Menu
‹ Chapter 241 of 294 ›

Unity and how not to promote it — By C. H. Spurgeon

12 min read · Chapter 241 of 294

ALL Christians desire the unity of the church. No one justifies the divisions of Christendom, or wishes to perpetuate them. The evil results of division are seen at home, and felt abroad in the mission-field; and anything practicable which would bring the churches together, and make them

truly one, would command the attention and the favour of all good men. Oh that once again we all rallied to the cry of "One Lord, one faith, one baptism"!

Out of this most laudable desire grows many an idle attempt, and foisted upon it there may come many a device of the enemy which will work serious mischief. The bait of unity may cover the hook of heresy. Division itself may be deepened and increased by methods which are proposed in the name of Christian love. Whenever an object is much upon the mind of masses of good men, the state of desire and expectancy engendered by it creates an opportunity for fanaticism on the one hand, and for diplomacy on the other. Availing themselves of a prevailing sentiment, men of policy have pushed forward their own designs under its cover. In this case, in the name of union, certain parties have striven for supremacy, and have again and again grasped at universal dominion in the name of Christian love. We shall have taken a step in advance, if from the history of the church we perceive the failure of one at least of the favourite remedies for division.

It has occurred to many minds of different orders, that the shortest

35

method for setting forth the unity of the church of Christ is to believe your own church to be the church of Christ; and to call upon all other churches to quit their separation, and come over to you at once. So very simple has this appeared to be, that it has commended itself to several parties, and it has seemed to them to be unquestionably the royal road to unity. It is being tried to-day, and those who are trying it have a childlike, not to say a childish, faith in it. The projectors of the method are all the day wondering why a stiff-necked generation has not been obedient to their call. Is it not self-evident that this is the readiest way out of all the entanglements of sectarianism, and the surest end to all the fends which arise out of the existence of denominations? Let our church be at once acknowledged to be the church of Christ, and let all sects and parties be merged therein once for all. To disobey a mandate so plainly right is a grievous sin, which can only be accounted for by sectarian prejudice, or the obstinacy of inveterate stupidity. Oh that men were wise, and without further controversy would join this one and only church, which has such a clear vision for the faults of other churches, and is itself so free from all defects!

But in all humility we venture to ask, Whence comes this authoritative voice? Our ears hear the sound of it from all points of the compass, and we are therefore puzzled. We have a difficulty even upon the infallible system now proposed: unto which of the saints shall we turn? Whence comes the supreme voice which we are bound to obey? Is it from the Romish hierarchy, hoary with age, and venerable with prestige? Certainly, if length of years can establish its claim to be the church, it holds its own against all comers as a separate institution. It is far younger than the church of Christ, but it is one of the oldest of the claimants of that title. Yet we venture to assert that no number of years can make falsehood to be true. A community which is defiled with idolatry in the worship of images, saints, angels, and so forth, is not the church of Jesus Christ. In innumerable ways the Romish church has departed from the words of the Lord Jesus; and if any man reading the New Testament will attend its worship, and enquire into its teachings, he will decide that it is not the church of the Lord Jesus, neither is it anything like it. Its claims are most imperious, its condemnations of all questioners are many and decisive, and its efforts to obtain universal dominion are zealous and far-reaching; yet we are persuaded that the rent robe of Christ will never be repaired by the Papal needle, nor will union come through all churches paying obeisance to the Bishop of Rome. The truth is, that it would be death for the church of Christ if the Papacy ruled over it.

A voice nearer home speaks the same word, and ever imitates the Italian tone. From the Roman to the Anglican establishment is a considerable step, for this last can never vie in historical evidence with the older claimant. How a church, which owes its separate existence to the Protestant Reformation, can set up an unprotestant claim to be the church we cannot tell. Indeed, it is not all the Episcopalian community which endorses this pretence, but only a portion of it. This section of the episcopalian body is very bold in its profession, and arrogant in its language. It is the church, and all who dissent from it are schismatics and heretics. It is sinful to hear a

515

preacher, however good he may be, if he does not belong to the church. All other so-called churches are mere sectarian societies, and are to be avoided by good churchmen. Even the evangelicals within the pale are set down as little better than disguised dissenters: the light which is in them is darkness. Join the High-church, and persuade everybody to do the same, and the unity of the church is secured; and all the more so since prayer is daily offered that the Anglican church may be visibly united with the Greek and Roman communions.

To this overture we reply that, if we did not see the church of Rome to be the fit centre for the faithful, we have equal difficulty in finding such a centre at Canterbury. Are we all to submit to a Prelacy, to use a stereotyped form of prayer, and to accept errors similar to the grand falsehood of Baptismal Regeneration? The church of Christ has never taught that doctrine. We find the teachings of the primitive church in the New Testament, and we perceive among those teachings truths which are diametrically opposed to this and other superstitions of Anglican priests. The arrogant claim put forth by this community to be the church is not worthy of a moment's consideration. By the same reasoning which it employs to prove its own point, and to condemn all Non-conformity, it proves fatally too much, for it vindicates the Papacy, and condemns itself.

Taking Holy Scripture as our guide, we are amused at the effrontery which is shown by these two bodies of ecclesiastics when they boast of being the church of Christ; they might as well profess to be a company of angels, or a herd of buffaloes. There is no relationship between these pretentious confederacies and the church of Christ if we view them in a spiritual light: as organized bodies they are about as far removed from the apostolic church as darkness from light, or death from life. We are not judging the many individuals within their bounds who may be godly and gracious men; we only refer to these ecclesiastical societies in their corporate form. There can be no union in the body of Christ by means of these confederacies, since they are themselves in many ways antagonistic to the true church of Christ, if it be still what it was in our Lord's days.

These two specimens of exclusiveness might have sufficed throughout all time to illustrate the way by which unity never can be reached. These are two instances of the reductio ad absurdum; two experiments resulting in disastrous failure; two specimens of the way in which the claim to be the church does not mend the torn vesture of the Lord, but makes the rent worse. The fact is, that this exclusive claim is of the essence of schism, and is the soul of sectarianism, by whomsoever it is put forward. No course of conduct is more sure to create division than for any church superciliously to exalt itself and claim to be the church of Christ. Yet the idea has a bewitching influence, and continues to mislead. If men were wise, they would see that the endeavour to set up your own party as a centre has been worked out in its inevitable consequences so many times already, that henceforth it is worthier of a kindly ridicule than of serious thought.

Among later incidents which illustrate our point, we may quote the story of Plymouth Brotherism. Here again was the church; not this time in cathedrals and palaces, but in upper rooms and hired houses;

yet quite as exclusive and infallible as old Rome. The brethren gathered to "the name," and all other believers were in Babylon, or some other city of confusion. Churches which had kept the faith, and suffered, and laboured for the Lord's sake centuries before the new brotherhood was born or thought of, were all less than nothing and vanity; but the half-dozen who broke bread in the "assembly," these were the church of Jesus Christ. By this means sects were to be ended, for "the brethren" were not a sect; denominations were to be annihilated, for "the brethren" were not a denomination. Few as they were compared with the great bulk of Christians, they were the wheat, and all the rest were the chaff. After creating no end of heart-burning in churches, and unnatural hatred in families; after warring among themselves, and splitting and splitting again, these brethren have left us as the net result of their exertions a sect which exceeds all others in party spirit and bitter exclusiveness. To hope for the unity of Christendom by this means would be to expect grapes from thorns, or figs from thistles. "The brethren," as individuals, are among the best of men, and we love and honour them; but in their collective capacity, as arrogating themselves to be the church of Christ, they are a transparent imposition. We repeat the remark, that not a word have we to say against "brethren" one by one; among them have been teachers at whose feet we would willingly sit; yet the community in its organic action commands from us no commendation, but very much the reverse. The eyes of astonishment are opened to the utmost when it is reported that little coteries of conscientious but unbrotherly brothers are in some way or other the core of Christendom, the élite of the elect—if not the whole of the chosen. There is no need seriously to argue against a claim so childish.

In this instance also it is seen that the leaven of exclusive pretence ferments to strife. Call yourselves nothing at all, but insinuate that you are the only ones who are really the church of God, and you have scattered seed which will produce a harvest of strife. The pretence of non-sectarianism will serve as a blind, so that you may the better attack the churches of our Lord Jesus, but there will be no other use for it: it will entrap the unwary, but it will answer no other purpose. To become a Plymouth Brother in order to escape the evils of sectarianism is to leap into the sea for fear of being wetted by its spray. In most localities this is so well known that what was once a potent weapon of offence has now lost its power. Observant persons no longer listen to the Siren song which once enticed so many upon dangerous shores.

