Compulsory Tithes: not founded on Jewish Tithes — [Sixth Article.] — By Pastor W. M. Hawkins, Hundon, Clare, Suffolk
THAT the Jews in the Holy Land paid tithes by God's command is indisputable. That God complained when they neglected to make the payments good is also certain. He pronounced severe censures and denunciations on the Israelites when they neglected to pay their tithes. He also promised to bless them abundantly if they would obey him in this. In Malachi iii. 10 to 12, we read: "Bring ye all the tithes into the storehouse, that there may be meat in mine house, and prove me now herewith, saith the Lord of hosts, if I will not open you the windows of heaven, and pour you out a blessing, that there shall not be room enough to receive it. And I will rebuke the devourer for your sakes, and he shall not destroy the fruits of your ground; neither shall your vine cast her fruit before the time in the field, saith the Lord of hosts. And all nations shall call you blessed: for ye shall be a delightsome land, saith the Lord of hosts." In this chapter withholding the tithes is called "robbing God."
Numbers xxxv. 2-8: "Command the children of Israel, that they give unto the Levites of the inheritance of their possession cities to dwell in; and ye shall give also unto the Levites suburbs for the cities round about them. And the cities shall they have to dwell in; and the suburbs of them shall be for their cattle, and for their goods, and for all their beasts. And the suburbs of the cities, which ye shall give unto the Levites, shall reach from the wall of the city and outward a thousand cubits round about. And ye shall measure from without the city on the east side two thousand cubits, and on the south side two thousand cubits, and on the west side two thousand cubits, and on the north side two thousand cubits; and the city shall be in the midst: this shall be to them the suburbs of the cities. And among the cities which ye shall give unto the Levites there shall be six cities for refuge, which ye shall appoint for the manslayer, that he may flee thither: and to them ye shall add forty and two cities. So all the cities which ye shall give to the Levites shall be forty and eight cities: them shall ye give with their suburbs. And the cities which ye shall give shall be of the possession of the children of Israel: from them that have many ye shall give many; but from them that have few ye shall give few: every one shall give of his cities unto the Levites according to his inheritance which he inheriteth."
To understand the subject it is necessary to examine these particulars.
1. The number of the cities appointed for the Levites was forty-eight. Six of them were for cities of refuge. "They could not enlarge the bounds prescribed to their cities, but they might increase the number of the cities, as the number of the Levites increased, and necessity required. The reason is, they might not add house to house, and field to field, lest, growing great in earthly possessions, they should forget God, who had otherwise provided for them than by manuring the earth; but if they wanted habitations, they might then seek for new cities, and the care of the people was to provide them for them. One Levite might not have more than sufficient for his habitation, but if the cities appointed were not sufficient to yield a habitation for every Levite, then might they assign new cities to that purpose."—Sir H. Spelman's larger work on "Tythes," c. III.
Each city, with its suburbs, appears to have been less than three miles in area. I confess that there is some difficulty in ascertaining the exact amount of land the Levites had.
The whole of the Promised Land was given to the lay tribes, with the exception of land for forty-eight cities and glebes. From the fourth and fifth verses in Numbers xxxv., I am of opinion that the entire amount of land allotted to the priestly tribe was less than 144 miles. According to W. Murphy's "Bible Atlas," p. 15, on "Palestine, or the Holy Land," "its extent is variously stated,
541
but according to the most accurate computation it may be said to be upwards of 210 miles in length, and probably 100 in breadth." This gives an area of 21,000 miles that was divided amongst thirteen tribes, reckoning the house of Joseph as two tribes, according to Joshua xiv. 4. Out of 21,000 miles of land the priestly tribe appears to have had only 144 miles, or less. That is only about a 145th part of the land. Each of the other tribes had on an average 1738 miles. Whatever amount the tribe of Levi had, it was so small that the tribe had "no inheritance." Their share of the country was a mere speck.
2. The lay tribes received nearly all the land, and therefore they received nearly all the wealth of the country. Probably each family received from fifty to one hundred acres of freehold. They had "no rent" to pay, and could well afford to pay tithes, even if they got nothing in return. But they received a great deal in return, as we shall see.
3. The whole of the time, talents, and energies of the tribe of Levi were devoted, by the command of God, to promote the spiritual and temporal prosperity of the whole nation. This the Levites did whilst the other Israelites were acquiring wealth. The Levites were set apart from every kind of trade, commerce, or profession, so that they might devote all their energies to the well-being of the tribes who had received from God nearly all the wealth of the country. It is necessary now closely to examine the duties divinely laid on the tribe of Levi, and the remuneration appointed, viz., tithes and offerings. The Levites were the descendants of Levi, but principally those who were employed in the lowest services of the temple, by which they were distinguished from the priests, who being descended from Aaron, were consecrated to higher offices. The Levites were descendants of Levi by Gershom, Kobath, and Merari, excepting the family of Aaron; the children of Moses having no part in the priesthood, and being only common Levites. Aaron's family was chosen out of the tribe of Levi to be priests. God chose the Levites instead of the firstborn of all Israel for the service of his tabernacle and temple: Numbers iii. 6, &c. They obeyed the priests in the ministrations of the temple, and brought to them wood, water, and other things needful for sacrifices. They sang, and played on the musical instruments in the temple, &c.; they studied the law, and were the ordinary judges of the country, but subordinate to the priests. The tribe of Levi had to take charge of all the holy things of the sacred places, with all their utensils, ornaments, and furniture; the fire on the altar, the lighting and trimming of the lamp, the replacing of the shew-bread, the offering of the victims, and the burning of incense. They had to be the physicians and ordinary judges of the nation. They led the singing and played the musical instruments in the places of worship. They studied the law, and were the ordinary lawyers of the country. They had charge of the cities of refuge. They were the mediators between God and his people. Besides all these works of mercy, they had to minister to the wants of the stranger, the widow, the fatherless, the aged, the infirm, and the needy. All these offices they had by law to perform. The Levites and priests, in fact, were the temporal and spiritual instructors, and physicians, and common friends, and helpers of the Jews. If a person had any complaint on him, he went to the priest to be examined. If the priest on examination was not satisfied, he would shut him up for seven days, and of course feed him. If a man unfortunately, by accident, caused any one to die, where was he to go for shelter except to one of the cities of refuge kept by the priestly tribe? He had no other refuge.
All these offices the Levites had to perform, and they had no wealth to draw upon. They could not acquire wealth, nor any income at all, except in the way that God had appointed, namely, by tithes and offerings. But, before proceeding further, it is well to prove what has been advanced.
1. That the priests and Levites could not have property other than their official income. Numbers xviii. 20, 24: "And the Lord spake unto Aaron, Thou shalt have no inheritance in their land, neither shalt thou have any part among them: I am thy part and thine inheritance among the children of Israel.
... But the tithes of the children of Israel, which they offer as an heave offering unto the Lord, I have given to the Levites to inherit: therefore I have said unto them, Among the children of Israel they shall have no inheritance."
2. They were to stand as atoning priests and mediators between God and the Israelites.
We very frequently read, as in Lev. iv. 20: "And the priest shall make an atonement for them, and it shall be forgiven them." Lev. ix. 7: "And Moses said unto Aaron, Go unto the altar and offer thy sin offering and thy burnt offering, and make an atonement for thyself, and for the people: and offer the offering of the people, and make an atonement for them; as the Lord commanded." There are many such passages. The Israelite was not allowed to do it himself.
3. They were physicians and plague examiners.
Lev. xiii., xiv., and xv. are devoted to the description of the priests' duties respecting uncleanness of all kinds, including leprosy in human beings, in dwellings, in garments, &c. In Deut. xxiv. 8: "Take heed in the plague of leprosy, that thou observe diligently, and do according to all that the priests the Levites shall teach you: as I commanded them, so ye shall observe to do."
In our Lord's time, when lepers appealed to him for healing, he sent them to the priests. This was done according to the law of Moses.
4. The tribe of Levi had to study the law, and to instruct the people. This is proved in Deut. xxxi. 9, 11, 12, and 13: "And Moses wrote this law, and delivered it unto the priests the sons of Levi, which bare the ark of the covenant of the Lord, and unto all the elders of Israel. . . . When all Israel is come to appear before the Lord thy God in the place which he shall choose, thou shalt read this law before all Israel in their hearing. Gather the people together, men, and women, and children, and thy stranger that is within thy gates, that they may hear, and that they may learn, and fear the Lord your God, and observe to do all the words of this law: and that their children, which have not known anything, may hear, and learn to fear the Lord your God, as long as ye live in the land whither ye go over Jordan to possess it." Also in Deut. xxxiii. Moses, in giving his parting blessing to all the tribes, said of the tribe of Levi, in verse 10: "They shall teach Jacob thy judgments, and Israel thy law," &c. They were the nation's lawyers.
5. The six cities of refuge were amongst the cities allotted to the Levites. Numbers xxxv. 6: "And among the cities which ye shall give unto the Levites there shall be six cities for refuge, which ye shall appoint for the manslayer, that he may flee thither: and to them ye shall add forty and two cities."
6. The widow, the fatherless and the stranger were to be fed from the tithe along with the Levites. Deut. xiv. 28, 29: "At the end of three years thou shalt bring forth all the tithe of thine increase the same year, and shalt lay it up within thy gates: and the Levite, (because he hath no part nor inheritance with thee,) and the stranger, and the fatherless, and the widow, which are within thy gates, shall come, and shall eat and be satisfied; that the Lord thy God may bless thee in all the work of thine hand which thou doest."
7. The whole of their time had to be devoted to advance the temporal and eternal interests of Israel, and of all who flocked to that nation. They had all the above described offices to fulfil; and some of them were costly, and they had no wealth to fall back on, as they could not acquire property.
The other tribes having received all the land, were commanded to give tithes to the tribe of Levi, who devoted all their time and talents for their good, and at the same time had no inheritance.
This, surely, was a fair and reasonable arrangement. No tribe of Israel could say that he was wronged of so much as a grain of wheat by this arrangement. It could not be said that the Israelites were not gainers by this divinely appointed plan. They had the land, and of course the wealth that the land produced.
543
8. The Jewish tithes were *not* compulsory. If they had been compulsory, there would have been penalties attached to their non-payment. We find no record of any such penalties. The payment of tithes was a subject of *conscience*. It was a matter *between the Israelite and his God*. For proof, "To the law and to the testimony." In commanding Moses respecting trespass offerings for sacrilege, etc., in *Leviticus v. 14—16*: "And the Lord spake unto Moses, saying, If a soul commit a trespass, and sin through ignorance, in the holy things of the Lord; then he shall bring for his trespass unto the Lord a ram without blemish out of the flocks, with thy estimation by shekels of silver, after the shekel of the sanctuary, for a trespass offering: and he shall make amends for the harm that he hath done in the holy thing, and shall add the fifth part thereto, and give it unto the priest: and the priest shall make an atonement for him with the ram of the trespass offering, and it shall be forgiven him."
The Rev. G. Wall, in his "Domestic Dictionary of the Bible," on tithes writes: "If a person had committed a trespass against the sanctuary, that is, had not paid the tithe of any particular things, and, if at any time afterwards, his conscience was awakened to a sense of his guilt, he had it still in his power to make atonement without incurring any civil disgrace. He had only to pay an additional fifth along with it, and to make a trespass offering." (*Leviticus v. 14—16*). Michaelis "Commentary on the Laws of Moses," vol. iii. art. 192.
Matthew Henry, Dr. Adam Clarke, and other learned commentators agree with the above, and are of opinion that the penalties attached to the non-payment of tithes were ecclesiastical *only*. There is nothing to indicate civil penalties of any kind either in the Bible, Josephus, or in Benny's "Criminal Code of the Jews." There is in Benny a passage that proves my point. On page 128, in writing of Miscellaneous Laws, he informs us, "Confiscation of property was unknown to the Hebrew law, a malefactor's possessions always descending to the natural heritors." The soul that sinned presumptuously was cut off from among the people (Numbers xv. 30). The Jewish tithe-system furnishes no basis for the English tithe-system.
Consider also the following:—
1. There is now no separate and distinct tribe set apart for the Christian Ministry.
2. Ministers are not necessarily without an earthly inheritance. Some of them possess houses and lands. Sometimes they are the most wealthy of any in the parish.
3. Tithe-paid ministers are not physicians, lawyers, or general friends of the people. There are honourable exceptions: but the vast majority of them have little sympathy with the masses of the people, and little faith in them. It cannot be said that they are, or have been, the friends of the people.
4. God himself appointed the Priests and Levites to their offices; but it cannot be proved that he appointed the tithe-paid clergy. When God appointed the tribe of Levi to their sacred offices, he laid down rules and restrictions. No priest who had any blemish could minister before the Lord. In *Leviticus xxi. 16—24*: "And the Lord spake unto Moses, saying, Speak unto Aaron, saying, Whosoever he be of thy seed in their generations that hath any blemish, let him not approach to offer the bread of his God. For whatsoever man he be that hath a blemish, he shall not approach: a blind man, or a lame, or he that hath a flat nose, or anything superfluous, or a man that is brokenfooted, or brokenhanded, or crookback, or a dwarf, or that hath a blemish in his eye, or be scurvy, or scabbed. . . . No man that hath a blemish of the seed of Aaron the priest shall come nigh to offer the offerings of the Lord made by fire: he hath a blemish; he shall not come nigh to offer the bread of his God. He shall eat the bread of his God, both of the most holy, and of the holy," etc.
All this refers to *ceremonial service*. *That service must be rendered by people without a blemish*. The *Christian service is spiritual*, and should at least be rendered by *spiritually-minded men*. How can a man who is not spiritual
discern that which is spiritual? What is a man but blind if he is not converted? If spiritually blind, he is as incapable of serving God as the Jewish priest who was physically blind, or lame, or in any way defective.
The priests and Levites devoted all their time to the duties belonging to their callings. There is no guarantee that this is so with the tithe-paid clergy. Many canons of the church, and acts of parliament, prove that thousands of the tithe-paid clergy never attended to their duties at all. It would take some considerable time to count up the canons and acts against non-residence and plurality of benefices. In a lecture by Sir John Conroy, on "Church Endowments," recently delivered, and published by the Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, I find on page 19, "It is difficult to picture to ourselves the state of things when pluralist rectors, who held several livings of which they performed the duty by deputy, were common (it is on record that at one time in the Diocese of Norwich there were three brothers who held fifteen livings between them): when bishops lived, not in their own dioceses, but at Kew, as was the case at the end of the last century with the Archbishop of York and the Bishops of Worcester and Exeter, and people did not seem to think it at all odd that they should do so: and when a sort of lethargy had overspread the church." This paragraph is by no means singular although it is very significant.
There is no need to make laws to compel earnest spiritual shepherds who wish to feed the flock of God to live amongst them. The canons and acts that were passed to compel clergymen to reside in their parishes, or give up the livings, are so many crying disgraces, and living monuments of the unfitness of multitudes of the tithe-paid clergy, and of the failure of the system that creates and supports them. Such men are not in earnest. Their hearts are not in their work.
5. The apportionment of the tithe in Canaan has no analogy in the English tithe-system. The Levites received the tithes, and paid one tenth of them to the priests. The Levites did all the secular work of the temple, etc., and received nine-tenths of the tithe, and one-tenth only went to the priests. Our State clergy would not like this part of the Jewish arrangement. The Rector takes all the tithe as his official property—his legal due, and keeps it as long as the chancel of his church is in good repair. In the Jewish system nine tenths of the tithes went to meet incidental expenses, relief of the poor, the aged, the afflicted, and the support of the six cities of refuge.
6. When tithes were established, the church and the nation were convertible terms. The Almighty himself was the Head of the church, and the King of Israel. This is not so in England, and never was. It is certain that the Church and the State are not and never were convertible terms in England. The tithe supported church is not national in any sense, except that everybody has to support it, either directly or indirectly. The Jewish church was designed to benefit the whole nation. The English church is intended only to benefit those who are able to put men's words before God's—the Prayer-book before the Bible. Every Israelite could claim a benefit from the tithes, but this is not so in England. In Canaan the poor had a share. In England the poor used to have a third, but they are now thrust out, and the whole nation is taxed with a poor-rate.
7. There was no personal tithe in Canaan. In the time of Charles I. an award was made to the clergy of the city of Norwich, that 2s. in the pound should be paid to them on the rents of all houses, shops, etc., etc., in the city in lieu of personal tithes. Personal tithes had been demanded from business men, labourers, artisans, soldiers, and even from prostitutes! Dean Prideaux tells us that in the Holy Land personal tithes were unknown. 1. Because there were none to pay. 2. Because, if there had been any, there was no need of them.
8. When the Jews left the Land of Promise, they ceased to pay tithes. This proves that they regarded the arrangement as local and peculiar to them and
545
to their possessions in Canaan. The Jews support their religion now on the grand and efficient voluntary system. Lastly, God appointed that his people should learn his law and wisdom from the priests. Mal. ii. 7.: "For the priest's lips should keep knowledge, and they should seek the law at his mouth: for he is the messenger of the Lord of hosts." Is there an honest response to this to-day by our "parish priests"? From these considerations, it is manifest that there is no foundation whatever for the English tithe-system in the laws of Moses.
[The writer of these articles has been repeatedly requested to publish them with others in book form. He would be glad if any reader would kindly furnish him with facts or incidents, that would be interesting as illustrations.]
