Notices of Books
Our Creed and Our Conduct. Address to the Yorkshire Association of Baptist Churches. By Rev. T. G. Rooke, B.A. Leeds: Walker and Laycock.
It did our very soul good to read this able address. There is hope for the churches while such a man as Mr. Rooke is at the head of one of our colleges: his deliverance is sound, judicious, and in every way invaluable.
Child-Converts: how to win them to Christ, and how to Train them as Christians. Circular Letter to the Churches in the Kent and Sussex Baptist Association. By Rev. T. Hancocks. Margate: R. Robinson.
ONE of the best circular letters ever written. It is first-rate, and deserves a circulation far beyond what the Kent and Sussex Association can procure for it. Mr. Hancocks here shows ability of the highest order.
Helps to Belief. The Morality of the Old Testament. By NEWMAN SMYTH, Cassell and Co.
WE have praised other books of this series, and therefore we are sorry to see such a mischievous work introduced among them. One rotten apple affects a whole shelf. This is no "help to belief"; but a packet of doubt seed. It is the way of modern thought to introduce its poisons among useful drugs.
Under pretence of defending the faith, Newman Smyth really undermines it.
The Resurrection of the Dead. By Rev. J. C. Bass. Dublin: Hodges, Figgis, and Co.
A LITTLE essay of forty pages read before a meeting of Christian ministers. The writer discusses an old question formulated by the philosophical Greeks, and quoted by the Apostle Paul (1 Cor. xv. 35): "How are the dead raised up? And with what body do they come?" He accepts and attempts to interpret the Apostle's answer. His theory is that the germ of the resurrection body is within us, and that the essence of the resurrection is the restoration of the vital principle; but that its present organic form will not be restored. The bare grain of wheat or of some other cereal thus supplies the hypothesis. Sixpence is quite enough to pay for this savoury morsel; a mere pamphlet in paper covers.
A Defence of the Baptists; or, the Baptism of Believers by Immersion the only Baptism of the Christian Dispensation By GEORGE GIBBS, of Norwich. Bristol: J. A. Vicary.
AN excellent treatise, which should not be allowed to die out. It first appeared some sixty years ago, and we are right glad to see a reprint of it. It ought to have a London publisher's name on the title-page.
Songs of the Pilgrim Land. By C. PENNEFATHER. Edited by E. St. B. H. Shaw and Co.
POEMS, not to be criticised, but accepted for their goodness. We feel a reverence for all that has to do with Mildmay and the name of Pennefather. This is a handsome volume, and the songs are such as are enjoyed in the form of leaflets, and have a special charm when newly issued in connection with some form of hallowed service.
The Poet in May. By EVELYN PYNE. Kegan Paul, Trench, and Co.
WE are conscious that these poems contain a good deal of poetry of a high order; but, somehow, we cannot get on with them. When we are puzzled it is hard to be delighted. We have spelled out the meaning, and when we have found it, we have wondered whether it was worth our while to have hunted it out. Song of this kind will charm its own select company; but minstrelsy is not alike musical to all ears, and this is not of the kind to which we yield our soul captive. We may meet this author again on themes more pleasing to our heart, and feel ourselves enamoured of his strains; for there is much in him, and he is not of your weaker sort.
Ecclesiastical English. A series of criticisms, showing the Old Testament Revisers' Violations of the Laws of the Language. Illustrated by more than one thousand quotations. By G. WASHINGTON MOON. Hatchards.
WHAT a terrible man is this Washington Moon! We should not like him to criticise anything we have written; for he has the eye of an eagle to detect the smallest speck. We have often said that it was a great pity that there was not placed upon the Revision Committee one man who was strong in pure English. We said this in reference to the New Testament, for which nobody has much to say; but we are sorry that the same observation applies to the Old Testament. Mr. Moon exhibits the slips and blunders of the Revision with an unsparing hand. There was good reason for so doing; such errors ought not to have been tolerated in so important a volume, produced under the highest sanctions. Did these learned men
think it beneath them to be correct in English? Did they all suffer from the neglect of the mother tongue which was so general in schools and universities in their younger days? We did not need a Blunder Bible to complete the series of eccentric Scriptures.
While there is a good deal of fun in this severe criticism, there is also much to arouse regret that the grandest opportunity for revision which could ever occur has been so sadly thrown away. However, good has come out of evil: the old Authorized Version sits secure upon its throne. There is none like it; nor is there likely to be.
The Church and the Franchise. By ANDREW SIMON LAMB, Scotch Advocate of the Inner Temple. Nisbet.
THE ideas of an eminently evangelical brother in the Church of England. We are glad to know his views; but if he could once see with our eyes for half a twinkling, he would no longer plead for an establishment. Our own belief is that the end does not justify the means; and we would no more perpetrate the injustice of establishing a favoured sect for the sake of truth than on behalf of error. In fact, it is because we love pure and undefiled religion that we would speedily disestablish and disendow every form of religion. Let not tenderness about Nonconformist endowments stay any man's hand: if they stand upon the same footing as tithes, let them go. But are they thus to be considered? The able articles by Mr. Hawkins which have from month to month enriched The Sword and the Trowel prove the contrary.
Outlines of Natural Philosophy for Schools and General Readers. By J. D. EVERETT, D.C.L. Blackie.
SUCH a manual as this makes us devoutly grateful for the educational advantages possessed by the young to-day, and half regretful that such were unknown by an earlier generation. Here is the latest research upon Light, Heat, Sound, Electricity, Mechanics, Hydrostatics, put in clear, fascinating form, and amply illustrated, for a few shillings. These outlines will sell quickly, and be read by all who delight in peering into nature's secrets.
501
Belaying-Pin Gospel; or, Cruelties Inflicted on Seamen upon the High Seas and in many Ports. By EDWARD W. MATTHEWS. S. W. Partridge and Co. Price 1s.
ACCORDING to its ample sub-title, this brochure is one "exhibiting terrible facts gathered from personal knowledge and unquestionable sources, which may demand the abrogation of laws that are incentives to vice or impotent to protect, with such legislation as may be necessary."
Certainly, seamen have no more warm-hearted advocate than our friend Mr. Matthews, the secretary of the British and Foreign Sailors' Society; and in bringing out this terrible account of the wrongs and abuses which are still rampant, he has shown courage and ability which deserve to be recognised. Many might be disposed to think that such crimes and cruelties as Mr. Matthews writes about could not characterize such times as ours; but now their eyes may be opened to see the actual perils and sufferings which beset a sailor's life. The public will read the details with amazement; but public sympathy will be awakened, and reform ought surely to follow. The author is fortunate in having at his side such a friend as Sir Thomas (now Lord) Brassey, so that we may hope to see great good come of this fearless exposure.
How to be Happy, though Married. Being a Handbook to Marriage. By A GRADUATE IN THE UNIVERSITY OF MATRIMONY. T. Fisher Unwin.
"THE Murray of Matrimony, and the Baedeker of Bliss." We do not wonder that this work is in its third edition. Punch has praised it, its title has salt in it, and there is real life in the book itself. We have met with most of this good advice before, but it is put in a novel and sparkling style, and therefore compels a reading. No literature is more attractive to certain minds than that which unveils domestic life, and makes mirth out of its occasional miseries. In this instance the scales are held very evenly: nothing is said in partisanship of marriage or celibacy: nothing which would drive a girl to the irrevocable deed, nothing which would restrain the judiciously resolved.
We feel sure that, as it was in the beginning, it is now, and ever shall be: men and women will marry, and be given in marriage. The Shakers will never be the dominant denomination, nor celibacy the universal custom. Nature teaches that this must be the rule of the road, so long as the race is to exist. Only let marriage be properly used, and it is a fountain of untold happiness: because it is so often entered upon with frivolity, and followed up with selfishness, its good is evil spoken of. The fault, dear Benedicts, is in ourselves, and not in matrimony.
"What, Jack, are you married? I am right glad of it." The speaker walked on a few yards, and then he stopped, and soliloquized—"I don't know why I should be glad either, the poor man never did me any harm." Then he walked on. This book manifests somewhat of this man's humour, and humour of a good-natured kind always commands an audience. We will hear a man if he will smile, and make us smile; and we are not wrong, for while sorrows are plentiful, merry words are by no means to be despised.
This book is rather dear at three half-crowns.
Morley: Ancient and Modern. By WILLIAM SMITH, F.S.A.S. With one hundred and thirty illustrations. Longmans, Green, and Co.
It is worth while to be an inhabitant of Morley to be thus immortalized. Mr. W. Smith has a genius for topographical writing: he has omitted nothing, and made the most of everything. He has done for Morley in one direction what Gilbert White did for Selborne in another. What with its engravings, histories, anecdotes, and records, this work must interest a Yorkshireman, especially if he also belongs to Morley. We remember preaching long ago in that growing town, but we did not know the classic ground on which we stood. Thanks, Mr. Smith, for your patient collection of facts, which your townsmen ought to value. We hope they will see that your noble volume is in all their houses. Topographical works have a singular value, and are never without purchasers: this is one of the best of them.
Salvation from Self. By the Rev. J. B. FIGGAS, M.A. Partridge and Co. Brighton: D. B. Friend.
THOROUGHLY lively as well as holy. The more of such preaching and writing as this the better for our times, and for all coming times. Practical godliness is here enforced by arguments fetched from sound doctrine. We have seldom met with a little book more completely to our mind.
Heavenly Relationships. By MARY E. BECK. Nisbet and Co.
GRACIOUS, but not very striking or suggestive. Sound, wholesome reading for godly persons.
My Bible Study for the Sundays of the Year. By FRANCES RIDLEY HAVERGAL. "Home Words" Publishing Office, 7, Paternoster Square.
A NEW and cheap edition of notes which appeared some time ago in fac-simile in a beautiful volume. It is a wise thing to issue these rich portions in a popular form: they are too choice to be reserved for the few.
The Lives of Robert and Mary Moffat. By their Son, JOHN S. MOFFAT. T. Fisher Unwin.
THIS is a new edition at 7s. 6d. of a work which should be in every missionary library. Our former notices render it unnecessary to say more.
The Earthly History of the Church of the Lord Jesus; as foretold by himself in Revelation ii. and iii. By JOSEPH DURDEN, Minister of the Gospel. C. Bateman, 26, Paternoster Square. Price Sixpence.
IF it be true that the letters to the seven churches set forth the history of the Church of Christ from his ascension to his second advent, this little treatise is invaluable. We do not endorse this theory, but we are, nevertheless, pleased with the careful exposition which our author has given. Reverent study of the Word is, in itself, most precious. Even when the student works under the influence of an idea which we cannot accept, we feel sure that his researches in the mines of Scripture cannot fail to unearth many a priceless gem. In this case we have here met with thoughts which we value, for which we feel grateful to the esteemed writer.
Wayside Songs of the Inner and Outer Life. By REV. HENRY BURTON, B.A. T. Woolmer.
MUCH music and more grace. Happy is the wayside which hears such songs!
The Pulpit Commentary. Ephesians Philippians, and Colossians. Kegan Paul, Trench, and Co.
ANOTHER instalment of what will be a library in itself. This huge volume is three large books in one; and it would have been more likely to sell, and more portable for use, if it had been issued as three separate commentaries. The able authors and compilers here present us with a mass of useful matter. It is not all of equal value; some of it we should not accept at all, but utterly reject; yet, as a whole, the bulky book is of fair quality. No preacher can consult such a work without finding material for thought and discourse. Well worth a guinea, but where is the guinea?
Ling-Nam; or, Interior Views of Southern China, including Explorations in the hitherto untraversed Island of Hainan. By B. C. HENRY, A.M. Partridge and Co.
QUITE a new book on what is really a new subject. China is so vast a theme that it would be a very slight exaggeration if we said that we knew next to nothing of it. Mr. Henry is a born traveller, and makes us long to go with him to the land of wonders which he describes. His journeys in the island of Hainan have introduced us to a country which is well-nigh as unknown as the heart of Africa. The drawings are mainly from Mr. Henry's own hand, and add interest to the narrative. What a country China must be! Will it not yet be won for Jesus? The land is full of temples of one-sort or another; will it not yet know the true God? This is a grand book for appearance, and cheap at 6s.
Inward Holiness; or, Remarks on the Guidance and Control of the Holy Spirit. By L. F. SELWYN. Nisbet.
WILL not do at any price. That holiness, which is based upon the assumption that we received the Holy Ghost in infant baptism, is founded upon a fiction, and is likely to fall, like the house of the foolish builder.
503
Bread of Life Picture Leaflets. By C. H. SPURGEON. Packets of 2 dozen at 4d. each. Passmore and Alabaster.
THE coloured title-pages of these leaflets are well executed, and must prove attractive. We hope our friends will scatter them by millions.
THE leaflets and tracts issued by Penman and Co., 33, Furnival Street, have about them a freshness of form which makes them quite a change from the usual run of tracts. The price is exceedingly low; but some of them are such little flimsy affairs that it can hardly pay to give them away.
The Earlham Temperance Series. Compiled by J. B. S. National Temperance Publication Depot, 337, Strand.
THE tracts are matchless. They are the pattern of what temperance tracts should be. In six really beautiful volumes at one shilling each they make up quite an elegant library. We know of no nicer present than these volumes in white cloth, gilt edges. We don't know how they can be produced at the price.
The Christian's own Calendar of Personal and Family Events. With an Introduction by the Rev. H. C. G. Moule, M.A. Seeley and Co.
A GOOD form of album: daily texts, with spaces for entries. We have almost wished that these things had never been invented, for we are continually called upon to write in them. By the way, do our friends know "The Spurgeon Birthday Book"? We prepared it with care, and we ought to have a continuous sale for it, as some solatium for the many times that our autograph has been required of us for albums compiled by others.
Proverb Will: His Sayings and Doings. With Pen and Ink Sketch of Primitive Methodist Camp Meeting. By GEORGE W. McCABE. Hurd, 4, Wine Office Court.
VERY good indeed. We doubt not that this homely talk will please many, and do them a power of good. Primitive Methodists will shout as they read.
Biographical and Literary Notices of William Carey, D.D. With Portrait and Illustrations. Northampton: The Dryden Press, 9, College Street. London: Alexander and Shepheard.
WE ought to have a Baptist Historical Society; and when this is the case, documents of this sort will be held in high esteem. Brought out in the best style, this is a valuable memorial of Dr. Carey. Possibly the general reader may not care for it, but the book-collector will prize it.
The Christian Traveller's Continental Handbook. Edited by the Rev. R. S. ASHTON, B.A. Elliot Stock.
EVERY tourist who desires to visit the churches of Christ while viewing the beauties of nature, should take this six-penny handbook in his hand. Many a pleasant hour may be spent to the mutual advantage of the Christian traveller and the native pastor now that they know where to find each other.
Wanderings Eastward. A diary of travels in Egypt, Palestine, Syria, Turkey, and Greece. By THEODORE WALKER, F.R.G.S. Partridge.
MR. WALKER has jotted down the story of his travels without attempting flourishes and word-painting. The result is a common-sense journal, giving a clear idea of what a plain man would see, think of, and remember if he had the privilege of journeying through Egypt and the Holy Land. Such books tempt men to travel. The get-up of this book is uncomely, but then the price is only 2s.
Hymn Writers and their Hymns. By REV. S. W. CHRISTOPHERS. Partridge.
THE public have acted wisely in buying this book, and demanding even a third edition. The subject is attractive, and the author has collected a mass of valuable information. Mr. Christophers' style is gushing—too gushing for our taste; but possibly, by this very excess, he manages to secure a reading where a less effervescent writer might fail. Always gracious and graceful, these pages deserve our warmest praise, not for their own sakes alone, but because they tend to endear our hymn-books to our heart, and even to explain them to our understanding.
Songs of Rest. Second Series. Edited by Rev. W. ROBERTSON NICOLL, M.A. Hodder and Stoughton.
WE are sure that Mr. Nicoll meant no harm, but if he had intended slyly to introduce Romanism into our families, he could not have gone more cunningly to work. What do our friends think of the dying going into Mary's bosom?
"Mary, mother of all mothers,
First in love as pain on earth,
Having known above all others
Mysteries of death and birth:
Take, from travail sore released,
One more mother to thy breast."
Are we to lay out our dead after the manner of little Christel—
"Three at the right, and three at the left,
Two at the feet, and two at the head,
The tapers burn"?
We point out these passages because there can be no need to introduce them into such excellent and attractive little books. It is an oversight. Mr. Nicoll is a man of such resources that he could have found better material than what we have quoted: the rest of the little book is so good as to prove this fact.
Prayers compiled by a Father for the use of his Children. With some Advice on Praying. Nisbet and Co.
WE cannot bring ourselves to believe in written prayers. The plan proposed is to give our young people forms, and encourage them to grow out of them. We prefer to show them what prayer is, and lead them to speak with God in their own words from the very first. Those who learn to walk by the use of stilts are apt to require them throughout life; better far to make many a stumble but learn to use your own legs.
Lights and Shadows of Human Life. By the Rev. JOHN PHILIP, M.A. Hodder and Stoughton.
THESE sermons are greatly to edification: congregations getting the like every Sabbath are made to lie down in green pastures. Mr. Philip has a flowing style, and intersperses his teaching with happy illustrations, and flashes of poesy, and hence his discourses are pleasant reading. We personally prefer something a little more vigorous and striking;
but peaceful Philip has his place as well as solid Peter.
Christ and the Bible. By STANLEY LEATHES. D.D. S. W. Partridge and Co. 1s. 6d.
WE highly appreciate this little book. A church-mission had been held in one of the suburbs of London. Who the missioner was it matters not. The more sensational his addresses the more satisfactory they would be to the promoters of that mission. To men and women of emotional constitution, ("men only," "women only,") the appeals would be made with thrilling effect. The pulpit stimulant fires their breasts, but takes no cognizance of their brains. They immediately join the crusade. So it often happens in these days. Salvation army, Church army, Blue Ribbon, Green Ribbon, White Cross, and many more, with their processions, decorations, life and drum, waving of handkerchiefs, solo shouting, and chorus singing, avail to provoke a feverish excitement, and to make many persons believe that they are on the Lord's side. All goes on swimmingly, and the vauntings are as loud as they are premature. Evil times come, and the fair scene dissolves, like a vision. A reaction was from the first to be feared; for the converts, who have been so eagerly counted, are children without knowledge, and consequently without steadfastness.
Our author comes to the front at an opportune hour. He, as a teacher, follows the earnest missioner in that suburban church with a calm and dispassionate review of "Christian evidences" in a short course of lectures. Lectures on that subject are often as dry as dust. We suppose that they are so because Dr. Dryasdust delivered them. But Dr. Stanley Leathes is a clergyman of another type. When we read his simple but scholarly discourses we feel as if we should like to have heard them. He has a way of so putting a fact that it becomes obvious at once. There is convincing, and, we hope, converting power in his arguments. Evangelists will do well to digest these sound, sensible, savoury expositions; and if our Colporteurs get into a district where revival services have been held, we recommend them to push this book.
505
Glimpses of Maori Land. BY ANNIE R. BUTLER. Religious Tract Society. ANOTHER of those attractive books of travel which have been lately issued by the Religious Tract Society. Our authoress writes pleasingly, and with the gracious tone of one alive unto God. We wish she had cared to see more, or having seen it, had made a record of what is now missing. As it is, the glimpses are rather more churchy than we should have expected from a lady who is so decidedly in harmony with all living work for God.
We are glad that friends at home should know all about the Maories, so that they may defend their rights the next time they are threatened, and may at this present assist in missionary efforts among them. This noble race must not die out, but must be saved from the ills of a Christless civilization, and lifted into the liberty of grace. We are sure our readers will be interested with this volume.
Christ and the Jewish Law. By ROBERT MACKINTOSH, B.D. Hodder and Stoughton.
Our literary friends, who follow the methods of scientific criticism, will be familiar with the modern practice of dividing the study of Scripture into sections. The old-fashioned way was to detail out the Bible into a summary of doctrines. As for this volume, its title tells accurately "the class" to which it belongs. The Mosaic Law, as it was revealed—in part ethical, in part ceremonial, in part statutory—reflected in the life and teaching of our Lord: that is the subject. Incidentally, however, it necessarily touches on the interpretations of that law, current at the close of the Jewish dispensation. In pursuing this study, Mr. Mackintosh owns his obligation to a German school of authors, without adopting the subtle conjectures which he freely examines. This is all very good in its way. But for popular and practical purposes, would it not have been better to allow time enough to elapse between reading their works and writing his own, for him to forget the obligation, and produce something ex animo, free from such technicalities as only advanced scholars can appreciate? As it is, our author does little honour to Dr. Ritschl, or Dr.
Weisse; and still less justice to himself; while to us, who scan his pages, he appears rather to take the part of a reviewer than a commentator. And yet he furnishes materials enough for a treatise of interest to all the churches.
The Homiletic Magazine. Vol. xiv. Nisbet and Co.
This volume is not inferior to its predecessors. It is not exactly to our mind, but we fear it will be long before we see anything better. On the whole, it may be regarded as second to none of our homiletical magazines, and it is as sound as the almost universal declension of the period will allow.
Why I would Disestablish. A representative book, by representative men. Edited by ANDREW REID. Longmans, Green, and Co.
THESE opinions of various personages who are opposed to a State-church are interesting reading, showing as they do the various stand-points from which the matter is viewed by different minds. We do not think that these extracts in any measure support the charge that Liberationists agitate for Disestablishment out of enmity to the Church of England. In our own case, we have never concealed our disapprobation of many things connected with the Anglican body, its Prayer-book, &c.; but, at the same time, we should rejoice to see a vigorous evangelical church of the Episcopal order, free from state fetters, and separated from the mixed multitude of semi-papists who now have so much sway in her midst. We differ most conscientiously, or we would conform: our Nonconformity is deep and thorough, but of ill-will we are not conscious. Neither, if we had an ill-will, should we adopt Liberationist views in order to effect a malevolent purpose. It might be a loss of gold, but it would be a sure gain of grace, for the Church of England to become a voluntary community after the manner of the apostolic churches. Meanwhile, "until the day break, and the shadows flee away," we must each one be faithful to his conscience, and to his Lord. There will come a time when everything that offends shall cease from the kingdom of Christ, and then there shall be no more fountains of strife among brethren.
Gospel Difficulties: or the displaced section of Luke. By J. J. BALCOMBE. M.A. London: C. J. Clay and Son, Cambridge University Press, 1886.
THE four evangelists furnish us with a theme of never-failing interest. We are wont to approach the study of their narratives from many different points. Sometimes we take them up one by one as several witnesses, each writing with a distinct purpose; for this avenue you may take Jukes as your guide. At other times we have culled the various parables and miracles they record, and have endeavoured to learn the moral and spiritual lesson of each one; then we often resort to Trench as a companion. Far more frequently we have pondered the sayings and the sufferings of our adorable Lord; and here we cannot name our numerous comrades, but we may mention Isaac Ambrose of early, and Stier of more recent writers.
As a simple matter of historical record, wherein each sacred author is presumed to verify his fellows, we, standing amidst a sceptical generation, set the highest value upon their concurrent testimony. Since the keen eye of modern criticism has searched out so many doubts and difficulties, it is not without a thrill of pleasure that we listen to a competent witness who can thread his way through the maze. Be it observed that there is nothing particularly new in the endeavour to form a diatessaron, or harmony of the narratives furnished by Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, arranged for consecutive reading, as a complete biography, gathered from four sources. But it is equally obvious that there are complications which the student finds it anything but easy to unravel. Some cavillers take a pleasure in pointing out seeming discrepancies. Others invent explanations of such doubtful accuracy that they make confusion more confounded than before they intermeddled. We are in better society among counsellors who, without any taste for controversy, are clear-sighted enough to detect riddles, or interpret ciphers. This kind of shrewdness has helped us many a time in Biblical literature. Well it might; since the original manuscripts are not to be found.
Here we have a reverent and learned attempt to adjust the several statements
of the four evangelists on unequivocal lines. The goal to be reached according to our guide is this—"that in accordance with the implied statement of the parable of the barren fig-tree, our Lord's ministry lasted for a period of four years, every portion of which is duly accounted for, and that in a manner which the exact order observed renders it impossible to misunderstand." The suggestion is that the passage, Luke xi. 14 to xiii. 21 has been displaced with a motive based entirely on a misconception; and if relegated to an earlier portion of the record, viz., to follow chapter viii. 21, it would bring the four narratives into perfect accord. Let it be understood (1) that our author holds an orthodox view of plenary inspiration—(2) that he takes full cognizance of the labours of previous scholars who have traversed the same field of enquiry—(3) that he accounts the real order of events to be not a matter of opinion, but capable of absolute demonstration—(4) that he therefore attributes any obvious difficulty to a corruption of the text, rather than to a failure in the unity of design and execution—(5) that while the third Gospel (that of Luke) lays the most specific claim to order, and was written to confirm, not to contradict, the testimony of Matthew and Mark (chapter i. 4) we must look the more curiously into his gospel for any displacement of events which seems to mar the evident sequence—(6) that only one method of re-adjustment can be absolutely just and true; it must be other than a paltry hypothesis, such a positive demonstration as commends itself to the clear judgment of every thoughtful unbiased student—finally, that our author (7) claims to have possessed great advantages from getting behind the Revision Committee of 1881.
These premises commend themselves to our approval, though they do not suffice to carry full conviction. In fact, we do not intend to sum up, or direct a verdict. Suffice it that we draw attention to a study so full of subtilty that any man must make it his own before he offers an opinion. The volume is very full, but confessedly incomplete, the herald of at least two other volumes to follow.
