Menu
‹ Chapter 23 of 288 ›

Notes on the Life of Dr. Morley Punshon — By C. H. Spurgeon

10 min read · Chapter 23 of 288

THE life of an eminently successful preacher is not often full of incident. If he has been a missionary, or a backwoods evangelist, he may have met with stirring adventure; but in England his career, in the telling of it, even when it is not so in actual fact, is apt to keep the level of the common-place. Among our Wesleyan brethren the system of itinerary, with its many excellences, might be thought to minister to the interest of a biography, but it does very little in that direction for the general reader. Its tendency is to keep Methodist preachers in one useful but un-eccentric course, and this is of far more importance than giving opportunities for remarkable singularities. For this reason we cannot promise a reader of the life of William Morley Punshon any thrilling passages or striking incidents.

The author has done well with his materials, and has shown us as much of the great lecturer as his canvas, colours, and brush allowed. Mr. Macdonald has not the marvellous descriptive power of Smiles, nor the lowlier diary-keeping faculty of Boswell, and therefore his memorial of his friend will not take a place among the classics of biography. Still, he will command a host of readers, who will buy the book at first for the sake of the greatly-beloved man whose life-story it contains, and will, many of them, read it again because of the quiet, self-concealing manner in which the author has set forth his friend, and obliterated his own literary skill. This is a noteworthy point about the volume. In other cases you see the author quite as much as the subject; even his reverence for Johnson does not lead poor Boswell to keep himself in the background; but in this case we have Punshon without Macdonald, and this is so truly remarkable that we are bound to note it.

We shall not attempt a complete outline of Dr. Punshon's life. His boyhood prophesied the man. He was always bent on the improvement of his mind: and when other lads would have been idling, or sporting, or in mischief, he was admiring the poets, or composing essays, or meeting with a few young friends for mutual instruction. His education all along was strangely without plan or continuity, as one would judge who did not know the youth, and what the Lord meant to make of him: but considered after the event, we do not hesitate to say that nothing could have been better. The Great Schoolmaster made no mistakes in the training of his pupil. The processes of education, as they are stereotyped in our general school-life, are not so absolutely wise that deviation from them is certain to be a calamity: on the contrary, we believe that many a man will be better developed by irregular instruction and earnest self-help than by the best-approved course of tuition. Punshon is not the only one who was helped by those hindrances which prevented his having all the flavour of his soul dried out of him by the current methods of instruction. He may have missed eminent scholarship, but he found his true vocation, and the best preparation for it.

The most of those who saw the Prince of Lecturers on a triumphant evening at Exeter Hall, or observed the honour rendered to him by all

* This is intended to be a review of the volume prepared by the Rev. F. W. Macdonald, and published by Messrs. Hodder and Stoughton.

57

his brethren, would not be prepared to hear that he was the frequent victim of great depression of spirit. Those whom God honours in public he usually chastens in private, lest they should be exalted above measure. We were not surprised to read the following passage, which reveals the experience of the successful orator's soul, and causes us to feel true fellowship with him:—"The side of Mr. Punshon's life which is revealed by extracts from his journal was wholly unknown to the multitudes whom he addressed, week after week, in all parts of the country. A few intimate friends were aware of his private sorrows and anxieties. But the spiritual conflicts to which they gave rise, the deep depression, the self-reproach, the sense of loneliness and helplessness that returned again and again—these were hidden even from them. Still less could the general public imagine at what cost to himself, with what inner distress and sinkings of heart, he was doing his work. To all outward appearance his course was one of unbroken popularity and honour. Judged by the crowds that flocked to hear him, by the tributes of the press, and the favour of the people at large, by the power with which, in the pulpit and on the platform, he swayed the hearts of tens of thousands, and, above all, judged by the results of his ministry among his own flock and elsewhere, nothing seemed wanting to the happiness of his life. But there was ample counterpoise of suffering to keep the balance. At no period of his life was he wholly free from the discipline of pain, and it would seem as though it kept pace, to say the least, with the increase of his honours and successes. Physical languor, the reaction from excessive toil, nervous fears, sharp attacks of painful ailments, never-ceasing anxieties concerning his children, an almost too complete sympathy with the troubles of others, the oft-reopened wound of his bereavement, and a certain tendency to, perhaps, morbid introspection—all these together made the 'thorn' which kept him from being exalted above measure. There are deeper notes of distress in his journal than any recorded here; but enough will appear in this record of his life to show that he was not exempted from that general law which makes sacrifice and suffering the conditions of victory. 'The servant is not greater than his Lord.'"

There is a common notion that Morley Punshon, though a very eloquent preacher, was not so notable for usefulness as for marvellous rhetoric. A measure of truth may possibly be found in the opinion, but this memoir will tend greatly to qualify the statement. In many instances his preaching brought a blessing to unlettered men and women, and he was often cheered by that fact. We should put him in the very first rank for oratorical power, but not in the same pre-eminence as a winner of souls; but if any one should assign him a low position in this last character, he would grievously misunderstand the good man's life. At any rate, he was always faithful to the gospel, as he understood it, and, at the same time, he felt a child-like dependence upon the Holy Spirit. No one more than himself would have denounced attempts at display. He spoke in majestic tones because those tones were natural to him, and not because he affected them. His was the style of Apollos because he was Apollos. It would have been the veriest folly in him to have tried to speak after the manner of Cephas.

Of course, as a Wesleyan Methodist, Punshon's methods of stating

doctrine were not those which a Calvinist would always approve; but there is an inner core of Evangelism in which all true believers are at one. The Wesleyan body is but little touched with the deadly plague of "modern thought," and our departed friend had no taint of it. With all his grandeur of speech, he was as old-fashioned a Methodist as "Daniel Quorn," and was as thorough a believer in man's ruin, redemption, and regeneration as any one of us. To him "the precious blood" was no mere phrase, and the atoning sacrifice no obsolete dogma. He had no doubts upon the authoritative inspiration of the Scriptures, and no misgivings as to the eternal verities. He was not a speculator, but a believer. That deep experience which we have mentioned, those inward conflicts, and strong cryings and tears, made it a necessity of his life that he should find a real refuge, and fly to it for consolation with full assurance that it was indeed provided for him of the Lord, and was no invention of men. His deliverance from the Presidential chair, in the year 1875, was so vigorous, and so prophetic, that we quote a portion of it with the utmost satisfaction :—

"Though I thankfully acknowledge that the great heart of England still hungers for the living truth, and that there is a music in the name of Jesus to which the masses are fain to listen; yet it is impossible to forget that the current thought of to-day is tending towards unbelief, and that we may have fallen upon times when many 'will not endure sound doctrine, but gather to themselves teachers having itching ears.' The old adversaries are still in the field, and there are others, more to be dreaded, who fight against the truth while they are clad in the armour of the true. . . .

"Brethren, it is needful that you be strong in faith yourselves, that you have a firm grasp of 'the faith once delivered to the saints,' if you are to grapple with the difficulties of your position, and become wise winners of souls. If you falter or hesitate, or fence the truth about with your reserves and your misgivings, like an Agag who 'comes delicately,' what impression are you likely to make upon your hearers? Men's opinions are but as the threads of the gossamer. Men's convictions are the powers that shake the world. You have no vantage-ground in dealing with many-sided error but in an honest and thorough confidence in the truth. Men declaim foolishly enough about dogmatic teaching. You must dogmatize when men are dying, and you are sent to them with 'the words of eternal life.' On minor matters, indeed, of taste, or criticism, or even of subordinate truth, you may hold your conclusion with deference, and avow it with modesty; but on the questions that press close upon eternity—on man's need and God's grace, on Christ's atonement and the sinner's pardon, on the Spirit's work and the believer's growth—on these there must be no room for hesitation or misgiving."

That he was President of the Wesleyan community in England for one year was a slight thing compared with his presidency over the Canadian Methodists year after year. To his brethren in that region he was a help indeed; one of them says that he advanced the denomination as much as it would otherwise have progressed in a hundred years. The detestable law, which forbids marriage with a deceased wife's sister, helped to drive him to our American Empire; and we mention it only because, by every means, the public should be kept in mind of the

59

astounding fact that what is right in Canada is wrong in the mother-country, and that chiefly by the will of the bishops of one denomination. In Mr. Punshon's case the evil prohibition worked good for an important part of the church to which he belonged. His heart was always in his own country, and soon after the death of his second wife he returned to England.

Perhaps our friend will be best known and remembered by his famous lectures. These, when they first astounded an Exeter Hall audience, were the topics of the day. To write the titles of those great efforts is like noting the names of Napoleon's battles. They cost him very much in preparation, and almost as much at each delivery. The wear and tear must have been enormous, and it is no wonder that the orator was spent, worn down, and compelled frequently to seek rest and change. One has only to recall "The Prophet of Horeb," "Bunyan," "The Huguenots," "Macaulay," "The Men of the May-flower," and others, to remember how unique were the orations, and how exhausting was the toil. These lectures were the very best form of that article. Sermons are the natural fruit of the preacher's vocation; and lectures of this order ought, as a rule, to be only his pastime; but in Punshon's case the truths which he taught were so important, and his evangelical spirit was so apparent, that we feel bound to regard his lectures as a sort of special discourses having the same end and aim as those which he delivered from the pulpit, but adapted to reach a different audience. One thing is their glory, as it was the glory of his life, that they were not for himself, but for the cause which was dear to him. They might have been the source of a great income, but he laid them at the feet of his Lord, and sought no recompense except the power to help the work of God.

The most striking point of this biography is that, in its close as well as in its opening pages, it is the story of a man whose sorrows never ceased. Surely he was one whom the Lord tenderly loved, for he was rebuked and chastened almost beyond precedent. How touching to read in his own words, "I am in the depths . . . compelled to go softly; but there is an arm around me, and it holds me up. . . I need a great deal of humbling; surely this heart of mine must have worn its pride high when such rude blows are needed 'to break the crown of it'"! Who does not sympathize with the man who writes, "Last night I heard the clock strike each hour from eleven till nine this morning. I long to be brought nearer to God by this discipline. Perhaps—

" 'When he hath my patience proved,

And sees me to his will resigned,

His heavy hand and rod removed

Shall leave the blest effect behind:

The sure inviolable peace,

The ripened fruit of righteousness'"?

Working, and suffering, he fulfilled a sort of double life until his divine Master called him home. Then, in deeply reverent tones, looking upward, he said, with a firm voice, "CHRIST IS TO ME A BRIGHT REALITY. JESUS! JESUS!" What a moment for his beloved wife when she saw a smile of rapture on his face, then marked him bow his weary head, and enter into the rest eternal!

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate