Menu
‹ Chapter 256 of 288 ›

The Apotheosis of Humanity

11 min read · Chapter 256 of 288

"YE shall be as gods," said the father of lies to our first parents, and the lie has never quite been repudiated. In some way or other the deification of man has been sought. We find the idea imbedded in the mythologies of Greece and Rome, which represent their gods as simply deified men; and the later practice of these people in deifying their deceased rulers, and sometimes even their living ones, was an outgrowth of the same idea. Every such apotheosis was, in effect, an attempt to express as a truth the devil's lie.

Alas! the truth is that, in the attempt to become a god, man fell from the lofty position in which God had placed him; and a yielding to Satan means an ever-increasing degradation; while it is only by renouncing the devil's lie and accepting the truth of God, that fallen man can be raised to a position of glory and honour.

The tendency of the present-day theological speculations is, in some way or other, to exalt human nature. Of course, we have in our midst full-blown Positivism boldly proclaiming that the only Deity is Humanity, and going through the strange farce of holding public worship; singing hymns in praise of humanity; preaching sermons, the subject of which is humanity, and offering prayers to humanity. The whole thing seems utterly ridiculous, and yet there are men, reputed wise in this world, who are foolish enough to take part in such meaningless mummery.

It seems to me, however, that what is known as "advanced thought" is closely akin to Positivism, though the relation may not be openly avowed or even suspected. If the various articles of the modern creed be examined, it will be found that they all converge to this point, which may be called the Apotheosis of Humanity. A creed the moderns undoubtedly have, albeit it may not be formulated as fully and clearly as the orthodox creed. We may best view these articles in connection with the leading truths of the Evangelical faith of which they are usually the negation, whatever else they may also be.

Notice, first, the Inspiration of the Scriptures. We do not ignore the fact that among the orthodox different views have been held as to the precise nature and extent of inspiration; but, in general, Evangelical Christians have firmly believed in the absolute authority of the Word, as the Word of God. Theories about the how of inspiration are one thing, the fact of inspiration is another. We unhesitatingly believe that fact in its fullest extent. Undeterred by sneers about "plenary" and "verbal," we believe that "All scripture is given by inspiration of God"; that its words are the words "which the Holy Ghost teacheth"; and that its letters may well be called "sacred."

The modern school begin by degrading the Scriptures from their lofty place. They exalt unduly the human element in the sacred Book. Inspiration is toned down till it is almost unrecognizable. It becomes possible to pick and choose among its doctrines and precepts. The authority of the book as a whole, is subverted. Human reason, refined taste, religious sensibility, must decide what portions possess authority; and so, practically, the supremacy of reason is substituted for the sufficiency of Revelation. Religious teachers dare to sneer at the "idolatry of the Bible," and bracket the idea of an infallible Book with the dogma of an

infallible church and an infallible Pope. The theological history of the past twenty years clearly shows that this humanitarian doctrine about the Word is the root of most other errors. Be it ours to hold fast "the faithful word"; to prefer the verities of Scripture to the vagaries of science; and bow to the authority of Revelation, rather than to the audacity of reason.

We glance next at the Divino Fatherhood. The glorious truth of the Fatherhood of God, as fully revealed by Christ, has ever been dear to the Christian church, nor can it ever be lost sight of while we continue to pray "Our Father!" The Christian doctrine of God's Fatherhood runs not upon the lines of nature, but of grace. It implies a re-creation, a new birth in the case of those who are enabled to recognize God as Father. The new school, however, will have it that God is the Father of all men in the same sense. At first sight, it seems to exalt God by making much of his love; but what it actually does is to exalt man. What a noble creature he is! Is he not a son of God? It ignores or minimizes the fact of man's fall and consequent sinfulness. Instead of the depravity, it talks of the dignity of human nature; vice is an accidental weakness instead of an intrinsic evil. I have heard a Christian minister say that we must tell men "that they are the children of God, not of the devil; that they are from above, not from beneath; that the hardest man has more affinity for godliness than for sin." Is not this the blankest contradiction to the statements of the Incarnate Truth? "Ye are from beneath," "Ye are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father it is your will to do." If God is equally the Father of all men, why is it that only when we believe we receive the "Spirit of adoption, whereby we cry, Abba, Father"? If children by nature, why are Christians told that they "are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus"? In opposition to the vapourings of modern thought concerning human virtue, we must declare to men the verdict of Jehovah: "all together filthy," "gone out of the way," "none that doeth good, no not one," "enemies by wicked works." Yet, withal, sonship is possible, but to attain it "Ye must be born again."

This brings us to the new theory of Regeneration. It is not surprising that, in the creed of those who believe in universal Fatherhood, evolution should take the place of Regeneration; and that, instead of the grand doctrine of the implantation of divine life in the soul, we should hear of the development of human goodness. Of course, if men are children of God already, the new birth is a superfluity; they are, at worst, but wayward children, who require to be told their duty. The culture of the intellect comes to be thought of more importance than the conversion of the soul. There is no need for the work of the Holy Spirit; or, if admitted at all, it is only needed in the way of training men; educating them in the virtues; helping them to improve themselves. The glorious third Person of the Trinity from being a convincing and quickening agent is degraded into an ethical influence.

Regeneration in the scriptural sense supposes total depravity, which is too humbling a doctrine for the deifiers of human nature.

Nor is it much otherwise in regard to Atonement. Atonement is made to an offended ruler. Penitence is a sufficient ground for the forgiveness of a father. If God is only a Father, how should he require

591

an atonement? and so our advanced theologians are consistent enough in rejecting the Evangelical doctrine of a vicarious atonement. Such atonement supposes too great a degradation of human nature. Hence, instead of the great transaction of Calvary being an expiation for the sins of men, it is regarded as simply an exhibition of self-sacrifice, an example of devotion to duty, or, at the highest, an expression of love calculated to win the heart of man. We believe it to be all that; but we hold that it is very much more. The very essence of that mystery lies in the fact that there was a real bearing of sin, a real enduring of penalty, a real satisfaction rendered to justice. On the other supposition, there is nothing but what man might have done; on this, there is what only the God-man could do. The lower views of the Atonement while they tend to the exaltation of man, in so far tend to lower God. They fail to recognize the honour due to his law, they overlook the far-reaching demands of his justice. On the supposition of a God all mercy, we do not see the need for an atonement at all; but accepting the Bible view of him as not only a God of love, but also a God of infinite justice, inflexible truth, and supreme holiness, we see the full glory of the Atonement revealed in Scripture, an atonement which certainly does not obscure the divine love, but makes it more gloriously conspicuous. In the words of Professor Gracey, "The justice of God demanded an atonement; the love of God provided that atonement." In proportion as the cross exalts God, it humbles men; nowhere is the sin of man so clearly seen, and while the Scripture doctrine of the atonement stands, the intrinsic goodness and glory of human nature must remain a fable.

Did space permit, we might notice the same humanitarian tendency in the treatment of the gospel record. The miraculous element must be toned down, and the mere manhood of Jesus made prominent at the expense of his Deity. "Ecce Homo!" is the favourite cry; a cry that we gladly echo, for we yield to none in our belief in the veritable humanity of Jesus of Nazareth: but we hold it ought not to be the loudest nor the most important cry of the gospel preacher. We think it better to imitate the example of Peter and Paul, than that of Pilate. They point to the man Christ Jesus, it is true; but of that crucified, risen, and exalted man they say in effect, if not in the very words of that ancient evangelistic prophet, "Behold your God!"

But we hasten over various points here suggested, to notice the advanced teaching on the momentous question of Future Punishment. The subject is awful, mysterious, soul-crushing. It becomes those who would speak of it to be bathed in the tender, compassionate spirit of Christ. Yet must it be spoken about, inasmuch as it is part of the "whole counsel of God." Evangelical Christianity taking the plain teachings of the Scriptures has not hesitated to affirm the eternity of the misery of the lost. Crude conceptions of that stern fact may have been entertained, grossly material descriptions may have been given, but no conception, no description can go beyond the awful reality as depicted by the tender-hearted Son of God. We are not concerned at present to advance arguments in support of the orthodox belief, nor to examine in detail the view of the new schools. We simply point to the fact that the chief arguments against the eternity of punishment resolve themselves into a matter of human sentiment. We are asked to imagine

a father treating a child as the orthodox creed represents God dealing with the lost; the most harrowing appeals are made to the natural feelings of men; and the attempt is made to show that eternal punishment is utterly repugnant to the best feelings of human nature and entirely at variance with the loving character of God. These two are really one; for by this theory God is clothed with human feelings, and we are simply asked to judge the matter from a human standpoint. There seems, too, to be underlying all the idea of human dignity. Man is too noble a being to be consigned to such an awful fate; if the essential good of his nature has been undeveloped or obscured during life, he ought to have an opportunity after death of showing his real nature; if God is as good as man he will give the lost another chance, etc. There is, doubtless, an amount of plausibility in the appeal to human feelings; but we respectfully protest against looking at this matter from a human standpoint, and regarding God as an ideal man. Men are not the best judges of their own doom, and God is something more than a Father, he is a judge, a sovereign, and we are bound to look at this question from a divine standpoint. To quote the words of a profound thinker of the past generation, Dr. Chalmers, "We cannot forget, although we would, that justice and judgment are the habitation of his throne; and that his dwelling place is not a mere blissful elysium or paradise of sweets, but an august and inviolable sanctuary. . . . . There is a sickly religion of taste which clings exclusively to the parental benevolence of God, and will not, cannot, brave the contemplation of his righteousness. It is this which makes the reasoning as feeble as the sentiment is flimsy."

It may be objected that, just as others clothe God with the softer attributes of man, we robe him in the severities of a despotic monarch. Our answer is, that we only present the stern aspect of the Divine character to counteract the speculation founded on the softer aspect, not as affording a basis for the orthodox doctrine, but to show that there is no inconsistency in the doctrine; and because it is the view that the Word gives of him in relation to this matter. For, after all, the matter is not to be decided by a priori theories as to the character of God, but by the plain declarations of his Word; and here we see how all the great doctrines depend upon the Inspiration of Scripture. If the Scripture is fully inspired so as to be an authoritative revelation, then there is no escape from the belief in the eternity of punishment. Post-mortem Salvation finds no foothold in that infallible Word. The holding of this solemn doctrine involves no lack of sympathy with men, or real compassion for them. He who was love incarnate uttered the plainest and sternest words about the fate of the lost. Nor is there real pity for men in the new teaching. We solemnly believe that it is a false sentiment of tenderness that would foster in men a hope larger than the Word of God warrants. Let sinners believe that salvation after death is possible, and the very thought will tend to lull them into a lifelong indifference. It is true love that warns of coming danger. "Knowing therefore the terror of the Lord, we persuade men . . . for the love of Christ constraineth us." It is well to have much sympathy with men; would we all had more! But ought we not to have sympathy with God as well? Ought we not to be ready to acquiesce in his judgments; to say "Amen" when he vindicates the eternal principles

593

of righteousness? Feeling that it is a wise and necessary law that has joined sin and punishment together, and believing that character tends to final permanence, ought we not to agree with the closing verdict of Revelation: "He that is unjust, let him be unjust still: and he which is filthy, let him be filthy still: and he that is righteous, let him be righteous still: and he that is holy, let him be holy still"?

In conclusion, looking at the broad general features of the new theology, may we not say that instead of theology it ought to be called Anthropology? The old theology tends to exalt God and lower man; the new seeks to exalt man while it lowers God. The new sets before us a fancied picture of human nature raising itself to God; the old shows, as a great reality, God coming down to man, and in infinite love laying hold of him and lifting him up to himself. So that while the death-blow is struck at the supposed innate goodness of man, true goodness is imparted, and man, recreated in the image of God, becomes by grace a partaker of Divine glory.

The new theology professes to be a theology of progress, and taunts the old with its stationary character; but there are two kinds of progress. There is progress in the truth, and that, we trust, will be ours—a growing "in grace and in the knowledge of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ." There is a progress beyond truth into error, which is thus described in the Revised Version, 2 John, 9: "Whosoever goeth onward and abideth not in the teaching of Christ, hath not God." Such seems the character of the "advanced thought" of the present day. From such "going onward" may the Lord preserve us! Be it ours to abide in the teaching of Christ.

Brannoxtown.

A. MCCAIG.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate