Notices of Books
Old Testament History of Redemption. Lectures by FRANZ DELITZSCH. Translated from Manuscript Notes by SAMUEL IVES CURTISS. Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark.
It is a long, long time since we have come across a book for students that has so delighted us as this. It is no crutch for lazy men; it doesn't profess to do the thinking for idlers; but in verve, suggestiveness, and fulness of thought it is most admirable. Gold in the nugget, a forest in an acorn, and a sermon in a sentence—that is the style of this little volume.
Professor Delitzsch is thoroughly acquainted with the German criticism of to-day, and yet is untainted by it; and the fulness of his Hebrew scholarship has only made him more loyal to Evangelical truth. The ordinary reader had better not meddle with this book, but for a diligent student it has a rich reward. Here are a few of his sentences taken from a whole host which might be quoted:—
"Christianity, as the religion of redemption, stands and falls with the recognition of the historical character of the fall."
"The sentence on man's sin is not, Thou shalt be put to death, but thou shalt die. Not an arbitrary punishment with death, but the necessary consequence of the transgression; not an instantaneous death, but a dying beginning from that time. Compare
Hosea xiii. 1. Ephraim offended and died, that is, he carried thereafter the germ of death in himself."
"As the evil arising from freedom of choice preceded the good arising from the same source, so the bad child (Cain) preceded the good (Abel)."
"Since the strife between good and evil has entered into the world, a new separation of that which is dissimilar is always the sign of true progress."
"Grace always raises itself on the foundation of that which is natural, after it has first destroyed it: thus the body of Abram must become as good as dead, before he could become the father of the son of promise."
"It was not the blood of the passover-lamb which changed the divine wrath into mercy, but the antitypical redemption which stood behind it, as yet a dumb, unrevealed secret."
Such specimens as these will show the kind of writing which Delitzsch indulges in, and the sort of sentences that Mr. Curtiss would not willingly let die. Nor do we think students of theology will be inclined to do so. We wish for it the heartiest success, and bid it a warm welcome.
Mothers' Meetings: how to form and conduct them. By Rev. W. H. PEERS, M.A. Elliot Stock.
A SMALL book giving hints as to the establishment and conduct of mothers' meetings: nothing very novel or instructive, but tolerably useful.
13
Decision for Christ. Counsel and encouragement for young people. By FLAVEL S. COOK, D.D. Elliot Stock.
EXCELLENT, compact, earnest, bright in manner, and withal full of earnest godliness. Dr. Cook is a sympathetic and helpful counsellor to the young, and his little book cannot fail of usefulness.
The Choice of Wisdom. By Canon BELL, D.D. Elliot Stock.
EIGHT earnest addresses of evangelical type, suitable for the young: somewhat prosy and proper.
The Holy Supper: A Manual for young Communicants. By W. K. MOORE, D.D. Nisbet and Co.
DR. MOORE has the happy faculty of putting old truth into fresh language, and giving a novelty of aspect to it. This he has done in these addresses, showing the different aspects in which the Lord's Supper may be regarded. It will be sure to sell, and we believe will be read: it deserves to be.
Our Brothers and Sons. By Mrs. G. S. REANEY. Hodder and Stoughton.
HAVING written a book for "Our Daughters," a book which has gone through more than one edition, Mrs. Reaney has now turned to advising the other sex as to their life, its happiness, and work. The style is clear, crisp, and attractive up to a certain point, and will be sure to be read; but we are half afraid it is too "preachy." Souls are wondrously shy things, and must be very wisely dealt with: the old-fashioned tract-style of writing is scarcely likely to do much to-day. Mrs. Reaney, we think, would have preached more had she manifestly preached less. Still, these are but spots on the sun, and we wish for her book a quick and extended sale.
The Biblical Kaleidoscope. For the Use of the King's Daughters at Noontide. By J. M. M. Elliot Stock.
DAILY readings for a month, each meditation being drawn from the distinguishing trait in some female Scripture character. The writer thus describes the design of her book:—"It is for noonday. While we are bearing the
burden and heat of the day, we usually find a brief breathing-space at mid-day, to gird on our armour afresh, to 'anoint the shield,' to gather up some fragments of cheer amid depression and discouragement, and to draw near to him who is the gladness of our joy" (Ps. xliii. 4).
The little volume, which is very nicely got up, would be an acceptable gift to a "daughter of the King"; but what can the authoress intend by calling it a "Kaleidoscope"? Is it that she has shaken together texts of Scripture, sayings of good people, anecdotes and brief reflections, which have, at first sight at least, as little connection with the subject and with each other as the fragments of pretty-coloured glass, beads, and odds and ends which are found in that pretty toy, needing correctly-adjusted reflections to give form and beauty to the heterogeneous mass? These were our reflections; if the Kaleidoscope be taken and shaken by others their reflections will take other shapes. Still, we think the title is very absurd.
Early Training: its Philosophy, its Nature, its Worth. By Rev. J. TONGUE, B.A. Jarrold and Sons.
BATING its reference to the ordinance, so called, of infant baptism, this pamphlet is not so bad an attempt to treat the subject as some we have seen. There is nothing new, nothing old strikingly put, but it contains very proper commonplaces, nicely and simply uttered. Our author is not a "tongue of fire."
The Speaking Dead; or, Select Extracts from the Writings of the Reformers and Martyrs. By B. BRADNEY BOCKETT, M.A. Elliot Stock.
AN attempt to make a book of daily readings out of Bale, Becon, Bradford, Bullinger, Coverdale, Cranmer, and men of their age and stamp. We do not think it is a success. Of course these venerable men said most excellent things, but their style is antiquated, and they are not quite the authors from whom to cut out brief extracts. We do not think purchasers will be numerous, and we feel sure that readers will be fewer still.
195
The One Hundred Texts of the Irish Church Missions. Briefly explained by the Bishop of Sierra Leone. Bemrose and Sons.
THIS little book of questions and answers to the hundred texts is intended for the use of schools; for the instruction of children. A Scriptural Catechism is always good, and adults might learn much of true teaching from this little manual. Its contents are better than appear at first sight.
The God-Man. An Enquiry into the Character and Evidences of the Christian Incarnation. Elliot Stock.
SOCIA a book as this could only have been written after much research and more study; and yet, after having carefully read and pondered it, we are obliged to ask, with a sense of disappointment, "What has he proved?" The author has tried to fathom the consciousness of Jesus, and to explain what has always been unrevealed—the philosophy of the union of the divine and human in the person of the Saviour. After much of preparatory fencing, we are told on page 74—
"If we are now asked to fix the precise period in his human life at which Jesus had grown to perfect consciousness of his divinity, the question must be declined as inadmissible. It is the very essence of consciousness that, while by it we know everything, of it we know nothing; each of us is perfectly ignorant of his consciousness in itself, and can only give an account of it as active . . . . We might be able to analyze particular actions or sayings of Jesus from the point of view of his consciousness, and to discover what that was as revealed in those sayings and acts. But of what we may call his potential consciousness, of this we can give no account. Moreover, there would be a species of theological vandalism in making such an attempt. The consciousness of every one of us belongs to a sphere of things which cannot be parcelled out and measured. How much less the consciousness of the Messiah! In fact, the whole matter transcends the limitation of our faculties."
And yet our author peeps and pries, and endeavours to analyze and explain for two hundred pages more; but with
questionable success. When will men learn that thought is limited, and that where mystery in the Infinite comforts us, reverence and not curiosity is our rightful attitude? Speculation is poor work at the best; but it approaches the irreverent when the subject is the person of Christ.
The Great Schoolmen of the Middle Ages. An account of their Lives, and the Services they rendered to the Church and the World. By W. J. Townsend. Hodder and Stoughton.
THIS work conducts the reader along a track which has been but little trodden. The mass of students dispose of the schoolmen as all typified by Duns Scotus, who appears to have supplied a name for the whole family of dunces. To the general public the schoolmen are a set of word-spinners who wasted their time in vain jangling. This judgment is sufficiently true to pass muster among those descriptive generalities which are not altogether false; but yet it is not a fair verdict upon a body of learned and thoughtful men. Who can afford to despise "the Master of the Sentences", or the commanding Stagyrite? He who does not honour Lombard and Aristotle is not likely to be much honoured himself. We have lost ourselves while following the lead of Mr. Townsend among a company comprising "the universal doctor," Albertus Magnus; "the irrefragable doctor," Alexander of Hales; "the seraphical doctor," Bonaventura; "the angelical doctor," Thomas Aquinas; "the subtle doctor," Duns Scotus; "the invincible doctor," William of Ockham; and "the most Christian doctor," Jean Charlier Gerson. If our reader does not know these most venerable doctors, it is time he made their acquaintance. They were doctors indeed, and not mere flaunters of the double D. Mr. Townsend serves very well to introduce the learned gentlemen; indeed he does this so well that we return him hearty thanks; but he does not satisfy us as to anything more. With so interesting a subject he might have done better. However, it is no small achievement to have brought the subject forward in so complete a fashion. He indicates the tracks along which a diligent student may pursue his investigations at his leisure.
The Norfolk Herald of the Cross; or,
Memorials of the late Robert Key.
By the Rev. T. LOWE, M.B. Fen-
wick, 6, Sutton-street, Commercial-
road, E.
SURELY the art of bookmaking is here
carried to an extreme. Pieces from
eminent authors of every school are
patch-worked together to set forth a
meagre biography. A little thread-like
stream of history finds its way amid
flowers, and meads, and rocks, and hills
with which it seems to us to have little
or no connection. Everybody is drawn
into the book, from Charles Dickens to
President Garfield. The intention is
excellent, and the skill is wonderful;
but the result is a cauldron of broth
made of all things under the sun, fla-
voured with the memoir of Robert
Key, an earnest Primitive Methodist
preacher.
London Missionary Society. Ten Years'
Review of Mission Work in Mada-
gascar. 1870-1880. Antananarivo:
1880.
WE congratulate the Society on this noble
Report of Ten Years' Work in Mada-
gascar. In a volume of more than three
hundred pages we are made familiar
with the political and social events
which have affected the Mission during
the last ten years; with the successful
efforts for extension; and with the state
of the native churches, of evangelistic
work, of education, literature, and me-
dical work. The labours of the other
Societies in Madagascar are also de-
scribed. Of these the "Friends' Foreign
Missionary Association," and the "Nor-
wegian Missionary Society" work ami-
cably side by side with the London
Society; but the "Society for the Pro-
pagation of the Gospel" has shown itself
to be a society for the propagation of its
own narrow sect. It had one missionary
on the island. It proposed, therefore,
to send a bishop and four assistants to
preside over him; to send these people
to an island which the London Mission-
ary Society has evangelized; where that
Society has laboured for more than half a
century; where it has 50 English mission-
aries, male and female, 1,142 congrega-
tions, more than 600 native pastors,
71,000 church members, and 250,000
native adherents; to an island where
these native churches under the London
Missionary Society have raised during
the last ten years £40,000 for the evan-
gelization of the country and for gene-
ral mission work. In defiance of the
protests even of Churchmen, and not-
withstanding the refusal of Earl Gran-
ville to apply for the Queen's license to
consecrate a bishop for Madagascar, it
has thrust a bishop into Antananarivo,
the capital, which is the centre of the
London Missionary Society's operations.
In protest against this unchristian con-
duct, the Church Missionary Society,
which had three missionaries on the
island, has withdrawn them. Such
action cannot serve to propagate the
gospel. It can only cast stumbling-
blocks in the way of a people just con-
verted to Christ, and make them
understand, what they ought never to
have understood, the unworthy jealousies
which, in Christian lands, are supposed
to be consistent with discipleship to
Christ. The enemy has many ways of
sowing tares amongst the wheat.
Taths with the People by Men of Mark.
Vol. I. The Earl of Shaftesbury.
Vol II. President Garfield. Edited
by Rev. C. BULLOCK. "Home Words"
Office.
IT was an excellent idea to give in these
compact shilling volumes the utterances
upon vital questions of our great men
of to-day; and in the two specimens
before us the idea is as well carried out
as conceived. A capital portrait of the
speaker is given, and selections from
public addresses judiciously arranged.
Long may Mr. Bullock live to carry on
this admirable work. These books de-
serve to be read by the million.
Thirza; or, the Attractive Power of the
Cross. By E. M. LLOYD. Elliot
Stock.
A SHORT, touching story of the con-
version of a Jew and Jewess, father and
daughter, to the Christian faith. If it
could only be read and pondered by
Jews, it would lead many to become
"Israelites indeed." The Christian
Church has not yet realized its re-
sponsibilities with respect to God's
ancient people: if this little book
should awaken them, we should be glad.
It is well worth reading.
197
The Logic of Christian Evidences.
By G. F. WRIGHT, U.S. London:
R. B. Dickinson, 89, Farringdon-
street.
The Great Problem; or, Christianity as
it is. By a Student of Science.
Religious Tract Society, 56, Pater-
noster-row.
The Resurrection of Jesus Christ. By
JOHN KENNEDY, D.D. Religious
Tract Society, 56, Paternoster-row.
THESE three volumes have in some
respects a common object, while each
of them has its own special merit. They
all essay to show the reasonableness of
Christianity in reply to those who affect
to regard it as a phenomenon of human
fabrication, and to ignore its claim to
be a system of divine revelation. If
sound argument could suffice to answer
the objections of agnostics, we should
soon hear the last of cavillers against
the gospel of Christ. The deference
observed by theological scholars towards
modern sceptics in recognising their
freetbinking as a fact, might well rebuke
the defiance of those who persist in
treating the gospel as a fable. No logic
can reach men who revile the Scriptures
as legends; who scout the possibility of
miracles as if they could be nothing
more than a mirage of the mind, how-
ever fully authenticated; who ascribe
doctrines to pious dotage; and resent
precepts as puerile, and of no value,
unless they are verified by self-interest,
like that egregious proverb, "Honesty
is the best policy." When will the
savans exhaust their stock of sneers?
We ask the question in their own in-
terest; for they do not disconcert us.
They fight with feathers against the
citedel of our faith. The living power
of the gospel of the grace of God gives
us such lively satisfaction every day
that if the evidences of the past could be
effaced, our experience of the present
would amply suffice to confirm us in
their credibility. But although books
like these which lie before us are not
very likely to be the means of convert-
ing many infidels, yet the learning and
labour of their devout authors are not,
therefore, wasted, nor are the pains they
have taken to no profit. We can hail these
treatises, each one of them, as helps to
those young disciples who desire to
qualify themselves for efficient service
in the church. To join in the worship
of the temple it was necessary to enter
within its walls; and yet the worshippers
of old were admonished to walk round
about Zion, to behold her bulwarks, and
count her towers. As partakers of the
regeneration, they cannot doubt the
Word of God, by which they are be-
gotten again; but as little children they
ought to be instructed in the rudiments
of Christian knowledge. At least, we
can say for ourselves that our heart is
beaving with anxiety to get the goodly
band of godly workers highly educated.
If we are to have "a salvation army"
worthy the name, it must be made up,
rank and file, of something better than
raw recruits who rely on anecdotes to
attract attention. They who would be
good Sunday-school teachers must study;
and they who attempt to open fire on
the adversaries of the cross of Christ as
wayside-preachers must read avarici-
ously and reason astutely. We should
like to put them all through their first
drill. The task we would try them with
would be this:—Read a dry orthodox
book, and transform it into a lively evan-
gelical discourse. But we have not
found a dull page in any one of the
three volumes under review. From
America we get a comprehensive manual
of Christian evidences, plentifully en-
riched with quotations from standard
authors on this side of the Atlantic. "A
student of science" throws down the
gauntlet in challenging an answer to
"the great problem."—How can you
account for Christianity as a fact and a
force without accrediting its own nar-
rative? Dr. Kennedy needs no com-
mendation. A more compact little essay
we have not seen for many a day. One
miracle absorbs his mind. It surpasses
all other marvels. The historical evi-
dence that Jesus Christ was raised from
the dead is demonstrated on evidence so
true and reliable that, after trying it
by every recognised test, to doubt it
were to discredit all the classic literature
which has fostered the civilization of
the human race.
Great Heights gained by steady efforts.
By the Rev. T. P. WILSON, M.A.
Nelson and Sons.
ENCODRAGES the young to press forward
with diligent industry. Excellent.
Sam: The Story of "A Little While."
By ISMAY THORN. Illustrated by
T. PYM. J. F. Shaw and Co.
SAM is a poor little orphan, a "nobody's
child," in training by sheer poverty to
become one of the pests of the village
till the squire takes an interest in him,
and—well, he does not become Lord
Mayor of London, though he did listen
to "what the bells had to say." The
writer is favourably known to many
little boys and girls as a "story-teller";
but the moral which the book points is,
to our thinking, not just that intended
by its writer. It might teach village
persons and justices of the peace how
much better it would be to catch all the
little Sams and "teach the young idea
how to shoot," than to wait until they
are introduced to them by some vir-
tuous ex-poacher to receive "justices'
justice" for the horrible crime of tres-
passing in search of game.
The Light of the Home; or, Mabel's
Story. By the author of "Aunt
Hester." J. F. Shaw and Co.
ALTHOUGH in English dress—and very
tasteful dress too—the story is one of
American home-life. The central figure
is one of that much-maligned class of
the genus homo always supposed to make
home odious—a stepmother. Mabel's
story will do much to refute that
calumny, and at the same time afford
her listeners very much profit and
pleasure. It would be difficult to find
a dull or prosy page in the book.
Step by Step; or, the Ladder of Life.
By M. A. PAUL. National Tem-
perance Publication Depot.
A STORY written for a purpose in the
author's best style. Two little boys,
after the death of a pious mother, leave
their home in St. Giles's because the
place has become unendurable through
the father's addiction to drunkenness.
In the good providence of God they
come within the influence of a godly
man, and his assistance, together with
that of their Sunday-school teacher, and
the remembrance of a sainted mother,
follow them in their chequered course,
until, after one or two false steps, the
ladder of life is actually climbed. While
written to warn the young from the
breakers of intemperance, the story
never lacks interest; but something a
little more decided might have been said
about the immoral tendencies of the
theatre. To talk about the purifica-
tion of the theatre being effected by
Christian people discountenancing those
things which are improper, such as the
ballet, is little better than mandlin sen-
timentality. The theatre is not likely
to be reformed, because its frequenters
do not desire that it should be; and by
extending their patronage to playwrights,
Christians will confer no benefit on the
stage, but the stage will inflict lasting
injury upon Christians themselves.
Orphan Lottie; or, Honesty brings its
own Reward. By KATHLEEN MARY
SMITH. Edinburgh: Johnstone,
Hunter, and Co.
A TOUCHING story of a little orphan
girl, who was too honest to steal, and
too independent to beg; but who,
through the blessing of God upon her
mother's instruction and her own in-
dustry, was raised to a position of com-
parative comfort and considerable use-
fulness.
Everyday Stories. By EMILIE SEARCH-
FIELD. F. E. Longley.
WE should not like to be condemned to
read such "stories" as these every day,
and yet we feel sure that to many they
will be acceptable. Tales of love,
courtship, and marriage are here told in
homely language, and illustrated in Mr.
Longley's usual style, with which our
readers are no doubt by this time
familiar. The binding is the best part
of the book, which seems to us dear at
3s. 6d.
Texts and Thoughts for Seamen. Ar-
ranged by a Naval Officer's Daughter.
Paisley: J. and R. Parlance.
AN excellent little book both in design
and execution. There is never a dull
page, nay, not a dull paragraph in it.
It is full of Scripture and practical
godly teaching: but it is Scripture and
gudliness made winsome by plain, earnest
exhortation and wise appeal. We
should like every sailor's bunk fur-
nished with a copy, in the hope that it
might serve as a chart to guide him
sately over life's stormy sea.
199
A Scottish Communion. By Rev. W. MILROY, A.B. Paisley: Alexander Gardner.
MR. MILROY is among those who look with fond memory to the long communion services once so general in Scotland, when, after six months' separation, the people would gather around the Lord's table, and set forth his death. In this book there is a full record of the high doings at such times, inclusive of the six sermons preached, the various prayers offered, and even the hymns sung on such occasions. The sermons are valuable as specimens of good sound Calvinistic theology, and altogether the volume is an excellent record of an institution destined in some of its features to pass away. We have no doubt that many of Scotia's sons will read with great pleasure this capital compilation.
The Drink Problem and its Solution. By DAVID LEWIS, J.P., Ex-Magistrate of the City of Edinburgh. National Temperance Publication Depot.
THIS valuable work ought to be placed in the hands of every statesman, minister, philanthropist, and employer of labour in the United Kingdom. It is the most "thorough" book on the Temperance question that we have met with for a long time. Doubtless many persons will not agree with the "Bailie" that "the only true solution of the drink problem is to be found in the total legislative prohibition of the manufacture, importation, and sale of intoxicating liquors as beverages, or articles for dietetic use;" but before they condemn the author as an unpractical fanatic, riding his hobby to death, let them carefully and prayerfully examine the arguments that have forced him to this conclusion. Mr. Lewis writes mainly from a Scotch standpoint, but his facts and figures are equally applicable on this side of the border, and also in Ireland. He thinks the flood-tide of the Temperance movement was reached at the general election in 1880, and very naturally rejoices over the great defeat suffered by "the trade" on that memorable occasion, when "the high-priest of liquordom," and no less than 80 other opponents of Sir Wilfrid Lawson in the former Parliament, lost their seats, and
305 members favourable to the principle of Local Option were returned. Mr. Lewis believes that it would be possible to pass at once a permissive prohibitory bill for Scotland, where the privileges of a Sunday-closing Act were first enjoyed, and in support of his opinion mentions the fact that 46 out of the 60 Scotch members elected in 1880 were in favour of the Local Option resolution, while 8 were neutral, and only 6 opposed to it. Most devoutly do we hope such a measure will soon be upon the statute-book; together with a Sunday-closing bill for England; an act for the abolition of grocers' licenses, which have been the means of a frightful increase of drunkenness, especially among women; and any other legislation which will prepare the way for the final overthrow of the power of alcohol in these realms. We had marked several passages as being worthy of quotation; but we have probably said sufficient to induce many of our readers to get the book and study its contents for themselves.
Bible Light for Truth Seekers. Haughton and Co.
THIS is the first volume of a small "Monthly," and contains a considerable variety of interesting and instructive articles well calculated to fulfil the promise of its promoter or editor, whoever he may be—"to be useful to anxious enquirers and young Christians." The authors for the most part veil their identity under initials; but they all love "free grace and dying love," and so, for the sake of the name that is above every name, we commend the little serial, and take no notice of the one or two "dead flies" we just caught a glimpse of as we turned over the pages.
The Women of the Bible: Old Testament. By ETTY WOOSNAM. Partridge and Co.
THESE biographical addresses are bright, thoughtful, and pious, and must have been both attractive and useful to those who heard them. They are good without being goody-goody, and entertaining without being puerile. A sensible teacher could get a capital series of suggestive lessons out of them.
