Menu
‹ Chapter 67 of 342 ›

Dr. Jeter's Memory, and the Effect of using Manuscript in the Pulpit

8 min read · Chapter 67 of 342

SOME men need to read their sermons, and have learned to do so with effect. In many cases, however, the necessity for crutches has grown out of the habit of using them, and might with advantage have been prevented by allowing the memory to run alone from the very first. Dr. Hatcher, in the biography of his friend Jeter, affords us an instance of how an able man contributed to his own disablement by using a written sermon when he might have done without it. Notes had better be brief; for the memory loves to be trusted, and will sweetly recompense the trust reposed in it.

Dr. Jeter's case is an extreme one, doubtless; but sometimes a truth may be all the better seen when a glaring instance is set before the mind. Young speakers should begin flying with their own wings, even if they incur an occasional fall. If they try the ballooning of copious notes, and passages which need reading, they will find the making of the gas a great trouble, and they may soar so high that the coming down may be fatal.

The volume,* from which we borrow, is a loving tribute to a friend. It is very candid, and hence instructive; but we are unable to share in the very high estimate of its hero which love has placed upon him. This, at the present moment, is not our point: we quote for the sake of advising young preachers.

"It was Dr. Jeter's custom to write his sermons, either in full or in part, and for many years he usually had his manuscript before him. That it was wise for him to write his sermons can hardly be questioned; but I think that it was a great mistake that he ever became accustomed to the use of notes in the pulpit. This remark is not born of prejudice on my part against sermon-reading, or other mechanical aids to the memory; though I must say, in simple truth, that my enthusiasm has never gone wild in favour of manuscript-preachers. Some men can handle a manuscript with tact, and can use it without losing that glowing passion which is the highest charm of an orator.

"But this was not the case with Dr. Jeter. When he used the manuscript, he used it, and made no attempt to disguise the fact from his audience. And when he used notes, he spread them out before the public eye, referring to them in a sober and self-respecting way. He did not imitate those preachers who attempt to use their manuscripts clandestinely, as if they were doing a dastardly thing, and were afraid they would be taken in the act.

"His way was far better, and yet it did not suit him to use a manuscript. It put a weight upon him. Being very tall and not quick-eyed, he often had to bend and scan the paper in order to find the place. He could not rattle smoothly along in the discussion of one part of his subject while searching among his notes for his next point.

"He usually paused, in the strain of his remarks, and gave himself

* Life of J. B. Jeter, D.D. By Wm. E. Hatcher. Wharton and Co., Baltimore.

127

to the one point of finding what was next to be said. When confined to his manuscript, he was always enfeebled in his delivery. Elocutionists may read, but orators speak. Dr. Jeter was too much of an orator to prosper in the rôle of a declaimer. He never did his best, except when untrammelled by notes.

"I have said that the use of mechanical helps in the pulpit was a mistake in his case. It was worse than a mistake; it was a positive injury. His memory, in point of vigour and retentiveness, was extraordinary, and his mind moved upon a logical track. For men who are florid in style, fond of making poetic quotations, and without methodical arrangement in their sermons, a manuscript is a necessity. But Dr. Jeter's sermons were structures. They were closely concatenated lines of thought. They grew out of the text, and were put together with the skill of a master. His divisions were simple and orderly, each suggesting that which was to follow. Such sermons can be committed and recalled without difficulty. Almost any attentive and sympathetic auditor, after listening to Dr. Jeter, could easily reproduce the points of his sermon in their order. My conviction is very decided, therefore, that he ought never to have entangled himself with manuscripts or notes. This he came finally to realize, and in his later life he made a desperate effort to break from the bondage of his habit.

"But it was then too late. He refused to trust his memory in the days of its strength, and it never forgave him for the wrong. It grew fitful, coquettish and cranky. Spoiled by being unduly helped in its task, it became capricious and balky. At times, it would perform its duty with admirable fidelity, and then again it would refuse to budge. Such was the penalty which he had to pay for sinning against his memory. It is worth while for young preachers to bear in mind that a memory generously cultivated and firmly trusted, is capable of almost indefinite improvement and service.

"I believe that this is the explanation of those painful hitches which sometimes befell him in his attempts to preach. He may have had other mental crotchets; but his tricky memory was his weakest point. It rendered him uneasy, timid and self-conscious. He was like a king going into battle under the dread suspicion that his chief general was a traitor, and might turn against him at the critical moment.

