Menu
‹ Chapter 293 of 342 ›

Hatred of Calvinism

2 min read · Chapter 293 of 342

THERE is something phenomenal in the reception which its opponents have given to the Calvinistic type of theology. Not in its extremes and its eccentricities alone, but in its moderate and balanced forms, men have heaped upon it abuse and obloquy. No other modern confession of faith has been debated with such virulent and venomous dissent. It is one of the rarest achievements of theological candour, if its opponent gives a statement of it which its believer can accept as his own. Philosophic thinkers lose their balance in assaulting it. Good men fall from grace in disproving it. The more "liberal" unbelievers are, the more intolerant is their reasoning, and the more vitriolic is their animosity. This is emphatically true of that class of men of letters in whose culture literature takes precedence of religion.

One of the pet ideas of Mr. Emerson is "the malignant mythology of Calvinism." Such is his modest caricature of a system of beliefs which has for centuries commanded the faith of a larger proportion of the cultivated mind of Christendom than any rival. It has been the favourite belief of the more thoughtful confessors of Christianity from the beginning. Men of independent enquiry, of well-poised minds, and of profound religious nature, have inclined to one or another form of it in larger numbers than those commanded by any other theological structure. The literature of the last three hundred years contains more of elaborate discussions in its defence than is to be found in that of all other compends of Christian doctrine combined. In substance, it is the spinal cord of the most illustrious of historic creeds. It is the soul of many of the most precious products of Christian hymnology. Men have argued it, and sung it with equal force of conviction. Sanguinary battles have been fought for it, as the most potentially of civil and religious liberty. Historians of the latest and most brilliant type of civilization laud it as a tributary to all that is most valuable in civilized society. Yet, in the face of all this, we are called upon to believe that Calvinism, in any form of it, is a mythology! The old Greek cultus is treated by many literary men with more decent respect.

The Calvinistic way of thinking in theology has commanded the loyalty of Christian womanhood, in its most refined and cultivated representatives, and these in larger numbers than can be claimed for any other symbol of religious faith now extant. Devout woman has trusted it, loved it, sung it, suffered and died for it, in multitudes incalculable. Yet, despite all this, grave and learned and reverend critics would have us believe that it is a "malignant mythology"!—From "My Note-Book." Fragmentary Studies in Theology, and Subjects Adjacent Thereto. By Austin Phelps, D.D., LL.D. (T. Fisher Unwin.) See Reviews.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate