22. Appendix B: The 28th Canon of Chalcedon
[REFERRING TO LEO'S LETTERS, see pp. 78 and 86.]
HISTORICAL REVIEW OF THE QUESTION REFERRED TO.
THE Bosphorus, as it begins to open into the Propontis, passes between Byzantium and Chalcedon. The former of these ancient cities had been selected by Constantine with admirable judgment as the site of his new capital; and on the occasion of its dedication (A.D. 330 or 334) an edict, engraved on a marble column, bestowed upon it the title of NEW ROME (Gibbon, Dec. and Fall, ch. 17). "The Emperor," says Sozomen, "created another senate, which he endowed with the same honours and privileges as that of Rome, and he sought to render the city which bore his name equal in every respect to that of Rome in Italy." (Bk. II. c. 3.)
Some fifty years afterwards this newly-built city, Constantinople, or New Rome, was selected as the rendezvous of the Second Œcumenical Council, and the 2nd Canon of this Council (the 3rd in the Greek copies) gave the second place of honour to its Bishop, "because it is New Rome."
This soon became a sore grievance to the Bishops of Rome: indeed Baronius says that a Council held at Rome in the very next year dealt with this matter; but the words he quotes are found in a Council 112 years later. However this may be, the subject was resumed at the Council of Chalcedon, and of what was done there in this matter we proceed to give an epitome :—
Flavian, Archbishop of Constantinople, and Domnus, Archbishop of Antioch, having been deposed at the Latrocinium of Ephesus, A.D. 449, Anatolius, a Deacon (who had been Apocrisiarius for Dioscorus at Constantinople), and Maximus were elected to the vacant thrones (Baronius, Labbé IV. 766); being consecrated apparently (as they had been elected) by Dioscorus and his coadjutors. Nevertheless, as they had professed the Catholic Faith, they were generally recognised, and sat in the Council of Chalcedon, which met in October, A.D. 451.
The composition of this Council is remarkable. An apprehension seems to have been entertained that scenes of violence, such as those which had disgraced the Latrocinium of Ephesus, might be renewed, unless the Synod were overawed by the Civil Power, which was accordingly represented by a deputation consisting of seven "most glorious Judges" and eleven members of "the most glorious and most ample Senate." The Synod met in the Great Church of the Martyr Euphemia: in the midst were placed the Holy Gospels: the Judges and Archons had a place of great honour assigned to them in front of the Altar, and took a very leading part in the Council all through. It should be observed, however, that though laymen, these Judges and Senators were all in full communion with the Church, and that they acted rather as moderators than as assessors of the Bishops. They did indeed suggest a very important amendment of the proposed Definition of the Faith (L. & C. IV. 1451), which amendment was adopted in the addition of the terms inconfuse, immutabiliter, inseparabiliter; and, at the request of the Bishops, they formed part of the Committee to which the recension of the Definition was entrusted before its final adoption by the Council (L. & C. IV. 1451); but they themselves acknowledged that the Decree had been made by the holy Fathers, in their presence.
But to return to the subject now before us. These Archons, as we have seen, sat in the midst before the Altar rails: the left was occupied by the three (or four) Representatives of Archbishop Leo, Anatolius, Bishop of Constantinople, Maximus of Antioch, Thalassius of Cæsarea (Cap.), Stephen of Ephesus, &c.; the right by Dioscorus (until he was ejected) and some others; and the body of the Church by the remaining Bishops, who numbered, it is said, 630 in all. (See L. & C. IV. 1938.)
The 27 Canons are referred to the 15th Action, held on the last day of October. Next day (the Kalends of November), the Synod being assembled as before, Paschasinus and Lucentius requested the Judge's permission to make a statement. They replied, Say what ye will. Yesterday, said they, after your highness left, and our humility followed, some things were done which we deem contrary to the Canons. We desire you therefore to command the proceedings to be read. The Judges thereupon gave the order desired. Actius, the Archdeacon of Constantinople, then observed that it was customary, after the chief business of the Synod had been transacted, to get other necessary matters arranged. We had, he said, some matters connected with the Church of Constantinople to be attended to, and we asked the Lord Bishops from Rome to take part in what was to be done. But they declined, saying they had no such instructions. We referred to your magnificence, and ye bade the Synod look into the matter. As ye were going, the Bishops here rose and desired the Action to be held. Nothing was done in secret: all was done in Canonical order.
The Judges then ordered the minutes to be read, and Actius gave the schedule to Beronicianus, Secretary of the Consistory, who read it. It was the document which forms what is known as the 28th Canon of the Council, referring to, and confirming, the privilege conferred on the Church of Constantinople by the 2nd Ecumenical Synod. "For the Fathers," says the Schedule, "rightly gave precedency to the Throne of the elder Rome, because it was the imperial city; and moved by the same consideration, the 150 Bishops most beloved of God gave equal precedency to the most holy Throne of New Rome, reasonably judging that the city honoured with Empire and Senate, and enjoying equal precedency with the older Imperial Rome, should be magnified, like her, in ecclesiastical matters also, being second after her; and that the Metropolitans alone of the Pontic, Asian, and Thracian dioceses, also the Bishops of the aforesaid dioceses which are among the barbarians, should be ordained by the aforesaid most holy Throne of the most holy Church of Constantinople, &c. This was subscribed by 184 Bishops, exclusive of many absentees, for whom others signed as proxies for them.
Lucentius suggested that these Bishops had been compelled to subscribe; whereupon they called out, "No one was compelled." After some further sparring, the Judges ordered each party to bring forward the Canons. Whereupon Paschasinus adduced the 6th Canon of the 318 Fathers, reciting it thus: "The Church of Rome hath always held the Primacy. Wherefore," &c. Constantine, a Secretary of the divine Consistory, read the same Canon from a Codex given him by Aetius the Archdeacon: "Let the ancient customs prevail," &c.; and "from the same Book," the first, second, and third Canons of the "2nd Synod."
Then the most Glorious Judges desired the Asian and Pontic Bishops who had subscribed to say whether they had done so voluntarily, or through any pressure. "Before God," said Diogenes of Cyzicus, "I subscribed voluntarily;" and similar answers, some by acclamation, and some at considerable length, were given by the others.
Upon these facts the most Glorious Judges then gave their decision that the Primacy and chief honour was, according to the Canons, preserved to the Archbishop of the Elder Rome, but that the Archbishop of Imperial Constantinople, New Rome, should enjoy "the same precedency," and, out of his authority, should have power to ordain the Metropolitans of the Asian, Pontic, and Thracian dioceses, after election "by the Clergy of each Metropolis, and by the holders of property, and the most illustrious men, as well as by all or most of the Bishops of the Province," &c. This, they say in conclusion, we have looked into: let the holy and Ecumenical Synod be pleased to shew what it thinks good. The Bishops cried out, This is a just sentence; this we all say: we all agree, let it hold good; and the like.
Lucentius said, "The Apostolic See ought not to be humiliated in our presence: wherefore we pray your Eminence to order the annulling of what was done yesterday against the Canons, when we were absent; but if not, our contradiction must lie against these minutes; but we must know what we ought to report to the Apostolic Man the Pope of the Universal Church, so that he may be able to give sentence concerning the injury done to his See, or the overthrow of the Canons.
John of Sebastia said, We all remain in the opinion of your Eminence. The most illustrious Judges said, The whole Synod has approved that we have spoken.
And so the Synod terminated. But the Western Empire was hasting to its decay, and the claims of the Roman Pontiff rose upon its ruins.
