, and that thy drowsiness is therefore thy death in the truest and awfullest sense of death." m The same is noticed of Vultures, by Orig. c. Cels. p. 29. (where see Spencer,) Basil Hex. viii. §. 6. Euseb. P. E. iii. 12. Ambrose, Hex. v. 20. A passage from vol. i. p. 117, f. may be worth adding. "The Father spake, and the Son wrought; and so it was fitting that the Spirit should Himself also exercise operation and shew it in His brooding over it, that hereby it might be revealed that it was by the
Trinity that every thing was perfected and finished. Consider, too, that since the Scripture is speaking of the agency of God, that this Spirit is not a being created and shed forth, which it explains to be brooding over the surface of the water along with Him; but it speaks of the Holy Spirit, how that He rendereth the water hot and boiling, and imparteth thereto generative powers. An image hereof is the hen, that broodeth over the eggs; and by the heat of her brooding warmeth them, and gendereth fruitfulness in them. It is also intended to furnish us at the same time with a type of Holy Baptism, which was, by means of His brooding over it, to gender children of God." This serves to shew how St. E. dwelt over the things of nature, and found in them types of the things of grace, arranged as it were in corresponding series. Compare what he says of Baptism, as typified by the Incarnation in n. f. p. 86.
1. PRAISE becometh the Son Who taught the Truth! do thou praise the Lord that became the brother of His servants! Honour is becoming from the time that He came in*, Who became a Child and ministered unto the lowly. Thy garment seeing it was the covering of Thy Human Nature, and Thy Body seeing it was the covering of Thy Divine Nature, coverings twain they were to Thee, Lord, the garment and the Body that Bread, the Bread of Life. Who would not marvel at Thy changes of garments? Lo! the Body covers Thy glorious fearful brightness: the garment covered Thy feebler nature: the bread covereth the Fire which dwells therein. Never at any time did the mind of mortal touch it. Who hath the Hands of Fire and the Fingers of Spirit which our Maker hath to grasp That, in respect of the Invisible Nature of Which even our mind is as it were a body? Neither again is the knowledge of the highest [Angels] capable of that Glorious One, Who is within all and without all. He is His own knowledge and our knowledge. He is the Life of our soul which dwelleth in us. Who is not astonished that though every thing is in Him, and He is also in them all, yet never at any time have they touched Him though
* Hahn takes the words as if a pleonasm for : this seems an unnecessary assumption; since may be a verb, and there is no great difficulty in supposing that 'to come in' might mean in Syriac as in English 'to be in season,' 'to be come into vogue,' or the like. they be in Him; like as the body never at any time hath touched with the hand it hath, the soul which is within it. 2. Who would not praise that Hidden One that is hidden from all, Who came openly to manifestations the plainest of all? S. to an open When He had clothed Himself with a Body bodies touched open-Him, though minds had never at any time felt Him. It is a ness Great thing that the little ones pressed upon His Greatness, from all that even It was made little in their form that It might be like: R. them. Since it was hard for them to be like unto Him, for xxxii. Him it was a light thing to make Himself like them. §. 3, 4.
3. The weak man that armeth himself is deceived. He putteth armour of brass upon his feeble body. Thou, O Lord, didst clothe Thy Nature with a frail Body, that Thou mightest be able to suffer in it. Divers remedies flowed from Thee to them that needed; though all of them were one undivided Virtue, it was many for the frail, was divided to the needy: it gathered [them into one] and was one Verity for the truthful. Thy Love collected stores for our neediness, R. vi. that to each one Thou mightest assign a different gift from §. 2. out of Thy Treasury. By little portions Thou didst move our needy estate, Lord, that it might come near to Thy door.
is part of His person and adorable as such; (see p. 158, n. c. p. 199, n. a. and Pet. de Inc. xv. 3.) The Fire, i. e. God, though so concealed, is unapproachable even by the mind. True that in the Eucharist the Word of Life is handled and seen, yet it will not follow from this that we can know, and explore, and grasp, as if in our hands, the Invisible Person there present, as the Eunomians fancy. (See p. 116, n. e.) We have not those Hands, &c. i. e. those creative energies (it not being the priest who is able to make the Body, p. 146, n. d.) which produce That which, in respect of It's Divine Nature, is such that even our souls are gross and material when compared with it. So far then from our mind being able to grasp It, even the highest Angels, who are ever praising Him, know Him not to the full; so far from having any independent knowledge of Him, He it is Who is the Light and Life of our souls. If then we would argue that we can grasp Him, because in a sense we do so in the Eucharist; let us reflect that we cannot lay hold of our own souls. This interpretation satisfies myself; it
the door of the mouth, it is as one that wandereth. Truth is its chamber, Love its crown; stillness and silence are the eunuchs at [its] gate. She is the Betrothed of the King's Son: let her not go forth to be lured into wantonness: but let Faith, as a bride to be seen in the street, mounted upon the voice ride stately on from the mouth unto the chamber of the ear. 3. For it is written, that there were many who believed on the Lord, whose voice because of danger denied the faith, while the heart within confessed it. With unbelievers did He count the speechless. Jonah prayed a prayer without any voice; the preacher was put to silence in the belly of the fish: from the midst of the reptile his prayer crept forth, and the High One heard, for silence was to Him a crying. In one body are, both prayer and faith, hidden and visible, for the Hidden One and also for the visible. Hidden prayer for the hidden ear, and faith for the visible ears. Our prayer is as it were a secret taste in the middle of our body. Let us then be rich and breathe forth the savour of faith, a savour which preacheth, and that to the taste of him that possesseth discernment in sweetly savoured things!
4. Truth and Love are wings that cannot be separated, since Truth without Love cannot fly, neither can Love and depth and of this world, preserve me as that pupil which is preserved for me in the eye. Be Thou, O God, a Preserver unto all that trust in Thee! And as a pupil in the eye, so may Thy preserving be their hiding-place! Two lids hath He made to the eye, that within them it might hide, that no hurtful thing might come into it: for by it the whole body is lighted. Two gates hath He set to the pupil which veils itself within the eye, as a modest virgin within them, as a beloved one in the bridechamber; two gates hath He raised before it, to be open or be shut; open to admit the light, and to keep out when shut things hurtful. Its eyelids furnish it with covering, that when any thing is falling into it, it may be kept from entering, and its clearness may not be impaired... The eye, it is an adulteress if it doth look not chastely; the ear, it is a fornicatrass if it hear not uprightly. When the eye looketh and lusteth after aught that belongeth not to it, it is an adulteress to God, and committeth
whoredom by lusts. It was to see the works of God that the eye was placed in the body, and to receive in itself wondering, and convey it into the region of the heart."
1. Do Thou, Lord, play on my harp with all Thy edifying strains: Sing we to the perfect with words that are healthful p. 152, and with pure words to the nuns, and with simple ones sing n. b. we to the simple! Come and hearken to Zacharias that answered Gabriel again! O aged man, search and look where-Luke 1, unto thy speech is gone! Thus is every one stopped and put 19. 20. to silence that dares to dispute with the Truth. For if Gabriel, though a servant, dealt so severely, because his word was not believed with a Levite, how much more severely will the Son of the Just One deal with those who believe not, that He is, as He said, the Son! 2. O Zacharias, barren so as to be past cure, in that thy tongue doubted how thou couldest have a son, while there was there that which might reprove thee! Appeal to the rod Numb. 17, 8. that budded, in the Ark. If then a mortal being so grudged his fellow servant, that he threw upon him the bit of silence, because he doubted concerning John, as for the mouth that Freedom from heretical deceitfulness
Is. 37, disparageth the Only-begotten, for it is the bit of Sennacherib fitted. 3. Let Abraham's single-heartedness be a mirror to shew thee that prying is an evil blemish unto faith. When he believed, he was also justified, and when he was prying, his seed was subjected to bondage. For as a partridge which calleth unto the young that are not her own, or a bird whose voice deceiveth him to whom she singeth, so let not the voices or openly, let thy voice set forth the savour of thy Truth. Moses also, with the mystic trumpets made the camp move, two trumpets only made proclamations; lo! the type is accomplished, since in the Churches two Testaments sound forth their proclamations. And David too, his harp also sang in three manners. With loud strings he sung to Thy Godhead, with tenor strings to Thy Humanity, with low middle ones he sang again of Thy Death*. And let Thy Church weak also be a harp to Thy praise! Appease, Lord, the strifes. wherewith its strings are untuned, that upon this harp we may sing of peace, truth, and concord!
1. PRAISE thou the Lord of all, Who fashioned and strung p. 217, for Himself two lyres, that of the Prophets, and also of the n. g. Apostles. Thus one finger struck the two distinct sounds of the two covenants. And yet, though the lyre hath different sounds, it is the same lyre and the same player; the lyres of Truth also, my son, have different sounds, though the Truth R. xix. be one. Also one flute is able to generate distinct sounds. §. 3. To the healthy ear it pipeth healthful sounds; to the ear of children simple sounds; to the ear of the sickly a feeble sound. These trumpets of Truth likewise set perfect sounds p. 152, before him that is perfect, but to him that is a child, they n. b. frame promises of milk and honey. 2. Who ever took a harp or horn, when men had set him for a help unto the commonweal, to sound one note at leisure and be gone? 'tis by diversity of notes that a rescue is secured. Thus therefore in many ways have the notes of the Truth set forth and sealed the Faith. The Father and the Son are my son, true to Their Names. If Jesus is dishonoured by fools, that dishonour [is done to] the Father also, John 5, and His Name is false and not true.
3. That Jesus that endured the mocking of strangers also endureth great dishonour from worshippers. Great insult is it to the Trinity, if it be in borrowed names that a man is St. Clem. Al. Strom. vi. §. 88. p. 784. Pott. gives the different mystical senses of a harp, more than one of which occur in these Rhythms, as follows: "The harp in the Psalmist allegorically signifieth in its first sense, the Lord; and in the second, those who continually strike their souls under the Lord as Chief Musician: the elect people would also be called a harp owing to the breathing of the Word upon them, and owing to their knowledge of God they are heard uttering glory notes, and stricken so as to express belief in the Word; and you can also take it in another way of the musical harmony in the Church between the Law and the Prophets, and the Apostles with the Gospel too, and the
melody which in each Prophet doth according to the changes of persons in the choir finally come out." Milk and honey were given at Baptism. See Cotel. on Barn. i. p. 19. and on Tertullian de Bapt. p. 163, n. u. i. e. The combination of notes is what gives them the power of sounding a retreat, &c. i. e. If, as the heretics say, the Names do not indicate something real. See on lxii. §. 4. Perhaps St. E. may be thought here to incline to the view of St. Athanasius, that heretical Baptism was invalid, c. Arian. ii. §. 42. p. 339. O. T. where St. A. speaks of "the rite administered by them as altogether empty and unprofitable, making a show, but in reality baptized! How should thy blasphemy be a song of praise? how should thy deficiency be as a superabundant gain? See How should thy strife, O daring man, be a treasurehouse of notification?
4. The Son knoweth His Father as a fruit doth its tree, and He also knoweth His Fruit as being the Stock. Lo! this knowledge of Them Both, in Both of Them is hidden and closed up: this knowledge of the Begotten and the Begetter is in a Treasury whose door is sealed up in mighty silence, and before the door is awful silence, and the keeper p. 115, of it also is a strong Chernib. 5. What mouth is that, my son, that shall question, or that shall speak near the door of that treasurehouse hidden and still? The Angels above when they gaze upon it, seal R. v. up their mouths with the silence of discernment. Whosoever knoweth not the awfulness of that place, as a drunken man chattering is he, and also his hearers. But if he abase himself, my son, the pride of him who was drunken is silent at Him and adores.
being no help towards religion;" and §. 43. "as deficient in religious meaning, so that he who is sprinkled by them is rather polluted by irreligion than redeemed." A passage from Didymus de Trin. ii. 15. is worth adding, "Those who come over to orthodoxy, even if they happen to have been baptized, are yet baptized—for rebaptized we do not call it, since they have not the true Baptism, not the Eunomians owing to their making but one immersion and saying that it is only into the Lord's death that they are baptized, and not the Phrygians from their not baptizing into the Three sacred Persons, but believing that Father, Son, and Holy Ghost are the same." D. also mentions innovations upon the form, p. 294. If the text appears to imply regularity in the use of the Name, it will appear from xxviii. §. 7. that the Divine Persons were only mentioned to cheat the unwary, not in the proper way. Hence what Mingarelli says of Didymus may apply to our author, that he looks on heretical Baptism as invalid only in the case of heretics who altered the form as the Eunomians did. See Greg. Nys. ii. p. 295, d. Didym. p. 279. Epiphan. i. p. 992. Sozom. H. E. vi. 26. and Reading's note. Tim. Presb. ap. Cot. M. G. iii. p. 384. men-
tions, that the Eunomians objected to baptizing the uncomely parts, using but one immersion, and that only partial. See Constant on Dionys. Alex. Ep. i. ad Sixt. Rom. Didym. de Trin. p. 25. "If in the beginning of the creation the first trees came into being with the fruits from them upon them at the time, and it is no absurdity for the fruit to have sprung up along with the root; in what way is it incompetent for the all-competent Father to have had the Fruit of His own Son in Him at the beginning, and for the Brightness to have shone with no interval from the glory of His Substance?" and Cyril of Alex. Thes. p. 304, c. and p. 308, b. "If...the tree is known by its fruit, and the Fruit of the Father is the Son, such must He of necessity be as that is which is generate from Him." St. C. as well as St. E. frequently applies the name to the Son, and to the the Father. See above, p. 10. n. a. and xlii. §. 3. l. §. 1. lxxvi. §. 1. lxxvii. §. 4. contr. Serut. i. §. 12. &c. and St. Cyr. Thes. p. 45, c. p. 126, c. p. 239, c. p. 240, c. p. 326, b. Dial. p. 413, c. &c. Vid. Petav. de Trin. v. 5. §. 15. Newman on Athan. p. 284, note e.
1. SPEAK on, harp, for silence is thine enemy; speak then whatsoever is to be spoken, for whatsoever we have no right to speak, if it be spoken, to the righteous it will be blasphemy. Unto the unbelievers is he nigh akin that dares to pry; on the very edge of death the rash standeth, in that he hath left the faith in his disputations to go down and search into the Ocean of hidden things. 2. Marvel not, my child, at what I tell thee. Take them, and compare them together discerningly. For the one denieth His Divinity, and the other searcheth how to depreciate God. The Lord of all is greater than all, as is His surname. They see by His Name that Lord of all who is greater than all. Who is there whose knowledge is great enough to feel after and mete out the Sea of all wisdom?
3. Cleanse the harp of thy soul from strife! Let it not sing in thyself from thine own, for self-will is death. Let not proud boasting speak in thee strains of mockery, for it is wholly mischief to thee. Tune then such strings as have become discordant by disputation: draw in the strains which go astray in vain searchings. Be first, my son, in the presence of the Divinity, and then shalt thou sing the praise of God, for then art thou a living harp and a reasonable. Liberty indeed thou hast in thy strings, and in thy words also, thou harp that from thy soul and from thy will singest unto thy God. Set thy soul then in tune, and sing without discord. Harmony gendered by keeping to revealed order of mysteries. 181 Purify thy strains and sing unto us, but not of hidden things. Be a disciple to all the things revealed, speak fair things which are free of danger; weigh out then thy words, sounds which may not be blamed; weigh also and sing strains that cannot be reproved, and let thy song be, my son, comfort to the servants of thy Lord, and then shall thy Lord reward thee!
4. Do not, therefore, sing things hurtful to mankind, neither divide, by thy disputation, brethren at unity together: put not a sword, which this questioning is, among the simple that believe in sincerity. Sing not then unto God perversely in the stead of praise, lest thou forget and sing iniquity. Sing like David to David's Son, and call Him Lord and Son as David did! Do not dishonour Father and Son at once! Neither again sing thou to the Father the reproach of His Son, lest thou sing to the Son too the dishonour of His Father, denying that He begat Him. That the Father is first, is without all controversy: that the Son is second, is without all doubt: as that the Name of the Spirit is third: so that thou shouldst not pervert the order of the Names. 5. Make ye then disciples, and baptize in the Three Names, that is, in the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. For the Name of the Son could not have come before the Name of the Father, that there might not be confusion. But how and why this is so, is encompassed in silence. Far off from that silence, without it, be thou speaking of His praise. Let not thy tongue be a bridge for sounds, which letteth all words pass across it. Praise do thou send up to Him, as the tithing of thy strains! A waive-sheaf of words offer unto Him from thine imagination, hymns also as first-fruits, and send up clustered hymns thy tongue hath culled.
1. WITH the weapons of the guilty wrestler, did the Lord prevail! He clad on a body which was from Adam, and from David, that with that body which the wicked one had made guilty, he might be brought low, so that his disgrace might the more abound. Yea, that littleness of Thine is too great for the eloquent. For who shall open his mouth [to speak] of Him that feedeth all, who was yet brought up at the poor table of Joseph and of Mary! [Coming] from the Bosom great and rich, which maketh all rich, in the poor bosom of Mary wert Thou brought up. Thou hadst a mortal father upon earth, the while Thou wert living and quickening all things. 2. He rode upon a lowly ass; hidden in His humility was His nobleness. They that rode upon horses and chariots were overcome while victorious. For David conquered the warrior ranks, and a weak rib brought this warrior low. The ass spake, and knew that she was an ass, and knew also her master for her master. What sort of teacher is he that cannot distinguish the work which is made, from the Maker? If Nabal too was overcome because he thrust forth his scornful tongue, in that he opened his mouth brutishly, for he esteemed lightly of David the great king, and joined his name with servants; then whoso is so foolish as to be like Nabal, flee from his tongue, my brethren, and from his death; for it is not the son of Jesse of whom he speaketh scornfully, but the Son of David.
3. The Lord humbled Himself and came down, and the Maker became a servant. He was as a minister, He was a fellow-servant who washed the feet. These things let us search into, my beloved, if we be able to give due thanks! The Lord of Heaven came down to the earth and became a sojourner! He was a sojourner [there], and a dweller, and also a traveller, that He might take us up and cause us to dwell in His Kingdom in an everlasting mansion. 4. Praise we with all our mouths the Lord of all tongues! how long shall we go astray, and how long will it be ere we praise the Son of the Living One, against Whom, because He took a Body in His Love, the crucifiers have been bold, and the disputers have been mad! On the sense of the word servant, see Petav. de Incarn. vii. §. 7. The word in the Syriac comes from the same root as the word for Maker. Hence it easily suggests to the mind the text, Ps. 119, 91. 'for all things are Thy servants.'
The well known words of St. Greg. the Great may be added here. Hom. in Matt. xxv. H. ix. §. 1. "Who is that man that travelled into a far country, but our Redeemer, who with that flesh which He had taken, departed into Heaven? For of flesh the proper abode is earth; and it is as it were led to a strange country, when, by our Redeemer, it is placed in Heaven."
1. WOULD that some one would give to me a little breathing of the Spirit, not that I might prophesy, for that were death to ask for, but that I might have enough to set forth the praise of Him, that is greater than all, with my poor tongue. For without the gift of that Divine Majesty Itself no mouths are able to set His treasures forth, since it is with His key that those treasuries are opened in the presence of His treasurers. Glory be to the Gift which lispeth in the mouth of the speakers, though by its speech it snatcheth not their own free will away. The mouth is owner of two things at once. With that which is His, it museth on Him; with that which is its own, it magnifieth Him: without the gift of the word too the mouth cannot declare of Him, who is the Word, what and how great He is. It is by word too that man is able to speak in behalf of himself, and be his own spokesman. The eye also is able by the light to see the light, for by the rays thereof is it able to see its beauty. Even by the brilliancy from itself man is able to see the lightning in the heavens. For without the guidance sent forth from the lights [of heaven], the eye were not able to come to the light, and also in the midst of thick darkness fire by its shining draweth the pupils unto itself.
3. The type of the Son of the Creator is sealed upon the creatures: through the light, fire, and also water, as with the rest wherein He is, can human nature approach, through the type of His Majesty. By the gift of the sea the swimmer has strength to swim on the deep, because the power of the water supporteth him. Not incoherent are the tides there, the dashings also, and the waves, and the murmurings. And as the surface of the sea is on the very verge and confine of destruction, whereon thou yet mayest ride; so there are also those that dwell in the depths of it, after the fashion in which these knowing men do in the generations of the Divine Majesty. 3. And though the seed be from us, yet is the fruit from His good pleasure; that Gift of His doth not teach us slothfulness. Its thriving strength suggests to us by thriving strength to seize upon the riches which His mercies have brought unto us. And the rain too which He sprinkleth over all is His Gift; this doth not teach idleness unto the husbandmen. Their labour increaseth their stores; and here again thrift increaseth solid boasts.
4. May Thy Gift, O Lord, take me up soon unto Thy height! by Thee I can be great enough to reach unto Thee. For if through the creatures man is able to attain to the creatures, may I through Thee attain, Lord, unto Thee! Me shall the example of Zacchaeus persuade, for he reached forward to Thee! By Thee his weakness was made great, and he mounted and reached to Thee. Lo! the voice which came from Thee to him, brought near to Thee him that had kept aloof of Thee. The fruitless fig tree yielded fruit; tasteless insipidity yielded a taste. The sycamore by means of its fruit became a salt, which cleared away tastelessness. A marvel is the fig tree which was despoiled of its natural fruit, and bare a different fruit that was not according to its nature, and that which in another form was not eatable, the hungry ate in the possessions which he distributed. May Thy Gift call me also as it did Zacchaeus, not that I may distribute possessions as he did, Lord, but that I may make haste, and restore again interest upon Thy money.
5. For this thing also, namely, that He gave His money to the merchants, sheweth us that without His being joined unto us, there were no trading: and so neither is there any finding of the Truth without His Gift. Run, my brethren, and gather along with us all similitudes, for lo! they are too many for our mouth to describe. Be ye then pleased St. Ephrem prays against unstableness. with what we have found, and it is right that we be also with what ye have. For the lump cannot without the gift of leaven partake in the flavours thereof. By the Gift from Him the whole lump may have it entirely diffused throughout itself. Neither can the curdle thicken milk without the hidden power of the rennet. By the gift that comes from it, it thickens milk's fluid nature into a close mass. 6. Grant unto my unsteady nature Thy straight ascents! By Thee, Lord, let my vileness ascend unto Thy Majesty! By Thee let it reach up unto Thy Height, in a large room, that there it may worship Thee!
Ass. recti aditus, as if from the occurrence of so immediately would alone seem to determine the etymology of the word, which does not occur in the Lexicon. Ps. lxxxiv. 6. would occur to those acquainted with the Greek and Latin Fathers, as referred to here: and possibly St. E. may have had a version in which the of the LXX was given.
1. THE Hidden God is by His First-born a Creator, wonderful yet tiring not, for in respect of master, He lacked Ps. 121, not one, nor was He feeble at the art, for at the nod of His 4; 40, 5. Will, noiseless and gentle, from out of nothing He created all, and ordered all: and as without labour He created, so without anxiousness He supporteth all. In the Beginning He created all things, while His Thought was with Him without any beginning. He hath no thinking as man hath, that He xxxii. §. should be moved in any new way, as is a child of flesh. His movement was not new, nor was His thought fresh. His creation is subject to time and starting and beginning. But His knowledge preventeth times, and beginnings it transcends. The natures of the Seraphim are concealed from us, so that we are to seek as to how an angel hath six Is. 6, 2. wings, and what his wings are, and where they are, and how a spirit needeth to fly by means of wings. Is this a parable? or is it plain truth? If a truth, very hidden it is; and if a figure, very perplexing it is. Withdrawn from us then is that Infinite Hidden Being, and the searching into Him is too deep for feeble men, and the seeking after Him too high for mortals. And who shall fly up unto His Height? or search out His Depth? He that ventureth towards His 2 p. 144, Height, stumbleth mightily, and falleth; and he that venn. g.
The objects and occasions to be considered tureth to His Depth, drowneth in it, and perisheth. Miserable is the death of him that pried into Him, and the drowning of him that dived to search Him out! 2. The sun that we see persuades us, my brethren, that it is harm to gaze upon Majesty, since His Nature is too potent for any mouth, and to all languages wholly strange, since our perceptions wist not how to shadow Him out, for there is none of them daring enough to be able to reach unto Him. But the writings of the prophets essayed to depict a symbol [of Him] in Names. For causes there were, why they should be spoken with after so imperfect a manner, since, if He had essayed to speak according to the marvel and wonder of His Divine Nature, it had benumbed their hearing, put a stumbling block before their childishness: the simple man had perished, and the perfect man had fallen short. By every similitude then He accommodated Himself [to them], that man might according to his power and ability suffice for Him.
3. The man that thinketh to liken the [Divine] Essence to the creatures, is in a great error. For us to body It forth as the mouth, the ears, and the eyes, this weakly frame of ours, is a danger: for us to frame a shape of It, is a terror: for us to measure It, a wickedness: for us to limit It, an iniquity. And though He was higher than these, yet in His mercy It condescended to be below these: the likenesses which are suited to man, came forth from the treasury of the Lord of all. According to the time and the circumstance, He setteth forth a likeness, that He may help us thereby. In the time of wrathfulness, in the time of cheerfulness, in the time of fearfulness, in the time of quietness, though His Essence remaineth equable, yet, according to the laws of men, He changeth Himself.
4. Lo! Moses, when he taught the people, spoke of His Majesty after our fashion: he overthroweth these same [ideas], in that which he says, Ye saw no similitude in the when God gives or withholds similitudes of Himself. 189 fire. For the Hidden One did not clothe Himself with a likeness in Mount Sinai, lest the people should shadow it forth in colours. He gat Him an Image and a Countenance with Moses, that he might shadow Him forth in his heart. And as it was profitable that He shewed no countenance or image in Mount Sinai, that He might not give profaneness occasion, to shadow forth Himself in erroneous conceptions to mankind, so was it profitable also that He clothed Himself with the likeness of a countenance, that He might shew us His glory, and we might perceive His fairness. In not shewing it He hindered error, and in shewing it He edified more abundantly.
5. When the elders saw Susanna, they sought to know her. And when Moses saw the glory of the Majesty, he betook himself to all humble entreaty, and besought Him that he might see Him, that He would make Himself known to him. The elders falsely said, that they had seen what they declared they saw. And Moses too when he saw, yet knew that he saw not, for that discerning person did not forget that his Lord put on borrowed similitudes. The sight of the Lord of all lowered itself to dust, and the Stablesher of all things formed it into shape! and as He condescended to shape it in His goodness, so He humbled Himself to shew Himself in His littleness. And if, though in our similitudes, Moses saw Him and was afraid, how then is it possible to stand before the real power of His Essence? Lo! the Son alone can bear that*!
6. Gaze then on Him [and see] that it was He, and yet it was not He, for the Real One veiled Himself with an image: His fulness was found within it. His Brightness was covered with our form: for the form was not devoid of His Majesty. This similitude then was not of the Divine Nature. The Majesty made itself a veil * On the place he says, 'I will cause to pass, &c.' i. e. glory, such as thine eyes can bear; thou canst not see My Face,' i. e. it is not possible for man to live among the living of this world after he hath seen It.' It may be added in allusion to what has been said above, note c. p. 116. that St. Chrysostom, who also refers to Ex. xxxiii. 2. conceives sight to be here knowledge; "For there are not the pupils, eyes, and eyelids, in the incorporeal powers; but what with us is sight, that with them is knowledge. When then you are told that 'no one hath seen God at any time,' consider yourself to be told this, that no one hath known God with entire accuracy."
1. GOD Who existeth essentially, hath a Nature glorious as His Name. And if He be an Entity Who is in His Name distinct from all, He is an Entity Who in the knowledge of Him is withdrawn from all: let things which are made harass themselves as they may to understand Him, since He hath nothing like to a created being, gaze they as much as they may upon the attributes, these it is which they behold instead of Him. Lo! natures fancy that they see Him, [even] Him Whom in them they cannot ever see! For they looked, and lo! they erred, in that God they deemed to be like unto themselves. For had they seen Him in Himself they had done well to think they saw Him; instead of Him they saw themselves, and thought that they saw Him. Oh, childish man, that feeleth himself, and fancieth that he toucheth the Hidden One. For the Nature of the Entity which cannot be shadowed out in the heart, as He is, of that what likeness shall we make, if we would not go astray and settle down in that for Truth, which is but like the Truth? If then in the likeness they fancy that they have seen Him, grievously are they misled, and do mislead grievously, they err and make to err. For the Fruit that is from Him alone knoweth Him in verity.
2. Woe to the blind synagogue of disputers! they stand in the light, and yet seek for it. They touched gold and imagined it the sun. They felt a seal, and thought it was the colour of the light. They handled every thing and felt every thing, and lo! they foolishly thought that they felt the sun. Each then as they fancied, took his shadow in his mind for the sun. Neither did they consider that there was but one sense akin to the sun. Their other senses were bereaved of and strangers to the sun. Its flavour is not tasted, its savour is not smelt: its clearness is not heard: its light is not handled. The sight alone, being related to it, is able to reach unto it, as a son to his father. 3. Light dwelt in the palate and it felt it not; it rose and dwelt in the ear, and it was not affected by it. It dwelt on the hand, and how came it not to touch it? The nostrils snuffed it not up. At its rising upon it, the mind and the heart, the king and the captain of his forces, and all the host of thoughts and their army comprehended not the sun: and yet into the Lord of light vile things of dust do pry! Lo! it is a disgrace, and a dishonour, and an ignominy, and a shame, that all of them [are employed] about one thing, and that they are not all of them together able to see this feeble light which is before them! Lo! it poureth itself about them, its radiance brushes by them, its brightness anointeth them, and though they are clad with it, it is removed a boundless distance; it is [as it were] by hearsay that the feeble beings have perceived it!
4. Lo! the blind in their questionings are like unto that proud blind man who took hold of the bow and shot arrows therewith into the flame, and he perceived not how his arrows were wasted away; for the arrows which he shot in his pride became ashes in the fire, became dust in the wind; and if it should happen unto him that he himself went up to it, he and his arrows would be consumed.
1. If clouds and lightnings and meteors, yea, and earthquakes and whirlwinds and floods, being but fellow-servants, are terrible to [us] servants, when they come impetuously upon our feebleness, and if the ministers that are appointed to minister to him, are thus awful to man who is ministered unto, who shall venture to gaze upon that Might, by Whose Power all things subsist? Lo! medicines have a different power, which is hurtful to us when they are not mingled, and wine also injureth with its sweetness, and spices with the strength of their odours. Sleep and food without measure are harmful. And if the weak things, when not [rightly] blended, are hard upon us, how much harder shall it go with the man who without restraint prieth into the consuming Fire? 2. Therefore the Good One hath appointed us weights, and measures, and rules, that we should approach with restraint to the creatures, in order to receive from them benefit and comfort. Is it not in measure then that He hath granted to us that men should approach unto Himself, Who is greater than all? or is it to be without restraint? How then cometh He to have put restraints upon all, and upon the disputings of the disputers to have put no restraint? Lo! His bounds are stretched forth upon every thing, and His restraints are spread over all. Over natural* things He
* S. Macarius, Hom. xv. §. 24. "The nature of irrational animals is tied down, that of the serpent, for instance, is bitter and venomous, and consequently all serpents are so, ... &c. The dove is guileless and simple, and the whole dove tribe are of the same nature. But man is not so: for one man is a rapacious wolf, another is as a lamb that is the object of rapaciousness; both are to be met with from the same race of mankind." St. E. vol. iii. p. 366. fin. "As the word of the mouth is loose, so is free-will loose, and as the tongue of the dumb is bound, so is nature bound. He hath not the word of the mouth; neither hath the latter free-will. Put thee on some of the things I have said to thee; taste free-will in thine own person; make trial in thyself of thy power over thyself; see whether thou hast it or no! From thy own self thou mayest thyself learn about free-will." Compare also St. Athan. p. 349. O. T. Cyril de Ador. in S. and V. p. 499, a.
The boundaries existing in nature coincide with sets Him a necessity; over free agents, mind and will. The natural things are fixed; things unbound are preserved; the law is a wall that preserveth free agency. Who can take away that which belongs to natural things, though our free will goeth astray? 3. Lo! the sun is bounded in his course, and the moon also hath her increases ordered: He hath appointed an order too for the earth and the heavens: the firmament hath He bounded by the waters which are above it. It is not He which is confused, but we that are perturbed. For if by the sand the waves are bounded, marvel at the rash man that proudly lifts himself up above Him Who is Lord of all! Lo! let us from his very self teach, my brethren, to the daring due restraint. For his conception in the belly was bound, as also in the womb of the earth his resurrection is, and his birth [therefrom]. Lo! the conception limited him, and birth limited him, and death limiteth him, and the grave, and the resurrection! lo! by these the rash man is limited, but his own questionings he limiteth not!
4. Lo! we will yet farther rebuke his confusion, since his will is perturbed by his liberty. For his nature is overruled Gen. 1, 6. Jer. 5, 22. S. gaze Eccles. 11, 5. Ps. 139, 2. R. xl. 4. 1. Butler Anal. i. 1. p. 40, n. g. by [Divine] Goodness, that nature might be distinguished from liberty. And if any one was minded to injure his members, yet he hateth those that so injure him, and loveth his own members:—thus maintaining the order of his bodily parts, while loosening and perturbing the order of his mental parts! 5. Lo! the Cherub was a boundary to Paradise, and an awful barrier to Mount Sinai. Whoso approached, was stoned without mercy: by things visible, He warned us from things invisible. If then He set a bound to that mountain for all that day, for eternity He setteth a bound to the loftiness of His invisible Nature. There, there was death for him that was daring: but here, there is Gehenna for the disputatious.
6. Lo! the leprosy that reproved the talkative, reproveth the insolence of the disputers; for though it was Miriam who spoke against the meek man, yet he wove his lips into a garment of leprosy for her. Her love clave to the child in the water; on the land she made the heart of Pharaoh's daughter swim. For that child who was swimming—from the wages for himself, he nourished his mother also. O miracle and wonder and amazement! for if Miriam spake against a mortal, who was indebted to her for the kindness done to him in the waters, although she was also older than Moses; yet that righteous man who had commanded elders to be honoured, upon this elder prophetess inflicted a disgrace, a disgrace without mercy; who shall be clear, if he seeks into the First-born of Him Who punisheth the talkative? 7. If then the Most High avenged the servant of his sister, a prophetess, who intermeddled with him, who shall meddle with the birth of that Majesty, Who is the Son of a Bosom which is consuming Fire, whence there flame forth lightnings
to be merciful to his own self, then he cannot be oppressive to his brother. The alternatives are placed in the midst: if a man call upon God as forgiving, then he has set his own debtor free; if as Avenger, then he has desired Him to be forgiving to himself. A man's neighbour then is stationed along with himself in all aspects. Wherever Divine Goodness is, there are his debtors stationed; and wherever Divine Justice is, there are his misdeeds stationed. If he seek to supplicate for his misdeeds, then has he for his debtors also lifted up a prayer: if he draw nigh to Divine Goodness, then he has let his debtors go: if he draw nigh to Divine Justice, then he has summoned his own misdeeds." This unfolds the meaning of the text: men will not let others hurt them outwardly without seeking redress; but they will mar their own inward constitution, and sell themselves to work wickedness, and then complain that they are slaves.
o 2 Audaciousness in heretics Acts 2, and Tongues [of fire]? The prying of daring men is as 3. stubble with Him; and the questioner and the contentious Is. 47, like as chaff, and like as thorns, are devoured. Gehazi also 14. 2 Kings who mocked and was mocked, tried to escape his master's 5, 1. &c. 1 p. 128, notice and was disgraced. The daring men try to escape n. h. men's notice [when pretending] that they baptize in the S.Trine Three Names. Now at the mouth of Three the judges decide. See here be Three Witnesses Who put an end to all strife! And who would doubt about the holy Witnesses of His Baptism? 8. If the Temple was avenged, because dishonour was done it, who would raise lowering questions about the Lord of all? Approach not to His Generation, lest thou be destroyed. For Uzziah offered incense, and was smitten; and since he was not ashamed to stretch forth [his hand] to the glory of the sanctuary, he was ashamed all his days, because his leprosy covered him; and since he dishonoured the hallowed house, he had to shut himself up in his own house, as unclean. The hallowed house which halloweth all, from it he went forth a leper all defiled. And the doctrine which rightly ordereth all things, hath been to us a fount of questioning disordering all things. The rain which profiteth all, by superabundance of it injureth all; and the sun which illuminates all, by the might of it blindeth all. Bread also which quickeneth all, to him that eateth gluttonously is a murderer.
9. His ordering of bounds bringeth the impetuous into order, seeing that it is with fire He hath surrounded His sanctuary. The two hundred men that dared to seize the priesthood a fire befriending the sanctuary consumed: it drift of the whole passage then would admit of being stated thus: Those who will not believe 'the record that God gave of His Son' (1 John v. 10.) are obliged to approach the most sacred rites with a lie in their right hand; they are worse than Gehazi, who thought that none would witness the sacrilegious use he was making of the type only of the Sacrament of Baptism seen in Naaman, (see on the place, p. 532, c.d.) which was 'by water only'; but these daring men make the most solemn adjuration a mere trap for men's souls, and while they call to witness the Three that bear record in Heaven, they thereby constitute all, that keep alive a religious sense of the honour of having had God's Name sealed upon them at Baptism, judges of their own sacrilegious intentions; they summon from Heaven Three Witnesses against themselves, and prove the Church's doctrine by the counterfeit of her rites, which to save appearances they are compelled to adopt. (See note d.) It may, in conclu-
sion, be right to remind the reader, that it is not St. E.'s usual practice to quote Scripture; he alludes to it in by far the greater number of instances. The wilfulness of false worships. Levitt. devoured the sons of Aaron because they offered up strange 10, 1. fire, as it were a harlot, and the hallowed fire was zealous p. 39, b. against the strange fire; and the knowledge of the truth is zealous against the contaminating disputation*. Lo! they are both shadowed forth for the wise in the hidden mirror of thought, as having both put on one shape of wilfulness and one stamp of venom from their liberty of will! Both of them willed to be priests to God. On their visible offering their hidden heart is impressed; for by occasion of their offerings 1 Sam. their secrets were openly set forth to shame. 5, 6. 9.
Church, have some of them laid violent hands on the faith which was put into writing in that glorious Council. Memorable is the king that assembled them!—Heads they became in the midst of the Churches! Some too were presbyters and deacons! others doctors and readers! some were even religious: and from the Church they stole ordination of each kind of ministers to act as priests, and to baptize, and to break bread, and to teach that our Lord hath come and will come. Blessed He Who hath restrained them all by His Truth!" And just before: "Let them be distinctly asked from whom it was that they received imposition of hands? if it was from us that they received it and then repudiated it, that sufficeth for the truth; but if they have made themselves priests and done arrogantly, that sufficeth to reprove them, for this very thing is to their shame. For every man is a priest if he please, and lays his hand on his own head. A confusion this which cutteth off hope!"
* Here again as above, p. 102, n. d. is an implied parallel between heresy and idolatry. See on R. xxxvii. §. 3. St. E.'s words upon Levitt. x. 1. may be interesting. "Nadab and Abihu suffered not upon one count only, but upon many, as Scripture hints; one was, because they brought in strange fire upon the fire which came down and consumed their sacrifices in its time; another was, that they despised Moses and Aaron, and brought incense without having received any permission from them; a third, that they confused the time of beginning their office, and offered incense not in their proper time; a fourth, that they entered into the sanctuary, a place which Aaron their father went into once a year. Now that they offered strange fire is typical. The strange fire he calls the wilfulness of Adam and Eve who were in a haste to become gods." And so on 1 Sam. xiii. p. 357. a. "By this action and the consequences of it he describeth to us a type of the first Adam, because both of them (Saul and Adam) despised God's commandment, and both of them also justified themselves and accused their fellow-creatures; both of them harmed both themselves and their sons; both of them dared to lust after a rank of which they were not worthy. Moreover by this they are blamed, who invade the rank of the priesthood, without receiving imposition of hands." Here we see St. E. again dwells on the wilfulness of the act of Nadab and Abihu as its main feature, though he views it as typifying another thing.
1. God in His mercies called mortals gods through grace; but they by their scrutinizing have set limits to Him who is God, as though he were man. This Body of yours which He put on, Cherubim bare up and Seraphim are awed before it, Angels are still before it; but yet ye that are despicable have made light of the generation of the Glorious One. For unto that weak body which He came down and clad Himself with, His names and operations were assimilated. And as it was needful for Him to be hungry, thus also it was needful for Him to pray, and as that hunger belonged wholly to the body, so His lacking belonged wholly to the , p. 210, body. Do not ye die by means of the names wherewith , n. b. the Living One veiled Himself that He might quicken all!
2. For the Mighty One clad Himself with names which fell short of Him in His pity for you by reason of the body. On which of them will ye fix as true, honourable, and glorious! True is the Name of the Father, Faithful is the Name of the Son, and to be loved is He as being a Pardoner, and to be feared is He as being Judge. Because the Son of man, he was bounded, without bound was He, because His Nature is God. Weak clay hath dared to go down and feel into the properties of the sea. It hath scrutinized the floods thereof to make himself acquainted with the place whence they come up and where they settle. That vile one that prieth cannot even find out from what place the hand which fashioned him took himself and gave him measures which he yet scorns. Who ever saw dust which dared to assay the power of the winds with questioning? The daring shall die in scrutinizing Him whose Breath quickeneth the dead.
1. GOD who is the Lord of all, who is not numbered with His works, as if among them, who is not subject to metre, or weight, or touch, or colour, or measure, is not confined in space, for He is not as the spreading forth of the wind or the sunbeams, that any thing comprehend to Him. Knowledge is His Essence; for all that have knowledge* are strangers to His Substance. For what escapes these rebellious men is, that the thing made comprehendeth not its Maker. The natures of Angels are fire and spirit: the natures of bodies are dust and water. The Nature of the Lord of all who can perceive? that Nature which these three natures are inadequate to the explanation of and which it is above them to say how, or where, or in what shape It exists? 2. Explain unto us these three things for instance, how great thou wilt say, when asked, that He is? how great His measure is and His weight? or His height and length of whatsoever is His? or again, how and what His appearance is, if He be
* Asseman. renders thus: Ipsius essentia Ratio est, hanc extra si quid aliud cogitas, ab ejus notione longissime abis. This is a paraphrase, and to me not a very clear one. It might be rendered thus: Ipsius essentia scientia est: omnia autem quæ sciunt, ab Ejus Substantia tamen procul absunt; i. e. 'With Him to know and to be are identical: creatures which have knowledge, are yet strangers to all but His doings and attributes. Himself they cannot attain to.' See p. 191. The sense here given to seems to be required by the context. It means the stem or stock of a tree, and is the Chaldee word used in Isaiah vi. 13. where our version has 'substance.' It is obvious enough to take some ordinary solid substance as the type of 'substance' in its metaphysical sense: in Greek, mula 'a root' in Sanscrit, stoff in German, in Heb. and in Syrbone, are similar instances. Basil. c. Eun. i. 12. "How great is the insolence of men that profess to know the substance of God! I should like to ask them what they have to say about the earth on which they stand, and from which they are? What
account they will give us of its substance, because if they can give any unanswerable statement about things on the ground, and close at their feet; then we may trust them when they are so positive about things out of the reach of all thought. What then is the substance of the earth? what the method of comprehending it? Let them tell us in answer, whether it was reason which arrived at this, or sense, and if it is sense that they say, to which of the senses is it comprehensible? Is it to sight? nay, for that graspeth colours. To touch then? why this also discriminates between hardness and softness, hot and cold, and the like, and of these no one would assert any to be substance, unless he was gone into a state of downright derangement." This passage seems almost to have been known to St. E. See §. 2. Either passage supplies us with the ordinary ecclesiastical sense of the word 'Substance,' as somewhat in no case cognizable to the senses. See xxxi. §. 1. The 'three things' allude to the common definition of body, . Sext. Empir. Pyrrh. H. iii. §. 39. ii. §. 30. &c.
202 God's condescension, though real in His Incarnation, 4. For the Fruit is blessed, being as His Root. He put on humility in His temptations. The abysses and the waves of His wisdom He veiled and concealed though questioned. p. 135, Scriptures which to us were of small account did He cite to the serpent, and lamed him and stopped his disputing and questioning. Our Lord cited from Moses, but the daring cite from error; for the serpent, subtle and disputatious, clothed his disciples with his own cast-off skin. Put off and cast away his cast-off skin, lest thou become corrupt and be destroyed by familiarity with him who destroyeth all. They that are new and white, in their newness have put on the moth of self-will: and, since it lay hid in their garments, have been corrupted and changed. Put ye on leaves which are strangers to the moth.
5. Since that disputer is subtle and acute, his intricacies overthrow the single-hearted. Put not on the disputatiousness of that servant; let not thy free-will become a fellow-servant of his, for that evil servant grindeth his fellow-servants, that he may stamp his own image upon them and dye them with his own stain. Whoso putteth on his likeness, it is not possible for him to see his own deformity. If then thou seest that the All-knowing hath become little, fancy not that He knoweth not. The love of us it was that made Him small, that He might not know. For He became small that He might measure thee, that thou mightest not be small. The humiliation was that thou mightest turn thyself aside from searching into Him Who searcheth all. For if thou art so weak as to be unable to struggle with wine, if what is lowly overcometh thee, how much more would that Generation lead thee into perplexity?
1. LET us praise Him that put on the names of the members: who named Himself cars to teach that He heard us, who surnamed Himself eyes to shew that He saw us; the names only of things did He put on. And as there is not in His Essence wrath or repenting, He put on the names of them for our weakness's sake. Let us know, that unless He had put on the names that belong to such things, it were not possible for Him to speak with us that were men. By what was ours He approached to us. Names did He put on that were ours, that He might put on us that which is His. For when He asked for and put on our form, and as a father with his sons, so spake He with us childish creatures; lo! that likeness did the Invisible One put on, and yet He put it not on; He stripped it off, and yet He stripped it not off; and though He had it put on, yet He had it stripped off! He put it on to assist us, He stripped it off when He changed. For as He stripped off or put on every form, He taught that this was not the likeness of His Essence; for the Invisible One shadowed that Essence forth in things visible.
2. He was in one place like an Old Man and the Ancient God's manifold economies Ex. 15, of Days: also He became like a Mighty Man active and a 3. Warrior: for judgment He was an Old Man; for battle He was Hab. 2, an active One. In one place He was as one delaying, and, as 3. He had run, in another place He is weary. In one place Ps. 44, He was asleep; in another He was empty. In every way 23; 50, He laboured that He might gain us. For that Good One, 12. when He could have made us glorious by compulsion without labour, laboured in all ways that we might be glorious by our and affirming He profited us to our instruction. In the vision of the sapphire [throne] He gathered Himself up Ex. 24, and sat upon it. He unfolded and filled the heavens, though every thing was in His fist. Himself He shewed in space, and shewed Himself every where. We fancied that He was in space, but every thing was filled with Him. He who was small that He might be on a level with us, was great that He might enrich us. He was small, and great again that He might make us great. Had He been small and not great, He had been small and would have made us small. Because He was fancied to be weak, therefore He was small, and great.
5. Let us marvel how that by being small He made our smallness great! Yet if He had not been great also, He would have made our mind's conception of Him small, since it would have thought Him weak, and would have been made less, in that it thought so. He is a Being of Whose greatness we are not capable, nor even of His littleness. He was great; we got ourselves bewildered: and He was little; and we got ourselves into guilt. In all things He laboured with us. He willed to teach us two things, that it was He and yet it was not He. He made Himself a countenance in His love, that His servants might look upon Him. Again, that we might not harm ourselves by thinking 'this is His form,' from form to form did He change, in order to teach us that He had no form, and though He departed not from the shape of man, yet in His changes of it He did depart from it.
eret. [L.] is often used, (cf. i. p. 136, e. illustration of this see on the latter place. ii. p. 333, e. iii. p. 529. contr. Scrut. i. The whole passage is to me far from §. 42. p. 187, c.) nearly in this sense. In clear.
image, which Thou didst borrow and clad on, made Thee R.xxvi. small, how much more would the Body make Thee small §. 6. wherewith Thou didst clothe Thyself in reality, not in likeness? Thou didst make Thyself small when Thou didst R.xxvi. create: for Thou didst come down from Thy Majesty to a §. 5. low estate, since creation was not possible, unless in a state of condescension Thou hadst come to Thy framing of it b. He clothed Himself with littleness 3 ere He was a Creator. 3 R. liii. How could He create, unless He could be little? or how else §. 4. could He do great things? Glory to Thy good-will! The Son immutable as being in the Father. 4. From Thine own Thou hast become little! from Thine R.xix.own too Thou hast become great! Thou becamest small, §. 2. because Thou didst let Thyself down from that Majesty; and Thou wert great, because Thou shewedst Thyself gracious, and didst create the creatures. Thou becamest small outwardly, and Thou becamest great outwardly: it was not in Thyself that Thy Glory waned and increased. Thy R.xxxi. Nature is equable, and high above those changes. My §. 5. littleness hath spoken of Thee, since Thy Majesty hath been willing to fall under words; and to be beneath voices, that R. v. Thou mightest be profitable to the mouth and to the hearing. §. 3. The Father and the Son are One, because Their Nature is p.87,n. One. They wander not out of One another; they are i. p.144, blended with One another; they are distinct from One n. g. fin. another. Glory to Thy blending! p. 235, n. h.
Syr. from a word of uncertain origin, probably formed (as a similar word in Hebrew and Chaldee) from the fut. of , 'to stand up;' for transpositions similar to the one required here occur in the Syriac proper names, for Jael, Naioth, &c. Etymologically then it would seem to be, 'that which stands firm,' as e. g. in R. i. contr. Scrut. §. 24. it is used for the 'firmament' of Heaven, and vol. i. p. 6, a: in §. 31. of the 'reality' or 'substance,' as opposed to the 'name' of the fruit, as also in vol. i. 6, b. ii. p. 532. and iii. p. 279, b: in vol. iii. p. 249. death is said not to have the 'reality' of speech and silence; ibid. p. 246, a. in our frame is Thy Baptism, and in our 'substance' is Thy living Body. But by far the commonest use of the word in St. E. is for 'self.' E. g. in vol. i. p. 373. Saul having in vain tried to get rid of David by means of the Philistines, 'himself' or 'in his own person' rises against him. P. 389, c. "a spirit 'in itself' wicked and lying and hostile, and hating God." P. 392, e. "to stretch forth his hand against the king 'himself,' the king's person." P. 497, d. 'by the sacrifice of Himself.' See also iii. p. 61, b. 259, d. 269, f. &c. In this sense it seems to answer to one use of hypostasis, in which it was used of essence, considered as subsisting in one person, i. e. of one person, viewed not as person, but as essence. Hence, e. g. when the Son is said to be the express Image of the Father's Essence
in the Syriac, Heb. 1. our version has Person, and above, 'a spirit in itself wicked,' would not in a popular way of speaking differ much from 'a spirit essentially wicked.' See farther on R. i. contr. Scrut. §. 31. and on R. xl. §. 1. In the text the adverb employed is equivalent to 'essentially,' if we view the Son's Human Nature, as an accident to His Essence. (Vide Petav. de Inc. vi. 8. §. 4.) What St. E. means to say is, that the Divine Nature remained what it was, as the following passage from vol. ii. p. 516, e. will shew: "It is not possible for the Nature of the [Divine] Majesty to become small or be humbled, except in similitudes." And p. 512, f. "A wonder is the visible sample that meets our eye, even the word [of Christ] that wished to persuade the learned concerning that Majesty, of which fools thought that It was not perfect. For us then it was that It was small when small, and for us that It was great when great; and though it was equable in Itself at all times, all similitudes did It put on in Its mercy, for the Nature of the Divine Essence doth not ever at any time wane or increase...He is One, that waneth not; He is One, that increaseth not: for the whole of Him is in every place. There is no space within Him for us to enter into, neither is there any room without Him to go out into. How should He expand or be greater, or how contract or wane?"
1. JOHN in truth when he saw Thee, shadowed out Thee, S. The truth of John in order that every man should shadow Thee out by that R.lii.§.2. type, in his mind, and not dare to shadow out aught that is p. 50, foreign to Thee. The appearance that the Spirit in John n. r. R. xliv.§.5. sealed upon us, therewith also are our heart and understanding and mind impressed. His Nature is hidden, yet revealed, though it is entirely hidden; for it is revealed that it existeth, but concealed in its mode of existence. Let us R. xlii. leave alone what He hath left, and that which He hath given §. 1. us to hold fast, let us hold fast. 2. If it be too difficult for painters to paint us the wind in R. xlii. colours; whose tongue hath painted the Generation, which §. 1. no mouths have painted with their words? When they paint the body, they paint not the soul; and when they paint the mouth, they paint not the voice, since these fall not at all under the pencil; the Scriptures which paint unto us the Son, paint not unto us, when [He became Son], and though R. l. they preach unto us the Father, yet they preach not unto us how §. 1. above, [He begetteth], since these things fall not under investigation. p. 69, n. t. And if then the devil cannot be shadowed forth with colours, who with his investigations hath shadowed forth the Holy Ghost? The unclean spirit chideth at their interpretations of Him: for as he concealeth himself from the painters, thus an hundredfold more concealed is the Godhead from their minds which do not comprehend the mode of His existence. comp.
n. c. p. 170. Spiritual Essences cannot be represented to sense. 3. And as colours paint not the voice, so thoughts suffice not for the Son, that mark at which they aim from a subtle mind. Which of the painters gazed upon that brightness in which Moses was enwrapped: neither the painters of faces nor the painters of drapery sufficed to paint him. For those heavenly tints could not even by the eye be perfectly taken in or by the mind, which was not correlative to either of them. Now if the countenance of an aged man and a mortal, because it was but slightly suffused with the heavenly tint, put the colours to shame, and perplexed the painters, who then shall shadow forth the Nature of that Essence which cannot be seen unto perfection? And whoever is said in Scripture to have seen Him, saw not Him, but a shape in which He wrapped Himself. For lo! the intelligible colours of all minds are not correlative unto the Son, so that we should paint therewith His likeness to the hearers, or know Him as He is. For if that breath which may be held and felt, we yet cannot paint, who shall shadow forth that Generation which is revealed to the Father alone, and withdrawn and hidden from all [others]?
1. BEFORE Adam had sinned, all the creatures were pure; and when he and they were pure, he garnished them with their names. And when the man sinned in his free-will, the Creator rejected them by reason of his sins, though he was more unclean than they, that by them He might teach him, and bring him unto pureness. Blessed be He Who by means of beasts taught him not to make himself like them. For like unto beasts and brutes he made himself, as is written. By them He shadowed forth man's own hideousness, that he might see how foul he had made himself; that when he saw his hideousness, he might be disgusted thereat; and when he saw the great blot upon him, he might feel ashamed; and when he saw whereto he was like, he might weep, and seek the brightness which he had lost. 2. One mirror serveth to minister unto many in a state of concord: but to Adam were many [given], that in them he might see his own manifold stains. He drew our attention to
1. LIKE is nature unto Scripture, and like are those within to those without. In their questionings do their losses come, comp. and by their own arguings their mischiefs. On nature those without looked and stumbled, in Scripture those within have p. 107, read and have been perplexed. Grant me, Lord, that I may suffice to plead with them according to Thy will! One, In the beginning, is like the other, and John also is like Moses: for in the beginning of their books they have reproved the scribes that searched amiss. For one preached God who came to suffering—and Moses also nature which came to travail in pain. That the hearers might not be weakened [in the faith] they wrote their glories in the beginning of their books. Blessed be the Pure One who in pure things opened unto us the mouth of pure fountains! 2. For from the words which are written concerning the humiliation of the Son of the Creator, the searchers thought that He was a creature. They too disturbed the fountain, and when they had disturbed it with their strifes they turned to prying, and drank the waters that their feet had disturbed, and though that doctrine was clear, yet they were drinking dregs from out of its clearness. O Lord, shew mercy upon our wilfulness which first disturbed and then drinks.
Nature and Scripture, save through man's fault, O Fountain of wonder that art clear and disturbed according to the parties using it. For it is pure to the pure who are purified in its pure drink; and to the disturbed it is disturbed, because it is to the disturbed as sweetness also is bitter to the sick. Truth is disturbed among the disputers, as sweetness among those that are sick. Lord, heal our sicknesses that we may hear of Thy Generation healthfully! 3. Those without looked on nature the whole of which was disturbed for Adam's sake; for in it were the sins from free-will, and the fearful stripes from [Divine] justice: they foolishly thought that it was nature that was deformed and confused. And those within slandered our Lord for His Human Nature; they saw His littleness, and were perplexed. The wicked one mocked both sides. Reprove, Lord, that deceiver who mocketh us as he did Samson. Because they have disturbed the stream by searching, they think that it is disturbed and its fountain disturbed the clear fountains enough, ye searchers? Our sin hath disturbed nature, and our searching hath confused the Scripture. And for the fair flock that cometh to drink it is perplexed, since we have given to it perplexed sounds to drink in. It came unto nature, we had corrupted it; and it came unto Scripture, we had confused it. Clear up, O Lord, the water-courses which the searchers have disturbed, who have been disturbers!
5. That searching which confuseth all, that strife which perplexeth all, Ezechiel had beforehand shadowed out when he reproved the shepherds, saying, 'My sheep fed upon pastures which your heels have trodden down, and they have returned and drank waters which your feet disturbed.' Lo the words, and lo the doings of the proud have disturbed the creation! Let us give thanks, that before the searchers [came] the fountains were clear to the Apostles. Clear up, Lord, the streams that the shepherds have disturbed before Thy flock. Avenge my simplicity, O Lord, from the wise that are very foolish; for if they had known Thy greatness they would not have dared to scrutinize Thee. For if they had cleaved to nature, yea, and to Scripture, they from both would have learned the Lord of both. Nature sheweth by open things, and Scripture too by plain things! Blessed He who by one quickeneth bodies, and by the other quickeneth souls. By pure Pastors give me to drink from the pure water-courses of Scripture!
1. THE Son came down to visit the servants, because their infirmities lingered and delayed, and the physicians had been forward to come, yet had been wearied of their labour. They healed but little and left much alone. Blessed be He that sent Thee! Since they were not able to see Him, He took Him clothing from the sheep. The flock approached to Him, and loathed Him not, since the smell of the sheep breathed from His clothes. The wolves that were crafty were afraid of Him, because He had changed [His garment]. They rent His garments and revealed His glory, and though they wished it not, His bright-shining glistened forth from His veil. 2. The chief pastors of that day, who saw that He was put to great shame for His sheep, as if drunken with the savour of strong wine thought that He was the Head of the pastors and shepherds; and the husbandmen that crucified Him felt that He was the Heir and Lord of the Vineyard. The shepherds thought Him a fellow-servant with the sheep, because in His love He became the Paschal Lamb. Let our eyes be opened with fountains of tears, since the Son of the Maker, by Whom we were made, did they that were made slander with their own names,—the reward that they paid Him Who made them great by His own Names.
Difficulties in nature accredit the Son's Generation. 219 with the creatures. There is freedom attached to thy own R. bondship: set not thine own yoke upon that Sovereign Nature xxviii. who freeth all. and b. S. His Lord-ship 4. Wherein thou art burdened, recount to us, for haply thy bruise is like His. Who shall define what number they were, or of what kind they were, which He bare for thee? What hast thou borne for Him? If thou doest not honour to Him, yet do not do dishonour. In what fire hast thou been burned for Him, that the smoke of the furnace of thy obstinacy hath come up even unto Him? R. xviii. §. 2.
5. See! with what zeal the Eternal Being is zealous, saying, One is not divisible into Three. Let alone His Name and shew His Nature; for this very Nature giveth eyes even to the searchers. The nature of stone is divisible, and the other natures are [herein] its fellows: the nature of fire is not divisible. See! the assaying of their natures proves to us as good as eyes. For they are akin in their names, when they are far off in their natures; so then thou canst not shew us a common name in which things divisible and not divisible are alike contained. Lo! every single thing that exists has a single name to it, each single body, each single person, each single one, as also every thing which is the subject of number. But if it be [only] from thy having called it so, that one is indivisible, thou art greatly in error: the nature of water is one, yet it is divisible also; in fruits and seeds it is even changed. It is impossible for us to rise up to Him without experience of His Nature. For the fact that He is one, doth not give us means of comprehending and finding an explanation of His Generation which is with-drawn from all. contr. R. i. §. 10. p. 136, n. e.
6. There are two different assay-furnaces, faith and exp. 122, n. i. The alternatives of faith and experience. perience; for either man believes the truth, or experience is able to teach him how it is. The faith of the children of truth needeth not to be investigating. To us the way of seeking for experience and disputation on every thing comes from the heretic. Take and cast him among the waves that he may cease entirely from his questionings. Demand of him an experience of the Divine Essence, how it exists, and where it exists, and whose it is? and if the Generation is explainable from any thing, or the creatures from what is nothing? Plough once and again the land of thorns, and it will yield thee the word of Truth, though itself ignorant of it.
1. ISAIAH darkly describes him who put the bridle of error Shints upon the jaws of men, the sign of humiliation which made at. Is. 30, men brutish. Blessed be He, whose Truth made error to . cease! When we had made ourselves like the beasts, God came down and made Himself like unto us, that we might be again like Him. Hail to the Blessed One! for from what a R.xlvi. place to how different a one have His mercies called me! But §. 6. man, who being in his honour understood not, was wroth and Ps. 49, rejected Him. Israel waxed fat, and kicked and rebelled 12. Deut. and hid and cast away that mercy. O thought most 32, 15. mournful! 2. From being wise and teachers, Satan made men brutish. S.great. Instead of the yoke that maketh one those that are divided, mournhe with the yoke of strife divided them by disquisitions. In ing. In the thickets he made them run into a maze, among snares, R.xliii. where on one side there were the mountains of guilt, and on the §. 2. other side again questionings and fearful rocks! In a place place R. xx. of ditches, where ten thousand eyes were required, and . 4. 6 comp. of ditches, where ten thousand eyes were required, with much 1 Cor. 13, 2.
Heresy has no faith, but is 2 Chron. 16, 9. he made gods among the unbelievers. To the artificer master. For He is a Wall of Adamant, such as the Prophet saw in the spirit; the dart of words, if one should fling against it, without fastening in it, will turn back and fix itself in those that spoke them. Look at a potter's wheel, and then behold ye the wheel of thoughts; for the motion of the one enhanceth the clay, but that of the other degradeth the Son, though He may not be degraded. Fight not with thy Fashioner who made thee a speaking vessel with discourse of reason. As for the potter, his vessels are silent. As for that Good One, the vessels which He enhanced strive with Him. The least fragment of searching into Him is a hard rock which cannot be made smooth. Two words to thee out of enquiry into Him are heaven and earth. What a space for thee to stray in!
5. Thy bound, Lord, no man hath passed: Thy great height no man hath lowered. The Nature of the Eternal One and the Bosom of the Father are the Walls of the Son which cannot be trodden down. As there is no nature which can enter into and feel the bosom of fire, outside of which every man keepeth; there is no wall to it, neither battlement is there, and yet every man is warned off by it. Who will dare to pry into the Bosom of that most fearful Essence? By the sea the rivers are stopped; and by the investigation of the Generation of the Son all venturesome disputers!
and cast it out, Thou hast made it as a confused smoke. Is. 51, 9. Thy measure weighed silence and speaking that we might do so likewise. And does not even nature teach, my brethren, that by one scale without the twin one we can weigh nothing? Let us avail ourselves of silence and of speaking; let our speech be as the day, and as the night again let our silence be; for both the hearing and the tongue require rest: for they may be likened and compared, the doctrines of truth to the broad day, and again silence and stillness are as the night; and as sleep again is rest abounding in sweetness. 4. For the word of Truth be we labourers, and, as upon ground, come and let us toil therein; sow we love and reap we peace. Let a sheaf come up from reconciliation to the Lord of peace. Lo, a breath of the Holy Ghost with its fanning purifieth the corn-heap; the chaff it winnows, the pollard it scatters, the wheat it gathers into the Barn of Life that hath no tares! Blessed be that Good One who gave us speech, and blessed be the Just that added silence! He gave us sides upon which we might search, and keepeth others from us that in them we may be silent, as being Teacher of all. And it is not the whole earth that He has given us to go up and down, but a portion of it only; neither the whole sea to go down to; neither the whole sun for the eye to exercise lordship over.
5. And how then is it that the mind wishes to have that Majesty, which cannot be thoroughly comprehended, to exercise a lordship over It, as though it reckoned It to be less than the creatures? And if those things which are given unto us are not given unto us fully, how should we search into the hidden Generation which has a bound about it continually, my brethren, as the Mount Sinai? 6. Adam wished to inherit brightness, and the earth became his inheritance. Uzziah wished to take to himself the priesthood, and a filthy leprosy was caught by him. And who shall venture upon hidden things, the boundaries whereof are stillness and silence, yea, the walls thereof are fire and judgment, and their hedges are wailing, and weeping, and gnashing of teeth? Who shall make a breach in the rampart walls and enter in and take the fearful woes? Whoso maketh a breach in the foundations the hedges and the walls, doth it for gain;
Orthodoxy a subject for thanksgiving. we, my brethren, should do it for damage. I will praise Thee, O Lord, who hast held me back from the hidden things, and from those follies which have emptied the trea-
1. IF, my son, the crucifiers and the heathen mocked our Lord, because He was the Son of Man, yet it is true that He is God of glory unsearchable; and instead of disputers who pry into His glorious Generation, Martyrs loved Him, who with the blood of their necks preached the Generation of the Son of God. Discern ye how our strife hath refuted all to a certainty that He exists. Rather, let it not be discussed whether it be possible for Him to generate, since He 8. is Master of all possibilities. For it is not on one side that the Godhead is confounding; it is a difficulty on all sides. Who hath been able to measure the grains of seed, and the drops of water, and the herbs of all tribes, seeing it is all wonder in all these? For if to us Its motion in our own procreation is incomprehensible, who can comprehend the Generation from Its own Bosom?
1. THE sun is our light, and it none is able to know; how much less to know man, and still less God! The light of the sun is not subsequent to it, neither was he at any time without it. The light is the second, and the warmth is the third; they depart not from it, nor are they identical with it. Look at the sun in his height, which is thought to be one; descend, and look, and behold in his light, a second; try, and feel, and search his heat, a third. They are like, and yet not like one to another. The second is blended with him, though well distinguished from him; and the third is mingled with him, distinguished, blended, and mingled. Light and also the sun are individual subsistences; there are in them three kinds mingled in a threefold way, himself, and also the light, and the heat the third, dwelling one in the other, and agreeing without grudging. Mingled, yet not confused; blended, yet not bounden; assembled, yet not compelled; yea free, and yet not divergent. Let then the haughty ones ponder the things which are seen, for lo, one are these three, and the three are one, blended, yet not compounded, distinct, yet not several! There is a marvel in all these things which putteth us to silence. Thus man also is compounded of three, and will rise in the resurrection, when he is perfected
The use of the sun as furnishing by its light a type of the Father generating the Son is very frequent indeed in the Fathers. The use made of it here and R. lxxiii. §. 1. is much less frequent: indeed I am not able to furnish any other instance of a passage exactly parallel, as they speak rather of the Holy Spirit as Light of Light, than as heat of light. St. Cyril Thes. p. 337. speaks of the Spirit 'passing naturally from the Father through the Son to those fitted to receive It as heat out of fire would do in a body;' which procession of heat from fire he elsewhere, e. g. 175. uses, as is commonly done, of the Procession of the Son from the Father. It may be added that a simile of a like kind used by Greg. Naz. p. 612, a. is urged by Veccus Or. ii. 13. G. Orth. vol. ii. p. 57. to shew the Procession of the Holy Spirit from the Son. 'Who is there with any parts or sense who would deny that the procession of the light through the ray is its existence through the same? For if the existence of the light from the sun were not through the ray, the light would never have been called the light
of the ray, &c.' I mention this because the passage in the text struck me as helping to indicate what St. E. held of the Procession of the Holy Spirit, before I had seen this passage in Veccus. S. [spontane] [sic], 'single natures.' So Alexander, Alex. in Theod. H. E. i. 4 calls the Father and the Son vâs vâ bôserâen dâm qâens, where Lowth quotes St. Clement Al. Strom. vii. §. 5. p. 831: whether St. Cyril also used the word qâens in the sense of Person is too wide a question to enter upon here. St. E. of course uses his word only of the type, and that in a way answering rather to the Greek bôserâen than to the Latin persona.—[scato] here rendered 'himself' is used of the substance of the sun, the light and heat being strictly not substances, perhaps, in St. E.'s view, but rather emanations. Still as the word is contrasted in part with [sic], the passage goes to shew the indefiniteness of the word in St. E.'s time. See n. c. p. 210.
See R. xviii. §. 1. "The race of birds is brought up by a threefold advance, &c." and note d. In vol. ii. entirely. The sun which, though one, is an uniform nature with three mingled in him, distinct yet not divided, and one by one the whole of him is perfect, and in one all of them are perfect, and the glory is one, yet is not one. This nature is a marvel; for it generateth solitarily, and gathereth itself up conjointly, and unfoldeth itself threefoldly. 2. If then a man dare to think that fire is not threefold, who will be led into error by him, and cleave to his foolishness, and agree with his perverseness, and reject the threefold which are seen to be equal and yet distinct, and this is one
p. 551. there occurs a Rhythm which will throw some light on this passage; the following are parts of it: "Let us reprove Bardesanes, since no man can take away any one of the forms appertaining to man, any more than he can the form of fire, for if he did, he would annihilate it; since it is by three parts that it liveth in perfection, as man is of a threefold composition... Their own simile reproveth them: by it they have given the body the surname of 'egg,' and the soul of 'bird,' and do not examine how bones and flesh come forth from the said egg, which is like the earth in which the body is conceived, and rends at the resurrection its earth and its sepulchre, and flieth at the advent. The comparison for the soul does not stand, for the bird has two generations: the first that of copulation, the second that of incubation. The womb generates by copulation, and the earth without it, after the type of the bird, performs the second generation in the Resurrection. Let us notice to what they compare our Saviour's work: for if He rent the bodies and made the souls to fly, then our Lord has overthrown the type of the unbelievers. But if the tombs were broken open as an egg, and the entombed bodies rose and came to life, then hath our Lord given the cause in our favour...
Eggs are reckoned like the dead by these frantic men, and they are quick in their nests to the wings of the bird. Corpses in their tombs are dead to the heretics, but alive in the grave to the Quicken of all: thus not even as powerful as that wing of the feeble bird have they reckoned the overshadowing of the Good One who raiseth all! Three things in the Resurrection are brought to be one whole, the soul, and the mind, () and their harp the body. The mind () dwelleth in the head, the word thereof in the mouth, and the soul participateth with them both in every
thing. Distinct are their names, easy are they in their significations, difficult in their primary essences." another. If then this fire is of a miraculous nature, which produceth, yet lacketh not; which is equable, and doth not chill; and when its heat is distinct from it, yet it is not cut off from it; that passeth through every thing, and grudgeth R. v. not; that flieth into bread, and blends itself with water, and q. 5. p. 105, dwelleth in every thing, while the whole thereof dwelleth in n. i. it; a symbol of the Spirit is in it, yea a type of the Holy Spirit, who is mingled in water that it may become a propitiation, and is blended with bread that it may become a p. 87, n. h. R. x. q. 4.
by St. Austin de Trin. iii. 4. 'The element is not consecrated to be so great a Sacrament, save by the Spirit of God working invisibly.' And so in the Missa Leoniana ap. Assem. B. Lit. iv. p. 27. Gothic. iv. p. 39. &c. Yet there can be little doubt that the Western Churches held, that the elements were consecrated by our Lord's words then repeated. See Gotti Theol. Scholastico-Dogm. Tr. vii. qu. 2. q. 2. and Le Quien on Damascene, p. 268, n. 2. Bened. xiv. de Miss. Sacr. ii. 15. Orsi de Liturg. Inv. Sp. Sct. ii. q. 2. Martene de Rit. i. 4. 8. q. 19. Benedict. Antirrheticon, ii. cap. 5. who quotes a passage from Theodulus Ben Althib. which will be of service here: 'The power of the Holy Ghost descendeth at this day upon the Bread offered upon the Altar, and consecrates it and makes it the Body of God the Word. For the power of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost, and their operation is one. (see p. 166, n. c. When the Son blesseth and consecrateth, then the Spirit blesseth and consecrateth; and when the Spirit blesseth and consummates, then the Son blesseth and consummates; when the Father imparteth His Divine power, it do the Son and the Spirit impart in like manner. For albeit the Persons are distinct, yet is the Substance and Nature one. Thus in like way is Their power and operation. Therefore the Bread which we receive is His Body, as He Himself saith;
and since He Himself calleth It His own Body, Who will not confess It so to be?' (comp. St. John Maro. cap. xxxiii. Assem. Cod. Lit. v. on which B. remarks, that Theodulus here conceives (1) the words of Christ to be the efficient cause of the Real Presence, and (2) operation of the Holy Spirit to be not distinct from that of Christ. Here also is perhaps the key to St. E.'s meaning: The Son and the Spirit are said to be sent, and not the Father; and this mission is of course
not any thing new, but Their Eternal Procession from the Father considered as affecting us. Vide Petav. de Trin. viii. Hence St. E. passes off from the doctrine of the Trinity to that in which the Mission of the Two Persons (as explained in note f.) is continually brought before us, viz. the Eucharist. Sacrifice: and though He seemeth to be entirely in all of them, His fulness is far removed. For it is not possible to shadow forth the mysteries of the Trinity, which cannot be
1. Who hath at any time seen a raven that was not single? or a hornet that ever companied with others? The virgin bee generateth in virginity, and the worm in solitariness gendereth. The cloud also bringeth forth the lightning gloriously, and the spark from the midst of the flint appeareth marvellously. The pool of waters also swarmeth with insects by means of the sun, and convinceth the infidels, because it gendereth in purity like as the waters brought forth creeping things at the beginning in chastity. Who would not wonder at all these, which are hidden, yet not suffocated; even the moles in the dust, and fish in the sea, and the babes in the womb. For by what motion is the iron of its own accord led to the loadstone; and another kind of nature hath been found which is never scorched in the fire, and many are the inventions also of stones, and roots, and medicinable virtues, and who hath been equal to defining and distinguishing their natures?
2. The solitary procreations which exist without intercourse, which have natures too difficult for them that are enquiring, and investigations too subtle for them that pry into them, justify us in not prying into the mode of the Generation of the Lord of all; and in not searching after the place, and in not saying the causes of It, and in not seeking after the time of It. And although there are a smell and a colour and a taste, which are beautiful and subtle, and cannot be touched by the hand, yet by the senses allied to them they may be comprehended; one is smelt, and another is tasted: but what sense is there akin to His Majesty, by which, as being related to Him, we may approach to the investigation of Him? • Similar reference to the mysteries of nature is made below, R. lviii. §. 1. R. lxiv. §. 3. contr. Serut. i. §. 10. It is held I believe at this day, that the copulation of one generation of insects produces other generations with the organs of the females in such a state as
to conceive afresh, without further intercourse. See Schubert Geschichte der Natur. iii. p. 64. Thomass. de Incarn. ii. 3. 10. Raynaud. Christus. iii. 2. §. 198. furnish similar instances to those in the text. Any thing that is not allied to us and of our race, who is able to search into? and who is able to scrutinize it? To Him it seemed good, and He revealed what His own Nature is: to Him it seemed good, and He became little, and humbled Himself, that He might shew Himself to us, and blend His without reason, how by our reasons doth he abuse and lead us astray? For as for the Lord of natures, His Nature is hidden from all. Grant to me to form no shape of ThyR.xliv. Nature by the creatures. But if [by any one] it be shaped out §. 5. so, in order to lead the daring astray, the Gospel is thy marvellous mirror, and in it the Threefold are seen without contradiction, since in Them the Apostles went forth and baptized without disputatiousness. O Lord, let not my searching afterp. 166, n. d. Thee make my baptism of none effect; for there is that hathp. 228, made his baptism of none effect by his scrutinizing. And ifⁿ. c. he be made a disciple afresh and renewed, then it is right for him to be also baptized afresh; but if one be not so baptized, he sheweth, that it is because he found no new thing that he abideth.
1. Who hath been able to comprise as it were in water-pipes and pass over in his thought the billows of hidden things? As searching is to us in our weakness, as it were, bitter, how much more then is the standard of glorious Might bitter? Who that hath his senses not healthful would be able to bear the might of that Power whose Generation is unsearchable? The sight of the Spirit were not suited to our pupils, and strange were the colour thereof for our eyes to gaze upon: and who is there that will by his scrutinizing become correlative to the Hidden One, who is in all respects unknown to all? Who that hath made his mouth correlative to flaming Fire and his taste to that Brilliancy which never was tasted at any time? Let him learn by this fire, the might of which cannot be tasted, though the power of it is tasted by the taste of what is dressed, and in this way it is our profit and altogether our gain. So also is the hidden Essence; mingle and take Its might in the divers kinds of blessings, since the investigating of It in Its own self is too arduous and difficult.
2. The sun passing into a transparent vessel, into water, begetteth in the cold element the hot fire, an offspring that is like itself; marvellously it generateth; an offspring rises up from it without division, so that his light is not quenched, and the water is not divided. The offspring is one of chastity, which glisteneth forth in spotlessness. Gold is uniform, a flower is threefold; stone is uniform, fire is threefold; burning, and heat, and light are blended in it. For it is not by one comparison only that the language of the creation mounteth up; and thus, as They are preached, so receive ye without gainsaying these Threefold Ones. For they stand not by the ordering of our wills; that nature as it exists, existeth threefoldly, neither can it be comprehended, wherefore it is found to be such, as without question it really is. For who would blame him who said that fire exists threefoldly? No man condemns him, since every one allows him. The passage of fire remains a mystery to thee, how it is conceived in the sun and hidden therein, and how again it is concealed in the womb of his brightnesses; and the pang which begot it is inscrutable! This wonderful birth of that miraculous thing silenceth thee and refraineth thy thought, since it surpasseth thy mind!
3. The fruit which thou hast never tasted what sort it is, if thou shouldst feel it with thy hand and smell it and also see it, yet because thou hadst not hitherto tasted it and tried it, thou wouldst rely upon another who had tried it; since then He is too mighty for thee, even that hidden Essence, believe that Fruit whereby His might hath been tasted. Take wheat, and open it, and examine it, and shew us how the blade, the ear, and the root are hidden [there], which are each one of them perfect within it threefoldly, and which is recent, which old, or which afore other: and though they had a beginning, yet this is difficult to comprehend, since their hidden beginning is from themselves unto themselves.
1. By the little egg set the bold disputers at nought, since R.xviii. the form is hidden in a threefold way in the liquid; ask then §. 1. its head and its feet and its wings, how they are three, that they may instruct thee. If then he be stifled in an egg by his scrutinizing thereof, how much more will he be whelmed that dareth to feel into the mighty Sea! Blessed p. 144, be He who with weak things hath astounded our mind! n. g. Lo, the wheat when stript yet hath its garment in it; we buried it unclad therewith; we saw it again glorified! That silent body which hath crept into its dust, it is a wonder that it therein hath gotten itself a covering, and its dishonour cannot be understood, now that it is swallowed up in glory, and the whole of it hath become a bride in bridal ornaments. For as in the stalk the wheat is secreted, thereby it amazeth the investigator and causeth wonder in the beholders, since they know not how to feel after it and investigate it. It is manifest and visible, yet it is not; it puts the searcher to R. xlii. shame, and lo, it crieth aloud in its silence, 'Be ye ashamed §. 2. with things visible, ye rude dealers with hidden things!'
2. Yea, there is a hidden treasure in that visible plant, or stem. three are hidden there, and cannot be searched out there; three that are one, and though one they are three. Who R. xlii. hath penetrated into the midst of a plant and [found] how §. 3. the root, and the fruit, a second, and the leaf, a third, are blended one with another? Therefore, that His true Church R. i. should not be the abode of strifes, and a sect of divided n. b. people, He shadoweth forth and shewed Himself how He S. divisions. is. For He Himself alone sufficeth to teach us concerning R. Himself, seeing that it is open to Himself alone to search xxxix. into the mode of His own Existence, and He hath given §. 1. R. ix. §. 6. foretastes thereof by His words for His true ones. He then who prieth into Him entangleth himself in Him, seeking out so as not to know Him, searching so as not to find Him: for he loseth that which is in Him and findeth that which is not in Him. A man may find Him so as to know Him, provided he seek not in order to know Him as He is.
Is. 65, 1. For if thou hast believed Him, then hast thou comprehended Him. 3. Choose thyself one of two things, of which enquiry shall be made of thee: that if He is true, rely and enquire not; but if He cause thee to go astray, who shall gather thee in? It is fit that thou shouldest rely upon Him in these two things. For Rom. 9, if He hath made thee to err, it were evil for thee to reproach Him with it. How much more should He be believed in that it is the Truth which He hath written and given unto thee! But
1. His Names admonish thee, how and what thou shouldest call Him. One He hath taught thee, that He is; another R.xivi. that He is the Creator: He hath shewed thee that He is §. 2. also good: He hath informed thee that He is just also. §. 3. 4. Father likewise hath He named, and called Himself. The Scriptures are an assay furnace: and the fool why should he babble? Assay in the midst of His furnaces His Names and His distinctions. Praises be to Thee from all, who confess Thee without scrutinizing! 2. For He hath Names perfect and appropriated: also He hath Names borrowed and transient, which He suddenly R. iii. clad on, and suddenly put off, as that 'He repented', and §. 1. contr. Scrut. R. l. §. 17.
* See p. 150, n. c. p. 190, n. f. p. 205, n. b. Vol. ii. p. 480, c. "The false teachers have been deceived by the expression 'He repented,' a sound word which is bitter to the infirm, and they distorted it, while it only explained how great Adam was. Lo! God essayed to persuade him that he was not the vessel of an impotent workman, seeing it was no other Workman that restored him. Dumbness belongs to the [other] creatures, but Adam had discourse by his nature. The seas are spread out, and the mountains are fixed, but Adam commands. Perversely then have men understood the word, and yet it has at this day currency, and it is the way with men to find fault [and say] that 'God exalted one whose character He did not discern; and Saul too beareth witness of His having repented also of having made him king and given him authority, and yet he proved perverse: what is not seen in Adam's case, is plain in Saul's.' It was that He might reprove the slanderers, that He by the kingdom ensnared the freewill, which has full power. He nourished and brought up children, and they corrupted themselves and proved perverse. Which is it that the hearers ought to blame?
God that honoured? or those that disgraced man?" Ibid. p. 506, e. "Whose nature would be made greater by that great One, unless He denied Himself by taking what is not in Him. For this He did when He said He ate, and ate not the sacrifice that the fire ate. (Ps. 50, 13. Levit. 9, 24.) He denied Himself by taking the appearance of a man, though He is hidden from all in His Essence: so did He by that repenting which is not in Him, that He might awaken it in our race in which it is. That, however, He might not be as it were divided with Himself as if hating altogether the truth which is with Him; He on the other hand confessed the verity of His Nature, that He might shew of what manner He is. When He stated that He hungered for fat, He on the other hand confessed that He eateth not sacrifices: when He stated that He dwelt in the Sanctuary, He also shewed that the Heavens are filled with Him. He denied His majesty, that He might shew how merciful He was, &c." P. 514, c. "When it was known that His Nature as unchangeable, was far from passions, He feared not to put on repentance; hence He was not ashamed cease to exist, then would the world be nigh to falling to ruin.
3. The Jews change the Names of God, yet they are not able to live upon the multitude of [their] surnames [for Him]. Because they rejected the one Name, they have been rejected in the many. The Names that that people put away and threw aside, in them are the Gentiles baptized. And who is able to untie those Names which have made a trench between us and that people? One cause alone made that people rejected, and he that untie it, buildeth Jerusalem. For it was not because they did not scrutinize, that the Jews were rooted out, but because they did not believe by the Son. Search for a cause which rooted up Jerusalem, and see that it hangeth over them until they cease to strive.
much as to the other: he who denies the latter will soon come to deny the former, they being in fact, though not in our conception of them, linked one into the other. In regard to the illustration here used, it may be mentioned that in vol. i. p. 12, c. he says, that "the heaven and the earth and fire and wind and water were created out of nothing as Scripture testifies;" and ibid. n. e. "the remnant of other things were made out of these same things which existed." See also p. 7, c. where he shews how the creation of things not specified in Scripture as created, are implied to be created within the six days. Here he omits earth and heaven, because they make up the world of which the others are the pillars. His caution against denying the obvious sense of Gen. 1. is quite to the purpose to add: "By Heaven and earth He means the very Heaven and the very earth. Let no man then suppose that there are allegories (Syr. Targums) on the work of the six days: neither may one say that the things which took place in the days took place in a moment, nor that the names are empty ones, or that other things are intimated to us by the names. But let us know, that as the Heaven and earth which were created in the beginning are in very deed Heaven and earth, and it is not any thing else that is surnamed to us by the name of Heaven and earth; so the remnant of things made, and of the courses which come after are not empty appellations, since the realities of the natures suit closely to the appellations of the names." p. 6. So in the text he
Assem. renders in Filium, which is not exact; St. E. means, that the Jews did not believe through or by the Son in "the Three Names which have made a trench, &c." comp. vol. iii. p. 592, c. St. Gr. Nyss. ii. p. 339. "If it be only that they may lay themselves a sort of foundation and starting-place for their blasphemy, that they allow an existence to the Son and the Spirit, it may be a bold way of putting it perhaps, but, at that rate, more profitable would it be to them to desert to the Jews' worship and forswear the faith than to do an insult to the title of 'Christians,' by their pretended admission. For they by continuing up to the present time in the rejection of the word, only carry their impiety so far as not to admit that Christ has come, but to be hoping that He will come; but for any conception wicked and subversive of the opinion they hold of Him whom they expect, none such can one hear them utter. (Comp. p. 71, n. z.) But these of the new circumcision, or rather, to use the Apostle's word, of the concision, do not deny that He who was expected, has come, but imitate those who in unbelief and insolence dishonoured the presence of the Lord in the flesh. They essayed to cast stones at the Lord; these with blasphemous words throw stones at the word of truth: they alleged the lowness and ingloriousness of the birth after the flesh, not affecting the Birth before all ages; and these in the same way by denying to the Gentiles. The Jews are looking for the dream of p. 74, their own intellect: it is the guess of their own wisdom that n. d. the children of [Gentile] error are worshipping.
6. The wicked one has left the pits; he has cast these into the midst of a wide waste, since he saw that prying had eluded the pitfall. [Free] enquiry in the place of a precipice engulfed the infidel. And if thou art hanging him to bring him up, this is his device that he may hang himself on to thee in his own place*. For he hath broken off his own hope, that his constant abode may be there. * 1/2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2023 2 mius, Apol. §. 2. as well as Arius, in Athan. p. 185. As for the earlier part of the section, its meaning is very obscure: perhaps it may mean, Satan has relinquished his plan of making traps for men's souls below the surface of the earth, (see n. b. p. 221. where however the Syr. word differs,) which traps are types of fables of the mind's own creating, he having observed that to an acute and wrangling spirit they were evident enough: he has now given men a wide waste 'a land of thorns' (see p. 220.) to dispute in, which engulphs his victims as successfully as the precipice, while it appears to be open ground.
1. THE eye and the mind teach one another: for any little thing that falleth into the eye worries and disturbs it; and so is thy mind. Scripture and a light, each make thee wise, the light is fair to the eye, and truth to the mind. Choose light for thine eye, the Scriptures for thy mind. How averse the eye is to aught that falleth into it: evil meddlesomeness however is cast into our imagination. A mote is distressing to the eye, how much more is meddlesomeness distressing to the mind, corrupting all things at all times. The finger is no assistance to the eye that it should meddle with it; nor is searching to the mind that it should fix in it. 2. His Fatherhood is easier to us than His Essentiality. It is impossible that another Ever-being should come from space: but it is possible that He should generate one Son, that is like unto Himself. Aught that is from aught is an easy thing, but [to conceive] an Everbeing which was not from aught is difficult, which though it upholdeth all things, yet dwelleth in all things. For if He dwelt in a space He would be small in His greatness, for then there would be a greater than He, since He would be found to dwell in space, and this is subject to a limit. But He that is illimitable, is a space which nothing can comprehend, and as it is not possible that space should be filled with the whole of Him, thus neither is it possible that His fulness should be in the mind.
As God transcend space, His Fatherhood is incomprehensible 251 3. And if He were commensurate with that which is space in regard to His knowledge, and yet not commensurate with it in regard to His Essence; then were His knowledge greater than His Essence, and it is found that He is made up out of two things: for lo, it is inconsistent, that He being One should be in them both. This His little-ness contraries His greatness, while He knoweth not if there be in that space entities without limit, and worlds, and creatures. The foolish therefore fall into a maze of blasphemy, and hence it is high time for them to say, that He is One from Himself, and a Father from Himself, and perfect, and entire, and Self-sufficing in all things. 4. For if He dwelleth in space, He would be little in His Majesty; and if He could not beget, then would His Fatherhood be void; and if He could not create, He would be weak in His Essence. Lo, He is wholly perfect in all these things, for He begat without suffering, and created without labour, and dwelt without space, and is rich without treasure! For there is no place that surroundeth and hemmeth Him in, neither is there any scrutiny which searcheth Him out sufficiently. Great is His Essence, as is also His Fatherhood. Space and intellect are cast and condemned, and Creation which is in space, is above man's reason.
as there is no space that sufficeth for His Essence. Whose §. 3. is the mind* that sufficeth to search into His Fatherhood? 5. Though it be quite true, yet it is hard to search out how He created any thing when there had not been any or mothing, and there would be no demonstration whereby thou del, see mightest search out if it were possible. And since in the dis-Is. 40, course of reason there is no place where thy mind may rest 13. 14. and say, 'lo, thus it was!' believe and repress the haughtiness S. of scrutiny. And inasmuch as thy spirit sufficeth not to gaze |△≡ upon the difficulty of the actual thing, search Him out in another way, that from another side thou mayest rest thyself; R. and reflect that to Him, the Lord of all, all is easy. The pleadxxxix. ing wherewith thou hast silenced investigation into the crea- §. 3. tures, oh, clad it on, and silence therewith the investigation into the Generation!
* Space is an element which enters into a vast majority of our conceptions of things; we explain time and its properties by reference to space, as the primary meanings of prepositions, &c. would shew. St. E. then probably means that, as we cannot bring God's Essence under space, it is impossible for our mind to conceive how the whole of that Essence was communicated to the Son. Even Angels we conceive to have relation to space and so comprehend their operations or energies. (See p. 187, n. b.) But such dim and vague apprehension of God's Essence as we have, presupposes Him to transcend space, and so precludes our reasoning about His operations. See however on R. lvii. §. 2.
1. BE restrained ye daring ones, and go not on with meddling any more! The fish leaps along the boundary of its river, R.lxiv. §. 5. and passeth not over it: we have passed with our scrutiny the boundary of Him who is the Giver of our life. The Breath of the Gospel sustaineth us, the waters support the fish, the Scriptures intelligent creatures. Within them is R. xlv. §. 1. p. life, without them is death. He that dareth to go in, my son, 279, n.d. where there is no air, dieth, since there is no breath there to Ideler. quicken him; that we may learn that we are not at liberty to go Meteor. p. 25. into hidden things. That Threefold Breath sustaineth thee, R. v. §. 5. R. lv. §. 2. and if outside it thou shouldst go forth into scrutinizing, the gust from errors will fly to thee, and kill thee.
2. The fool rageth, saying, "Wherefore should God have a Son; for if the True One begat, it was either by His p. 133. own Will or not by His own Will that He begat; and if R. lv. §. 3. R. it was by His Will, then was that which He begot no God; lx. §. 1. but if it was not of His Will, He denied Himself though Scripture employs the words 'Father,' free." Wherefore is thine eye evil, because it was owing to His p. 121, being Good that He begat? thou art envious of that in which n. f. p. He was not envious. Leave all these things, and seek what 231, n.b. His Will is. The Father willeth that thou shouldest believe contr. that the Son is from Him: now if He willed this to be so, the Serut. Truth of Him agreed with His Name; and if He did not i. §. 44. will it, it would have been opposed to His Name: the Name ii. §. 6. R. liv. of Son were then a borrowed one. Faithful is His Name, §. 1. and true is the Name of His Son. Confess and fear not, since Mat. 3, 17; 17, His Voice encourageth thee, His Voice is as it were a pledge
5. that gladdeneth thee touching His Son. Pet. 1, 17. &c. 3. Thamar, inasmuch as her action was hard [to justify], took, in belief, the witnesses for her innocence. She took his pledge, that it might go forth and strive with him; for the silent ones went forth and justified her. Let a man learn then from Judah who was overcome by his own pledges, that if S. with-He blame thee, His writings are within thy reach. For it is in thee. not another man that crieth, that thou shouldest doubt comp. p. [thereof.] Moses and Elias were still and silent, and even he 279, n.d. who baptized Him, as if he knew Him not, gave place to the Father, that He might give a true account of Him. And if He blameth thee, repeat to Him His own words: He clave the Heavens open, and cried and clave strife asunder.
4. And if thou were to refute this, [and say,] that He i. e. not a Name of Nature, but of Grace. See on R. xliv. §. 2. See p. 38, n. b. p. 49, r. 1. St. E. means, 'If you say the Father will blame you for believing without being able to state the doctrine in terms of human science, do you deal with Him as Judah with Thamar, and produce against Him His own pledges to shew that He is the Father.—Without a certain devotional affectionateness such applications of Scripture may appear irreverent: with it such applications are true to facts, to say the least. St. Austin, in Joan. Tr. iv. §. 15. thus states St. John's seemingly contradictory account of himself. 'See, my brethren, John is placed before your eyes, John the Baptist standing at the river; see the Lord is coming still to be baptized, as yet not being so! Hear the voice of John: Comest Thou to me? I have need to be baptized of Thee. See he now knows the Lord by
whom He wishes to be baptized. When baptized the Lord ascends from the water, the heavens are opened, the Spirit descends: now it is that John recognises Him. If it is only now that He recognises Him, why was it that he said before, I have need to be baptized of Thee? but if it is not only now, inasmuch as he had known Him before, why is it that he says, I knew Him not, but He that sent me? &c. &c." In Tr. v. §. 8. §. 11. he makes the main answer to this question to be that St. John knew Him to be Lord, but did not know that the 'power of the Lord's Baptism would not pass from the Lord to any man, but that the ministering of it would.' This brings to the point from which St. E. starts in the next §. viz. the distinction between sonship by grace which the Son could give, and that by Nature which the Son has and none other.
'Son,' 'sons,' with discrimination, and as a guide to us. 255 calleth even the sons of men 'sons,' thou hast refuted that John 1, which refuted this: since he shewed the nature of man to be from the dust, and what the nature of the angels is He hath also shewn. He cried of the Son that He is the Son, and of the Spirit that He is the Holy Ghost. He purifieth and putteth these very things into our hearts. He wittingly called mortals 'sons' (their body convicting them of having a created nature) that we might know that angels are our fellow-servants. Since, however, their nature was high above ours, they were not called at any time 'sons of God', that they might not confuse their name, by reason of their natures. 5. Go and call Adam earthy without questioning, and call Gabriel also spiritual: seal up in silence Those Three. If a man asketh of thee, there is written for thee the nature of inferior beings as warranty for that of higher: but He hath not had it written for thee, that thou art to search into the Three! Refrain thyself, O foolish one, and follow Him wholly,
See on R. xxi. §. 2. and Bas. de Sp. Sanct. xvi. quoted p. 120, n. c. Probably St. E. alludes to such passages as speak of the Angels being made spirits, and all the host of them being made by the Breath or Spirit of God's Mouth. In what follows he means to say, that God purposely bestowed the name of 'sons' on mortal men and not on angels, that we might learn from the fact of such a name being bestowed on corruptible beings such as men, that the name has a derived sense, in which it does, as well as its true one in which it does not suit servile natures. This the bestowal of such a name upon embodied spirits proves more markedly. Angels on the contrary are not called 'sons,' that men might not confuse their name with that of the Son, which they were more likely to do 'by reason of their natures,' i. e. because they were incorporeal beings, as well as He.
The older writers (out of respect to the book of Enoch perhaps) applied the term 'sons of God' in Gen. vi. 2. to Angels. In process of time, Christians were led partly by reflection and partly by the necessity of opposing heresies to drop a notion, which is valuable only as a protest in favour of the duty of believing Scripture statements in simplicity, but was found incompatible with a scientific adjustment of such state- ments with other Scripture statements. No one perhaps was more explicit than St. E. in asserting that the expression must mean the sons of Seth. Thus he takes Gen. iv. 26. to mean the giving of the name of God to Seth's tribes, now separated from those of Cain; he accounts for the dwindled state of Cain's race which made Seth's progeny giants to them by supposing (i. p. 49, d.) that the curse on their ground prevented Cain's race from being else than dwarfed: he urges (ii. p. 456, a.) most ingeniously that if the production of giants requires the intervention of Angels, then the production of dwarfs must be supernatural; and p. 478. that if Angels could make women mothers, then devils could, and so would have imitated the Birth of a Virgin; that if God had intended the race of Angels to be propagated, He would have made them male and female; that, finally, the name of 'sons of God' may be accounted for, (i. p. 145.) by supposing the family of Seth to have dwelt apart (as some say) on Mount Hermon, and devoted themselves to a life of angelical devotion and contemplation.
See n. c. p. 121. St. E.'s words imply, that one may argue from one order of creatures to another in some degree, but about God we must depend wholly on what He reveals. and of all that He speaketh unto thee, look not whether it is R. lii. suiting, since thy appreciation [of it] sufficeth not to give aught §. 3. unto Him. If thou approvest Him, hitherto it is but a little; and when thy faith is very great, worship exceedingly, in that He hath brought the truth of His words down to the ear that is of dust. Oh! wonder, that God should have humbled Himself to the dust, and should have given it the ornament of life, and Vol. ii. enhanced it with freewill, and delivered His Son up for us p. 451. to shew unto us His love! But instead of being astonished n. g. that it was so great, (and if he had wondered and been silent, p. 235. still that had been but little,) by the paltriness of their wranglings they have made light of the Glorious One.
6. They are called gods, but He is God entirely: they are called fathers, but He is the True Father: they are surnamed spirits, but there is a living Spirit. They who are called 'sons,' and 'fathers,' have borrowed names, which teach by the grace [given], that He is the One Father in Truth, who hath the Son in Truth h. h The Fathers argued that men were not properly fathers, since they attained the age at which they become so by degrees, and lost the power of being so again, their sons in turn going through the same course. See Athan. O. T. p. 192, p. 201. Below, R. lxii. §. 4. Vol. ii. p. 479, e. 'He lifted man above every thing, seeing He was called and named God.' i. p. 430, a. 'It is plain that Angels and saintly men receive from God sanctification, illumination, and godship.' So Clement Al. Strom. ii. §. 104. speaks of a 'saint as becoming God Holy of holies.' And vi. §. 113. 'The soul having received the Lord's might practises to be a god.' Comp. §. 146. 'He calls them sons and gods.' vii. §. 56. Iren. iv. 38. §. 4. quoting Ps. lxxxi. 6. as does Justin M. c. Tryph. p. 353, b. (we are called and
are true sons of God,) Orig. c. Cels. p. 128. p. 375. where he speaks of those honoured by God with the appellation of god, and partaking of His Godship. Athan. c. Ar. i. 39. and the note c. p. 236. O. T. Didym. de Trin. p. 139. ("Though there be but one God and Father, and one true Son, all of us through His goodness and profuseness are called after His Image gods and sons, not that we are so in truth, but according to that Ps. lxxxii. 6. &c.") and p. 331. §. xlii. Basil de S. S. ix. §. 23. 'the summit of things desired is to become god,' and above, p. 120, n. c. c. Eun. iii. 5. G. Nyss. in Or. Dom. Vol. 1. p. 752. b. c. Ambr. de Fid. v. §. 22. Austin in Jo. i. §. 4. in Ps. xlix. §. 2. Cyril c. Nest. p. 41, c. p. 121, b. in Jul. p. 59. Spanh. &c.
1. THE work of artisans, the weaving of clever workmen, the beams and the cunning work, bracelets and necklaces, books and calculations, meters and measures, have men found out by their wisdom, when they measure the earth, and when they weigh the waters—these are things easy to the learned and hard to common men. Yet if the simple are not able to scrutinize the wise, though it is but a little by which they have surpassed them in advantage of learning, how far short does the wisdom of the wise fall of Him, who created all in His Wisdom! and how mad must they be to think that they can scrutinize and search into the Nature of the Creator, and the Generation of the Maker! 2. Let us feel awed to think, how it is by these little and deficient natures, (by which used as types they are not able to attain to the fair Beauty of the Real One, or the Generation of the True One,) that He has perplexed the enquirers into all these. For if they were unable to attain to the creatures by scrutiny, how far short would they be of Him that is far beyond all! Our being stopped amid the weak boundaries of visible things, shews that the measures of our thought reach not unto the Son, the Beginning of whom none is able to explore, since His Father is in all things hidden from all. And how much soever a man may reach out his intellect and his mind, He will not have His place explored nor His magnitude comprehended. Be awed then at the creatures and honour the Creator, and do not strive to search into the Nature which is greater than all!
3. For vain-glory is the cause of thy scrutinizing, Thou weak and feeble nature! go forth, go see thy shame in the midst of thy contest which thine enemy reproacheth thee with, and along with him do thou [reproach] thyself also, that thou mayest know that haughtiness is the cause of thy strife. For into these things Prophets pried not, and the just men, the Apostles, did not scrutinize. Was it that they were unlearned men? Moses will put thee to shame, who was learned, and yet cast quite away from him the wisdom of Egypt, and wrote with plainness the Truth in open characters. 4. Daniel too was learned and had been taught wisdom in Babel, such that she was not to be compared even with a gleaming of it: the bands of the wise men, that came in to the trial, in all sciences all of them did he silence. And since he knew that the treasury of revelations was closed, prayer gave him the key of interpretations; He was meditative above all the just, and when he heard that the words were sealed up in secrecy, he sealed his own mouth with silence, and bounded his questioning, and was yet for the sake of his countrymen prevailed upon and asked with discretion; and as he knew that he was a man he asked things pertaining to men, and reverenced the things pertaining to the Divinity.
5. The bold [disputant] forgets his nature, that he is a man, and leaveth the things pertaining to man and scrutinizeth those pertaining to the [Divine] Essence. If then he forget his own nature, whose nature should he search into? for he forgeteth his own measures and turneth wanton. If he had cast up his strong wine and known that he is a mortal, then had he been silent and had kept the measures of mortals. Comp. 6. Look at that Daniel, who, though a Prophet indeed, asked the Angels that he might learn simple things: the foolish seek, each of them, into hidden things and put them i. e. not in hieroglyphics which he mentions vol. ii. p. 145. as used by the heathen for their mysteries. See R. viii. §. 7. and p. 67, n. p. p. 205, n. b. The prophecies of Daniel relate chiefly to the affairs of the world, 'as it is God's world,' rather than to any detailed account of God's attributes and dealings with His Church. As the
"soothsayers and Chaldeans proclaimed that it was by their soothsaying and calculations that they had raised the king of Babylon, Daniel was to come in and wrestle with them by his God, of whom they thought that He would certainly be overcome by the gods of the Babylonians." (on chap. ii.) 6. forth. Moses also a glorious Prophet, asked in fear about His Name, I AM*; yet we pry into hidden things in sport. The Apostle was more subtle than these rash [disputers] when he went into the city that was the metropolis of the Greeks, spoke to them of their own that he might shew that he knew it; but when they were overcome, then he cast aside their weapon, and taught them the truth: they rejected the medicine of life, since they had now of a long time been enfeebled with the disease of disputations. 7. Sit thee in the contest that thou mayest see the strifes: for in a clear place before them comes a thing as clear as day, which clear as it is they cannot see, though striving, and struggling, and shouting. If then thou examinest them who have come to a stand-still in things clear, how much more will the foolish men be overwhelmed in the Sea of hidden things. Go again, seek an assembly which is all still and clear, and cast in amongst them searching and strife, and sit thee down and contemplate the composed persons that are turned frantic, the quiet that are disturbed and that disturb. If a single one is prostrated there, then all shout together. Searching it is, the smoke whereof hath blinded many!
* contr. Scrut. i. §. 48. Vol. ii. p. 554, f. "Moses witnesseth to us that he called no other by the Name of 'Essence.' They were called gods, but essentials [or ever-beings] were they not called: that by one Name He might teach us the taste of His grace, and by another Name let us us know the mightiness of His Essence, that we might confess both. To Moses did He reveal His Name, since He called Himself, I AM, which is the Name of His Essence. And never at any time did He surname another by this Name, as by His [other] Names He did many; that by the one Name which He left, He might shew us that He alone is the Essential, and that there is no other." It may be just mentioned in justification of the old translation 'I AM' here preserved, that the force of the Name lies not in the tense employed, but in the fact that Being is all that can be predicated of God. See Maimon. ap. Petav. de Deoi. 6. §. 5. So St. Hilary de Trin. i. §. 5. says of this passage, (Ex. 3, 14.) "I felt mere wonder at so finished a description touching God, which put the incomprehensible knowledge of the Divine Nature into words the best suited for making It understood to man. For that no one thing is more peculiar to God than Being, is understood, because the very fact that He is, belongeth to One neither ceasing at any time, nor begun, &c."
1. GRANT that I may open my senses to Thy Well-beloved, since He alone is able to tell me of Thee: and he that hath not learnt of Him Thy Nature, hath erred greatly in thinking that he had found Thee. In the faithful are shadowed out the Names of the Threefold who have not been searched out at any time, nor comprehended at any time. Give unto us that our congregation may praise Thee without division! Nature & Grace teach the willing, condemn the unwilling. 261 His Law. His Light and His Law are a lamp that, without grudging, with His bright glistenings crieth aloud to them that see it, that by the gleamings of the Law the Truth is to be comprehended. Nature was an instructress to us in every thing, and every man according to his ability learns in proportion his pains; and he that learneth not is reckoned among the unlearned. Compare one with the other, and be persuaded that he who subjects not himself to the Teacher of all, is justly styled 'one who errs through self-will.'
3. It is hard for one to find fault with a poor or an unlearned person, that he knoweth not how to paint, or that he skills not to chase gold; yet one might be able to find fault with him who, it may be, did not learn. In the former case he escapes, and the latter he is condemned. And yet not even on this very score for which he thought to have escaped, could he have escaped, if men had condemned him upon the same. Let go to a full length the fish that he may get himself refreshed; for thee he is struggling, and his labour is against himself; he bringeth the crown to thee by his run though he perceive it not. Despise thou the bold disputer and the erring man, who is overcome by his own weapon; for when he thinks that he shall draw with him, then is he drawn himself at the will of the fisherman. Since he could not explore the sea into which he plunged deep, the air he wished to pierce into, and the height he wished to explore, though not able to live in a place not his own. The fish whose frolicksomeness leads him astray, leaps and goes aloft that it may come up and feel the air; because the breath thereof tosses him away, back into his waters does it send him; because he is a child of the water he thinks that every thing will give him a watery dwelling-place. His stream persuadeth him that he is not of a nature adapted to a dwelling in chambers, and that he is not of a nature at all adapted to our dwelling-place. Thus our priers are not of a nature adapted to, or capable of, attaining to the things above, or searching out the natures thereof.
4. The Gospel in the figure of Gihon breaks forth to give us drink; by Euphrates is typified its fruitfulness, because of the abundance of its doctrine; by Pishon is shadowed forth the type of it and of the pause put to scrutinizing it. Our The rivers of Eden types of Gospel graces. washing, like the Deklath, with its word washeth us, and we come up by it into the lands of Paradise. And let not its fishes pass over the boundaries of life! "Gihon means 'breaking forth'—Euphrates he connects with a word signifying fruitfulness, as Simonis ap. Gesen. in v. has done. See Ecclus. 24, 27—38, which St. E. probably had in his eye. As for Pishon it seems to a Hebrew scholar connected with 'pause' by the mere accident of alliteration, though in Syriac the same root is used in the sense of stopping. In like way he connects Deklath the Syrian name of the Tigris with a Syriac word signifying 'washing,' which is against the well-attested etymology of the name from
the Persian teger an arrow, though possibly it may be a correcter one for the Semitic name Hiddekel. St. E. on the whole may perhaps be said to be very much less open to the charge of nonsensicalness in etymologies, so deservedly brought against the ancients, than his Grecian and Roman cotemporaries: in places he traces accurately and scientifically the ramifications of a word's senses from a common idea, and therefore some weight is to be attached to his opinion in such matters.
1. Oh! how august was Noah, who was above comparison with any of the men of his generation! They that were weighed by righteousness were found wanting in the balances, and one soul alone was of due weight by the force of chastity. S. They were drowned in the Flood who were lacking in weight: and he that was chaste and grave was lifted aloft in the ark. Glory to Him who was well pleased in him! Noah extended His ministry between both sides [of the flood], and marked out two types. He sealed up that which was passed, and began that which was, and between two generations ministered two types, since he interred the former days, and made preparation for the latter: he buried the old generation, and nursed up the youthful one. Praises to Him that elected him!
2. The Ship of the Lord of all fluttered upon the flood. It went out from the east, and reached nearly to the west: it flew to the south, and reached to the north. Its fluttering over the waters was a prophet to the dry land, and preached that its offspring should multiply on all sides, and increase in every quarter. Praises to its Redeemer! It marked out by its course the standard of its Preserver, the Cross of its Shipman, and the Tree of its Sailor, who should come and fashion for Himself a Church in the waters, and by the Name of the Trinity rescue them that dwell in it; and the Spirit instead of the dove was the Minister of her unction, and of the Sacrament of the Redemption by her. Praises to her Redeemer! His mysteries in the law and His types in the ark bear witness to each other: for as the recesses of the ark were emptied, thus also were the types that are in the Scriptures emptied. He who by His coming brought the mysteries of the law to a close, fulfilled in the Churches the types of the ark. Glory be to Thy Coming!
3. My mind is amazed that it hath embarked upon the fearful flood of our Redeemer! Blessed be Noah, since even though the ship was afloat upon the flood, and the ark also, he was himself collected. Be my faith, Lord, a ship for my weakness: for lo! the foolish are sunken in the depths of their prying into Thee. Praises to Him that begot Thee!
1. THE Son who was with His Father before all things surpasseth also all times, for in Him were created times, and He was before numbers, moments, and seasons. His p. 66, mode of existence cannot be searched out, neither the date n.l.p.69, of it be comprehended, neither can enquiry discover why it n. t. p. 126, was. It hath not been measured out how great He is, nor p.305, d. been explored of what quality He is. Praises to Him that R.xxx. §. 2. begot Him! Who is there whose mouth would not hold its peace at the Begotten, whose glory no mouths are able to utter? R.xlvii. Who is there that would not reprove his own self, and bethink §. 2. himself that if the Begotten could be comprehended, they would have made Him that begot small: and if the Fruit p. 179, could be searched out, they would have set bounds to the p. 305, d. Root thereof; for that They are blended One with the Other. p. 25, n. y. Glory be to Thy Father in Thee! p. 210, ref. 4.
2. Who would not be ashamed for concluding within the narrow womb of his own imagination prying without measure, searching out without limit into the Begotten and the Begetter? R.xliv. §. 5. R. liii. §. 5. The searching out of the creatures even is too great for our minds: the searching out of the Creator there is none that can span, for it is too great for any nature. Praises to His Greatness! §. 3. R. 3. Who would not allay his prying into the Begotten, and be astonied at Him that begot Him? That He is Son, is easy for us: how, is hard for us: that we should feel Him so, is easy for us: that we should pry into Him, is difficult for us: R.vii. since from every nature is the prying into His Essence concealed. To the Father and to Him let us offer up glory by means of silence. Praise be to Him that sent Him! blessed be His coming! R. ii. §. 1. iv. §. 6. li. §. 6. Gen. 2, 7.
4. Who would not bless the Good One who gave to dust its soul, that it might feel Him; who gave to the small dust discourse and reasoning; who sent His Son, and clothed it, and brought it up to glory. The wicked one envied at His p. 53. The envy of the devil in leading men to disputation, and his inexplicable subtlety in tempting them. 267 it, and it perceiveth not his intimate access. He is not seen with its eye, neither is he felt with its hand, neither is he tasted by it, that it should know that he is bitter. He is not smelt by it, that it should perceive that he is a stench, since he is wholly bent upon blood. Blessed be He that
vol. i. of Satan. "The creatures are not too straight for Him, and when the heart seeketh for him, the heart though little holdeth Him. He taketh Him but a small space out of a man to dwell therein, that he may be a temple of God, so that He may dwell in him, and abide in him. A temple unto Him is the soul made, the heart is made the holy Altar, that He may be glorified on it, and have worship done Him, and that offerings may be offered on it. And the Spirit is made as it were a priest (comp. n. d. p. 146. and n. a. p. 282. that stands thereat, and ministers at it. Let not foul sin come in, and the Spirit go forth from thee, &c. In vol. ii. p. 504, b. he asks in a Rhythm we shall have occasion to quote below, how the devil, who [according to the Manichean theory] was akin to body, came to be more subtle than the mind, and be in one self in dreams, and yet one does not know how? and speaks of it as an inexplicable mystery. (See on R. lvii. §. 4. Ibid. p. 546, a. "If the soul be an inspiration, angels that are spiritual, whence be they? If the angels are out of nothing, then the soul is so likewise.
If, however, all of them are from the Creator, how is it that angels need not a bodily nature in order to see, while the soul cannot see or hear without the senses? If devils again are the offspring of matter, and the body which cometh from it is vile in their sight, how came the Maker to want to dwell in it by His inspiration; (see n. a. p. 263. and how is it that the devil is unable to smite the body and dwell in it? or if the body be alien from his properties, how comes he to be akin to the soul? Oh what falsehoods these unbelievers utter! Here he evidently contrasts God's power of dwelling even in men's bodies with Satan's inability to do so, (i. e. without permission,) and implies that into the soul he could not enter. Into this alternative he does not explicitly enter, as his object there is to shew that evil and matter are not identical. Upon this and upon the text the following passage from vol. iii. p. 575, b. will throw light. It treats of a question analogous to the very important question which is said to have been some-
what grotesquely stated by the Schoolmen when they asked, 'How many angels could stand upon a needle's point?' "I have also enquired this: whether paradise is sufficiently large for all the just to dwell therein? I enquired things not in Scripture, and He taught me by things in Scripture. Look, He said, to that man in whom a legion dwelt of all the devils: they were in him, yet not known, since that power is more subtle and fine even than the soul itself. The whole of that power dwelt in one single body. Now an hundred times more subtle is the body of the just after they are risen, and have come to life again! Here he is using the power which a number of devils had to dwell in a body, as an illustration of the way in which, it may be, all the just will dwell in one space.—Not being aware of any passages which really affirm the view the text is calculated, at first sight, to give one, one may presume, from the denial of that view implied in what has been quoted, that St. E. means in the text to insist upon what appears to be (but is not really) the case, as a difficulty inexplicable to man. Somewhat also might be said upon the ground that 'soul' is used so excessively often in Syriac for 'self,' as to create an indefiniteness in the expressions used, which the context will not allow one to attempt to keep up in the English.
The Holy Spirit also is said to dwell in men before Christian times in which only, in a strict sense, He blendeth His substance (so to speak) with men: which might not only account for, but seem to justify, a less exact use of the word in regard to evil spirits. St. Austin (see Pet. de Angelis. i. 7. §. 10. at one time thought that devils could see such thoughts as were thrown, in our minds, into explicit reasoning, though unable to search the heart fully. This would go to shew how strongly he, as well as St. E., felt the closeness of Satan's approach and his seeming ubiquity: to explain which, notwithstanding the many damned he has to consult with, may be an impossibility, though it be a duty to submit to the received doctrine in spite of such difficulties to the reason.
The subtlety of Satan inexplicable. frustrateth him! Because the soul perceiveth not the devil, therefore it is that, if he dwelleth in itself, it never toucheth him or creepeth up to him; and if he encampeth against it from without, that his intimate access hath never touched it. And whether he be in its neighbourhood, or again in its substance, the soul doth not perceive. Let us bewail ourselves that we have been bold towards the Son of our Creator. Praises be to Thee from all! There are several passages in St. E. in which he exhibits no common insight into the subtleties of Satan's temptations. The following which will throw light on the text, may be adduced as a specimen: vol. i. p. 412, b. "From this (the history of Amnon and Thamar) thou mayest learn the craftiness of Satan, and the silliness of the soul that is off its guard: for Satan, when he wishes to obliterate its beauty, and is unable to effect any thing by force, struggles with it craftily, and persuades its childish simplicity to actions which are not imagined by it to be blameworthy, as those which very many times are by the subtle movements of the thoughts mischievously set in motion, and which, as if not blameworthy, we are negligent of; or as words which are as it were said in mirthfulness and in love—or as
it happeneth in those things, which we without perceiving it, suffer when devils rise up against us, and throw us into a battle of imaginary obscene passions in visions of the night. Now concerning these and the like to these, when their soul repenteth and reflecteth in sober thought, how wrong they are, and how much they disturb its brightness and blacken it, and how that they are the beginning of transgression, it bewails itself, and from its weakness pours forth tears, and rendeth its garment, that is, the body, with hard labours, and the heart by the passion of repentance. They cover their head too from their passion and their shame, and go, crying as they go from their whole heart and calling aloud to the Lord to do judgment upon their prersecutors."
1. Who is able to requite Thee for having humbled Thy Majesty unto all which is little, and having brought Thy p. 209, Highness down to the limits of a lowly estate, and brought 10. and 10. and Thine own Life down to the rank of mortality. And Thy Thine own Life down to the rank of mortality. And Thy Richness came down and dwelt in all necessity, and Thou hast subjected Thy Lordship to the yoke of service. Praises p. 183, be to Thy goodness! Who, Lord, can gaze upon Thy invin. c. siblenness which came down to a visible state, and Thy vol. i. concealedness which came to the light and to manifestation, p. 493, b. concealedness which came to the light and to manifestation, p. 305. n. and Thy retiredness came forth to boundless openness, and R. xix. Thy awfulness came to the hand of them that seized Thee. §. 2. R. x. These things happened to Thee, Lord, because Thou wert §. 4. 6. Son of Man. Praises to Him that sent Thee!
2. Who would not be afraid, since though Thy rising and Thy Human Birth were so manifest, yet so incomprehensible is Thy Generation, that it hath baffled the investigators. For p. 115, there is that preacheth that it was a body only that Thou n. c. tookest: and there is that teacheth that it was a soul and a body: others have erred in thinking it was a heavenly frame. The Divine objects of faith Praises to Thy Generation! Lord, seal our mouth: since, if Thy revealed estate has baffled the wise; (for they have not been able to grasp Thy Birth of Mary, seeing the learned are divided into parties about Thy Birth;) if also men comprehended not Thy Humanity, who ever shall be equal to Thy Divine Generation? Praises be to Him that begot Thee! 3. Whatsoever is allowed, let us sing, Lord, upon our harp: let us not utter any thing thereon which is not permitted, seeing it is the harp of frail creatures. Neither are the sounds of it equal to the probing of Thy Generation; neither on harps high and spiritual of the highest Angels can Thy Generation be comprehended. Praises to Thy secretness! Lord, let my tongue be a pen for Thy glory, and let the Finger of Thy grace mark out and write therewith words of edification. The pen, Lord, cannot, without one to hold it, of itself write at its own will. Let not my tongue slide off into speaking, without Thee, aught which edifieth not.
Who could deny the Threefold Names, whose over-shadowing ministered of old, by the Jordan? True is it that by the Names wherewith Thy Body was baptized, that our bodies are baptized; and though there be very many Names of the Lord of all, He hath baptized us in the Father and the Son and the Spirit distinctly. Praises to Thy Majesty! 4. Who would not be amazed at the painter, who if he painted even a common horse, when he should have added a head and the members, out of fear added them not? O foolish wise men that by questioning have counted a small thing that Generation which is not small, and though He is like One, yet have likened Him to many! Glory to the Son of our King! 5. Who hath seen in the subtle air a way akin to that way which a fowl wendeth, or a man walking as upon the back of the wind? The breeze is spread out, and made a path for that which walketh there, and admonisheth not to go at all outside of it, for out of it is death. Praises be to Thy monishing! Lord, make me also to be fully instructed by that danger, and to be afraid of going beyond the boundary
allusion to St. Luke 1, 35. (in which the word Power is taken by some of the Son,) it has been rendered 'overshadowing.' For the River that baptized Him was a type of His Conception in St. E.'s view, p. 86, n. f. Perhaps by 'ministered' he means to imply that this was the beginning of the Christian, as the end of the Jewish, dispensation. Vol. ii. p. 185. "The long-suffering which was granted to this priesthood, (the Jewish,) and was granted also to it unto wickedness and violence, must needs be granted to it until His Son the Messiah, whose the priesthood is, should come, and bring it to a consummation in the Jordan by means of John." Comp. p. 488, b. (above, p. 197, n. d.) and 495-6. Vol. i. p. 526, d. p. 532, e. (Jordan the mother and beginning of Baptism.) p. 534, b. The word 'ministered' has, however, the technical sense of pouring water upon the hands. See Ass. Cod. Lit. v. p. 221. and the Ch. Paraph. 2 Kings 3, 12. from which this sense is doubtless taken.
The received faith rejects novelties. of my faith. Thy Truth is easy and straight: to them that R. l. §. 3. believe, it is easy; and to them that are perverse, it is difficult. Scribes The simple disentangle themselves, and escape: the learned err, and fall into the pit of disputatiousness. Oh that the Lord may lift them out! Praises to Him who findeth all! 6. From those His Names also the might of interpretation shone forth unto us. The Names of the Servant and Son of the Lord bear witness; for the name of servant teacheth that he is not the Son, as does the name of Son proclaim that He is not one of the fellow-servants. Of both their names preach without doubt. Praises to His Majesty! The bold one then that teacheth aught that is new let us reproach and say, that my faith is perfect. My gem is entire, not needing thy grinding. It will not beautify in Thy furnace, since its beauty is from itself; and if it be graven, it is rejected from the crown of the King of Heaven. Praises be to Thy Kingdom!
g i. e. the name of servant shews that the Nature which appears outwardly, is not the Only-begotten Son who always is and was and is to come. The followers of Apollinaris made the flesh of Christ (as contradistinguished from His mind and soul) to be eternal and yet that which saved men as being servile in its nature. See Greg. Nyss. c. Ap. 40. To this perhaps St. E. here alludes. Comp. §. 1. p. 183, n. c. and Vol. i. p. 493, b. "Oh marvel unspeakable, which E-alias calls a wonder, that unto man his Lord came down and took the likeness of a servant, and made the servile nature commensu- rate as it were with the Divine!' ii. p. 90, c. "He was called a servant by the Father when He came to fulfil His will in the salvation of men, and took the likeness of a servant in that He clothed Himself with our body."
h S. pearl. See Pearl ii. §. 1. n. b. Probably the word is here used generally for a gem, as rendered: for a pearl would be destroyed by heat, whereas it is said to be the practice with jewellers to get out flaws and specks from some gems by exposing them to heat.
1. FROM God Himself let us learn God; for as by His Names it is comprehended that He is God, and is Just, and also Good; so the Name of Father evinceth that He is a Generator. For the very Name of Fatherhood used of Him bears witness of the Son; and as He was the Father of One, in His love it is that He is so of many. Praises be to His grace! He is the true Lord; and lo, His servants stand witness; and He is King over His possessions! and that He is Creator, lo! His creation standeth [witness]: and because He is Father of a truth, He hath a Son of a truth! But if His Name of Father be borrowed, (which cursed be he that thinketh) then by strife are dissolved the kindred names also. Praises be to the True One! Who would speak so stoutly against the Father of the Truth, as to say that He could not beget, and that that Name of Fatherhood wherewith He did invest Himself was borrowed? But since He is verily Truth, His savour is preserved in Himself; R. lx. §. 5. p. 133. R. lviii. §. 3. . (which hush and curse) See R. xliv. R. xlvi. §. 2. R. lx. §. 1.
274 The Names of Father and Son proclaimed in Scripture, and the futility of all heretical cavils against them. 275 by their abundant streams become limpid and purified. And if a man pry into them they eddy him in and cast him down, p. 141, seeing that he has died in his scrutinizing. Praises be to Thy Righteousness! 4. Who would not refrain his searching into secret things? it is a plague which the Apostle calleth a canker. Contentious searching is a fountain of mischiefs for the fool that busieth himself therein. From out of it there may be formed a passion of a sudden, which is sweet in the beginning thereof, bitter in the end thereof. Praises be to Him that exhausted it! Who hath persuaded thee to use thy feeble pupils in gazing on the secret and strong Lights, whose glistenings the Angels cannot look upon. Moses wished to pierce through them and see them there a little while. And as he did not look to pry, the glistening was eager to meet him, blinding, as it does, them that pry. Praises to Thy Majesty!
5. Who would not believe the two Testaments concerning the Father, and the Son, and the Spirit. Comment on them where you will, yet are They not called by the name of 'made,' 'created,' or 'formed.' No affinity to Them have the names there given to things created. Thus He willed it should be written, and since He is God, it is meet that we believe Him. Praises to His Lordly State! Who would not submit himself to his teachers and learn as they have taught him? p. 139, But if a man hath thought that he has surpassed the measure of his teachers, empty is his vaunting! O man, whose taste is lost, and who hast raised a quarrel with God, to whom hast thou likened thyself? Who among the wise is as He who giveth wisdom unto all? and who among deliverers is as He who giveth all freedom? or who in revelations can compare with the Holy Spirit? Praises to Thy teaching!
6. What strong reason then hath he that striveth with us? for the Truth fetters up all their reasonings! One of three things happeneth unto him that is a bold disputer: either grant that he is an infidel, or grant that he is a deceiver, or A prayer for peace and unity. suppose that he is an ignorant fellow. [The cause] of them that pry is at a stop: [the cause] of them that are faithful is established. Praises to Thy victory! What then remaineth to the side of the vain-babblers? as they speak, so would I speak: for even when a man uses lies, he is able to overcome them. For either it was feebleness that He could not beget, and He concealed His weakness, and made us think that He was Father; but if He was able to beget, this is a crown of victory on our side in two things. Why then should we add any new truth to that which He hath had written for us? The Names that we have added, they have been partizans to the bold disputers. At all hateful additions, thou hast added questionings, thou hast added strifes, and changed what is written.—Thou hast quieted those which were in confusion. Praises to Thy calmness! O Lord, make quiet in my days in Thy churches, and blend and unite, O Lord, the contentious sects, and still, and rule also the conflicting parties. And may there be at every time one true Church, and may her righteous children gather themselves into her bosom to confess Thy graciousness. Praises to Thy reconciliation!
1. Who would not wonder at the Just One who omitted not to write the deeds of beings above, and mark out those of beings below, and write those of the creatures, and embrace every thing even to the matter of the rods and the history of Gen. 30, the mandrakes? What chaste women have spoken, He caused to be written by the Holy Ghost, and it was placed in the Ark. Marvellous are Thy appointments whereof the causes are hidden! Praises be to Thy doctrine! Who would not be afraid that there are offences on the earth, contentions in the world, disputations in the streets, and in assemblies divisions, and in the midst of Churches the sword and the scimetar? Women fall out with women, and men with their comrades, even priests too with kings; and the whole world is in uproar! 2. Who would not weep that the earth hath been tossed for so long a time, and hath settled again: yet the tossings and strivings of the Churches are not stilled. Waves and billows are silent in the sea; yet fools and enquirers are in medicines, and there are men that are quite strangers to S. roots [Scripture] lections; and their words are contradictory in the mouth of foolish clerks. The Scriptures are full of S. harmony, and the clerks of confusedness. What then remains, save this alone, that we should establish [our cause] by witnesses, but not by one only, since the Just One did not command that it should be received: for at the mouth of three witnesses (it says) the matter shall be decided. Let us appeal to the great tribunal of Justice, and let both sides call witnesses to their accounts.
4. In order that the thing may be made clear, let alone words which proclaim the littleness of our Lord, and His greatness. For one perceives His Human, and another His Divine, Nature in them. Let us leave interpretations, and examine with simplicity the bare words 'Son' and 'creation.' They will be able sure to tell us as finished clerks, learned in the law, ready in the prophecies, that Solomon puts the matter beyond all controversy; for he felt, and called Him a creation and a formation. Solomon then forsooth is the great stronghold of all these changelings! From me that am an Haza 280 The usual Names of the Son clear up the unusual.
1. THE King of Heaven, when His Son came down to the earth, did the people who had not known Him, know from the voices of Them Both. For the Father bare witness to the Son, and the Son called Him Father, and even in His low estate He was comprehended to be the Lord; for He was honoured by all things; for the sea was His chariot and the air His car. Praises be to Him that sent Thee! From those who ministered to Him learn whose Son He was; for when He was in His low estate the Angels came down and ministered to the Son of their glorious Lord. And as unto handmaids, so gave He orders unto the creatures, and the world in the image of a slave was governed by His nod, after the type of His Father, whose silence ordereth all things.
2. For since the Lord exalted the children of His house, and they fools despised themselves, and fell, and wallowed [in the mire], He came down and drew them up out of that same wallowing. Error erred because it saw our blots upon His garments: knowledge alone knew that He came to the mire that He might bring to the Washing. From His taking up of this burden it was comprehended that He was the King's Son, and as a good Heir, He diligently kept His Father's House. He saw His servant that was laid; He raised him up in healthiness. He saw His handmaid that was laid; He rebuked her fever. He saw that bread was lacking, and He satisfied them of His household, and they praised Him that sent Him. Who would not love Him that loved them of His household, that was blended and mingled with His handmaid and servant? They invited Him and He despised it not, He went to the feast and made it glad with His Majesty. He also threw in His marriage-gift, the wine in the flagons, since He carried with Him the treasures of His Kingdom.
Heretics are impure and disputatious as 29. in love, they passed not judgment on His words. The Mark sectarians deceitfully laid wait for His words: for their 12, 13. detestable strife was as it were the adversary of that Righteousness, which laboured by fiction to overbear the right. 5. The Lord had spoken: plain men were cheered, sullen men were confused, and the simple heard and relied; the John 6, crafty heard and questioned, [saying,] 'How can this Man 52. give us His Body? Their questioning kept them deprived of the Medicine of Life: let not our questionings deprive us also of reliance [on Him]. The words of God ought not to be assayed in our furnace. For look at the disciples, and again look at the unbelievers, how confiding the chaste are, and how questioning the furious! They thought that the Son Himself, who could never at any time have His measure comprehended, was not yet fifty years old. John 8, 57. Wherefore we will briefly say, that all scrutinizing belongs to the left hand. For even the thief that was crucified p. 135, on the left hand himself scrutinized, that we might learn by his questionings the audacity of the investigators. O thou hopeless one, that when even pierced and crucified Lake 23, scrutinized His Lord! Who again would not be astonished 39. at that thief on the right hand, who, though he hung, saw and believed that He was the Son of God, and quickened us who have believed that He ascended unto glory and sat down at the Right Hand? Him did the Crucified persuade; but as for us, not even the Cherubim that carried Him, persuade us.
them. Rather then we ought to believe in Christ, and by assenting without thought to what is said by Him, to be anxious rather to learn how to win the blessing, and not with drunkard recklessness to say, 'How can this man, &c.' See Athan. p. 326. O. T. and other passages in Petav. de Trin. v. 6. against this use of 'How.' Philo de Abrah. fin. 'Touching those things whereof God witnesseth what befiteth men, but with all certainty to believe.' c i.e. though the highest angels adore Him in spite of His Flesh, we are not to be persuaded: see on R. xvi. fin. and R. xxix. 1. and n. a. p. 285. Perhaps this passage refers to the interpretation of Is. lxiii. 1. &c. commonly received among the Fathers, (as Antonelli on St. James of Nisibis, p. 298, rightly notices,) and alluded to by St. E. vol. i. p. 372, a. on 1 Sam. xviii. 6. ('In the going out of the damsels and their rejoicings in David's victories, behold by contemplation the victories of Christ, and His return from the place of the dead, and how the Angels and the souls of the just went forth to meet Him,') and plainly adopted by him in vol. ii. p. 307, c. where he writes as follows, on Zech. xiii. 6. 'They shall say, What are these wounds in Thy
Hands?' and He shall say, These are the wounds wherewith I was subdued in the house of my friends. This is to be taken of Him who above was called a Fountain of life, (quoted note c. p. 196. fin.) and suits with the Son in every respect. For the heavenly powers, the friends of Christ the Bridegroom, and His labourers ask Him about the wounds wherewith He was subdued by the crucifiers, and about the rents of the nails in His hands. And it is they whom He probably answers and says, These are the wounds wherewith I was subdued, not by Mine enemies, but among My friends and My kinsmen: owing to their hatred of the false prophets, they thought that I was a deceiver and one of the lying prophets. After this fashion the heavenly powers asked the question also in those words that are written in Isaiah, and say, Who is this that cometh from Edom, with His garments red from Bozrah? when they saw that His Body was mysteriously dyed with the Blood of the sufferings of His own self.' Petav. de Angelis i. 8. §. 11. in part disapproves of this interpretation, but does not mention that Orig. in Joan. vi. 39. G. Naz. Hom. in Pasch. Nyss. in Asc. iii. p. 443. Ambr. de Inst. Virg. v.
Christ's ascent gazed on by Angels. §. 39. Alex. in loc. et ap. Ang. Mai, A. C. x. p. 61. Arctas in Apoc. ed. Oxon. p. 460. all have this interpretation. All he mentions are Theodoret, Anastasius, Sin. Ambr. de Myst. vii. 36. J. Martyr c. Tryph. §. 36. J. Firmicus de Err. prof. rel. 25. Max. ad Dionys. de Cad. Hier. vii. §. 3. p. 91. Petav. however allows §. 12. which is enough perhaps for the present passage, that the Angels are represented as asking questions, but doubts if we can infer that this is more than an economy to teach us: for St. E. may be taken to imply that they are said to believe what they were told, in order to instruct man.
1. Who, my son, would compare natures which are not like one another in their births: for from all of them is the Nature of Him who created all, different. For if the generation of fire is hard to relate, though quite open to the eye, how much more hidden from us is the Fruit of our Maker, and the Generation of our Creator. Praises to Thy concealedness! For he that discourseth of Him who gave all things their nature, §. 3. ought to discourse of every nature first. Let us let alone His Majesty, and speak of His chariot; let us shadow forth how it is. Let us also explain the living wheels of it, and if too the beasts have reason. Who hath ever seen a chariot, whereto the air was made in the place of the earth, and the wind in the place of a road; lo! it leadeth its own self, and turneth not itself aside: for the four sides have four heads over the throne. This is the direction of its faces, and the countenance thereof looketh unto every place.
2. And since the son of Buzi saw the likeness of a Man upon the throne, and since that chariot turned not itself aside, was it the throne therefore that changed its posture that it might explore every side? But if the throne be a marvel, who can suffice for the Watcher that sitteth upon it? Speak, and shew us the nature of Heavenly Beings, the image of Michael, and the form of Gabriel, who are fire and spirit. Wherein is this fire seen, wherein is this spirit breathed? and are they short or tall? and their cast, of what cast the feel of them is? whether The Divine Nature more easily conceived it may be touched by thee? Who hath gone, upon investigation, out of the world, and beyond it, that he should come and tell thee? And if there be no bound to it, so extended is it, go measure it with thy mind, that it may answer thee by the measures of it. There is One who hath measured all things, who may not Himself be measured; and that containeth all things, though nothing may contain Him.
3. this is to His glory. For there is one thing which is not in the power of that Lord, in whose power are all things; and this is His commendation. For His Will, than which there is nothing higher, alone and by itself is high; and this is its crown. Seeing that there is no possibility of this being declared in words, if one has been obliged to do so, it is not with a view to that being declared in words, which being hidden, never was at any time spoken or declared in words; it was the prying that I wished to reprove: for, if His not having given a nature to Himself, is a thing beyond its reach to attain to, how much more beyond our reach is prying into His Eternal Essence! 4. Who, my beloved, hath been able to feel or to embrace aught which existeth not? Even thus difficult and hard is it for thee to search into that which [really] is. And see how He sealeth up the searching into Himself, my son, since that which is not, beareth witness unto that which is, in this, that by scrutinizing Him, He cannot be searched out unto perfection. From this itself let us learn what perplexity
what is that operative will which proceedeth from Him, which also according to them gave the Son His Subsistency, it being able forsooth to create and to make the things that are not? While they avoid saying that the Father's Creative Word was generated from His Essence, in very truth they are driven to the selfsame point—for the Will of the Father which liveth and is in His Essence is the Son, and His Word by whom all things are wrought." Epiphan. i. p. 963, c. "In all things whatsoever thou sayest concerning God, O Aetius, He is wholly very simplicity, incomparable, perfect in Himself, not standing in need of aught. For He is perception itself and will itself. Wherefore in a way incomparable the Only-begotten Son did He beget, yet neither thereby did He deprive Himself of His own Essence, &c." See on contr. Scrut. i. §. 30. where the subject of the one Will in the Trinity will occur.
d i. e. if one cannot conceive an unoriginate Nature in such way as to keep clear of difficulties, then neither can we so conceive His Eternal Essence. It may be said, that if God did not give Himself His own Nature, He cannot alter that Nature, therefore He is not free in the absolute way He ought to be; for a necessity forces Him to be what He is, and prevents Him from being other than He is. This indeed is a case which no pious mind would wish to put, and which the confutation of heretics is the only object which will justify one in putting. Still when men profess to be able to investigate His Eternal Essence, it is allowable to shew, how what we conceive as attributes belonging to that Essence, and so more intelligible than the Essence Itself, are incomprehensible to us. Heretics say God begat at His Will: let them explain that Will, is St. E.'s reply, and then we may think of arguing with them. See R. xliv. §. 2.
Human proof inapplicable to things Divine. is ours, every time we gaze upon that first Essence, who when there was nothing, yet is found to have existed, and there is no proof of the mode of His existence. There is also another perplexity, as often as we go into Him, and how He begot from all eternity hath not been comprehended from all eternity. 5. It is from Him that we say of Him, that as it is necessary to confess His Essence; this being matter of necessity, not of proof, since it is too great for any proof: so too it is necessary that thou shouldest extol His Fatherhood without searching and scrutiny, seeing it is too high for any search. In prying into His Fatherhood, thou hast pried also into His Essence. Who will not honour in silence both of them? For they are withdrawn from all, and they are blended together. If they dispute, it is together; and if they overcome, it is together. For gracious is the Fatherhood: fearful is the Essence: after the fashion of the hands they assist one another, since their crown is one.
6. Who is there among ready speakers, whose speaking is equal to speak with all languages the Lord of all languages, which have never at any time spoken Him. For whatever will allow the whole of itself to be uttered, is also akin to us: its nature is fellow to ours. He alone it is who is not a servant: since by reason of His Father He is Lord. at full mid-day any one were to essay to teach men with their eyesight sound by argument, that the sun is the brightest of all the heavenly bodies. Now if a man who shews by argument things plain to sense is ridiculous, how can he who so teaches the things admitted by men's common notions be else than guilty of the same absurdity? For sure to men of right mind things like this are far better believed than the objects of sight...Do we indeed want the syllogisms of Aristotle and Aristippus to learn that the Ingenerate is not generate either from Himself or from any other, and that He is neither older nor younger than Himself? What then is he aiming at in all this? I suppose he wishes to make a display amongst his followers, as a person of a deep and piercing mind, sharp at spying out an absurdity, and sharper still at confuting what he detects, and that this is why he disports himself in a
wreath of arguments, and works so subtly at a demonstration of the truth, that the Ingenerate is not generate either from Himself or from any else." St. E. seems in this and the next § to be alluding to the above-cited passage of Eunomius, who, as St. Basil goes on to shew, in spite of all his parade of argument only involves himself in contradictions. The last note will explain his meaning here. The words 'of necessity' may be illustrated by Aristot. Meta. iv. 5. "That which doth not admit of being otherwise we say is necessarily so...demonstration moreover belongs to the head of 'necessary,' because it cannot be otherwise, if it be demonstrated in an absolute sense. But of this the principles will be the cause, if those from which the syllogism is made are incapable of being otherwise, &c." St. E. uses the word of all principles we cannot prove.
1. Who would not imitate those patriarchs, who have believed in simplicity? They examined not, and scrutinized not; for they set aside and cast out the disputations of the subtle one, who made our heart wax gross; and it became too heavy to rise up to the Godhead. I rejoice in the simple who have believed and have triumphed. 2. Who could ever comprehend how Noah was silent, who for a hundred years repressed his questioning within his heart? When the foolish jeeringly asked how the Flood should be, he questioned not, neither disputed when the surge should slay the ungodly; for, indeed, it was not revealed to him that in a hundred years it was to be. Who could look to Abraham and not be silent, for he bound his beloved son, the son of the promise, and upon the altar he placed him; he questioned not, he scrutinized not: he disputed not, he asked not, Where is the promise, or where the vouchsafement? He sheathed his tongue, and drew his knife. Who would not marvel how Abraham was silent, when there was indeed room for him to speak and to enquire? If that aged man were silent, and asked not concerning his son who was to die, who is there so desperate as to dare to scrutinize about the Son of God, by whom Isaac was redeemed?
