Menu
‹ Chapter 88 of 366 ›

The Orphanage and the Electric Railway

6 min read · Chapter 88 of 366

NOW that judgment has been delivered by Mr. Justice Kekewich in this case, the friends of the Institution are anxious to know the extent of the injury inflicted, and what relief, if any, will follow the ruling of the Court.

The injury may be stated in the terms used by the expert instructed to examine the premises. Mr. H. Graham Harris says, in answer to the question of the Judge:—"In my judgment, the defendants' engines and machinery in their buildings, as they now exist, do occasion such noise and vibration as to interfere, to a very serious extent, with the ordinary comfort, physically, of any occupants there might be in Houses Nos. 1 and 2, and, probably, those of No. 3, of the plaintiffs' Orphanage; and this according to plain and sober and simple notions prevalent amongst the English people."

The following sentences are from Mr. Harris's detailed report of his visits:—"In all the rooms of the house, the noise and vibration are very great; indeed sufficient, in my judgment, to constitute a nuisance."

"The beat of the engine is most distinctly heard, and there is a vibration of the whole building at each stroke."

"Came to the conclusion that there was a very decided cause of complaint."

"There was vibration of the whole house, and the booming noise was very distinct indeed."

"The whole building appears to be in a state of vibration, responding to each stroke of the engine."

"The noise and vibration are very distinct indeed, and sufficient to constitute a thorough nuisance."

The Judge himself, having heard the evidence of the witnesses, and the report of Mr. Harris, said in the course of his judgment:—

"Notwithstanding all that had been done by the company, there remained the intolerable nuisance to persons dwelling in the plaintiffs' buildings, and his Lordship was afraid that, in spite of all the efforts to abate the nuisance, the diminution was not much."

"Part of the premises might still be used for some purposes; but with regard to another portion, they had been rendered, for ordinary purposes, uninhabitable."

Of the facts, stated upon such authority, there can be no question, and NINETY CHILDREN are thus deprived of the home which was provided for them, at a cost of nearly £4,000. For twelve months, these houses have been quite empty, and the children have been lodged in hired houses a little distance off. This arrangement is attended with considerable expense and inconvenience; the unity of the Institution is broken, and the discipline impaired.

The judgment is of so much importance that we give the main portions of it.

Mr. Justice Kekewich said the law was settled by various authorities that, when powers were given to a public body by statute, there was also given to it every subordinate or incidental power which could be reasonably required for the exercise of the main powers; also that, if you found, on

looking into the Act of Parliament conferring the powers, an intention on the part of the legislature that the powers should be exercised free from liability to damages or interference by injunction, that intention must be given effect to, notwithstanding consequent injury to private individuals. His Lordship had therefore to consider whether the defendant company's Acts of Parliament had, as a matter of fact, given the company power to do that which they said they were empowered to do, notwithstanding it created a nuisance; and if he found they had the power, and were creating a nuisance, he must further inquire whether they had done all that could be done to prevent a result which could not have been intended if it could be reasonably avoided. His Lordship then referred to and commented on the company's Acts, by which the company were empowered to work their railway by electric power, or by such other means, other than steam locomotives, as the Board of Trade might from time to time approve. If, said his Lordship, the company, in carrying out their statutory powers, did create a nuisance, that nuisance must be borne with; he would be departing from the reported authorities on the point if he decided otherwise. But there was a serious question beyond that. According to the authorities, the company were liable for omitting to do all that was to be reasonably required of them, if they caused a nuisance. His Lordship thought, upon the evidence, when the case first came on before him, that what the company were doing did create a nuisance, and that they had not done all that could be reasonably required of them to avoid it; and he accordingly directed an adjournment in order that the company might put themselves upon a sound footing, and Mr. Harris, to whom the case had been referred, had made a report. The result was that, notwithstanding all that had been done by the company before that report was made, there remained the intolerable nuisance to persons dwelling in the plaintiffs' buildings, and his Lordship was afraid that, in spite of all the efforts to abate the nuisance, the diminution was not much. His Lordship thought that they had done all that they could be required to do, and that they had done as much as they could to prevent this intolerable nuisance, though he was afraid not much had been done. Part of the premises might still be used for some purposes; but, with regard to another portion, they had been rendered, for ordinary purposes, uninhabitable. The company were wrong in June last, but they removed that wrong as far as they could. His Lordship thought, therefore, that they must pay all the costs of the action up to, say, the 31st of December last, by which time they had made their alterations; and they must also pay some damages, which his Lordship would assess at £50. As to the costs since the 31st of December, although the company had succeeded in point of law, his Lordship could not forget that when the action was commenced they were in the wrong. Accordingly, he could not give them any of those costs. The costs, however, of Mr. Harris's investigation and report, as it had been useful to both parties, would be divided between them.

It will be clear to our friends that this judgment does not give us ample compensation for the past, nor does it secure us any relief for the future. The amount of damages—viz., £50—is only given for the excess of nuisance over and above the nuisance which of necessity attends the working of the engines and machinery, after every reasonable provision had been made to reduce the nuisance to a minimum. It does not represent the damage actually done to the Institution; still, this is all the Court could allow.

Although the railway company must pay the costs of the action up to the end of December last, the taxed costs, as is well known, do not cover the outlay, and the Institution must bear the loss of the difference.

195

From the 1st of January till the hearing of the case on the 23rd of February, the parties to the suit must pay their own costs; and the expenses of the expert appointed by the Judge to examine and report must be divided between the plaintiffs and defendants.

We are not yet in a position to state the amount, but the loss and damage to the Institution are very considerable.

In the first place, two houses, to accommodate ninety children, are, according to the report of the expert, rendered uninhabitable.

2. A large schoolroom for eighty children has had to be abandoned.

3. The Institution is only awarded £50 damages, and this does not equal half-a-year's rent of the two houses we have hired.

4. The Institution must pay the difference between the law costs to 31st of December last and the taxed costs which are allowed by the Court.

5. The whole of the law costs on our side since the 1st of January must be borne by the Institution, and half the expense of the report of the expert.

The President and Managers fully hope that the friends of the Orphanage will approve the efforts that have been made to deliver the Orphanage from the nuisance with which it has been visited by the working of the engines of the Electric Railway, although the application to the Court failed to secure the relief sought. An appeal must be made for funds to meet the expense incurred, and to provide for the ninety children who have been deprived of shelter in the Institution. To reduce the number of inmates by ninety, is an alternative the President and Managers are assured their subscribers would not desire them to entertain. The present must be a time of waiting upon God in prayer, that a way out of the difficulty may be made clear to us, and that the friends who have stood by us in the past will not withdraw their sympathy and help in this hour of trial and of need.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate