Notices of Books
The Preachers' Monthly: containing Studies for the Pulpit. Edited by the Rev. W. HOPE DAVISON. New Series. Vol. VI. John Lobb.
THIS volume contains a good store of condensed sermons. Such a monthly visitor must come to lone preachers in rural places as a boon and a blessing. The Editor gives as much variety as the object of the magazine allows, and his selection of homilies is, upon the whole, a commendable one. We recommend ministers to buy the volumes, for then they will be likely to retain them among their stock-in-trade, and every now and then, when they are hard driven, they will find a discourse in them which they can use. These ministers'
helps should be used as we use a walking-stick: we can walk without it, and we do; but when we cannot manage without its aid we are glad to lean on it just a little rather than not walk at all.
The Psalms in Private Devotion. By the Rev. G. STRINGER ROWE. T. Woolmer.
THE meditations, prayers, and invocations will be gracious and helpful to the general reader; but to our taste they have not enough in them of fresh thought arising out of the psalm itself. We would say of the book that it is good, but hardly up to the average ability which should lie at the back of all devotional works.
239
The Closing Days of Christendom. By BURLINGTON B. WALE. London: S. W. Partridge and Co.
THIS is a second edition, considerably enlarged and very considerably improved. Many thoughts of many minds are here assiduously collated and ingeniously melted down into small compass. The result of much reading on prophetic subjects is thus registered. In Mr. Wales's conception we are drawing near the time of the end. Like Mr. Grattan Guinness, he imagines that we are already in the rapids. Unlike Mr. Guinness he dispenses with disquisitions on cycles and calendars. "Not dates but characteristics" is his chosen motto. Thus he avoids the adylum and adopts arguments more likely to convince a less intelligent class of readers.
Thoughts on Holiness. By MARK GUY PEARSE. T. Woolmer and Co.
As an inimitable story-teller we have long delighted to listen to Mr. Pearse: his Dan'l Quorm was a study of character that held us spell-bound, and was full of quaint, gracious wisdom. But he is a safe theologian as well as a charming writer, and these "Thoughts on Holiness" are brimful of deep teaching put in crystal form. His perfectionism is Scripture perfectionism, an ideal not a boast, a purpose not a pride. Young Christians will find in these pages a holy stimulus to devoted life and service, and older saints will learn much of the hidden things of God, those secrets of the Lord which are with them who fear him. Mr. Pearse has put all denominations under obligation for these brave, clarion words.
Wayside Springs from the Fountain of Life. By T. L. CUYLER, D.D. Hodder and Stoughton.
THERE is no need for us to say more of this little series of all-alive chats than that "they are Dr. Cuyler's, and just like him." For sentences that strike and stick; gems that gleam and glow; and thoughts that thrill, commend us to our American friend. A good dose of Cuyler taken on Saturday night, would work wonders in some pews and Sunday classes the next day. Try it, Sister Doleful, and Brother Prosy, and see the result.
Talks with Young Men. By J. THAIN DAVIDSON, D.D. Hodder & Stoughton.
A YANKEE evangelist some time ago informed certain learned professors that the only man in Scripture who confessed himself a D.D. was Mephibosheth, who called himself a "dead dog." This was very rough upon doctors, among whom are numbered certain of the ablest of our brethren. Let any man read these talks of Dr. Thain Davidson, and he will neither think him a dog nor dead. He gives young men fine manly advice, full of grace and truth. Enlivened by story and proverb, fresh with sympathy, and on fire with zeal, these short lectures are just what they should be; and all that they further need is to be largely distributed among the crowds of our advancing manhood. To begin to read is to be bound to continue: the talks are so sensible, and so spiritual, that no one wishes to silence the talker by laying aside the book. Well done, doctor, we have always esteemed you as an earnest preacher, and we do not think your writing at all inferior to your living speech. At 3s. 6d. this volume would be a profitable investment for a teacher to read to his class little by little, though we fully admit that speaking out of your own heart is better than the best reading from the best books.
Capital for Working Boys. Chapters on character building. By J. E. M'CONAUGHT. Hodder and Stoughton.
A HIGHLY American flavour runs through this book, and we like it none the less for that. We should like every working-boy to read it. It is full of wise saws and modern instances, pithy quotations, and taking anecdotes. The spirit of persevering industry and independence will be fostered by such reading, while neatness, promptness, truthfulness, economy, and true religion are not forgotten. We are pleased with the style and spirit of the author: he reminds us somewhat of our friend Haig Miller, and he will develop into an author of that same quiet, genial, chatty, anecdotal school. Every wise father, who has sons about to leave the home fire-side, should give each one of them a copy of this capital book.
The Scottish Church and its Surroundings in Early Times. By ROBERT PATON. Edinburgh: Jas. Gemmell.
THE people whose minister can give them such instructive lectures may think themselves highly favoured. Mr. Paton tells us about the very earliest apostles to the Picts and Scots, and then tells us of Columba, Mungo, Kemtigern, Cuthbert, Hilda, and all the shining lights down to the Venerable Bede. His lectures make a valuable book, but we wonder that he did not avoid the frequent repetitions which appear in it. In lectures given to an audience it is wise to rehearse things formerly spoken, in order that the assembly may catch the thread of the history; but in a printed book it is neither needful nor profitable. The volume wants boiling down: yet it does not need to become smaller, for many facts might be added concerning Columba and others which would occupy the space now filled by narrating the same fact three or four times. We do not say this to depreciate the book, which has much edified us, and is worthy of most cordial praise. No Scotchman should remain ignorant of this story of the olden time. All who would know correctly how the dawn of the gospel came to this island will find the facts plainly put in these lectures.
A History of the Jews in Rome. B.C. 160-A.D. 604. By E. H. HUDSON. Second edition. Hodder & Stoughton.
A WELL-WRITTEN work upon a deeply interesting subject: we wish the author would give us a second volume, completing the story of the Jews in Rome down to the present time. Miss Hudson has not made any discoveries, or greatly enlarged our information, for she had no access to original documents; but she has collected and collated facts which are known to most students, but which even they will be glad to see so well-arranged. Her volume is quite as much a history of Rome, or of Christianity, as it is a history of "the Jews in Rome"; indeed, it would have been a small affair had the writer confined herself closely to her subject. The Jews in Rome are a small object in the picture, but they are set well in the foreground, and perhaps all the accessories are needful to
bring them out into fair light. At any rate, we have read the book with much pleasure, and advise others to do the same. Ministers and teachers will find here much that will throw light upon the relation of Christianity to Judaism, and of both of these to Paganism, and its sins and philosophies.
Elder Logan's Story about the Kirks. A book for the Young. By JOHN STRATHESK. Edinburgh: Oliphant, Anderson, and Ferrier.
WE do not think that many English children could be made to feel an interest in the various Kirks of Scotland; but we have no doubt that north of the Tweed the juvenile mind will lend itself more readily to a consideration of the Secession, and the Relief bodies, and the Old Light and New Light Burghers and Antiburghers. Mr. Strathesk has written the history of the United Presbyterian Church with much heartiness, and he has made it as attractive as possible for the young whom he aims to instruct. It is most desirable that the brave days of old should be remembered, and that the grand principles for which the fathers struggled should be set before the rising generation. We fancy that young men and women will derive more benefit from this work than the younger folk are likely to do; for put the Presbyterian controversies how you may, they require a considerable measure of theological knowledge before they can be appreciated or even understood, and this knowledge is not commonly possessed by boys and girls. We commend "Elder Logan's Story" to every member of the United Presbyterian body, and advise that a copy be placed in every household belonging to that excellent community.
George Fox and the early Quakers. By A. C. BICKLEY. Hodder & Stoughton. A PORTLY volume, inscribed to John Bright. The life of one of the purest of mortal men deserves to be written over and over again. It was an inspiration to us to study that biography years ago, and it is still a stimulus to go over it again. Mr. Bickley has produced a very readable version of the life-story of the great Quaker, and we doubt not that it will be beneficial to all who read with earnestness and discretion.
241
History of the Canon of the Holy Scriptures in the Christian Church. By EDWARD REUSS. Translated by DAVID HUNTER. Edinburgh: James Gemmell. 1884.
THIS work, we are told by the translator, has long been known to scholars. By his skilful labour it is now placed within reach of the English-reading public. Much good may it do them.
Monsieur Reuss himself informs us that his history originally appeared as a series of detached articles in the Revue de Théologie, published at Strasburg; and the compact volume has already passed through two editions in France. There is little enough that is doctrinal or devotional in its tone. The author aims to construct a history without betraying bias or prepossession in favour of or in opposition to the Bible, as we possess it. He would fain have us accept his essay as a simple contribution to the modern art of scientific criticism in the department of theological literature. To a certain extent he does leave the facts to tell their own tale, though in the issue he lets us know what significance he attaches to them. The question is this—"How came the canon of Scripture to be composed of these books; so many, and not more?" Our space will not permit us to take even a cursory retrospect of the growth of the Canon while the scattered writings of the apostles were gradually collected into one book,—the New Testament. Far less shall we be able to glance at the winnowing process which separated the apocryphal writings of the Old Testament at first, and then entirely severed them from Holy Scripture. Lovers of literature who like to lounge about in the shady groves of history may here find pleasant recreation for their leisure hours. To the last three chapters we must turn for the cream of the volume. The age of "The Protestant Reformers" our author highly extols; though his copious quotations from Calvin and Luther lend colour to the suspicion that he prefers the scruples they expressed during the struggle to the services they rendered in bringing about a general accord. "The Confessional Schools" is the title of a subsequent chapter which interviews the immediate successors of the Reformers. He finds
fault with these for diverting attention from Scripture itself, and constructing confessions of faith and catechisms, with the intent of stereotyping new standards of orthodoxy. In a supplementary chapter—"Criticism and the Church"—he takes us into his confidence, and acquaints us with his own convictions and conjectures. At the outset he admits that "The doubts of scholars have hitherto had the value only of individual opinions, and their influence on usages and institutions has been the less that, in most cases, they have remained unknown to the general public. The results of a science too bold and rash to inspire universal confidence have in no way encroached on the heritage of tradition." Still he thinks it desirable, in the interests of theology, "to build the conception of the Scriptural Canon on another basis." But this magnificent design is merely a castle in the air at present. Whether to develop it "by the processes of theory or by the help of history" he has not yet determined. In a passage too long to quote, though too significant to ignore, our author observes that the researches and debates which have been going on for more than a hundred years can record little else than mistakes and still-born hypotheses. Criticism has followed false tracks, and has often had to retrace its steps, after apparently wasting its strength. It is very improbable, he imagines, that the controversy will ever end in a general and complete agreement. Yet his own sympathies clearly flow with the savans whose avowed object it is to undermine the authority on which Holy Scripture is consolidated into one volume. If better success does not attend the labours of eminent critics in the future than have waited on any of those in the past, they may well give up their inglorious enterprize in despair. The sooner the better.
Amusement and Recreation. What to choose and what to avoid. By EVANGELIST HOPEWELL. Passmore and Alabaster. (Price 1s.)
VERY sensible remarks about how to provide yourself and others with healthy and useful amusement. The talk is exceedingly good; some may think it rather small, but it is healthy and honest.
Winning an Empire. By GRACE STEBBING. J. F. Shaw and Co.
To those who like reading of the din of battle and the clash of arms, this life of Clive will prove full of thrilling interest. To our minds the hero of the story is only to be admired from a military standpoint in "Winning an Empire"; for while victorious in war, he remained a conquered captive to the influences of opium. "He that ruleth his spirit is better than he that taketh a city."
Wilson's Tales of the Borders, and of Scotland. Edinburgh: James Gemmell.
THE people who dwell on the borders of England and Scotland must surely be born story-tellers. It must be grand to sit over the big farm-house fire, and listen to legends, tales, and marvels like these. The Arabian Nights are dreary compared with nights around Kelso, and Yetholme, and Berwick, and the like. These seven volumes contain enough to stir all souls in our manse for the next twelvemonths. What with romance, domestic incident, martyr death, smuggling, poaching, gipsying, and all manner of adventure, there is something for everybody—something even to raise the hair, and make the flesh creep, should it be desired. Scrupulous folk who are particular as to the onion which brings the tear to their eye, can have their choice; and those who do not care to waste a pitying drop over fiction can also be obliged with a narrative of a more cheery kind. The tone and tendency of these volumes are at all times pure and manly. If ever we are snowed up for a night in a roadside inn, may a good providence arrange that "Wilson's Tales of the Borders" shall be in the cupboard, and we shall pass a merry time. What a mass of amusement in these seven volumes! They are neatly bound, and are only 2s. each.
"Go Work." A book for girls. By ANNIE FRANCES PERRAN. T. Woolmer.
SATURATED with grace and goodness. Here is nothing very brilliant in the direction of fiction, but the hallowed influences of true godliness upon daily life are sufficiently sparkling in their natural truthfulness. The story should be in every Christian family.
The Way of the Cross, and other Tales. By EMILY S. HOLT. John F. Shaw.
WE are sorry to meet with Miss Holt in this line. Tales into which Scriptural narratives are interwoven are peculiarly distasteful to us. Here is one in which a Gentile maiden desires to weave a piece of fine linen for the Lord, and it is bought by Joseph of Arimathæa! What! is nothing sacred? Must the last grave-clothes of our Redeemer be wrought into fiction? We know that some people are charmed and even profited by these pious inventions, but our heart revolts at them. Miss Holt does her work reverently and graciously, but it ought never to be done at all.
Busy Hands and Patient Hearts. Translated from the German of Gustav Nicritz by ANNIE HARWOOD-HOLMDEN. Hodder and Stoughton.
ALMOST childishly improbable. Germanic in style and name. Gracious and godly to an eminent degree. We have no heart to dissect a story so full of holy life.
Strawberry Hill. By CLARA VANCE. The Judge's Sons. By Mrs. E. D. KENDALL. The King's Daughter. By PANSY. Glencoe Parsonage. By Mrs. A. E. PORTER (Anchor Series). Edinburgh: James Gemmell.
FOUR volumes of a very cheap and attractive series of stories for the young. How the larger volumes can be sold for 1s. 6d. beats all our calculations. Of course, as these are American productions, there is nothing to pay for copyright; but where is there anything to pay printer, and publisher, and all other forms of the piper? "Strawberry Hill" and "The Judge's Sons" should in all conscience be sold at twice the price named.
Lory Bell. A story about Trust in God. By KATE WOOD. Partridge and Co.
A WELL-TOLD tale of a poor widow, who trusts in God to provide for herself and her fatherless boy, and whose faith is in due season rewarded. Rich relatives discover the lad, who grows up to be an eminent artist, marries his wealthy cousin, and of course they live happily ever afterwards.
243
The Angel in the Marble, and other papers. By G. F. PENTECOST, D.D. Hodder and Stoughton.
Our author is known as an earnest, zealous evangelist in America, and these papers are a collection of short pieces written in magazines, etc., and now made into a volume. There is a tender, beautiful presence of Christ in every page, and much teaching for the innermost circle of Christian experience. An illustrative style makes clear and popular what else would be metaphysical analysis only, and hence attention is arrested and sustained all along. It is a little book to be read, digested, prayed over, and then read again. At the same time we do not endorse all that Dr. Pentecost has written.
Sermons. By the Rev. JAMES SMELLIE. J. and R. Farlane, Paisley.
It is said of the author of these discourses, in an introductory note, that, "He was above all things a preacher of the gospel." Judging from the specimen before us, this witness is true. It is the pure gospel, without an alloy of science falsely so called, or of modern thought rightly so called. It is the gospel, moreover, in its own simplicity, and as its own witness without the need of logic or rhetoric for its commendation or defence. It is the gospel of Erskine and Rutherford experimentally and practically applied. That it should have been appreciated in Edinburgh was a good sign of the times. It will now meet we trust with much acceptance elsewhere.
Characteristics of Christianity. By STANLEY LEATHES, D.D. James Nisbet and Co.
This book consists of three parts in nearly equal proportion. There is a preface, in which the historical evidences of the resurrection of Christ are chiefly considered; and a course of lectures upon the genuineness of Christianity in distinction from all other religions in the world; and notes and illustrations in explanation of what might be thought new and less credible in the former part of the volume. As a defence of the outworks of Christianity, it is similar to that of Paley's, and in some respects a valuable addition to it. As a defence of Christianity itself, it is more evangelical
than moral in distinction from that of Paley, though not to the full extent of the real meaning of that term. While he admires the Church of England, of which he is a distinguished representative, and would look upon its fall as a great loss to the cause of Christ, he does not consider it to be essential to the permanent welfare of the divine kingdom. The church he owns is not Christ, and much less should any part of it identify itself with him. Living Christianity is not a theological creed, but a personal union with a living Christ. He is evidently sincere and large-hearted, and would gladly if he could take the whole world with him to heaven.
The Little Horn of the East: an exposition of Daniel viii. 9 to 26. By the Author of "The Great Roman Eclipse." London: Elliot Stock.
A SMALL section of the prophetic scroll is here placed under the powerful microscope of the expositor. The reader is supposed to have some previous acquaintance with popular literature of this particular genus. In that case he will be aware that "The Little Horn of the East" has been almost universally understood to denote Antiochus Epiphanes. Some other views have been put forward, but they have not found much acceptance among students. To these divergencies of opinion, our author refers in a short opening chapter; and then proceeds with a bold attempt to interpret this entire passage of Mohammed and Mohammedanism. As we have not ourselves a particle of preference or prejudice for or against the claim of either candidate to the heraldic title of "The Little Horn," we shall simply refer our friends to this interesting volume, for all the reasons, critical, historical, and practical, in favour of Mohammed. On the other hand, they can find in Albert Barnes's "Notes on Daniel" a fair résumé of the arguments for Antiochus Epiphanes, which have hitherto been received with general favour. In either case facts and figures must be taken into account. Each partizan finds it easy to be eloquent about the characteristics. Both find it difficult to determine the dates—"Unto two thousand and three hundred days; then shall the sanctuary be cleansed."
Early Church History to the Death of Constantine. Compiled by the late EDWARD BACKHOUSE. Edited and enlarged by CHARLES TYLOR. Hamilton, Adams, and Co.
Two gentlemen of the Society of Friends have here catered for us in glorious style. What can a man of literary tastes, who has a sufficiency of this world's goods, do better than supply us with material for studying the history of the church of Christ? In this volume we have valuable photographs
of many of the Christian and Jewish memorials now remaining in Rome. These alone would be a precious collection, but they are merely the illustrations of a truthful history of the earliest centuries of Christianity. To write early church history from the standpoint of the Society of Friends, and to light it up with accurate drawings, was the design of the author and editor, who share the creation of this volume between them. It is a bulky book, full of condensed facts, and it should enrich every wealthy Christian's library.
