Compulsory Tithes: Enforced by Crushing Pains and Penalties — [Third Article.] — By Pastor W. M. Hawkins, Hundon, Clare, Suffolk
![Compulsory Tithes: Enforced by Crushing Pains and Penalties — [Third Article.] — By Pastor W. M. Hawkins, Hundon, Clare, Suffolk](/images/books/sword-and-trowel/1886/p0290-290.jpg)
WE are continually told that the nation mutually and willingly agreed to give one-tenth of the land's produce to the church. That this particular tenth never, after that mutual gift, belonged to any one but the church, and to withhold it is to rob God. That it never did belong to the present owner of the land, and that it is beyond the power of the nation justly to interfere with it in any way.
We can prove, on the other hand, that the nation did not either willingly or mutually give a tenth; but that the tenth was FORCED from an UNWILLING people, who reluctantly paid it when they were compelled by the stern and irresistible power of civil authority. Nothing can be more misleading than the idea that tithe-payments and Nonconformist endowments stand on the same basis. In fact, tithes and Church of England endowments are separate and distinct from each other. When we say that tithes are a "legal tax," we are not including lands, or churches, or annual payments from property, that were given by individuals or companies to the church, or to separate churches. I trust this important distinction will never for a moment be lost sight of in these papers, either by the writer or by the readers. As the learned John Selden truly says:—"And the truth is, that divers of them that writ, with more will than judgment, for tithes, fall often from their Jus Divinum, before they are aware, and talk of them as supposed due also by human positive law of (or) practice. But they are far enough from showing what or where that law or practice is. What do they else when they confound tithes and consecrated lands together? And apply that to tithes which is equally to be spoken of lands given to the church? I trust they mean not that the church had an original title also, Jure Divino, to lands arbitrarily consecrated to it."—Selden's "History of Tythes," A.D. 1618, p. xv. Preface.
If we do not make a clear distinction between tithes and endowments we shall be in a dense fog. There is no fear of losing endowments by the same laws that could appropriate tithes. Some people think there is danger. I know this bogey is often raised to terrify people who have an interest in endowments. It need not frighten any one. Tithes and endowments rest on totally different foundations. Tithes are national property, because they were exacted by laws; endowments were not. But more of this in a future article.
People were not obliged to give property, or tithes, until the law was made by the king. After the year 855 they were obliged to pay the tithe; and this is true to-day. They had no will in the matter, and we have none. We must either pay the tithe rent-charge, or redeem it.
In speaking of Ethelwulph's charter, Dr. T. Fuller says:—"Indeed, before his time many acts for tithes are produced which, when pressed, will prove of no great validity. Such are the imperial edicts in civil law, never of full power in England; as also the canons of some councils and popes, never admitted into plenary obedience by consent of princes and people. Add to these, first, such laws as were made by King Ina and Offa, monarchs indeed of England in their turns, as I may say, but not deriving the same to the issue of their bodies: so that their acts, as personal, may by some forward spirits be cavilled at, as determining with their lives. Join to these (if producible) any provincial constitutions of an English archbishop, perchance, Egbertus of York: those might obey them who would obey, being otherwise not subject to any civil penalty. But now this act of Athelwolphus appears entire in all the proportions of a law, made in his great council, equivalent to after-parliaments; not only cum consilio episcoporum, 'with the advice of his bishops' (which easily may be presumed
willingly to concur in such a matter of church-advancement), but also principium meum, 'of my princes,' saith he; the CONSENT OF INFERIOR PERSONS NOT BEING REQUIRED IN THAT AGE."—Book II. Cent. IX.
This renowned church historian clearly points out—1. That civil rights and penalties were first attached to tithes by this law of Ethelwulph. 2. That the law was made by the "upper ten," most if not all of whom had an interest in the working of the law. 3. That the consent of the bulk of the people was neither given, nor asked for. The people did not have any hand in making the law. The only thing they had to do with the law was to obey it. An archbishop recently expressed their relationship to the law, in speaking of that of the bulk of the people in our day, when he said, "All that the poor have to do with the law is to KEEP IT." And yet people tell us, in the language of Sir John Conroy, Bart., in a lecture on "Church Endowments," p. 12—"The duty of paying tithes was one that was insisted on by the clergy, and appears to have been gradually acquiesced in by the laity. In process of time the law recognized and enforced these payments, but not till the time of Edward the First, or nearly six hundred years after they commenced." The law recognized and enforced these payments in the time of Ethelwulph. I must not omit one thing more. Fuller attaches to the great charter, that psalms and masses were to be said every Wednesday for the soul of Ethelwulph and the other just men who had consented to this grant.
The Rev. J. Johnson, M.A., informs us—"Councils of all sorts were rare in this age (but especially synods for regulating and restoring the discipline of the church), by reason of the frequent invasions of the Danes. They first infested our shores in the year 787 A.D., but grew more terrible still for almost a hundred years together. . . . They were for many years so violent that they did in effect extinguish not only law, but religion, and reduced this nation to a great degree of ignorance."—Johnson, p. 310.
"The following laws could scarce be made before King Alfred's first league with the Danes, A.D. 876, because till that time he was wholly engaged in wars for the defence of his kingdom, and was sometimes reduced to great straits, and they must have been made before his other laws upon Guthrun's baptism, A.D. 878. See Saxon Chronicle." Laws and canons of the Church of England, p. 330. Laws quoted relate to morality. Johnson, on p. 330, says further—"He (Alfred) was a king of a martial spirit, and is said to have fought fifty-six battles by land and sea; and within seven years after his advancement to the throne, he so far reduced the Danes as to bring them to terms of agreement. Their King, Guthrun, professed Christianity, and is baptized, Alfred standing godfather at the solemnity: he relinquishes all further pretensions on King Alfred and his people, on condition that he might have the kingdom of Northumberland, and of the East Angles; and these are the religious laws by which they agreed to administer their government; for I conceive that, as to civil matters, both kings were left to their own native laws. The truth is, King Alfred seems to have studied nothing but religion and war."
No. 6 of the said laws, A.D. 878, is:—"If one withhold his tithes or his Rome-fee, or do not pay his lightscot, or his plough-alms, or deny any ecclesiastical rights, let him pay a mulct among the English, or a fine among the Danes. If he fight against [those who demand it], and wound a man, let him forfeit his life; if he kill a man, let him be outlawed; and let all that love right pursue him with hue and cry; and if he cause men to kill him, by opposing the right of God and the king, and if this be averred, let him be without any satisfaction."—Johnson, vol. i., p. 332.
"Forfeit his life"—forfeit the legal security of his life. "Let him be without satisfaction," means simply that his case is beyond satisfaction to his relations. Alfred went for the second time to Rome, when he was seven years old, to see the Pope. The Pope confirmed him, and declared that he would be king—he even went so far as to anoint him, and to assure him of his interest and of the interest of the Papacy in him.
285
Mr. Pulman observes: "Alfred was not content with establishing a religion—he provided for its maintenance by causing it to be taught to the young as well as the old . . . being thoroughly satisfied that to ensure the permanency of a NATIONAL RELIGION it was necessary that its teachers who administered its sacraments should be provided for by a PERMANENT FUND, he took care to re-enact the ANCIENT LAW of the land, that the tithes arising from land should be set apart for their support" (p. 65). By the ancient law I understand the laws of Inn, Offa, Ethelwulph, &c.
"A.D. 925.—King Ethelstan's Laws Ecclesiastical. I, Ethelstan, King, by the advice of Wulfhelm, my archbishop, and other of my bishops, command all my reeves (sheriffs) in the name of the Lord, and of all his saints, that they do in the first place give tithes of all my estate, both of the living stock and of the fruits of the earth, and that all the bishops do the same of all that belongs to them, as also my aldermen (some copies have earls) and reeves (sheriffs). And my will is that my bishops and sheriffs give this in charge to all that are subject to them, and that they do it effectually by the time that we have fixed—that is the beheading of St. John, Baptist. Let us consider what Jacob said unto the Lord: 'I will give thee my tithes and my peace offerings.' [This is an interpolation of Gen. xxviii. 22.] And what the Lord saith, 'To all them that have shall be given, and they shall abound,' and we may remember what to our terror is written in this book, 'If we are unwilling to pay our tithe the nine parts shall be taken from us.' It is not my will that ye get anything for me by indirect means." The last part of this paragraph is abridged from Lambard's text, which in this place is thus translated by Mr. Thorpe:—"We may, moreover, think on this which fearfully in these books is written; 'IF WE WILL NOT GIVE OUR TENTHS, THE NINE PARTS SHALL BE TAKEN AWAY FROM US, AND THE TENTH ALONE SHALL BE LEFT US.' The divine doctrine exhorts us that we should earn the heavenly things with the earthly, and the everlasting with the transitory. Now ye hear what the Lord commandeth us, and what it behoveth us to fulfil. Do so that ye acquire those things that ye for me may rightly get. I will not that ye get for me anything with wrong. If I grant to you all your things on the condition that ye for me acquire mine, be ye warned, and those who unto you belong, of God's ire and mine."—Johnson's "Laws and Canons of the Church of England," vol. i., p. 340.
The archbishop and bishops fraudulently used a saying of St. Ambrose, as if they were quoting God's word. They put Ambrose's saying, "If we are unwilling to pay our tithe, the nine parts shall be taken," and pretended that it was a quotation from Holy Scripture. It was easily done, without risk of detection or suspicion, at that time.
"The Anglo-Saxons, it has commonly been supposed, were provided with a complete vernacular translation of the Holy Scripture. No such volume has, however, been discovered. Hence the existence of such at that time is very questionable. The Bible, in fact, was evidently considered as a Latin book in ante-Norman England. Texts were generally cited in that language, and then rendered into the native idiom, according to the Roman usage of later times. Doubts even entered reflecting minds as to the expediency of opening Scripture unreservedly to vulgar eyes."—Soames' "Anglo-Saxon Church," p. 250.
In Efrie's Canons, A.D. 957, Canon 21, we read: "And the priest shall have the furniture for his ghostly work before he be ordained, that is the holy books, the psalter, and the pistol-book, gospel-book, and mass-book, the song-book, and the hand-book, the calendar, the pasconal, the penitential, and the lesson-book. It is necessary that the mass-priest have these books; and he cannot be without them if he will rightly exercise his function and duly inform the people that belongeth to him. Addonda: And let him take care that they be well written." The Rev. J. Johnson explains: "These books did not contain the entire epistles, or entire four gospels, but such portions of them as were assigned to be read at the altar at mass. The psalter, or lectionary, or lesson-book, or
19
legend. Antiphony, containing the prayers, canticles, and psalms for every day in the year, which, with the loctonary, makes the present broviary. The missal—the baptismal service, and I am apt to think it contained the whole ritual, that is, all the services for administering the sacraments (except the eucharist) and sacraments, the martyrology for the circle of the whole year, and the computus with a cycle, which I take to have been meant by the kalendar, as I turn it after our Somner, that is, the tables of new moons, and for finding moveable feasts, and for finding Easter for ever."—J. Johnson's "Canons," vol. i., p. 396. Johnson quotes Bode, Sir Henry Spelman, Thorpe, &c. I quote this canon to prove that the priests possessed only a very small quantity of Scripture themselves, and that, it must be remembered, could be only in manuscript. As they possessed so little, it is evident the public had less. Any imposition by crafty designers was perfectly easy on an ignorant and superstitious people. They could not discover a "pious fraud" if they tried. If even they suspected it they could not be certain. The lying quotation succeeded fully, and bore fruit, as we shall see presently, in Edgar's reign.
"A.D. 914. King Edmund's Ecclesiastical law. No. 2.—We enjoin all Christian men to the paying of tithes, by virtue of their Christian profession, as also their Church-scot and alms fee.* . . . Let them who will not do it be excommunicated."
A.D. 950, or thereabouts. Johnson, Wilkins, and Spelman range between A.D. 949 to 997. The Laws of the Northumbrian Priests. "Law 51. . . . If any withhold his tithes, and he be a king's thane, let him pay nine marks and a half—£6 6s. 8d. If a landed man, five marks and a half—£3 13s. 4d.; if a common man, twelve ore (12 ounces) of silver—£1.
"King Edgar A.D. 958, approximate. And let all the tithes of the young animals be paid by Pentecost, and of the fruits of the earth by the equinox; and let every Church-scot be paid by Martin's Mass (Nov. 11th), under pain of the full mulct which the doom-book mentions; and if any will not pay the tithe as we have commanded, let the king's reeve (sheriff), and the bishop's reeve, and the mass priest of the minster go to him, and take by force the 10th part for the minister to which it belongs, and deliver to him the 9th part; and let the 8 parts be divided into two, and let the lord take one half, the bishop the other, whether it be a king's man or a thane's man."—Johnson, vol. i., 409.
What a picture! What a strange way of "taking up the collection"!
Could any action be more crushing and more certain to alienate people from religion, and make them utterly neglect it? Especially when they were taught that their religious duty chiefly consisted in paying tithes, and the priest's duty in consuming them—frequently in shameless dissipation and riotous living!
It mattered not what depredations the Danes constantly committed upon these helpless people, nor how they continually robbed them of the fruits of their labour, still the tithe must be paid, or the king's reeve and the bishop's reeve, with the parson of the mother Church, would come together and seize all that the man had except 1-10th, and divide it between them.
To me this seems so incredible that I would not have believed it if it did not rest on the highest authority.
Not only does high authority support this law, but to my amazement a Bampton lecturer attempts to justify it.—Soames, p. 105.
This law is enough to take one's breath away. Could anything more clearly establish the cunning craftiness and grasping greediness of the clergy, the dire ignorance and complete helplessness of the people? It is certain that they did offer stern and prolonged resistance to tithe-payments, or there would not have been any necessity to make such severe laws to compel people to pay
* Alms fee, or Plough alms—an offering made to the Church in proportion to the number of plough-lands which every man had.
287
them. We see here the complete surrender of the king and his counsellors to the crafty exactions of the church, as the priests were pleased to call it.
But there are considerations that throw light on their action. 1. The king and his chief men had their pickings out of it. They had patronage, and some of them had "livings." It is difficult to estimate the value of patronage to the rulers of that, or, in fact, of any other age. The people had lost all voice in the election of their ministers. It was not likely that any priest would get patronized by a ruler if he did not hold the candle to that ruler. The influence of the priesthood was immense. It was not possible to govern the country with any success or comfort without church-influence; neither, indeed, could a king long sit on his throne without it. Charles I., in later days, often used to say to Independents and others who argued against Episcopacy, "To do away with the bishops is to do away with the crown." He upheld the bishops, so that they in turn might uphold him. Neither, on the other hand, was it possible for priests or bishops to gain their greedy ends unless they had the goodwill and help of the crown. The two powers (civil and ecclesiastical) united to oppress and fleece the people they governed. That was indeed a mutual compact. The lord of the manor got 4-10ths, and the bishop got 4-10ths of the person's property, when some John Hampden or William Penn disputed the justice of the parson's claim. The argument was cut short by the speedy meeting of the parson and sheriffs, and the prompt division of the victim's property. Could any action be more cruel, more barbarous? I challenge any one to produce its equal. This done by Christ's representatives? Never! They were impostors in religion, and conjurers with religious things.
Writing of this King Edgar, Dr. Thos. Fuller, in his "Church History," Book II., Century X., says:—"I have read in a most fair and authentic gilded manuscript extant in the precious library of Sir Thos. Cotton, wherein he (Edgar) styleth himself 'God's vicar in England for the ordering ecclesiastical matters.' . . . The devotion of King Edgar may be condemned to be biassed to superstition." Soames states "that he styled himself 'the Vicar of Christ.'"
Dr. T. Fuller was no Dissenter, neither did he believe in voluntarism. He was a dignitary of the Church of England, "Prebendary of Sarum, &c., &c.," and, as I shall have occasion in these pages to show, an earnest advocate for tithe payments. This Dr. Fuller tells us that "the devotion of King Edgar may be condemned to be biassed to superstition." Are all the generations of Englishmen for ever to be bound by laws made by superstitious men? Historians prove that the kings who made the laws by which the Clergy claim civil right to tithes, were superstitious, and even worse. One was a murderer, who caused a neighbouring king's death, so that he might seize his kingdom. He made the law to satisfy the menacing demands of the clergy, as penance, a few months before his death. Another was a monk, and designed by his father for a bishop. In all respects he was more fit to be a churchman than a king. Furthermore, he was in great fear of losing his crown. And that ground was diligently ploughed and plentifully sown by the clergy, who harvested an excellent crop. Are we to be bound by their laws—laws antagonistic to Apostolic teaching and practice? The grants of tithes by law were got by fraud through fear. The people were taught to believe that God's word commanded Christians to pay tithes, or else forfeit nine tenths of their property. Tithes were enacted in that belief. The Bible was to them a sealed book. These are our "pious ancestors" who "gave us the tithes"! And these are the "pious" ways in which they were induced to give them! "Surely this is the 'art of arts,' as Bishop Gregory testifieth."
