The "Down-Grade" Joke — By R. F. Weymouth, D.Lit., M.A

IF any further proof were needed that the solemn warnings recently given in this magazine concerning the present state of the Christian ministry and the Christian church were not ill-timed, it is furnished by a recent paragraph in The Freeman. To many readers it must have been a sorrowful surprise to read the opening paragraph in the issue of October 7th. The paragraph in question begins the account given by "Our Own Delegate," of his visit to Yorkshire to attend the Sheffield Assembly. Of the Baptist ministers and delegates who were his fellow-travellers to that assembly, "Our Own Delegate" says, "a merry party we were"; and to that surely no objection can be justly made. But the account proceeds to state that among these ministers and others (whether in the "too excellent, well-cushioned saloons" or in the third class is not absolutely clear), "Of course, the great joke was the Down-Grade question. It did not seem to be treated very seriously. It was about thus: Most thought it was but the 'big gooseberry' of the dull season. The successful men had little sympathy with the outcry. The unsuccessful thought, 'Say what you will, there is something in it.'" It is right to say at once that I learn on good authority that the particular phrase "big gooseberry" did not refer to Mr. Spurgeon's articles, but to newspaper correspondence and articles.
But omitting from consideration that one expression so unhappily, and, no doubt, unintentionally equivocal, there yet remains the mournful fact that such a subject was treated only as a joke by such men. It was not any particular extravagance or absurdity that some more able man or more "successful" preacher pointed out in Mr. Spurgeon's way of putting the case. It was the "question" as a whole that seemed so ludicrous; that is to say, the question whether the Christian church at this present time is or is not on the perilous inclined plane of laxity, alike of doctrine and of practice. This it was which constituted, "of course, the great joke," far transcending all others in brilliancy, which was especially relished by the merry party of Baptist deacons and divines. Such is the statement which "Our Own Delegate" has put on record, substantiated by his personal evidence as having been himself one of the party.
But for such evidence, one could not but ask, can it possibly be true? That the purity of those who are "the salt of the earth," the clearness of the shining of those who are "the light of the world," the health and vigour or sickness and failure and decrepitude of "the church, which is his body," should be a matter of indifference to any who profess and call themselves Christians, is melancholy enough. But here we find "men of light and leading" among us (to borrow once more Burke's oft-quoted phrase) to whom this subject not only does not seem a momentous one, one deserving of being "treated very seriously," but who find in it matter of laughter, merely a fitting playground for their wit. Or shall we be told, those of us who share Mr. Spurgeon's views, as I do in saddest sincerity, that we have altogether misread our Bibles, missed—in the dulness and crass stupidity that characterizes us all,
and notably Mr. Spurgeon—the humorous element in the Scriptures, and misunderstood the spirit of the apostles and of our divine Lord himself, and that therefore such notions as ours are, "of course," only fit to be treated with derision?
Without entering into a long disquisition, let me entreat the serious attention of my readers—my jocund friends included—to just four passages in the authorities we all profess to revere.
1. As to Christian practice: "Be not conformed to this world," writes St. Paul to some whom he regarded as holy and heavenly-minded men—"God's beloved ones, [his] called holy ones." Indeed, one would think, to read the Epistles of Paul, that he was earnestly desirous that all his converts should live in the world, as though they were not of it, with their affections set on higher objects, mindful ever that their citizenship is in heaven, ever gazing with longing eyes at the things that are eternal though unseen, the "eternal weight of glory." But is all this an error? Was the inspired writer (whatever that inspiration may have been) only laughing in his sleeve when he wrote about not being "conformed to this world"? If he were now here among us, with Timothy and Titus and Silvanus, and his other helpers in the ministry of the Word, would they all frequent balls and card-parties, and go in a body with the Rev. A. B. and the Rev. C. D., and a dozen or two of their deacons, not to that prayer-meeting yonder (which is good enough for less-exalted souls, and may suit their dimly-lighted intellects), but to hear Henry Irving and Miss Terry, or to witness "Les Cloches de Belville," and then would he declare amidst universal merriment and nods of judicious approval, that he had only been jesting in his Epistle to the Roman Christians?
2. As to doctrine: St. John writes (as correctly given in the Revised Version in verse 9 of his Second Epistle), "Whosoever goeth onward (mary, taketh the lead) and abideth not in the teaching of Christ, hath not God: he that abideth in the teaching, the same hath both the Father and the Son." I have been accustomed for many years to regard these words as containing a warning of simply awful import, a warning prophetically uttered concerning precisely that loudly-vaunted "advanced thought" which will "lead onward," and which refuses to abide in the teaching of the apostles concerning Christ and his redeeming work. Is there not something said somewhere about a tall fabric erected of "wood, hay, stubble" being wholly consumed, with the dreadful addition that the builder himself is only "saved so as through fire"? Truly, it makes one shudder. What then of him who "hath not God"? A Christian teacher who turns a deaf ear to the voices of prophets, psalmists, apostles, and finds what he thinks is better spiritual pabulum in the works of modern philosophers and poets, or in his own lucubrations! If indeed he "hath not God," what an awakening for him hereafter! But doubtless our merry divines will decry all this as a mere hallucination. "Look closer," methinks I hear one of them say, "and read between the lines, and you will clearly see the reflection of a quiet smile on the writer's face: it is only a joke!" Yes, indeed, a ghastly and impious joke!
3. As to anxiety on the part of ministers concerning the work to which they are—or are supposed to be—called of God, St. Paul
563
enumerates his sufferings for the Lord's sake: "Of the Jews five times received I forty stripes save one, thrice was I beaten with rods," and so on, culminating in this, "There is that which presseth upon me daily, anxiety for all the churches. Who is weak, and I am not weak? Who is made to stumble, and I burn not?" So elsewhere, in addressing the elders of the Ephesian church, he bids them "remember that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears." But times have changed. It is not so now. Now let any one lift up the voice of warning, and ministers and deacons and delegates will listen certainly, but it is for the fun of the thing! Facetiousness runs rampant! See what energy he displays in beating the air and chasing shadows full gallop! Oh, it is a "great joke"! Yes, our ministers, the "successful men"—by the way, I have been puzzling myself to find out how this epithet would be expressed, to do it justice, in New Testament Greek: had I been in one of those "well-cushioned" saloons I might have had the question answered; but to return—our "successful" ministers, or at least some of them (for, thanks be to God, there are many exceptions still) are wiser than the apostle pretended to be, and no such anxiety distresses their tranquil lives, provided they themselves are "successful."
4. As to responsibility: (and does not responsibility press specially and heavily on our men of light and leading?) it is the "venerable nomen Iesu" that I have now to appeal to; let us listen with bowed head: "Whoso shall cause one of these little ones which believe on me to stumble, it were better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and that he were drowned in the depth of the sea." It has been often remarked that our Lord was never known to laugh. There is no "joke" here; and if it is so that the Church is deluding herself with a mere idle conceit that she is "rich and increased with goods, and has need of nothing;" while some, perhaps many, of her ministers and other men of influence are tripping up babes in the faith with stumbling-blocks in matters either of faith or practice, those solemn words of our Lord may possibly have some bearing on the case. Dear brethren, "successful" and "unsuccessful" alike, who may chance to read this pag, ponder those words of Jesus, I beseech you, and consider how far, if ae all, they are intended or available for your guidance and admonition.t
No doubt, there are fitting times to be jocund, and fitting subjects for merriment too; but also there are times when God will "set a mark upon the foreheads of the men that sigh and that cry," and there were some of old for whom "a book of remembrance was written before him." It is assuredly better to be among those "that weep now," for they "shall laugh" hereafter.
