Sunday in the City — By A Correspondent

A SHORT time ago, in company with a friend who was likewise interested in the subject, we made a perambulation of the City on a Sabbath forenoon for the purpose of discovering whether the churches of the Establishment were as poorly attended as reported; and we found that rumour had in no degree exaggerated the condition of things. We should probably not be far wide of the truth if we were to say that, with the exception of the Cathedral, which attracts visitors from the distance by its music and preachers, the whole of the City churches do not draw together a congregation as numerous as might be found in one Nonconformist chapel in the suburbs. We even venture the opinion, without much fear of its being successfully challenged, that there are more worshippers at noon on Sunday in the City Temple than in all the churches within the City area.
Of course, it may be said, that a change has come over the City, for which the clergy are not responsible, and that the State-appointed pastors do their best under the unfavourable conditions of these busy days when the City may be said to be completely utilized for commercial purposes. The change referred to was undoubtedly inaugurated by the Great Fire, when eighty-nine out of one hundred and twenty-five churches originally found within the walls were destroyed; for forty-five only were rebuilt, thirty-five having been united with other parishes. Driven out into the suburbs by the Fire, it would appear that the citizens contracted a taste for the country which from that day to this has gone on increasing. As early as the reign of Queen Anne the change was becoming very apparent; for now that a new London had risen over the ashes of the departed city, prosperous merchants, whose fathers had lived at their warehouses, were contracting a liking for suburban villas away from the smoke, noise, and dirt of a city which was not so well looked after as the streets of our own better days. It is really astonishing that more than a hundred churches, with their churchyards, should have occupied space on so comparatively small an area. It is even more surprising that the dead should have been interred in such vast numbers in the very thick of the population, contaminating the air breathed by the people and poisoning the wells from which they drew their water. This senselessly pernicious practice was continued until the middle of the present century; and though we may sometimes talk about charnel-houses, few who daily pass the many beautiful city churches still existing ever dream of the repulsive sight which the vaults beneath could reveal. Dotted over the City there are still remaining several churchyards which have remained without buildings since the Fire; and as open spaces which are well kept, these are ornamental breathing-spaces. Thirty years ago the number of Established Churches within the City was seventy-three, with forty-one thousand one hundred and ninety-nine sittings; but in 1859 an Act was passed which permitted the demolition of any one under certain conditions, with the exception of St. Stephen's, Walbrook; St. Swithin's, Cannon-street; St. Peter's, Cornhill—one of the oldest in the country;
and St. Martin's, Ludgate. The Institute of Architects endeavoured to protect many others, and all the steeples; but though nearly all of those erected immediately after the Fire are the work of Sir Christopher Wren, the attempt was unsuccessful beyond the four examples noted above.
In walking through the City on the Sunday morning already mentioned we commenced our enquiries at St. Magnus, London-bridge, an historical spot of considerable interest. Here at Fish-street-hill the Fire of London commenced on September 2nd, 1666; and the church of St. Magnus, which stood at the foot of Old London-bridge, was one of the earliest buildings to fall a prey to the flames. The present church was designed by Wren, and with its octagon lantern surmounting a square tower, is an interesting object to passengers crossing from Southwark to the City. On looking in during the service, the congregation was found to number about twenty persons; but, although we are not tempted to remain, a tablet on the south side of the communion-table is well calculated to catch the eye—"To the memory of Miles Coverdale. . . . On the 4th of October, 1535, the first complete printed English version of the Bible was published under his direction." Coverdale was rector of this parish, and hence this fitting tribute to his memory. The congregation has dwindled since the sixteenth century.
Our next call was at St. Swithin's, Cannon-street, an ancient site, the church having been rebuilt by Wren after the Fire, when the parish of St. Mary Bothaw was included. According to our own observation the general congregation of the two parishes consists of six persons, including the pew-opener. In what degree this congregation has diminished since the union we are not aware; but the gentleman in charge has the consolation of knowing that his followers are not fewer than the flocks of several of his brethren around. He has the additional solace of being protected by Act of Parliament; for as his sanctuary encases the "London Stone," no vandals may touch the building. Thus it happens that some churches are interesting as historical monuments, while others, with few or no externals to attract the curious, are centres of earnest Christian work.
Crossing the street, we dive into some of the narrow lanes near the river, all of which are sufficiently alive during the business hours of every week-day, but which are now as quiet as country lanes, echoing the footfalls of intruders in a very singular fashion. Then we come to the spacious and beautiful church of St. Mary Aldermary, Watling-street, restored by Wren after the Fire, and restored again during the last few years. Though miserably thin, the congregation here is an improvement on some of the places around; but still we are not inclined to linger.
We will now briefly mention a few other churches which were hastily visited, and then the service in one sanctuary, fairly representative of all the rest, may be described. Bow Church, Cheapside, the steeple of which, after leaving the Cathedral out of the reckoning, is regarded as Wren's chef-d'œuvre, had a congregation of forty—small, indeed, compared with the assembly of the dead below in the vaults, where leaden coffins are stacked one upon another to the height of thirty feet. We
165
remain seated for a few minutes with the congregation while the prayers are in progress; but the gentleman's intonation so closely resembles the humming of a Brobdignagian bee that not a single word is intelligible, and we accordingly retire. On coming to St. Michael's, Wood-street, we found a dozen auditors besides a few school-children; and here we may explain that our numeration generally is exclusive of surpliced choirs and the few charity children who, in some cases, seem to be more attached to their parish churches than their elders. At St. Alban's, in the same thoroughfare, thirty-four were counted; while at St. Giles', Cripplegate, where Cromwell was married, and Milton was buried, the number came to between forty and fifty; but the tone of the gentleman in the reading-desk was still unintelligible to Non-conformist ears. This church, the stipend of which is very large, was also a favoured seat of Puritanism, the Cripplegate Lectures being still prized by lovers of the sound old theology.
Hastening back to Lombard-street, we reach St. Mary Woolnoth some time before the prayers are ended; but here, as we have found so often elsewhere, the intonation seems specially designed to make the words uttered as incomprehensible as an unknown language. As a specimen of architecture the interior of the church is strikingly beautiful; but still more interesting is the inscription on a memorial stone: "John Newton, clerk, once an infidel and libertine, a servant of slaves in Africa, was, by the rich mercy of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, preserved, restored, pardoned, and appointed to preach the faith he had once laboured to destroy."
Entering and taking our seats while the Decalogue is being read, we recognise an occasional word alone as common English; and although such reading might be ecclesiastically correct to ears accustomed to its eccentricity, it is to outsiders a monotonous drone which unpleasantly contrasts with the clearer responses of the boys in white. The extracts read from the New Testament are equally unintelligible to those who do not follow the service in the Prayer-book.
The congregation consists of thirteen adults, including ourselves; and we now, therefore, look forward with some extra expectation to the sermon, the more especially as the pulpit is provided with a handsome sounding-board, such as was in favour with old-fashioned preachers of a century ago. After the notices, which chiefly concern the Bishop of Bedford and "Candidates for Confirmation," the discourse, founded on Proverbs i. 27, 28, commences, and is a reproof of those who after frequent calls have not heeded the word of the Lord. Punishment would follow such; and the meaning of the text was, that there might come a time when the day of grace would be past. There was a stage at which the Holy Spirit ceased to strive with man, when the sinner was past hope. Instances of this were met with in Scripture, as, for example, "My Spirit shall not always strive with man." At the same time, a space for repentance was given, as in the time of the Flood; and Christ taught the same truth in the parable of the Barren Fig-tree. When, however, the sentence went forth, men were given up to a reprobate mind. Such a saying as, "While there is life there is hope," was not to be implicitly trusted. The preacher then went on to speak of those who were apparently without fault in the eyes of the world, but who
were, nevertheless, the slaves of some besetting sin. Sinning in one direction, they endeavoured to make some atonement by striving after goodness, and in some things being better than other people. Conscience in such persons grew fainter, uneasy thoughts became fewer, and they at last became incapable of repentance. Let them look at the matter more practically. Perhaps some present who were good in other things were indulging in some one besetting sin; and that sin unrepented of was begetting a dead conscience. Though all might appear well in such a case the way trodden in was the road of death. The sinner might even go on unto death in peace, seeing Scripture said that there were no bonds in the death of such. People reasoned that God would not be hard; but one sin could not be indulged in without corrupting the whole body. There were sins of the flesh and of the spirit, and as either might destroy both body and soul, it became all, especially in the Lenten season, to find out and renounce their besetting sin.
This kind of gospel, which we take to be mere legalism, is common enough in the Church of England; at all events, it is the pabulum which is chiefly offered to seeking souls in the City pulpits, though, of course, there are exceptions now, as there were in the days of Newton and Romaine. This gospel consists in leaving off sin, in being good, and in attending church. It was perhaps perfectly exemplified in the person of Sydney Smith, who, through his earnest desire to do something acceptable to God, appears to have lost sight of the one glorious Atonement for sin.
The inequality of the incomes of the City churches is a singular fact; and very effectively shows how little the example of primitive Christianity influences the laws of a State Establishment. Thus the income of St. Bartholomew-the-Less is put down at £13 a year, while that of St. Andrew Undershaft is £2,000. St. Helen's, Bishopsgate, is £40; but St. Botolph, close by, is £1,650; and with a rector who is sufficiently discreet not to talk about "hanging theology," it is supposed to be the stage before a bishopric; or perhaps more properly, a bishopdom. The church of the Holy Trinity, Minories, has £69 a year; but St. Ethelburga has £1,065, and St. Giles's, Cripplegate, has £1,580. What is more scandalous is, that in the case of at least one of the churches with a diminutive income, large sums on account of tithes, which are supposed to be devoted to the cause of religion, are taken by a lay impropriator. If all the truth about Aldgate church and lay appropriation could be told, we fancy we should have in that alone a powerful plea for disestablishment. The practice is an anomaly which is a disgrace to our age and country. If possible, it is worse than robbery for burnt-offering. Another anomaly is that a large staff of men are drawing ample revenues for doing nothing of service to the cause of religion. Their churches have been all but empty for years, and the congregations still show a tendency to decrease, yet they continue feeding the stalls which the flocks have deserted.
