Ministerial Reserve
BEFORE me lies a letter, whence written, and by whom, matters not. I shall disclose no more than that the place is not Utopia, and the writer is a living, earnest, and useful minister of the gospel.
It is with a particular passage in the letter that I am at present concerned. Referring to some of his ministerial neighbours, the writer says:—"I find many a good fellow who in conversation can be fearfully heterodox; but let these same men stand up to preach, and you hear nothing but what Moody or Spurgeon would teach. And those who in conversation speak of such men as holding antiquated views and creeds, preach those same truths as matters of direct revelation, of which there can be no possibility of doubt."
My correspondent believes that he has successfully vindicated these ministerial paradoxes, and proved that it is of comparatively little moment that his brethren profess in private to repudiate evangelical teachers and teaching, so long as their public utterances are made to conform to the recognised standard of orthodoxy. The question, however, forces itself upon my attention, and will be answered—which is the real man, the repudiator or the champion? And, without venturing upon the dangerous enquiry as to motive, which is one for the decision of the Master of us all, there is yet another query which needs reply. How far can a man hope to be successful in the public assertion of facts
173
which in private he denies? seeing that the conviction which we secure in others is mainly proportioned to that which exists in ourselves.
Yet another enquiry. How far is the non-success of so many ministers—in soul-winning—due to this duality of sentiment, this fashion of equivocal utterance? I remember a ministerial gathering which, whenever convened, arrayed itself, as if by instinct, according to an order strikingly similar to that which is said to exist in the French Chamber. On the extreme left of the chair was a small but demonstrative body of “advanced thinkers,” men who had the courage of their convictions, and were fully prepared to become their champions at any moment. To these men the “old” truths were antiquated, and must be superseded by the “new,” though how to formulate the new they seemed to be at a loss to say. True exemplars of the “liberal bigotry” of the time, loquacious, demonstrative, cynical, smart in repartee, unsparing in the denunciation of opponents, whom they did not scruple, by covert sneer or open imputation, to brand as Pharisees, or timid time-servers, who dared not preach “a new thing” for very fear; you knew them, what they meant, and how to treat them. Sitting near to these, not by accident, but habit, was a group of the younger men, striving hard to attain a position among the “cultured,” “thoughtful,” “advanced”; but hesitant in utterance, seldom going further than innuendo, and never committing themselves to any definite statement which would mark them as heterodox, but like those preachers to whom my correspondent refers, making their pulpit utterances square with the commonly-accepted standards, albeit with but little emphasis, or fervour, and—it must be confessed—without much to show as the result of their work.
If additions were made to their churches, they were mainly from the Sunday-school, scholars having been led by earnest teachers to the feet of Jesus; or by transfers from other churches; direct conversions, as the result of the ministry, being scarcely looked for. These, if they occurred, might generally be identified as the results of some fugitive evangelistic effort, which was certain to be as strongly marked by the emphatic declaration of what some of us still regard as “the gospel,” as the ordinary ministrations of these men were by its absence. The rest of the assembly would be made up of the mild and timid evangelicals of the “kid-glove persuasion,” careful to a period as to the manner of their utterances; and close to them the more fervent and the most fervent preachers of “the everlasting gospel.”
It is with the section which comes second in order that there is the great difficulty in dealing, to which this paper refers. It seems probable that it might, truthfully, be subdivided into two classes, both marked by that indecision which Shakspere characterizes as
“Letting I dare not, wait upon I would,
Like the poor cat i’ th’ adage.”
One wing coquetting with heterodoxy, yet scarcely decided enough in convictions or intentions finally to cross the line and join the extremists; the other inclining towards the gospel of a crucified Christ with the affection begotten of experience of its truth, yet fearful of
sacrificing the reputation for culture, which "advanced thinking" and the repudiation of "the harsh tenets of Geneva" is thought to secure. What the former class may do when confronted, as even they must occasionally be, with the dread facts of agonizing conviction of sin, and intense human suffering, it is difficult to see. The latter, in all probability, fall back upon the certitudes of the faith, which the tests of time and need render still more certain.
Would it not be well for these brethren of the "Yea-and-Nay" order, in the face of the world's deep want, and the claims of Christ and man, to see to it that their attitude becomes more determinate, and their utterances less equivocal than now? What blessing can be expected to rest upon words spoken with less than the fulness of conviction, with an inspiration less fervent than that of the constraining love of Christ? If in anything in the Christian life, most assuredly in the ministry of the Word, the reference is not to the good-will of men, but to the judgment of God. In his sight the petty distinctions which are characterized by such contemptible epithets as "broad" and "narrow" count for nothing; faithfulness to our trust is all. And while we can afford freely to accord to those who differ from us the right to free speech, so long as the speech is free, and the hearers are permitted to know its meaning and intention, we ought to vindicate, beyond controversy, and in our every utterance, the principle of which experience teaches, not only the right, but the expediency.
"Men should be what they seem." If we believe that that which, to its strength and comfort, the church in all ages has deemed to be the gospel, is so, let us manfully declare our adhesion to it, not suffering our speech, in public or private, to imply anything less; and the rich reward of a clear conscience and a successful ministry will assuredly be ours.
JAMES DANN.
