Menu
‹ Chapter 155 of 297 ›

Touches of Nature in the Gospels

6 min read · Chapter 155 of 297

THERE are two ways of testing the authenticity of an ancient work, first, by applying external, and secondly, by producing internal evidence. External evidence consists of the testimony of contemporary writers, and the history of the work itself; while internal evidence consists of undesigned coincidences found in the work itself, and if the work refer to human beings, of physiological truth, or agreement with human nature. The latter species of proof is the most satisfactory and conclusive, because it is the most difficult of all to counterfeit, and, we may add, it is the most difficult of all to obtain. That which constitutes the transcendent merit of Shakespeare is the marvellous agreement of his characters with the course of human nature, and as it is not contended that the authors of the four gospels were Jewish Shakespeares we may safely assume that, if we find a similar consistency between the characters they portray and human nature, they were simply relating plain unvarnished tales of real individuals.

It seems a pity that this test has not been more extensively applied to the Gospels by moral philosophers and others skilled in the workings of the human heart. Let us try if we can gather a few of these physiological coincidences from one gospel alone, that by St. Mark.

In the fourth chapter we read as follows:—"And when he was alone they that were about him with the twelve asked of him the parable" (ver. 10); and again:—"Without a parable spake he not unto them; and when they were alone, he expounded all things unto his disciples" (ver. 34).

Now everyone is alive to ridicule and contempt; contempt, says the Eastern proverb, will pierce through the shell of the tortoise; but everyone is, at the same time, endowed with an instinct of curiosity. Knowledge can often be obtained only by questioning and inquiring, and especially was this the case before the invention of printing flooded every land with books. Yet, since the exposure of ignorance is liable to provoke ridicule and contempt, the vast majority of persons are very chary about revealing the extent of their ignorance; showing their hand by asking questions. When other persons are present, this sensitiveness is increased in proportion to the number of listeners. Anyone who has lectured classes or taught in schools will understand this remark. When, however, the persons assembled are strangers to each other (as at auctions and other promiscuous assemblies) the tendency becomes almost inveterate. Now the disciples, and those who associated with Christ, would naturally wish to be thought conversant with all his dark sayings and secrets, and would hesitate to let themselves down to the level of the outside multitude, by asking their own Master what he meant by what he said while preaching in public.

341

Therefore it is that the disciples almost always waited and obtained their explanations in private and alone. Thus it is that we read as follows:—"And when he was entered into the house from the people, his disciples asked him concerning the parable" (ch. vii. ver. 17); "And when he was come into the house, his disciples asked him privately, Why could not we cast him out?" (ch. ix. ver. 28.) "And in the house his disciples asked him again of the same matter" (ch. x. ver. 10). "And as he sat upon the Mount of Olives, over against the temple, Peter and James and John and Andrew asked him privately, Tell us when shall these things be?" (ch. xiii. ver. 3, 4.)

Let us now notice another touch of nature. In chapter iii. ver. 21, we read: "And when his friends heard of it, they went out to lay hold on him; for they said, He is beside himself." What was it that our Lord's friends heard of which made them think that he was beside himself?—that he "could not so much as eat bread." Christ did a great many wonderful things, but it was only this abstaining from eating that caused his friends (or "kinsmen") to conclude that he was losing his reason, and ought to be put under restraint. Great men are generally moderate eaters, and many illustrious persons have been exceedingly abstemious, the greatness of their thoughts and occupations, no doubt, keeping down their animal cravings. Napoleon I., say his biographers, never willingly spent more than a quarter of an hour at his dinner. Newton often forgot to come down to breakfast in the morning, or even to dress himself: he used to sit on the edge of his bed for hours together, lost in the cogitation of some absorbing problem. Socrates frequently forgot to eat. Xenophon tells us that he was extremely frugal, and often lived on next to nothing. Plato relates that on one occasion, "he stood wrapped in meditation in the open fields, apparently endeavouring to unravel his thoughts. He was seen to stand there from the morning, throughout the day, all through the night, and until sunrise next morning, when, with a prayer, he departed" (Symposium). Thus "great wits are sure to madness near allied." Now, any one familiar with lunatic asylums will readily admit that refusal to eat food is one very common result of insanity. There are probably few asylums of any considerable magnitude where one will not find one or more of the patients suffering from this species of affliction, and various devices have to be employed to compel them to take nourishment.

Here, then, is probably the key to the conduct of Christ's kinsmen. When he fasted for forty days he was alone, and no doubt they did not know where to look for him; perhaps they knew nothing at all of the matter at the time; but here he walked about openly among the people:—"There were many coming and going, and they had no leisure so much as to eat" (ch. vi. ver. 31); "And the multitude cometh together again, so that they could not so much as eat bread. And when his friends heard of it they went out to lay hold on him, for they said, He is beside himself" (ch. iii. ver. 20, 21).

Yet another instance. When we see the laws of nature, in any important instance, broken, or apparently broken, we are disposed to be afraid, notwithstanding that the violation of them should bode us no ill. More than that, we would be alarmed even though the preternatural event in

25

question should be that for whose occurrence we would give all we possessed. A young widow with her children weeping in unconsolable anguish for her husband, snatched away from her in the fulness of manhood and affection, would, we can have no doubt, be extremely terrified were the husband to sit up in his coffin and begin to talk to her. The general reason for this tendency is probably the reflection that the same power which violates the laws of nature in our favour, could and might violate them to our damage and destruction. We should feel that we had lost our sheet anchor in life; we should become terribly uncertain; we should not know on whom to depend, or what to expect next. Thus it was that some of our Lord's miracles, wrought solely for the benefit and behoof of his disciples, only filled them with alarm. It is not wonderful that, when they saw him walking upon the water, and thought it was a spirit, they cried out, but that, when after having wakened out of his sleep in the ship, he stilled the waves, and made a great calm, they should "fear exceedingly," does seem, without the help of the foregoing explanation, a little odd (ch. iv. ver. 41). In like manner, the Gadarenes were frightened when they saw a maniac restored to sanity:— "They come to Jesus, and see him that was possessed with the devil, and had the legion, sitting, and clothed, and in his right mind: and they were afraid" (ch. v. ver. 15).

These touches of nature could hardly have been the result of design. A fabricator would have dwelt upon the amazement, the wonder, the joy with which the people and the disciples witnessed Christ's miracles of grace and beneficence, but they would hardly have called special attention to that subtle, unlooked-for, but perfectly natural feeling of consternation and alarm, which will possess the mind under the circumstances in question.

No doubt numerous other instances of a like description, calculated to show that the men and women of the Gospels were realities, lived, moved, and had their being as they are described, may be discovered by those who will analyse patiently, and read, mark and inwardly digest what has been written for our learning.

A. W. HOLMES-FORBES.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate