Compulsory Tithes: Enforced by Crushing Pains and Penalties — [Fourth Article.] — By Pastor W. M. Hawkins, Hundon, Clare, Suffolk
![Compulsory Tithes: Enforced by Crushing Pains and Penalties — [Fourth Article.] — By Pastor W. M. Hawkins, Hundon, Clare, Suffolk](/images/books/sword-and-trowel/1886/p0366-366.jpg)
THE following ancient document proves still further the unpopularity of compulsory tithes, and gives a peep at the harsh treatment of the poor by the rich. Its date is about a hundred years after Ethelwulph's tithe charter:—
"KING EDGAR'S PROCLAMATION."
"Here is manifested in this writ, how King Edgar considered what might be for a remedy in the pestilence that greatly harassed and diminished his people widely through his kingdom.
"This is then, first, what he and his Witan thought, that this unfortunate state of things was earned by sins, and disobedience to God's commandments; and chiefly by the subtraction of the bounden tribute which Christian men should yield to God in their tithe-payments. He bethought and considered the divine course by that of the world. If any agricultural tenant neglect his lord's tribute, and rendered it not to him at the right appointed time, one may think, if the lord be merciful, that he will forgive the neglect and take his tribute without punishing him. If he then frequently, through his messengers, admonish him of his tribute, and he then hardeneth himself, and thinketh to hold it out, one may think that the lord's anger will wax to such a pitch that he will allow him neither property nor life. So one may think our Lord will do, through the boldness with which common men resist the frequent admonition which our teachers have given about our LORD'S BOUNDEN TRIBUTE, which are OUR TYTHES, and church-shots. Then bid I and the archbishop, that ye provoke not God, or earn a sudden death in this present life, nor, what is worse, a future one in everlasting hell, by any subtraction of God's rights; but let every one, whether poor or rich, who has any cultivated land, render to God his tythes, with all pleasure and liberality, as the act teaches, which my Witan enacted at Andover, and now again at Whitbordestane, with a pledge confirmed. Moreover, I bid my reeves by my friendship, and by all that they possess, that they punish every one of those who pay not this, and break the pledge of my Witan with any prevarication, even as the aforesaid enactment teaches; and in the punishment let there be NO FORGIVENESS. Whether a man may be so poor as to be tempted into encroachments upon which is God's, to the ruin of his soul, or so hasty-tempered as to think little of that which he does not consider as his own, that surely must be more his own which lasts for ever, if it be done with a truly cheerful mind.
"Then will I that God's rights stand everywhere alike in my dominions;
and that God's servants who receive the payments that we make to God, should live clean lives, that they should through their purity intercede for us to God. And I and my thanes enjoin our priests what is taught us by the pastors of our souls, that is, our bishops, whom we should never fail of hearing in any of the things that they teach us for God, that we, through the obedience that we yield to them for God, may earn the everlasting life which they persuade us to by teaching, and by the example of good works."—Soames' "Anglo-Saxon Church," Appendix, p. 259, A.D. 1856, fourth edition. Soames quotes from "Brit. Mus. MSS.," Cotton, Nero, E. 1, f. 389. Mr. Thorpe has printed and translated this piece under the title of "Supplement to Edgar's Laws," in the "Anc. LL. and Instt. of Engl." i. 271.
No one can say that King Edgar, "the vicar of God on earth," did not do his uttermost to induce and compel the people to pay the tithes. Every archbishop, bishop, and, in fact, every clergyman, did all that was possible—both good and bad—to get the people to pay them. Bishop Swithin, or Swithin, was canonized as a saint, because of the successful part he played with Ethelwulph, in wheedling, and badgering, and threatening him; and plotting, and planning, and preaching, until by "hook and by crook." Ethelwulph, the "apt pupil" and "tool," was induced to pass the law by which the clergy claimed legal right to tithes in all England.
Coercive laws were continued "hammer and tongs," "tooth and nail," throughout all the reigns; and it is by coercion alone that the tithe rent-charge is paid to day.
Ethelred, in A.D. 1008, and 1012, contributed laws in addition to the foregoing, to compel the unwilling nation to pay the tithe-tax that the aristocracy had imposed upon the people. Canute, in a Parliament held in Westminster, A.D. 1032, revived and re-enacted, with additional penalties, the laws of Edgar and Ethelred for tithes, plough-alms, and church-scot.
Throughout all the changing fortunes of our nation, the law to compel tithe-payments was over fresh, vigorous, and operative. It mattered not whether the Anglo-Saxons, the Danes, the Normans, the Plantagenets, the Tudors, the Stuarts, or the Hanoverians mounted the throne, the law sternly commanded the tithe to be paid.
Why was this? The answer is at hand. It is clear and complete. Tithes had friends in court. Not only friends, but interested friends—yea, deeply interested friends. Princes were often bishops and abbots, princesses were abbasses, &c., &c. These great and lucrative offices were not created for the poor or worthy. No one is now so ignorant as to think they were. They were created for the rich, and for rewards rendered for services to kings, &c. Also abbots created knights. "Brand, Abbot of Peterborough, knighted his nephew, Hereward, in the reign of William I. Lanfric, Archbishop of Canterbury, knighted William Rufus." Rapin also says (Book vi., p. 217): "We find in 'Anglia-Sacra,' and the 'History of the Church of Winchester,' by Rudburn, that in 1144 Pope Lucius sent the pall to the Bishop of Winchester, KING STEPHEN'S BROTHER, with the intent to erect that see into an Archbishopric." Is not this delightful reciprocity! "The upper ten making things comfortable all round for themselves," as Mr. Bright expressed it. "A kind of concurrent endowment," as the late Earl Beaconsfield suggested. What would have been done with the beautiful Stephen's brother if there had not been "the church" to fly to? It is comforting to the wealthy to-day, as in the days of old, to know that the church, as now constituted and supported, is able to find shelter for any of their sons who are unable to hold their own in this competitive world. Bishop Sanderson complains that "those who have advocations of church livings must needs have some of their children thrust into the ministry." "Here we have a fulfilment of the prophecies when the best families got put into the best offices." Quaint old Quarles wrote truth when he penned,
"The church sustains the extremes of cold and hunger
To pamper up the fat advowson-monger."
367
We have within the last few months seen most of our tithe-paid clergy turning every stone, marshalling every skeleton of an exploded argument, in order to tax the people's food. Were they earnest and sincere in their endeavours? Most assuredly they were. The dearer the bread is that their flocks eat, the higher their tithe rent-charge rises. When corn runs up to starvation price they greatly increase their stipends; the tithe rent-charge being regulated by the price of corn. Dear corn, hungry sheep, and well-fed shepherds! Self-interest rules their policy. Are people's doings known by their fruits? What fruit should we have seen growing in our beloved country during the past hard winter, if those "legal shepherds" had had the feeding of the people with dear bread? They did their uttermost to put a tax on it. Why? Shall I be charged with want of charity if I give the only true answer? Be that as it may, I know no reason why they should want to tax food, except for fat tithes. And, in like manner, there is no reason why the various grades of the clergy were created, except to make fat livings for friends and favourites of civil rulers. That they are not chosen to rich livings for their spiritual experience, or theological attainments, or arduous labours, is illustrated by the last great appointment. In a recent issue of The Rock, a Church of England organ, we find the following:—"Our readers will, doubtless, remember that we recently called attention to the vagaries of the Bishop of Lincoln, and expressed regret that the Bishop of Ely was following suit. We understand that at the last ordination he wore his new mitre, blazing with jewels, as he walked from his palace to the Cathedral. What, however, distresses us most is that he should have told his candidates that he could not address them on any spiritual subject, because he did not feel competent, nor on any theological topic, as he had never had time to study theology, and he would, therefore, speak to them about three of the rubrics. (The Bishop's only charge for many years was a small parish of about one hundred souls.) This, then, is the raison d'être of the mitre, we suppose. The Bishop is to supplement his spiritual and theological deficiencies by the variety and completeness of his wardrobe. We wonder how his lordship reconciles it to his conscience to draw a large salary for the discharge of duties he is incompetent to perform. The head of the police in London recently resigned because the public considered him inefficient. We would recommend the propriety of a similar step to any bishop who feels himself unqualified for the efficient discharge of his duties."
The Rock may criticize, suppose, and suggest anything it likes; but it is of no use, since knowledge of theology, spirituality of mind, pastoral capacity, and Christian experience are no grounds of promotion, even to-day in the tithe-supported church. They are in other churches. The bishop was a lord before Prime Minister Salisbury "frocked" him. He was chosen on other than religious grounds. Thus it is clear that the money said to belong to the church is paid away for other reasons than for the promotion of spiritual religion. What is this but spoliation? Is not this using religion as a drudge to promote party interests?
Being a resident in the diocese of Ely, I am not a little interested to learn how Lord Compton occupied his time before he became a "Right Reverend Father in God." He "never had any time to study theology." "He is not competent to address" the young clergy on "spiritual subjects," and yet he is the man "whom the Holy Ghost commanded the Dean and Chapter to elect." Sad, sad, and dreadful blasphemy!
Can the greatest opponent of the State-church system affirm that in all the thousands of the clergy there is not a true, well-equipped man of God who is competent to address soul-inspiring spiritual counsels to young clergymen on the most solemn day of their lives? If this is a fact it is unique. I will venture to affirm that there is no other sect which could not with an hour's notice furnish all that is needed for any ordination service. No, no. Lord Compton was not chosen because there are no spiritually-minded men learned in theology in "the church." Other and more pressing considerations sent down
the scale, and therefore theology and spirituality had to kick the beam. So it ever must be in a State-church—there is no remedy for it.
Must all the country for ever be taxed to support this sect?—a kind of huge family compact! Yes, the most gigantic family and political society in the world. The only sense in which it is national is that everybody, either directly or indirectly, has to support it—must support it. There is no choice, and will be none, until the law is altered. I hope I have clearly proved why governments have so long been in favour of tithes.
Possibly it is imagined by some people that when the Danes, or Normans, &c., conquered England, they rejected and repealed their predecessors' ecclesiastical laws. Historians assure us that this was not done, but that the existing ecclesiastical laws were confirmed and adopted by all the various governments.
The links of this chain are more complete than those of the boasted Apostolic succession. Apostolic succession is a fiction in the sense in which it is generally used; but tithe succession is a stern reality, which has put gall and bitterness into many a widow's bleeding heart as she has seen her fatherless children's food taken out of their mouths to pay the tithe-tax.
When William, Duke of Normandy, came to England, Aldred, Archbishop of York, placed the Duke on the throne, and administered to him the oath usually taken by the Saxon kings. The substance of the oath was, "That he would protect the Church and its ministers; that he would govern the Nation with equity; that he would enact just laws and cause them to be strictly observed; and that he would forbid all rapines and unjust judgments. Malmsbury adds, he promised to behave himself mercifully to his subjects, and govern the English and Normans by the same laws." Rapin, Book vi. p. 167.
The king called a parliament to ascertain the laws by which the kingdom had been governed in the reign of Edward the Confessor. The laws then brought under review were adopted as the foundation of what is called the "common law" of England. F. Plowden, Barrister-at-Law, in "The Principles and Law of Tithing and Tithe Cases," p. 136, says, "As the common law of England can have been in no instance altered, abrogated, or affected, since the time of memory (A.D. 1189), but by statute law, all decisions of the judges, however apparently contrariant, are but declarations of what the common law is, or how it has been altered or affected by the statute law: and the construction of statutes rests with the judges of the different temporal courts of record. It would be redundant to attempt to enforce by reasoning individual submission to the acts of the legislature, in whom, under God, the supremacy of that civil power, to which Englishmen owe submission is vested. Separate negatives are not to be raised against the will of the majority, which is that of the whole. It will be proper here to observe that the old canon law, to which frequent reference is made, is a part of the common law of England, and binds the whole nation: but the latter canons of 1604 bind only the clergy, and not the laity. Every part, therefore, of the old canon law, which bears upon any object within the competency of the civil magistrate (such is by far the greatest part of that huge mass) became incorporated with our municipal or common law, by adoption of the nation; and according to Sir M. Hale (one of the most constitutional law writers), their authority is founded merely on their being admitted and received by us, which alone gives them their authoritative essence and qualifies their obligation; we are not bounden by their decrees further or otherwise, than as the kingdom has, as it were, transposed the same into the common and municipal laws of the realm, by admission, acquiescence, or express declaration, which alone can make them of any force in England. I need not give particular instances; the truth thereof is plain and evident, and we need go no further than the statutes of the 24 Henry VIII. c. 12, 25 Henry VIII. c. 10, 20, 21; and the learned notes of Selden upon Flota, and the records there cited." . . . p. 140. "Nothing can so conclusively demonstrate that tithes are objects of civil power, and were always so considered in this country, as the uniform application to parliament by our ancestors to explain, alter, modify, abrogate, or repeal the payment
369
of them on every occasion of doubt, difficulty, or inconveniency, arising out of the system."
The above testimonies from distinguished lawyers carry immense weight. 1. They show that all the canons passed between A.D. 1189 and 1603 were binding on all the nation. 2. Also that if even for the sake of argument we were to admit that the great charter of Ethelwulph is of such early date that doubt is cast upon it, we have sufficient in these canons to establish everything that the charter gives. We are entirely independent of the charter. We do not, however, admit that the charter is in any sense doubtful; but if we did, it would not matter. 3. Also that tithes are not church property, but property belonging to the State. 4. That they were always so considered in this country. 5. That the ancient parliaments "explained, altered, modified, abrogated, or repealed the payment of them, on every occasion of doubt, difficulty, or inconveniency, arising out of them." 6. That very ancient ecclesiastical laws were handed down to succeeding generations and received as binding. But Rapin and other historians place the charter and the ancient laws above cavil when they inform us that the laws that governed England in the time of Edward the Confessor were adopted by a parliament in the time of William I., "as the foundation of what is called the common law of England."
Rapin, p. 137, says, "Before the reign of Edward the Confessor (A.D. 1011), the West-Saxon, Mercian, and Danish laws were observed in England, namely, the first in Wessex, and the second in Mercia, and the last in Northumberland. This prince reduced them all into one body; and from that time they became common to all England, under the name of the laws of Edward, to distinguish them from those of the Normans, introduced afterwards." Here we have connecting links that unite the ancient laws and canons into one compact body down to the year 1603.
This brings us down past the Reformation.
