At Dr. Pusey's Grave — A Dialogue
ON a marble slab in the floor of the nave of "the Cathedral Church of Christ,"* at Oxford, is an inscription, inlaid in lead, to the memory of the late Canon and Professor of Hebrew, whose name has so long been known as a symbol of that ecclesiastical revival still popularly called Puseyism.
He was buried here in the presence of a vast concourse of sympathetic spectators, on the 21st September, 1882, in a vault where he the remains of his wife and two daughters. His own original inscription to their memory is reproduced on the new stone; and the venerable doctor himself is thus simply commemorated:—
EDWARDI BOUVERIE PUSEY, S.T.P.,
LINGUÆ HEBRAICÆ PROFESSORIS
ET HUJUSQUE ÆDIS CANONICI,
QUI IN PACE ET MISERICORDIA JESU
OBDOMIVIT D. SEP. XVI. MDCCCLXXXII.
NAT. ANNOS LXXXII. DIES XXIV.
BENEDICTUS DEUS, QUI NON AMOVIT
ORATIONEM MEAM ET MISERICORDIAM SUAM
A ME.
"In the peace and mercy of Jesus." "Blessed be God, who hath not turned away my prayer, nor his mercy from me." As I traced these words on the marble, I recalled the memory of a sermon heard from his lips in my early boyhood, from one of those passages in St. John's Epistles which dwell on the love of God as manifested in his Son; and the conviction then formed (undisturbed since, amid all the conflict which has raged around his name) that, whatever of lamentable folly and pernicious error was to be found in the system, and however graceless many of his individual followers may have proved themselves, the man himself had deep practical experience of the transforming power of the love of Christ. Whatever else he was, he was one who loved and trusted in his God, by whom he was not forsaken in his old age. He had learned at his Saviour's feet the secret of "peace," and fell asleep at last trusting alone in the "mercy of Jesus."
As thus I mused, I was joined by one whom I recognized as a devout Churchman and constant attendant at the cathedral services; and we naturally fell into talk on the topics suggested by the memorial stone. My companion expressed the same belief in the Doctor's goodness, while strongly deprecating the direction in which his great influence was exerted; and our subsequent conversation took something like the following form:—
A.—I well remember a characteristic incident related to me by a clerical friend, as we stood together waiting for the solemn funeral procession. Speaking of the strength gained by conscious personal contact with the Saviour, he once heard Dr. Pusey mention that though in the course of his life it had been his duty to read carefully through many infidel works, none of them had for a moment shaken his faith; and he regarded this experience as a fulfilment of the divine promise: "Ye shall take up serpents, and if ye drink any deadly thing, it shall not hurt you." His soul rested in loving trust on the only Saviour; and though, like the rest of us, he "saw through a glass darkly" here, now he knows even as he is known. "In Christ!" That is the only security for life or for death. To be out of Christ is the condition of exclusion from peace and happiness here and hereafter.
* This is the official designation of the Cathedral at Oxford. The name "Christ Church" (Ædes Christi) should never be spelt in a single word, as the Times persists in printing it, thus confounding it with the Hampshire town.
B.—But do you not think there must be a state after death in which those who have not "accepted salvation" here may have another chance? I cannot believe that God made any souls to be finally lost.
A.—Every truly Christian heart would gladly share your hope. The subject teems with perplexities to many thoughtful minds. I knew a man, for many years resident in this parish, who through a long life was greatly troubled with intellectual doubts, which hindered his acceptance of the Divine revelation. He was an early disciple of that school of which grand old Thomas Cooper was in those days a prominent teacher; and though in after years he listened with attention to all his old master's lectures in defence of the faith, he was unable to shake off the fetters of unbelief till very late in life, when, I have good reason to believe, the change came, as he "humbled himself, and became as a little child." A dear and honoured friend of mine, to whom he had confided his perplexities, wrote to him some twenty years ago a letter, a copy of which, by a singular chance, is now in my pocket. Let me read you my friend's words on this very question. They may be of some help to you.
"With respect to the disturbing thought which you present, I cannot affect to offer a solution. I hold the problem to be unsolvable here, intellectually. Our only help is in a moral-intellectual process. For myself, I must confess that the thought of sentient beings, with so much capacity for suffering, being miserable for ever, is overwhelming. And then, as you say, we think of our own dear and beloved ones, and of the fearful possibility. But, I ask—Whence have we these deep human yearnings? Who has given us the natural and spiritual emotions of a father? Who, but THE FATHER! 'Like as a father pitieth his children, so the Lord pitieth them that fear him.' 'If ye fathers, being evil, know how to give good gifts unto your children, how much more shall your heavenly Father,' etc. Will not our Father pity us? And if, beside being Father, he is the Ruler of the universe, then 'shall not the Judge of all the earth do Right?' Surely! and so I bow the head. It was with highest reason that the Hebrew prophet declared, 'Though he slay me, yet will I trust in him.' It is hard to attain to this; but that is the resting-ground. Then, to take the small to illustrate the great. We—you and I—have seen, both at home and in society, and among friends—so long as the untaught or perverted will of the child is in opposition to the wise and just will of the parent, so long there must be unhappiness, and a dividing gulf. I leave out, as I must, the question of the why of a possibility of the resisting and perverse will. That is. Because of it, we are; and the question with you and with me is not, 'Why does man exist?' but, 'existing as he does, how much light and guidance is there for him? and where may these be found?'"
B.—Yes. All that is true. I quite see that it ill becomes us to imagine ourselves in a position to dictate terms to the Almighty.
A.—It always saddens me to hear men discussing the purposes of God concerning those who die in unbelief; and even pleading their notions as a valid excuse for their own refusal to submit to the Divine claims. Why, if God had merely revealed to us his holy law, our hopeless defection, and his intention to visit transgressors with condign punishment, something might with some show of reason have been said against his dealings. But the grand theme of his revelation is summed up in the declaration, "God so loved the world that he gave his Only-begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him might not perish, but have eternal life." And the pity is that, instead of accepting this wonderful truth with the gratitude which is its due, men waste their precious time and harden their foolish hearts with vain speculations as to what will become of those who reject it.
B.—And yet it is a mystery—you cannot deny it—that so many are permitted to live and die without embracing—ay, and millions without even the chance of embracing—the "glad tidings."
A.—There are many mysteries in the world which we must accept, though we cannot pretend to explain. The very existence of suffering and death is one
365
of them. I was brought face to face with this mystery in my own experience not many months ago, when I watched a darling daughter through a terrible fever, and had at last to yield her up, and close her dear eyes, never to have my face irradiated and my heart cheered with their brilliant beauty again. I would have borne any torture—would have given my life to save the sweet loved one from the distress she was enduring. But my sympathy was powerless. The strong and relentless hand of death was upon her, and I had to submit. The mystery was dread and almost insupportable. But through it God taught me a yet greater mystery, which stilled my heart's murmurings, and enabled me to say with entire sincerity of soul, "Even so, Father, for so it seemed good in thy sight." For through my agony I learned such a lesson of God's "inestimable love" as I had never learned before. "He that spared not his own Son, but delivered him up for us all!" If such was the anguish of an earthly father's heart as he watched the suffering of his innocent child, what must have been that of the Heavenly Father ("in whom every fatherhood is named") as he saw his Only-begotten and Well-beloved Son, the perfectly holy and sinless One, bearing the weight of the world's iniquity!—as he heard him plead "with strong crying and tears," "My Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me," and could only reply: "My Son, it is not possible: the cup must be drunk to the dregs." It was not impotence which stayed the hand of the Omnipotent. He might have "spared" his dear Son; but he spared him not. Why? He was under no constraint, save the compulsion of his own infinite love for undeserving sinners! Oh! if the unimagined agony of the Son of God, as he bore on his head the weight of the world's sin, was consistent with the perfect love of his heavenly Father, because through it he would "bring many sons unto glory;" shall we wonder or repine if in our life, as well as in our faith, we meet with inexplicable problems? Surely, in the presence of this mightiest of mysteries, we can be reconciled to all other mysteries of the divine government, even if we cannot yet find their full solution. And this grand central conviction—the infinite love of the Infinite Father—affords a firm anchorage in every storm of doubt. Out of seeming evil God still educes good; and when our weak short-sight prompts the poet's question—
"What hope of answer, or redress?"
our faith can safely rely on the Rock on which our hope is anchored, "within the veil."
My friend gave sympathetic assent to these thoughts; and the topic soon changed as he spoke of the teaching commonly heard in church pulpits. We had left the cathedral, and were walking through the great quadrangle.
"I am tired," said he, "of hearing perpetual appeals to 'the church,' and extollations of 'the church' in every sermon. I know what it all means. It is the old assumption of the Church of Rome: 'Out of the church no salvation.' Roman Catholics say this of their church; the priests of the English church make the same claim for theirs. I hope your dissenting ministers don't indulge in that sort of talk concerning their 'denominations.'"
A.—No, indeed! An Evangelical Nonconformist cannot consistently be a bigot. On the sacerdotal theory of salvation, everything depends on the man's connection with a "true church," and his reception of the rites of that church by the hands of a duly ordained priesthood. We cannot wonder, therefore, when a Churchman refuses to recognise a Dissenter as a fellow-Christian. Outside the pale of "the church," he is bound to regard him as ipso facto in an unsaved if not an absolutely unsalvable condition. In our view, on the contrary, everything depends on the personal relation of the individual soul to the Lord Jesus Christ. We hold and teach that there is "none other name under heaven given among men, whereby we must be saved," but the name of Jesus; but that "in him whosoever believeth is justified." "He that believeth in the Son of God hath everlasting life." "Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest." Pardon, acceptance, safety, and eternal
life, are his free gift, to be appropriated by simple faith. "We are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus." And thus we can consistently recognise as our fellow-Christians "all who love our Lord Jesus Christ in sincerity," by whatever name they are called; and rejoice in the belief that there are many true members of "the household of faith" in every branch of Christ's church, who, differing on many matters of doctrine and discipline, are joined in one Spirit to "the Head," and will one day join the "great multitude which no man can number, out of every nation, and kindred, and people, and tribe"—and every ecclesiastical organization, too—"who have washed their robes, and made them white in the blood of the Lamb!"
B.—Well, I have often thought that it does not seem to be God's will that we should all think alike in this world. It does not follow that we do not equally love the Lord Jesus Christ because in some matters we act on our different interpretations of his will.
A.—Just so. As I heard Mr. Spurgeon say last Easter Sunday, when expounding the tenth chapter of John's Gospel: Our Lord never promised that there should be but "one fold." In the original the word is "one flock;" and as a matter of fact there never has been but one flock, and never will be. The Good Shepherd goes before, and his sheep follow him; and all who know the Shepherd's voice, and follow him, belong to the One Flock.
B.—It is not at all inconsistent, then, with your convictions of divine truth to believe that a man may be a Ritualist, or even a Roman Catholic—may, in fact, belong to a false church, and yet be a true member of Christ's flock.
A.—Certainly. The point is, a man is not saved by his "views;" nor by his creed, correct or incorrect; but by the free grace of God, through his own personal appropriation of the Lord Jesus as his only Saviour. And men's churchmanship, so to speak—their ecclesiastical position, I mean—is largely determined by early education, tone of thought, or taste. "God fulfils himself in many ways." Some men's religious sense is moved by the fervid and impassioned appeals of a Revival preacher, whose manner and methods would be repulsive to others cast in a different mould; while some are reached through their aesthetic tastes, and are won to the love of God and faith in his Son amid the solemn grandeur of the church's services, whose hearts would never have been melted in the cold dreariness of a whitewashed "conventicle," or even warmed into life by the fiery zeal of the Salvation Army.
B.—Well, at all events, you are certainly no bigot.
A.—Nearly thirty years ago I was for ever cured of the spirit of intolerance. I had an elder brother, the dearly-loved companion of my studies and my pleasures, who, when a boy, was of a distinctly sceptical turn, and by his scoffing at sacred things caused his more tender-hearted brother many bitter tears. When he left school, he was articled to an architect in the town of L—, and in that capacity developed his growing taste for Gothic architecture, then in its early revival. His favourite pursuit naturally led him to read the Tractarian literature of that day, in which the renovation of our old churches brought in its train the restoration of so many of the doctrines and practices which had been rejected or disused at the Reformation. By the fascination of these works, together with the reading of a funeral sermon on the elder Pugin (an eminent architect, and a Romanist), combined with the persistent efforts of an Oxford pervert, then a Roman Catholic priest in that town, he was led not only to a close study of Roman and Anglo-Catholic theology, but to a devout search of God's word; and at length avowed himself a Catholic. But through these various avenues the love of God in Christ dawned upon him; his heart was changed by Divine grace; and when, a few months later, he lay on his death-bed, after a very brief illness, his trust in the One Mediator, the Great High Priest, was unfaltering, and almost his last words were—
"Nothing in my hands I bring:
Simply to thy cross I cling."
367
My daily prayer for years on his behalf had been, "Lord, lead him into all truth!" and thus the prayer was fulfilled; and by a way most unexpected and undesired, he was led to him who is "the Way and the Truth;" and "in the face of Jesus Christ" caught the first bright gleams of "the light of the knowledge of the glory of God," so soon to burst upon him with unclouded splendour in "the beatific vision."
B.—I do not wonder that you were much impressed by such an experience. How fitly that hymn expressed your brother's faith! It has often struck me that in the hymns of the church all Christians seem to speak the same language.
A.—Yes; because in their hymns of devotion they speak the language of the heart; and the hearts of all real Christians beat in harmony, however their heads may differ. I think Lord Selborne points out this fact in the preface to his "Book of Praise." John Bunyan and George Herbert, Charles Wesley and Augustus Toplady, John Henry Newman and T. T. Lynch, Francis Faber and Frances Havergal sang but one song on earth, as they all join in the One Song in heaven.
B.—That reminds me of a very beautiful hymn I noticed in our Lenten service here last night. I think it is No. 186 in "Hymns Ancient and Modern." Can you tell me who wrote it? It begins—
"I could not do without thee."
A.—Oh, yes! I know it well. It is Miss Havergal's; one of her very best, I think.
"I could not do without thee,
O Saviour of the lost,
Whose precious blood redeemed me
At such tremendous cost!"
The whole hymn breathes the very life-breath of every true Christian, by whatever name he may be called. Do you remember its closing verse?—
"I could not do without thee;
For years are fleeting fast,
And soon in solemn loneliness
The river must be passed;
But thou wilt never leave me,
And though the waves roll high,
I know thou wilt be near me,
And whisper, 'It is I!'"
Ah! my friend, in that supreme moment you and I will need nothing else if we have Christ as our All in All. And as in death so in life, his love is the only real uniting bond. "Ye are all one IN CHRIST JESUS!"
And so our thoughts have wandered back again to Dr. Pusey's grave, and those words of simple trust—
"IN PACE ET MISERICORDIA JESU."
Oxford, 1884.
E. C. A.
