THE OLD AND NEW CONNEXIONS OF GENERAL BAPTISTS — By The Writer Of The First "Down-Grade" Paper
THERE is good reason for believing that the earliest British Christians practised baptism as enjoined by Christ and administered by the apostles. The community of Christian believers—miscalled monks—who had established themselves at Bangor Is y coed (Bangor in the Trees), in Flintshire, practised baptism after the same model.* In England, though the doctrine of "Believers' Baptism" was held and taught by some of the Reformers, the practice seems not to have been revived until early in the sixteenth century, when refugees from the Continent settled in Kent, and a few other places. Though these were, in some respects, the immediate progenitors of the early English General Baptists, in others the General Baptist body must be viewed as a separate organization, and as having had a separate origin. For our present purpose we will take a view of the early English General Baptists as they were in 1660, when the body published a Confession of Faith; and then sketch important movements in the body which led up to the formation of the New Connexion, in 1770.
At the former date the churches of this denomination throughout the country, with a few exceptions, were evangelically sound. They held very strongly, and made a great point of, General Redemption, but in most other points they differed little from moderate Calvinists, and, indeed, would be thought quite strong Calvinists at the present day. The great doctrines relating to sin and salvation were their constant themes in preaching; they laid low the sinner, and exalted the Saviour in his Person and work; and they insisted on repentance and faith as prerequisites to baptism and Christian fellowship. The ministers were, with scarcely an exception, unlearned men, knowing little of Homer and Virgil, but they were close students of the Bible, especially of the Gospels and Epistles. They laboured with a zeal and earnestness which befitted their great vocation; and, if there have been any successors of the apostles, as apostles, these men were among them, albeit no episcopal hands had been imposed upon their heads. They had what is infinitely better, anywhere and at any time—the fire of redeeming love kindled on the altar of their hearts by him "who touched Isaiah's hallowed lips." Perhaps the most prominent man among them was Thomas Grantham. At the age of seventeen he, with three others, left an Independent church, and was baptized on a profession of faith. This was in 1651, and it was the beginning of the General Baptist interest in Lincolnshire. The Confession of Faith, above alluded to, was drawn up by him. On the doctrines of the Trinity, the Deity, Incarnation, and Atoning Death of Christ, the Personality and work of the Holy Spirit—and, indeed,
* Llys-bedydd, or Llynisbedith (court of baptism) is the ancient name for the parish (in Shropshire), now called Bettisfield. Some fields on the side of Hanmer Pool are called Holy Crofts; and it is supposed the (so-called) monks of Bangor, or St. Chad, baptized their converts in this pool. See "Philip Henry's Diaries."
9
on most of the points he touched—there was strict conformity with Scripture. On Election, and kindred doctrines, it may be enough to say that he was nearer Baxter than Calvin. This "Confession" was hastily drawn up, as it was required to be presented to Charles II., on the restoration of monarchy, and was thought to be deficient in several points. In 1678, therefore, the General Baptists of Bucks, Beds, Herts, and Oxon, drew up a larger document, consisting of fifty articles, and denominated it, "Orthodox Creed," &c. It was signed by fifty-four messengers and elders. What Mr. Grantham simply asserted, this later document sought to explain; but it involved metaphysical distinctions, which the common people could not well understand. So far as it differed from the "Confession" of 1660, it verged nearer to Calvinism.
In 1691, the General Baptists of Somersetshire and the neighbouring counties published a "Confession of Faith," in twenty-seven chapters. This differed little from that of 1660, but it was not at all commonly known other than in the Western and Southern counties.
If our space would allow it, many proofs could be brought to show that the body of the General Baptists, at this time, were evangelically sound on all important points, including the inspiration and absolute authority of the Holy Scriptures in all matters of faith and practice. Here and there, as in the neighbourhood of Staplehurst, in Kent, there were spots of theological leprosy to be seen; but the body generally was sound.
Thomas Grantham had among his Lincolnshire adherents a strenuous advocate of gospel truth in Joseph Hooke. A clergyman had asserted that the General Baptists held that Christ is not the true God. Mr. Hooke replied to him: "Whoever did or do hold that Christ is not the true God," says he, "I believe it is a pernicious doctrine, contrary to God's word, and destructive to the Christian faith." After citing many Scripture texts in proof of his position, he adds, "He is God, co-essential and co-eternal with the Father. For, most certainly, he that made all things, visible and invisible, was not himself made; and, as he is man, he did not create all things. And yet, that he is man is as true as that he is God. He is David's Lord and David's Son; David's Root, and David's Offspring: Immanuel, God with us: God veiled in the flesh. That Christ is a Person having in him the nature of God, and the nature of man, is clearly revealed; but how these two natures are joined in personal union, remains a mystery." A mystery they found it, and such it will ever be, and by no metaphysical researches can it be solved; but
"Where reason fails, with all her powers,
There faith prevails, and love adores."
On the subject of the future state of the righteous and the wicked, the General Baptists were sometimes charged with a departure from the plain teachings of Scripture. A few of them held the opinion that the souls of believers sleep until the resurrection, but this sentiment was not generally entertained; and, as for the heresy of annihilation, or the kindred heresies of future probation and ultimate restoration, no trace of them is to be found among them at that period. As to the preachers generally, though, as in other times, a few were unfaithful
123
and immoral, their souls were too fully aflame with the love of Christ to dabble in vain speculations or give the people the husks of human conceits instead of the Bread of heaven. All too soon this was changed, as we shall presently see. Now, however, there was a soul-hunger awakened among the people, and a cry for "Bread, bread!" Spiritual awakenings have ever brought out this cry, to be followed by-and-by with the song of satisfaction and joy. And even in our own day, it is bread the people want, and neither husks nor chaff will satisfy them. When the famine pressed sorely on the Egyptians of old, the people cried to Pharaoh for bread. They had a land of matchless fertility, but no bread. They had gold and silver, and precious stones, and raiment and ornaments in abundance, but no bread; they had temples of unrivalled magnificence, monuments of art and skill which are even now the wonder of the world, but the people were dying for bread. "Bread, bread! Give us bread!" was their cry. Joseph did a grander thing for the people when he fed them in their starvation, and built for himself a more lasting fame, than if he had founded a hundred royal dynasties, and erected a thousand glorious temples. The man who feeds the hungry souls of dying men with the Bread of Life, and wakens the perishing to their needs, does a grander and nobler thing than if he could outvie Angelo in painting and Handel in music. But what shall be said of him who withholds the Bread, and starves the people with husks of man's opinions dished up after his own fancy?
But these brethren were not only sound in their theology, they were judicious in their proceedings generally, and careful and exact in matters relating to Christian living and Christian fellowship. For a long time, and in some places to a remarkable degree, brotherly love prevailed. Walking in the fear of God, and in the comfort of the Holy Ghost, churches were multiplied, and believers added to the Lord yet more and more.
But, alas! the fine gold became dim, the silver mingled with dross, and the wine mixed with water. There was a defection of doctrinal soundness, and with it a decay of practical godliness. Whether the former produced the latter, or the latter the former, it would now be difficult to ascertain; but there they were, working and co-working, the sickness affecting the appetite, and the want of sound diet aggravating the sickness.
As early as 1677 there was considerable difference of opinion among the members of the church meeting at Spilshill, Staplehurst, which had flourished under the ministry of Mr. Kingsworth. He died in that year, and his removal gave opportunity for the more open propagation of erroneous sentiments. Sad to say, also, two out of the five sons of Mr. Kingsworth, who became preachers, went so far in error that they headed a division which assembled at Biddenden and Frittenden, and afterwards at Headcorn. At Headcorn there is a struggling remnant still, but at the other places the church has long been extinct. The Staplehurst church is represented by a small cause at Smarden, and where the old General Baptist church met at Staplehurst a congregation of very Calvinistic Baptists now assembles.
The leaven of heresy worked in relation to the Trinity. The record of the old church-book, which I remember to have seen many years ago,
states :—" After the decease of the aforesaid Richard Kingsworth, there appeared a difference in their apprehensions concerning the doctrine of the ever-blessed Trinity, and, after many debates which arose on this head, they brought it to this conclusion : that, forasmuch as there was a division in the eldership and ministers on both sides, they, for peace sake, granted a quiet dismissal to their brethren who differed from them on this point."
The church at Spilshill continued sound. In 1706 there were more than two hundred members, but after this it declined, and became extinct, the Smarden portion continuing to the present time. This church, though sometimes troubled with Unitarianism, remained sound, and is, I believe, the only one of all the General Baptist churches in that part of Kent which has survived that terrible "down-grade" catastrophe.
The Western and Southern churches have, with a few exceptions, either become Socinian, or have died out. In some cases, as in Northamptonshire, the Baptist element in the population has gone on the up-grade, and has founded many churches of the Particular Baptist order. This has been the case, to some extent, in Essex.
About the middle of the seventeenth century there was a strong General Baptist church at Horsham, in Sussex, the pastor of which was Mr. Matthew Caffin, who laboured in that and neighbouring counties, with equal zeal and success. He was so celebrated for the defence of the truth that he was cried up by the people, says Mr. Taylor, as "their battle-axe and weapon of war." Mr. Caffin endured serious persecution for the gospel's sake. Five times he was committed to prison, once being to Newgate, where he narrowly escaped death by that sickness which was fatal to so many of his fellow-prisoners. But after these sufferings and labours for the truth, sad to say, he departed from the "simplicity that is in Christ." For half a century he had been looked up to as the champion of his party, and his influence was deep and far-reaching. His seems to have been a case of beginning in the spirit and seeking to be made perfect in the flesh. He puzzled himself with the deep mysteries of the faith, bringing them to the bar of reason, and foolishly rejecting those things he could not understand, though he saw them to be plainly revealed in the Word of God.
Before we enter further on this subject, it will be needful to state that the General Baptist body at that time did not consist of separate and independent churches; there was a good measure of Presbyterianism in the form of their church polity. This was not confined to the General branch of the Baptist body, for the same thing prevailed in connection with the church at Bedford, over which John Bunyan presided; but it was characteristic of the Generals everywhere. Almost every single church was scattered over a wide area, and its members met at different places for worship. Churches in different localities were grouped into Associations, and the Associations in their united capacity formed the Assembly.
Mr. Caffin began to vent his new opinions more privately at first, as they had reference to the Person of Christ—his Deity, the sinlessness of his human nature, and so forth. He divulged his speculations to a Mr. Wright, pastor of a church at Maidstone. Mr. Wright, perceiving the destructive tendencies of these sentiments, and, no doubt, having traced
125
their effects, thought it only right to prefer a charge of heresy against Mr. Caffin at the Assembly, and to demand his expulsion from the Assembly, and from the fellowship of the churches. Mr. Caffin made so plausible a defence, that the Assembly fully acquitted him, and censured Mr. Wright for his want of charity. Mr. Wright, in conjunction with another minister, returned to the charge at the next Assembly, held at Aylesbury. There he failed again to arouse the brethren to the importance of his charges and to the gravity of the situation. The Assembly resolved, "To maintain amity and friendship with Mr. Caffin, though he might differ a little in some abstruse unrevealed speculations."
Mr. Wright, finding his efforts unavailing, withdrew from their Assembly, protesting against its proceedings; and though he lived and laboured to about the end of the century—sixteen or seventeen years—he took no further public action in the matter.
But the matter did not rest. Mr. Caffin took courage to spread his opinions more openly, and the leprosy spread. In the Assembly of 1692 he avowed his sentiments with considerable freedom. His words were taken down, and the charge of denying the divinity and humanity of Christ were again preferred against him. The clearest evidence was before the Assembly, but the majority voted that "he was not guilty of the matters charged against him." And yet, with a strange inconsistency, as though to preserve their own credit for orthodoxy, they resolved, "that the opinions ascribed to Mr. Caffin were heresies." Protests followed, signed by some of those who were still sound; but the Assembly, as if ashamed of its double dealing, adjourned for three years. At its meeting in 1696, the protesters insisted on Mr. Caffin being brought to trial, but the majority held to their former decision. The protesters then withdrew from the Assembly, and shortly after formed what they called the General Association. Want of space prevents our giving the names of the honoured brethren who thus bore witness to the truth, and of the churches they represented, but the church in Berkhampstead is the only one now existing. They addressed a long letter to those churches which they considered to be sound, stating the reasons of their separation from the General Assembly. They concluded this address with these words: "Therefore, beloved brethren, hearken to the call of God—'Come out from among them, and be ye separate, saith the Lord, and touch not the unclean thing; and I will receive you.' For it is impossible to have communion with men who are thus guilty of heresy, blasphemy, and idolatry, but you must needs be defiled. In vain is it for you to separate from such as err about the subjects and manner of baptism, if, at the same time, you maintain communion with heretics and idolaters, as those must needs be who deny the Deity of the Son of God."
As the case became known, there were more seceders. Subsequently, there were overtures for peace, and, after a time, some sort of transient reconciliation was effected; but the wound was never healed. The Assembly, like the Association formed of the seceders, avowed faith in the Godhead of Christ, and yet strangely resisted the zealous efforts of the defenders of that doctrine against those who either questioned or denied it. The mischief arose, largely, from the wide-spread sympathy with Mr. Caffin, on account of his former labours and successes; and
certainly all this ought to have been considered, and due respect paid to his age; but the claims of Christ, of the gospel, and of the souls of perishing sinners, are of paramount consideration, and even Gabriel himself ought not to be tolerated for a moment in the preaching of "another gospel."
But while the cause of the Redeemer was declining in some parts, it was prospering in others. This was notably the case in the Midland counties, in Lincolnshire, and in Yorkshire. In all these districts evangelical doctrine was the one theme of the preachers. "Jesus Christ, and him crucified," was their one testimony. Many triumphs of grace were won, and the "Word of the Lord had free course" in many parts. The simplicity, fervour, self-denying zeal, and evangelical earnestness of many of the preachers, were above all praise, and serve as an example that might be copied to advantage. True, there were persecutions without, and occasionally disorders within, but, in the main, prosperity and blessing attended the labours of God's servants, and the efforts of his people.
One of the foremost figures in the northern district was the celebrated Dan Taylor. Born in 1738, he preached his first sermon in a dwelling-house at Hipperholme, near Halifax, 1761. Efforts were made to induce him to join the Wesleyan Methodists, but he was not satisfied with some of their tenets, and, with four others, left their company, and commenced an interest at Wadsworth. For many years, both before and after the formation of the New Connexion, he was a leading spirit in all the proceedings of the body, and he bore himself well under the trials which came upon him.
The leaven of heresy was still at work, east, west, and south. In the west, the churches had, for the most part, gone on the "Down-Grade." In Kent and Sussex it was the same to some extent; and also in Lincolnshire. In Lincolnshire especially was the defection visible. The churches in this Association had been conspicuous for those principles which formed the banner of the Early English General Baptists—the divinity of Christ, his atoning death, justification by faith alone, and regeneration by the Holy Spirit. But now, in the sixth decade of the eighteenth century, many of the churches and ministers either denied them entirely, or so explained them, that they were shorn of their dignity, glory, and attractiveness. Sad to say, the older members and ministers were the most prominent in heterodoxy, as if the apostle's order was reversed; for instead of the inner man being renewed as the outer man perished, decay without was more than equalled by decay within.
The grave divergence of sentiment produced discussion, and besides the unhappy altercations, there was fostered in very many a spirit of sceptical inquisitiveness—prying into things that have not been revealed, and controverting those essential verities of the gospel which simple faith receives without questioning.
In the midst of these contentions, Mr. Dan Taylor made the acquaintance of some of the Midland churches, and finding them one with him in the faith of the gospel, he sought a closer union with them. The Lincolnshire Association also sought to draw them over to their side, and sent their messenger, Mr. Gilbert Boyce, of Coningsby, to promote
127
this object. The Leicestershire friends steadily refused to have any connexion with persons holding the sentiments some of them were reputed as holding. They went so far as to express a very decided opinion that all who cherished faith in the doctrines of Christianity ought to separate from such. This was in 1769. This opinion grew into a conviction, and the conviction took strong hold of many of the orthodox in all parts. About Michaelmas the same year, a meeting was held at Lincoln, when separation was resolved on, and that a New Connexion should be formed of such as held fast the old faith. The meeting took place, as had been arranged, in London, 7th June, 1770.
Before this meeting, however, strenuous efforts were made to prevent the separation. Mr. Boyce laboured and argued with a zeal and a courtesy worthy of a better cause. He urged all possible considerations to prevent disunion; but he seems to have lost sight of the interests of truth in the superabundance of his charity. He plainly admitted in a letter written so late as 17th May, 1769, that there was a difference of opinion between them on a point so vital as the Deity of the Son of God. It was impossible that there could be any real spiritual union when one party built their faith on a human Christ, and the other on a Christ "who is God over all, blessed for ever."
The meeting of the New Connexion took place in Church Lane, Whitechapel. The following brethren attended and took part in its formation:—Samuel Deacon, Boston; John Tarratt and Nathaniel Pickering, of Kegworth; John Grimley, of Loughborough; William Smith and George Hickling, of Longford; Francis Smith and Thomas Perkins, of Melbourn; Dan Taylor, of Wadsworth; William Thompson, of Boston; John Brittain and William Summers, of London; John Knott, of Eythorne; James Fenn, of Deal; John Stanger, of Bessell's Green; David Wilkin, of Halstead; Charles Parman, of Castle Headingham; and R. French, of Coggeshall. The designation of the new body explains its objects, which were "to revive experimental religion or Primitive Christianity in faith and practice." They agreed to "Articles of Religion," which embodied the evangelical faith, which all the ministers signed. Other churches and ministers joined them afterward, and the new increased and the old decreased. At the present day the old body is almost extinct, for the churches which clung to their vain speculations gradually died out, or became Socinian. Very many of the old churches which joined the New Connexion remain to this day, and some of them are strong. Others became more Calvinistic, and were absorbed in, or changed to, Particular Baptist churches, which have become fruitful in their respective neighbourhoods.
This very meagre sketch may suffice to show that truth must not be sacrificed at the shrine of charity; that in matters concerning the faith once delivered to the saints there must be no compromise; that "speaking the truth in love," we should "hold fast the faithful word"; and that separation from such as connive at fundamental error, or withhold the "Bread of life" from perishing souls, is not schism, but only what truth, and conscience, and God require of all who would be found faithful.
