Hard Times—Past and Present
FOR some years past Great Britain, in common with other countries, has been passing through a season of depression, which has touched all classes—the landowners, the farmers, and the manufacturers, all having alike been disastrously affected. The cause of these hard times has been explained in different ways by various people, some thinking that free-trade—which has, undoubtedly, been a vast national benefit all round—is our stumbling-block, while others find it more convenient to blame the weather, or to trace our sorrows to over-production. Our present object is not so much to solve this problem as to show that history repeats itself in a remarkable manner. As people are not always well acquainted with things which have gone before, it is quite natural that they should think their experiences to be exceptional. In very many instances “the oldest inhabitant” has been brought forward as a witness; and if this person only declares that the like of a certain thing has never been heard of within living memory, everybody at once concludes that nothing of the same kind ever happened in the wide world before.
First, in regard to the weather. The weather is never “bad” in the truest sense. The best weather is such as God sees well to send. At the same time, we have only to take notice of what observers have recorded of other days to be convinced that, on the whole, the weather in England is still just what it has been for long generations; and there are no symptoms of radical change, as some not over-wise newspaper writers would have us believe. In the Diary of Samuel Pepys, for example (27th November, 1662), there is a reference to warm winters: “At my waking, I found the tops of the houses covered with snow, which is a rare sight, which I have not seen these three years.” Then, in 1666, he speaks of a long and severe frost, which covered the Thames with ice, and made full amen's to those who may have been thinking that winter was retiring to the North.
But may not agricultural depression in part be owing to a succession of cold, wet summers? Who has ever heard of such seasons as preceded 1879, and brought a culmination of disaster in that year? Writing in 1783, Cowper says, “I shiver with cold on this present third of July. Summer and winter, therefore, do not depend on the position of the sun with respect to the earth, but on his appointment who is sovereign of all things. Last Saturday night the cold was so severe that it pinched off many of the young shoots of our peach trees. The very walnuts, which are no bigger than hazel-nuts, drop to the ground; and the flowers, though they blow, seem to have lost their odour.” On account of the hot, dry mists which prevailed in its summer, the year 1783 was one of the most singular ever known. “The sun continues to rise and set without his rays, and hardly shines at noon, even in a cloudless sky,” writes the poet. So that when anything very unusual occurs, it can commonly be matched by something quite as remarkable which has happened before. This is especially true of wet summers; and the facts which might be mentioned under this head surpass our own modern experience. Thus the inundations of August, 1799, extended throughout the country during the time of hay and
217
corn harvest. On some parts of the road the Manchester and London coach found "the water was so high that the horses were up to their necks, and the body of the coach in the water; the trees were their only guide, the hedges being in general washed away." ("Annual Register," 1799, page 30.)
This will suffice concerning the weather; and by turning attention to other things, it will be easy to show that our forefathers, who lived in the reign of George III., were generally much worse off than ourselves. We sometimes justly complain of heavy taxes and rates; but, compared with the crushing burdens of eighty or ninety years ago, our own payments are moderate indeed. These burdens, and the excessive price of provisions, led to serious riots in the provinces, as well as in London. At Birmingham, the attacks on bakers' shops, and worse things which were threatened, rendered the presence of soldiers necessary. On the 15th of December, 1800, the famishing poor of London made a show of rising. "Inflammatory bills, posted on the monument in the night preceding, urged the people to rescue themselves from famine by their own exertions, and to take vengeance on monopolists and forestallers. In the morning, a mob appeared in Mark Lane, insulted the dealers in corn, and clamorously demanded an abatement in the price of that necessary article." ("Annual Register," 1800, page 212.)
Unwise or selfish legislation on the part of landowners in Parliament was formerly the cause of much mischief; and very much still remains to be done in the direction of reform before the peasantry of this free country are all that they ought to be. The notion was that farmers must be protected at any cost, both by duties on corn, and by the peasantry having their wages supplemented out of local rates. Speaking in the House of Commons in 1807, Mr. Whitbread showed, that out of a population in England and Wales of about eight and three-quarter millions, nearly a million and a quarter had parish relief—"That is, that nearly one-seventh part of the people of England was indebted to the other six, wholly or in part, for their support; but by far the larger part of that number wholly." At the present time the population of England and Wales is about 27½ millions, or more than three times what it was in 1803; and yet the persons receiving relief in 1884 were only 586,717 outdoor, and 187,593 indoor, instead of 1,234,000. The numbers for 1884 were less by more than 20,000 than they were in 1883, so that the outlook is not quite so hopeless as some foreboders of evil have led themselves and others to suppose.
Agricultural distress is no new thing; but it is hardly likely to pass away until the Parliament deals with the subject in an enlightened way, and abolishes the laws which now hamper or oppress the farmer. In the war-time of the first years of the century, the unnaturally high prices which then ruled made the tillage of the soil one of the most profitable of callings; but in the year after the peace (1816) farmers, as well as manufacturers and traders, learned how multiplied disasters naturally follow after protracted wars. Wheat having fallen to about seven shillings a bushel in March, the House of Commons showed its own urgent need of reform, and the tendencies of the age, by discussing the expediency of imposing heavier duties on imports, and of encouraging
exports by bounty. In those days it was not always possible to repel by fair argument and common sense those who came forward with such unpatriotic and suicidal proposals; but in 1816 they were very effectively answered by an inclement season. Instead of being over-supplied with the necessaries of life, as the friends of farmers had pictured in the spring, when debating the matter, corn rose to 103s. a quarter in December, the farmers, meanwhile, having in the main lost their crops. The fear was now of famine rather than of too great abundance; the long-continued and heavy rains of the summer having destroyed a vast amount of produce. It was the coldest and wettest season which the new century had seen; and the general distress exceeded anything that could be remembered. Although Adam Smith had written his book about forty years before, no one as yet seemed to understand his arguments; all alike clamoured to have their own interest protected; and, as the land was the most powerfully represented, the landlords in the main had their own way.
Thus, as the year grew older, wages went down, while provisions rose to semi-famine prices and employment became more and more difficult to obtain. We are told ("Ann. Reg." 1816, p. 93) that "The growing discontents first began to assume a menacing appearance in the counties of Norfolk, Suffolk, Huntingdon, and Cambridge, where nightly assemblages were held, threatening letters were sent, and houses and rick-yards were set on fire." In the Isle of Ely and in the Eastern counties the disorders reached a climax rarely equalled even in more turbulent times; for it was a new thing to find labourers gathering in mobs to demand "bread or blood" of those they supposed to be responsible for their miseries, and to burn or otherwise destroy their property. Then, while stacks were burning in the farmyards, and while the shops of butchers and bakers were attacked by frantic peasants who thought that they could reduce prices by dictating what they were to be, masked desperadoes roved hither and thither to demolish machinery or houses in towns and villages. This Luddite iconoclasm had been carried on in 1812. "Armed bands, under the orders of a chief, held the inhabitants in nightly terror, commanding them to put out their lights and keep within their houses, under penalty of death," says Charles Knight ("Hist. Eng." viii. 61). "Their ravages were not confined to towns; they would march with suddenness and secrecy to distant villages, and rapidly effect their purposes of destruction. The General Ludd would address his forces in a short speech, divide them into parties, and assign their respective operations."
The distress in all the centres of mining or manufacturing industry was far more acute than anything we have experienced in our times. Ironworks and coal-mines which had employed great numbers, suddenly came to a stand. In the North of England, in South Wales, in London, work was failing, provisions were rising in price, and large subscriptions were collected from the charitable to prevent the people from starving.
All this was bad enough, but probably it was exceeded by what occurred some years later. At the beginning of December, 1825, we are told ("Ann. Reg." lxvii-123), "the agitation in the city exceeded everything of the kind that had been witnessed for many years. Lombard-street was nearly filled with persons hastening to the different banks to
219
draw money, or waiting in anxious fear of hearing of new failures." Then follows a list of seventy-three banks in London and the provinces which in that memorable month failed or stopped payment! Many others followed in the new year, 1826. The "Annual Register," on its opening page, bears strong testimony to the pressure of the distress: "The demand for the labour of the artisan had not yet revived, and want of employment and its concomitant misery were the results. . . The ship-owners, likewise, were suffering from the inability to procure freights. . . There was thus throughout the whole community a great deal of pecuniary embarrassment, of comparative privation, and of positive suffering."
In the year that the present Queen ascended the throne the outlook was also very dark and threatening; for although the Reform Bill had been passed, and a new era entered upon, generations of bad government and of enormous war expenditure could not be got over all at once. In all directions the complaint was of want of trade and want of work. The poor, who had been pauperized, and thus demoralized, by the old poor laws which had been amended shortly before, were becoming more and more discontented, and hence came the Chartist agitation. A prophet of evil might then have thought that the country was on the verge of actual revolution.
Ten years later, or in 1847, trade became paralyzed in a similar manner. "Each day brought tidings of gigantic failures," we are told by Sir T. Martin ("Prince Consort's Life," chap. xxii). "In Lancashire alone, between July and October, the failures were stated by Lord Stanley to have amounted to close on £16,000,000. Liverpool, Birmingham, Glasgow, and the other great towns had the same tale to tell. . . Credit was suspended, and the whole trade of the country seemed upon the verge of being brought to a standstill."
After this the outlook brightened; the corn laws were abolished; the country entered upon that great era of free trade which, under God, has seen Great Britain outstripping all other competitors in the markets of the world. In 1870 we also entered upon the new era of national education; and the vast benefits which will arise from this departure will be seen more and more as time goes on, especially if the Sunday-schools and Ragged-schools throughout the country are well sustained to supplement the teaching of the Board Schools. Those who say that the nation is going back, or that, having reached a stage never paralleled before, we are on the verge of ruin, know nothing about the testimony of history. The statistical returns from the Balance Sheet of the World show that even in hard times the nation has made progress, and that there is a vitality about our own free trade which is altogether wanting in that of "protected" countries. Instead of inspiring alarm or misgiving, the present distress should only stimulate our efforts for its removal; for it is happily self-evident that the Legislature, by passing wise and needed measures, still has it in its power to further the re-establishment of prosperity in the country. We do not need to keep our toiling millions from want by the charitable intervention of the State; we rather want to see the unnatural restrictions removed which now fetter agricultural enterprise. If tithes, which alone are a chief cause of agricultural depression, and entail were abolished, and the
transfer of land made as cheap and as sure as it is in France—where there are nearly six millions of small freeholders—those reforms alone would go far towards introducing a new and better era. As it is, however, we are going forward, and not backward, despite the hard times; the amount per head earned by the population has risen considerably since the middle of the century; education is extending; crime is diminishing. Indeed, to compare the worst of our bad times with those of other days is actually ludicrous to those who are acquainted with the facts of history. Do we now ever hear of fifty-two shillings in the pound being paid for poor-rates, as was the case at Hinckley, Leicestershire, seventy years ago? Were not the bad years which immediately followed after the Queen's accession far more heartrending than anything we have known, when Glasgow had 12,000 persons receiving relief; when only 100 persons out of a population of 9,000 at Accrington were fully employed; and when the poor-rate at Stockport was ten shillings in the pound, the money having been needed to pay those who were breaking stones on the road? Facts without number might be given to show that the old times were in all respects worse than our own. Only let religion be more widely accepted, and let habits of soberness and of thrift become the rule rather than the exception, and England will go on progressing. In proportion as her people recognize the truth that righteousness exalteth a nation she will prosper. G. H. P.
