Notices of Books
Messrs. Hildesheimer and Faulkner, 41, Jewin Street, City, send us a parcel containing cards in great variety, suitable to all tastes. As works of art these are by far the best cards submitted to us this year. How can they possibly be excelled? If the Royal Academy itself should compete, would it do better? We have no retail prices sent, but the quotations seem to be very low for such first-class goods. The Private or Autograph Cards, upon which you can write your name, are delightful novelties, and strike us most. The Half-crown Prize Competition Box of Christmas and New Year Cards is a wonderful treasure for the money. Cards by B. D. Sigmund are simply perfect. The greatest masters of landscape cannot excel these sparkling bits of scenery. Frederick Hines produces certain trees and winter pieces, well worthy to be framed. We should have thought them worth a large sum of money, if we had not known that they are merely cards to be given away. Designs by R. W. Fraser are equally delightful. Jean Dealy excels in pictures of children: they are beautiful indeed. Miss Maguire's catties and doggies will win everybody's votes. Ernest Wilson produces some exquisite things: but his greatest novelty consists of views of London, North Wales, and the Lakes; these cards contain within them a little book of views. We cannot give more details, but friends who want thoroughly artistic works should ask to see the cards of Hildesheimer and Faulkner. Many stationers keep a cabinet of them on view.
T. Nelson and Sons. Chromo View Christmas Cards. These packets, illustrating Edinburgh, the Clyde, the West Highlands, and the English Lakes, are dainty mementos of happy visits. Admirably designed and excellently executed. Can chromo-lithography further
go? Their delightful little book, entitled Glad Tidings, is another specimen of their art, and is altogether beyond criticism: we simply sit down and enjoy it, and wish every reader of The Sword and the Trowel could do the same. Just the best of Christmas cards made into a book, by the help of well-selected poetry.
Castell Brothers, 6, Paternoster Square, go heartily into the card business, producing articles entirely of a religious character. Some of these we do not admire, but certain others are very excellent. We rejoice in the manifest desire to do good which appears in all the specimens sent to us. Their little book entitled Heavenward, printed in fifteen colours, and containing texts and poems for every day for a month, is worthy of special note. The sets of cards entitled Snowdrift, Songs of Bethlehem, Wishes for Children, Joy Bells, and Cathedral Chimes, are superior in taste and execution. Notable authors have contributed verses to these publications.
Mr. Mack, 28, Paternoster Row, sends us Scroll Texts at one shilling each, which we greatly admire; their size is 41 in. by 10 in., and they will be fine adornments for school-rooms and for Christmas-tide. The Home-Truths packet of much smaller scrolls is cheap, for it contains five for a shilling. From Morn till Eve, by Cecilia Havergal, is prettily got up, but the rhymes will not pass muster at all. They are after the Miss Havergal, and a dreadfully long way after. In Motto Cards for the Year Mr. Mack distinguishes himself. Churches and societies would do well to apply to him. Cards to be written upon are good. Ladies should send for specimens. The Birthday Scripture Text-Book, which originated with this house, is supplied by them in many varieties. In German cloth, at
637
As, it is very attractive. King's Service Sunday-school Reward Tickets. These are exceedingly beautiful, and at forty-eight for 6d. they will break nobody's bank. Forget-me-Not is a neat floral album, with spaces for autographs. We wish success to the Book Society, which we suppose is embodied in Mr. Mack. There is a measure of "go" in these publications which should secure them large acceptance with the public, especially at this season.
The Little Ones' Own Prize: being the Yearly Volume of the Little Ones' Own Coloured Picture Paper. Edited By Mrs. ELIZABETH DAY. Dean and Son.
WHAT a volume for three shillings! This is for the times, and it is all bright with colour, and alight with fun. Mrs. Day, your work is charmingly done. Your volume should be in every nursery in Great Britain and America. We wonder how you can write so much and so deliciously.
The Quiver: an Illustrated Magazine for Sunday and General Reading. Vol. XXI. Cassell and Company.
THIS magazine supplies its constituency with the best literary fare. In art, in composition, and in religious tone it is superior to most periodicals, and second to few, if any. We always read it with extreme satisfaction.
Scripture Calendar (1887). Daily Calendar. Proverbial Calendar. Benrose and Sons.
For many years one or other of these diaries has been hanging up in our study, and we have found it extremely handy. Cheap at a shilling.
The Herald of Mercy. Morgan and Scott.
VERY good. Cannot be better. The very thing for distribution in its monthly form; and not less suitable for a present when bound up. Price one shilling.
The Queen: a Jubilee Narrative of Personal Incidents and Scenes in the Life of Queen Victoria. Partridge. 1d.
THE forerunner of royal literature without end which is coming upon us like a flood. We shall feel the atmosphere
charged with loyalty, and men will be Queen-struck through the summer heat of British sentiment. Our only hope is that the poor will have a festival, and the rich make the tables groan beneath the weight of their hospitality to their needy neighbours. A flow of liberality will be the best way of celebrating the jubilee of "the good Queen."
Thrilling Tales of Enterprise and Peril, Adventure and Heroism. By Dr. MACAULAY. With Sixteen Illustrations. Hodder and Stoughton.
RIGHTLY named. Dr. Macaulay knows right well what will thrill a fellow. "The Fate of Glenveih," or the story of an Irish landlord's driving out hundreds of tenants, is one of the most horrible things we have ever read; and the worst of it is, it is true. "Railway Trains seen in Collision," is another of those true tales which make one lie awake at night. Dr. Macaulay, what is to become of you if you go on at this rate? Your book is quite a big affair, and well worth the six shillings asked for it.
A Pocket Encyclopedia of Useful Knowledge on a Thousand Subjects. By HENRY GREY. Griffith & Farran.
VERY well for what it is. Too small to be of any great use. An Encyclopedia for the pocket, price one shilling, reminds us of Goliath of Gath going through the eye of a needle, or a Cyclops dancing in a thimble. The idea is not to be entertained.
Short Biographies for the People. By various writers. Volume III. Religious Tract Society.
A THIRD series of lives, well chosen, and well condensed. The memoirs of good men are lines of light by which we trace our own way through the darkness of our age. To hang out a lamp from his doorway was the duty of a London citizen in the olden time; in a godly life a man lights a lamp for his own and every succeeding age. The Society does service to us all by the issue of such histories. Wesley and Whitefield, Chrysostom and Alfred, Wilberforce and Howard, Morrison and Judson, Sidney and Lords Bacon and Shaftesbury are portrayed in these pages.
The Religious Tract Society's Cards for Christmas and the New Year are good and various. The Society does not go in for the very highest art and the most luxurious productions; and in this it is wise, for it can be no part of its business to compete in art. It supplies attractive Scriptural cards, good enough for anybody. Gospel Signals will be found admirable for all who dwell by the sea or have to do with ships, for the signal flags are here made to teach important lessons. Twelve for 6d. is cheap. Christmas Bells are first-rate, and so are the New Year's Bells: these are six in a packet for one shilling. The fashion of sending out cards has so many advantages about it that we trust it will never die out. We have too few of these cheerful prettinesses in English life. Opportunities for showing little courtesies are privileges to be valued. Like everything else, the custom can be used for foolishness; but as yet we have seen nothing which could call for censure. We even believe that a holy text, printed with artistic surroundings may commend itself to the careless heart and lead it to the fount of life.
St. Giles' Lectures. Sixth Series. The Church and the People. Edinburgh: Maeniven and Wallace.
THESE lecturers in defending the Scotch Establishment say the best that can be said for their cause, but in our judgment it does not amount to much. Of course favoured persons will always argue for their privileges, and will feel their wits sharpened by the thought of losing them. We are a little amused at the picture of those wicked voluntaries persecuting the good established folk. It is horrible to contemplate! O dreadful Free Church radicals, what are you at? The poor dear establishment oppressed by brother Presbyterians! Let all humane persons hasten to the rescue! The piteous appeals of these lecturers ought to melt a heart of stone. Ours is not of stone, and therefore it is not affected.
We wish the ancient church of Scotland, by which we mean all the Presbyterian bodies, a visitation of grace enriching it with all covenant blessings: we do not consider union with the State to be one of these.
Songs of Earth and Heaven. By NEWMAN HALL, LL.B. Hodder and Stoughton.
WE must apologize for leaving these songs unnoticed so long; but somehow they escaped us. Mr. Newman Hall, "faithful among the faithless found," remains true to the gospel of our Lord Jesus. One may be always sure of him that he is keeping near the cross, and labouring to bring souls to Jesus. He has long been known as a writer of hymns and poems, and this volume will increase his reputation. His versified "Memories of a Palestine Journey" are exceedingly good. Many of the hymns for public and private worship will get into the selections, and increase the praise treasury of the church universal. Long may our friend and neighbour yet be spared to pour out his heart unto the Lord in the midst of his brethren!
The Offering of Christ finished upon the Cross. By C. H. WALLER, M.A. Elliot Stock.
A FORCIBLE argument against the Ritualistic notion of a continual offering. Our author is strong, but gentle. Oh that all high-church clergymen would read this treatise: it would only cost sixpence, and might be worth to such readers a mountain of gold. As for the Ritualists, we bear them witness that they have a zeal of God; and if knowledge went with it they would be the hope of England.
Saint Augustine, Melancthon, Neander. Three Biographies. By PHILIP SCHAFF, D.D. Nisbet and Co.
DR. SCHAFF is at home with each one of his three subjects. Upon Augustine he writes with appreciative discretion: he is a great subject, a thousand men in one. With Melancthon, whom he styles Praeceptor Germaniæ, Dr. Schaff has evident sympathy; and as for Neander, he seems quite at home with him. It is odd to find these three sketched in one book: we wonder whether Dr. Schaff had any motive in joining together three worthies in three distant ages born. We have had much pleasure in looking through the three lives, and we believe that our pleasure will be increased by a second perusal. The price is 4s. 6d.
639
The Liturgy of John Knox, received by the Church of Scotland in 1564. Hamilton, Adams, and Co.
WE value this as a curiosity, but we cannot say that in any other respect we set much store by it. It belongs to the infancy of the Protestant Church in Scotland, and has passed away as that church has outgrown the swaddling bands of its babyhood.
The "Book of Common Order" has often been called "John Knox's Liturgy," and within due limitations it is not inaccurately so denominated; but the term is apt to be misleading, and it needs to be added that the forms contained in it were not prescribed for constant and exclusive use, but were given in the way of a directory to ministers as to the conduct of the service. Though Knox had, undoubtedly, a hand in the preparation and sanction of this so-called Liturgy, Dr. Laing has unqualifiedly affirmed, "that in no instance do we find Knox himself using set forms of prayer." One can hardly imagine him praying by a book. The crass ignorance of his age probably compelled the preparation of this Directory to give hints to the illiterate. The book contains much else of weighty import.
William Tyndale. A Biography. By R. DEMAUS. Religious Tract Society. THIS volume has obtained a very high repute, and, therefore, it is re-issued in an improved form. The portrait and facsimiles largely add to its value, and the exhaustive index is also a great gain. Great pains have been taken to produce the best possible edition. Tyndale is rising from the sepulchre of oblivion: truly there is a resurrection of characters as well as of bodies.
The Ignatian Epistles entirely Spurious. A Reply to the Right Rev. Dr. Lightfoot, Bishop of Durham. By W. D. KILLEN, D.D. T. and T. Clark. Price 2s. 6d.
CONTROVERSY conducted in a fair and kind spirit. We do not care much about the question. No doubt much that has been attributed to Ignatius is upon the surface of it a clear imposture; and Dr. Killen is upon sure ground when he says that these epistles reveal a spirit of which no enlightened Christian can approve. If the tone and matter are
not according to the mind of Christ, it is cruel to father such writings upon Ignatius.
Straight Paths for your Feet. By the Rev. MARCUS RAINSFORD. Hodder and Stoughton.
NEAT binding enclosing much sound theology. In brief papers Mr. Rainsford discusses the great articles of the faith, comparing spiritual things with spiritual. We do not think the style is so lively as to make the book widely popular; but those who can appreciate solid scriptural teaching will read with pleasure and profit.
The Testimony of the Temple to the Truth and Nature of Christianity. By "A WORKMAN." Elliot Stock.
THIS workman needeth not to be ashamed. He is no mean artist in words and arguments. The pamphlet at 1s. 6d. contains much deep, original thought, and beats heavily, as with a battering ram, against the walls of Rome. We have made from this treatise an extract for our pages.
Scripture Readings for High and Public Schools. Education Department, Toronto.
OUR Ontario friends have selected these readings from Scripture for use in the schools of the State, and the selection has been judiciously made. Without violation of religious liberty the Bible is thus read in the public schools; and why not? What is education without religion and morality? Where can those be so well learned as from the sacred Word?
A Handbook of Bible Difficulties; or, Reasonable Solutions of Perplexing Things in Sacred Scripture. Edited by Rev. ROBERT TUCK, B.A. London: Elliot Stock.
VERY well done. Those who have a complete apparatus for study will not require this Handbook, but to men whose shelves are almost bare it will supply a great lack. It is not possible that all these explanations should seem to us to be such as we should have given; but they are always helpful and instructive. Not at all a bad present for a minister. We recommend it as a capital New Year's gift to a needy pastor.
Little Miss Matty: a Tale of the Sea.
By Mrs. GEORGE CUPPLES. Hodder
and Stoughton.
If we were to judge by the frequent
recurrence of stories on these lines—a
dear, good little girl, motherless,
Anglo-Indian, shipped to rich relatives
in England, wrecked, rescued, unknown,
adopted by an old sailor or fisherman
on the coast of Devon or Cornwall—
then we should be greatly distressed by
the thought that very many dear little
lambs are actually lost in this fashion
every year. But we control our feel-
ings; for if we may believe the story-
tellers, each dear child becomes a mes-
senger of mercy both afloat and ashore,
and is rewarded by succeeding to wealth
and the big house on the hill.
Bertha Pemberthy; or, the Gift that is
in thee. By H. S. GROSER. S. S. Union.
THIS precious child was not wrecked at
sea, but cast away on shore at a fisher-
man's door, at Appledore. With this
as a foundation, a very readable story
is constructed, exhibiting much know-
ledge of the heart, good descriptive
powers, and ability to interest and profit
young people.
Wakefordbridge. A Story of Christian
Service. By BENJAMIN CLARKE.
Sunday School Union.
GRACELESS novelists—and now and then
a renegade or "candid friend"—have
gloriedin magnifying and thus caricatur-
ing the weakness of the pastors and
deacons of our "Little Bethels," as
they derisively call our country chapels;
but it is seldom that we meet with a
book, in story form, which
'Speaks of them as they are, nothing
extenuates,
Nor sets down aught in malice.'
Here, however, we have a faithful por-
traiture of a country "cause" and its
leading spirits, especially its wise and
zealous pastor. With the art which
conceals art, Mr. Clarke gives in every
chapter of his story valuable hints,
stimulus and encouragement to Christian
workers, especially in the Sabbath-
school; and seeks to provoke his
renders to love and to good works. As
a story, it is all that could be wished,
and may help to remove the prejudices
that some good "Church" folk have
inherited as to their less favoured fellow-
Christians.
The King's Army. By ANNIE GRAY.
Sunday School Union.
THE same worthy object that the author
of the previous story evidently had
before him, namely, the quickening of
interest in the spiritual welfare of the
young, is present all through "The
King's Army," to which we award equal
commendation. Not a few spiritual
difficulties and troubles of young con-
verts are ably dealt with, as the story
proceeds to its very unexpected and
rather romantic termination.
Eyes to the Blind. By C. BIBLEY.
Hodder and Stoughton.
THE title is illustrated by the ways and
means adopted by the children of an
Irish curate to alleviate the affliction
of their protégé, a chorister boy who
has lost his sight, and to help him to
become the church organist. The book
may please the children of dear old
Mother Church; but much of it is too
improbable for our less inventive minds.
Villegagnon: a Tale of the Huguenot
Persecution. By W. H. G. KINGSTON.
Sunday School Union.
WITH such a theme as the Huguenot
persecution for such a pen as that of
W. H. G. Kingston, it is no wonder
that, when once we opened this book,
we did not close it till we had read it
through. To every boy or girl who has
the opportunity, we say, "Go, and do
thou likewise."
Young Sir Richard. By H. FREDERICK
CHARLES. Religious Tract Society.
A WELL-TOLD tale of a spoiled child, the
only son of a baronet, who was so occu-
pied with the affairs of the State that
he neglected to look after his heir. Be-
reavement and trials bring out the true
manhood of the "Young Sir Richard,"
and the story ends with the promise of
a godly and useful career. There is
much real gospel in the book, and
although there are 464 pages in it, there
is not a love story or a bit of match-
making in it. Perhaps some people
will not think this is a recommendation,
but wiser people will.
641
Through the United States and Canada.
By Rev. J. K. CAMPBELL, D.D.
S. W. Partridge and Co.
THOSE who have read Dr. Campbell's
tour through Egypt and Palestine will
be prepared to find this account of his
Holiday Ramble through the States
equally lively and instructive. The
descriptions are graphic and true, while
the record of his various experiences
en route is written in a bright way. It
is a handy little volume for anyone
about to visit the Western continent.
The Child's Own Magazine. New
Series. Sunday School Union.
THE numbers of The Child's Own
Magazine make up a pretty book, for
the binding is most delightful. We do
not know where Mater-familias, on the
look-out for a Christmas-box for little
Harry, or Amy, could get more for
eighteenpence.
The United Methodist Free Churches
Magazine. Edited by R. ABERCROM-
BIE, M.A. Crombie, 119, Salisbury
Square.
A MAGAZINE conducted with remark-
able energy: a credit to the body which
it represents.
The British and Colonial Temperance
Congress. London, July, 1886.
National Temperance Publication
Depôt, 337, Strand.
WISELY did the National League utilize
the great gathering convened by the
Colonial and Indian Exhibition. Many
seed-thoughts fell from the various
speakers which will, we doubt not,
fructify in various ways. Fetch men
from where you may, and with one
voice they denounce strong drink as the
enemy of their people. It is evil, only
evil, and that continually. The sorrows
caused by it are immeasurable. And
yet many Christian people countenance
drinking customs.
The Handy Natural History. By J.
G. WOOD. Religious Tract Society.
It will be no small advantage to the
young naturalist to have such a book
as this to begin upon. It will give him
an outline of the animal world in all its
departments, and then he can at leisure
fill in the details from larger works. To
stimulate the desire to know about
God's living creatures is a good design,
and Mr. Wood is above most men suc-
cessful in this direction. This volume
would make a fine Christmas present.
With its wealth of illustrations, and
general attractiveness, it will yield great
pleasure to any person who becomes its
possessor. Our readers who are not
naturalists will bear with us if we say
that they neglect one of the most fertile
fields of study. We have a thousand
times found our surest recreation in
going to the ant or the bee, or in read-
ing stories of lions or dogs. We prefer
an hour of zoology to all the novels that
were ever inflicted upon this much-
enduring age. Fiction is the alcohol of
the mind, but natural history yields
draughts of pure water from fresh and
sparkling fountains.
Young England. An Illustrated Maga-
zine for Recreation and Instruction.
Young England Office, 56 and 60,
Old Bailey.
THIS juvenile serial is so largely made
up of stories, that we cannot consider it
the best kind of literature for youth.
We do not quite see why the Sunday
School Union should issue it. From
ordinary publishers we should accept
the book with thanks for its moral and
religious tone; but from a Christian
society we take it with less gratitude.
It is not up to our ideal.
Our Four-Footed Friends. By MARY
HOWITT.
Stories and Pictures of Birds, Beasts,
and Fishes. By JAMES WESTON.
Our Picture-Book. By D. J. D.
Partridge and Co.
BEAUTIFUL! Beautiful, without and
within. Only two shillings each.
We should not know which to choose
if we were Master Tommy, and we
should hope that papa would feel in
the same difficulty, and would get out
of it by buying all three. By such
books children are taught kindness to
all living things, and this lesson needs
constant repetition. What cruel crea-
tures boys are! We see them hunting
cats in the street as if it were a sacred
duty. As for a frog or a newt, what
eagerness to crush it! There is an im-
provement, but there is yet sad need to
rebuke the brutality of many men, and
to prevent similar savagery being per-
petrated by their sons.
43
Ingleside; or, Without Christ, and with him. By Mrs. MADELINE LESLIE. Hodder and Stoughton.
THE author says that her object is "to prove from a series of scenes drawn from real life, the misery of those, whether rich or poor, who live without Christ, and the peace and comfort of those in whom the spirit of Christ dwells as the actuating principle of duty. The scenes were selected by the author from a number, either falling under her own observation, or narrated by friends who vouched for their truthfulness." Very remarkable and romantic some of these "scenes" are; and wrought into what we may term a "unified" story, the result is a delightful book. When we say that the writer is an American, the reader will "guess" that it is a live story. The get-up of the book bespeaks for it a welcome.
The Prince of the House of David. By the Rev. Professor J. H. INGRAHAM.
Uncle Tom's Cabin. By Mrs. HARRIET BEECHER STOWE.
Strawberry Hill. By CLARA VANCE.
The Talbury Girls. By CLARA VANCE.
[Four volumes of "The Ivy Series."] Hodder and Stoughton.
CHEAP at two shillings each—perhaps the cheapest in the market. "The Prince of the House of David" has been very popular; but we question the propriety of turning the holiest of holy facts into fiction. The other three books need no remark, for they are old friends.
Frank Fielding; or, Debts and Difficulties. By AGNES VEITCH. Hodder and Stoughton.
A WELL-INTENTIONED story for young men: there are no boys nowadays, at least, so we have heard, or we should have said "for boys." The narrative lacks the style which would make it acceptable to the average male youth.
A Final Reckoning: a Tale of Bush Life in Australia. By G. A. HENTY. Blackie and Son.
MR. HENTY is the king of story-tellers for boys. Here he is among blacks and bush-rangers, with his blood up, and all his wits at work. We suppose that
there are fathers who will spend five shillings in giving Jack and Tom a real sensation of a book; but we certainly should not be among them. The boys would like the tale no doubt, and would want to sit up all night, and read every word of it upon the spot; but we do not feel so very sure that such reading would do them much good.
Two Little Books. By LOUISA SILKE. Religious Tract Society.
ONE of the prettiest of little story-books. It deserves to be the favourite of the season.
Gideon Hoole's Secret. A Story of Trial and Truth. By WILLIAM J. LACEY. Sunday School Union.
To lads just leaving home to begin the battle of life this "Young England Prize Tale" may prove a blessing, by putting them on their guard against the wiles of vicious fellow employés, or by dispelling the illusions of those who are contemplating running away to sea to end a sea of troubles—jumping into the sea to escape from a shower.
Down the Snow Stairs; or, from Good-Night to Good-Morning. By ALICE CORKRAN. Blackie and Son.
AT first sight one is tempted to say, "Here is another of those wild fairy tales"; but, indeed, there is much more in this elegant volume. A girl is on the cover in gold, with a little black demon near her face: what can the book be about? It is filled with allegories setting forth the temptations of life as they come to children. We have a very pretty framework in the story of a sister and her sickly brother Johnny. The little lady's dreams form the bulk of the volume, and bring before us vivid pictures of a soul in its struggles after the true way of happiness. It is a singular book: its philosophy is deep and its imagination remarkable. We have read it with much interest. It would not have been easy to work in the spiritual facts which lie at the base of all high morality, and act as the stimulus of all struggling after better things; but as far as morals go, the teaching of Miss Corkran's book is first rate, and the tale which enshrines it is a notable one.
643
Phases of Christian Truth: Sermons.
By A. J. PARRY. Third Edition.
London: John Barton, 11, St.
George's Road, S.E.
WE praised these sermons when we received the first edition, and we see no reason for altering our judgment. We like the vivacity of Mr. Parry. He burns and blazes with Welsh fire. Success to the third edition. The publisher's name will be new to most readers, but he is well known to us, and to many of our students. We hope his first venture will prove a happy one.
Preludes to the Reformation; or, From Dark to Day in Europe. Church History Series. By the Rev. ARTHUR ROBERT PENNINGTON, M.A. Religious Tract Society.
MANY agencies were preparing the world for Luther's Reformation: he was as much the child of the reformation as he was the father of it. Canon Pennington traces the causes of the grand event, noting the decline of the power of the Pope, and the real results produced by what seemed to be unsuccessful attempts at reforming the church. The influence of the revival of learning is also mentioned, and the increased brightness of religious knowledge is dwelt upon. We do not think the book is as lively as it might be, but it is solidly good.
The Pulpit Commentary. Edited by CANON SPENCE and JOSEPH EXELL. HEBREWS. By Dr. BARMBY, and others. Kegan Paul, Trench and Co.
WE feel satisfied with Owen. Perhaps a commentary on the Hebrews is less required than on any other book of the Bible. We suppose it was necessary to issue an exposition of Hebrews to complete the Pulpit Commentary; but we do not think it was needful for any other reason.
The great fault of saying a thing over several times occurs in this, as in the previous volumes. The work is tolerably well done: nothing very remarkable, but fairly good. We do not vouch for all the doctrine, even in this case; but in some other of the New Testament volumes we see teaching to protest against. On the whole, this large commentary threatens to be buried
under its own colossal bulk. The portly expositions will be useful to those who can get them; but guineas are scarce with ministers, and when they have one to spare they do not buy volumes which are in any measure padded with repetitions. We are sorry to have to say as much as this, for we heartily welcomed many of the earlier volumes; and even these, about which we feel no enthusiasm, are works of considerable ability, by no means to be dismissed with cold censure. The present comment is a gain to exegetical literature; but we do not think it takes the very highest rank. The price is 15s.
The Homes, Haunts, and Battlefields of the Covenanters. By A. B. TODD. Edinburgh: James Gemmell.
OUR author is not brilliant, but he is chatty, and knows how to make a good deal out of small incidents. We do not blame him for this, for in the stream of covenanting history every tiny pebble looks like a jewel. He looks up old houses and old stones, and dotes upon them. He is, moreover, a great lover of Church and State, and, as we judge, holds to the old-fashioned letter of covenanting as well as to the spirit of it. In this we have no union with him. The principle which maintains a national church led to the persecution of the Covenanters. The Lord Jesus is King of Scotland, and of every other nation; and we feel assured from all we know of his righteous rule that he would not exact forced support for a favoured sect, but would issue his mandate that his cause should be supported by the free gifts of his willing people. It is not Christ, but Cæsar, that establishes national churches. However, we do not quarrel with Mr. Todd for his peculiarities, for we like to see any man holding fast to that which he believes to be the word of the Lord. In these ill days we can do with a few more Covenanters, even of the oldest school. We heartily unite in doing honour to Scotland's heroic martyrs, and we thank our author for preserving their memories.
"The Solemn League and Covenant
Cost Scotland blood, cost Scotland tears;
But it seal'd Freedom's sacred cause.
If thou'rt a slave, indulge thy sneers."
