"A Lively Newspaper, called 'The Sword and Trowel.'"
THE good Bishop of Rochester has described The Sword and Trowel to the House of Lords as "a lively newspaper." We are afraid our friend is not so well acquainted with his Sword and Trowel as we could wish him to be, for it can hardly be called a newspaper; its shape, form, and monthly period of issue most distinctly place it among magazines. Still, that is near enough for recognition; and the adjective appended is so complimentary that we accept it with pleasure, and consider it rather a feather in our cap. What good can a magazine or any other publication effect, if it is not lively? Our trying state of health often makes us fear that we shall grow dull, and we accept the Bishop's kindly criticism as a doctor's certificate that the magazine is up to the mark, is, in fact, a "lively paper." It is all that we can hope if our readers will add, "and so say all of us."
The occasion of the Bishop's criticism is, however, far more important than the remark itself. It arose out of the matter of church lands, and the number of public-houses thereon. Many of our readers are already well acquainted with the incident which connected us therewith, but for the sake of others we must go over the ground again. In the early part of 1882 we received for review a book entitled, "Disestablishment from a Church Point of View." This book is written by Mr. Gilbert, an attached member of the Church of England, whom we hold in very high esteem. He is an indefatigable hunter up or hunter down of abuses of all kinds; unnoticed wrongs he drags to the light, and so assists in their removal. We would take Mr. Gilbert's word without question, whatever he might allege, for we have full reliance upon his honour. He may be mistaken, but he is incapable of a wilful misstatement, or even of an exaggeration. In this book he deals with the Temperance question in connection with the Church of England, and therein makes some declarations which struck us as being nothing less than terrible. We quoted a passage, and said, "Is it true? We ask without casting any doubt on Mr. Gilbert's veracity; but fearing the possibility that he has been led into error as to the true state of affairs. His book is before the world, and challenges reply." It will be observed, therefore, that The Sword and Trowel is not the source of a single statement upon the matter of the Ecclesiastical Commissioners and their public-houses; nor did it even go the length of making a quotation, and asserting it to be a matter of fact. The quotation was given because we wished to call attention to the book, and therefore selected a striking extract; as it involved a very serious matter, it was cautiously guarded with the question, "Is it true?" We do not see how we can review books at all if we are required to investigate the accuracy of every paragraph we quote; life is not long enough for such labour. Neither do we see how we could call public attention to any important statement in a more guarded and judicious manner than that which is conspicuous in this incident. If the case were so, it was time it was looked into.
Our esteemed friend, Canon Wilberforce, saw the aforesaid passage in The Sword and Trowel, and straightway, like the bravely honest.
505
man that he is, he addressed a letter to the late Archbishop of Canterbury upon the subject. This was precisely the best thing that could have been done, for there is nothing like appealing to head-quarters when anything is thought to be wrong. The Archbishop was of opinion that some notice should be taken of the Canon's letter. It is clear that a conscience may dwell in a corporation, for the Ecclesiastical Commissioners thought it worth their while at once to appoint a Committee to enquire into the allegations. They could not bear to lie under the imputation that they were the largest owners of public-house property in the world.
The Sword and Trowel never thought itself of so much consequence as to stir the minds of these notables, but the fact that they were so stirred should give the Commissioners a higher place in public estimation. Evidently they are not men inclined to sit down under a charge of complicity with the drink traffic. Be it remembered that we never brought this charge, we simply quoted it, and asked, "Is it true?" We were very pleased to find from the report of the committee of enquiry that the mischief was nothing like so great as Mr. Gilbert had supposed. We must leave him to defend his own statements (and we have a lurking suspicion that he can defend them), but at the same time, as far as we are concerned, we rejoice to abandon any share in the charge. We never brought the charge, and, therefore, cannot retract it, but we rejoice to answer our own question—"Is it true?" by saying it is only true in a very small degree. No doubt there are public-houses on church lands, and no doubt in years gone by this was not regarded as an evil, but a change has passed over the spirit of the scene. The Commissioners are evidently anxious to abate the evils engendered by the past as much as they possibly can with due regard to prudence and faithfulness to their trust. They ought not to be charged with the offences of their predecessors. The most earnest abstainer can ask no more than that they should get rid of inherited mischiefs as soon as they can. It is almost impossible to buy ground-rents to any extent without a licensed house being included with them; and so long as the purchaser intends to give up the license the moment he is able to do so we cannot see how he can be blamed for holding the property, especially if he does so as a trustee. It must be exceedingly satisfactory to Canon Wilberforce to observe the zeal with which gentlemen in office endeavour to clear themselves from the charge of making money for the church out of the sale of alcoholic drinks. It is nothing more than they ought to do, but it is cheering that they do it so zealously.
Thus has our "lively newspaper" said its little say upon an important question, and we are sure the Bishop of Rochester will believe us when we say that we are glad that the committee could to so large an extent clear the Commission, and we hope that in the future the Ecclesiastical Trustees will become yet more blameless and harmless, utterly without rebuke.
C. H. S.
33