3. Lest thou shouldest err, and think that Abraham was not of the eloquent, thou wilt find that he was both an orator, and comprehend that he was a questioner. For if he did not blush to be earnest for the people of Sodom, when he made the Judge of all content with ten instead of fifty; his speaking was a benefit, his silence was a victory. He spoke, because it was beneficial: and was silent, because it was becoming; he kept [silence] discriminatingly, and answered beneficially. Also, lest thou shouldest think that he was of the weaker sort, in that he avenged not himself, four kings were conUnbelief reproved by Scripture examples, Gen. 14, quered [by him], and he went and delivered his brother's 16. son, whom they had snatched away from him, and was patient so as to be victorious. 4. Let us learn from the Old Testament, which the children of the truth heard with discriminating love, and believed on 1 R. liii. the Giver of it, and relied upon the Writer of it, that all of it §. 1. was edifying. And the children of error heard it with ears of strife: and the mouths of mockers were rejected, because they 2 R. viii. scorned it. Wherefore both the Testaments persuade us that and ix. faithful men at no time ever disputed or scrutinized, since they believed God. But the learned and the cavilous disputants 3 R. liii. §. it is that rest not; the Scriptures are full of peace: and they
3. R. lix. are full of angriness; their disputing is inveterate in them: §. 5. R. their rust fretteth them away. Ixv. §. 1. R. lxvi. §. 2. 5. Who would not [be led to] fear by Moses, who because Numb. he let himself slip and become doubtful, as to whether a rock 27, 14. could bring forth water, was hindered from going into the land of promise? Who shall be able to enter into the abode of the living, who believeth not upon the Son of Divine Majesty? From the artificers one may gain wholesome learning, since it is not permitted to, or put in the power of, 4 R. xlvii. those that are uninstructed to judge of their works; nor are §. 1. these able to serve as an assay-furnace of their skill, since when skill of all kinds is measured, feeble men cannot make 5 S. the a point which is above their skill. Who then can judge haven the words of the Judge of all? Who can reprove the Voice which is of Him who reproveth all? As the blind searcheth not, but too great of fir them. trusteth to the medicines, and confidingly commits his pain to the knife to be healed, though it excruciate him much; yet he confideth, and this even to cauterizing, though it torture him much: who would not wonder that every one
6 R. liii. believes in the book of medicines, wherein the physician §. 3. Vol. ii. p. 437. "It is by love that he who would be a physician in difficult cases, increases the sick man's pangs: he gives pain without wrath, and suffering without anger, for he is no physician who cuts from hatred. And though his love be indeed great, his knife is fearful and severe, sweet in the relief he gives, but bitter in his medicines." See R. lxv. §. 3. This seems to allude to some definite book in vogue then, possibly to some of the pharmaceutical works of Galen, (whom St. E. mentions vol. ii. p. 317.) which were then in great repute. The parallel, here tacitly alluded to, between the physician and Christ, is fully drawn out, vol. iii. p. 388, e. it may be allowable to add a portion of it here. "The medicines of Thy goodness it is the sick only that need. See them stricken at Thy door, asking of Thee pardon! Whoso needeth not, O Lord, to him and by man's belief in physicians of the body. 291
reads and repeats and instructeth us, that we should rely on his words, and agree to his medicines, since questioning is not befitting: and yet the books of God have not yet been able to convince men concerning the Son, that He is His Begotten? mercy is not beloved. The good physician also hath no triumph, save in ulcers: he is not able to give a healthy body to one in health. For what way should a physician who cometh to the sick, heal one in health? Idly labours that physician that would heal a man in health: it is in ulcers and in pains that he shews the triumph of his art, and by merit and with propriety taketh the reward of his healing. In the sick the physician triumpheth when they get well of their pains...greatly doth the physician rejoice that pains and sicknesses increase, and ulcers, in his own neighbourhood, that he may gather from them advantages, yea, praise and glory, and the triumph of his art. And Thou so merciful and kind, O bring to me the medicine of Thy mercies, and triumph in me that am weak and longing for Thine abundant mercies," &c.
prehended so as to know who He is? And it keepeth hold of the names of the creatures without labour, and though there be no space in it, yet is there in it space for all. And how is it that by the names all things take up their abode in it, though its vigour wearieth not? Who can enter into the memory and feel where these names of the creatures are, since neither it nor they can be explored? In the mind and in the Essence all things dwell. Thus is the Father of Very Truth: in Him is the Son of Truth; for neither He nor those things allow their place to be explored. Mysteriousness of the memory, 3. Who doth not know that his soul goeth not out [of the body], and that if it did, the body would die with its departure; and still the memory flieth to all quarters, yet it hath no place that thou shouldst say, 'lo, here it is!' and though it is in the body, yet the creation is small to it: since the whole of it is in every place? Who hath searched into one asleep, for lo, although he sleepeth, he goeth to and fro. And if the soul wandereth in dreams, wherefore should the intellect wander along with it,
as an energy of the soul, shewing that not even the soul and far less God is circumscribed by a body. See Leontius, (p. 416, quoted ab. p. 167, n. h.) who charges the Nestorians with deriving their notions of God's uncircumscribed Nature from what is locally uncircumscribed, and so attempting to prove the impossibility of God and Man being compounded in Christ. which is incapable of sleep? Who hath been asleep and seen, after he was waked and remembered, how he saw when asleep, and how he forgot when awake? For lo, in all these things is a miracle! 4. How is it that the soul without the mind from out of its own self seeth a dream against itself; yet if it sees, how is it that it perceiveth not that it seeth, and in what memory is it that it retained all that it saw, until that [other] half of it be awakened which also giveth it light? How cometh that to cause [the soul] to remember which was sunken in sleep along with it? Who would not marvel at the sun which hath no feet, whose way is above itself, and how it can go therein—by feet? yet it hath none; by wings? yet it hath none; by motion? yet it stirreth not. It doth not belong to walking creatures; it doth not belong to flying; nor yet to the swimming. Lo, in all these things there is a miracle!
5. Speak thou, and explain to us, thou discourse of mortal man! where dwelleth thy store, and in what part of the their interpretations examines and expounds their own dreams to their own selves! Who is it that would not be astounded at this confusion? who that would not be awed at this commixture? who that is equal to comprehending this discreteness? how that it is one, and how that it is many; knowing, and yet knowing not; perceiving, and yet discerning not; forgetfulness, yet memory; himself, yet not himself; if asleep, he is awake; if dead, alive; if quiet, yet of wide wandering; if entranced, yet a prophet; the prophecy of his sleep in his awaked estate he expounded; he is with his essence, and is not with his soul; he is in himself, yet not in himself; for lo! while lying down he runneth about! is it he who goeth forth and cometh? or is it another that cometh and entereth into it? What report is to be given of the emotions which take place in a dream, which stirreth the limbs and maketh the eyes weep real tears in a dream which is not real? If we say it is real; behold it is not wholly so! if we say it is false; behold it is not wholly lost! Lo, their guilt is the same, because their dream is the same: amidst their great quietness their wrestling is great! &c. &c." Comp. vol. i. p. 412, quoted in p. 268, n. c. Vol. iii. p. 480, d. e. and Leont. c. Nest. i. 14. who notices that matter, unless animate, does not sleep.
Man's word inexplicable, much more the Word. mind is it that thou dost abide? art thou a portion of the R.l.§.1. soul, whereto there is yet no bound? art thou the offspring R.lxiv. of thy fountain, which bringeth forth, yet faileth not? And §. 3. where is it in the heart that thy motions beat? From this mere lowly discourse of thine then thou mayest learn amazedly the glorious Word, the Word of God. For if thy S.word own discourse knoweth not at any time how to relate its own R. lii. history, honour in thy silence the Word of thy Creator, whose §. 2. glory cannot be searched out! Comp. Pearl iii. §. 4. R. xxv. §. 1. R. xxxiii. §. 1. The Syriac word here answers precisely to the Greek , and may mean discourse, either in the mind, or, discourse in words. Thus far then our word 'discourse' sufficiently expresses it; but since the words and 'sermo' were dropped as names for the Word of God, because calculated to give a Sabellian impression, it would not be fitting to use the term 'discourse' of the Son. Hence some little confusion arises in the translation, as we do not use the term 'word' of the discourse in the mind. The points of resemblance between the type and Prototype, on which St. E. here dwells, are
its mysterious coinherence in and coextension with the mind, the generation from the mind without passion or partition, and its incomprehensibleness. Numerous passages from the Fathers upon this type will be found in Petav. de Trin. vi. 2. vii. 14. Thomassin ibid. tr. ii. 18—20. The latter well observes, 21. §. 2. 'Hinc lubet admirari stupendam illam consensionem Scripturarum cum illa sive ratione sive philosophiâ defœcatissimâ, quæ interdum superne nobis allucet, et cujus nonnullas scintillas in Gentilium libris, sed multo magis in sanctorum Patrum monumentis deprehendere est.'
1. Who hath seen the waters in the womb of a tree, which there undergo a change in a vast multitude of ways, as the waters alter themselves at His command, that they may turn to a body and become wood for buildings, and out of the very same there may be made bridges and ships, so that by means of themselves we prevail over the waters. Praises be to Thy wisdom! Who hath seen wood which has been consumed in a furnace, how that it is entirely dissolved and wandereth about in the air, so that even the sensible perception of it has departed by means of the fire, so as to yield no holding to its holder's hand. It began in the sprout and ended in the flame, and wondrously hath it withdrawn itself! Who can search out in what place the smoke of incense is left, the fat of sacrifices, the smell and the fumes of burning woods? Is it preserved in any thing that it may come to any thing again? or is it dissolved into nothing, that the Lord of every thing may be magnified in every thing?
God's gracious condescension heightens 2. When a servant has searched throughly, he findeth his fellow-servants; and if one hath searched the creatures, he findeth things proximate to himself; for his Lord is hidden from him, and how vile is the name of 'dust' compared with that of God! Yet still more vile is his disputing in His Maker's eyes; in name and in truth is it vile, yea in both of them. Who will not admit this without controversy, that audacious are not willing to confess even that He is the King's Son. Him they surname fellow-servant, and the crown that He received [they say] exalted Him by grace. Our King and the Son of our King opened His treasures, p. 71, and scattered abroad the good things of His Kingdom. n. y. He gave unto us two worlds, that which passeth away, and that which is waiting to come, yet since His love out-passed
His gift, the King took the King's Son and gave Him unto R. liv. us as a gift for His beloved, and killed Him and redeemed us by Him. §. 1. 5. Who then hath cast among us strife and harasses and mischievous disputing, the device of harm and the plenitude of blasphemy and the utmost evils, envy for love, jealousy for truth? The wicked one saw the Good One, who freely shewed us mercy; he clothed himself with jealousy, that he also might force us to be ruined. Wherefore let us say unto Satan, who worried us to pry into our Redeemer, Get thee forth, go, pry into thy devils, that thou mayest find thy fellow-servants; and also pry into the spirits, that thou mayest be acquainted with thy neighbours; and pry into Gehenna the fire whereof is reserved for thee, and feel after the darkness, the whole whereof is prepared for thee!
1. THE waters of our expiation and the stream of our 1 R. lxv. Atonement have become to them [the waters] of strife, §. 1. since in them their disputings range themselves on two Gen. 26, sides. The [Jewish] people strove in the wilderness, the 21. Gentiles strive in the Church; they contended angrily Ex. 17, concerning the waters of the Red Sea, and now these 7. concerning the waters of the Red Sea, and now these Ps. 106, contend angrily about the waters of the Sanctuary. Praises 7. 32. be to Thy Atonement! Who is there that striveth not, Ezech. 47, 12. who is there that asketh not his comrade [saying], 'who p. 203, baptized thee then, and whence was thy baptism received?' n. g. Who is it that doth not admonish and adjure another [saying], p. 197. let not such and such a schismatic priest's hand baptize thee? p. 178, and so they have come to be waters of strife to parties of n. d. strife. p. 196, 2. The Holy Spirit we called on at Baptism. The bold n.c. Nat. disputers have rejected the truth: they strive, and say that Alex. it is not right to make Him equal with the Father and the diss. Son. Who is it that hath despised the Holy Spirit, and xliii. p. hath numbered with the embodied Him who admitteth not
526. of a body? Yet in no place have the Prophets brought in a 4 R. lii. charge of weakness against Him, or the Apostles of deficiency. §. 5. R. As a servant and minister, as a creature and subordinate liii. §. 2, person, the Prophets never have preached Him, as they &c. preached the Son. For He is high above any body, and Scripture implies, that the Holy Ghost & so the Son is God. 301 high above all these. From Him by Himself let us search: for if they must needs write unto us the Nature of the Father and the Son and the Spirit, and reveal concerning the Maker that when nothing was made, He did make; and, as these R. ix. say, wrote of the Son also that He was created, how was it$^{§, 1}$ that they revealed not unto us, of this Third Person, of what Nature He was?
3. Who knoweth not that he rangeth in his thoughts, and numbereth in order the Threefold Names of the Father, the Son, and the Spirit? And it is meet that as he reckoneth up Their Names, so also he should reveal Their Natures. If then it be written, let them read it: if not written, let them confess that their Nature is hidden. Inasmuch as He hath not given a revelation to us concerning the Third [Person], He sheweth most clearly that it is not the Natures of the Father and the Son and the Spirit into which we ought to search; but the anxious care of the Good One hath been, how by all means and by all occasions He might shew mercy unto the children of men! 4. Wherefore without controversy allow, that every thing which is given in writing, or by word, that names, and appellations, aim at giving mankind the life more abundantly. It is not for scrutiny nor for distinctions, that we should
not to me very clear to what heresy St. E. is alluding: [see §. 4.] perhaps he wishes to shew that Aetius, by making the Spirit finite, approximated to the Montanists in some respects, and to the Manicheans in others, either of these parties making the Spirit incarnate in their Paraclete, and thus by introducing a duality, obliterating the Catholic doctrine of the Trinity. St. Basil de Sp. S. cap. 2. notices a principle of Aetius, as that on which the Pneumatomachi or Macedonians founded their heresy, viz. that things unlike were declared in unlike terms, and that, conversely, what are declared in unlike terms, are unlike. From this they argued, that the Holy Spirit was not consubstantial with the Son. This will perhaps serve to shew why St. E. appears in this §. to pass from the Macedonian, to Montanist or Manichean, heresy, and from those again to the Anemeans. St. Basil, c. Eun. ii. §. 33. and §. 84. says, Eunomius was the first to call
the Holy Spirit a creature, and that he asserted that He was created by the Only-begotten, who Himself was created by the Father. (where see Ducæus.) To this blasphemy St. E. plainly alludes in the end of the §. search into Their Nature, but that we might be instructed in the greatness of Their Love. Say that the Holy Spirit hath not taken flesh. He is high above voices and the odious sounds of voices that have been uttered. Proclaim the Divinity of our Lord and His Humanity, since these are words which the Holy Books have scattered and cast into the ears of men.
1. WHAT was it, pray, that compelled the true Father, who 'generated' all things, to use the names 'Generate,' 'Father,' and 'Son?' "It was because He chose to do so." What, chose to lead us into error? "To adorn Himself was what He chose, and He denied Himself." But if this were the case—but far be this from being so, nor let such things come into the mouths of the faithful—still from this selfsame expression, if it did 'adorn' Him, does He who denied Himself, in spite of His not being so, yet prove to be a Generator? The Names of Father and Son intended to 4. The Lord that knoweth all, asked of the devil what his name was; and the unclean devil denied not his own name; as neither did the devils deny His Name: and the clerks are put to shame who have called our Redeemer a creature; for the devils themselves betrayed that He was the Son of God. Of His own self alone Legion taught, that as his own name of Legion agreed with the interpretation of it, so he cried out because he felt that He was the Son of God, whose Name implied His Father. But if His Name comforted the sick, even His mortal Name, which agreed with His Human Nature, how much should that of our God [comfort us]?
5. For who would compare the Names of the Holy One, [and not see] that He agreeth with Himself in all, in that of 'Eternal' with His Eternity, in that of 'Just' with His Justice, in that of 'Good' with His Goodness? in these He agreeth, and how comes it that His Fatherhood is different, in that it agreeth not with itself, if He hath no glorious Son from His own Womb! Who is there that does not see whether these surnames agree with the [things] themselves; with dust Adam [agreeth], Eve with 'living,' Phaleg with 'division,' and Babel with 'confusion.' Since we have touched on this confusion, let us avoid agitation. Receive in order the Names threefoldly. For from Babel one learns, that even there Three came down and confounded. For it says, Come Ye, let Us go down, and that Invisibleness was an attribute of the Father's which the Son did not possess. St. E. then would imply in the text that the Son is the Fruit and consubstantial with the invisible Father; the Invisibleness of the Son would be implied in that of the Father, because 'generate from' means 'having the same nature from' the Father. See St. Aust. c. Maxim. ii. cap. 9.
The expression 'that knoweth all' might be noticed as bearing upon the question, (p. 190, n. g.) whether our Lord grew, really, irwisdom; but the meaning of the original is far from clear. See n. d. on R. lxxvii. See p. 68, n. r. The Heb. and Sam. have the singular in the present text; the Chaldee and Syriac and the Vulgate also have the plural: the LXX. 3. As St. E. elsewhere refers to readings found in the Hebr. only (e. g. in Vol. i. p. 539, d. to the Cethibh in 2 Kings viii. 10.) it seems likely that some Codices then had the reading from which he here argues, , although de Rossi gives no such reading. There is however the same difference in Gen. xi. 3, 4. and Ex. i. 20. where the singular occurs again with a plural verb, which might be alien to the usage of Chald. and Syr. but is akin to the use of Syr in Greek (Kuhner Synt. §. 430. n. m.) and 'age' in Latin (Ramshorn 70. ii. 2.) with a plural. The passage is used by other Fathers to prove a plurality of Persons, (see Sabatier on the place, Petav. de Trin. ii. 7. 10.) but they do not seem to insist particularly upon the 'Venite.' It is right to add that this passage according to the Talmud (see Voisin ad R. Martin, fol. 559.) was altered by the LXX. to the singular to prevent the heathen from deducing a plurality of Gods from it.
1. Who is there that would not fear, since the Lord threatened a millstone to the neck of him that maketh one of the children of light to stumble? They that trouble the simple with questions have their prying for a millstone, they are drowned by scrutinizing, and will not emerge p. 87, again, since they keep not silence from that evil wrangling of theirs. The word which teacheth patiently concerning the Father and the Son, who are united with Each Other, S. is that, which has either lowered the Father as well as Him to a kinsmanship with the creatures, or else has raised the Son as well as Him to a state different from that of creatures; since the Son would be like His Father. 2. Any word with a proper meaning in it, is not intended either to leave that meaning unuttered or to give a contrary one; for if the name of Son be suitable to the creatures, then If 'Father' and 'Son' have no corresponding
the name of the creatures is suitable to the Creator; and if the name of the creatures is alien from the Creator, then is it alien also from the Son of the Creator. Whatsoever happeneth to the Nature of Him that begot, may also happen to the Son of Him which begot. The Ray is bright, because bright is He 1 R. xl. that begot It; and It is not cut off, since It is like to Its R. lxxv. Root; neither is It stinted, since It is bound up in His Surn. e. p. name and like Him in all things. From the Father one may 339, c. learn the Son; for if the Generator be akin to the creatures, i. 12. the Generate also would prove a fellow-servant with the 3 n. c. on creatures. But if the Father be alien from, is His Fruit akin R. lxxiii. to, them? or shall we separate This from Him and say that 4 R. xlvi. He is not the Son? But if He crieth aloud that He is §. 4. p. the Son, then He hath put strife to silence! 272, g.
5 R. lii. the Son, then He hath put strife to silence! §. 2. R. 3. Who would not marvel at a wedlock of roots which lxii. §. 1. have lost their own nature and have changed their names; R. lxv. both of them are bereaved of what are their fruits! a Root of §. 4. freedom with a Fruit of bondage; and a Tree of bondage 6 R. lviii. with a produce of Majesty. How, when blossoming, do They §. 1. blossom? From this very expression thou shalt learn: for if 7 R. lii. the Son be verily reckoned so, then is He verily Generate: §. 1. He must count for a servant if He be not Generate; it R. lxxvi. must be one of the two. For either both Parties stand good, §. 1. Each of Them in His proper place; or They have undergone a c. Serut. change, and have loosened Their Names, and fluctuated in i. 12. 8 comp. Their Natures. Who would not enquire, whether, if the Name p. 234, of the Son is to be made 'creature' in his scrutinizing, this n. f. [word] 'creature' is not to be Son in the enquiry. Since then it was impossible for this name of its to be consistent with 9 S. its itself, it relinquished it: for the thing intended betakes itself reality to 'Generate,' as the Name of 'Son' also assorteth not with R. lxii. the creature. For that word 'creature' were no longer like a §. 2. creature, as also 'Generate' is not like Son. Whence there arises a great confusion—for the Name of Son will not be consistent with 'creature;' and the word hath forced the 9 S. its wrangler to call the Son 'creature,' and the creature 'Son;' reality and with the Name he hath also destroyed the worship of R. lxii. §. 2.
10 On Athan. p. 423, n. m. This is like the use of the word in Greek Fathers, (see Petav. de Trin. iv. 10. §. 5. Le Quien on Damasc. i. p. 37, n. 5.) for whatever is accessory to the Essence of God in our conceptions of Him, e g. attributes, whether personal or not; here of course personal attributes are out of the question. 3. the Son of God,—the which be far from happening! It is not for any one to abide in what is right, that hath transgressed what is becoming! 4. How was Moses demeaned, who received even the Divine Name and a heavenly glory, yet dared not to say he was God, and deceived not the people? When the children of that people went astray in the desert, then he by all methods reproved them in every thing; and he cried against them, and called heaven and earth to witness against them. How again was the saintly Apostle demeaned and his colleague, when the men began to offer sacrifices unto them and to burn incense to them, and called them gods, because they saw their wondrous works? They rent their inward heart and their outward garments, and allowed themselves to be stoned rather than to be worshipped. Why did John exempt himself, saying, 'I am not the Christ whom ye seek?' But and if the servant had felt that his Lord was his fellow-servant, then the Nazarite who lieth not, did on the contrary deceive greatly. For he set to his seal, that He was the Son of God, and lo! this preacher's word crieth aloud in the world!
5. Why did not Gabriel deceive Daniel and say he was God, or the Seraph not deceive Isaiah and say he was the Son of God? He was an Angel and he deceived not, a Seraph and he lied not. The Apostle is true and deceived us not, and he asserted and revealed Him to be greater than all. Hear what I say,—that if this were not the truth, it would have been confuted and come to an end. The truth alone is able to increase to the East, and to spread to the West, and to lay hold on the North, and to clasp the South. Into the depth It went down and conquered! into the height It went up and abode and ruled in all places over all! Dan. 8, 17. Is. 6, 6
1. FROM the very beginning our fellow-servant seduced and Rom. 1, enslaved us in the service of our fellow-servants. His Son 25. set us free from all; and when He liberated us from servants, p. 223, our Lord became our fellow-servant; and when we had let d. go what we had found, the creation was again made our portion. See p. 272, n.g. For it is to the adored Father in the adorable Son that we offer our adoration. Praise be to Thy Light! Who doth Gen. 1, not know that Adam gave those creatures their names, and the names which the servant gave pleased the Lord of all, and were written and were believed? yet have the sons of
relation to man's fallen state, and in that state, the result of gradual development, was in Adam from his birth (so to call it) what gave him the power of making and choosing particular names; much as in the gift of miracles (which of course is not without God's agency, comp. p. 68, n. r. the recipient is not tied down to determinate acts of miraculous power, but uses or even abuses that power in particular acts. Eunomius, on the other hand, spoke as if God had Himself uttered certain words and syllables, i. e. assumed that the phrase 'God said, &c.' was not in any sense an accommodation to man's notions, but a literal fact. St. Chrysostom in Gen. Hom. xiv. p. 124, b. speaks in a like way with St. Gr. of Adam's great wisdom being displayed in giving the names; and so Basil of Seleucia, p. 8. (ed. Dausq. "Go thou up Adam to thy dignity and confirm thy lordship by the names given to the animals; imitate the Creator's dignity! He creates natures, do you give the appellations! And one might see a secret watchword carried orderly through all the animals, and they all flowed together to Adam confessing their subservience to him by their passing before him. For God, it says, brought all the animals, &c. Be thou a creator of names, Adam, since of creatures thou canst not be, and let them be formed by Me, but when formed be named by thee! Let us share the glory of creative wisdom!
Me let them recognise as Creator by the law of nature, thee as master by the word of naming! give the appellation to those, to which I have given the substance. I subvert not the name; I reshape not the gift. St. Austin Op. imp. in Julian. P. lib. v. init. notices that Adam's giving 'the names to all kinds of creatures was a proof of most excellent wisdom;' it being so held even by Gentiles, (see Plato's Cratylus, §. 8. §. 14. &c. from whom Nyssen, p. 815, a. says Eunomius borrowed 'the nonsense which he through poverty of ideas tacked on to his own trash')—St. A. adds, "that we might have most reasonably conjectured, (even if we had learnt nothing of the sort about Adam,) what kind of nature was created in that man in whom there was absolutely no fault; which any one can see...slowness of intellect or memory to be. Severian of Gabala, a less saintly author, in
the on the place, p. 75. on the other hand speaks as follows: "Since God made him after His Image, He wished also to bring his honour out to view, and to shew verily that he beareth the Image of Wisdom. And see what a marvel! God prefigured ( ) to Himself the names, and wished it to be shewn by the image that Adam's decisions agreed with the acts of God's will. So Scripture then being minded to shew that God had also foreordained the names which he gave, says, 'and every thing that he called it, that was the name of it'—i. e. this was foreordained, God had decided it. So Eusebius, (whose heretical bias is thought plain by many great divines,) P. E. p. 516, a. where he also is commencing Plato, says of the same text, "What else does this prove, than that the names were given according to nature? for the name which was now given, this (it says) was long before comprised in nature, that to each of the things named there should be and preexist this name which the man aforesaid, inspired by a power above him, had given it. To which view Origen also strongly inclines, contr. Cels. (i. §. 24. p. 18. Spenser, (see his notes) as does Mahomet, Coran ii. 31. and perhaps others referred to (anonymously) by Moses Bar. Cephas de Parad. i. p. 477. B. P. Max. vol. xvii.
It is not meant that there is any Catholic doctrine upon the subject known to the writer, but that the opinions of orthodox writers on the whole run one way; as they did hold Adam to be possessed of supernatural grace and knowledge, so they seem to hold the need of believing a freedom in the use of the latter, as well as of the former, as if guarding against any depreciation of Adam's supernatural state,—the belief in which the heterodox in all ages seem by some instinct, as it were, led to attempt to obliterate. A supernatural gift of knowledge then freely used in cooperation with the external circumstances in which, by bringing the creatures wonderfully to him, God had placed Adam, seems to be that which originated language. As such a view does not preclude a belief in the continuity of God's enlightenment of the soul, (comp. p. 209, n. b. during the process, it is not in any way connected with a heathen notion, that men Adam not been ashamed to wage the war of disputation against the names of the Son, which the mouth of God proclaimed in their ears.
began with being a 'mutum et turpe pecus.' (See Horace, Sat. i. 3. 100. and Lucret. v. 1027. whom Simon quotes. It also falls in with the following other passages from St. E.; vol. i. p. 24, d. on the place. "His saying that He brought them to Adam is to shew his wisdom, and what peace there was betwixt the beasts and Adam before he transgressed the commandment. For they came to him as to a much loved shepherd...Not only the power over every thing which He had promised did God give to Adam, but He added moreover the right of giving the names which He had not promised. Now if He did for him somewhat over and above, which he asked not, how, without Adam's having sinned, could He withdraw what He had promised? For if a man were to impose names few in number, for them to be kept in the memory is no great thing. But an excellent thing it is, and greater than man can attain to, when in a single hour a man imposed thousands of names without giving the latter the names of the former. For for a man to put forth a multitude of names for a multitude of tribes of creeping things, beasts, and cattle, and fowl, is possible, but to do it so as not to give the names of one tribe to its fellow, this is of God, or of that man to whom this is given by God.
If He gave him power and associated him in the creation, (comp. Bas. Sel. above, which forms a scholion upon this seeming misprint for Lacopo which occurs in p. 24, f. and clothed him with glory, what was there more that He could do unto him to make him mindful of the commandment, which He did not do for him? Here the whole drift of the passage is the same as it is in St. Chrysostom, viz. to shew that the fall was not from any want of wisdom in Adam, and St. E. minds not what view is taken of giving the names provided that is admitted; though he seems plainly from the second of the alternatives (of that man, &c. which he gives, to prefer referring it to the supernatural state of glory in which Adam then was; as he says in p. 22, c. "He clothed him with glory,
and gave him his discourse and intelligence and perception of God. p. 27, c. "He was more subtle than all who had given the names to all; for as the children of Israel without a veil were not able to look upon the face of Moses, so neither were the beasts able to look upon the glory of Adam. With downcast eyes did they pass before him what time they received their names from him. Here again he is arguing to the same purpose, viz. to shew the serpent's own subtlety was not greater nor as great as Adam's. So in vol. ii. p. 455, f. speaking of the diverse races of men, he says, "From the wonderful fountain of Adam the common stream of words and of forms flowed; which implies that he draws a parallel between language and other natural gifts. The sense then in which such passages are to be taken is to be estimated in part by the heresies the Fathers were opposing. When Eunomius wanted to shew an inherent connection between words and the things signified by them, he is plainly talking of words as they now exist: and therefore it is to the purpose to urge against him, as St. G. does, the endless variety of languages as proof that there is now no such connection. When he or others represent Adam as a mere material instrument in God's hand, it is important to insist on his supernatural state of knowledge and grace, and maintain the existence and free operation of created wisdom.
This of course is quite another thing from denying, as Eunomius implies St. B. does, all interference of God or dependence of man in such matters. A portion of a fragment of St. Athanasius ap. Leont. in Mai's Coll. N. vii. p. 86. will fitly conclude this note. "Thus did God make man, and God as being good made man so great and goodly. Do not then consider his present contemptibleness, but imagine to thyself his first constitution, seeing that it was in God's Image that He made him, &c. &c."
us to His Father; and 'the Gate' again, because He hath brought us into His Kingdom. They also mystically called Him 'the Lamb,' and He was slain to be our reconciliation: and as He John 1, was sacrificed and thereby made good His title as Redeemer, 36. how much more was His Generator entitled to that Name, seeing that if He was Son, He was also Generate. From R. lxi. the name itself by itself may its force be tasted; for there . 3. is a name that may explain itself to us. The word 'made' n. c. proclaimeth a Maker, 'creature' a Creator, 'framed' a Framer, . 3. 'Son' a Father, beyond all controversy. That is a weapon which, through its truth, hath at no time been overcome. 3. From the confusion made, a perversion is detected; c. Scrut. for lo! every name is of a piece with its root, and agreeth i. 12. with it, 'Made' with 'Maker,' 'Creature' with 'Creator,' and R. lx. 'Begotten' with 'Begetter.' Is then the name of every thing p. 307, to stand, and the name of Son only to be lost? It is not lost, since the lost by it were found and returned. From its own mere self alone it appears, that as this word 'creature' means creature without all controversy, both in name and in reality; so one may rightfully insist that, in like manner, S. it is the Son, our Lord, is the Son, only if He be Son both in the requisition name and in reality: but if the names be empty, then pretend of fitness that all things are names, and nothing else.
and as oil to another, and as butter, and as the fat of wheat; and this is a type of Christ that true Rock, the Head of the Everlasting Building and the Fountain of Life. To every one that draweth near to Him, is He according to his desire: to one He is the River, to another the Gate, to another the Way, and to this one Wisdom, and all things becometh He to all that He may gain every man." The Anomeans, as it would appear from Gr. Nyssen, p. 525, when told by the orthodox that the Son could not be made son in the sense in which men are called sons of light, without making Him capable of moral advance, urged that the Son had a number of other titles, as Stone, Axe, Foundation, &c. which plainly were not names which really agreed with His Nature; therefore neither does the Name 'Son' do so. To this St. G. replies, p. 526, c. 'that though the names which are given by Scripture to the Son are, as they say, many, there is none which we say implies by its
relativeness a connaturalness with the Generator. For we do not, as in the case of the Father's Son, so also in that of Stone, Resurrection, Shepherd, or Light, or any of the other names, use the term to imply a relation to the God of all: but one may as if by some artificial rule make a twofold division in the meaning of God's names. For some of them contain a setting forth of His high and unspeakable glory, and others set forth the manifoldness of His providential dispensations.' Comp. p. 672, d. p. 792, c. Epiphan. Hier. lxix. §. 35. and see on Athan. p. 25, &c. p. 153, n. d. and above, p. 29, n. g. Vol. i. p. 334, c. "The gods of the Gentiles are names without meaning. The argument in this §. is, that relatives imply their correlatives. See Aristot. Categ. §. 7. p. 6. l. 27. Bekk. St. Bas. c. Eun. ii. 9. "Who doth not know, that of words some absolutely pronounced, and by themselves are significative of their subject matters; but others being used relatively indicate only the bear1 §. 7. R. him? the names of Generate and Generator then are borrowed! lx. §. 1. and so would the Father in His Name be at variance with R. lx. Himself, and the Son also in His Generateness. That the §. 3. Fruit and the Tree are not divided, Their Names proclaim by their true taste.
Who can taste any thing 'made' in the Name 'Generate,' or in the Name 'Son' any 'creature.' For the Fruit by itself alone may have its taste comprehended. But if the taste of what is bitter give sweetness, the names of S. are every thing give contradictory impressions. Yet who shall heard make the Names of the Lord of all contradictory? Men do pervertnot, from having a surname by grace, lose on that account edly. R. lxv. §. 1. their natures by the surname, seeing they remain clad with R. lii. §. 1. names unalterably attaching to mankind, and their own name §. 1. is an assay-furnace to them. If the Son be a servant, then S being clad He is found to be our fellow-servant; if the Son be our Lord, with fixed then in truth He is our God. names of p. 316. ref. 3. R. 5. Who would not be astonished to think that if even the lxiii. §. 4. Son is a servant, that the Womb of His Generator made Him p. 122, fellow-servant of all; and that He was more glorious in the n. i. birth from Mary, which did make Him a true Brother of man-R. xlvi. §. 4. kind, than in that from the Womb which did not make Him §. 4. either Angel or man, but made Him the fellow-servant and Ps. 110. kinsman of creeping things and of brutes. Who can deny p. 133. R. lxv. §. 1.
ing they have to their correlatives. 'Man,' e. g. and 'horse,' and 'ox,' brings before us each of the things mentioned; but 'son,' or 'servant,' or 'friend,' are merely indicative of the connection with the cognate word. Whenever, at this rate, a man has heard a generate thing mentioned, it is not to some essence that he is carried in mind, but its connection with another is what he thinks of. For a thing generate is an expression used of that which is generate from some thing." And his brother, vol. ii. p. 403, d. "God is called both Father and King, and by countless other names, by Holy Writ. Now out of these names some are used in this single way, thus absolutely I mean, e. g. 'Incorruptible,' 'Eternal,' 'Immortal,' and the like. For these, even if no other conception be understood along with them, in themselves comprise a kind of perfect notion of God. But there are other names which
only signify a relative bearing, as 'helper,' 'shielder,' 'protector,' and as many of this signification as may be met with: from which if you take away that which needs assistance, then the power indicated by the word comes to naught. But some there are used both of themselves and with correlatives— as 'God,' 'good,' and such like... There is no reason why a person, who sets before us the Father and Him who is from Him,... should not at the same time by the appellation 'Father' signify to us that He begat the Son, and also explain by the same word His own Unoriginateness." Comp. the next note. the Names of the True One; he hath heard His true Nature in His Name: and if the name of Son and of Generate were found to be untrue, then was He a deceiver. But if the name R. lx. of the creature really applies to it, that name is found to §. 1. be true; yea its appellation is a name of taste and soundness, while that of Son is tasteless. Nay, 'tis we are tasteless, who have made it tasteless!
6. But who would make the fixed Names of Father and §. 4. Son and Spirit tasteless, by which the clerks that lack taste ref. 4. have gained taste? For every word which may be tasteless hath its force from the adjoined words. The Names of S. by nature Father, Son, and Spirit, since they alone are fixed, have a comp. force which cannot be made void; for there is nought that is Athan. p. 286-7. akin to them so as to be adjoined to them. Who could be p. 316, baptized in disjoined names? Who could confess in borrowed ref. 1. §. 4. R. lxiii. §. 4.
title instead of giving the Son any pre-eminence, expresses no more of Him than what might be said of the brutes, i. e. only expresses that He is a creature as well as they. Nyssen, ii. p. 558. "If the Son be a creature, then the Heaven is a son, and each of the things that are made is, according to this fiction-writer, with propriety called by the name of 'son.' For if it is not by sharing the nature of Him who begot Him that He hath the name of Son, but He is called so just because He is created, then this same argument will make a lamb and a dog and a frog, and all things that subsist at the will of the Creator, to have the appellation of 'son.'" St. Austin c. Maxim. lib. i. 6. "In order to shew that the Son is of the same Nature as the Father, I opposed to the monstrousness of your error the progeny even of animals that die, to reprove the heart of you who deny that God the Son is of the same Nature as the Father, though you do not deny that He is a true Son. For God Himself gave to animals the power of generating that which themselves are; in which case I called not only man man's son, but a dog a dog's son, not for their likeness to God, but for the confusion of those who detract from the Son of God; who when they see natures corruptible and mortal, which yet have a unity of nature from their parents, are still unwilling to allow to the Son of God a participation of One Nature from the Father, though He be inse-
parable from the Father, and incorruptible and eternal with the Father. Whence also I said that, on your theory, the estate of man, in which such growth is possible that at least thereby the sons may arrive at the parents' strength, is the better: but the Son of God, as ye say and teach, being born less than the Father in such way continued so, that He could not come up to the form of the Father, and did not grow." The heretics of the Arian school generally asserted, that Son had unalterable relations to the Father, as St. A. here assumes. See St. Greg. Nyss. ii. p. 369, c. and p. 639-40. (ab. p. 175, n. a.) in which latter place he contrasts as was commonly done the Angels' natural capability of moral advancement with the unchangeableness of the Son. This then will throw a light on the word 'Angel;' and the passage from St. A. on the word 'man.' Angels are capable by nature of continual approximation to God, as man is to his parents, or indeed to God: but the Son in the Arian view not being really a true Son, and yet being fixed to one unalterable state as they allow, is rather like brutes than rational beings, has a title which, with the heretical explanation of it, concedes to Him whom God bare from all eternity, not so much real advantage as attaches to the nature of man or Angel, to wit, a capacity for indefinite progression towards their Creator.
Heretics pervert the use of language. names? They are essentially indivisible; it is we that have made a division in the Truth. For the virtue of the Father can never be made void of Him who is Generate from Him, neither can the Son be severed from Him. Who can sever the harmonious Names? Who would not scorn to say that the Creator made the creatures greater than His own Essence in that their names are united, while He divided the Name of Father? Every man is clad with names of his own; and the Father and the Son alone have Their Names stripped from Them.—They have falsified the names of every thing in every thing!
1. Who doth not perceive, my son, that whatsoever hath surnames, hath had them given from some occasion; and that when there is very urgent cause, at the time of a testament bonds and loans, they come to an end, and are broken off: and veritable names are requisite at that time, that they may seal the truth? Who doth not know that when our Lord was crucified, He cried to His Father, and commended His orphans and disciples, saying, 'Father, take and keep them.' And when John 17, He was raised again, He sealed by His Resurrection His 11. R. 4. Sonship to that Father, and made His Name to pass through the assay-furnace, that it might be believed on in all the world. Who doth not confess, that even during His Cruci- 1 S. upon fixion it was to His Father He cried, and commended the Luke 23, 46. Flesh 2 of His Humanity 3? And that they might believe 2 or Body Mat. 27, that He was the Son, His voice rent the graves, and rent the
50. p. 23. sanctuary; it scattered the nation of crucifiers, and gathered Is. 60, 5. together the nations; and they believed in His Divinity, and Zech. 8, confessed Him the Very God, the Son of Very God. His 32. Voice was as a witness, shouted, confessed, avouched, and wrote, and sealed, that He was not a servant, who as a Son fled to His Father. 2. Since the watch was a man of distinguishing mind, who is called 'centurion,' he diligently observed how the voices of our Redeemer, who cried unto His Father, were in
c. Arian §. 5. has the following remark upon the passage, which will perhaps help to shew St. E.'s object here. "He commends all mankind to the Father by Himself, as they are quickened in Him; for they be His members, and the members being many are one Body, which is the Church, &c. quoting Gal. iii. 28. What St. E. then may mean is, to consider the voice at the Crucifixion in its effects upon the Church, and hence, as He is speaking of the Resurrection, he is led to mention not its effects upon men's souls in the intermediate state, but upon their bodies afterwards. In vol. i. p. 561. we find the following passage, in which there is a reference to the way in which Scripture blends the First-fruits with the effects on the lump. "Isaiah had said, Take a lump of figs, &c. 2 Kings 20, 7. The lump of figs which was put upon Hezekiah's boil, and by which being put on it a cure began to be effected, is a type of the Incarnation of Christ out of our nature. For from the time that God condescended to Flesh, and was united with It, the cure of Adam's boils began. But the figs be a type of the generations out of which the lump of healing effect was derived unto us. Beautifully then doth Scripture add, that it was on the third day that Hezekiah's cure was perfected, and he went up to the House of the Lord;
because it was not before the third day that Christ healed by His Resurrection our mortality; and He became the First-fruits of them that slept, and made ready for us an ascent to the House not made with hands. For the Apostle Paul saith, Eph. 1, 6. God lifted us up with Him, and made us sit in Heaven in our Lord Jesus Christ. In the same way he may here apply what is said in Scripture of Christ to the orphans and disciples who were, by virtue of His commendation of Himself
to His real Father, to attain to the adoption, to wit, the redemption of the body. So above, p. 23. in a passage throughout parallel to this, he says, 'When upon the Cross He quickened the dead, His Body quickened them, yea, rather His Will.' Yet the addition here 'yea rather' makes the meaning plain, not to say that 'Body' ought to occupy the place of 'them' to make this clause parallel to the text in this point also. What one would suspect is, that a letter should be altered, and we should read 'Body of our humanity.' Vol. iii. p. 507, b. "O Lord, when Thy mercifulness moved Thee to come down and put on the Flesh [or Body] of our humanity, &c. See R. lxxiii. §. 2. and R. lxxvii. §. 1. This taken in connexion with the way in which St. E. speaks of the Old Adam, (p. 328, n. c. would give a good meaning to the passage, the main object of which is to shew Christ called God 'Father' to the last. Didymus, de Trin. iii. 30. is worth quoting, as shewing what use may be made of the text against heretics. "Through His own Person He commends the human nature which is quickened into Him by faith, which also He deigned to call His members, or possibly He partly teaches all to know how much Arius was in error herein, he having supposed Him not to have a soul in the Incarnation;
and partly teaches all to pray at their last breath, and use this voice, confessing in a right spirit, that it is from God that the being of us men originates, and to Him that we have to return. And so what took place was a precept. See also p. 350, n. d. and Le Quien ad J. Dam. F. O. iii. §. 24. The expression, however, in St. E., as it stands, would go the other way; it is so strange that this note cannot pretend to do more than A.'s version, i. e. to palliate the difficulty.
to pretend these are undistinguishable from proper, names. 319 a voice diverse from all voices. The earth beneath it shook, the sun above it darkened, yea, he also cried, and set to his seal p. 23. that He was the Son of God. From the Lord of all Himself one Mat. 27, may learn how sweet He is; for He called not Himself by the name of the [eternal] Essence, for the Name of Eternal were great and high in His justice, rather than in graciousness. Neither can the height of His name and His surname be brought down, so that He should invest the creatures with it, since it is the Name belonging to the [eternal] Essence. 3. Who would not marvel at His Name and at His mercy? for His Name is inaccessible to all, and His Love condescendeth even to all. Since He hath other Names which are sweet, and accommodate themselves to creatures, and which are condescending in order to magnify His works by His surnames, it was in these that He came down, and clothed His own creatures with His Names. The Heavenly King made kings of His servants: because He was God, He called them also by the name of gods; and because He was Judge, lo, His servants are judges; and because they were travellers, weary did He call Himself by name; and by reason of their riding He also made Himself a rider, that He might in all things be like unto us.
4. Who is there that is in such sort wholly unwise and hard-hearted, as to fancy ever so short a while, that because men were called by His Names, that the nature of man and of God is one [and the same]; or again who, because the Lord was called by the Name of His servants, would imagine a thing made and the Maker to admit of being compared together? For when He called us kings by His own Name, the reality was His, the likeness ours. Again, when He called Himself by the names of His servants, the nature is ours, His is the surname, in the place of the true name: and the borrowed name is plain, both in our case, and in His case. Now by His mercies wittingly did He set His own Names upon His own creatures, not for disputation, but for consolation. Let questioning be stopped, my brethren, and let us pray more. For when He shineth forth unto us, He is as of our race, and though distinct in all things from all things, yet is He with all things in all things.
1. LORD, root out the thorns, whose sower is the evil one, p. 220, and the husbandman of tares. For they saw that we disputed, p. 217, and they rejoiced that we wrangled, and they agreed together n. g. at our separation, and they assembled at our dispersion, and they rejoiced that our assay-furnace put not their frauds to p. 122, the trial, nor our light their spots, nor our voice their n. i. disputings. Who would not weep that we have become perverse? For where it was fit that we should keep still silence, there our voice was tumultuous; and were it was p. 118,9. right that we should reprove, there we were tongue-tied by the persons of men. We have gone astray, and have turned p. 162, n. a. on our eyes away from our own hateful faults. We have warred Athan. and risen up against the High One, for we have pried into the p. 190, n. c. hidden things of God, [to see] how He exists. Yet who is able to search throughly into that party which disturbeth and p. 326, n. c. troubleth us? For if he indeed have senses, how then is R. l. §. 5. he formed, and how are his ears and eyes furnished with R. lxxv. openings? and if he hath a mouth? for behold he hath no §. 4. body; and if he hath limbs? for behold he hath no frame.
2. Who then—[to take] this apostate Satan, who teacheth n. b. R. lxxv. e. us the prying into secret things—who hath searched him p. 203, n. f. out, [so as to know] whether the whole of him is any man, p. 104. and how he is able to blend his design with our mind, and p. 299, n. e. R. his words into our words, and how too he insinuates his will lxvi. §. 1. into our heart? Here is a marvel in his hateful doings! p. 326, n. c. Who would not be ashamed that the wicked one entereth R. l. into his body and maketh a sport of the soul which dwelleth §. 5. therein; and how that it feeleth not the intimate access of Satan, who dwelleth in itself, and entereth into it; neither can it comprehend how to feel the touch of him that sojourneth in it. While searching into its Lord, let it search into its murderer!
3. Who hath explored into the earth, (which yet appears Scrut. i. to be a thing limited by measures,) to see, whence the ear is §. 7—11. R. lviii. §. 1. 322 Difficulties in nature teach submission to those in Scripture.
1. SPEAK for thy side: Nature is before thy hand, Scripture before thine eyes, and nature is hard for us, Scripture is easy for us; for it was not from nature that we learnt Christ. It is right and meet that from the same source whence we learnt His Humanity, we should also learn His Divinity. It is right that from the same source whence we learnt His Birth from Mary, we should also learn His other prior Birth. And though nature is hard to us in every thing, the Scripture is able to teach us of the Father and the Son and the Spirit, if They of a truth baptize us and give Basil us life. He is convicted by himself! for either he denies p. 721. the baptism of the heretics to be valid; or else if he is baptized xliv. §. 3. and asserts their baptism to be valid, he is like Marcion, who d. ate the goods of the Maker, and denied the Maker, and though he was conceived and born, yet vilified marriage. Tertull. A bitter fruit this which denieth its own root! For who when c. Marc. i. 29. he baptizeth denies and casts aside That into Which he R. lxii. baptizeth? He cannot then cast them aside, since he cannot R. lxii. baptize without the Names of Father and Son and Spirit. And though every form of words has a fixed shape, thou hast Though had trial of those of the heretics! every word
2. Who hath searched out the ventricles and ducts of animals, meats and their changes, natures and their vicissitudes, some whereof are solitary, and some of them productive of others. There is also reason to be greatly astonished at the trees, how it is that they put forth and bear leaves and branches and yield fruit; the investigating whereof ends in stillness, and the searching after them in silence. Who 324 Necessity of faith illustrated by the case of the blind.
1. Who is he that hath been daring and hath forgotten himself, and hath wished to be a measure of Him that formed him, himself being but dust? Let him who feels that he is dust praise that Image who fashioned, yea, and ordered him. The seducer seduced and bewildered the sons of men. Against the invisible Sun he incited them and darkened them, not that they should see, but that they should pry. By the Trinity, whereby they were washed, they have defiled themselves, in that they have made divisions about Their Names. 2. There is wrangling in the Church, and in the presence of the Truth the heart is divided upon disputation. In the Church envy biteth men, and in the Ark there was a treaty of peace among the fanged beasts. Under the pretext of truth there were bows; a quiver have they made of wrangling, and it is full of arrows. The wicked one hath decoyed the simple, and introduced them to hopeless questions and crushed them to pieces therewith. He hath irritated men with things which are not convenient, that they might leave off from those which are allowed. Because they were intoxicated, they put on strife as a coat of mail; they have rent Truth as the garment. Yet is the Truth itself not divided, for it hath rent them that rend it, and cast them out of the Kingdom. Lo, they have put on armour, as in war, for that victory in which is concealed condemnation! They have worn the Scripture to pieces, not that they might read it, but that they might go astray and [see] how to pry and wrangle. They are clothed within with hidden poison, while they are convicted of having the Serpent hissing amongst their words. Who shall be able to allay them who, when supposed to be searching after the
1. THE standard of truth hath been set in the Scriptures, the blear-eyed leave it; for they seek to shoot at the Lord of angels. This standard is that the Father is One, indivisible; and the Son is One, unsearchable. A visible standard is set in the light, and he who is foolish shooteth darts by night into the darkness. Let stillness be a boundary to the vain talkers, and let silence be a boundary to the disputers concerning hidden things! Let the mouth learn how it should speak, and thus let it speak, lest it repent after it hath spoken; let it learn first, and thus let it teach, lest it become as it were a passage for things not convenient. 2. The Scriptures are set as a mirror: he whose eye is clear, seeth the image of truth therein. There is the likeness of the Father set: there is the image of the Son shadowed out, and of the Holy Ghost. The Names of these Three are set one after another in the faith at baptism. Pretence entered in to make confusion, [saying,] that we ought to pry into them, in order that we may gain them. Scrutinizing entered, strife entered, struggling entered, and truth fled. The right thing was then, that they should gain the truth without disputing, and not that we by searching should let go of the whole of it. It was fit also that in simplicity we should gain life, and not by much wisdom to gain death. It is fitting too in the time of thirst to drink the water, and not in stead of drinking to measure the fountain. It is fitting for a little child to know his father by the sight of him, and not by closely examining him. It is fitting then that one should learn the
1. THE Scriptures are agreed, men are divided, seeing that it is about the one truth, that strifes have risen from free-R. lix. will. Under the pretext of truth vile men have designed the obtaining the mastery, after having called men to their side. R. xxxviii. The congregations chose their masters, captains of thousands and of hundreds, and captains of tens: because there was abundance of peace, all the spoilers that spoiled by troops every man his neighbour, were vehement at disputing as at a contest, so that brothers cast their darts against brothers. p. 190. Mighty sorrow! The vile drew their tongues; they smote, n. c. R. lxiv.§.1. and were smitten: and without blood or danger that sword though feeble raged. The tongue as a murderer scorneth, §. 2. because it is blinded! 2. Vain-glory troubleth the disputants, as the crown causeth sighs to the wrestlers who smite and are yet overcome. They are much overcome even by that wherewith they conquered, since their excuse was rash boldness. Mighty woe! In what sense has he conquered, who in having conquered, hath yet been the more overcome, whom his own pride hath conquered? How doubly great is the loss of him also that loseth his suit, who by disputing loseth it and by envy too, with perfect loss! Whoso hath entangled his fellow by searchings, him hath haughtiness entangled as in a pit-fall. R.xliv. O great humiliation!
3. One is filled with wrath, another with strife, which [leads to] endless evils. And what hope is there for them that have lost all hope? Let us weep that they have been daring against God and against men, that they may hoodwink them by vain babbling. The headiness on earth goeth into heaven; the earth is disturbed: disputation funeth up as a smoke. The Heaven and the Heaven of Heavens are unproductive of disputation, and the caverns of earth are full of the Disputation dissuaded and prayed against. blasphemy. The Heaven distributeth over things beneath dew and rain, streams that are full of all good things. The earth hangs the things above with all sorts of questionings, with disputation that is full of all blasphemies. The things of clay have clashed, by their disputings, with their handiworks, and have fallen upon the earth and become dust! 1 R. iv. 4. Ten thousand times ten thousand Angels are still, and two are prying; the soul and the body are in disturbance. Still is Michael and Gabriel too, and dust disputeth and ashes too. O heavy wrath! Sicknesses pressed on us: their words 2 S. by ceased, as by the prospect of death have their scrutinizings means of their end and disputings also. Praise be to Thee, Lord, because that Thou hast restrained me from such scrutinizing as all the bold disputers use, that I may live before Thee.
1. If thou priest into the Eternal, it is a distraction; where wilt thou begin, and where wilt thou end, O weak man! From the beginning to the end there is rest to him that goeth by the King's high-way. To the Eternal there is no beginning nor end, and so He perplexeth him that seeketh into Him. If in the Truth which thou hast laid hold of, thou lettest thyself be of divided mind, thou wilt pour thyself out and error will drink thee in, that thirsty land. If with His secret counsel thou let thyself become perplexed, disputing about Him will be a mighty sea and will come over thee. In the faith as in a ship go down to His Scriptures as a sailor to the port. Save by His Scriptures go not thou down into Him, for He hath made Him many havens among His billows. Praise thou His Name!
2. The High One came down in His Love and became small though greater than all, and was little unto Him who was too weak to go. Again, in His Love He hath become a Sea, that he might traffick therein who was lacking in treasures. But if in His own Nature one should familiarly use Him, neither things above nor things below can go down into Him. What created thing can search into His God-head, when there is a gulph between him and the Creator? Unto the Godship is naught of the things which are made far away; for Love is between Him and the creatures. Unto God there is not a man of the disputers that cometh nigh, though He be very nigh unto them of distinguishing mind. In that Holy One none that is impure partaketh, for that He dwelleth in His entirety in the holy. To that All-knowing One none attaineth that is subtle, for that His Love is with plain men. To that High One none that is haughty attaineth, since His Love condescendeth to the lowly. He, being God, cannot be measured of a man, though very loving unto men. He, being Maker, cannot be measured of things made, how great No faculties can find out God.
soever the thing made by Him may be. He, as Only Living, cannot be uttered by mortals, nor His Generation by the disputers. Unto that Majesty who can reach? the spirit is feeble, the soul is little, the flesh weak*. Whoso hath thought that he could search out Him, of him the speech strayeth, of him the heart roameth, of him the whole rebelleth. * It seems but little to add, that the flesh cannot reach God, which assertion may yet be illustrated by reference to n. d. p. 116. It would however appear more likely, that the word 'flesh' is used (as in Scripture) for the soul considered as acting upon, and acted upon by, the body; and the sentence will then mean, that that one substance, (which we call spirit, soul, or flesh, according to the subject matter which at the time of speaking we conceive of it as acting upon,) cannot by any of its faculties find out God. The oneness of the soul in all these three functions ought to have been noticed above, p. 166, n. d. and p. 295, n. d. as what St. E. makes analogous to the oneness of God in Three Persons. It will be
following the example of the Fathers again to remind the reader, that God is not one out of all things and does not come under the laws relating to all things, and that consequently any one of them selected to illustrate His Nature only illustrates It partially. Each of these three functions of the soul seems as we contemplate them to engross its whole substance, and so to correspond to the Trinity in Unity in the rude way in which alone we can contemplate His Adorable Substance. The soul's mode of existence does not, in reality, answer to God's mode of existence: but the two objects, as we contemplate them, do (Leveia, see p. 145, n. a. p. 246, n. b.) exhibit a kind of resemblance. Comp. R. lvii. n. a. b. p. 341.
1. WITH what eye shall the thing made look upon the Maker, when it is a creature, and He the Creator? There is no seeing of the soul within us, gaze and look as we may, R. lvii. either with the mind or with the eyes. For if we enquire §. 2. after it with the mind one believeth in it, and the other denieth [its existence]. Oh, great stumblingblock! How R.i.§.1. should the soul that is so blind that it cannot see even itself, n. e. gaze upon the Godhead? Neither can it feel itself, yet will it with these senses dare to search into the Creator. Get thee down to the haven, feeble man! for if the sea be R.lxix. vehement, the haven close at hand is as a place of refuge. §. 1. Draw near to a searching proportioned to thy strength; and then if thy heart be amazed and lost, wait thou in silence! Stillness is not at a distance, nor is it at a dear rate that thy mouth can buy silence. Silence is easy; disputing R. li. is hard. It is not by any necessity that prying is thrown §. 5. upon the bold disputer; and even the commandment, though it seem to be altogether constraining, is not of necessity, since it is of free-will. And if the law be not of R. v. necessity, what disputing can constrain us to be searching? §. 5. R. xxviii. He gave the commandments, and refrained disputing; in His §. 2. c. Testaments there is no seeking and no prying. He gave the R.i.§.12. law instead of disputation, and instead of searching, the e.Scrut. faith, unto our feebleness. The natures which He made are R. not to be comprehended; how much less the Nature of R. lxxii. Him who is hidden in Himself, and is unspeakable! §. 1. R.lxvii. §. 3. Mat. 11, 27.
2. The Son, which is of Him, knoweth Him without controversy, as not erring as to the way of searching into Him. Every thing made erreth altogether, whensoever it prieth, for that it cannot reach unto the Maker. If then His Love magnified us, let us know what we are—that our nature R.xxix. cannot pry into His Nature. For every thing which is a §. 1. R. lxiii. §. 3. Creatures cannot comprehend the Creator. creature goeth altogether astray, if it thinks that it is capable of prying into the Creator. Let not that which is made go astray, since by scrutinizing into Him it goes to a wider distance from the Maker thereof.
1. THERE cannot be among the creatures a vessel large enough to contain that Majesty! there cannot be among minds a womb that sufficeth for the knowledge of the Godhead! For the Maker is very wise, so that He would not be at issue with Himself, as in sport, about the manner in which He should create. For if He were to make a vessel capable of containing Him, then were the thing made greater than its Maker. Folly this, that the thing made should be the greater and more excellent, while the Maker thereof were not greater than it! 2. If then the Creator be the greater, how can the thing made, which He hath made, be commensurate with His knowledge? and if He hath made any thing commensurate with Himself, this were an amazement not to be believed. Again, since every thing which He hath made is marvellous, it is because the Creator is great that they be glorious, though created things. Great is the creature, because great is the Creator of it; and little again, since however great it is, it is worthless [compared] to Him. Nothing then is small which He made by reason of His Love, and yet it is small [compared] to Him by reason of His Glory. Yet the Creator acted not counter to Himself to create aught which should limit Himself, neither did the Maker strive against Himself to make aught which should set bounds to Him. It was not any envy between the Creator and the creatures, since He is clothed with Love toward His subjects; [but] it is not the lot of that which is created that it should be a match with its Creator in its knowledge.
3. Of what is a creature, the Scriptures cry aloud, that great as it may be, it is far less than its Creator. Let no one imagine these things, or the like of these, of the Fruit or of the Begetter of Him. The Prophets cry, the Apostles confess, yea things above, yea things below, that He is the Son of the Highest. Yea, His noble acts which are rife in Heretics deaf to God's teaching. all the creation are enough to convince even the blind; and who is there that will despise the mighty thunder of all His
1. WITH mighty wonder set thy soul a boundary, O hearer, and gather in thy mind from distraction! By faith He draweth R. lxx. §. 1. nigh unto thee: but by prying thou removest far off from His blessings. Great disputing is not adequate to the exploring of Him, since He is hidden entirely from the disputatious. In faith wait thou for Him; and if thou hide in Him, to Him it is that thou hast come! how great refreshment hast thou found! Yet even to attain this thine own running sufficeth not, since without Him thou couldest not even know that He exists. If thou wert to search for ever and ever, it is He that giveth thee this, to be able to know of His existence only. And how much soever he that laboureth doth labour, this he knoweth, and beyond it there is none that knoweth. 2. For He is very manifest to him that seeketh Him, and very concealed from him that prieth into Him. Be still, bold disputant! He is withdrawn from thee; He is not in the height above, nor beneath. He is lost by thee: yet found to thee. Lo! in both these who can reach unto Him, seeing He is withdrawn from thee, O searcher; He is found to thee, O worshipper? He is revealed in His Goodness: concealed in His Essence. Instead of His Majesty, seek His Goodness, which may be found of thee. His treasure is open: Himself is withdrawn. Instead of thyself, seek the Deep; instead of scrutinizing Him, seek His aid. His great mercy calleth unto thee, O weak man, that thou mayest know that His treasury is full of compassion.
1. Lo, there is a similitude between the sun and the Father, S. are the radiance and the Son, the heat and the Holy Ghost; of parables and though it be one, a trinity is beheld in it! That incomprehensible who can explain? One is many, a one that is three and a three one. Mighty wonder, marvel visible! The sun is distinct from its ray; they are distinct, yet alike, since his ray is itself also the sun; yet of two suns no one speaketh, though his ray is also the sun over things below. We call Comp. Chem not two Gods, though our Lord be also God over the creatures. Who can search out how and where His Ray is bounden, bounden and yet free His Heat? Though not divided, R.i. §. 5. 2. Types of the Trinity and the Incarnation drawn and when it is shut up in sleep, the ray putteth it off again, as the dead [body] that is to be raised up again.
3. And how the light pierceth into the eye no man comprehendeth, as [neither how] our Redeemer dwelt in the belly. The light from within the eye putteth on a fair appearance, and goeth forth visiting the whole world, as our Redeemer clothed Himself with this vile body and went forth and sanctified the whole world. But when that ray passed to the fountain thereof (for it doth not separate from its generator) it leaveth its heat here; as the Holy Ghost, whom our Lord left with His disciples, without changing from His own place. 4. Look at the likenesses among the creatures, and do not thou be divided about the Trinity, lest thou perish; since thine own life is too hard for thee, being one that is three, a trinity which is one.
1. Who shall make me able to gaze and look upon thee, thou great light! wherein are crowded together types of thy Lord? Who can search out the heat thereof, which though separate is not cut off, as the Holy Ghost? The might of his heat dwelleth over every thing: the whole of Him is with every thing, and also with each one. It is not cut off from the ray which is blended in it, neither from the sun as being mingled with it; and when it is spread over the creatures, each one
Comp. Basil de Sp. S. §. 22. fin. In this sentence may be contained an allusion to the doctrine, that the Holy Spirit sanctifies the elect by the application of His Very Substance to their souls, each one of which taketh up that divinely infused Heat according to his ability. Yet it may be observed, in confirmation of the view taken in n. b. and c. to R. lxxiii. that St. E. here speaks of the heat as spread over the creatures, as he did of the ray in that passage. For as it would be heretical to make the Holy Spirit, (who never took into union with His Person a nature capable of change as the Son did,) to be in any way subject to change; it seems that this passage would shew in what sense the other is intended to be taken. For the mission of the Holy Spirit (of which §. 2. speaks clearly) is His Procession, viewed as influencing those 'who take up the might of His Heat,' i. e. the elect. (see Petav. de Trin. viii. 1. §. 10.) So far then the passage might be taken to allude not to what is eternal only, but also to what is temporal, i. e. to man's part in the matter, inasmuch as it would be difficult to some to distinguish in words between the Unction of Christ's Human Nature with His Divine, and (what of course in reality is a very different thing) the Unction of the elect with the Holy Spirit. (See however Petav. viii. 7. §. 10. &c.) Yet even the Incarnation of the Son, in spite of the new relations to man to which it gives rise, (p. 234, n. f.) is in such way the result of His eternal Procession from the Father, that neither of the Other Persons could have been incarnate with-
out a confusion of the order of the Trinity. (Petav. de Inc. ii. 15. Thomassin ibid. ii. 1. and 2.) Nor is it else than remarkable, that those who favoured the Nestorian view of Christ's Mission were also opposed to the Latin view of the Holy Spirit's Mission. (vide Le Quien. Diss. D. i. §. 13. Petr. Strozza de Dogm. Chald. p. 17. ed. 1617. Assem. B. O. iii. 2. p. 233.) If then in a passage of disputed meaning what makes for A.'s explanation is not concealed; it is hoped that what is done for fairness' sake will not be taken to be done from hesitation as to the explanation here given. For it seems, that had St. E. had before him here only the substantial application of the Spirit to the elect, he would have spoken of His being 'mingled' with them or 'dwelling' in them; and that the clause really alludes to the two constituents of the notion implied by the word 'mission,' the eternal Procession of the Omnipresent Spirit being alluded to by the phrase 'spread over the creatures,' and His union with the elect by the remainder of the sentence. See on c. Scrut. ii. §. 8. Calcas (in Petavius) illustrates the Mission of the Spirit much as St. E. does that of the Son in the last R. as follows; 'Although we take the Mission in a sense implying time, referring our own affection to God, yet may we not make it subject to time. For if a blind man were just to recover his sight and enjoy the sun's ray, one should not say that the ray or light then for the first time proceeded from the sun. For it is plain that before the man recovered his sight, &c.' St. E. himself gives such The operation of heat and the Spirit compared. 343
taketh up the might of its heat according to its ability. By it the naked getteth him warmth, while putting it on, after the likeness of Adam who was unclothed; this it is which is See on c. Serut. grateful to all that are naked, while it sendeth them forth, as i. §. 34. men invigorated, for all labours. 2. The Spirit also clothed the Apostles and sent them forth to the four quarters of the world upon labours. By heat all things are ripened, as by the Spirit all things are hallowed! O visible type! By that is the cold that is in the body overcome, as uncleanness by the Holy Spirit. By p. 73, that things which the frost hath bound are loosened; as n. d. souls which the wicked one hath bound are by the Holy Spirit. By it the calves of Nisan dance; as the disciples p. 27. [rejoiced] by the Holy Ghost which dwelt in them. By the heat also are the bridles of winter broken loose, wherewithal it holds back the fruits and the shoots; by the Holy Spirit again are the bridles of the wicked one broken off, wherewithal he hindered all graces. The warmth awakeneth the bowels of the still earth; as the Holy Ghost doth holy Church. How much then is it that he will go astray, and how much that he, a feeble man, will be searching the mighty boundless treasury? and how can he go astray so far as to measure with Him, unto whom whatsoever is in the four corners of the world is small? §. 1. p. 235, ref. 1.
3. Heat looseneth the evil bridle, yea, the chilly silence of comp. the frost upon the lips, and penetrateth the mouth, yea, and R. lxxii. the tongue, as did the tongues of the Spirit which settled on the Acts 2, Disciples. The Holy Spirit by His Heat applied by the. tongues chased silence away from the Disciples, the evil, yea, an abundance of illustrations that it requires some apology for introducing thus much from Calecas. But to use the words of Petav. viii. 5. §. 8. "rapit nos ad sese ac sine satietate delectat tantæ rei ac tam suavis jucundæque recordatio." The operation of heat and the Spirit compared. God's condescension and man's inadequacy dissuade prying.345 in the firmament, three senses fail, if thy whole body were senses they would not reach to the Godhead that is hidden from all. The three senses that failed at the types of the Threefold, that are the in sun, they cry aloud, that they are ignorant how to scrutinize the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost.
2. Again, place water before the sun, and behold there a semblance of the Birth of that Holy One. For without separation and without flowing it generateth a fire, a generate which is chaste as the generator thereof: this is not by separation from the sun, nor by severance from the water. Mighty symbol! For while the water and sun are unimpaired, a generation takes place, wherein a man seeth the Generation of the Son. He hath shadowed out difficult things by simple ones for our feebleness, that we might know clearly that He is the Son. By every similitude the Gracious One came near to our weakly estate, that He might heal it. 3. And if that Great One who is God, without semblances approacheth not unto mankind, let man who is feeble not seek to bring his own weakness near that Majesty without a medium. Linger not, O mind, construct spiritual bridges, and pass on to thy Creator. O son of a servant! serve thyself of the wings of the Holy Scriptures, that thou mayest reach to the Son of thy Lord. And let this soul too avail itself of every medium, that it may reach to the Holy Spirit; and thou body be not slothful, fly as an eagle unto that Body which quickeneth all.
4. And since those senses of man's are too feeble to scrutinize the Godhead, deal not extravagantly. For lo, the senses of the Angels on high, subtle though they are, yea spiritual, yet suffice not! Stay then the coarse senses of the gross bodies which carry off excretions! from searching these things are relinquished as too pure; tell us concerning the unclean things of unclean devils! Let the senses of thy body tell us of the spiritual senses of the foul-smelling devils, with what nostrils doth Legion snort? and with what feet runneth the wicked one through the whole world!?
sages may be added here. Canon liii. fin. "Oh, High Priest, who didst offer Thyself for us a Sacrifice to Thy Father, receive from us, O Lord, our offerings in Thy mercy, and clothe with glory those that have waited for Thee and kept and done Thy commandments." xxiii. §. 3. "Lo! the pillar that did lead Israel, causeth His Light to rise to thee in darkness, for there is hidden in thy limbs His Body that rouseth all, and in the blood of thy spirit is there mingled the Cup of Salvation which leaveth not thy body in destruction." liv. §. 3. "Take Baptism and the Body and Blood of Christ with thee as a passport." lxxxi. "As provision for a journey Thee have I taken unto me, Thou Son of God, and when an hungred Thee have I eaten, O Redeemer of the world! Far be the fire from my limbs, and when the smell of Thy Body and Thy Blood striketh from me, may Baptism be to me a ship that foundereth not!" Paræn. v. 1. p. 414, c. "O fatted Calf that wert killed to be a Sacrifice for sinners, blot not out me wretched man, O Lord, from the number of them redeemed by Thy Blood! Thy Body have I eaten, and Thy Blood have I drunken, and by Thy Death believed that I should live." p. 429. "Because
Thou hast given me Thy Body to eat and Thy living Blood to drink, by Thy Body may I be pardoned, and by Thy Blood have my sins forgiven, and rise to praise Thee among the assemblies of Thy Saints." p. 432. "That sea of fire disturbs me and terrificeth me, and I am in fear by reason of the iniquity I have done. May Thy Cross, O Son of the Living God, be to me a bridge, and from Thy Body and Thy Blood may Gehenna go away ashamed, and I by Thy mercies be redeemed." p. 452, f. "Leave me not in the enemies' hands, nor give him ground against me; for Thy Body and Thy Blood hast Thou mingled in me, and Thy Rood betwixt mine eyes is stamped." p. 480, c. and f. "From hateful lust deliver me by Thy living Body that I have eaten, and I will lay me down and sleep in peace, and guardian be Thy Blood to me, and to the soul that is Thine image." p. 482, c. p. 488, e. p. 490, f. p. 493, f. p. 494, e. p. 519, d. p. 535, c. p. 545, c. ('Thy Body and Thy Blood as an earnest of life is hidden in their members,') p. 551, d.
1. By the names of trees, lo, their fruits also are named, R. lx. §. 3. R. lxii. §. 4. whether they be sweet or bitter! The names of the trees then and their fruits are the same; they are distinct, yet equal. A great type! Distinct is the fruit from its tree, and yet the same with it, since one appellation is given to S. surthem both. If the root be sweet, then the fruit is sweet; the same name men call them both, it and its fruit. Distinguish p. 317. the names of the stem and the fruit, and yet make them the same also, and call the fruit by the name of its tree. For if it be sweet, they call the fruit also sweet, and the root how-R. lxxvii. §. 3. c. §. 12. §. 31. & p. 383, n. x. ever stringent. Distinguish the Names of the Father and the Son, and also make them equal, since the Father is God and the Son is God. For God is the Name of the Father and God also is the Name of the Son, as it is written. For He is distinct in Name, in that He is the Son; and equal in the Name, in that He is God also. Glory to His Name!
2. And if [the names of] trees as well as of their fruits be true, how much more true are [those of] the Father and the Son. He shadowed forth things hidden upon things which are visible, that He might shew the things which are not seen by the things which are seen: He imprinted His mysteries upon trees, that He might explain the things which are not comprehended by the things which are comprehended. For He also interpreted difficult things to us by the things which are easy, that we might easily gain a knowledge of Him, and things difficult by things which are clear, He made clear unto us, that we might know clearly that He is the Son. That He is our Lord then, yea, and our God, the just feel: p. 372, n. n. scriptures cry aloud, that the Father is God and the Son is God. Without God is the [Jewish] people who gainsay Him.
Mark 13, 32. §. 3. R. liii. §. 5. R. lxxviii. §. 1. 2. R.lxxix. §. 1. 1. 'THAT Hour knoweth no man;' this the childish have balanced with the Son, and it as it were preponderates. For if the First-born does know the Father, who is there that is greater than the Father Himself, whom yet He doth not know? That hour, forsooth, no man knoweth, not even the First-born, for it is the Father only who knoweth it. And if as they think, it is because He is a creature that [the Son] does not know it; behold fools are making Him a creature by their pryings. 2. Come, wonder ye how our Lord, because He is a creature knoweth not that hour, while they which are created by His own Hand have dared to pry, not into that hour, but into the Lord of hours. Would that they would abide by their own word, that every thing which is a creature might keep silence before its Creator!
3. By that knowledge wherewith He knoweth His Father, is that hour also pondered upon in His knowledge: for if He gave Him to know His glory, and concealed from Him an hour of time, then is it greater than Himself. Set the hour which He knoweth not, along side of the Father whom He knoweth, and weigh and see whether is more excellent. 1 §. 1. For the Son by the mere fact of His knowing the Father knoweth Him entirely: He is not less than Him; for that He lacketh naught. And since the Root is real, in a real way doth the Fruit which He brought forth know Him 2. And what fruit is 2 R there that knoweth less than the root thereof, in that the whole of it is blended 3 with the whole. For if in its knowledge it fell short of its tree, then in name also hath it ceased, for it were not its fruit. If then that fruit agreeth with its root in its name, it agreeth also therewith in knowledge. The sweetness which is in both of them is one: one is the knowledge 4, which is in both of them, being they are commingled. 4 R. xlv. §. 3.
4. The fruit is mingled into its tree, and so is its root into the fruit: who can sever them? They are not divided in the sweetness; they are not divided either, in the knowledge of perfect truth. The love of the fruit is amid the root, and amid the fruit that of the tree: who can divide them? The Names of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost, equal are they, and at unity in the illapse at Baptism. The Names are united, the movement is the concordant 5 one of S. equal one Will 6. They bear as it were one yoke, and come; and as 6c. Scrut. They are equal in the illapse at Baptism 7, so are They also in Their unanimity. 7 p. 166, n. d. 5. But the Fruit came down and clothed Himself with a Body 8, and clothed Himself along with it with the feeble 8 or Flesh
b It might seem from the Latin, (completitur et representat,) though very loose, that it was intended to be printed 4 was comprised in His own knowledge; which certainly would make the passage run on more easily. Christ's seeming ignorance names of His kindred, that as He even put on our human nature, He might also put on our knowledge for our sakes*.
4 This squares with the passages noticed above, p. 190, n. g. p. 305, n. e. The words 'for our sakes,' which tally with 'for our profit,' in Athan. p. 461, n. f. are explained by the next sentence, in which the asking of questions evidently refers not to the real state of our Lord's knowledge as Man, but to what He said and did with a view to carrying out the economy, asking questions when He Himself knew what He would do, as though He did not know. Having put on our nature, He demeaned Himself, so to speak, as though He had all its accidents, some of which He suspended at will, see p. 202, n. c. p. 199, a. So in a Sermon on Lazarus, vol. ii. p. 391, c. he says, 'When the third day of the death had come to the dead, (Lazarus,) and upon the fourth the worm had begun to gnaw his features, the Quickener with His disciples came to the city of the deceased, and asked his buriers that were assembled, Where have ye laid him?' The question about this was owing to the perverse [Jews]; for it is clearer than the sun that Himself had no need to ask it: it was to attest his burial that He asked. ...He did not say, Where is his sepulchre? but, Where have ye laid him?
He knew the haughtiness with which they gainsayed His noble acts, and so by the question tied them down to the place in which they had laid the buried man. He did not ask, Where is Lazarus laid? or, Where is he buried? but, Where have ye laid him? do you shew Me, ye gainsayers! Even of the Father is there a question which is like to this, and what is uttered by many that do I through reverence abstain from, without going into perverse disputings. Truth standeth by itself; it is not a marshalling of words that grapples with faith; simplicity with cheerful look it is which beholdeth truth as it is, and without wordiness and strife it standeth on the side of verity that is without strife and disputing. Whether of the two is greater to know, where the sepulchre is, or to raise him after he stank? That He was a knower of hidden things He proved before He came, by His revealing to His Apostles that 'our friend Lazarus is fallen asleep;' but the gainsaying buriers did He ask, 'Where have ye laid him?' that He might take a pledge of his burial from them, and then call
him. He wittingly bound them down to their having laid the buried man there, that when He had called him and raised him up, they might be witnesses of his resurrection. He asked, Where have ye laid him? they say unto Him, Come and see. They were tied by the question, that they might not gain fresh haughtiness. The Son is not inferior to the Father, through His asking concerning the sepulchre, or from His weeping over Lazarus. His Incarnation did He attest; both in His weeping and in His sweating the tears and the sweat were His own, yet do they not minish the Son, seeing He is a Raiser of the dead as His Father. He wept to attest the reality of His Body; He called the dead to shew His power; He put questions to tie down the gainsayers; He prayed to shew His perfectness. Neither doth His prayer over the grave make Him less than His Father, and indeed from His own language thou learnest, that it was not from any need to do so that He prayed, for what I say, He says, is for the sake of the people of the Jews, that they may believe that Thou hast sent Me. The mind of the people did He heal, seeing their hearing was weak, and they manifestly doubted if He was the Son of the Most High.
This was why He referred all His actions to the Father, to shew that it was not from 'robbery' that He was Lord and Quickener of the dead. In lowliness were the things done by Him, done, that the understanding might behold His love. It is beside our purpose to speak of these things here. Clearly shineth truth in its generations, and without our words it gleameth! Perfect is the Generate, as is His Generator! Wonderful the Firstborn, as He that sent Him! a Raiser of the dead is He, as is His Father also! For He that wept raised also. Upon this point it is possible for us, if ye asked us, to speak many things, if we see that the seed of our word hath budded in your ears. Even if ye reject it, I shall not cease to sow! Be not a rock unto my word, nor the high-way, nor a place of thorns, &c. &c.' In this passage we see that St. E. used the account of Lazarus' resurrection to establish any thing but a true ignorance of what our Lord asked about, which the Adoptionists afterwards used it for: see on Athan. p. 466, g. What St. E. argues He that knew all things became unknowing, He asked and listened, as a man, for man's sake!
6. If feeble men then have pried into the Essence [to see], how He is the Son and yet cannot contain that [Essence], either let them be still, if He knows it not, or if they pry, let §. 2. them confess that the Son knoweth all things. If then they pry when not permitted, this is audacity; or if it be permitted, p. 128, it is as a gift [of grace]. He then who gave dust [the liberty] to search, how should He hinder His Son from knowing an hour of time? Grant that He knew not that hour: the cause of His not knowing was the Body where for Flesh withal He was clothed. from it is, that our Lord's disclosures of His knowledge were made with reference to those whom He was addressing, and also to prove the reality of the Flesh, i. e. to shew that He had a certain Nature, not to describe the state in which that Nature existed in Him. See Eulogius in Phot. p. 284. ed. Bekker. who has many topics in common with St. E. here quoted, and in R. lxx.
1. SHOULDEST thou at any time be minded to say that the Son knoweth not that hour which He does know well, since that hour is from His reckonings, He knoweth it, for by Him were all numbers framed. If it be [an hour] of the year, He R.1.§.1. knoweth it well, for by Him the months of the year were framed as its limbs; if it be of the months, He is acquainted with it, since by Him were framed the days of the months as arteries; and if it be of the days, it escapeth Him not, since Mark 2, by Him were divided the hours and the sabbaths and the weeks; and if it be of the sun, He is acquainted therewith, since it is He that hath trodden out for it the paths of winter and the steps of the summer; and if it be of the moon, again He knoweth it, for it is He that made the full moons, with the beginnings of the months. If it be in the height or the See Is. depth, it is in His fists: by His finger are all creatures suspended! 40, 15.
2. Compare the hour that He knoweth not with the Holy Ghost whom He doth know, [and see] whether is greater! and set forth clearly unto us the reason how and wherefore He concealed from Him the hour of His triumph? If the reason why He concealed it from Him, was that He might be less than Himself, lest He should make Himself like Him by stealth, that conceit is very weak, and see how soon it is solved with a single word. For when that hour shall be revealed, and the trumpet hath sounded, and the triumph is going on, it shall be solved. Now then compare the two together, and the inequality will have become equality upon their assumption. One of two things must be: if it be in the fact of His not knowing that He is inferior, then by knowing He will become equal, when He doth perceive it; or else if He be not advantaged when He doth perceive it, then of what advantage is it? for see though He does know it, He is still inferior, inasmuch as even Satan may know that hour, for when revealed, he will be ruined thereby. A mighty thing then is St. Mark xiii. 32. discussed.
that hour to conceal from His Well-beloved, when even Satan may know it! 3. Come then and hear the ground of His glory who is Lord of all, who is greater than all, whom all things depend upon! For the ground of the glory of God which has respect to us is His loving-kindness, which endureth for ever; and the ground of His glory in respect of His Son is His Paternity, which also is from eternity to all eternity. Oh, holy grounds, which neither towards creatures nor towards the First-born shall ever cease to act! Time is the ground of the hour of time, and it is for a time, and with time itself its time passeth away. Mighty is the ground of His Makership, so that nothing made can ever be as great as its Maker! Mighty is the ground of His Paternity, so that His Begotten can never at any time become the Begetter!
4. Of that hour there is yet another question for us to proceed to examine, since that former one hath been explained. And he that hath been induced by this gave thanks, and declared that our Redeemer also knew that hour! He as it were whispered to us as in secret, that it was strife that framed it, and spoke it, that it might prevail therewith. Strife hath pleaded guilty, and truth prevailed! questioning hath ceased, and the crown hath come to the Conqueror! † St E. here is evidently speaking of some one with whom he had had a controversy, and whom he had won back to the faith. Who it was, I am not able to discover. The two questions which he examines here are, (1) Whether Christ's apparent ignorance of the day of judgment is inconsistent with His glory viewed as relative to man, or (2) whether that ignorance is inconsistent with the same viewed as relative to God. The latter (if I mistake not) he means to dispatch by saying, that, as He is the Maker of all things, and of time among them, and so cannot be a creature, He must be taken to be teaching in the text in
question, that He derived His knowledge from the Father, and so is a distinct Person from the Father. The former he reserves for the next Rhythm, merely stating here that he had gotten his adversary to allow that our Redeemer also knew that hour. The words 'our Redeemer' are remarkable, as shewing that they had discussed, whether Christ (see R. lxxix. §. 1.) as such, i. e. considered as Man as well as God, knew that hour, and that St. E. had opposed the view held afterwards by the Agnoeter; at least it is very unlikely that he should use such an expression of the Son, considered as God. Comp. R lxxix. §. 6. A a 2
1. WHICH, my son, is the most glorious in the comparison, and which, again, is heaviest in the balance, that the Son knoweth not that hour or that He knoweth it? The Father who is great beyond comparison, He did declare; yet said that He knew not, and declared that He intended not to pry into, the hour, that by the hour He might hinder, yea, that the hour might rebuke thee, bold man, from prying into the Lord of all hours. To Thee be glory, Thou Son Christ, who knowest all things! 2. By thine own self know that He knoweth, since He has prevented and tied up thy knowledge: for thy free-will is a defiled handmaid, which, being in wine, spoileth exceedingly her Master's treasures. Chains He prepared for her, gyves also He made for her, hedges too, and they surrounded her, and walls, and they encompassed her; and if these preserved her not, from all this her madness is made known. He knew that the families and tongues, and that the Greeks, that are eager after hidden things, were to come to His discipline. For it was the net which collected those of every Man's chief good is God's rule in all He gives him. 357
sort. His leaven bridled and brought the wild asses to His doctrine, and in order that they might not be confused in their race, by one yoke of truth He taught them one race of concord. He gave not a place to the light-footed, that by himself he might run apart from others. He gave not him that pryeth a place, that he might be loosened from the yoke of the faith; [upon] clerks and unlearned men, the subtle and the simple, upon all of them the one yoke of equality was extended, even the yoke of His chariot, whereby the divided gain concord. 3. That we eat, and drink, and sleep, and rise, is of the free power of our will; the senses too possess free-will, in that they have power to do as they wish, yet not to do as much as they wish. Thus beneath the yoke of love which is put on them, [and] of truth wherewith they are encompassed, is it, that they neither go astray, nor lead astray, seeing they obey the will of their guide. If where free-will does not exist, it yet does exist, to wit, in the family of brutes, how much rather will it be found in its own abode, in man, who hath the motions of himself within his power, that is bounden by the truth, yet free in his actions, and by perversion can transgress against the things that are good; but if he slip from off the verge of truth, to error is he degraded.
4. One watcheth and [after] sleepeth, and when he sleepeth yet the reward of his watching is reserved for him; again, one fasteth and eateth in his season, yet his fast is not by any means lost to him by his eating. For food and fasting are both of them clean and fitting. Truth is single, yet error is the neighbour thereof; and if thou strayest ever so little R. xi. §. 3. 4. 358 Christ, who made all things, and all time among them, could possibly be concealed from His Finger which shaped all things? If then this was impossible, it escaped not His Foreknowledge, and He prepared a place for it that it might be established therein, and a time when from being secret it should become visible. When it was not found, yet was it p. 353, found by its Master, seeing it was kept in the treasury of ref. 3. His knowledge. And if it be hidden in the Root, it is not hidden in the Fruit which is in His Bosom.
1. INQUIRE and hearken discriminatingly that faith is a second soul; and as the body standeth by the soul, the life of the soul also hangeth on faith, and if it deny it or be divided, it becometh a corpse. That mortal body then dependeth upon the soul, and the soul is dependent upon faith, and faith also itself dependeth upon the Godhead; for from the Father Himself by the Son the Truth descendeth which quickeneth all of them in the Spirit. For by this Truth it is that man can link his soul with those above: by the soul he liveth, and by means of the body he seeth and heareth: by Faith and Love and Wisdom he is blended also with the Godhead, and hath His Image formed in him. Let us not then loosen this wondrous fabric, nor let the faith become void in our souls, lest we should become dead invisibly, whereof the Living One said, 'Let the dead bury their dead!' This air is a soul which without living breath quickeneth the body, and whoso ventureth to cut himself off from it, his life floweth away, and he is visibly a dead man; and whoso cutteth off himself from the Word of Truth, his soul is invisibly a corpse.
2. Ezech. 18, 23. 2. I have no pleasure at all in the death of him that dieth, witnessed the Living One who quickeneth all. As the Sea, is that True One which cannot be deceived, a Fountain of Life! He hath made known His Will and hath certified His Love, which thirsteth mightily to kill our death. The Scripture hath sealed unto us that the just in faith findeth life. He hath made the Truth as a glorious root, and works as fruits Comp. hath He hung upon faith, and suspendeth them on the branch R. xvi. of truth. By a visible type, lo! hidden things shew them-R. xiii. selves to thee as it were to the eyes; for the body longeth R. over the gains as a merchant, and let the mind too gather lxxvi. together its treasures as a sailor, into faith the ship of Life! R. xlix.
3. And as the body standeth by the life of the soul, the §. 3 R. soul too though full of life yet without works is not even §. 2. alive; for by the deeds of faith it is able to live, and the James2, Scriptures are witnesses. Lazarus the faithful answered and 26. came forth! and sweet was his savour through the voice of Him p.350,n. that called him: and after the type of Lazarus, the Gentiles were quickened with the hidden life; and as a type of the Jews did the thief die that hung himself, and left his ruin as an heritage to the Scribes that hired him.
Source. English translation by J. B. Morris, from Select Works of S. Ephrem the Syrian, translated out of the original Syriac, with notes and indices, by the Rev. J. B. Morris (Oxford: John Henry Parker; London: F. and J. Rivington, 1847; Library of the Fathers of the Holy Catholic Church 41); public domain. The text was read by machine (Mistral OCR) from a scan digitised by Google at the Internet Archive and has not been proofread against the printed book. SermonIndex has removed running heads and page numbers, joined words split across lines, and divided the text into chapters and short sections; the wording is the translator’s own. Footnotes and the editor’s introduction are left out. Morris’s preface and advertisement, his footnotes, the notes printed after some of the rhythms, the additions and corrections and the indexes are also left out; the short arguments that head each page are removed. No original-language text is shown beside it, and no modern English version has been made.
Licence. The translation was published in 1847 and is in the public domain.
Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.