Notices of Books
PLEASE note that books which are reviewed in these pages are honestly judged upon their own merits, and not upon the merits of their authors. When we receive a book, and consider it to be upon the whole a good one, we do not think it right to condemn it because its author has been heretical in other works. We are not judging the man, nor the whole of his writings, but simply the volume before us. It may be wise to intimate in our review that the writer is not considered to be sound; but sometimes we are not aware of that fact, and we cannot be supposed to know everything. If any questionable book has received commendation from the editor, or his helpers, it has been done in ignorance; for we have no sympathy with any departure from the faith once delivered to the saints. At the same time, we decline to follow those rabid brethren who will not accept a good book because at some time or other, or on some point or other, the writer was not absolutely orthodox. Before us are many works, and we do our best to weigh them; but we know that we make mistakes, and we have no hope of rising out of the danger of doing so. It may be well to note that nearly all the notices are by the editor, but some few are from other hands, so that it may not always be correct to quote these notices, as publishers constantly do, as by C. H. Spurgeon in The Sword and the Trowel. This is mentioned merely for the sake of accuracy, and not because the editor wishes to escape from the responsibility of anything which he inserts. So many books come before us, and so many other matters claim our attention, that we may accidentally let a black sheep pass muster, but it will not be so if we can help it. The marvel is that, despite our supposed severity, books come to us in such great numbers: certainly it is not because we flatter. We know that our favourable word is worth having, for in several instances a whole edition has been sold by one of our notices, at least so the authors have gratefully acknowledged. This makes us the more careful in our judgment. We should think it a robbery of the public to recommend a book out of personal
friendship to its writer. Strict impartiality has been our rule, so far as a fallible mortal can be unbiased, and we believe that this constitutes the value of our review department, such as it is.
We give an extra quantity of notices this month, that we may get clear before the new books come in.
A Century of Village Nonconformity at Bluntisham, Hunts. 1787 to 1887. By R. W. DIXON.
AN extremely interesting chapter in the history of Nonconformity. The church in Bluntisham has, indeed, an honourable record in the past. May its future be worthy of its palmiest days! Coxe Feary, the founder of the community, is a name enrolled among the worthies of our Israel, and we feel grateful to Mr. Dixon for making him more widely known. A copy of this well-written history should be found in every Nonconformist's library. It is not a dry narration of facts, with lists of names and statistics, but is an all-alive account of the struggles and triumphs of brave men who dissented when it was costly to dissent, and suffered for the faith because they had a faith worth suffering for. This book ought to be published in London, but it bears no name except that of the printer. Copies can be purchased of the pastor of the church, Mr. W. C. Bryan, for a half-crown each.
Vita Vinctis. By ROBINA F. HARDY, ANNIE S. SWAN, and JESSIE M. E. SAXBY. Edinburgh: Oliphant, Anderson, and Ferrier.
A GROUP of five stories equally good. They breathe a true missionary spirit, and are calculated to inspire a sense of duty and courage in the face of many difficulties. Fiction in her homeliest garb is well used to convey the truth.
Tom Larkins; or, the Boy who was no good. By C. A. BURNABY. Religious Tract Society.
A SHILLING story-book, telling how a very bad boy became a very good boy, and even a choir boy. It is rather sensational, but no more so than tales of its class. It is more suitable for the village church boys than for our well-taught Sabbath scholars.
35
Israel: a Prince with God. The Story of Jacob re-told. By Rev. F. B. MEYER, B.A. Morgan and Scott.
EXCEEDINGLY good. Not only spiritual, as everything from our brother Mr. Meyer would be, but also thoughtful, fresh, suggestive, and thoroughly practical. We rejoice at every remembrance of the good work done in Melbourne Hall, Leicester, by this laborious worker, and we are glad to see that Mr. Meyer is likely to be useful with his pen, as well as with his tongue. Oh, that hundreds of our younger men gave signs of such real godliness, such true devotion, and such clear knowledge of the gospel as we see in this pastor!
Moses: his Life and Times. By GEORGE RAWLINSON, M.A. ["The Men of the Bible" series.] Nisbet and Co.
As easy to read as a story-book. Its information is wonderful. Our author makes Moses live before your eyes. Such is the writer's acquaintance with Eastern history, manners, and scenery, that he becomes the Macaulay of Moses, only without the inaccuracy of our English historian. This is grand change for half-a-crown. If the other "Men of the Bible" find such biographers, the publishers will have to enlarge their premises. Friend, buy this book. We believe you will thank us for the advice when you find yourself fairly fascinated by it.
Solomon: his Life and Times. By Rev. F. W. FARRAR, D.D., F.R.S. Nisbet and Co.
ARCHDEACON FARRAR has a highly picturesque style; but his attractions lie not in his style only, he has something to say which is the product of wide knowledge and profound thought. We wish we could trust him, but we cannot; we find that his statements, when they verge upon theology, often need confirmation, and frequently require revision. He is too credulous towards modern criticism, and treats a mere assertion of a sceptical scholar as if it were an unquestionable fact. In the present case, much can be learned from this life; but the reader should regard it as little more than a notable guess at
Solomon's history. How the great king ended his career the reader is likely to know quite as well as the Archdeacon. If the reader is also wise enough to find the Lord Christ and his church in the Canticles, he may feel it no shame to agree with Bernard, even though Farrar should chide him. Yet, with every discount, Farrar's "Solomon" is well worth reading, and it constitutes such a magnificent word-picture of the great king that one rises from it with a more vivid idea of the royal preacher than one is likely to obtain by any other means. The cost is only half-a-crown: the literary taste, and skill, and learning are worth a thousand crowns at the least.
Praise: Meditations on the One Hundred and Third Psalm. By MARK GUY PEARSE. T. Woolmer.
To Christian people who have a relish for holy things it is only needful to say that this is another book by Mark Guy Pearse. At once they ask, "What is the price?" It is priceless, but it costs 2s. 6d. to transfer the stock.
Common Praise: a Hand-Book of Non-conformist Church Music. By F. G. EDWARDS. J. Curwen and Sons.
THOSE who are enamoured of choirs and organs will here find directions derived from the experience of an adept in the science, who was once organist at Surrey Chapel. We maintain a stern simplicity of worship as a protest against the elaborate ceremonials of the day which even Dissenters run after. "All things are lawful unto me, but all things are not expedient." It is expedient to me, doubtless, to endeavour to show that a congregation can be maintained without tickling their ears with music. Behold, they go to their churches and chapels and enjoy sweet sounds which charm their senses, and they suppose that their sensations of delight are spiritual worship. "But it attracts the young people." Perhaps it does, and the reason is a handy one; but it puts us in mind of the widowers who never marry to please themselves, but always for the sake of the children. Why not advocate Japanese juggling on Sunday because it would attract the young? We shall come to that yet, or even to worse.
495
Theism and Evolution. By JOSEPH S. VAN
DYKE, D.D. Hodder and Stoughton. A SERIOUS attempt to refute the atheistic theory of evolution on its own ground! We are emphatic on that word "serious." Our modern sceptics, infidels, and anti-theists have a way of their own, and that is by no means a serious one. They are for the most part scoffers. They sneer, joke, pun, chaff, and laugh at their own jests, rather than listen to the voices of reason and revelation. We do not suppose that there are many, if any, unbelievers who are such by pure conviction. They are entangled: the books they read, or the companions they associate with, hold them captive.
It is not want of temper on our part, but haughtiness of tone on their part, which prompts this reflection. We judge that their conceited mannerism conceals a latent mistrust, or unrest of conscience. Few men carry their hearts on their sleeves; fewer still have had the courage to register the action and reaction of their own conscience. One book of this kind has been the priceless treasure of centuries. Little men have dotted down little things in their own line; but still, "The Confessions of Augustine" shines out and sparkles, a star of first magnitude. Their savants are only meteors in comparison with our saints; but yet they are too wise in their own conceit to acknowledge any sense of frailty.
Disciples of Christ are often harassed with doubts, which distress them much, though they cannot destroy their faith. Floats there in our mind a distich by a poet of the last century—"But stop, my friend, a still small whisper hear; he knows no faith who never had a fear." If this be so with true believers, how must things fare with those who have no faith, but, like houseless mendicants, are seeking one? Any honest, ingenuous thinker, who has cut himself adrift from the traditions of his childhood, "the prophecy," as said Solomon, "that his mother taught him"—a tradition which grew with his growth, and ripened with his rising years—must, if sincere, be startled ever and anon with shocks that electrify his inmost soul; else he may justly suspect that his conscience is affected with a creeping paralysis, and is in peril of being seared as with a hot iron.
Dr. Van Dyke speaks of "atheistic forms of evolution." Have any of our friends ever challenged the meaning of that word evolution? For our own part, we do not exactly know what it correctly expresses; though we presume it is borrowed from the most exact of all the sciences. In our school days we understood it to be an algebraic or geometrical term, the reverse of involution: this latter being the raising of powers, while the former was said to be the extraction of roots. Involution was the multiplying of a quantity into itself any given number of times; while evolution taught us to find the particular root of a number. But the old text books of our boyhood stand us in poor stead to-day. We hear old familiar words, but they have new and unfamiliar meanings attached to them. Of course it is to Charles Darwin's famous treatise on "The Origin of Species" that we owe the fresh impetus given to the study of nature in our times. The theorists who have followed in his wake—notably Mr. Herbert Spencer and Professor Huxley—in their attempt to dispense with God and guidance, revelation and religion, have far outstripped all those deductions which can be supported by exact observations, though the aforesaid observations are vaunted as of higher value than any oracle of heaven. How the first spark of life was kindled without Jehovah, the universal Father; without the Eternal Son, who hath life in himself; without the Holy Spirit, who quickens, illuminates, and energizes every animate, sentient, intelligent phenomenon of the animal and physical cosmos; without, in fact, the Trinity in Unity and the Unity in Trinity of the holy catholic faith, is a problem in front of which our most advanced thinkers halt, as if they had reached a gulf they could not ford or fathom.
The volume before us is modest and well meant. The author assumes that Scripture and science are never at variance, optical illusions notwithstanding. Books like this are not worthless, even if they do not fall like thunderbolts upon the encampment of the Philistines; for they rouse the patriotism of our noble army of Christian recruits. Our batteries must never cease firing in this warfare, whether we silence our
assailants or not. Since Darwin's death, the scientists have been so feeble in fight that we suspect they run rather short of ammunition. "Evolution" in geometry we all accept, but evolution as a scheme for dispensing with a Creator will soon be numbered with the dreams of folly.
Sunny Sundays. Hints for Conversational Classes. The Fruits of the Spirit. By S. M. HOLWORTHY. Nisbet and Co.
AN odd book. Grandma says some very good things to her little congregation; but the whole concern is rather a mix-up. The dear god-children (whatever that may mean) were in very safe hands in the main; but we hope the majority of Christian parents reading this magazine would prove to be equally clear and able instructors. We are not much struck with the work.
Echoes from a Village Church: Words spoken in the Parish Church of Hinton Waldrist. By the Rev. F. HARPER, M.A. Shaw and Co.
SHORT—very short, but sweet. We seem to recognize the titles of several of these sermons, and a good deal of their material; but as the preacher does not conceal his obligations, we do not mention this as a fault. He has preached Christ earnestly and briefly, and he deserves our hearty thanks.
Rays from the Sun of Righteousness. By the Rev. RICHARD NEWTON, D.D. Edinburgh: Oliphant, Anderson, and Ferrier.
Hible Warnings. Same author and publishers.
THESE are first class. Anything for the young by Dr. Richard Newton should be within reach of every Sunday-school teacher and scholar.
Young People's Prayer Meetings, in Theory and Practice. By Rev. F. E. CLARK. Funk and Wagnalls, 44, Fleet Street.
THE plan of prayer-meetings for the children is very well defended, explained, and enlarged upon. We do not think there is much that is new or very suggestive to a pastor who is already wide awake; but it will prove useful to workers among the young,
who want showing how. The book is American, but the work which it advocates will suit every land.
The Children for Christ. By Rev. ANDREW MURRAY. Nisbet and Co.
ALTHOUGH we are unable to accept all that our writer puts before us, and cannot endorse his teaching upon infant baptism, we most cordially recommend the book. We would venture to say that if every mother in our land could be possessed of a copy, and train her children according to the spirit of the volume, the rising generation would be a holy and God-learing one. Portions for each day are followed by simple and short prayers, and both must prove helpful.
The Daily Fountain for the Young. By JOHN MITCHELL. Partridge and Co.
A COMBINATION of Daily Portion and Birthday Album. The price is only two shillings. The texts are instructively selected. We cannot say that we judge the meditations to be at all deep or striking; but they are devout and orthodox. Many young people would be glad to own such a Birthday Book.
A Garland from the Parables. By WILLIAM EDENSOR LITTLEWOOD, M.A., late Vicar of St. James', Bath. Second edition. W. Mack.
WE do not wonder that these poems survive. They have a pith and a force in them which make them too vital for oblivion. If they had been turned into prose they would not have been prosy, and that is no ill test to which to put a friend's verses. If there is no point in the sense itself, it is idle to put the words into rhyme; for what is rhyme without reason? Mr. Littlewood gives us interpretations of those parables from which he culls his garland. Here is a pretty, sententious bit:—
THE TARES AND THE WHEAT.
"But he said, Nay; lest while ye gather up the tares, ye root up also the wheat with them."—Matthew xiii. 29.
In olden time, to weed the land
Required an eye discreet.
And rightly, for we understand
Their tares were like the wheat.
And still in modern days we pause;
Alias! that no one dares
To hint that we refrain, because
Our wheat is like the tares.
497
Notes on the Book of the Revelation.
By THOMAS NEWBERRY. John F.
Shaw and Co.
Wherein Millenarians are Wrong. By
REV. JAMES GALL. Hamilton, Adams,
and Co.
The Two Dispensations: Gentile and
Millennial. By JOHN WILLIAMS.
Elliot Stock.
WHAT though the labouring press is
groaning beneath the prolific multiplica-
tion of books on the Apocalypse, none
need be displeased or distracted in any
degree by the number of the commen-
tators, nor by the variety of their com-
mentaries. One prefatory verse of "THE
REVELATION" itself has for a long time
buzzed in our ears, and held us spell-
bound. It is the third verse of the first
chapter, "Blessed is he that readeth,"
&c. The student is thus encouraged to
hope that he may keep abreast with
the seer, and he who reads may become
almost as entranced as he was who
wrote it, with the enchanting symbolism
which depicts in glowing colours, and
describes in gorgeous language, things
that were, things that be, and things
that shall be hereafter. Possibly it may
hap here among the students, as in the
parable, among the expectant virgins,
some may be wise and some foolish. It is
for our friends to appraise the value of
this conjecture. Our main pity at the
moment is for the majority of those who
publish their lucubrations. As there is
no blessing pronounced on the perusal
of commentaries, our fear for the large
majority of such authors is that their
enterprise will not pay the expense of
a first edition. But that is mere detail.
The three volumes before us are
"diverse one from another," though they
are all of them published in this year of
grace 1887. Let us say a word upon
each.
Mr. Newberry is always interesting.
His gloss aims to be brief, analytical,
accurate, and devout. It ought to be
very helpful to the average student of
Scripture, who does not know enough
of the niceties of the Greek to follow
the original text. We suppose that
subscribers to Mr. Hurditch's "Foot-
steps of Truth" have already sampled
this work in the pages of that periodical
with a considerable measure of satisfac-
tion.
Mr. Gall seems to be a partisan of
present religious societies; so he is
jealous of any interpretation of prophecy
or parable that might perchance put the
skid on popular efforts for the conver-
sion of the world. His voice falters at
the chorus of the Apocalypse, "Even
so, come, Lord Jesus," in response to
him who saith, "Surely I come quickly.
Amen." To his idea, a literal interpre-
tation of the sure word of prophecy
betrays a misunderstanding, both of the
purport of the manifesto and the pur-
pose for which it has been published.
What with Sunday-schools, Missionary
Associations, Mildmay Park Confer-
ences, and the Salvation Army, he
thinks we are driving the team faster
than it ever sped since the days of the
apostles. Alas, say we, that the show
of vitality is so spasmodic! As we are
unable to concede his premises it would
be useless for us to parley about his
conclusions. While he imagines that
the whole world is to be brought under
the sway of the Redeemer, before he
cometh with clouds, we fail to imagine
why, in that case, "all kindreds of the
earth shall wail because of him." So,
amidst visions of the night, our dreams
differ.
Lastly, Mr. John Williams, in a book
of larger bulk, far too clever, too con-
fident, and too conclusive for our mental,
moral, or spiritual digestion, invites a
notice for which we must humbly
apologize to our subscribers. The
sacred and the secular, prophecy and
party politics, are oddly mixed up in his
reveries. The opening of the seals he
understands exactly. Not the year
only, but the day of the month he
specifies in each instance. The first
seal was opened A.D. July 24th, 96.
The second seal A.D. May 20th, 451,
and so on till the sixth seal A.D. Sept.
24th, 1870. Then comes "The war in
heaven; or, the Berlin Congress." And
a little further on, "The Devil's Diplo-
matic Manœuvre," in which the Right
Honourable William Ewart Gladstone
figures as "Satan's deluded human
representative." This is violent, virulent,
vicious—a flagrant libel on a living
statesman. In still worse taste, Mr.
Williams tells us: "Events pre-suppose
that God the Holy Ghost, in harmony
with the permission given to Satan,
induced Earl Beaconsfield," &c., pp. 282, 283. Enough! We forbear to finish the sentence. Is not such a treatise a serious breach of literary ethics? Our marvel is that Mr. Elliot Stock allowed his good name to appear at the foot of the title-page.
The Gospel according to St. Luke. With Introduction, Notes, and Maps. (2 vols. of the "Hand-Books for Bible-classes and Private Students.") Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark.
THESE two hand-books make up an invaluable aid to Bible-class teaching upon the gospel according to Luke. Dr. Lindsay gives enough, but never too much; we wish we could say this of all who attempt to expound the Scriptures.
The Sum of Saving Knowledge. With Introduction and Notes by Rev. JOHN MACPHERSON, M.A., (Same series as preceding.) Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark.
AN invaluable treatise. The Christian world should be grateful for the republication of this capital piece of sound divinity; but we do not suppose it will be, for nowadays anything sells better than orthodox theology. At 1s. 6d. it is a very cheap reprint, for which the Messrs. Clark deserve hearty thanks.
Thirty Thousand Thoughts, being Extracts covering a Comprehensive Circle of Religious and Allied Topics. Edited by the Very Rev. H. D. M. SPENCE, M.A., Rev. JOSEPH S. EXELL, M.A., and Rev. CHARLES NEIL, M.A. Vol. V. Nisbet and Co.
EVEN unto this last we are unable to see the usefulness of the plan of this work. The scheme was laid down at the commencement, but the result is that the extracts are more in a muddle to our mind than they would have been had there been no plan at all. Moreover, we do not judge the extracts themselves to be so excessively valuable as to be worth putting into huge volumes. Some of them are surpassingly precious, but more are excellent common-places, and nothing beyond.
If any rich deacon should make his pastor a present of these five volumes the good man would be bound to be very grateful. Moreover, if he has only a
small library he will find himself enriched with a good share of quotable material, and he will also refresh himself with thousands of good and wholesome thoughts. So that his deacon would have done a generous deed, and he would receive a full reward in the improvement in his minister's sermons.
We could not recommend men with shallow purses to lay out 16s. on a volume like the present, especially as it is Vol. V., and there are more to follow. Baptists cannot approve of the article on Baptism, and we should think no Calvinist would consider the extracts upon election to be worth his reading, unless he could forget them as soon as he closed the book. Much of this section is sheer rubbish: a little outspoken Arminianism would have been nearer the truth. Still we do not make a great point of this, for in so large a mass of writing there must naturally be somewhat with which we could not agree. The work is great, but we do not think it a great success.
Ripples in the Twilight: Fragments of Sunday Thought and Teaching. By J. R. MACDUFF, D.D. Nisbet and Co. MACDUFF is always good. It is the water of life even when it is only a ripple, and it is the light of coming day when only twilight. We do not place these odds and ends of thoughts among the best things our friend has produced, but still they have a value of their own, and are quite fresh and new.
Mornings at Mildmay. Notes of Lessons from the Beatitudes. By E. C. Partridge and Co.
GRACIOUS matter. Those must be very memorable hours which are spent on Tuesday mornings in Room No. 6, Conference Hall, Mildmay Park. These notes contain nothing very fresh or profound, but much that is devout and practical.
The Kingdom of Heaven, and Dives and Lazarus. By ANGLICANUS. Elliot Stock.
ANGLICANUS will not make many converts to his interpretation of the story of Lazarus and the rich man. He thinks our Lord is the beggar full of sores, and the Jewish hierarchy the rich man. This will never do. We do not see anything in his little book which is likely to edify.
499
The Story of the Nations. Carthage.
By ALFRED J. CHURCH, M.A. T.
Fisher Unwin.
No reader of fiction can have been more
absorbed in his author's day-dreams than
we have been in these veritable records
of actual history. He cannot have been
profited even to a fractional part of our
profiting. How Carthage could not
conquer though victory was long within
her grasp, and how Rome could not fall
though her doom seemed often sealed,
are two of the marvels of history! That
the Sidonian city should be blotted out
so remorselessly by her rival seemed as
absolutely needful as it was brutal;
there was not room in the same world
for two such imperious queens as Rome
and Carthage. Did the curse of Canaan
follow the lords of the far-off Tarshish?
Was it possible for the worship of Mel-
carth and Astarte to be allowed to throw
its baleful shadow over the civilization
of the west? Surely the Lord wrought
with the insatiable ambition of Rome,
and used it as his sharp axe with
which to hew down the evil branch
which sprang from the old accursed
root of Baal and Ashtaroth.
The character of Hannibal shines
like a bright particular star amid the
storm-rack of these Punic wars. Roman
courage, cool as the steel it carried, is
also seen to a wonderful advantage, and
strikes us as bearing, among earthly
things, a wonderful likeness to that faith
which staggers not at the promise
through unbelief. When Hannibal had
pitched his camp at the third mile-stone
from Rome, there was a sale within the
city of plots of land, whereon the
enemy's camp then stood. The small
matter of Hannibal's being there did
not hinder the biddings! This is a style
of confidence which cannot be counter-
feited; but where it is truly possessed,
it makes it a joy to undergo affliction;
indeed, tribulation only adds a new zest
to life. Roman doctrine we abhor, but
if we could obtain and exhibit the old
Roman faith, we should regard it as one
of the greatest acquisitions with which
we could be enriched. Firm conviction
of the truth of the old Calvinistic faith is
the best possible material out of which
to fashion a steadfast, immovable life,
which shall always abound in the work
of the Lord. Puritanism supplied back-
bone to Cromwell's Ironsides, and it
will yet, we trust, nourish a race of
men valiant for the faith, who will hold
the standard of truth against all comers
in these evil days. Lord, send it,
because of thy cause and covenant!
A Dictionary of Philosophy in the Words
of Philosophers. Edited, with an in-
troduction, by J. RADFORD THOMSON,
M.A. R. D. Dickinson.
WHEN human ignorance grows con-
fident it speaks philosophy. This Dic-
tionary is a sort of index to the innu-
merable dreams and dotings of men who
obtained credit for being wise. We
suppose it must be a valuable work, for
so many eminent professors praise it;
but to us it reads like a catalogue of a
madman's library, or a list of the fancies
bred in an opium den. So long as we
are in this mad world we shall have need
to know the terms and phrases by means
of which it arranges and methodizes its
follies, and this is the very book to help
us to supply that need: yet the informa-
tion which it affords has little or no in-
trinsic value, and a man knows as much
that is worth knowing before he under-
stands most systems of philosophy as he
did before he heard of them. Having
turned to one marvellous philosophy
after another, as described in this dic-
tionary by the philosophers themselves,
we have felt inclined to enquire for
Democritus, that we might have a
hearty laugh with him at all the philo-
sophical generations. Whether or not a
single hearty laugh would not have done
mankind more good than all the philo-
sophies we will not say; but we are of
opinion that the most of them are too
much honoured when they are laughed
at. Wit is folly in sport, but philosophy
is folly in earnest.
Of course, by all this we mean phi-
losophy "falsely so called"; but as yet
we have not met with any other kind of
philosophy, nor do we expect to meet
with philosophy truly so called except
in connection with revelation, and the
devout thought which draws its life
therefrom.
Little Folks: a Magazine for the Young.
New and Enlarged Series. Cassell
and Company.
As good as ever. We don't see how it
could be better.
English as She is Taught: being Genuine Answers to Examination Questions in our Public Schools. Collected by CAROLINE B. LE ROW. With a commentary thereon by MARK TWAIN. T. Fisher Unwin.
WHO would have thought that so much fun could have been found in the answers of children at examinations! Yet our observation leads us to accept these as genuine blunders, and not the inventions of mirthful inventors. The particular use of reprinting them we do not see, except it be a moment's laugh. Here are some splendid mathematical answers:—
"A straight line is any distance between two places."
"Parallel lines are lines that can never meet until they run together."
"A circle is a round straight line with a hole in the middle."
"Things which are equal to each other are equal to anything else."
"To find the number of square feet in a room multiply the room by the number of feet. The product is the result."
Disease and Sin: a New Text Book for Medical and Divinity Students. By A MEDICAL MUSER. Wyman and Sons, 74—76, Great Queen Street, Lincoln's-Inn Fields.
No doubt there is something of truth in this striking volume, but it is pushed much too far, so as to verge upon absolute cruelty to the suffering. Disease is not in every case caused by a violation of natural law on the part of the afflicted, neither would the most careful observation of the laws of hygiene prevent certain persons from falling into sickness; for, as our author admits, we are the creatures of parentage. Besides, there are surroundings, necessities, and inward accidents, which may involve pain which cannot be stayed, and create disease which medical skill is as yet unable to touch. That physical evil on a broad scale has come of moral evil is doubtless true; but to put the finger on any case of disease, and say, This man sinned, or his immediate parents, is to turn truth into falsehood, and act the part, not of "a medical muser," but of an unsympathizing dreamer.
A History of the Legislative Union of Great Britain and Ireland. By T. DUNBAR INGRAM, LL.D. Macmillan and Co.
OUR author is of opinion that the Union between England and Ireland was undertaken from the purest motives, and carried through by fair and constitutional means. This is certainly a very different view of the case from that which we have taken, for we have always judged the Union to have been the product of bribery and fraud. We are puzzled. History, like statistics, can be manipulated; but who has manipulated in this case we will not pretend to decide. How far Dr. Ingram is accurate in his statements, and correct in his inferences, his readers can judge for themselves: he certainly takes a view of things which will be new to many, and he has produced an important historical document.
Great Waterfalls, Cataracts, and Gey-sers, Described and Illustrated. By JOHN GIBSON. Nelson and Sons.
A FASCINATING subject well worked out, both by author and artist. Very interesting to us are the falls of the Congo. What a river it is! What must Africa be which contains four such mighty streams as the Congo, the Zambesi, the Niger, and the Nile! This huge continent can only be won for Christ at immense cost. Is the church capable of the self-denial which it will involve? This work is produced in Messrs. Nelson's usually excellent style. It is a treat to read of falls of water in this rainless summer-tide. May we have falls from the firmament ere long.
Hints on Spectacles: when Required, and How to Select Them. By W. ACKLAND, Surgeon and Optician by Special Appointment to the Queen. Horne, Thornthwaite, and Wood, 416, Strand.
Most wise hints. The author of this sixpenny treatise is a master of his art. We would trust him with our eyes in preference to any other oculist. Spectacles bought at random may prove a serious injury: a little care and expense in due time may save sight, and this is more precious than mines of gold.
501
Only a Factory Girl. Scenes from West London Life. By UNA. Nisbet and Co.
A BRAVE young lady has seen for herself the factory girls in their haunts, amid the foul tobacco-smoke and the fouler talk of licentious lads. Certainly, it was a brave deed, worthy of that Una whom we have so often seen riding in her glorious innocence upon a lion. To go to the filthy theatre, and the still viler music-hall, and then to tell the story for love of God, and the poor daughters of Eve! Well! few could, would, or should have done anything of the kind; but Una did it, and we thank her.
This plea for help for the saving and uplifting of factory girls deserves to be widely spread. No doubt the surroundings of work-girls in London are well arranged for the production of immorality of every kind. To provide cheap, clean, and quiet lodging is often to give elbow-room for purity, which else is apt to be driven into the kennel by sheer lack of space. New hearts do not prevent the need of new homes; say rather that they add fresh force to the demand.
A Treatise on the Principle of Sufficient Reason. By Mrs. P. F. FITZGERALD. Thomas Laurie, 28, Paternoster Row.
We admire the freedom of the press; men and women may print whatever they like. We have an equal admiration for the freedom of the desk: we may read what we like, or let it alone. After trying this noble volume in many places, and finding it equally stiff at all points, we give it up. Our freedom is asserted by leaving "the Principle of Sufficient Reason" alone; and we believe we have more than sufficient reason for so doing. When the squirrel found that what he was trying his teeth upon was not a nut, but a lump of cast-iron, he wisely left such solid fare for some stronger and more metallic animal than himself; whether that animal ever came along the tradition doth not tell us.
Buy your own Cherries. By J. W. KIRTON. Illustrated by GORDON BROWNE. Partridge and Co.
SENT forth in such an attractive form, this story should take a new lease of
life. The illustrations look like sepia drawings, and are graphic and telling. For fourpence we have here the best possible temperance tract, so adorned as to become self-preserving, and so touching that the man who does not yield to its argument must be very far gone from original sobriety.
Lead, Kindly Light. By JOHN HENRY NEWMAN. With illustrations by F. Dadd, engraved by R. Paterson. T. Nelson and Sons.
HIGHLY artistic, but we do not see the suitableness of the engravings to the verses. Our imagination pictures far more of an "encircling gloom" than Mr. Dadd has drawn, and of "the night is dark, and I am far from home" we have a much more terrible notion than any which his drawing would suggest. The work is produced in a faultless manner, and it will charm many.
The Cookery Primer. By AGNES C. MAITLAND. Hogg, Paternoster Row.
OUR Dr. Kitchener says that this is a sensible book. It contains receipts for very cheap and wholesome dishes fit for hard-working thrifty people. It is a good shilling's worth viewed from a printer's point of view. Next to godliness cleanliness, and next to cleanliness thrifty cookery.
Oliver Cromwell and other Poems. By DAWSON BURNS, D.D. S.W. Partridge.
WE do not like giving an opinion of a relative's babies or of a friend's poems. These are most readable verses: some of them seem a little made-up and laboured, but others go with a flash and a rush. The variety is great and the quality well sustained throughout—never gold, but never dross.
Dado; or, Stories of Native Life in East Africa. By WILLIAM YATES. Andrew Crombie, 119, Salisbury Square, E4C.
GOOD! likely to interest our young people in Eastern Africa. What a work yet lies before the Christian church! When shall we begin to begin? Dado, a youth of the Gallias tribe, was brought to England, and gave great promise of usefulness. Here is the story of his brief life.
Life of Henry Wadsworth Longfellow.
By ERIC S. ROBERTSON. Walter
Scott, 24, Warwick Lane.
A WORK of high literary merit. The
idea of selling it for a shilling is worthy
of a great publisher; but whether it
will result in increasing the greatness of
his income we do not care to divine, for
we remember George Eliot's wise say-
ing: "Among all forms of mistake pro-
phecy is the most gratuitous."
Puritanism is very roughly and un-
fairly handled by Mr. Robertson; but
we did not look for much else in a life of
a great Unitarian poet. The estimate
of Longfellow given in this critique is,
we think, soberly made and lovingly
moulded. He was not the greatest of
poets, but he was one of the most useful
of them; and he will live in the popular
mind when greater men will lie hidden
among the embalmed of history.
The question as to whether he was as
great a poet as Tennyson is a very proper
one to be discussed at a High School for
young ladies, or a Mutual Improvement
Society of men who are soon to be; but
such comparisons are unwise from the
beginning. We should, however, think
that Longfellow never produced such
poor things as certain of our laureate's
later off-throwings; if the American
could not rise so high he would not sink
so low as his great contemporary has
done. The bulk of us feel that we can
understand Longfellow, but full often we
cannot tell where Tennyson is, nor what
he is singing about. We confess that
we have no right to expect a man to
sing for us common-place people only;
and if he prefers an audience made up
of the few, of mind circuitous, and
thought involved, he must be allowed
his preferences, and much good may
they do him.
To return to our theme — these
"Great Writers" are wonderful books
for a shilling, and Robertson's Long-
fellow is one of the best of them.
"Great Writers." Edited by ERIC S.
ROBERTSON, M.A. Life of Samuel
Taylor Coleridge. By HALL CAINE.
Walter Scott.
WE have felt the spell of a master's
wand while reading this story of a man
of real genius, who was like a powerful
cugine which fails to do its work from
lack of some one screw or bolt. Had
he been more deeply religious he would
have become a leader among the mys-
tics; even as it was, Hazlitt said of him,
"His genius had angelic wings, and fed
on manna." Opium was his bane for
years, and though he mastered it, his life
was clouded by its influence. This life
is as good as it is cheap: we mean good
in the direction of literary excellence,
and interesting incident; beyond this it
makes no attempt to go.
Biographical Sketch of the Life and
Work of Mr. William M'Gavin, fol-
lowed by Notes from M'Gavin's "Pro-
testant." Edited by Mrs. MARIA
DENOON PEDDIE. Edinburgh: Re-
ligious Tract Society, 99, George
Street. London: Partridge and Co.
THE biographical part of this pamphlet
is meagre indeed. We hoped to have
seen a life of the eminent Protestant
controversialist, and instead thereof we
have some sixteen pages of remarks
about him. The rest of the book con-
sists of notes from M'Gavin's famous
"Protestant," which is a marvel of
trenchant argument. In its own day
"The Protestant" did grand service,
and it is useful still as an armoury. Mrs.
Peddie, who edits this compilation, is a
hearty defender of the faith, and we
wish her every success in her mission.
So few care anything about truth in
these days, that it is refreshing to meet
with an old-fashioned Anti-papal Ad-
vocate.
These Seven Years; or, The Story of the
"Friendly Letter Mission." By V. M.
SKINNER. Stirling: Drummond's
Tract Depôt. London: Partridge.
A GATHERING up of incidents connected
with Miss Skinner's Friendly Letters.
We have here a specially instructive
instance of what can be done by an
carnest worker whatever form her efforts
may take. It is cheering to see how
much personal work of a really spiritual
sort is being quietly done for our blessed
Lord. The night is dark, but it is not
without its stars. The false doctrine
and the loose practice of many professors
sadden the hearts of the gracious; but,
on the other hand, the consecrated lives
of many holy men and women tend to
lift up the hands that hang down.
Doubtless the Lord is among us still.
503
The History of Pudsey. By the late
SIMEON RAYNER. Edited by WILLIAM
SMITH, F.S.A.S. Longmans, Green,
and Co.
PUDSEY is highly honoured by having
such a history. Mr. William Smith has
edited the work of the late Simeon
Rayner; and has thus supplied Pudsey
with a bigger memorial than that which
he prepared for Morley. We say bigger,
but it is by no means better, for the
subject is a comparatively narrow one,
and falls short in interest of the story of
Morley. We have a weakness for these
topographical books: they are the gossip
of history, the chit-chat of geography.
In their homeliness they furnish the
mind with recreation, and the brain
with rest. It is a healthy thing that a
man should think well of the place
wherein he was born or nurtured.
Something of the honour which is due
to parents is reflected upon the place of
parentage. Better far than tales of
battle are the records of the peaceful
growth of village and township, and the
rise and decay of families. The annals
of our forefathers, the pictures of their
antique abodes, the descriptions of their
manners—all these have a quiet charm
about them, and help to make hours of
leisure bright, cheerful, and useful.
This is a noble volume. One is tempted
to ask—How comes Pudsey to be so
favoured when many a larger place is
left unhonoured and unsung? It has,
probably, an unusual number of public-
spirited men who have aided in a pub-
lication which will be an honour to
their town.
