The Good Earl of Shaftesbury
ON a certain piercingly cold evening, in the early part of 1886, we visited the author of "The Life of the Seventh Earl of Shaftesbury" in his study at Willesden; and in that snug retreat we found our friend surrounded with materials for his great work, the like of which we had never set eyes on before. The archives of the ancestral house of the Ashley-Coopers, in Dorsetshire, had yielded up their treasures without stint; the voluminous diaries, which the seventh Earl had kept from an early period of his life, were all there; and, in addition, there were letters from royal personages at home and abroad, as well as others from a host of the world's principal literary or political celebrities, such as would have caused any eager autograph-hunter to have gone beside himself with excitement. The vast amount of the material thus brought together, as well as its richness, threatened to embarrass the author. Having thus seen for ourselves the difficulties which Mr. Hodder's Herculean task would involve, we are the better able to congratulate him on its accomplishment. The general verdict will be that the book is in all respects well done, and that the great and good nobleman, who was content to forego ease and impair his health for the sake of the suffering and the ignorant, is portrayed as he really lived and laboured. It is a narrative of singular interest; and we advise all who can do so to read the three ample volumes for themselves.
When, in the reign of James I., John Cooper, of Rockborne, in Hampshire, married the daughter and only child of Sir Anthony Ashley, of St. Giles's House, Cranborne, Dorset, the two families became united, from which sprang the lamented philanthropist who has just left us. The son of Lady Anne and Sir Anthony Ashley was the erratic first Lord Shaftesbury of Puritan times, whose uncertain advocacy, first of one party, and then of another, was a source of perplexity to his friends, and of bewilderment to his biographers. The second Earl was of handsome features, but not remarkable either for strength of body or of mind, and his eldest son, the third Earl, was the celebrated author of the "Characteristics." The fourth Earl was a cultured man in the uncultured age of George II.; he was the friend of Handel, the manuscript of whose oratorios he possessed, and of Thomson, the poet of the Seasons, whose writing-table is still preserved at the family seat of St. Giles's. Possessing means which the family could at a later date have used with greater advantage, this enthusiast in art expended thousands sterling on a grotto in the park, made of foreign shells. This is thought to be one of the finest things of the kind in existence. The fifth Earl died in 1811, and was succeeded by his brother, Copley, the sixth Earl. He was the father of our own Lord Shaftesbury, the seventh and the best. Eighty years ago The Gentleman's Magazine referred to "a benevolence that is hereditary in the Shaftesburys": but it was the seventh Earl who best displayed that family feature.
* "The Life and Work of the Seventh Earl of Shaftesbury, K.G." By Edwin Hodder. With portraits. Cassell and Co. Three volumes, 8vo. Price 36s.
65
The childhood of the seventh Earl was a time of suffering such as he ever afterwards looked back upon with horror. He received no sympathy from his parents, his mother having been devoted to fashion and pleasure, and his father to public affairs. "It is clear," remarks Mr. Hodder, "that Lord Ashley and his brothers and sisters, when they were young, experienced unkindness almost amounting to cruelty from both parents, but especially from the mother." Our good Earl himself wrote: "The history of our father and mother would be incredible to most men, and perhaps it would do no good if such facts were recorded."
Of the school to which he was sent at Chiswick, he added: "The memory of that place makes me shudder: it is repulsive to me even now. I think there never was such a wicked school before or since. The place was bad, wicked, filthy; and the treatment was starvation and cruelty."
As a little child he had found a faithful friend in Maria Millis, the housekeeper at St. Giles's, who had been lady's-maid to his mother at Blenheim. This happy Christian woman was his first religious teacher: it was she who first interested him in the Bible, and taught him to pray in words which he continued to use until his old age. The death of this family servant was a severe trial to the child so unhappily circumstanced; but he bore up bravely, never forgot the lessons she had taught, and her own gold watch, which she bequeathed to him, appears to have been the only watch which the Earl wore till the end of his long life. Let godly servants note how great may be their power to influence those around them: Maria Millis did great service in having helped to give the world the good Lord Shaftesbury.
His transfer from "Dotheboys' Hall," otherwise the Manor House, at Chiswick, to Harrow, was a grateful change so far as outward surroundings were concerned. Young Ashley had an ardent yearning after spiritual things, but he was not sufficiently settled in his opinions to think for himself until he was twenty-five. While his mother neglected him, his father was content that he could give correct answers to the questions of the Church Catechism. The religion of the household did not rise above the cold Anglican formalism of the time, having been warm in nothing save its prejudices. It was thought meritorious to hate Dissenters; and the Bible Society was denounced as an institution dangerous alike to Church and State. "It was not till I was twenty-five years old, or thereabouts, that I got hold of Scott's Commentary on the Bible," said the Earl in later days; "and, struck with the enormous difference between his views and those to which I had been accustomed, I began to think for myself." He does not mean that he became converted at that time, for he always held that he commenced his spiritual life at seven years of age, under the Christian teaching of Maria Millis. His first aspirations to become a philanthropist came at Harrow, when he was about fourteen. He was one day startled by seeing five drunken men carrying a coffin to the grave. Shouting certain Bacchanalian lines, they allowed the coffin to fall to the earth. "Good heavens!" exclaimed the horrified school-boy to himself, "Can this be permitted simply because the man was poor and friendless?"
According to his own confession, he learned very little while at
5
Harrow, having been too fond of amusement to make the most of his opportunities. He next passed some time with a relative, who was a clergyman in Derbyshire. Here he indulged in various out-door sports, and in visiting a neighbouring family who were glad to entertain him. "Perhaps no two years were ever so misspent," said the Earl. "I hardly ever opened a book, and seldom heard anything that was worth hearing; nevertheless, there were constantly floating in my mind all sorts of aspirations, though I never took a step to make their fulfilment possible." The next stage, in 1819, took him to Christ Church, Oxford, where one of the greatest surprises of his life occurred, when, in 1822, he took a first class in classics. Thus he came to the end of his student days. "And now I am twenty-five years old," he wrote, on April 28th, 1826, "a great age for one who is neither wise, nor good, nor useful, nor endowed with capability of becoming so."
Viewed from a temporal standpoint, his situation at this time was not altogether an enviable one; for he wanted to find a vocation, and as the heir of a leading peer of limited means he was not so free to choose as young men of humbler station. He had his ambitious dreams, days when he had "thought of nothing but fame and immortality," and when he altogether resented "the idea of dying and being forgotten." When he was twenty-six, however, he had quite sobered down, and desired above all things to be useful, and in every situation to exemplify true Christianity. "Whether I shall ever be well off or not, God alone knows," he wrote about this time; "but this I pray that, never asking for wealth, should it be sent to me, I may receive at the same time a heart and spirit to lay it out for men's happiness and God's glory." Should he take to a political career? Or should he give his energies to science and literature? In any one of these pursuits he might, probably, have made his mark; but his life-work was opening in another direction. For a short time he held office under the Duke of Wellington as Commissioner of the India Board of Control; and under Sir Robert Peel he was engaged at the Admiralty Board, in 1835; but he soon turned aside from the arena of party politics to fight the cause of the oppressed.
It was Lord Ashley who led the way in promoting the reform of the Lunacy Laws; and truly there was urgent need of such reform. Since the Act of Edward II., in the fourteenth century, which provided that the king should "have the custody of the lands of natural fools," the lot of deranged persons had been a cruel one. As late as the reign of George III., the unhappy inmates of "Bedlam" could be seen as one of the sights of London for a small charge; and the horrible severity with which they were treated was supposed to be most proper and commendable. The Quakers set the example of other methods in their asylum at York, at the end of the last century. The exposure of the atrocities practised at Bethlehem Hospital made a sensation in 1815; but it was not until Lord Ashley took up the subject with determination that better times for the insane really came. He retained his interest in this department until the last, and showed it by remaining for fifty years Chairman of the Lunacy Commission.
It was chiefly as the friend of the industrial classes in the great
67
centres of manufacture that Lord Ashley was destined to make his mark, however; and those alone who are capable of realizing in some degree what the condition of the common people was half a century ago can estimate what a task the reformer took in hand. The accumulated evils of generations of neglect and indifference were seen on every hand to inspire dismay and alarm. When he visited the worst parts of Glasgow, in 1839, Lord Ashley found it "intersected by small alleys, like gutters, crammed with houses, dunghills, and human beings"; and the condition in which the people lived was said to be the cause of nine-tenths of the crime and of the disease which abounded. The unhappy people who herded in Whitechapel and Bethnal Green were in a similar plight; and, after exploring those districts for himself, Lord Ashley intimated that neither pen nor pencil could describe the filth and degradation as they were, adding that "one whiff of Cow Yard, Blue Anchor, or Baker's Court outweighs ten pages of letterpress." The almost universal ignorance of the poor was quite in keeping with their physical ills. A few charity schools were found here and there, but in one instance, at Oldham and Ashton, an area eight miles long and four miles broad, containing a population of 105,000, there was not a day-school at all for the poor. No wonder that the evils of popular ignorance, about which John Foster had so pathetically written, were showing themselves in many aggravated forms. Crime was so rampant that the brutally severe laws framed for its repression seemed to be ineffective; and when times became bad, in consequence of the disturbed state of trade and agriculture, the suffering people, who were too ignorant to see what the causes were which led up to their trouble, vented their wrath in a savage manner.
Riots and incendiary fires were the order of the day; and the country was fast approaching an outbreak which would repeat the horrors of the French Revolution. In such a state of things Lord Ashley sacrificed his own interests for the sake of fighting the cause of the poor.
The development of the factory system in England had led to many changes, and especially to an amount of suffering among child-operatives which was disgraceful to the country. In the olden time, the spinning-wheel used to be part of the furniture of an ordinary peasant's home; and it was not until after the middle of the last century that the primitive mode was superseded by the spinning-jenny of Hargreaves, a Lancashire man, whose contrivance for working a number of wheels at the same time so enraged his fellow-operatives that they broke his machines, and drove him from the county. Further advances were made by the invention of Arkwright; water-power was utilized, and factories sprung up in rural districts, with houses attached for the unhappy "apprentices," who, for the chief part, were supplied from the workhouses of London and the large towns. The parish guardians were glad to be thus relieved of a burden which weighed heavily upon the rates. Such was the avaricious anxiety of mill-owners to make their machines as profitable as possible, that their engines worked by night as well as by day, and the atmosphere of the work-rooms was deadly. We can judge of the hardships of the workers by the fact that an attempt to restrict their labour to ten
hours a day should have been so fiercely opposed by the mill-owners. The appointment of a Royal Commission, in 1833, to enquire into the condition of the juvenile operatives was resented by the reformers, because it was thought that no further evidence was needed in respect to the disgraceful abuses which abounded. The commissioners with their own eyes, however, saw enough to touch their hearts when, at Leeds, "three thousand ragged, wretched little ones," and five times as many spectators, came to the hotel to plead for consideration, the children having "Ten Hours' Bill" printed on slips of paper in their hats. How the battle, stage after stage, was fought and won, is far too long a story to be told in this place; but the struggle, from first to last, was one of the most exciting passages of our social history. The Earl has been thought by some to have been at times injudicious in his public utterances; but, however this may have been, he won the battle of the poor. He carried on the warfare from the dark opening days, when not two mill-owners were on his side, to the triumphant close, when not two were against him.
The atrocities brought to light, in connection with the employment of women and children in mines and collieries, were appalling; and the sufferings of the child chimney-sweeps were a standing disgrace to a civilized country. To these our hero gave his earnest attention. In one instance after another evils were removed; and at length the Christian nobleman who was the chief agent in effecting their removal, was recognised and honoured as the great benefactor of the working-classes.
To fight such a battle, and to win such a series of victories, with few, save the poor, for his allies, was an achievement to be remembered. Meanwhile, as we look back on the conflict through the long vista of an entire generation, the question, "Who helped the Earl in his work, and who opposed him?" becomes fraught with uncommon interest. Here is what our late venerated friend himself wrote on this subject, not very long before his departure:—
"I started to assail home interests with every one, save a few unimposing persons, against me. O'Connell was a sneering and bitter opponent. . . Bright was ever my most malignant opponent. . . Cobden, though bitterly hostile, was better than Bright. He abstained from opposition on the Collieries Bill, and gave positive support on the Calico Print-works Bill. Gladstone is on a level with the rest; he gave no support to the Ten Hours' Bill; he voted with Sir R. Peel to rescind the famous division in favour of it. He was the only member who endeavoured to delay the Bill which delivered women and children from mines and pits; and never did he say a word on behalf of the factory children, until, defending slavery in the West Indies, he taunted Buxton with indifference to the slavery in England! Lord Brougham was among my most heated opponents. He spoke strongly against the Bill in 1847. Miss Martineau also gave her voice and strength in resistance to the measure."
Long before this, or in 1841, Lord Ashley had asked, "To whom should I have naturally looked for the chief aid? Why, undoubtedly to the clergy." From these, however, with some bright exceptions, he "received no support, or next to none"; and this was
69
the rule throughout his earlier career. Probably this shows how great have been the strides made in public morality. If the flagrant abuses in question were in existence now, the clergy would certainly be found on the right side: at least, we hope so. We give these extracts merely to show the Earl's own view of the situation.
In our limited space it would be impossible to give even a brief summary of the many reforms and controversies in which Lord Shaftesbury took part in his earlier days; and we will, therefore, take notice of a few things which help to portray the man, and enable us the better to understand the reasons of his success.
He was always extremely careful about his facts, never having been content to accept anything at second-hand. He says: "In factories, I examined the mills and the machinery, and saw the workers and their work in all its details." "In collieries, I went down into the pits. In London, I went into lodging-houses and thieves' haunts, and every filthy place. It gave me a power I could not otherwise have had. I could speak of things from actual experience, and I used often to hear things from the poor sufferers themselves, which were invaluable to me."
In the Continental tour, which he took with his wife in 1833, he carefully noted the contrasts met with in the cantons of Switzerland. "This contrast is very remarkable throughout the Confederacy," he says; "everywhere the Protestant cantons exhibit a picture of order, cleanliness, and taste. Dirt and discomfort are the guardian spirits of the Roman Catholic."
His family relationships were peculiar: helpful to the last degree on the one hand, and depressing on the other; at least they were so for a lengthened period in the earlier part of his life. His wife—a daughter of the fifth Earl Cowper, of Panshanger—was in all respects a model countess, and to her, under God, much of the great philanthropist's success was due. This is how he wrote about her in 1839: "Took a walk with Minny. Much interesting conversation with the darling. It is a wonderful accomplishment, and a most beautiful answer to one's prayers, to have obtained a wife, in the highest matters and the smallest details, after my imagination and my heart. Often do I recollect the very words and sentiments of my entreaties to God, that he would give me a wife for my comfort, improvement, and safety. He has granted me to the full all that I desired, and far more than I deserved. Praised be his holy name!" This devoted woman was spared to her husband for forty-one years, and when, on the 15th of October, 1872, she departed hence, "almost her last words were, 'None but Christ, none but Christ!'"
His relationship with his father was far less happy; but a reconciliation took place in the fall of 1839. For ten years Lord Ashley had not crossed the threshold of the ancestral home. He had gone forth a young man, whose aims and sympathies were uncongenial to his parents; he returned with a wife and six children. This estrangement had, for years, been one of the chief crosses of his life, and when it was ended, the removal of such a weight from his mind called forth many expressions of gratitude. We find him writing, "I do most entirely thank God for his mercy in softening my father's heart, and pouring therein the sympathies of charity and truth. Not only in great things, but in the smallest, there is a wonderful and a complete change."
This will help us to realize at what a cost to himself Lord Ashley carried on the work to which he had set his hand. With his opportunities, what a position of ease and affluence might he not have won had he chosen to go with the stream, and to leave the suffering and the poor to themselves! What he endured from nervous excitement, from overwork, from attack and misrepresentation, and even from poverty, one can learn, in some measure, from Mr. Hodder's volumes. In regard to straitened means, we find him writing in 1841: "My finances are low, very low, but I and mine have yet, blessed be his name, the barrel of meal and the cruse of oil!" During the greater part of his life it was a serious trial to him to be presiding at public meetings on behalf of great charities, and to have so little to give from his own purse. Few can appreciate this but persons of large heart and delicate sensibility: we know that it was often the cross of his life, and only splendid self-forgetfulness could have enabled him to work on as he did with this drawback hindering him.
The appointment of Dr. Alexander, a converted Jew, as Bishop of Jerusalem, was an exciting incident in 1841, and one that brought Lord Ashley into close contact with the good King, the late Frederic William of Prussia. The High Church party, and the Puseyites, though willing to make great advances towards Rome, were averse to joining hands in any work with the Lutheran Church. In the following year, the Tractarian controversy broke out; and we see in what things Lord Ashley differed from Dr. Pusey—his old college comrade and life-long friend. "You speak of 'abhorring our principles'; are you quite sure that you know them?" wrote the churchman. "I may reply," returned the philanthropist, "Are you quite sure that you know them yourself?" Lord Ashley soon afterwards ventured a prophecy, which is even now in course of fulfilment: "The issue I have long foreseen is approaching; a collision between the clergy and the mass of the people. The Church will destroy itself."
What Lord Ashley did in opposing the opium traffic, and in promoting the establishment of Ragged Schools, is told at length by Mr. Hodder. He was, perhaps, more than anything else, the friend of poor children. The work of the Ragged School Union may, in some respects, be regarded as his greatest work. What London was in those days, few really knew, save the friend of the poor himself, and the few heroic souls who were then associated with him in what was really a service of danger. With what holy elation did the grand old man speak of the stirring days when myriads of children were saved from the gutter, from homes of infamy, and from schools of crime—the total in about forty years having amounted to 300,000! If this had been the whole of his life-work, he would have lived in history as one of the greatest benefactors of his country.
In one other paper we hope to depict the latter part of our late venerated friend's career—the days in which he lived and worked as Lord Shaftesbury.