There are signs that the plan is now to be tried over again by another band of professors. The Campbellite denomination of Christians has as much right to make proselytes in England as any other body of religionists, and we should not think of going out of our way to oppose it. All sorts of workers will find ample scope in London and other great cities, and all may work together for good. But all denominational extension should be done openly and above-board; there should be no pretence of unsectarianism when a sect is endeavouring to convert others to its peculiarities. If the Campbellites wish us to believe that they are the church of Christ, they should also let us know what they are as to their distinctive views. That they are Christians we never doubted: that they are Christians more than any other baptized

517

believers we greatly question. Their advocates, it seems, are pleading for the church of Christ, and they themselves are Christians, while others are only Baptists, Episcopalians, Presbyterians, or Methodists. We are as truly Christians as they are, and possibly all the more truly Christian in spirit because we lay no invidious claim to the title. Yet it is hinted that if we join the Campbellites, we shall join the church of Christ, and put an end to schism. We are all invited to unite ourselves with this American community. We like it neither the more nor the less because of its Transatlantic origin; but we do not see the propriety of subsiding into it. We esteem our brethren, but we do not subscribe to their teachings, and we repudiate their claims. Is it so, that they are Christians, and we are sectarians? Let them prove it by their greater likeness to their Lord, and their clearer manifestation of the spirit which vaunteth not itself.

The climax of sectarianism is to call your own body the church of Christ, and look down upon other believers as sectarians. Those churches which hold the head, Christ Jesus, and are quickened by the Holy Ghost, are all parts or members of Christ's body: or, in other words, they are sections or sects of the one great church. Hence we ourselves, in using the word "sect," do not imply the least censure; but when that word falls from certain lips it has a meaning full of contumely and condemnation. If the various churches dwell together in peace and love, they act according to the spirit of union; but if any one of these portions claims to be the whole, and begins to monopolize for itself the title of the church of Christ, it breathes the spirit of discord, and is not working towards unity, but towards division. The tendency on the part of those who listen to arrogant claims is to answer indignantly—Who are these that they should give themselves such airs? What is there about them that they should push us on one side, and say—Stand by, for I am more Christian than thou? It needs a great deal of grace to keep one's spirit calm when persons are pushing you down in the name of brotherly love. The offensive claim is greatly to be regretted, for the raising of even self-defensive questions is not helpful to love and concord. It may serve the ends of those who are introducing another denomination where there are enough already; but to talk of creating unity by it is vanity of vanity.

The most sectarian of all the sects are those which boast that they are not sects: this witness is true, and every candid observer will confirm it. These are not the men to foster unity, these whose hands are against all who do not agree with them. We are not now referring specifically to Campbellites, or Plymouthites, or Ritualists, or Romanists, but to any and all of those who proudly venture to urge peculiar claims to be the church. One of the first steps to unity will be for these exclusives to become decently humble, take their own places, and cast away once for all the delusion that they are anything in particular. When men are content to be on a level with all who love our Lord Jesus Christ in sincerity, and are able to see Christ in every part of his mystical body as well as in their own limb of it, they will be further advanced upon the way to unity than they are now in exalting themselves into a papal position. Each church will have enough to do to fulfil its own obligations to the Lord; it need not be ambitious to school its fellows into a sense of inferiority.

Even in controversy against pretensions which must be opposed, we must avoid falling into the error which we assail. Those who call us sectarians must not be allowed to conquer us so far as to make us retaliate. So far as there is anything opprobrious in the term "sect," let us not use it even towards the very sect of sects. These good people even in their vexatious claims are aiming at an ideal which is commendable. It is true they are destroying what they desire to build up; yet it is well that they wish to build it. Their failures serve to show us how perplexing is the problem of Christian union, and how great the difficulty of working it out. Possibly it may be better worked out incidentally than by any distinct effort. It is evident that other questions also demand attention, and perhaps some of them must first be answered, before we can touch that of unity. Let us seek after unity in its proper relation to other desirable objects of pursuit. Let us be first pure, then peaceable. Let us seek truth, and be ready to die for it; yet let us seek peace, and aim to live in it. How far we can be loyal both to love and truth is the question which only the Spirit of God can help us to answer. To be loyal to both should be our endeavour; but the path is one of such extreme difficulty that we must wait upon the Lord for daily guidance, or we shall soon miss our way. We must not sacrifice conscience to run with a denomination, neither must we forsake our erring brethren out of personal pique or private ambition. Above all, we must not aim at unity by setting ourselves up as the church, and styling all others "sectaries." This is to cement our walls with dynamite, and lay the foundations of peace upon barrels of gunpowder.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate