Extract from Address
BY THE LATE REV. W. ALEXANDER, D.D., ON THE OPENING OF THE THEOLOGICAL SESSION, 1877.
I WOULD be very far from maintaining that no advance in any sense, or in any direction, can be made in theological science. It would be strange, indeed, were this the case. Strange that the church, with the Spirit of Truth abiding and dwelling in it, should, after centuries of thought and experience, have made no progress in the knowledge of divine things. This we may confidently say cannot be; or if such were the case, the church would be in fault, and its teachers to blame.
Progress there ought to be, and we may presume will be, in each succeeding age. The Bible, the fountain of divine knowledge, is for all ages; and as men continue to study it, and reflect on its teachings and gather experience in regard to the practical bearing of these on the wants and needs of men, it cannot be but that fresh discoveries will be made both as to the real meaning of its contents, as to the relation of its varied utterances to each other, and as to the adaptation of its revelations to the spiritual and social interests of the race. But as there may be a wrong progress as well as a right, as there may be progress in a wrong direction—progress away from the truth—it concerns us to enquire in what way is progress of the right kind to be made in theology? and by what methods is this to be secured? Every wind that blows will not waft a ship on its proper course, and there may be “winds of doctrine,” which instead of aiding men to reach the haven of spiritual rest, may only drive them on rocks or quicksands, where they may “make shipwreck of faith and of a good conscience.”
But with these slight exceptions, the Scriptural evidence in respect of dogma remains exactly as it was. Take any of the Reformation Confessions: the divines who espouse the doctrines asserted in these appeal to the same texts of Scripture in their defence, and expound these in the same way as their predecessors did; and those who impugn these doctrines follow their predecessors in like manner.
It is not, then, in respect of the substance of divine truth that progress in theology is to be sought or expected. There may, nevertheless, be progress even in regard to the cardinal verities of religion. This progress may be both intensive and extensive—intensive, in that by patient study and earnest thought we may penetrate even more and more deeply into the meaning and essence of the divine utterances; and extensive, in that we may apprehend these even more and more in their breadth and length, in their comprehensiveness, in their bearing on the manifestation of God, and in the width of their applicability to the condition and needs of man. We may survey more fully the varied aspects of the truth revealed. We may see more clearly the harmony of the fundamental truths with each other, we may discern more accurately how they fit into each other so as to form a compact system, and we may perceive even more clearly how they are indeed fundamental, how they sustain the entire body of revealed truth, how they give meaning and consistency to many detached utterances in the Bible
281
which are in themselves obscure. We may also, by the use of proper methods, pursue a course of deduction which shall carry us to conclusions beyond those we have already reached, so as, if not to discover new truths, to ascertain more fully the bearings and consequents of the old. We may advance also in the fitting expression of truth in the form of dogma so as to bring our formula to be more truly and fully the expression in words of the signification of what in divers modes is announced to us in Scripture. There is thus a field for salutary progress in different directions, progress which, whilst leaving intact the essentials of Christianity, shall enrich our theology, and enable us to present the unchanging verities of the "everlasting gospel" in forms more fitted to express them adequately, and at the same time more adapted to new conditions of society, and new forms of thought among men.
