Little-known facts concerning the Reformation in England — I.—Deification Of Mary
THE low state to which the church had fallen in the last years of the fifteenth century is well shown by the fact that the Dominicans and the Franciscans, who were orders of begging friars, spent almost all their time in rancorous disputes concerning the Virgin Mary. The Dominicans, who, in their black habits, went about the country as itinerant preachers, held that the Lord's mother was born as "all other children of Adam" had been; but their opponents maintained that she was spotless from the first. Hence arose what Foxe calls "a turbulent tragedy." He adds, that "this frivolous question, kindling and engendering between these two sects of friars, burst out into such a flame of parts and sides-taking, that it occupied the heads and wits of schools and universities, almost throughout the whole church; some holding one part with Scortus, some the other part with Thomas Aquinas."
These ridiculous wranglings extended over the Continent of Europe; and even after a papal bull settled the matter in favour of the Franciscans, the Dominicans had not played their last card. Some of their number, of an ingenious turn of mind, who watched the controversy from Berne, "devised a certain image of the Virgin so artificially unique, that the friars, by privy gins, made it to stir, and to make gestures, to lament, to complain, to weep, to groan." When controversy was carried on in this fashion, how can we wonder that the credulous, ignorant people, who came to ask questions, "were brought to a marvellous persuasion" that the Dominicans were in the right? Seeing "their kitchen to wax cold, and their paunches to be pinched," because the stream of alms was diverted from them, the Franciscans were sharpened to detect the fraud; and the stake being regarded as a last reply in religious differences, they had the satisfaction of burning four of their opponents who were convicted of imposture.
II.—EARLY ENGLISH CONFESSORS.
As early as the year 1510, one Joan Baker rejected crucifixes and image-worship. It was urged against her, at her examination, that Joan had persuaded a friend lying at the point of death to trust in God, who worked all miracles, rather than in the Pope, who "had no power to give pardons." Here and there enlightened persons spoke against pilgrimages; and a certain Richard Woolman had such a severe regard for truth, "that he termed the Church of Paul's a house of thieves"; alluding no doubt to the traffic then carried on in the cathedral. The vengeance of the church was at the same time especially visited upon those who met together to read English books. That such little congregations did meet together in the night we have ample evidence. When in 1518 Richard Butler was arraigned before the Bishop of London, he was charged with having, at intervals during three years, met a number of persons at the house of Robert Durdant, near Staines, where, through an entire night, he had "erroneously and damnably read in a great
book of heresy . . . certain chapters of the Evangelists in English." He not only read, but expounded, and exhorted his hearers to keep and hold the truth. Some did so, even unto the martyr fires; but others gave way, and did penance for having been disobedient children of mother church.
