The Religious Outlook in France — By Pastor George Samuel, Birmingham
WHEN I arrived in France, a few weeks ago, the first French newspaper I bought, on getting into the train at Calais, showed that the government was in extremis, the parliament in tumultuous uproar, and the Republic throbbing with fanatical excitement. It was further evident that this was no mere surface or partisan agitation, which would soon subside. Great constitutional questions were at stake; and the peace of Europe might even be broken by the issue of the crisis. Yet it was all brought about by what seems a most trifling incident.
A party of French pilgrims had gone on a pilgrimage to Rome. While mixing pleasure with devotion, by way of seeing the sights of the Eternal City, one pious pilgrim innocently wrote in the visitors' book, that lies near the tomb of Victor Emmanuel in the Pantheon, the simple words, Vice le Pope! When this was discovered, it was reported to the Italian government, and published in the Italian newspapers. It acted like a spark of fire dropped into a magazine of gunpowder. The Italian government treated it as a national affront, and the Roman populace was enraged. The Italian government complained to the French authorities, and would not be easily satisfied. The French government, knowing of the Triple Alliance, and remembering that, on a quarrel raised about the Pope, Italy might well reckon on the support of Germany, made the best reparation within its power. Instructions were issued to the Catholic bishops of France declaring that such pilgrimages must cease. The bishops were forbidden to organize them, and were required to discourage them. This soothed the wounded susceptibilities of the Italian government, and allayed the anger of the Roman populace; but it aroused the fanatical fury of the faithful in France, and brought upon the French government a cannonade of attack from the most diverse quarters. In the church, in the press, in the Senate and the Chamber of Deputies, by all sorts and conditions of politicians, it was violently assailed. One proud prelate, the Archbishop of Aix, hotly denounced the government in the interests of the church. He was promptly prosecuted, and heavily fined.
This spirited action on the part of the government by no means quelled the agitation. A question was put in the Senate which led to a debate, and a division. The same move was made in the larger and more popular Chamber of Deputies. Here two resolutions were moved, and prolonged debates, characterized by some disgraceful scenes, preceded the critical divisions. One of the resolutions raised the question of the conduct of the government, and the other the entire question of the connection of the Church and State. The government firmly stood on its defence, and as resolutely opposed the separation of the Church from the State. In the speech with which the premier wound up the debate, he laid it down that, by the connection of the Church with the State, the bishops were under the authority of the executive as much as the officers in the army and navy, and the chiefs
of the civil service; and that, in all matters affecting the State, they must obey the orders of the executive as promptly as the heads of other departments. He resisted the proposal to sever the Church from the State, as it would give the hierarchy a free hand, by which they might work mischief to the executive; and he held that the Church could not be permitted to hold property in the State, for, thus set free, and possessed of vast resources, it would be a standing menace to the Republic. Though confronted by the heterogeneous opposition of Clericals, Boulangists, Loyalists, and Ultra-Radical enemies of all religion, the government triumphed in both divisions.
The matter, however, did not end there. The agitation goes on in various quarters, and assumes various aspects. The heads of the hierarchy have issued a declaration to the Republic. Père Didon, one of the most eminent men in the French Catholic Church, has eloquently exhorted the clergy to abandon their sullen aloofness from all the affairs of state, and take part in political discussions and elections. Some extraordinary ecclesiastical measures have been laid on the table of the house, and the government seems resolutely determined to increase rather than relax its control over the entire affairs of the Church. So we may see strange things before long.*
Some may be puzzled to know why the simple words, Vive le Pape, written anywhere in Rome, should enrage a Roman Catholic populace, and give offence to the government of a Roman Catholic country; and why the French government should be so ready to conciliate them, and on what ground a Republican government should issue such peremptory instructions to the bishops. Here we must call in our history to help us.
Until the year 1870, the word Italy was a mere geographical expression. The Emperor of the French stationed troops at Rome to keep out the King of Italy, and to maintain the Pope as a temporal prince in the city of the seven hills. But when, in that year, he foolishly declared war against Prussia, he soon found that he wanted all his soldiers to fight his battles, so he had to leave the Pope to shift for himself. As soon as the French troops were withdrawn, Victor Emmanuel, without waiting to see the issue of the war, to make sure that he would not be ejected by a victorious French army, flushed with the glory of a triumph over the Prussians, entered the eternal city, and made it the capital of united Italy. By that stroke, he not only established his kingdom, but he destroyed, without discussion, diplomacy, or bloodshed, the temporal power of the Pope. He who previously claimed the City of Rome as his, and aspired to rule from it, not only the Catholic Church, but the nations of Christendom, was limited to the mastery of his official residence, in the same way that any other man is master of his own castle, cottage, or office. Then the occupant of "St Peter's chair" received a superabundant accession of meekness, and tried to excite the pity of the faithful by calling himself "the prisoner of the Vatican." It will easily be seen, then, that
*Since this article was written, the government has fallen; and although the issue was so obscured that the President demurred to receiving the resignation of the cabinet, this vexed ecclesiastical question was at the bottom of the ministerial defeat in the Chamber.
255
for a French pilgrim to write "Vive le Pape!" in the visitors' book in the Pantheon, close by the grave of that Italian king who wrested the city from the dominion of the Pope, may seem to Romans and Italians not such a simple and innocent proceeding as at first sight it appears to us. Thank God, when Victor Emmanuel, the king of United Italy, entered Rome with all the apparatus of government, James Wall, the Baptist missionary, entered, too, with the Bible in his hand; and from that day the religious liberty, which was so ruthlessly trampled upon by the "holy Catholic Church", has been freely accorded to the messengers of a free gospel in Rome itself, and throughout the whole of Italy.
When the French army was completely vanquished by the Germans, and the French Emperor sought the refuge of inglorious exile in England, the French nation still remained, and a Republic took the place of the Empire which had fallen amid such ignominy. The newly-organized Republic refused to be the oppressor for the Pope as the Empire had been. It left the Italians free to enjoy religious liberty in their own land, and it began an era of religious liberty in France itself; although it refrained from any fundamental change in the relations to the State of the Church.
From the days when the power of Pagan Rome was broken, and France became one of the nations of Europe, the Church of Rome has been closely connected with the French government. The dignitaries of the Church were often the advisers and even the performers of some of the foulest acts of oppression perpetrated under the régime of the most dissolute kings of France. When the nation rose, a hundred years ago, and threw off the oppressors' yoke, and overturned the throne, the Church and all forms of religion were voted down amid the tumult and upheaval of the Revolution.
But religion, even when grossly superstitious, is hard to kill; and when Napoleon the First had waded through rivers of blood to an imperial throne, he recognized the religious forces of the nation; and he had read enough of history to know that a Church allied to the throne becomes its most tractable supporter, even in acts of outrage on popular liberty; so he revived the union, but on his own terms. The Church was to receive the pay of the State, but the head of the State was to be master as well as paymaster; he was to appoint the bishops, and they were to hold their sees subject to him; the Church was to hold no property of her own, but the State was to hold it for her. These and all other arrangements were formulated in the famous Concordat.
This modus operandi still obtains, with the simple difference that the executive of the Republic stands in the place of the autocratic Emperor. Hence the recent action of the government, and the stand the premier took on the question of separation.
While, in England, we have only one state-endowed Church, lifting up its haughty head in baneful ascendancy over all others, calling itself the Church, and practically refusing Christian recognition to others, in France there are several state-supported Churches, and the Churches that refuse to accept State aid, and to submit to State control, are not frowned upon by richly-endowed neighbours, and suffer no disabilities or inequalities in the eyes of the law.
Les Eglises reconnues, or the state-recognized Churches, are chiefly the Roman Catholic, the French Reformed, the Lutheran, and the Jewish. Other forms of religion obtain subsidies in some forms; and I read, a short time ago, that a Mohammedan propaganda received State aid; but this would probably be in some dependency outside the Republic proper. Of the four established Churches mentioned, the Roman Catholic is out of all comparison the largest.
Out of a population of thirty-seven millions, there are only six hundred thousand Protestants shown in the returns. These figures cannot be taken as absolutely accurate; there are probably one hundred thousand more Protestants not returned as such. Those in the army do not require to declare their religion, and there may be many, in rural districts, who either do not avow their faith, or get left out of the reckoning. Before the war with Germany, the number of French Protestants was estimated to be a million and a half; but, at the end of the war, Alsace-Lorraine reverted to Germany. That district was largely Protestant; hence the drop in the figures shows no decrease of Protestantism. Then there is a large number of men in France who have renounced the Church of Rome, and have not become Protestants, but have sunk into infidelity. The custom is to belong to the Church, whatever life a man may lead; so there are crowds of utterly godless men and women who are still good Catholics; and it is computed that the Church of Rome can claim for her communion eighty per cent. of the French population.
The Protestant and Jewish Churches that receive State aid receive it on about the same terms as the Church of Rome. They are under State control in various ways. One important point is that the churches can only appoint their own ministers subject to the approval of the executive of the Republic.
Outside the Reformed and Lutheran Churches, there is the Protestant Free Church, declining all State patronage and control; and outside that Church again are to be found, in some parts, single Protestant Evangelical churches that judge it best to stand free from all denominations. There is generally some local or temporary explanation of such an attitude.
The difference between the free and the endowed Churches is obvious; the difference between the two endowed Protestant Churches is partly historical, but chiefly sacramental. The Lutherans cling tenaciously to consubstantiation; the Reformed Church holds to Calvin's view of the Lord's Supper. Wherever the Zwinglian view is held in any church, it is generally the accompaniment of Rationalism—a conjunction Zwingle never contemplated. The attitude of the Lutherans concerning the sacrament erects a barrier between them and their fellow Protestants, and otherwise works evil results. A Lutheran pastor will extort from his young people going out into life a most solemn promise, amounting to almost a vow, or an oath, that they will never take the communion with those who do not hold the real presence in the elements. Lutheran churches are few throughout France, and the young folk may find themselves located where there is no Lutheran church, though in every important town a Protestant church of some kind will probably be found; but the promise bars
257
communion. Then there is a struggle with conscience, and a shaking up of all religious opinions; and if the promise is kept, it is sometimes at the expense of the person's Protestantism, and sometimes to the complete loss of religious profession; and, in any case, it entails sore suffering of mind and probably injury to spiritual life.
Happily, there is now in France the utmost religious liberty. In past generations, it has been a land where the saints of God have been ruthlessly oppressed! Its fertile soil has been drenched by the blood of countless martyrs, and its fair skies have often been darkened by the smoke from the martyr's stake. Even within the memory of people still in middle life, confiscations, fines, and imprisonments were the reward of men who faithfully preached a free gospel to their fellow-countrymen. Now, there is almost as much religious liberty in France as there is in England or America.
With religious freedom, there is free education, from l'Ecole première right up to the universities. In many State schools there is no religious instruction. Protestants have a fair field, and they need ask no favour. Many are using their opportunity to good purpose, and so the truth is spreading. Conspicuous among evangelizing agencies is the McAll Mission. It began its work in Paris; but it has spread to the provinces. It is undenominational, and that is at once its strength and its weakness. It thereby secures more general financial support; but it is thus prevented from forming its converts into churches, and providing them with the ordinances and organizations necessary for the maintenance of their outward Christian life. The constitution of the Mission provides only for evangelistic work, and scarcely admits of distinctly Protestant teaching, even for the converts. This defect sometimes causes a serious leakage of the habitués of the Mission. There comes to them, sooner or later, a time of testing, such as marriage, the death of a relation, or some festival of the Church, which in some way touches the every-day life of the people. If the convert has not grasped the principles of Protestantism, he is apt to slide into conformity with the practice of the Catholic Church. This gives the priest his opportunity of enticing the convert back into Romanism. It may be difficult for the missionaries to avert this danger. They may fairly say that they have not come to lecture on Protestantism, but to preach the gospel; and that they could not expound and enforce Protestant doctrine, even to their converts, without appearing to attack the Church of Rome; and that might evoke annoyances and hostilities from the priests that would cripple their evangelistic operations. I am informed that, though the Mission keeps itself aloof from the Protestant churches, its attitude towards them is very friendly, and that such of its converts as wish for church-fellowship and Christian ordinances, are passed on to Protestant evangelical pastors in the neighbourhoods where the converts reside.
There are several other evangelizing agencies at work in France. Some of them have borne noble witness for the truth in times of darkness, and amid bitter persecution. The "Baptist Forward Movement", under the leadership of M. Saillens, one of the Associates of the Pastors' College Evangelical Association, received a kindly notice and a cordial commendation in the pages of this Magazine only a few months ago.
