Aérated Rationalism
DR. JOHN KER, in his admirable "History of Preaching," gives a
description of Karl Schwarz, which might, perhaps, be applicable
to some preachers even in this country. "Schwarz is the exponent of
The Newest Theology, a kind of manifesto of his party, and his sermons
have already passed through several editions. He is a man of sharp
intellect, ready and eloquent of utterance, while a breeze of imagination
fills the sails of his speech, and makes up for the want of real warmth
and light. His principle is, that a preacher must translate the spirit of
Christ into the wants and feelings of his time, by which he means the
adaptation, not of language, but of the substance of Christian doctrines.
He would take the ideas of sin and atonement, the death, resurrection,
and ascension of Christ, and, having stripped them of what he calls their
mythical dress, he would apply them to the human nature of our day.
Thus, for the Holy Spirit, he substitutes 'the higher reason of Chris-
tianity'; for the sinful heart 'the laxity of modern life'; for regeneration,
'the beginning of nobler impulses'; instead of Christ's ascension, we have
'the elevation of humanity'; instead of personal immortality, we have
'corporate immortality.' The old words are very often so skilfully used
that the superficial hearer thinks he is getting the Bible, and it is only the
hungry heart which feels the want of living bread. There is, at the
same time, a constant repetition of scorn for traditionalism and Phari-
saism, with a claim to superior enlightenment and culture. But it is
simply the old rationalism aerated—Hegel in the pulpit instead of Wolf;
and when it stands awhile, or comes from an unskilful imitator, it is as
dead as such teaching was in the middle of the last century."
