Menu
‹ Chapter 254 of 288 ›

Good and Bad Reading—an Alarming Outlook

8 min read · Chapter 254 of 288
Good and Bad Reading—an Alarming Outlook
Good and Bad Reading—an Alarming Outlook

IN one reminiscence of her life in London, Hannah More says: "I never saw Johnson really angry with me but once; and his displeasure did him so much honour that I loved him the better for it." The fact was that Miss Hannah confessed that she had read "Tom Jones"; and the sage, who by this time regarded himself as something like the guardian of his country's morals, thought it to be his duty to make a vigorous protest against such a maidenly indiscretion. "I am shocked to hear you quote from so vicious a book. I am sorry to hear you have read it: a confession which no modest lady should ever make. I scarcely know a more corrupt work." We can not only go with Johnson in a speech like this, we can even sympathize with him in the prejudice which would not allow of his seeing the genius of a writer like Fielding, whose books were calculated to lower the standard of public morality. Because Richardson was a better teacher, Johnson insisted that he was the abler man, which was, of course, not true, except in the sense that Richardson had a reverence for things that were pure and elevating.

This question of the corruption of the press in the eighteenth century is one about which ordinary present-day readers do not know very much; but it was a matter concerning which our Christian forefathers had to be very watchful. Addison refers to the beautiful work produced by the English presses; but printing classics and works for scholars was quite a different affair from producing the cheap, meagre, and oftentimes not very decent books which were then alone available for the poor. As they appear preserved in the libraries of collectors, these books, which were once hawked by chapmen from town to town, and village to village, afford such a revelation of other days as no historian can give us. How can we call those "the good old times" in which few, save the upper and middle classes, were able to read at all. Indeed, the casual purchasers of papers and books in the towns, as well as in the villages, were mainly dependent on such presses as that which rendered St. Giles's notorious in later days.

This kind of ephemeral trash, however, did not represent the worst characteristic of the literature of the eighteenth century; the most disastrous feature was the loose morals of the authors. Fielding was not the worst of the school of which he may be called the leader. A very superficial examination of the novels, and a good deal of the poetry, which constituted the lighter reading of the eighteenth century, is sufficient to show that it was so deplorably corrupt that no one would in these days venture to give examples of the grosser passages, lest they should come within reach of the Act for suppressing obscene writing.

Now, the eighteenth century is admitted to have been a time of going back; a time of moral deadness and crime, when the prisons would not have held the inmates provided for them if the gallows had not been constantly in requisition. The obscene chapbook and the immoral novel were, therefore, quite in keeping with other phases of its life. The corrupt press did neither more nor less than reflect the national life. At the present time, however, we profess to have greatly advanced in religion and morality, and to be more genteel altogether than the readers who had to choose between Fielding and Richardson.

583

When Johnson roared at Hannah More, by way of denouncing the prevailing fashion, only the minority would have gone with him: but now the majority would, at least, loudly proclaim themselves on the side of the virtuous and the pure.

But are we better than our fathers in this matter of impure literature? As regards the supply, we have advanced many hundredfold beyond anything that they were acquainted with; but, of course, we make a far better show in providing the antidote. The abundant supply of cheap and good literature in our time is a grand fact; but surely never before in the annals of the world was there such a flood of heart-corrupting trash as at present drenches every town and village in the land! Until the magistrates showed a disposition to put down the nuisance, the streets or main thoroughfares of London became a disgrace, by being appropriated as a market by the traffickers in the grosser kinds; but the worst, or such as the law can take hold of, we leave out of the calculation; and there are still left vast supplies of that more decorous filth which, in the end, is no less destructive of morality. We believe that something like a million papers of a demoralizing kind go forth from London presses alone every week, of course not reckoning Sunday newspapers. It is thus a plague which is not easily put down, and will, probably, never be wholly corrected by the law. The evil is one of long standing; for half a century or more ago we find Charles Knight, as publisher for the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge, complaining of the "hundreds of reams of vile paper and printing issued weekly, to the disgrace of cheap literature, and having considerable hold upon the less informed of the working people, especially upon the young." The effect is seen upon the boys and girls who read such papers. A glamour is thrown over crime, until to the imagination of unknowing youths it appears to be a "game" thing. The passions are excited until everything is sacrificed at the shrine of gross indulgence, and the physical as well as the moral nature is left a wreck. Some time ago an authority on the subject said, "Criminal literature of the lowest class has been diminished"; but we differ from that opinion, and believe that the total of this pernicious trash was never so great as it is now.

Nor can it be said that we are a whit better than our fathers in the matter of what are called higher-class or fashionable novels. Nearly twenty years ago, a publisher's periodical said that, "Among educated persons a sensational literature has become fashionable, the most appreciated authors being those who most vividly describe the sins committed against society. Very many of the popular works of modern days have an immoral tendency, and are far more pernicious in their effects than the works of Fielding, Smollett, and kindred authors of the last century." The approved "Society" novel of to-day is spiced with immorality; and not seldom is made a vehicle for attacking Christianity itself. What is, perhaps, an even worse symptom is, that our "intelligent" ministers, who, at any cost, must maintain their prestige with their cultured congregations, think it to be their duty to read such works, and to preach about them. If they would learn what is their duty from the Word they profess to expound, they would see that their duty is to preach the gospel as the only corrective of existing evils, and

not to parley with the enemy. Fancy where we should have been if Wesley, Whitefield, and the preachers of the Revival had concerned themselves with replying to deistical objections, and with counteracting the immoral influence of licentious story-tellers, instead of straightforwardly applying the truth to the consciences of those who were perishing for lack of knowledge.

Of late years we have been exposed to a plague of another kind, and one from which the country was comparatively free even a generation ago; we refer to the translations of the most horrible French novels. Of these one firm in London has, we believe, circulated a million volumes. The printed filth of Zola and his school, seems actually to have found a ready market in England.

"But what is astonishing," says an anonymous writer, referring to this subject, "so astonishing, that it is matter of amazement to the present writer, that the public attention has not been drawn to the fact before now—is the support which has been lent to what, at best, can but be regarded as a somewhat equivocal commercial enterprise, by a considerable proportion of the English Press. Many of the leading daily and weekly journals have, for some time past, prominently advertised the English editions of these novels. Their titles in large type, and, sometimes, with laudatory Press-notices subjoined, stare one in the face in quarters which one is accustomed to associate, not merely with a conventional propriety, but with some approach to a high tone upon moral questions. We are, in short, confronted with the astounding spectacle of a Press, upon the whole, freer from what is harmful, morally, than any other in Europe, industriously disseminating in the vulgar tongue, books which, even in their less accessible native dress, the leading English circulating library has declined to admit to its shelves." *

This is about as bad as bad can be; and it is a matter in which Parliament might be required to interfere.

It is a pleasanter thing to turn the attention to what is being done in providing really wholesome fare for the young, and for the people generally. The enterprise is supposed to have commenced between 1830 and 1840; but little was done until nearly twenty years later. Neither Charles Knight and his society, nor the brothers Chambers, did anything directly to forward the cause of religion; but it was far otherwise when John Cassell founded the firm which developed into one of the greatest pure literature agencies of the kingdom. Others followed. The Religious Tract Society has grown immensely during the last thirty years; and, in the main, the quality of its supplies have correspondingly improved. When we look through the volumes of The Leisure Hour and The Sunday at Home, for the year 1887, and compare these with those which were issued at the outset, we see how great the advance has been. Both periodicals are now, as regards excellence, in the front rank.

Separate denominations are also doing something to provide what is wanted. The Established Church has its Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, and lesser agencies. Nonconformity also has its

* "The New Godiva, and other Studies in Social Questions." T. Fisher Unwin.

585

publishing associations. The drawback of the Church society first named, and which will, in ten years' time, be celebrating its bi-centenary, is that many of its publications are such as we should strongly disapprove of. The Church of England is really best served by private enterprise, like that of the Rev. Charles Bullock, who, by the service he has done in this department, has become a national benefactor. As regards their religious teaching, there is no uncertain ring about the periodicals which come from Home Words office. Home Words itself is a Christian teacher in a large number of parishes, while The Fireside is a good model of what a family magazine should be.

Our own notion is that more trouble should be taken by Christian people in the matter of circulating pure and educating literature. Colportage should be encouraged and extended; Sunday-school teachers should look well after their scholars' reading; and even churches might have their magazine agencies; for some who have tried this experiment have had the best of encouragement to persevere. The fact is, that the powers of darkness are using the printing-press; and unless we, on our part, make it, what it is so capable of becoming, the church's lever, we shall forego advantages and conquests which are well within our reach.

G. H. P.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate