Menu
‹ Chapter 105 of 294 ›

Compulsory Tithes: their Origin — [Second Article.] — By Pastor W. M. Hawkins, Hundon, Clare, Suffolk

16 min read · Chapter 105 of 294

DEAN PRIDEAUX on "Tithes: their Origin in Public Law," Part III., says: "Thus till towards the fourth age of the church all the necessities of it were fully answered by the voluntary offerings of the faithful; and what was given by them this way, as it did much exceed a tenth of their income, so it did much more than suffice, not only for the maintenance of the ministers, but for all other occasions also." . . . "But then this zeal beginning to grow cold, some offering too little, and others nothing at all."

It is of considerable importance that we should ascertain how this change for the worse came about. What caused their zeal to grow cold towards the fourth century? Settle this satisfactorily, and then you will have the key that will unlock and discover a great deal that needs now to be brought to light.

It was not through persecution, nor through poverty, that their zeal waned. The venerable John Wesley, in a sermon on the "Mystery of Iniquity," says: "Persecution never did, never could, give any lasting wound to Christianity. But the greatest it ever received, the grand blow which was struck at the very root of that humble, gentle, patient love, which is the fulfilling of the Christian law, the whole essence of true religion, was struck in the fourth century, by Constantine the Great, when he called himself a Christian, and poured in a flood of riches, honours, and power upon the Christians, more especially upon the clergy. Just so, when the fear of persecution was removed, and wealth and honour attended the Christian profession, the Christians did not gradually sink, but rushed headlong into all manner of vice. Then the mystery of iniquity was no more hid, but stalked abroad in the face of the sun. Then not the golden, but the iron, ago of the church commenced.

"This is the event which most Christian expositors mention with such triumph! yea, which some of them suppose to be typified in the Revelation, by the 'New Jerusalem coming down from heaven.' Rather say, it was the coming of Satan and all his legions from the bottomless pit; seeing from that very time he hath set up his throne over the face of the whole earth, and reigned over the Christian as well as the Pagan world with hardly any control." Sermon lxi., secs. 27, 28. John Wesley.

Constantine, the Emperor of Rome, abandoned Paganism for Christianity, and then Christianity became the recognized and fashionable religion. True religion was swamped by the enterprising and unscrupulous part of the people belonging to the great Roman empire. Vast numbers of people professed to be Christians for the sake of fashion, office, and favours of various kinds.

The "church," as it was called, was united with the State, and was regarded as a part of the empire. The government of the church was changed—changed for the worse. The Head of the church said, "My kingdom is not of this world." The early Christians kept it separate and distinct from the world. But Constantine the Great united it to the State, and commenced to build up that system—the grand hierarchy—which was and is so great an attraction to the ambitious and to the worldly-minded. The clergy, instead of remaining all on one level, so far as civil governments are concerned, had to be remodelled on the plan of the army, with its officers of all grades and all scales of remuneration, to meet the needs of the wealthy and ambitious worldlings who wished to "enter the church" as a means to promotion. It was natural, then, that the best families should be put into the best offices—natural, not spiritual. Neither did it advance the spiritual interests of the church, although it advanced the temporal interests of emperors and princes at the expense of true religion.

It does not require much effort to understand some of the more immediate ill effects of this change. Many more hundreds of thousands of pounds were soon required every year to meet the extra demands made on the churches to

235

pay the salaries of these superior State-church officials. A greater demand was made on the liberality of the Christians without a corresponding increase in the liberal spirit that animated the first Christians. Why was this?

1. The extra demand brought no corresponding benefit to the community. This is easily seen by anyone who asks himself, "What benefit do I or my brethren get by our having to pay £15,000 a year to an Archbishop?

2. Vast numbers of people who professed to be Christians did so from worldly motives. This class of people did not give their share to the church funds. Hence it is that Dean Prideaux came to the conclusion that "their zeal grew cold, some offering too little, and others offering nothing at all." The Dean was wrong if he thought that the zeal of true Christians grew cold. It was the nominal, the fashionable, the professing part of the State-church that on the one hand created artificial and extravagant expenses, and on the other hand, introduced multitudes of mean-spirited, Christless people into Church-fellowship.

The following has been asked many times in my hearing:—"What benefit does the religion of Jesus Christ derive from the payment of £176,300 a year to two Archbishops and twenty eight Bishops in cash, besides 33 episcopal palaces?"

This and other artificial expense is only a small part of the bad fruit brought forth by the tree that Constantine planted in the Lord's vineyard in the fourth century, when he established the Church; that is, when he made it a creature of the State. In other ways also he sowed thorns and thistles in the "garden of the Lord."

What use are Archbishops, Bishops, Canons, Deans and Chapters, and such like? It is true that we read of Bishops in the New Testament. We also read of them in the first centuries of Christianity. We also read of Pastors, Elders, and Presbyters, as well as Bishops. These words all referred to one class of officers in the Apostolic and early days of Christianity.

The Rev. H. Soames, M.A., Chancellor of St. Paul's Cathedral, in his "Anglo-Saxon Church" (p. 38), says, "The care, universally marking primitive Christianity, to provide a bishop for every church, necessarily connects the stream of British prelacy with Apostolic times." I accept the fact, but reject the inference. The fact is proved by other writers, but the inference is a matter of opinion.

Father Simon, a learned priest, in his "History of the Origin and Progress of Ecclesiastical Revenues, Laws, Ancient and Modern," tells us, on page 8, "The bishops in these assemblies had the same honour as the ruler of the synagogue amongst the Jews had in their synagogues. The superiority of the rulers of the synagogue, in respect to priests and elders, consisted only in some titles of honour as being the chief amongst their brethren. And therefore they are all comprehended under the name of priests and elders in the 107th Psalm, verse 32: "Let them also exalt him in the congregation of the people, and praise him in the assembly of the elders," which was the place of their meeting. So we find in the New Testament that the names of priest and bishop are indifferently taken the one for the other."

Jerome and Hilarius Diaconus maintained in the fourth century that originally bishops and presbyters were on an equality with each other. Polycarp, in his Commentary on the Epistle to the Philippians, makes mention only of presbyters and deacons, and seems to style himself only as the principal presbyter of the church of Smyrna. Modern writers always speak of him as "Bishop Polycarp." Irenæus uses the words presbyter and bishop interchangeably.

The bishop was the chairman or president, holding a similar position to the chairman of the Baptist and Congregational Unions, and to the presidents of the Methodist bodies, and to the Chairman of the District amongst the Methodists.

Hilary says, "At first presbyters were called bishops, so that when one (who was called bishop) passed away, the next in order took his place." The bishop

was simply the senior pastor. Dr. Killon, in his learned and suggestive work on "The Ancient Church," has accumulated valuable evidence in support of this statement. It is conclusive that bishop, and presbyter, and pastor, were identical in origin. In the early days of Christianity the highest officer in the churches next to an apostle, was an elder, frequently also called pastor, presbyter, and bishop. We do not read anywhere in apostolic times, or in the ages immediately succeeding them, of prebendaries, archdeacons, archbishops, canons, or deans and chapters. These are all the creations of human ingenuity, ambition, and avarice. They absorb yearly the enormous sum of £470,094. How many earnest, godly, useful preachers, would this large sum maintain?

What is the use of archbishops, deans and chapters, canons, &c.? The people who introduced such officers into the church had not been instructed by the true Teacher, or his apostles, or by their immediate successors. This is proved by Mosheim, in his "Ecclesiastical History" (vol. i., part ii., sec. viii.): "The rulers of the church were called either presbyters or bishops, which two titles are in the New Testament undoubtedly applied to the same order of men." It is manifest from the diligent researches of Dr. Dale, of Birmingham, Dr. Paton, of Nottingham, and many other scholars and historians, that the early disciples of the Lord did not know anything of diocesan-bishops, archbishops, deans and chapters, canons, cardinals, popes, curates, rectors, vicars, incumbents, prebendaries, right-reverends, most-reverends, very-reverends, or superior or inferior clergy. The constitution of the churches did not need them. They had congregational bishops; that is, each bishop was the pastor of a church.

Further, these ancient pastors, or bishops, were chosen by the people to whom they ministered, and never appointed, or even nominated, by anyone else. Each company of believers was a church, and each church was a separate and independent republic. Gibbon, in his "Decline and Fall" (chap. xv.) says, "Such was the mild and equal constitution by which the Christians were governed more than a hundred years after the death of the apostles. Every society formed within itself a separate and independent republic; and although the most distant of these little states maintained a mutual, as well as a friendly intercourse of letters and deputations, the Christian world was not yet connected by any supreme authority or legislative assembly." "Independence and equality formed the basis of their internal constitution."

Mosheim, in his "Ecclesiastical History" (vol. i. part ii., chap. ii., sec. xii., page 48), tells us: "Let none, however, confound the bishops of this primitive and golden period of the church with those of whom we read in the following ages. For though they were both distinguished by the same name, yet they differed extremely, and that in many respects." "A bishop, during the first and second century, was a person who had the care of one Christian assembly, which at that time was, generally speaking, small enough to be contained in a private house. In this assembly he acted, not with the authority of a master, but with the zeal and diligence of a faithful servant. He instructed the people, performed the several parts of divine worship, attended the sick, and inspected into the circumstances and supplies of the poor. . . . And though the episcopal office was both laborious and singularly dangerous, yet its revenues were extremely small, since the church had no certain income, but depended on the gifts or oblations of the multitude."

This was all changed by the action of Constantine. Great offices were created, and, of course, great expenses. To meet these new and artificial expenses measures were resorted to that found no warrant in the New Testament—measures not needed in the days of pure Christianity. Let history speak.

David Hume, in his "History of England," in describing the reign of Ethelwulph (chap. ii.), A.D. 838—857, says, "The ecclesiastics, in those days of ignorance, made rapid advances in the acquisition of power and grandeur. . . . Not content with the donations of land made to them by the Saxon princes and nobles, and with temporary oblations from the devotion of the people, they had cast a wishful eye on the vast revenues which they claimed as

237

belonging to them by sacred and indefeasible title. However little versed in the Scriptures, they had been able to discover that, under the Jewish law, a tenth of all the produce of the land was conferred on the priesthood; and forgetting what they themselves taught that the moral part only of that law was obligatory on Christians, they insisted that this donation conveyed a perpetual property, inherent by divine right in those who officiated at the altar. During some centuries, the whole scope of sermons and homilies was directed to this purpose; and one would have imagined, from the general tenor of these discourses, that all the practical parts of Christianity were comprised in the exact and faithful payment of tithes to the clergy." I can give you a specimen, furnished by the celebrated Sir Henry Spelman, the great authority on tithes, and a staunch advocate for their "Divine right." He quotes it from a sermon of St. Augustine, on tithes, who came with forty monks to convert England, in the year 597 A.D. "Ingrateful and perfidious deceiver! I speak to thee in the Word of the Lord. Behold, the year is now ended; give unto the Lord (that giveth the rain) his reward. Redeem thyself, O man! whilst thou livest. Redeem thou thyself whilst thou mayest. Redeem thyself (I say) whilst thou hast wherewith in thy hands. Redeem thyself, lest if greedy death prevent thee, thou then lose both life and reward together. Thou hast no reason to commit this matter over to thy wife, who haply will have another husband. Neither hast thou (O woman!) any reason to leave this to thy husband, for his mind is on another wife. It is in vain to tie thy parents, or thy kinsfolk, to have care thereof. No man after thy death surely shall redeem thee, because in thy life thou wouldst not redeem thyself. Now then, cast the burden of covetousness from thy shoulders, despise that cruel lady, who, pressing thee down with her intolerable yoke, suffereth thee not to receive the yoke of Christ. For as the yoke of covetousness presseth men down to hell, so the yoke of Christ raiseth men unto heaven. For tithes are required as a debt, and he that will not give them invadeth another man's goods," &c.—(Sermon 219, De Reddendis Decimis). See Sir Henry Spelman's De non Temerandis Ecclesiis (of the "Rights and Respects due unto the Church," page 19). I wonder what our modern hearers would think of the like.

Dean Prideaux quotes many passages nearly in the same strain; all with the same object, from various archbishops and other great lights of the church, who gave themselves no rest until tithes became their legal property.

Turning again to Hume, we see how successful they were: "Encouraged by their success in inculcating these doctrines, they ventured farther than they were warranted, even by the Levitical law, and pretended to draw the tenth of all industry, merchandize, wages of soldiers; nay, some canonists went so far as to affirm that the clergy were entitled to a tithe of the profits made by courtezaus (prostitutes) in the exercise of their profession." In support of these statements, Hume quotes Padre Paolo's Sopra Beneficii Ecclesiastici, pp. 51, 52, 132, Edit. Colon. 1675; and Spelman's Concil. vol. i. p. 268, as his authorities.

This famous historian also goes on to say: "Though parishes had been instituted in England by Honorius, Archbishop of Canterbury, near two centuries before (Parker, p. 77), the ecclesiastics had never yet been able to get possession of the tithes; they therefore seized the present favourable opportunity of making that acquisition, when a weak, superstitious prince filled the throne, and when the people, discouraged by their losses from the Danes, and terrified by the fear of future invasion, were susceptible of any impression which bore the appearance of religion." (Hume, chap. ii.)

The Historian Rapin has something important to say here:—"The continual wars with the Danes during the eighth century and the early part of the ninth, wore no less fatal to the church than to the State. They produced an extreme corruption of manners and a profound Ignorance all over the Kingdom.

"Ethelwulph was addicted to religion both in temper and in education, having been a monk. Two prelates bore an absolute sway over him. He was

16

naturally of a slothful and indolent temper. Bishop Swithun, all in all with the king, confirmed him more and more in his natural bias to a religious life. Above all, he instilled into him an extreme affection for the Church and Clergy, wherein the main of religion was made to consist."—Rapin's History of England, vol. i. p. 80.

By the advice of Bishop Swithun, the King granted to the Church the tithes of all his own land, as follows:—"I, Ethelwulph, by the grace of God King of the West Saxons, &c., with the advice of the Bishops, Earls, and all other persons of Distinction in my Dominions, have, for the Health of my Soul and the Good of my People, and the Prosperity of my Kingdom, taken the Prudent and serviceable Resolution of granting the tenth of my whole Kingdom to the Church and Ministers of Religion to be enjoyed by them, with all the Privileges of a free Tenure, and discharged from all Services due to the Crown, and all other Incumbrances incident to Lay Fees. This grant has been made by us to the Church in Honour of Jesus Christ, the Blessed Virgin and All Saints, and out of regard to the Paschal Solomnity, and that Almighty God might vouchsafe his Blessing to us and our Posterity. Dated at the Palace of Wilton, in the year 854, Indiction the second, at the Feast of Easter."—Rapin's History of England, vol. i. p. 3. Rapin says, "The Charter here translated is in the Monasticon, p. 100, and is dated at Wilton in 854."

Dean Prideaux gives the same Charter, and adds to it the following, as part of the original:—"Whosoever shall augment this our donation, may God augment him in his prosperous days! But if anyone shall presume to diminish or change it, let him know that he must give an account hereof before the Judgment Seat of Christ, unless in the interim he doth make amends by giving satisfaction for the same. I, Ethelwulph, the King, I, Elstan, Bishop, I, Swithin, Bishop, I, Wulffal, Abbot, I, Werford, Abbot, I, Ethelred, and I, Alfred, the King's Sons, have given our consent hereto."—Dr. Prideaux, on "Tithes, their Origin in Public Law," chapter iv. See also the learned John Selden's "History of Tithes," Original Edition, A.D. 1618, Chap. viii. pp. 204-211.

Ethelwulph immediately made a pilgrimage to Rome, and after spending large sums of money on the Papacy, and a year's time, he started homeward. On his way he called on the French King, Charles the Bald, and foolishly married Judith, his daughter, a girl only 12 years old. He gave her the title of "Queen." But when he came home he met rather a cool reception, and found the people in no way pleased with his marriage; they also objected, on principle, to the King's wife being called "Queen." Bishop Elstan and the King's eldest son, Ethelbald, with others, plotted against the King to depose him. To appease the clamour of the church officials for compulsory tithes of all the Kingdom, and to put the crooked things of the nation straight by the influence of the Ecclesiastical powers, Ethelwulph expressed his willingness to grant a tenth of all the land in the Kingdom to the Church. The Pope, the Cardinals, the Bishops, and all the Clergy had been plotting and planning and preaching and passing canons in their councils for centuries to get the Legalization of tithes.

They succeeded. I quote from Dr. Prideaux, Dean of Norwich, "Tithes; their Origin in Public Law, Chap. iv."

1. "Our Lord Jesus Christ reigning for ever. Whereas, in our time, we have seen the burnings of war, the ravagings of our wealth, and also the cruel depredations of enemies wasting our land, and many tribulations from barbarous and Pagan nations inflicted upon us, for the punishing of our sins, even almost to our utter destruction, and also very perilous times hanging over our heads.

2. "For this cause, I, Ethelwulph King of the West Saxons, by the advice of my bishops and other chiefmen of my kingdom, have resolved on a wholesome and uniform remedy—that is, that I grant as an offering unto God, and the blessed Virgin, and all the saints, a certain portion of my kingdom, to be held by perpetual right—that is to say, the tenth part thereof; and that this

239

tenth part be privileged from temporal duties, and free from all secular services and royal tributes, as well the greater as the lesser, or those taxes which we call Witerden (a tax or royal aid imposed by Saxon Parliaments), and that it be free from all things else, for the health of my soul, and the pardon of my sins, to be applied only to the service of God alone, without being charged to any expedition, or to the repair of bridges, or the fortifying of castles, to the end that the clergy may, with the more diligence, pour out their prayers to God for us without ceasing, in which we do in some part receive their service.

3. "These things were enacted at Winchester, in the Church of St. Peter, before the great altar, in the year of the incarnation of our Lord, 855, in the third indiction, on the nones of November, for the honour of the glorious Virgin and mother of God, St. Mary, and St. Michael, the Archangel, and of the blessed Peter, prince of the apostles, and also of our blessed father, Pope Gregory, and of all the saints.

4. "There were present and subscribed hereto all the archbishops and bishops of England, as also Boered, King of Mercia, and Edmund, King of the East Angles, and also a great multitude of abbots, abbesses, dukes, earls, and noblemen of the whole land, as well as of other Christian people, who all approved of the Royal Charter, but those only who were persons of dignity subscribed their names to it.

5. "King Ethelwulf, for the greater firmness of the grant, offered this Charter upon the altar of St. Peter the Apostle, and the bishops on God's part received the same of him, and afterwards sent it to be published in all the churches throughout their respective dioceses."

The Dean says: "This charter we find recorded in three of our ancientest historians—Ingulph, William of Malmsbury, and Matthew of Westminster; and Ingulph being the oldest of them, as having been secretary to William the First in Normandy, before the Conquest, and after his coming into England made Abbot of Croyland by him, I have here set it down as I find it in him. But the second paragraph being so depraved by after transcribers, as not to be made sense of, I have jointly with it added the same paragraph as it is in Matthew of Westminster."

Here, according to Selden, Prideaux, and multitudes of tithe writers, historians, and ecclesiastical lawyers, we have the foundation of the civil right of the clergy to tithes in England. It is not so many voluntary gifts on the part of "our pious ancestors," but law made by a few of the people, and most of that few had an active interest in the law. I propose in the next article to show how the people were compelled to pay the tithes by most cruel laws and penalties: thus proving that they did not give them of their own free will.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate