"The Larger Hope." — An Appeal. By Rev. J. Idrisyn Jones

WE know not of any surer method in these days by which a writer or a preacher can become unpopular than by denouncing the above theory. Nevertheless, we venture to take our stand once more on the side of the older theology, and to make an appeal on its behalf. The doctrine of "universal restoration" is spreading at a rate which must exceed the most sanguine hopes of its apostles. Is it not partly due to the fact that there is almost absolute silence on the question, on our side, both in the pulpit and the press? Our opponents consider that the pulpit, at least, has almost surrendered to them. Is there not, then, an urgent necessity for crying aloud, in order to warn them, and to save others who are wavering? We need not use harsh words towards those whom we oppose, knowing that, however mistaken they may be, they are sincere in their opinions. The view we wish to combat has come to our land in these modern times, through the sluices of German Rationalism, and has been championed by men small and great in the ecclesiastical and literary realms.
It is not our purpose, on this occasion, to argue with opponents, but to appeal to friends, and to base that appeal on three considerations.
(1) The larger hope is a species of infidelity: by this we mean, that it involves the rejection of some parts of the Bible. The rejection of the entire Bible is infidelity made complete; therefore, the rejection of the Bible in part, is infidelity in part. Very startling is the language used by some: thus, the Rev. Mr. Collyer, of America, says, when speaking of the Bible, "I would shut up the Book, and never open it again, rather than be compelled to acquiesce in the one hideous monstrosity of an eternal hell." John Foster, Olshausen, Theodore Parker, and Sir J. Stephen have each admitted that the Bible language is strong on the other side; yet they would not abandon the theory. In this manner infidelity is streaming into our churches; and it is the same spirit which engulfed the world in the days of Noah. Not one of the advocates of the larger hope accepts the teaching of Christ in those words: "And these shall go away into everlasting punishment." Shall we, then, hold our peace at such a time as this?
(2) Heaven may be shown to come to an end by the method of interpretation used in support of the larger hope. Every passage of Scripture relating to man's future doom, in which the words "for ever", "everlasting", and "eternal" are used, are construed in the sense of a temporary duration; therefore, the same terms, when used in relation to future bliss, must be interpreted in a similar sense. If the exegesis is right in the one case, it must be also in the other. The Bible, then, teaches two co-ordinate doctrines: hell comes to an end; heaven comes to an end; or, heaven is without end; hell is without end. These stand or fall together: for example, in the two following passages, one in either Testament, quoting the Revised Version: "And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt" (Dan. xii. 2). "And these shall go away into eternal punishment: but the righteous into
eternal life" (Matt. xxv. 46). The period of duration in each case must correspond, or language is no longer reliable as the medium of thought. We challenge the world to prove the contrary. If, then, it is insisted that the reference to doom in each passage is to one of limited duration, the reference to future glory in each passage must also be taken in the sense of limited duration. So heaven is to come to an end: its sweet songs of music; its glorious service; its sublime adorations; its fond friendships; its entrancing scenes shall, alas, cease to be ours! What then? Whither shall our fate lead us? No heaven at last. Oh, it is too terrible to contemplate! Ah, but heaven shall be for ever! and the same Bible that tells us so, in the same manner tells us that hell shall also be for ever.
(3) The theory of the larger hope imperils the salvation of the soul. There are divergent opinions in the churches where the point of difference does not affect one's final destiny. Thus, it will be conceded, that Arminians and Calvinists are equally salvable persons; but we venture to think that the theory of the larger hope will be fatal to many. Man is swayed by two opposite motives; the gospel, therefore, appeals to both; to his hope, by the promise of a supreme reward; and to his fear, by the threat of a supreme penalty. Man, therefore, must be won by the combination of the two. To minimize or omit the appeal to his fear is to take out of the case one of the great factors of his salvation, and to lame the gospel in its great struggle to win the sinner. If in any case man is sure of a future heaven, will he not be in great danger of hardening himself in sin and worldliness? It is significant that Origen, in the third century, who believed in Universal Restoration, thought it prudent not to mention it in his discourses to the multitude. The battle with the sinner is, under any circumstances, not easy to win. "Ye will not come to me, that ye might have life", said Christ; but how much less likely is the victory, if we teach men that, however guilty and polluted they may be when they cross the "dark river", that afterwards, sooner or later, Heaven's Gate shall be wide opened to let them in?
Should we, then, remain silent and neutral? Shall we do nothing to stem this current of fatal theology? We venture to suggest that there are three things which we might do. (1) Issue a popular Tract, and scatter it broadcast under the auspices of a special organization. It is by means of the press, in the shape of the religious newspaper, and pamphlet, and sermon, and treatise, that error is so rapidly spreading; why should we not use similar methods? (2) Convene a conference of those who still adhere to the old truths, and thus seek to strengthen each other, as well as inspire a bolder treatment of the question in the pulpit and elsewhere. (3) Pray more earnestly for a great revival of religion in the land. Such heresies can only flourish when the churches are cold and worldly. But old truths come to the front again when a baptism of the Spirit melts the hearts of believers, and leads sinners to cry, "Men and brethren, what must we do to be saved?" Then, the "Eclipse of Faith" is past, and the doctrines which have blessed and energized the church in all her brightest epochs will shine in unimpaired lustre.
Let it not be thought that we aim at mere controversy. But, as it is fashionable in these times to proclaim a criminal truce between all
317
wrangling creeds, and thus give Satan the advantage, we must remember that we are divinely summoned to "contend for the faith once delivered to the saints"; and woe be to us if we come not up to the help of the Lord against the mighty! We must come quickly; for the seeds of error are taking root; and our Lord and Master bids us be up and doing.
Crouch Hill, London.
