Christian Fobe—the strongest Argument and best Victory
THE Arminian controversy of 1770-75 was very violent, and degenerated into anger and personalities, which each party must deplore. The two Wesleys were too much employed in diffusing the gospel to waste their time (then far spent) in a polemic strife, which found valiant combatants on either side. The saintly John Fletcher viewed the conflict between brethren in Christ with deep sorrow, and while favouring Arminian views, kindly laboured to promote peace, and soften the asperities of party. He wisely showed the faults of both sides, and also where they could agree, but was especially severe against the hyper-Calvinism then gaining ground. He condemned its dangerous errors in doctrine and practice in his "Five Checks to Antinomianism."
A singular proof of the subduing power of love is recorded in the case of one minister who felt himself so checked in spirit upon the publication of "the fifth" or last Check, that he resolved at once to seek out the author in his quiet retreat at the Vicarage of Madeley, and "have it out with him face to face," and so settle the disputed points.
He set out on his long journey on horseback, furbishing, we may suppose, as he pursued his lonely route, his armour and best controversial weapons for the decisive attack. Having put up his horse, he knocked early in the morning at the door of the laborious and studious Vicar, and on the appearance of a female servant inquired somewhat sternly: "Is Mr. Fletcher at home?" On being answered in the affirmative, he said, "Will you tell him that Mr. R—, of Taunton, wishes to see him?" Whether to "the gentleness of the dove" to which the Saviour exhorted his disciples, the Lord had given "the wisdom of the serpent" to discern the object of this unexpected visit; or whether he had resolved to vanquish and disarm his visitor by love, instead of long and fruitless argument, the reception accorded by Mr. Fletcher was a complete surprise to the traveller on the door-step, when he saw the holy master of the house hurrying downstairs with outspread arms, exclaiming: "Come in! come in! thou blessed of the Lord! How is it that I am so honoured this morning as to receive a visit from so esteemed a servant of my Master? Come in! Wherefore standest thou without? Mary, prepare some refreshments, and, meanwhile, let us have a little time in prayer." The two ministers then entered freely into close Christian conversation, and so enjoyed each other's society that there was no room for either Calvinism or Arminianism, and Mr. R— found himself unable even once to hint at the object of his call. To their mutual delight and profit, he was easily persuaded to prolong his stay at the Vicarage for three days, and ever after was known to refer to this journey, and declare that never in his life had he so realized the true communion of saints on earth as he had done in heavenly intercourse with John Fletcher. E. H.
