"Are these Things so?" or, the "New" Theology — By The Writer Of The First Of The "Down-Grade" Papers

IT seems rather late in the day now to talk about "New" Theology. The term seems to imply that a further revelation made of divine truth has been granted in these latter days; that when God spake unto us by his Son, the revelation was not complete, and that when the Divine Saviour, without whose teaching we can know nothing aright, committed to the apostles the "ministry of reconciliation," with the command to proclaim it to every creature, there were some important omissions. We earnestly ask, "Are these things so?" And we at once reply, "No; by no means." These things cannot be so, for the simple reason that a dreadful curse rests upon all who shall add unto the words which are written in the sacred Scriptures. The passage of divine truth to which reference is made, is so solemn, and so much to the point, that it will be well to quote it in full. The risen and reigning Christ, the faithful and true Witness, declares, "For I testify unto every man that heareth the words of the prophecy of this book, If any man shall add unto these things, God shall add unto him the plagues that are written in this book: and if any man shall take away from the words of the book of this prophecy, God shall take away his part out of the book of life, and out of the holy city, and from the things which are written in this book." (Revelation xxii. 18, 19.)
These words plainly prove that the revelation which God has made in these last days by his Son is complete and final, and that he will add nothing to it, and take nothing from it. It also proves that for any man to add to, or take away from, the testimony recorded in the Holy Scriptures, is not only an act of daring presumption, but also a terrible sin, involving eternal loss of all that is good. Now, if we do not say that the so-called "New" Theology does this, we must and do say that it does something which approaches frightfully near to it. The words we have quoted should be sufficient to deter any man, however bold in his speculations, from assuming that he, forsooth, has discovered a better gospel than "the gospel of our salvation," as committed to the apostles, and by them made known in the name of Jesus.
The apostle Paul tells us whence his gospel came, and how he received it: "I certify you, brethren," says he, "that the gospel which is preached of me is not after man. For I neither received it of man, neither was I taught it, but by the revelation of Jesus Christ." This gospel which he so received, and taught, so every way suited to meet the necessities and woes of humanity, he held as a sacred trust. He describes it as "the glorious gospel of the blessed God," and as "the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth," and as so revealing the only way of deliverance from "the wrath to come" that any other message of salvation delivered in God's name is no gospel at all, and the abettors of it are declared accursed. (Galatians i. 9.)
This, then, is the position truth compels us to take with regard to the boasted "New" Theology.
But is it new? Is it not rather the hashing-up of old falsehood; an old heresy revived? Peter Martyr combated and overthrew the theory of a probation after death three centuries and a half back, in his lectures
63
on the First Epistle to the Corinthians in the University of Oxford. This theory has, or at least appears to have, a very close resemblance to the Romish doctrine of Purgatory. In a Common Place upon the doctrine of Purgatory, Peter Martyr draws a distinction between two classes who uphold that doctrine—those who regard it as a necessary article of belief, and those who advance it merely as a theory or speculation. This last is the position taken by many of the adherents of the "New" or "Progressive" Theology.
The above distinguished theologian absolutely denies that the doctrine of a future probation can be drawn from Scripture. He also warns those who hold the doctrine merely as a theory, that it is sheer foolishness, which leads men to uphold things which they do not know to be for the glory of God, and which cannot be clearly drawn from Holy Scripture.
At the end of his arguments against those who theorize upon the subject of Purgatory, he writes:—"But if the speculations of men are to be indulged in, perchance some men will be found who will set up, instead of Purgatory, what I may call an Eruditorium, in which the souls of unbelievers who have never heard of Christ in this life, or of rustics, or of infants, who have never been taught, may learn salvation, and find an opportunity for believing. Forsooth, some one will consider it to be barbarous that either the ignorant should be eternally condemned, or, on the other hand, that those who have not been adorned with the knowledge of God should be introduced into heaven. And, so fruitful of errors will they be, they will be able to concoct many other things of this kind."
Peter Martyr was a man of sound and critical judgment. While still in the Church of Rome, admired for his vast theological learning, one of the most brilliant preachers, and possessing a store of patristic and scholastic theology beyond all his contemporaries, possessing also a clear understanding of the teaching of Rome, and of the results of Romish theories, as soon as he had diligently studied the Bible, he protested against the doctrine of Purgatory and all theories allied thereto. When he had openly departed from Rome and joined the Protestants, he denounced in still more forcible terms the theory of probation after death, classing it in the same category with the dogma of Purgatory, which, he said, had "neither built up the church nor stimulated holy living, and therefore had been unadvisedly invented."
This ancient invention we are now asked to receive as the truth of God, though to receive it means practically to ignore—not to say deny—the teaching of Holy Scripture and the "glorious gospel of the blessed God"—"the faith once delivered to the saints." Instead, then, of "New" Theology, the thing so much vaunted is no other than an old book republished in modern style. Cheap jewellery may be all very well for those who have a taste for such gewgaws, but it is rather too much to ask us to give up our precious stones for the paste, and glass, and tinsel of modern manufacture. The old wine of the kingdom we know to be good; it has cheered and strengthened myriads, as it has cheered and strengthened our own spirits; and, therefore, when the new mixture is offered us, we have only one answer—"No, thank you, gentlemen; we would much rather not, 'for the old is better.'"
The question has been raised—and it is both pertinent and proper—
How far has this "New" Theology been received by the present ministry of the Baptist denomination? That is a question which time alone can adequately answer. That it has been received, and that it is taught to some extent, there seems to be only too much reason to believe. There is one comfort, however, and that should be a consideration of great weight—the heads of our colleges, so far as the writer knows their views—and he knows all the gentlemen to some extent—are personally sound and free from the modern bias of thought. How far their method of teaching theology is adapted to educate young men in sound views concerning divine truth may be open to question. There may be an excess of toleration in some cases, and too little emphasis given in others to the distinctive doctrines of the gospel. Books, however, have been the more powerful agents in the inculcation of erroneous sentiments, and works embodying the so-called "new views" have done much mischief to men whose faith has been rickety, and whose knowledge and experience of divine things have been shallow.
The crisis is, undoubtedly, a serious one, and there is room for grave concern, and much need for earnest prayer and diligent effort; but there is no reason for complete dismay. Streams sometimes get polluted, but the access of fresh water clears them after no great length of time. The worst of fevers may be stamped out, and the most terrible of fires quenched. The highest tide comes to an ebb. All this has been proved over and over again; in England, Germany, Holland, and elsewhere.
The followers of Arminius went beyond their leader in the direction of Pelagianism when he had been taken from them. The Remonstrants against the decisions of the Synod of Dort became more and more estranged from the sound doctrines of the Reformed, until Arminius himself would have been ashamed of them, and renounced them for their great advance in the direction of Socinian heresy. In like manner the city of Calvin became honeycombed with neological doctrine, and a rationalism as deadly as death itself. But God sent a Robert Haldane to Geneva. He raised up a Cæsar Malan, a D'Aubigné, a Professor Gaussen, and others, and the truth lifted itself up once more, and shed its healing, sunny light around. So, in Holland, there have been revivals of the evangelical faith; and a movement is now on foot which is full of good promise, many churches and people shaking off the shackles of State direction and control, and claiming and using that freedom which Christ gives to all who hold fast to him. The pendulum swings both ways; and, whereas in fundamental error there are ever the seeds of death and decay, so in the truths of the everlasting gospel there are life and light, and a divine force, which has resurrectionized men, and churches, and people again and again, and shall yet prevail over all error and evil, as the vitality of spring triumphs over the death of winter, as seen in every garden and hedge-row, and in every floweret and meadow.
Let us, then, be of good cheer; for "more are they that be with us than they that be with them." The darkness, and all that belongs to darkness, shall die and disappear, and the light of life shall triumph, to earth's lasting good, heaven's boundless praise, and God's eternal glory.
But what should be our posture and policy during the darkening of the horizon with the thick cloud of error? There are three courses suggested. One is to accept the new doctrines as the veritable faith of
65
Christ. That is impossible. That were to deny the Lord who bought us, and to tread the crown of his mediatorial glory in the dust. With one voice and heart we say, "That cannot be; no, never, never." Another course is to ignore them, or, in other words, tolerate them; treating those who hold and teach them as brethren still, and closing our lips concerning their departure from the faith of the gospel. This would be in effect to allow these creeds and daring speculations to be possibly true; to be unfaithful to the sacred trust of the glorious gospel; to be parties to, or quiet spectators of, the re-crucifixion of our glorious Lord and Saviour; and to become partakers of the condemnation of those who destroy and scatter the sheep of God's heritage, giving to the hungry husks instead of wheat, and stones instead of bread. A passage from The New York Observer is pertinent on this point:—
"To permit these new doctrines as to the incarnation having saved all men, as to death not being a finality, as to this life being for but a small portion of humanity the determining influence of the life to come, to permit these ideas, and many others equally revolutionary, to take their place in our schools and pulpits, is simply to surrender the citadel of evangelical religion. Our churches may indeed continue to have a majority of ministers who believe the Old Theology, and preach the old gospel, but they will also have—and sooner than they expect—a multitude of men who despise it, and who will glory in their liberty to treat it with scorn and contempt. This has never worked but one way. It has worked in this way in the home of John Calvin, until his city became the grave of everything that resembled faith, piety, and evangelical religion. One after another of the plainest doctrines of Scripture were thrown overboard, like the children in the sleigh pursued by wolves, but the family was not saved. Before a refuge could be reached, the wolves had captured, not only the travellers, but horses, vehicle, and all. There is an evangelical church at Geneva, renowned for its ability and devotion, but it is no part of the original church, for that has long since ceased to be in any respect evangelical, and in ceasing to be evangelical it has ceased to be a spiritual power."
No; we must do as Paul did when Peter dissimulated. We must withstand them to the face. Peter's dissimulation affected chiefly the liberty of the gospel, and Paul so acted; but here it is not only the liberty of the gospel, but the gospel itself that is threatened, ignored, denied. No doubt the advocates of the "New" Theology will disapprove of such a course; they will cry "Charity, sirs, charity." They do practically say, "Let us be friends; we will tolerate you, and you should tolerate us." This sounds very prettily, but it is unreasonable, and more than that, it is unscriptural and unapostolic. Men who have entered our houses for the purpose of carrying away our most precious things might just as well claim toleration, and ask us to be friends with them. No, sirs; it cannot be. We believe in charity in just the same proportion as we believe in truth, but we will not give up one for the other. The centripetal and centrifugal forces being equally balanced according to the unchanging law of the Creator and Governor of the universe, the earth and other planetary bodies hold on their true course; and in like manner truth and charity, by their mutual co-operation, keep us on the lines marked out for us by him who is truth as well as
5
love. Referring again to the article from which we have already quoted, the writer says:—
"This New Theology, with its insidious attacks on the faith of the church, in regard to the consequences of sin, the issues of life and death for all mankind, the nature of eternity, &c., strikes at the evangelical view of those very matters of faith which are vital and fundamental. Its advocates say, while we present this New Theology as a modern improvement, suitable to the temper of the times, we nevertheless baptize it 'progressive orthodoxy'; we want to have your family name the same as ours, and to be welcomed as a brother; we want our new tune to be put in your hymn-book as a mere variation of the old gospel music; we want you to feel that our trumpet makes no discord with yours; we can tolerate your ideas of death and judgment, sin and need, loss and ruin, and all we ask is, that you tolerate ours; we are all believers in God, and Christ, and righteousness, and we can even use your scriptural and theological and other religious terms in a sense of our own, that produces much apparent harmony, and prevents the unlearned from realizing that there is much difference after all."
As there is more organization among the Congregational churches of America than in those of this country, there is little doubt but that the question will be taken up there as a denominational one;* but it will hardly be so dealt with in this country, and the heresy will go on to spread its baleful and deadly influence until God interposes to call back the devastating tide. But those who hold the truth—the faith as delivered to the saints—must contend for it, and do so with all the earnestness which the momentous issues at stake involve. We cannot act in the spirit of a certain vicar, who shall be nameless, who, in advertising for a curate said, "Views, if any, must be moderate." Our adversaries may and will be diligent in filling the ministerial bushel with chaff, let us be equally earnest and diligent in filling it with wheat. "The Word of God and prayer" must be our refuge, our armoury, our resource at all times. Truth is eternal; it is mighty through God, and must prevail. "For all flesh is as grass, and all the glory of man as the flower of grass. The grass withereth, and the flower thereof falleth away: but the word of the Lord endureth for ever. And this is the word which by the gospel is preached unto you." (1 Peter i. 24, 25.)
* The Convention at Springfield, held recently, has confirmed the hope of those who love the true faith of Christ, by declaring, in an emphatic manner, against the Andover speculations. The Rev. R. S. Storrs, D.D., LL.D., was elected to, and has since accepted, the presidency of the American Board of Congregational Foreign Missions. He has spoken out on the subject. He is in sympathy with the action of the Board, who will not send out, as a missionary, any man who is not clear in his evangelical belief. In his letter of acceptance—among many powerful and important utterances—he says:—
"This Society exists for a purpose, wide as the world, solemn as the cross, connected with eternal issues. It is always responsible to the Lord of the gospel for what its messengers proclaim in his name. And it should, as I think, expect these messengers to stand on a higher level of conviction—higher and steadier—than may be occasionally occupied at home by scattered churches, or individual teachers, who are not yet excluded from the general communion."
Dr. R. Stoddard, of The New York Observer, has sent enquiries to all the Congregational pastors in New England. He reports on 501 replies, a vast majority of which are from men who hold fast the gospel. Some few—five per cent. or thereabouts—avow their sympathy with the "New" Theology, and some few wriggle and twist like an eel on a hook, after the usual manner of go-betweens. The leaven of false doctrine is in the churches and in the pulpits, but the great majority are avowedly sound and true. There is reason for thankfulness; but still those who love truth and value souls must be "jealous for the Lord of hosts."