"There were times when his memory got sulky in advance, so that it was impossible for him to call up an old sermon when he wished to use it. Here is a case in point:

"Dr. Jeter had a sermon he called his 'Eel-Sermon.' It was quite famous in its day. He was often solicited to repeat it. On some public occasion, at one of the large gatherings in the country, he was solicited to preach this sermon. He went out into the woods and walked to and fro for nearly an hour, attempting to recall the discussion and prepare himself properly to preach it. All his efforts were without avail. After wrestling with his topic for some time, he finally gave it up as hopeless that day. On his return, he was asked if he would preach that sermon. 'No! no!' he replied, 'the slippery thing gets away from me. I must try something else.' He did try something else, and preached with his usual power. The slipperiness with which he charged his sermon ought to be put to the account of his memory. That was famous for its slips.

"It was pitiable to look at him when he fell a victim to the trickiness of his memory. It gave him a cowed and helpless mien, which was distressing to behold. He was preaching on 'Moses' Invitation to Hobab.' After giving the context, he approached the discussion; but he was evidently out of sorts. He moved heavily, and presently came to a dead halt. Slowly reaching his hand around into his coat pocket behind him, he drew out a little black book, and said in a deeply lugubrious tone, 'I find my memory is treacherous this morning, and I will have to use my notes.' He spread them before him, but the bad behaviour of his memory had thrown a pall over the entire household of his faculties. They would not work. He was utterly devoid of enlarging power. He crept timidly along the line of his notes, and, as they were brief, he speedily reached the end. When he took his seat, he looked as gloomy and crestfallen as if he had just been condemned to be shot. At his request I followed in an exhortation, and closed the meeting, feeling unusually solemn and tender. As I did not know what to say to him, I concluded to slip out of the pulpit in silence. As I was leaving, he caught me, and, drawing me back, said, 'My heart feels like a vacuum, and my head like a pumpkin.'

"It sometimes happened that his memory would trip him at the moment of his highest exhilaration, and when he was in the midst of his boldest flights. He was preaching one Sunday morning on 'The Dignity of the Christian Life.' At one point he compared the glory of the Christian with the distinctions of earth, and showed its superiority. He was in the preaching humour, and was towering in his passionate eloquence. Rising to the climax, and with his voice at the highest pitch, he exclaimed: 'I would rather be a Christian than to have the wealth of the Rothschilds; I would rather be a Christian than to be the President of these United States; I would rather be a Christian than to wear the crown of England; I would rather be a Christian (here he was very high) than to—than to be (here he began to shake and fall) rather be a Christian, I say—than—than to be—than, I say, to be Julius Caesar!' Why he lugged in the tyrannical Julius at this point I never knew. He may have thought that he would meet the exigencies of the case, inasmuch as the imperial Cæsar is reputed to be useful in 'stopping a crack to keep the wind away.' I suspected that he brought in the bloodthirsty old Roman in a spirit of vexation, and as a curt way of expressing contempt for himself.

"In the winter of 1859 I went to Grace Street Church one Sunday night to hear him preach. His audience was not large, but he seemed to be in excellent trim for preaching. His text was, 'Strive to enter in at the strait gate: for many, I say unto you, shall seek to enter in, and shall not be able.' When he came to that part of the text about not being able to enter in, he showed that our entering in at the gate depended, among other things, upon the time we sought to enter. He said there was a time for entering, and if we allowed that to pass, we ought not to hope that we could afterwards enter. Then he began to illustrate. 'If you are sick,' said he, 'and the physician prescribes a remedy to be taken at a certain time, and you fail to take it until the time is past, you ought not to complain if it does not cure you. If you do not sow in seed-time, you must not expect to reap in harvest. Much

129

less, if in seed-time you sow your ground in weeds, ought you to hope to reap wheat when the harvest-day comes.

"When I was a boy I read a story of Goodman Hodge, an unbalanced and shiftless swain. Goodman fallowed his fields, and made them ready for the seed. When the day for sowing came, he went forth and sowed his fields broadcast with—(here he was swinging his long arm around in imitation of the sower)—sowed his fields broadcast—(another pause, and still swinging his arm)—sowed his fields, I say broadcast with—(here he took in his arm, came to a dead halt, drew his hand over his face, and then, with a downcast look, slowly scratched his head). Well really, brethren, I have forgotten what it was—I know it well; for it grows very extensively here in Virginia, and has a large bloom; but, after all, it does not matter—it was a noxious weed. He sowed his ground with the seed of a noxious weed. (This seemed to right him up, and he started out anew.) When the time for harvest came, Goodman Hodge called in his servants, put his reapers in order, and went forth expecting to reap a harvest. But when he came in sight of his fields, instead of waving with the ripened wheat, they were all abloom with thistles—ah, that's the vegetable; that's the vegetable! He found his field filled with thistles. 'Whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap.'"

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate