Elihu; an Example to Young Men
(Job xxxii.—xxxvii.)
BY JAMES L. STANLEY.
THERE is perhaps nothing which so quickly and so completely reveals a man as his words. "Thy speech bewrayeth thee," said the maid to Peter; and in so saying she illustrated a common principle of judgment. What is in generally comes out; if not at once, yet in the course of time; and we know the good or evil which lies in the heart. "A good man, out of the good treasure of the heart, bringeth forth good things; and an evil man, out of the evil treasure of the heart, bringeth forth evil things." And what is not in, cannot come out; and so we know the wisdom or ignorance, the depth or shallowness, of the man. "Out of the abundance of the heart, the mouth speaketh."
It is by his speech that we must know Elihu; for we have no other means of knowing him. His discourse, and a few attendant circumstances, make up the whole material available for forming an estimate of his character. The address is left to speak for itself; and this it does emphatically.
The conduct of Elihu, indicated in his opening remarks, recalls the words of Psalm xxxix.: "I said, I will take heed to my ways, that I sin not with my tongue: I will keep my mouth with a bridle . . . I was dumb with silence, I held my peace, even from good. . . . My heart was hot within me, while I was musing the fire burned: then spake I with my tongue."
The introductory sentences of Elihu's speech are in full accord with the Psalmist's language, and reveal the first striking characteristic of his utterances, viz., Modesty. Can anything exceed the charming simplicity of these words—"Then Elihu answered, and said, I am young, and ye are very old; wherefore I was afraid, and durst not show you mine opinion." I said, "Days should speak, and multitude of years should teach wisdom." Here are a becoming reserve, a wholesome diffidence, a suitable deference to the opinions of others; characteristics which would adorn persons of any age, but which are eminently appropriate in youth. Elihu acted in the spirit of Solomon's words, "A wise man will hear, and will increase learning." With him, there was not only a "time to speak," but a "time to keep silence." All through the long speeches of Job's other friends, Elihu remained a patient listener, and if he did not learn by their wisdom, he learned by their folly. It is of immense importance to ourselves, and to others, to know when to keep silence. Bishop Butler says: "The wise man observes that there is a time to speak, and a time to keep silence. One meets with people in the world who seem never to have made the last of these observations; and yet these great talkers do not at all speak from their having anything to say, as every sentence shows, but only from their inclination to be talking; their conversation is merely an exercise of the tongue, no other human faculty has any share in it. . . . Is it possible that it should never come into people's thoughts to suspect whether or no it is to their advantage to show so very much of themselves? Oh, that ye would altogether hold your peace, and it should be your wisdom! . . . But one would think that it would
439
be obvious to every one that, when they are in company with their superiors of any kind, whether in years, knowledge, or experience; when proper and useful subjects are discoursed in which they cannot bear a profitable part—that these are times for silence, when they should learn to hear, and be attentive, at least in their turn." That quaint and holy poet, George Herbert, says:—
"If thou be master-gunner, spend not all
That thou canst speak, at once, but husband it,
And give men turns of speech: do not forestall
By lavishness thine own, and others' wit
As if thou mad'st thy will. A civil guest
Will no more talk all, than eat all the feast."
Silence at times is courteous; for it has respect to the claims of others. It is modest; for it indicates a moderate estimate of one's own powers. It is wise; for it increases our means of gaining knowledge by attending to the wisdom of others.
Elihu's conduct also exhibits Veneration for Age. "I am young, and ye are very old," says Elihu. Therefore he paused, as he says it is said of him, "because they were elder than he." This regard for age is not a mere sentiment; but a healthy moral instinct, based upon the relations of inferior and superior. Elihu himself explains, "I said, Days should speak, and multitude of years should teach wisdom." But it may be argued, Elihu's experience did not confirm his expectation. He had to say, "Great men are not always wise: neither do the aged understand judgment." Then, we say, all the more honour to Elihu that he gave them credit for wisdom, and did not judge them unfavourably until he had proved them at fault. To honour old age is not only to obey a natural instinct, but to submit to the Word of God. "Thou shalt rise up before the hoary head, and honour the face of the old man." (Lev. xix. 32.) Multitude of days gives a natural advantage to their possessor. The mental powers, by exercise and cultivation, become matured; and a long experience furnishes ample material to guide the judgment. True it is that old age does not always realize this ideal; and hoar hairs are not always combined with those high moral qualities which command respect; nevertheless, the general obligation is not thereby cancelled. We must be guided by the rule, and not by the exception. To say the least, it is probable that, in the majority of cases, the old man will prove the abler counsellor, and the young man will lose nothing by recognizing and acting upon that probability. There was a king once, as Old Testament history shows, who "forsook the counsel of the old men," and soon after he had done so his subjects forsook him. Yet we would by no means imply that wisdom only resides beneath the snows of age; for the histories of Daniel and Joseph show that it dwells in those who still possess the dew of youth.
Elihu's conduct also exhibits a beautiful and exemplary Self-restraint. His self-restraint would have been most commendable had Job's friends been other than they were, and he had listened quietly to the teachings of wisdom. But there was an element in their utterances which, to a mind like his, must have proved a sore test of patience. They were all wrong in their conclusions, and Elihu saw it; he could see their
mistakes as they went on, and yet he held his peace. His self-restraint was wise in two ways. He heard all they had to say, before he came to a final conclusion. Then he appears to have indulged the hope that they would say something to the point: "Behold, I waited for your words; I gave ear to your reasons, whilst ye searched out what to say." It was just to hear all; it was kind to hope for something good. It is well to feel the stirrings of indignation, enthusiasm, sympathy, affection, and the like; but it is also well to have these emotions under the control of reason, and the fear of God. Self-control in any direction is no easy matter, and there is plenty in Scripture and experience to show that one of its most difficult tasks is with the tongue. But Elihu succeeded well under the circumstances of strong temptation in which he was placed; so may we. Let us try.
But, let it be observed, there was a limit to this restraint. He spoke at last, and here we see his Courage. There was nothing sullen or morose about the silence of Elihu. He did not belong to that
"sort of men, whose visages
Do cream and mantle like a standing pond;
And do a wilful stillness entertain.
That therefore only are reputed wise
For saying nothing."
Nor was there aught of servility, or meanness, or idolatry of men about him. It is true Elihu says, "I was afraid;" but that did not mean that he was afraid of men. When the proper time came, he was prepared to utter his opinion, although that opinion was totally opposed to the elders to whom he had listened. Elihu had clear convictions, and he had the courage to avow them; he had formed a judgment, and he feared not to express it. In his conduct we see a just balance of behaviour. There is not, on the one hand, the insolence of conceit and forwardness; nor on the other hand is there the obsequiousness of a slavish spirit. He knows how to treat men with respect; and he knows how to maintain a due respect for himself. There was true courage in Elihu's conduct. Some can only express dissent under the influence of strong passionate feeling; but this is much the same as for a man to nerve himself for some disagreeable work by the use of stimulants. In both cases there would be excited feeling impelling the will, and in all probability the will would be in a mischievous condition. He is truly courageous who, taking a calm view of all circumstances, and fairly estimating consequences, deliberately resolves to speak the truth. Elihu was no trimmer. Not only did he refuse to suppress his convictions; but he did not shape them in order to please anybody. "The fear of man bringeth a snare"; and one snare consists in the temptation to cut, and pare, and tone down truth to curry favour with others. It becomes us always to be temperate in language, and no right-minded person would be reckless of the feelings of others; yet, at the same time, we should never shrink from avowing what we believe to be right.
So far, we trust, we have shown that Elihu is a pattern to young men. Imitate him.
