The "Down-Grade" and the By-Grade; — Or, The Power Of Truth
THE decay of true piety, or godliness of life, has commonly been associated with a defection of doctrinal belief; or, in other words, a departure from the faith of the gospel of Jesus Christ. On the other hand, a revival of true religion has commonly been attended with or followed by a renewed attachment to evangelical truth. This may be very much like saying over again the memorable words of Luther, that the holding or not holding the doctrine of justification by faith is the test of a standing or a falling church. Of course, he meant, and we mean, not the holding of evangelical doctrine in a theological or philosophical sense only, but the holding the truth in its living power, and gracious, holy influence. The history of Christianity and of Christian churches in England, Wales, Scotland, France, Germany, and other parts of Europe amply corroborates this statement. But nowhere do we see it more plainly than in the history of the Christian Church in Geneva, the city of John Calvin.
The common course in the Down-Grade movement has been, first of all, while still professedly holding the truth, to hold it less and less in its living, experimental power, until it has become little more than a theory or a form. Next, it has been common to gradually drop the form of sound words, and to make the opinions square with the life, instead of permitting living principles to inspire and regulate the conduct. Finally, it has sometimes happened, according to the temper of the man and his associations, to deny, slander, and denounce the very truths he once professed to hold and teach. The surroundings of iniquity, especially iniquity in a dress of religion, will soon cool down the fervour of inward piety if the repellant power of faith and prayer and communion with Christ be wanting; and when love to Christ has been cooled down to the point of tolerating error and sin, and living in conformity to the world, the full result of spiritual deadness and disloyalty to Christ and his truth is soon reached.
In reference to Geneva, and the lamentable departures of its ministers and people from the true faith, which reached its maximum in the city has been so present century, there was not only a departure from the same acted as if it taught by the greatest of the Reformers, but from all men the sugar-co, until the ministers and professors, and most of the men followed together Arians or Socinians. We cannot go into details, but God has not a brief summary of the state of things. When we go to Geneva. There was, plucked up by the roots and trodden under foot, we did, who saw the hand of the spoiler has been there, turning the beginning for some into a ruinous waste. Something like this had which was dealt out by Geneva. It had passed through great political young men formed a lot with the first French Revolution and the wars of report. They were only tribulations did not work either patience or a love to Christ which p have led the Protestants to a deeper, truer, time the society was broke, who comforteth his own in all their tribulations found a Moravian congreof, it made them haughty, and hard, and
daringly impious. As to their faith, they were altogether on the down-line; and they not only had no brake to check their descent, but they desired none. Professing themselves to be wise, they had become fools.
James Alexander Haldane, Esq., in writing the memoirs of his uncle and father, Robert and James A. Haldane, describes Geneva as it was in its former glory, and as it was in its shame and disgrace:—
"Geneva is one of those names which symbolizes something far more glorious than the little town, whose ancient battlements were at once the monuments of the defensive skill of Vauban, and the persecuting tyranny of the house of Savoy. Geneva has been for ages a term antagonistic to Rome. Placed at the extremity of its own placid and beautiful lake, where the blue waters of the arrowy Rhône rush onwards to the ocean, this free city, as if designed by God to be a witness against Popery, whether Ultramontane or Gallican, stood between the Jura and the Alps, themselves the types of beauty and sublimity. Within its hospitable gates were received several of the Italian families proscribed for favouring the Reformation. It was the city where Knox, with other exiles from Scotland, found an asylum, and whence he imported into his own favoured land that form of church government to which Scotland has so fondly and firmly adhered. At a later period it welcomed many of the French who fled from the persecution which followed the revocation of the Edict of Nantes. Geneva was, indeed, the glory of the Reformation, the battle-field of light and darkness, the Thermopylæ of Protestantism, from whose Alpine heights the light of gospel truth once streamed forth with brilliant lustre athwart the blackness of papal superstition. But Geneva fell from its ancestral faith, and proved how vain are historic names, orthodox creeds, and religious formularies, where the Spirit ceases to animate the lifeless frame."
As far back as 1757 a celebrated French infidel complimented (?) the pastors of the city in an article in the French Encyclopædia, after his own fashion: "To say all in one word, many of the pastors of Geneva have no other religion but a perfect Socinianism, rejecting all that they call mysteries."
Be it remembered, that they did not call themselves Socinians. No, their apostasy was less open than real. The same infidel writer, with a befitting sarcasm, adds, "I should be extremely concerned to be snapped of having betrayed their secret."
One fruitful source of false doctrine, and a frequent subtle dissemination of error, was the plan practised by Vinet of that day (1779) of allowing students to maintain an exile in Arian theses. This was the mistake at Northampton's are the salt of which was so fatal to many students, of which Dr. P's power to keep Is the same mistake repeated as to other errors in sisters in aiding to conformist colleges of to-day? If so, it behoves all children understood to see to it. I suppose few persons, if any, are so un them together upon their table wholesome bread, and bread were the question, "Why poisonous ingredients, that their children and others, not unnaturally, see, and take that which they prefer. This is a fair illustration of
At the early part of this century, Jean Jac Geneva. In one of his letters he writes his ministers of his day:—
Teaching and Teachers,"
415
"It is asked of the ministers of the Church of Geneva if Jesus Christ be God? They dare not answer. It is asked if he were a mere man? They are embarrassed, and will not say they think so. A philosopher, with a glance of the eye, penetrates their character. He sees them to be Arians, Socinians, Deists; he proclaims it, and thinks he does them honour. They are alarmed, terrified; they come together, they discuss, they are in agitation, they know not to which of the saints they should turn; and after earnest consultations, deliberations, conferences, all vanishes in amphijouri; and they neither say, 'Yes,' nor 'No.' O Genevans, these gentlemen, your ministers, in truth are very singular people! They do not know what they believe, or what they do not believe. They do not even know what they would wish to appear to believe. Their only manner of establishing their faith is to attack the faith of others."
French intercourse, specially during the First Empire, led to the introduction of French manners. The Sunday evenings saw the theatres open; and it was by no means an unusual thing for the pastors to dismiss their congregations earlier on the occasion of solemn festivals, that they might themselves join in the festivities of the Lord's-day, which were closed with—fireworks on the lake.
We in England may seem to be a very long way from this state of things; but we must not be the victims of a false security. It is well known that, in the Ritualistic section of the Church of England, people are found at the theatre at night, and at the communion the next morning; and that after an "early celebration" on Lord's-days the evening may be devoted to the claims of a dinner-party, or to lawn-tennis. In many Nonconformist circles it is the custom to attend chapel in the morning only, and spend the rest of the day at home—doing what? We do not say. It may be in reading good books, catechizing the children and servants, or, after the manner of our fathers, going over the morning sermon with them. But we suspect many people would laugh at us if we even suggested such a thing. One instance is well known to us in which a rather loud professor has a "musical evening" on the Sabbath, with a considerable medley of invited guests, for whom are provided the choicest refreshments. The Christian World has done much harm in the direction of secularizing the Sabbath, and other publications have followed in its wake. The first part of its title has been supposed to sanctify all its contents; or, at least, people have acted as if they thought so, and so the tinge of "Christian" has been the sugar-coat for the great bolus of the "World," and all has been swallowed together.
But God has never left himself without a witness, neither did he in Geneva. There were a few young men, thoughtful and religiously disposed, who saw through the shams of the pastors, or at least had a yearning for something different from the chaff of human opinions which was dealt out at the churches from Sunday to Sunday. These young men formed a society, which lived a little beyond its first annual report. They were only half-enlightened, but they were the possessors of a love to Christ which panted for a fuller revelation of him. After a time the society was broken up, some being removed, and others having found a Moravian congregation to unite with. One of these earnest
seekers was induced to enter the household of Madame Krudener, as her chaplain. Her views of Divine truth were far from distinct, and light was lacking.
In 1816 a Welshman, or possibly an Englishman, of the artisan class, of the Calvinistic Methodist persuasion, settled at Geneva, on the ground of the ancient convent, where, nearly three hundred years before, the Reformation was first proclaimed by William Farel. The name of this good man was Richard Wilcox. He took his religion with him when he left his native land for a foreign country, for it evidently had its seat in his heart. He met a few of the members of the disbanded religious society which we have just mentioned, and he gave the enquirers the benefit of his knowledge and experience. He was so far a true Calvinist as to dwell much on the eternal love of God the Father, and on the certainty of the salvation of all his chosen people; but he lacked one important feature of Calvinistic doctrine, the inviting of all who hear the gospel to come to Christ and believe on him unto eternal life. In this he fell short, but nevertheless he strengthened those who came into close fellowship with him in the true faith of Christ.
It is a very common thing with preachers who dislike Calvinistic doctrine, especially those who have never given themselves the trouble to study it carefully and closely, to draw caricatures of Calvinism, or, as a distinguished preacher has lately remarked, to set up Calvinism as a kind of target against which to discharge their arrows; in doing so, they not only misrepresent some of the most earnest and successful preachers of God's Word, but they mislead their hearers. In certain cases which have come to the knowledge of the writer, young men of small experience, with a daring which wiser men would never have displayed, have held up to ridicule the thing they called Calvinism, which was not Calvinism at all, but some scarecrow of their own dressing up, like unto nothing in either heaven or earth. At the same time, these gentlemen left their hearers to guess what doctrines they would have them receive in the place of those they would have them renounce. There is an old proverb about children playing with edge-tools, which we will not repeat, for we intend not to be unkind, but would rather "rebuke them sharply that they may be sound in the faith." There is a temptation in this age of change to make truth subservient to charity, and everything to popularity. But this is folly. Whatever new kinds of diet may be invented, bread will always be in request; and when all the changing notions of theological speculators, and all the quiddities of those who are wise in their own eyes have had their little day, and lie like driftwood on the shores of time, the eternities of Jehovah will remain the joy and song of the redeemed. Eternal love, eternal life, eternal redemption; everlasting righteousness, everlasting salvation, according to an everlasting covenant, will be the everlasting portion and the eternal joy of all the called, and chosen, and faithful.
Would that we could speak a word kindly, and in a brotherly or fatherly, or, at least, a Christian spirit, to some of those men, young men mostly, whom Satan is trying to get into his sieve, and bewitch with a love for novelties and the things that "go" with the unthinking multitude; we would not tell them to wait until they are sure they have a God-given message to the people, and a "Thus saith the Lord"
417
for what they deliver in his name; but we would ask them humbly and patiently to wait upon God, and lay aside every consideration of success, advancement, and widening influence; and, like young Samuel, cry, "Speak, Lord, for thy servant heareth."
Coming back to Geneva, we find that towards the close of 1816, Richard Wilcox was about to leave Geneva, and that M. Empeytaz, one of the leaders of the little band of enquirers, was also quitting the field of conflict, where the ministers, with their lay-assistants and the Government officers, called the Consistory, were determined to crush him. His friend and colleague, M. Bost, was also leaving for the Canton of Berne. The outlook was dark for the praying few, who were like those "feeble Jews," in the days of Nehemiah, who sought to rebuild the ruined temple of the Lord on the original foundations. But help was at hand. When was the time that there was not "redemption in Israel"? And whoever looked for "redemption in Israel" in vain?
It was in the autumn of this year that Mr. Robert Haldane, in a remarkable way, had his steps directed of God to return to Geneva, after having, as he supposed, finally left it. He was well adapted for the work, as all God's instruments are. He was not a minister, as that term is usually understood, but a gentleman having means at command. He was one well instructed in the things of the kingdom of God; an all round Calvinist, sober minded and spiritually minded, with a maturity of understanding, an experience of divine truth, and a ripeness of Christian character rarely combined. He had also a zeal well balanced by prudence, a devotion to God and his cause, and a courage which had been proved in the service of his king and country.
The time, too, was opportune. There had been some little stir made by a pamphlet, entitled "Considerations on the Divinity of Jesus Christ." Henri Empeytaz, its author, we have already mentioned. Though to an ordinary body of evangelical ministers or students it would appear nothing special, this book created a good deal of excitement among the rationalistic students at Geneva. They assembled in the great Hall of the Consistory, and having elected one of their number chairman, passed an address to the "venerable company" of pastors, in which they solemnly protested against the "odious aggression" of the "calumnious" pamphlet. Two only of the students—M. Henri Pyt and M. Guers—refused to sign it. The president was M. Merle D'Aubigné, who soon appeared with new surroundings.
Mr. Haldane commenced reading the Scriptures in one of the rooms of his hotel. As he could not speak French with sufficient accuracy for his purpose, he employed one of the students as an interpreter. The first was M. Rieu, then M. Frédéric Monod, then M. James. His expositions were clear, forcible, and both earnest and striking. The first student brought others, and at length he met a number of them twice a week, to whom he expounded the Epistle to the Romans. As those expositions were afterwards published, and the work is still procurable, they need not be further described than that they were thoroughly Pauline in their character, Calvinistic in doctrine, and evangelical in spirit. These readings and expositions were carried on to the end of the session in the summer, and wonderful was the result. Among the converts were men to whom the church and the world are under everlasting
28
obligations. If we mention the names of some of the better known, that must be sufficient. Dr. Merle D'Aubigné, Frédéric Monod, Gaussen, Henri Pyt, M. Guers, M. James, Charles Rieu, M. Gonthier, and last, but not least, Dr. Cæsar Malan. This last, as we are told by her sister, was the means of leading Charlotte Elliot into the light and liberty of the gospel, that gospel she so well understood, Calvinist as she was, and has so forcibly and beautifully expressed in her world-known hymn,
"Just as I am, without one plea," &c.
In Geneva, and France, and Switzerland, and elsewhere, the Word of the Lord ran and was glorified through the ministry and writings of those men who were either first awakened or led into the liberty of the gospel by the clear and lucid expositions of Mr. Haldane. A foundation was also laid for evangelistic efforts both at home and abroad in the future.
Félix Neff, "The Pastor of the Alps," was not immediately one of the fruits of Mr. Haldane's labours, but he was indirectly such, through the instructions of Gonthier and François Olivier.
The conversion of D'Aubigné was very remarkable. It is the fashion nowadays in many Nonconformist pulpits to ignore the doctrine of the fall of man, and the total alienation and corruption of the human heart. There are ministers not a few who would be offended and indignant if one were to ascribe to them such sentiments concerning the depravity of man as were held and taught by Mr. Haldane, yet—hear it! all ye who only preach the doctrine in an undertone—God blessed the preaching of this doctrine in a remarkable way.
Young D'Aubigné heard of Mr. Haldane as the English or Scotch gentleman who spoke so much about the Bible, a Book with which he had only a slight acquaintance. One day he met Mr. Haldane at a private house with some friends, and heard him read from an English Bible, and expound a chapter of the Epistle to the Romans, concerning the natural corruption of man, a doctrine of which he had no knowledge. The truth was astounding to him, but he was clearly convinced of it by the passage read, and he said to Mr. Haldane, "Now I do indeed see this doctrine in the Bible." "Yes," replied the venerable man, "but do you see it in your heart?" That simple question was carried home to his heart. It was the sword of the Spirit. He was thoroughly convinced of the corruption of his own nature, and he gladly embraced the truth of salvation by grace alone. Thus did God prepare him to be the historian of the Reformation.
After Mr. Haldane left Geneva, in the summer of 1817, he spent two years at Montauban, where were 6,000 or 7,000 Protestants, and where was a Protestant college, established by Napoleon I., having then some sixty students. Here he laboured with fidelity and blessed success.
Now we want to make one or two observations on the foregoing.
First, we see the sad results of declension from the truth, and yielding to the specious pleas of rationalism concerning inspiration, the Divinity of Christ, his death as an atonement for sin, justification by faith, the work of the Holy Spirit in conversion, and such like. These truths are like so many links in a chain: give up one, and, in effect, you give up all, and you have nothing left but a cold, dreary, hopeless scepticism.
419
Therefore, we must neither give them up ourselves, nor connive at or shelter those that do. Truth first, and friendship and charity afterwards.
A course which has been often recommended by good men, and which may be right in some cases—that of avoiding controverted subjects, and simply dwelling on truths commonly received among professing Christians—was not that followed by Mr. Haldane. It could not well be; in him vagueness would have been ill-timed and criminal. The pastors and professors in the Faculty heard of the doctrines he was teaching, and they preached openly against what he taught; while he, on the other hand, collected their arguments and laboured to destroy their heresies. They taught that men are born pure, and spoke of the Saviour as the first of created beings; and he boldly opposed and refuted these errors. They taught that the gospel was useful, but not necessary to salvation; but he declared, with all boldness, that there is "None other name under heaven given among men whereby we must be saved." It was not, therefore, by avoiding controversy and controverted doctrines, that he laboured to raise up the fallen standard of the gospel at Geneva, but by declaring the whole counsel of God, "dwelling," as he says in his letter to Rev. E. Bickersteth, "on every doctrine of the Bible, whether it was controverted or not, or however repulsive to the carnal mind; and confronting and bringing to the test of Scripture every argument levelled at my instructions, both by pastors and professors."
This full, unhesitating, all-round exposition and declaration of the gospel is wanted now. Let the truth be proclaimed from the house-top, with no rounding off of angles, and no apologizing for its sternness. Let us declare "all the counsel of God," and leave our own comfort to him whose honour should be more to us than life itself.
It is clear that there is a mighty power in those truths which are denominated evangelical. Mr. Haldane's methods were far enough removed from professional revivalism and every kind of sensationalism. It was by the plain, humbling, unwelcome truths about sin and salvation, plainly spoken, but earnestly and affectionately pressed, that God wrought so marvellously. The Lord used those very truths which are so little preached, and so little understood, in these days. Many are trying to work men up to Christ's character and excellence, without first of all bringing them into contact with Christ as the source of all grace, righteousness, salvation, holiness, and spiritual power. It was the "virtue"—the healing power—that went out of Christ, responsive to the act of faith in the diseased woman, that effected her cure; and it must be so in salvation; for Jesus is all-in-all, that God may have the glory of all. Christ will never be truly understood as Exemplar till he is received as a Sacrifice; and certainly he will never be followed in his life till the disciple has been quickened through faith in his death. You must take the Lord Jesus as a whole, and then there flows from him a wondrous power for moral cleansing: then, we say, and not till then. Christ crucified, and all the great doctrines which surround him and his cross, are the great restoratives of our fallen humanity.
Now, if these truths are the channels of such mighty power, and if God has, in numberless instances, so wonderfully blessed them, those men run a fearful risk who ignore, deny, underrate, or throw them aside. There may yet be new modes of travelling, and new methods of doing
many things, but there is not, there never will be, any new method of saving souls. While sin is what it is, and the human heart is what it is; while the prince of darkness holds the disobedient in the chains of enmity to God, while the natural man understandeth not the things of the Spirit of God, the grace of God will be absolutely necessary; for only the grace of God can accomplish the wonderful work of saving the lost, raising the dead, justifying the ungodly, and making condemned sinners children of God. Therefore, O ye servants of God, hold fast that ye have received, and never think of casting away the weapons of your spiritual warfare. The Lord bless us all with more and more of his Spirit, his light, his love, his power, that by the faithful preaching of the "everlasting gospel," we may batter down the walls of superstition, error, infidelity, and sin.
The writer of this article specially commends to all the readers of The Sword and the Trowel, ministerial and otherwise, a very excellent work,* by his old friend, Rev. D. Pledge, of Ramsgate. It is gold from the mine of truth, and "the gold is good." The work is specially opportune.
