Menu
‹ Chapter 49 of 279 ›

II.—THE DIVISIONS OF OUR DENOMINATION

8 min read · Chapter 49 of 279

1. We are told that we are so many contending sects. The Registrar General practically says so. If we are to believe his report there are no less than fifteen Baptist sects—that is, fifteen denominations call themselves by our name, not to speak of others who agree with us in our two main contentions, but who yet do not call themselves Baptists.

Here is a national, authoritative document representing us as hopelessly subdivided, and unless we are at pains to explain this matter, outsiders must get a false impression when they read of "Baptists," "Baptized believers," "Old Baptists," "Strict Baptists," "General Baptists," "Calvinistic Baptists," "Open Baptists," "Scotch Baptists," "Particular Baptists," "Union Baptists," "Unitarian Baptists," "Presbyterian Baptists," "Seventh day Baptists," "New Connection General Baptists," and "General Baptists' New Connection." Besides these there are the several sects, or segments, or fractions, or factions of the Plymouth Brethren and the Christadelphians—for these hold practically to our two distinctive contentions, though they differ so widely from us on other points. We must remove this blot. We must not allow the enemy to describe us as fifteen sects. We ought to have our places of worship registered as simply "Baptist" chapels, and then we can specify what distinctions we think proper in the schedule of doctrines appended to our trust deeds, and in our Baptist Handbook. We as a denomination, notwithstanding these fifteen names given us, are substantially one in every sense; no religious body can be more united than we are, and yet we have permitted ourselves to misrepresent ourselves to our own hurt. Cannot the Secretary of the Baptist Union set this matter right? I hope he will be induced to try.

Eminent church historians represent us as actually divided into contending sects. John Henry Blunt is an arch-offender in this respect. He hates dissent bitterly, but he hates the Baptists most of all; and in at least one of his "Church History Manuals" he misrepresents us as antagonistically divided among ourselves, "contending sects," as he calls us; and this manual is used by thousands of church people. Mr. Blunt is an able man, and his works are deservedly popular among Episcopalians, and hence the greatness of the injury done us by his writings. Dean Stanley, who powerfully argues that our contention is right, yet speaks of us as the narrowest sect of Christendom, and Baptists so often allow these statements to pass unchallenged that many, both Baptists and others, think that we are narrow, bigoted, and sectarian. We are to blame for this, for no such statement ought to pass uncontradicted and emphatically repudiated. Even the Rev. R. H. Haddon, in "Church and Chapel," represents us as the most divided of all the sects. He then specifies fourteen names by which we are known. This work finds its way into cultured episcopal homes, and our Church-friends who know no better really think that we are divided into fourteen different religious sects. If they tried to ascertain who were the fourteen presidents, secretaries, and treasurers of these sects, they would surely have their eyes opened. I do not blame Church people for not knowing our denomination better, but I do blame the Baptists for their own carelessness in the matter. The fourteen names forthwith ought to give place to two—"The Particular Baptist," and "The General Baptist."

The Rev. John Henry Blunt and others contend that we have no right to the name "Baptist." Now, we will not quarrel about a name, for during the past eighteen centuries we have called ourselves, and been called by others, many names. The name to us is a matter of very little consequence, for we have covered all the names by which we have been known in history with glory; and, as the rose by any other name would smell as sweet, so we by any other name would still be the church of the New Testament. We do object, however, to be called "Anti-Pædobaptists," as some still persist in calling us. The

Pædobaptists are anti-Baptists, for we existed before the oldest of them were known. We existed in the person of the Lord Jesus, who was a Baptist. We existed in the apostolate, for all the apostles were Baptists. We existed for the first few centuries with few rivals, for the early church was a Baptist church. All the sects of popery, the Eastern Church, the Anglican Church, and all the Protestant bodies are simply Anti-Baptists,—bodies, that is, that appeared and opposed us, for we did not appear in the course of the ages to oppose them. We were founded by the Lord Jesus, and the Pædobaptists appeared during the course of ages.

The church founded by the Lord Jesus Christ was a Baptist church, and, therefore, however appropriate the term "anti" may be to others, it is altogether inaccurate when applied to us. If we draw our information from the Registrar-General and our ecclesiastical opponents, we appear self-ruinously divided; but we who know ourselves best know that we are all substantially one; and live, and move, and have our being as one.

2. We are said to differ seriously in points of doctrine. The names which appear in the Registrar's return are supposed to show the extent of our differences, and these suggest that—

(1) We have General versus Particular Baptists. The former believe that the atonement of Christ had a general reference to all men, and a particular reference to none—that in fact he died equally and in the same sense for all men. The latter believe that the Lord Jesus died in a general way for all men, but more particularly did he die for his own people. He laid his "life down for his sheep;" "he loved the church and gave himself for her," and in this way secured the certain salvation of a numberless number. The General Baptists have a denomination and a college, and a home and foreign mission of their own. They are, roughly speaking, about one-tenth the strength of the Particular Baptists, and it is greatly to their credit that they spend £10,000 a-year on foreign missions. These two bodies are on the most amicable terms. General Baptist churches accept Particular Baptist pastors, and vice versa. We accept each other into our several county associations and our Baptist unions. We are one substantially, and ought not to subsist as two denominations, which we do more technically than truly. We may and we ought to unite formally.

(2) We have Trinitarian versus Unitarian Baptists. This difference sounds serious at first, and if it represented a reality it would be mournful in the extreme. The fact is, a number of General Baptist chapels and endowments fell into the hands of the Unitarians, or else the people themselves became Unitarian, and stuck to the property, and we had an Act of Parliament passed which enabled us to reclaim some of the property—the rest of it remained with the Unitarians, where it is to this very day. These Unitarians call themselves "General Baptists," but they are Unitarians, and not Baptists. They are not recognised by us, nor are they members of any of our associations or unions, nor do they subscribe to our institutions. They are identified with and by the Unitarians. The only point wherein they agree with us is the immersion of believers. In all other points they are as the poles asunder from us. We recognise all whose names appear in our handbook, and that document reveals no serious doctrinal divisions among us. We are most united.

3. We are represented as being divided on most important points of church discipline. What are they?

(1) We have Presbyterian versus Congregational Baptists. There is nothing very serious in this fact. Both these systems of church government have their strong and their weak points; each is endeavouring to secure the strong features of the other, and thus they are drawing nearer and nearer to one another, and the end may be a mode of government which will combine what is best and strongest in both systems. The Book gives us no hard and fast rule on this subject, but it does insist on Congregationalism as being at least the basis of all church discipline, and we as a body strictly adhere to this, and will adhere to it to the end.

137

(2) We have open versus strict communion. This difference does not constitute us two denominations. In all our churches we have members who are strict communionists and members who are open communionists; and, though the controversy is keenly conducted by many, yet we all sit down at the same table. Both sides can quote powerful names and urge strong reasons for their respective positions, yet we are one, and belong to the same churches, associations, and union, and all our colleges, with one exception, take in students of either way of thinking.

(3) We have "Baptist" versus "Union" Churches. That is, we have churches consisting solely of immersed disciples, and churches where some of the members have been immersed, the others having been sprinkled by some Pædobaptist. The pastor in every case is a Baptist, and when he baptizes he immerses, but the church will receive Pædobaptists into its membership. We have not two sects here, but one. While some conscientiously approve of this discipline others as conscientiously disapprove of it, but we have substantially the one aim in view. The Union churches are increasing in number, but they are all our churches, and are numbered among us.

(4) We have "Scotch" versus "English" Baptists. The former allow the church to edify herself by the members who have the gift of utterance, and the pastor is more the evangelist of the church than anything else, but the Scotch Baptists can, if they so please, allow the minister alone to edify the church in public. The latter course is for the most part followed by the English Baptists—that is, by the Baptists of the Baptist Union. But we can vary our service, and if we think proper we can allow the church to edify herself. In fact, this is simply a question of arrangement and convenience, and not one of principle, and it is simply outrageous to label the Scotch and the English Baptists two sects when they are thus essentially one.

(5) We have "seventh-day" versus "first-day" Baptists. In this country we have a handful of Baptists who worship on Saturday like the Jews, because they believe that the Sabbath of the Old Testament is still in force. In Rhode Island, and some other parts of America, the brethren are stronger than they are in England; still, they are everywhere but few in number. All the other Baptists worship on the Lord's day. We have no serious difference here. It is only a question of—Shall we rest on the seventh day of the week or on the first? Surely a difference of opinion on a matter of this kind, when we agree in all others, is not such as justifies anyone in calling us two sects. Thus the whole fifteen sects mentioned by the Registrar-General are one, and for the most part members of the one Baptist union, and they extensively co-operate in the extension of the Redeemer's Kingdom. The Baptists throughout the earth are substantially one, and are at least as united as any other denomination

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate